 the hadith of ibn umar when he heard a flute that blocked his ears and he said i was with the messenger of allah and he heard something like this and did something like this this is a hadith that supports the point of view of those who do not see singing as permissible and for this reason ibn aljawzi mentioned it and said if this is what they did with a voice that does not go beyond moderation then how about the singing and flutes of the people of this time! ibn taymiyyah said some people say that the messenger did not order ibn umar to block his ears and the answer is that he was young or it is answered that he was not listening but was hearing and there is no sin in this.
٢ حديث ابن عمر حين سمع مزمارا فسد أذنيه وقال كنت مع رسول الله فسمع مثل هذا فصنع مثل هذا وهو حديث يؤيد وجهة نظر الذين لا يرون حل الغناء ولهذا أورده ابن الجوزي وقال إذا كان هذا فعلهم في حق صوت لا يخرج عن الاعتدال فكيف بغناء أهل الزمان وزمورهم! وقال ابن تيمية من الناس من يقول إن الرسول لم يأمر ابن عمر بسد أذنيه فيجاب بأنه كان صغيرا أو يجاب بأنه لم يكن يستمع بل كان يسمع، وهذا لا إثم فيه .