what kind of sorcery is this i cannot stress enough how truly amazing this liner is [SEP] i originally purchased this eyeliner at a kohls department store for my daughter for her to practice with makeup however i ran out of my regular eyeliner one day and i had to use i had to use hers it was soooo amazing that i immediately went to amazon to see if they had and to my pleasant surprise they didit glides on with ease its true to color and does not lighten after application its extremely precise and beyond easy to use it is by far genuinely the easiest liquid eyeliner i have used in my years of using liquid liners the felt tip is more hardened which makes its super easy to control and place on the eyelid whereas other liquid liners have softer felt tips which are floppy and they bend easy leaving you with having to press lightly so you do not mess up your straight line this elf liner is opposite of all that its hard but not too hard that it does not glide precisely with your stroke it has a perfect sized super thin tip which allows me to give my cat eye a precise small line finish at the corner of eye it is perfectionmy most favorite part of this liquid eyeliner is that it does not get cakey if i want a thicker more pronounced look i can go over the same line several times and it does not cake up i mean sure if you are gonna put layers on i am sure it will eventually cake but building with layers no cake first time i tried to do thicker line i was so nervous not wanting to mess up my entire eye makeup but i had faith and gave it a try and was shocked that it did not get thick and cakey and it still looked like i only had layer of eyeliner ondid i mention it stays put i will sometimes get watery eyes in the corner of my eyes and this magic liner does not smudge does not rub off it could be that my make up setting spray helps or it could be the eyeliner but whatever it is its definitely some sort of sorcery haha but regardless with the insanely affordable price you will not be disappointedit removes super easy with make up remover or just soap and water i always wash my face then use make up remover to get any remaining make up off and the eyeliner always seems to be gone after just soap and watertruly the best bang for your buck