text: who should win american idol? i think taylor should. personally, i think katharine is a good singer and all, but, she has an attitude and she thinks she's all that. taylor, on the other hand, has always been humble and he's just plain entertainment and doesn't care what people thinks of him when he's on stage. what do you think? who should win? i think that taylor hicks will win american idol 2006 and he will be the second winner of american idol from alabama after ruben studdard.