okay but could be much better [SEP] these were okay for the most part my big con is the stoppers that came with this set this was my first time making lip gloss but even when i used less that the proper amount of product to fill the first couple tubes as test runs the stoppers always found a way to pop out as soon as you try to insert the applicator brush to complete the tubes this was especially annoying considering i bought these to make lip gloss as christmas giftsthese were mediocre at best it is possible to fill these tubes with the included stoppers but it will be more trouble than what it is worth i would suggest either just using the lip gloss squeeze tubes or buying these from a different seller with better results