Review title is Not a fan [SEP] I was very excited to find a cruelty free mascara with so many good reviews. I've tried using it a couple times, and I do not like it. It honestly does not even look like I'm wearing mascara at all - it doesn't add length or volume or make a difference. In addition, I know it's waterproof but it's the hardest to get off out of any mascara I've used before. Can't use it.