Review title is I will not buy this eyeliner or the makeup spray again! [SEP] I bought both this eyeliner and the makeup spray and was very disappointed with both!  The eyeliner has a sharp point which you think would result in a clean line but the eyeliner does not flow cleanly on your lid. The makeup spray came out in globs and ruined my makeup and felt grimy on my skin.  The eyeliner was like using a dried out permanent marker on your lid.  Wasted my money on two different luminess items!  Will not buy anything else from them!