Review title is I liked this eyeliner mainly because it is cruelty free [SEP] I liked this eyeliner mainly because it is cruelty free. It stays a long time and makes nice opaque lines. I'm giving it a 3 because of how it turns to like rubber when it dries and the first time I tried to take it off it was stuck on my lashes and I pulled a couple lashes off in the process of peeling off the rubber. Maybe if you have some fancy makeup remover you're good, but I just use safflower oil.