in every event if he claims prophethood he needs a miracle. how can it be and it is inconceivable that a miracle can be estimated since it has become clear to us that muhammad may god bless him and grant him peace is the seal of the prophets? if we allow lying about muhammad in his saying i am the seal of the prophets while performing a miracle then how can we be sure that this infallible person is not lying? even if he performs a miracle and claims to know it from a text that has reached him then how can he not be ashamed of claiming the text of the owner of the law on events that it is inconceivable to enumerate and count them? rather if a person lived the life of noah and did not work except after the images and texts on them he would not… he comprehends onetenth of it. at what age did the messenger may god bless him and grant him peace comprehend all the images through the text? if he claimed knowledge based on rational evidence then how ignorant he is of all jurisprudence and rational matters since the religious laws are conventional established matters that differ according to the conditions of the prophets eras and nations just as we see the different laws. so how can conclusive rational evidence be permissible in them? if he claimed it based on rational evidence that is useful for consideration then all the jurists have this rank.
في كل واقعة فاذا هو مدع للنبوة فيفتقر الى معجزة كيف ولا يتصور تقدير المعجزة إذ بان لنا أن محمدا صلى الله عليه وسلم خاتم الانبياء فإن جوزنا الكذب على محمد في قوله أنا خاتم الانبياءمع إقامة المعجزة فكيف نأمن الكذب هذا المعصوم وإن أقام المعجزة وان ادعى معرفته عن نص بلغه فكيف لا يستحي من دعوى نص صاحب الشرع على وقائع لايتصور حصرها وعدها بل لو عمر الانسان عمر نوح ولم يشتغل الا بعد الصور والنصوص عليها لم يستوعب عشر عشرها ففي أي عمر استوعب الرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم جميع الصور بالنص فان ادعى المعرفة بدليل عقلي فما اجهله بالفقهيات والعقليات جميعا إذ الشرعيات أمور وضعية اصطلاحية تختلف بأوضاع الانبياء والاعصار والامم كما نرى الشرائع مختلفة فكيف تجوز فيها الادلة العقلية القاطعة وان ادعاها عن دليل عقلي مفيد للنظر فالفقهاء كلهم لهم هذه الرتبة