Review title is Not Soft and Buttery [SEP] Since this isn't quite what I was wanting, but still usable, I have rated it a 4. There is no smell to this product, and that is a definite plus for people who are sensitive. It isn't a creamy mixture, but rather like a pliable,hardish smoothness, if you can imagine that. It takes considerably more than a couple of seconds of warming it in your hands to heat/melt it enough for a smooth application to the skin. I have found that it is the prefect consistency for use with thick spa socks for keeping my feet soft.