text: who would you take the good one or the bad one? alright guys and girls, who would you go for, the good guy or the bad boy, and the good girl or the bad girl?  i'd take the good girl personally. you can still work with the good girl and kinda mold her but the bad girl already comes with all the mileage and the bagage. the good one, because if you take the bad one, you think everything's all good until you end up in trouble.