it is a nice dupe for benefit is chacha tint [SEP] it is a nice dupe for benefit is chacha tint i think the photo makes it appear darker than it actually is it is much peachier in person i think some people were saying how it stains a little if you do not rub it in right away i have not experienced this problem when using on lips i have found that it is best only to swipe a little on the middle and then smooth out the rest with your finger to achieve a gradient natural look like the photo elsewise it would get too peachy if you tried to apply it like a lip gloss or a lipstick has kind of an artificial smell when you open the bottle but that goes away after application good for the price too