not the best [SEP] unfortunately i had an allergic reaction to something in these i only use liquid waterproof eye liner and i ve never had a problem previously it s not their fault specifically but what is different with these versus everyone else also this stuff will peel off your eyelids if you put a lot on for me i always heat up my eye lash curler before use to get a better curl and this melted the eyeliner off i had to reply in portions none of the other waterproof liquid eyeliners i ve tried have ever done that just a heads up