I really loved this Elizabeth Mott eye liner pencil when I first ... [SEP] I really loved this Elizabeth Mott eye liner pencil when I first started using it. Unfortunately, after I sharpened it, the pencil inside was mushy and gooey and there was no way it would sharpen. I had mushy goo stuck all over my eye pencil sharpener and still not able to sharpen and use my new Elizabeth Mott eye pencil! Had to return it!