Review title is Tiny pencil [SEP] So I purchased this product several years ago at major retail store and it was a chunky pink pencil that required sharpening but worked great. This one I'm not so sure. I like the old one better. This is very tiny. Click up by twisting container but can't unclick. So watch the length at end. I can barely see it once applied to inside bottom of eye and in corners. I had high Hope's, but can't recommend this product.