not very impressed [SEP] so i was really hoping this would easily remove eye make up well it does remove it but not so easily if i apply it to a dry face and i leave it on about seconds and then rub it in with my fingers and then rinse really well then it works pretty well but you must let it sit and then rub it in especially for mascara and i do not even use the waterproof kind i also do not like that it is an oil i like nutrogenas natural cleanser and make up remover much better but could not find it online this time