dry crumbly terrible not like what you buy in beauty stores [SEP] i ordered this product because it is my daily go to liner on my top lid i religiously order it from sephora but recently moved out of the country and could not find any sephora stores therefore i turned to amazon the product that i received from the amazon warehouse is not at all like what i receive at sephora it was dry crumbly and would not even apply to my skin after trying to use this for a week and failing daily i finally just threw it away i could hardly even get the product to rise through the applicator to be applied because it was so dry and thick i will never order this product via amazon ever again