this review title is: not as good as advertised and the content is: i have been looking for a smudge free mascara for quite a while this had the words smudge proof so i thought i would try it out way too much money for a mascara that is not as advertised the product goes on well but i still have raccoon eyes at the end of my day i guess i am still looking.there are other information for this review, one is this reviewer did purchase it and the other is 2 people think this review is helpful.