very nice liquid eye liner [SEP] i really like this eye liner it is not too expensive it is a nice liquid eye liner that has a nice fine tip it is easy to use and applies nice and evenly you could get a wing done with this one without trouble if you have a steady hand because the tip is nice and finei have had no issue with smudging with this one which is nice it is a very nice dark ebony color that looks great i have gotten some compliments when i have used this because it just makes your eyes look great it is easy to remove so no problems there