 5 6 as for the report about the companions of the messenger of god while they were in a hut listening to singing and about ibn omar and that he was traveling to sell a female singer and that he and abdullah bin jaafar heard singing on the oud this is something that ibn hazm alone reported from the references that we relied on but this is not from his school of thought since everything that is less than the book and the sunnah of the messenger is not an argument for him and it is strange that he did that here in the argument for the permissibility of singing.
٥ ٦ وأما الخبر عن أصحاب رسول الله وهم في عريش يستمعون إلى غناء، وعن ابن عمر وأنه سفر في بيع مغنية، وأنه وعبد الله بن جعفر سمعا الغناء بالعود، فمما انفرد به ابن حزم عن المراجع التي اعتمدناها، ولكن هذا ليس من مذهبه، إذ كل ما دون الكتاب وسنة الرسول فليس بحجة عنده، ومن الغريب أنه فعل ذلك هنا في الاحتجاج لإباحة الغناء.