Review title is Not if you like the tub [SEP] I REALLY wanted to love the stick version  because I despise using my finger. That said, I haaaate the stick. It's in a drawer for emergencies only. (I rather use Classic Cherry Chapstick over this.) But yeah... The stick is bulky, formula is thick, soaks in way too fast & have to re-apply constantly. Wish it was the same as the tub formula. Feels like putting weird, goopy lotion on your lips. I think it's the shea butter in it maybe? Unfortunately, stickin to the tub, keeping my nail cut short & washin my finger.