Nice product, not sure how my eyeliner tube came slashed [SEP] I'm giving this 3 stars because of the packaging. One of my tops came slashed and melted somehow?<br /><br />The stamp was great. I will go crazy with my winged eyeliner sometimes so it was nice to have a guideline! I enjoyed using the eyeliner overall. I had to be go over the eyeliner a free times to achieve the darkness I wanted.