Product is absolute TRASH [SEP] I thought I'd give the Navy a whirl because I thought it would be....Navy. This liner is bright Royal Blue. Just as vibrant a blue as your every day ball point pen.  And speaking of pens, the consistency is of fountain pen ink.  I spent an HOUR trying to remove this junk from my eyes.  First, a makeup remover cloth. Next, actual makeup remover. I ended up scrubbing my eyes with a microdermabrasion scrub because having tiny sand particles in my eyes was the lesser of 2 evils here, believe it or not.  Not only did it stain my skin, but it spread around my entire eye area and I looked like Papa Smurf on a 3-day bender. Never again... right in the trash. Yikes.