not smudge proof doesn t work over eyeshadow and [SEP] did not go over eyeshadow it was a very faint gray not happy at all i really wanted to love it because the winged tip can be used in either eye without problem i was able to use it without eyeshadow but if you re going to male a liquid eyeliner make it good enough to be applied over eyeshadow if not what s the point also it is not smudge proof will be returning