this review title is: nice product not sure how my eyeliner tube came slashed and the content is: i am giving this stars because of the packaging one of my tops came slashed and melted somehowthe stamp was great i will go crazy with my winged eyeliner sometimes so it was nice to have a guideline i enjoyed using the eyeliner overall i had to be go over the eyeliner a free times to achieve the darkness i wanted.there are other information for this review, one is this reviewer did purchase it and the other is 1 people think this review is helpful.