Review title is Ooooh LOVE it!  Really silky smooth application, stays put all day. No flaking or caking... GREAT Product! [SEP] I received this today and was excited to try it so put it straight on. I have to say I love the consistency - it's very silky and goes on very smoothly. It stayed put all day and looked fantastic. I am so happy to find this product as since throwing out my Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner which has toxic stuff in it I have tried to find something as good that is also safe and so far this totally hits the mark.  I removed it with some moisturizer and it was easy enough to remove.  This is great stuff.  I will try to remember to touch base after I've been using it for a while to update this too.