crappy eyeliner [SEP] hate it i thought this was the other elf eyeliner i use and love upon opening i realized that this was not it i decided to give it a chance wish i had not i just got these about a week ago and the first one is already drying up just opened the second one and is not going on smoothly at all it is like it will not draw on some parts of my eye i even tried shaking it and drawing a couple lines on my hand i do winged liner and it is so hard with this is like the point of the felt tip does not work so it is hard to make a sharp pointed wing it does not last throughout the day fades and smudges quickly definitely not waterproof at all i will never purchase this again garbage