the creamiest spicy red [SEP] absolutely love this chunky pencil stick it is a perfect dupe for chili with maybe a bit more brown while it is not ultra long lasting it applies smooth and is easy to re apply my only issue is the price i understand this is an all natural kind of product and indie but is a little steep for a pencil you will need a special sharpener for this as well because it does not come with one on the other end if it did i would justify the price