We are in the process of a short sale and the lender XXXX Wells Fargo XXXX has denied providing us a copy of the appraisal completed on XXXX/XXXX/2015. The lender actually informed us that due to it being an internal report and not for credit we cant receive a copy. They are clearly violating CFPB guidelines that state any means used to determine a property value are to be supplied. This seems to only happen when our value is good and the lender is trying to fraud the seller. We previously received copies on XXXX/XXXX/2015, dated XXXX/XXXX/2015. We sent in a value dispute package on XXXX/XXXX/2015 and the lender requested a new appraisal XXXX/XXXX/2015 completed on XXXX/XXXX/2015 the new value {$55000.00} down from the original appraisal of $ XXXX.Here is the file timeline:XX/XX/XXXX : short sale was XXXX : called spoke to XXXX XXXX Presidential team said they do n't give out copies as they paid for it, desktop value $ XXXX completed XXXX requested copy via XXXX : called spoke to XXXX XXXX XXXX, XXXX requested copy of BPO & fax XXXX : email XXXX XXXX, processor/negotiator requested copy of BPO & sent MLS XXXX : XXXX emailed me the address where to send request copies of Appraisal, fax/mail sent, Counter received at $ XXXX : MLS rebuttal emailed to XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX Loan Adjustor Spec XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX Executive Office called stating the appraisal sent via mail on XXXX : mail rcvd desktop appraisal $ XXXX dated XXXX : Value Dispute Package XXXX, XXXX, : email req XXXX : email rcvd XXXX XXXX ( Loan Servicing Specialist XXXX asking for loan # XXXX : email rcvd XXXX XXXX he ordered new XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX : 3 faxes sent & mailed Req copies of XXXX : XXXX Executive Offices called copy will be sent out next XXXX : email req update from XXXX XXXX, called WF XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX left VM XXXX called WF CS spoke to XXXX ID # XXXX transfer me to XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX full appraisal done & got it back on XXXX came in $ XXXX : email XXXX XXXX update? Called WF spoke to XXXX ID # XXXX resent XXXX : email rcvd/reply XXXX XXXX asked for buyer highest/best I said buyer came up $ XXXX : fax rcvd Ltr SS withdrawal due to not rcvd docs on time by XXXX XXXX in Liquidation Servicing XXXX, emailed XXXX XXXX he said he did n't send withdraw but file is open with him. Need buyer XXXX : XXXX XXXX WF escalations called she is unable to send copy BPO due to it being internal use and not for credit I said per CFPB yes, will file complaint, 3 faxes/mail sent req 2nd copy of BPO XXXX mind you she called me on XXXX & XXXX previously and told me the copies were sent out for desktop appraisal ) 
