text: who do you think will win the colts and giants game? peyton or eli?   giants are much improved on defense and if they get arrington they'll even be better the game will also be home for them in the meadowlands. the colts lost their star running back and it's not known if anyone can fill it. peyton manning got exposed against the chargers and steelers. with all that being said i say the colts by 3! ha ! vinitari kicks game winner.