1) some of these signs were transmitted by alhanbali from ibn hazm see alandalus magazine p. 327. and something similar was mentioned in the diwan of passion and after and compare what alwasha mentioned of signs . as for ibn alqayyim in rawdat almuhibbin he adapted the expressions of ibn hazm and an example of that is his saying among them is the addiction to looking at something and the eyes focus on it for the eye is the door of the heart and it is the expressor of its consciences and the revealer of its secrets. you see the lovers gaze turning with his beloved how he turns and wanders with him in the directions and thoughts. among them is the focus on his conversation and giving all of his hearing to him emptying his hearing and heart for his conversation and if he appears to be focused on someone else it is a borrowed focus in which the affectation is evident to the one who is looking at him. among them is the astonishment and awe that occurs when facing the beloved or when hearing his mention especially if he sees him suddenly or appears to him suddenly. among them is the lovers giving what he is able to in pleasing his beloved. among them is the love of solitude and the enjoyment of seclusion and being alone from people etc. i said despite ibn alqayyims reliance on what came in the ring of the dove for he denounces this type of love that bears these signs and considers it animal love. a stone found on the coast of the atlantic ocean and is famous among the people of the far maghreb and the stone is sold for a good price especially in the country of lamtuna and they say about this stone that whoever holds it and goes on a need it will be fulfilled for him with the utmost care and it is good for them in tying tongues according to their claim .
 بعض هذه العلامات قد نقله الحنبلي عن ابن حزم؛ انظر مجلة الأندلس ص ٣٢٧؛ وورد مثله في ديوان الصبابة وما بعدها، وقارن بما ذكره الوشاء من علامات أما ابن القيم في روضة المحبين فقد تصرف بعبارات ابن حزم، ومثال ذلك قوله فمنها ادمان النظر إلى الشيء وإقبال العين عليه، فإن العين باب القلب وهي المعبرة عن ضمائره والكاشفة لأسراره فترى ناظر المحب يدور مع محبوبه كيف دار، ويجول معه في النواحي والأفكار ومنها الاقبال على حديثه والقاء سمعه كله إليه يفرغ لحديثه سمعه وقلبه، وان ظهر منه إقبال على غيره فهو اقبال مستعار يستبين فيه التكلف لمن يرمقه ومنها البهت والروعة التي تحصل عند مواجهة الحبيب أو عند سماع ذكره، ولا سيما إذا رآه فجأة أو طلع عليه بغتة ومنها بذل المحب في رضا محبوبه ما يقدر عليه ومنها حب الوحدة والأنس بالخلوة والتفرد عن الناس الخ قلت رغم اعتماد ابن القيم على ما جاء في طوق الحمامة، فإنه يستنكر هذا النوع من الحب الذي يحمل هذه العلامات ويعده حبا حيوانيا. حجر يوجد في ساحل المحيط الأطلسي وهو مشهور عند أهل المغرب الأقصى، ويباع الحجر منه بقيمة جيدة لا سيما في بلاد لمتونة، وهم يحكون عن هذا الحجر أن من أمسكه وسار في حاجة قضيت له بأوفى عناية، وهو جيد عندهم في عقد الألسنة على زعمهم .