new york u.s. judge friday reject effort joaquin guzman accuse mexican drug lord know el chapo dismiss massive international narcotics conspiracy indictment grind extradite improperly brooklyn challenge merit case guzman lawyers claim indictment violate extradition treaty unite state mexico mexican authorities initially agree extradite client southern california western texas lawyers question mexico could suddenly consent u.s. authorities hurry guzman brooklyn new york city face charge extradition seek violate so-called rule specialty brief order u.s. district judge brian cogan say guzman legal right challenge brooklyn indictment mexico object cogan also say federal appeal court manhattan whose jurisdiction include brooklyn courthouse uphold principle late july unrelated case protest objection mexico express provision extradition treaty unite state mexico cogan write therefore defendant motion dismiss indictment base allege rule specialty violation deny michelle gelernt federal public defender represent guzman email say office disappoint surprise order still believe mr. guzman right treaty violate give circuit court give defendant right object violations extradition treaties hope supreme court decide issue favorably mr. guzman say prosecutors accuse guzman 60 run global cocaine heroin methamphetamine smuggle operation leader sinaloa cartel play major role decade-long mexican drug war 100,000 people die guzman face life prison convict hold without bail u.s. judge dismiss accuse mexican drug lord el chapo 's indictment