not the same formula [SEP] i have been ising dirt by jonathan for many years and absolutely loved it when i went to reorder this time i could only get this product i researched and discovered jonathan had sold his business i figured it would be the same but it wasn t the company was great at first i explained the formula wasn t the same and that it was too thick stiff to work with they were mixing up a new batch and send another jar for free this one was a little better but same issue when i reached out again to ask how to return get a refund they told me they didn t accept returns or give refunds for used products don t buy it not the same dirt at all i did stumble on sun bum surf paste a little thin but the best substitute i ve found so far