Smudges on Me! [SEP] It is not smudge proof on me, but needs a slight bit of extra effort to remove. I have always had the problem of mascara and eyeliner smudging under my eyes. It really has to do with the eye structure that causes the eye to ‘warm up’ the make-up resulting in smudging. I also wasn’t crazy about the pencil tip. I didn’t like the line it made, thus requiring smudging of the line with a q-tip. Sometimes, I couldn’t even tell if the tip was exposed enough.