
You are an expert in evaluating and guiding a web navigation agent. Your task is to help the agent effectively complete a given mission on a website based on the user’s intent. The agent’s goal is to navigate through the website to reach the desired state that aligns with the user’s objective.

You will analyze the next state of the webpage (OBSERVATION) after each action and determine whether the agent is successfully progressing towards the task goal. You will also assist the agent by choosing the next action if necessary, considering the dynamics of the web environment and how each state transitions.

Key Points:
1. Understand the intent:
- Identify the user’s goal (e.g., finding information, navigating to a specific page, modifying content).
- Make sure the next state of the webpage aligns with achieving that goal based on the current state and user’s intent.

2. Evaluate the Next State:
- When assessing the next state, consider how it contributes to reaching the intended goal. If the next state moves the agent closer to the user’s goal, it is evaluated positively.
- If the next state does not progress towards the goal or leads to an error, suggest alternative actions that will result in a more favorable next state.

3. State Guidance:
- If the next state shows that the agent is on the right track but hasn’t completed the task yet, recommend further actions that could bring the next state closer to the goal. Focus on guiding the agent to reach a state that reflects clear progress towards the goal.

4. Types of Tasks:
- Information Seeking: The next state must provide the specific information the user seeks (e.g., product price, reviews). If the information is unavailable, the next state should explicitly indicate that.
- Site Navigation: The next state must reflect that the agent has navigated to the exact page or item. Check if the state includes content based on the user’s intent.
- Content Modification: The next state should indicate that the requested content modification has been successfully committed (e.g., form submission, comment posting).
- General Task: Evaluate the entire process to ensure the next state reflects task completion. Stop actions should only be issued when the objective is met.

5. Common Pitfalls:
- Repetitive typing actions: Ensure that the next state does not show corrupted input due to repeated typing.
- Incomplete navigation: Ensure the agent’s next state reflects navigation to the specific item or content, not just to a general page or category.

Output Format with a Score Between 0 and 1:
Each next state will be evaluated with a score between 0 and 1, assessing how well the state moves towards the task’s completion. This score provides nuanced feedback on the state’s effectiveness.
0: The next state is a failure or leads away from the task.
Values closer to 0 (e.g., 0.1, 0.2): The next state does not contribute meaningfully but isn’t a total failure.
0.5: The next state is neutral, and the agent is maintaining its current position.
Values closer to 1 (e.g., 0.7, 0.8): The next state is helpful and moves the agent closer to the task goal.
1: The next state is optimal and is directly aligned with completing the task.

Response Format:
1. You should write your rationale providing a detailed analysis of the next state and reasoning for its score, providing a score between 0 and 1 based on how well the next state contributes to task completion.

Output Format: [Rationale] <your thought> [Score] <a value between 0 and 1>

OBJECTIVE: Show popular news which is at number one in comics.
PREVIOUS ACTION: ["click [310] where [310] is 'News'"]
CURRENT OBSERVATION:		[4414] button 'Focus Reset'
		[4416] button 'Toggle Sidebar'
		[4425] image ' IGN Logo '
		[4444] button 'Search'
		[4451] button 'Reviews'
		[4459] button 'News'
		[4474] button 'Discover'
		[4494] button 'Videos'
		[4504] button 'More'
		[4518] button 'Add to Library'
		[4549] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[4557] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[4565] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[4574] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[4582] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[4590] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[4598] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[4616] button 'More'
		[4624] heading 'Site Themes'
		[4628] radio 'Classic' checked: false
		[4640] radio 'Dark Mode' checked: false
		[4652] radio 'Automatic Based on system preferences' checked: false
		[4662] button 'More'
		[4670] heading 'Change Region'
		[4765] button 'Home'
		[4773] heading 'More'
		[4778] button 'Site Themes'
		[4784] button 'Change Region'
		[4796] button 'AdChoices'
		[4827] button 'Home'
		[4835] heading 'News'
		[4872] button 'Home'
		[4880] heading 'Reviews'
		[4903] button 'Home'
		[4911] heading 'Discover'
		[4937] button 'Home'
		[4945] heading 'Videos'
		[4965] button 'Home'
		[4973] heading 'Account'
			[4991] figure '' details: 
				[4996] image 'james9091 Avatar'
		[4999] button 'Notifications'
	[5004] button 'Collapse Sidebar'
				[5023] image 'Star Wars Celebration: Everything Announced'
				[5027] heading 'Star Wars Celebration: Everything Announced'
				[5031] image 'Ahsoka: Grand Admiral Thrawn Live-Action Actor Confirmed to be Lars Mikkelsen'
				[5035] heading 'Ahsoka: Grand Admiral Thrawn Live-Action Actor Confirmed to be Lars Mikkelsen'
				[5039] image "Nintendo's Shigeru Miyamoto on The Super Mario Bros. Movie"
				[5043] heading "Nintendo's Shigeru Miyamoto on The Super Mario Bros. Movie"
				[5047] image 'Minecraft Legends: The Final Preview'
				[5051] heading 'Minecraft Legends: The Final Preview'
			[5056] heading 'The Biggest News from Star Wars Celebration 2023'
	[5062] button 'Scroll Right'
	[5069] image 'Ahsoka: Everything We Know About Live-Action Thrawn'
	[5074] image ' Play '
	[5084] image "Skeleton Crew - What We've Seen So Far"
	[5089] image ' Play '
	[5099] image 'Star Wars Celebration 2023: How Return of the Jedi Influenced The Mandalorian'
	[5108] image 'Mon Mothma Actress Reacts to Ahsoka Trailer Appearance, Talks About Growth in Andor'
	[5118] region '3rd party ad content'
	[5523] heading 'Latest Featured Columns'
	[5529] button 'Scroll Right'
	[5544] heading 'Why Doesnt IGN Review Everything X Times and Average the Scores?'
	[5557] heading 'Forget Weapon Durability, The Legend of Zelda Tears of the Kingdom Needs a Cooking Overhaul'
	[5570] heading 'Resident Evil 4 Remake Is a Love(craftian) Letter to My Favorite Monsters'
	[5583] heading '4 Things Every Good Fight Scene Needs'
		[5591] image ' IGN Logo '
		[5673] image ' Group Black '
CURRENT ACTION: click [1065] where [1065] is 'Comics'
NEXT STATE PREIDCTION: 		[8549] button 'Focus Reset'
		[8421] button 'Toggle Sidebar'
		[8559] image ' IGN Logo '
		[8578] button 'Search'
		[8585] button 'Reviews'
		[8593] button 'News'
		[8608] button 'Discover'
		[8628] button 'Videos'
		[8638] button 'More'
		[8651] button 'Add to Library'
		[8681] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[8689] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[8697] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[8706] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[8714] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[8722] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[8730] status '' live: polite atomic: True relevant: additions text
		[8748] button 'More'
		[8753] heading 'Site Themes'
		[8757] radio 'Classic' checked: false
		[8769] radio 'Dark Mode' checked: false
		[8781] radio 'Automatic Based on system preferences' checked: false
		[8791] button 'More'
		[8796] heading 'Change Region'
		[8891] button 'Home'
		[8896] heading 'More'
		[8901] button 'Site Themes'
		[8907] button 'Change Region'
		[8919] button 'AdChoices'
		[8950] button 'Home'
		[8955] heading 'News'
		[8993] button 'Home'
		[8998] heading 'Reviews'
		[9021] button 'Home'
		[9026] heading 'Discover'
		[9031] button 'Home'
		[9036] heading 'Videos'
		[9056] button 'Home'
		[9061] heading 'Account'
			[9079] figure '' details: 
				[8419] image 'james9091 Avatar'
		[9086] button 'Notifications'
	[9091] button " IGN Logo GUIDES Resident Evil 4 Clockwork Castellan LocationsResident Evil 4 WalkthroughLast of Us Part 1 Safe CodesGTA 5 CheatsPokemon Scarlet and Violet PokedexZelda BoTW ShrinesHogwarts Legacy Secrets DEALS IGN DealsBest Lego SetsCheap Gaming LaptopsBest Cheap TVsZelda: Tears of the Kingdom PreordersBest Board Games SITES IGNMap GenieHowLongToBeatIGN Boards Group Black IGN supports Group Blackand its mission to increase greater diversity in media voices and media ownership. Group Black's collective includes Cxmmunity, Black Women Talk Techand AFROPUNK"
			[9105] region '3rd party ad content'
			[9115] heading 'Comics'
			[8414] image 'The 10 Best Star Wars Video Games of All Time'
			[9127] heading 'Popular Stories'
			[9145] image ' Comments '
			[9165] image ' Comments '
			[9185] image ' Comments '
			[9205] image ' Comments '
			[9225] image ' Comments '
			[9232] heading 'All Comic BookNews'
			[9238] tablist '' multiselectable: False orientation: horizontal
				[9239] tab 'All' selected: False
				[9242] tab 'Popular' selected: False
				[9245] tab 'Videos' selected: False
				[9248] tab 'Articles' selected: False
				[9251] tab 'Reviews' selected: False
			[8415] image 'Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom Figures Revealed at Star Wars Celebration'
			[9272] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True
				[9274] image ' Movie '
			[9279] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True
			[8422] image ' Comments '
			[9293] image "The Mandalorian: Hasbro Reveals Din Djarin's N-1 Starfighter Toy"
			[9304] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True
				[9306] image ' Comic '
			[9311] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True
			[8423] image ' Comments '
			[9325] image "Dave Filoni on Whether His Star Wars Movie Is Mandalorian Finale: 'The Next Logical Step'"
			[9336] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True
				[9338] image ' Comic '
			[9343] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True
			[8424] image ' Comments '
			[9357] image 'Mandalorian Producer Confirms Din Djarin is No Longer the Only Main Character'
			[9368] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True
				[9370] image ' Comic '
			[9375] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True
			[8425] image ' Comments '
			[9389] image "Star Wars' Lando Calrissian Series Is Definitely Still Happening"
			[9400] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True
				[9402] image ' Comic '
			[9407] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True
			[8426] image ' Comments '
			[9421] image 'Mandalorian Episode 7 Clip Hints at Live-Action Return of Beloved Star Wars Character'
			[9432] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True
				[9434] image ' Comic '
			[9439] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True
			[8427] image ' Comments '
			[9453] image "Marvel's New Silk Series Drops Cindy Moon Back Into the Spider-Verse"
			[9464] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True
				[9466] image ' Comic '
			[9471] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True
			[8428] image ' Comments '
			[9485] image 'TMNT: The Last Ronin Graphic Novel Has Been Discounted'
			[9496] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True
				[9498] image ' Comic '
			[9503] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True
			[8429] image ' Comments '
			[9519] image "The Mandalorian's Big Cameos are Setting the Internet on Fire"
			[9530] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True
				[9532] image ' Comic '
			[9537] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True
			[8430] image ' Comments '
			[9551] image 'Why Spider-Man 2099 Is the Perfect Villain for Across the Spider-Verse'
			[9562] PluginObject 'Related Content Link' disabled: True
				[9564] image ' Comic '
			[9569] PluginObject 'Author Link' disabled: True
			[8431] image ' Comments '
			[9585] region '3rd party ad content'
			[9593] image ' IGN Logo '
			[9675] image ' Group Black '
[Rationale] The next state indicates that the agent successfully navigated to the 'Comics' section of the website after clicking on the 'Comics' button. This is a positive step towards the user's objective of showing popular news in comics. The heading 'Comics' confirms that the agent is in the correct area, and there are multiple entries indicating related comic news. However, while the navigation is effective, the agent has not yet filtered or displayed the specific popular news stories, so further steps are necessary to reach the ultimate goal of showcasing the number one popular comic news. The score of 0.67 reflects that the agent is close to achieving the task but still has work to do to refine the results to meet the user's intent fully. [Score] 0.67