awful [SEP] i was so excited about this purchase and was so sure i would at least like of the items so at the price i ordered sets huge mistake i think the eyebrow pen would have been awesome if it was brown black or black or even actual dark brown but it has a red tint to it and just a weird color i have dark but thin brows and i think if this color was closer to my natural brow color it would have been awesome same with the brown powder just a weird shade of brown and the eyeliner is definitely not even close to smudgeproof or waterproof and to make matters worse only of the eyeliners was not completely dried out and it is almost dried out after atrempt at using i am so disappointed and mad at myself for paying for sets and none of it is usable for me i am just going to chalk it up to a loss it is not worth the hassle of the return process so i am just out the money for setsif you have red hair or brown hair this might be okay for you but the reddish tint looks ridiculous on light black eyebrows