it works fine it is cheap [SEP] it works fine it is cheap but damn it is messy like any tube glue it is hard to get it to come out exactly the way you want it gets goopy around the lid etc i got the black glue because i thought it would work well to cover up the lash line and fill in eyeliner in fact it works very well for that purpose but unfortunately if you barely touch the lash line to any part of your eyelid or it slides a bit you have a line of sticky black tar where it touched whatever it is fine eyelash glue is always a pita i will probably get clear next time but otherwise there is no major complaints here