COMPLETEY DRIED OUT - ORIGINAL & REPLACEMENT [SEP] UGH!!!  Ordered this as have liked it in the past.  First arrived completely dried and cracked.  Amazon offered a replacement, so I thought, OK - maybe this was a fluke.  NOPE.  Replacement was exactly the same - dried, cracked, shrunked - anybody who has opened old eyeliner gel knows what I mean - disgusting little pellet.  so disappointed!