smudges very easily [SEP] this mascara smudges so badly that it is impossible to wear for long enough to determine if the grow claim is credible i tired on off for two weeks and have since given up just for perspective i work inside and the smudges still occurs very easily by mid day the mascara does not look as it did upon first application as at least half of it has rubbed off under my eyes i do not think that i have ever used another mascara that has smudged like this i really wanted to like this product but now would only be willing to use it again if i can find the waterproof version to see if it would stand up better