Meh [SEP] The outside packaging with the ribbon was very nice..and the box is quality.<br /><br />The romance card (describing each scent) was bent & glued on crooked.  And I noticed several typos in the descriptions.  I question the authentic of the product (yes, Caswell-Massey was the seller).<br /><br />The scents:<br />Old Faithful, Mammoth & Canyon reminded me of earth smells…I liked<br />Tower Fall & Lake reminded me of inexpensive perfumes way back in the day.<br /><br />I adore the Caswell-Massey soaps, especially the unisex scent of Marem, but the Yellowstone set is a pass. Would I spend $15 for each bottle on its own? No.  Maybe if I mix/match scents, like another reviewer recommended but on their own….meh.