Security Iran-Russia S-300 Affair Takes a New Spin
Ariel Cohen /
@Dr_Ariel_Cohen
Michaela Dodge /
@MichaelaTHF
Iran escalated its dispute with Russia recently.
Tehran filed a lawsuit against the Russian Federation at the International Court of Arbitration as Russia refused to provide the Islamic Republic with the S-300 air defense system delivery and providing a new spin to the complicated Russian-Iranian relationship.
Tehran and Moscow signed an $800 million delivery contract in 2007 despite U.S. and Israeli protests. In June 2010, the United Nations Security Council passed a fourth round of sanctions on Iran due to its continuous violations of its Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty obligations.
While the S-300 system is not specifically mentioned in the U.N. register of conventional arms, Russian President Dmitry Medvedev signed a decree three months after the sanctions were passed banning the S-300 system sale as well as delivery of other conventional weapons to Tehran's theocratic regime. Russia even returned the Iranian down payment on the S-300.
The prevention of the S-300 transfer from Russia to Iran was one of the brighter moments of the international effort to halt Iran's nuclear weapons program. The S-300 air defense system would significantly complicate potential air strikes against Iranian nuclear sites if Israel - the U.S.'s most important ally in the Middle East - or the U.S. itself decide that Iran's nuclear weapons program progressed enough to possess an existential threat to either nation.
Iran hopes that the court will rule in its favor and thereby provide the Russian Federation with legal grounds to fulfill its obligations under the original S-300 delivery contract. So far, Russian representatives expressed their surprise with Iran's steps, stating that U.N. sanctions did not give them any other option but to cancel the sale of the system.
While the halt of this sale is a good beginning, it will not be enough to address the broader issue of Iran's quest for nuclear weapons - something the Obama Administration has neglected recently due to the focus on Afghanistan, Libya, and domestic economic woes.
As The Heritage Foundation suggested, a multi-faceted strategy targeting Iran's ailing energy sector would contribute to compelling Iran to give up its nuclear weapons program. More broadly, the primary task of the United States and its allies must be to dissuade Tehran from acquiring nuclear weapons and work to advance liberty for the Iranian people by discrediting the radical regime.
Keeping pressure to deny Iran the S-300 anti-aircraft missiles or their equivalent is a necessary part of the strategy. Additionally, the U.S. should not shy away from articulating its priorities and values to its Russian partners - and have Russia halt its cooperation and arms sales to Iran.
Ariel Cohen
Ariel Cohen brings firsthand knowledge of the former Soviet Union and the Middle East through a wide range of studies, covering issues such as economic development and political reform in the former Soviet republics, U.S. energy security, the global War on Terrorism and the continuing conflict in the Middle East.
Michaela Dodge specializes in missile defense, nuclear weapons modernization and arms control as policy analyst for defense and strategic policy in The Heritage Foundation's Allison Center for Foreign Policy Studies. Read her research.
International Commentary Putin's Syrian Gambit Exposes Flaws in Obama's Naive Foreign Policy
InternationalCommentary Secret Side Deal Reveals Disturbing Flaw in Iran Nuclear Agreement
SecurityNews Ted Cruz: Because of Iran Deal, Jihadists 'Will Use Our Money to Murder Americans'
asdsd says: August 31, 2011 at 3:18 am UN CHARTER VII ARTICLE 51:
Provides for the right of countries to engage in military action in self-defense, including collective self-defense (i.e. under an alliance) FOR IRAN TO NONSTOP FIGHT FOR ITS RIGHTS AND FREEDOM, LIBERTY. IRAN IS A LAND OF THE BRAVES. King Tut says: March 16, 2012 at 1:47 pm Iran has very good people and a strong history.
The freedom and rights it needs to fight for is within its rulers.
You don't want what Iraq got, just because your ruling party members are bent on world destruction through terriorism.
The iranian people need to stand and do the right thing. Daniel Feliu says: May 3, 2012 at 9:03 pm I hope iran get those S300 systems to defend his nuclear facilities from those zionist scumbags!! Comments are Closed