nice shades great for lazy people fewer touch ups [SEP] yes the packaging is gimmicky and i totally fell for it but i make no apologies i bought shades and and they are all quite nice that said the is a bit lighter than i expected so i will probably get more wear out of the other twothe tints are pretty long lasting i was able to wear the all day yesterday and even through lunch and drinking mugs of tea i did not need to touch it up til the end of the day and truthfully since it was the end of the day and there was still a hint of color i was lazy and just did not bother the tints are not noticeably drying either although i am a balm addict and usually put some on over the color throughout the day luckily this does not seem to have a terribly detrimental effect on the color there is a slight taste which is neither unpleasant nor pleasant i did not especially like it but it did not bother me i am not a wine drinker but my guess is they do not really taste like wine just kind of fruitythe only other true tints stains i have used are the tony moly ones and i think these compare favorably to those in terms of ease of application i think these are more forgiving durability drying and taste the tms had a more chemical taste i do not dislike the tms but these are just better imoi would recommend these tints and will probably buy again especially to try out the other other colors