it works better as a liquid eyeliner [SEP] i was super excited to try this out especially because my alternative is more expensive it got here in days i was disappointed for sure i ll be going back to my normali order jet blacklooks good in a photo but does not last because of natural oils from skin as well as mild sweatingeven after application it still transferred into a dry napkinit does not last for daysgreat for a quick weargoes on pretty fierce