Review title is Wanna keep q-tipping your eyes...mascara flakes and so does the liner. [SEP] At first I thought these were pretty good.  Missed my window to return them.  Mascara flakes pretty often and the liner absolutely doesn’t last.  You have to put the liner on second or it will all peel or smudge off after applying the mascara.  I’ve owned much better products.  I tried these many times...and always the same results.  I’m a normal/dry skin type, too.