disappointing dry and flaked off [SEP] i am a huge pony effect fan i have purchased and loved at least of their eyeliners stay put in various colors i was excited to try this as i am always looking for budgeproof long wearing eyeliner as it is the only eye makeup i wear this went onto my top lid nicely i love the thin line and deep color but maybe i got an old one or something because it seemed dry and flaked off in clumps not long after application i will stick with my favorites so far physicians formula gel max factor x masterpiece high precision liquid eyeliner glo skin and cargo swimmables eyeshadow stick