Not very good [SEP] I bought this as a gift for my niece. The lipstick sets in a cute box but unfortunately it was torn open. Out of all the fall colors they could put in this box...2 were in the brown family and holding them together I think, I THINK they may be two different shades, 4 were the same mauve with a hint of orange, 1 straight mauve, 3 of the same orange, 1 red orange and 1 pink orange. A complete missed opportunity to have 12 DIFFERENT fall colors.  Several lip sticks are cracked, the individual lip stick packaging is horrible. The plastic wrapper around some of the tubes are cut jagged or do not fit properly and I still cannot get over the colors. For the price I wasn't expecting high end quality but I did expect 12 fall related options for a teenager to experiment with. Instead I will keep the two brown shade for quick trips to the store on weekends and donate the ones that aren't cracked.