Review title is I was hoping but disappointed. [SEP] Actually I will be returning. I am not sure if the product is old but the brush is stiff therefore making it really difficult to follow the line of my eye. Not only that, it so very dark black. I have only used it once because of what I have already said, but when I tried to take if off just seconds after I attempted to apply it, it would not come off. I even took makeup remover and it did nothing. Then I had to get in the shower with very warm water and scrub my eyes with a wash cloth. And when I got out, half of it was still there! AT my age (63) the last thing you want to be doing is scrubbing the tissue around the eyes. Sorry. I was hoping but disappointed.