The product itself is good. It's creamy [SEP] I don't really blame the product. I have YET to find ANY eyeliner, whether it be pencil, cream or liquid, that doesn't smudge. I've tried everything, including dabbing on smudge proof products, etc., and nothing works for the &#34;outer&#34; corner eye from smudging. It's impossible. So unless somebody out there knows a secret that I haven't tried yet....please tell me!<br /><br />The product itself is good. It's creamy, but not to where it is like night cream, and easy to apply!  :)