this review title is: not waterproof as advertised by this seller and the content is: do not label it waterproof mascara when it isn t waterproof mascara is something you can swim in this mascara will flake off in water it doesn t smear but it does flake off great mascara if you don t need waterproof.there are other information for this review, one is this reviewer did purchase it and the other is 1 people think this review is helpful.