this review title is: beautiful felt tip liner and the content is: this product is very smooth application and very bold black but not shiny it is a little bit irritating to my eyes if i wear it all day hours although almost all eye liners irritate my eyes if i wear them too long otherwise it is very waterproof very easy application and very beautiful to wear i am in love.there are other information for this review, one is this reviewer did purchase it and the other is 0 people think this review is helpful.