meh [SEP] the outside packaging with the ribbon was very niceand the box is qualitythe romance card describing each scent was bent glued on crooked and i noticed several typos in the descriptions i question the authentic of the product yes caswell massey was the seller the scents old faithful mammoth canyon reminded me of earth smells i likedtower fall lake reminded me of inexpensive perfumes way back in the dayi adore the caswell massey soaps especially the unisex scent of marem but the yellowstone set is a pass would i spend for each bottle on its own no maybe if i mix match scents like another reviewer recommended but on their own meh