this review title is: not too happy with this pencil and the content is: i was anxious to try a more natural eye pencil of this price but unfortunately in this case you get what you pay forthe color is more a dark grey than black not highly pigmented does not apply smoothly and does not last i was using anne marie borlinds black pencil which is a more pigmented true black and applies smoothly but also doesnt last very long and is more expensivestill on the hunt for the perfect natural ingredient black eye pencil.there are other information for this review, one is this reviewer did not purchase it and the other is 0 people think this review is helpful.