My mortgage lender, Bank of America, issued a trial modification plan for my home, but then they refused to make the modification permanent!! 
Bank of America told us that we qualify for modification and we meet all the requirements, but there is an issue from 4 years ago that has caused a red flag on my file!!! 

They claim that we failed to give them correct tax returns during the previous modification request which was 4 years ago. The fact of the matter is that 4 years ago we applied for modification which was denied. That process was done through a " third party '' that represented us during the modification request 4 years ago. Everything that was requested at that time we provided -- including tax returns -- to that representative who should have forwarded them to Bank of America. If that third party failed to forward the requested items to Bank of America, it was not our fault. 
Furthermore, 3 months ago I sent the tax returns for those missing years to Bank of America. 

Now Bank of America claims that 4 years ago they did not receive the tax returns in a timely manner and this is a sign of a legal tax violation!!! Their excuses are just absolute none sense! I have provided all tax documents for 2014 and I even provided the tax returns that they claim were missing from 4 years ago, even though it has no relevance to my current modification request. Bank of America 's response is very unreasonable and unfair. They claim that I qualify for all requirements of the modification plan but because of some vague and unclear excuses, from a previous 4-year old closed file, they can not finalize my current modification file!!! 
They also refuse to explain the problem clearly and in writing!! 

It is very absurd, unfair, and unreasonable for a lender to deny " permanent '' modification after they approved the trial modification, Based on the status of a 4 year old previous file which was closed a long time ago!!! 
This is very unreasonable and unfair. 
