this review title is: mascara was crap and the content is: of my products i loved but this volumizing mascara was absolutely crap dried out clumpy rubbed my finger over the brush and nothing came off was looking forward to the possibility of a new mascara because i love elf mascara and i am nearly out bummed the tinted moisturizer was awesome.there are other information for this review, one is this reviewer did purchase it and the other is 29 people think this review is helpful.