not if you like the tub [SEP] i really wanted to love the stick version because i despise using my finger that said i haaaate the stick it is in a drawer for emergencies only i rather use classic cherry chapstick over this but yeah the stick is bulky formula is thick soaks in way too fast have to re apply constantly wish it was the same as the tub formula feels like putting weird goopy lotion on your lips i think it is the shea butter in it maybe unfortunately stickin to the tub keeping my nail cut short washin my finger