This Review Title is Bad knock off... and the content is: The lipsticks themselves are good enough but the tubes that they come in? Cheap aluminum junk- the bottoms fell off before I have even used one time... I will not be able to take in my purse. Waste of time and money. Def a knock off- and a bad one....There are other information for this review, one is This reviewer did purchase it and the other is 1 people think this review is helpful.