just ok might go with another brand that is waterproof [SEP] the eyeliner which is very liquidy is easy to apply lashes are a little more difficult in staying on the corners of your eyes i wore them all day and the eyeliner runs everywhere by the end of the day it looked like i had applied black eyeshadow it also smudges super easily if accidentally touched the upside is that it is easy to clean with soap and wateri think the eyeliner ingredients could use a revamp so it does not smudge run so easily imo i will then have no complaints