Terrible!!! [SEP] okay first, the tip breaks easy. It doesn't last or leave a smooth, clean line. Very translucent color, does not apply well. Isn't even that waterproof! It definitely comes off in the water. It you want cheap eyeliner that's precise, applies well, and actually leaves a clean line, don't get this product. It doesn't do its job. Maybeline New York eye is also cheap and it's incredible I wish I just bought that again!