same as the non waterproof version [SEP] honestly i absolutely love dollywink liquid eyeliners and have been using them for years the only reason i took off a star is because i do not see the difference between this one and the other super black one waterproof the staying power in the original one was long lasting already so i thought this one would be even more durable nope same lasting power same super black color same super fine application do not get me wrong dollywink is literally my favorite eyeliner but this is exactly the same as the non waterproof one which is actually cheaper i basically bought the same eyeliner for a higher price and different color packaging