love them [SEP] love these eye liners black brown i have tried some of the best from to but these work great for me dependable meaning comes up easily does not break from just looking at them i sometimes wear bang but end up with brow partially missing throughout the day but not with these they say put thank goodness bc at do not need to walking around looking a racoon i sometimes deal with watering eyes again it stays put palladio are wonderful i used makeup wipes to remove thanks please do not stop carrying selling them