Don’t waste your time $$ [SEP] Haven’t tried the black but I ordered these for a special bride customer of mine for many years. We were extremely disappointed with the white on pink  nails. Could not even see it or tell what it was! I then tried on my red nail, same difference. Save your $ and try something else. Not an amateur here. I have done nails and art for 30 years. I gave one star because it arrived on time. I’m sending back