Review title is old. [SEP] Was so excited about this little set.  Have tried a few of these in the past but wanted to compare side by side.  I was happy the packaging seemed new and unopened. However, 4/5 of these seemed already dried out/old.  They did not compare in quality to the full size mascaras that i have tried for 3 of the brands.  Wanted to buy this as a gift set for a few women for Christmas, but now I will not be doing that.