smells like older womens perfume and not in a good way [SEP] so i cannot speak for how they were in the tub but the smell of the packaging threw me way off it smelled like what i can only describe as older womens perfume which is not really what i want my bath to smell like i was expecting floral scent or lavender not quite this so i have not opened them and i will be returning because the smell just is not for me but again i cannot speak for the way they acted in the tub or the toy inside