liner is weird [SEP] this review is mainly for the liner i put these on the day i got them and loved them i do not wear makeup super often so after that they sat unused in the cabinet for about a month when i went to use it again the outside of the eyeliner felt greasy or oily i figured something had spilled on it wiped it off and went to apply when i tell you this stuff was dry i mean dry i had to keep putting it back in the tube and shaking it to get anything out and as soon as i started to apply it would dry out and just drag against my eye i am assuming whatever is in the liner separated and leaked out i think they would be fine if you are going to use them regularly but if you are like me and dont have time to do makeup everyday good luck i guess