this review title is: old sticky mascara order directly from yonique and the content is: i have always ordered this mascara directly from yonique and absolutely love this mascara in the future i will continue to order straight from the company the mascara i recieved from amazon is sticky and seems old i could hardly get any of the mascara to actually go on my lashes because it was all clumped on the brush i am extremely disappointed in this product i wish i could return it.there are other information for this review, one is this reviewer did purchase it and the other is 2 people think this review is helpful.