overpriced for quality quantity [SEP] i m not convinced this is new the pencil is about inches cm shorter a full shorter than the cardboard box in which it is packaged which in my experience is unusual if it s not used it is at least over packed in terms of box size there also was no safety wrapper around the pencil and its cap which again is usual and customary with cosmetic pencilsapart from that i m really glad it s organic however it is not particularly gentle it should be substantially softer for use near the eye rich and creamy it certainly is not it is so hard it does not go on easily and barely shows up when applied it also irritates my eyes more than i expected from something labelled for sensitive eyes i really wanted to love this pencil but i am quite disappointed