tubes slide off too easily [SEP] this started out pretty good it s very liquid but with a little drying time between the coats it made my lashes look very nice long and voluminous however while it didn t smudge the breath coming up from my mask was enough to make the tubes slide off and that s not exactly the idea i did want a tubing mascara because it s easy to remove with just water but i don t want it coming off while i m going about my business unfortunately had to send it backbetter alternative maybe line snapscara you ll thank me later