the product itself is good it is creamy [SEP] i do not really blame the product i have yet to find any eyeliner whether it be pencil cream or liquid that does not smudge i have tried everything including dabbing on smudge proof products etc and nothing works for the outer corner eye from smudging it is impossible so unless somebody out there knows a secret that i have not tried yetplease tell methe product itself is good it is creamy but not to where it is like night cream and easy to apply