good product not so good dispenser [SEP] although the color was not exactly as shown it was a great color it stays on well but i recommend liner as it seems to like to soak into the outside edges of my lip looking less defined i really really like it overall but i do have complaint the container dispenser is aweful cheap plastic wouldn t twist up at first but i jimmied it around until it worked then it wouldn t twist down needs some improvement on the dispenser but the product is very good