the dark lip color you have been looking for forever [SEP] four stars only because the product was broken in tube when arrivedi love this line of lipstick i have two of them now aaphrodesiac and she devil and they are the velvety darks that i have been searching for for a long time they stay put reasonably well you will need to reapply a few times but the pigment is strong enough that it will not have to be very oftenthough the one i received from amazon was broken on arrival it is still usable and overall the packaging is very good