Review title is Ineffective and irritating [SEP] I have been using the oil-free eye makeup remover for several years, so I thought I would try this. I don't recommend it. It did a good job of dissolving mascara, but really just smeared it around. I had to use several pumps of oil to get the mascara dissolved, but then could not get it to rinse off. I tried using a cotton pad, but still had mascara residue around my eyes. My eyes were irritated and blurry (that stuff hurts when it gets in the eyes) after using this, even when I rinsed with water. I ended up using an additional product to get all the mascara off. The instructions on the bottle make it sound like you can just pump, massage, and rinse off your makeup. That is not the case at all. I love Neutrogena products, but can't recommend this one. I will return it and go back to their oil-free eye makeup remover.