this eye shadow does not stay as a cake it becomes completely loose powder causing a mess [SEP] when i found the han eye shadow i was thrilled as it would replaced the discontinued color i would use from mac i bought one cake to try and it was a good color spread well i liked it so much that i bought more cakes however only after one or two months of use of my first open case the powder started getting loose and started spilling out of the case and making the area where i put make up on a complete mess i finally had to find a larger screw top container to pour all of the eye shadow in the manufacturer ought to fix this problem now i have more cases of this eye shadow i have to deal with