made in china otherwise just okay [SEP] if i had realized that this product was made in china where cosmetic products sold there must be tested on animals by law i would not have taken it but i saw that nowhere on the product page i try to avoid products made there because i do not agree with that other than that this is a decent but not great lip scrub good luck getting a pea sized amount to your lips because it is so crumbly that you will lose a good part of it on the way or at least i did it does scrub reasonably well but did not entirely eliminate the roughness on my winter chapped lips it did help smooth them though it smells good but i am certainly not going to try to eat the residue as the instructions say you can at the current listing it does seem a bit overpriced for something which is basically large grained sugar with some oil thrown in for good measure