Review title is My Favorite Eyebrow Makeup [SEP] My hair is black with gray throughout. When I went into Sephora to try this product, the rep used #3 which was way too dark. Foolishly, I bought it and wasn't satisfied with the color but I love the product. I ended up buying #2 at a later date and it's okay but still on the darker side. I found this #1 on Amazon for a lot less expensive  so I decided to give it a try. What's funny is that this is meant for blondes but it works fine with my dark hair. I like a more natural look rather than bold, so this works great.