nice set [SEP] i got these for my granddaughter for xmas she is only but at the stage of using a few cosmetics sometimes i have not heard any specifics as it is mascaras she has told me she liked the cruelty free aspect and that no animal products were used also she did try the curling mascara and said it did noticeably curl her lashes will update as time goes on i want to know for myself too excellent bargain especially if the mascara performs well