Chapter 1 - Romeo's Lucky Night

Notes - All characters featured in this story are the age of 18 or above. This story takes place in an alternate universe separate from the canonical storyline.

A/N - I have a Discord Server & Patreon available on my profile. 

Contains - Harem, Blowjob, Creampie.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Late at night, in the Fairy Tail Guild.

Mirajane Strauss, Erza Scarlet, and Lucy Heartfilia were all staying back at the Guild after hours drinking. They were already in the prime of their lives, and typically spent their time enjoying themselves whenever the opportunity presented themselves. After the entire debacle with Agnologia and essentially saving the country or even the world, they were able to sit back and relax for the most part. Of course, they were practically drunk out of their minds, sensitive to alcohol per usual, as their conversation veered from innocent chit-chatter to very mature, adult discussions.

“Huh?!.. What do you mean, Mirajane?.. You might be a supermodel, but I have a body that competes with even you!..” stammered Lucy, whose head was swirling and face flushed red from the sake. 

“That’s right!.. I refuse to back down.. Just because Sorcerer Weekly branded you as the most sought out woman in the country, don’t think that we’ll give up that easily!..” exclaimed Erza.

“E-Eh?!.. When did this become a competition, you two!..” responded Mirajane. 

“If I were to place a bet, I’m pretty sure I’d be a better lover in bed than you!..” claimed Lucy, puffing out her chest and vehemently stating her case confidently. 

“Oh, a challenge?.. Do you think that I’ll pass this up?..” followed Erza, joining in on the fray and commotion.

“Oh, I don’t know about that one, Lucy.. Trust me, I’ve probably slept with more guys than you, anyway. They can never get enough.” replied Mirajane playfully, teasing her friends who’d gotten riled up over some friendly banter, all in good fun of course. 

“Is that so?.. Then, why don’t we see for ourselves!..” yelled Lucy, holding her tiny cup of sake high in the air.

“What do you mean, Lucy?” curiously asked Erza, truly lost at where she was getting at, as MIrajane followed in her confusion.

“We just need to find a man to judge our skills in bed, and prove once and for all who really is the best!..” 
“I had no idea you were so perverted, Lucy!.. Well, who do you think we should ask?” laughed Erza, holding onto her stomach at the ridiculous proposition.

“Hmm…..” muttered Lucy, as if in deep thought, lifting her head up and scanning the vicinity of the room. Mirajane silently stared as everything unfolded, wondering where letting this play out would take them. It was an intriguing idea, really. The only thing left to wait for was their perfect candidate. 

Amongst everyone staying past operating hours was Wakaba, Makarov, Macao and Romeo. The three old drunkards were somewhere far in the back laughing amongst themselves, meanwhile Romeo seemed to be spending some time alone, perhaps receiving a late-night drink before heading out. The young man had only recently turned into an adult, and thus his curiosity was piqued upon listening in on their conversation, only sitting a table length away. 

“T-They’re looking at me, aren’t they?..” thought Romeo, the handsome young man, was typically used to women staring at him, having grown up to be very attractive, he was a sought out commodity. 

“Hey, Romeo!~... Can you come here for a second?” waved Lucy, wearing a seductive smile as the young man gulped down his drink before cautiously turning around. 

“There’s no way that they’re going to ask me to-.... Are they?...”

“H-Hey, everyone.. Lucy… Mirajane… Erza…” nervously stammered Romeo, not dense enough to not understand where things were heading.

“I apologize for their craziness in advance, this happens a lot when we go drinking.” giggled Mirajane, her massive tits slightly jiggling as a result, leaving Romeo flustered and hopelessly staring at all over their abundant cleavages. 

“Are you busy tonight?... If you’re not, then would you care to let us sleep the night over?” asked Lucy, smiling at him. 

“U-Um..”

Mirajane wrapped his arm around his biceps and pulled him closer, her chest smashing against him, leaving him gasping in surprise. Having all of these beautiful, busty women that he saw everyday show keen interest was driving him wild, unable to handle himself accordingly. 

“Y-Yeah.. I wouldn’t mind that…” he replied, hearing all of the women’s cheers and celebration.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Back at Romeo’s house…

“So?... What are your thoughts, Romeo~.. Who’s the sexiest out of us?..” teased Mirajane, surprisingly seductive and quite the temptress when it came to sex. Her typical demeanor was completely different than her personality when aroused, it was almost scary how in-control and dominant she felt solely based on her awe-inspiring figure. Truly befitting of a woman who was featured on the front cover of Sorcerer Weekly.

“Hey!.. Don’t stare at her so much.. Young men your age love boobs, don’t they?.. Here, you get an eyeful here.” said Lucy while sending him an inviting wink, holding her hands underneath the weight of her milky, enormous breasts and purposefully lifting them before allowing them to drop and jiggle wildly. Amongst the three, Lucy definitely boasted the most enticing pair of tits. 

“Sure they do, Lucy~.. But it’s not their favorite.. From the books I’ve read and by personal experience, it’s the ass they truly care about.” argued Erza, striking a pose that had her plump butt sticking out, wiggling it side to side in a manner that couldn’t be overlooked. 

“What God decided to bless me today?!.. They’re all so sexy, I have no idea where to even look at anymore!..” thought Romeo, who’s blush was redder than a tomato, eyes pacing back and forth as blood rushed towards his baby-making regions. All three of the ladies were wearing the sexiest pair of lingerie he’d ever seen, all color-matching with their lustrous hair, thin-laced skimpy panties that hugged their fat butts like they were a thong, combined with a matching pair of erotic bras that struggled to contain their advanced sizes. Fairy Tail was truly a reaping for the hottest woman on the entire planet, it seemed. Considering how irresistible each and every single of them were. Left with the task between choosing a favorite between all of them, it was nearly impossible. Only time and experiencing their bodies in their rawest form was the only viable method he could choose to make his final decision. 

“I-I don’t know!.. Sorry if it sounds like I’m dodging, but you’re all so beautiful it’s difficult to make my mind!..” he admitted, desperately attempting to hide his arousal by casually dropping his hands lower towards his crotch and concealing his growing hardness. 

“My, such a charmer~..” purred Mirajane. It was a bit different seeing someone who was like a motherly, or older sister to him wearing such extravagant clothing. But man, did it not disappoint at all. And that womanly voice she wore was way too pleasing in itself.

“You’ve definitely grown into a fine man, Romeo.” said Erza, who showed a glimpse of her cougar-side, eyeing him up and down and realizing that he was quite desirable himself, originally going along with this for fun, but was now completely intrigued and bought in. 

They all approached him in unison, still fairly tipsy and drunk but generally were in control of their actions and thoughts. Romeo, who wasn’t necessarily foreign to womanly contact, still felt overwhelmed by three of the hottest bombshell babe’s any man has ever seen being so willing to sleep with him. He was pushed back until he’d taken a seat on the edge of his bed’s sizable mattress, although it didn’t feel like he was in the comfort of his home with the anxiousness of meeting these apparently horny ladies expectations. It wasn’t normal for him to be anything but the dominant partner, but this was the first time he was left relatively silent and having the other women take the lead. 
“T-This is really happening!.. Oh my god, a part of me doesn’t want to keep this a secret and tell all the guys.. But I’ll probably be killed!..” 

Lucy took the initiative in lifting up his shirt past his shoulders and over his head, exposing his chiseled and toned body that was a result of his frequent working out and training. Never relenting in his effort towards surpassing Natsu as a powerful mage, as unattainable as it be. Erza immediately pounced onto his enticing muscles, experimentally running her hands up and down his front, familiarizing herself with the figure that was going to keep her up all night. Mirajane found herself with the luckiest task, unbuckling the front of his trousers before he could even utter a word, heading straight to business and pantsing him free of any concealing clothing, his surprisingly well-endowed cock springing out and nearly hitting her directly on the face.

“Oh my… Romeo… With a cute face like that, I could never imagine that your penis would be so big…” muttered Mirajane, her warm breath tickling his junior, a front-seat view to the veiny, virile member that didn’t share much resemblance with the innocent young man they once knew. 

“R-Romeo?!... You have a dick like this, and I never knew?!..” exasperated Lucy, visibly shocked and gasping when turning her attention towards his crotch. 

“Huge… It’s almost like the way they describe some of them in the books…” muttered Erza, in disbelief just like the rest of them.

It was almost embarrassing having everyone absolutely fawn over the size of his cock, not that it was a problem or anything like that. In fact, he was now brimming with confidence after being showered by compliments, his huge phallus twitching in response. He wasn’t so sure going through with this in the very beginning, giving their close relationships and how they might be affected. But all of that nonsense seems trivial in hindsight, his head swirling with the boundless amount of sheer breasts and mouth watering curves. 

“You wouldn’t mind if I sucked it, would you?” asked Mirajane in a seductive tone, clearly a rhetorical question as she took the first swing at him, possessively grasping onto the base of his shaft almost as to say “This is mine”, claiming him from the jump. 

“Oh, not so fast, you cheeky woman!” exclaimed Lucy, resting on her stomach on the mattress and bringing herself down towards his crotch, face close enough that he could feel the warmth of her breath. 

Erza wasn’t ready to be outdone just yet, either. Taking the available side to his right and mimicking Lucy’s position, normally there wasn’t enough room for a man to handle three women at once, but with Romeo’s god-gifted size it seemed possible at the very least. They all eagerly anticipated his answer, even though there wasn’t a doubt that he’d concede, staring up at his blushing face with expectant eyes. 

“A-All three at once?...” he murmured, having never even heard of anyone he knew being spoiled like this. 

“Mhm~... You can tell us who’s the best once you cum..” whispered Mira, beating the rest to the punch and diving forward to place a wet kiss with her plump lips directly on the bulbous head, earning a surprised groan from the man as the others grumbled and immediately made their attack.

“Mira, that’s not playing fair!~..” 

Lucy and Erza were both relegated towards occupying the sides of his enormous, girthy shaft. Hating having to play support as Mirajane was in charge of the pre-cum oozing slit all to herself, getting a taste of their impending treat as the buxom blonde and crimson-haired babe opened their mouths wide and dragged their wet, hot tongues lewdly up and down the elongated shaft. Leaving a trail of their saliva as they openly breathed on his skin, allowing him to feel the true nature of a woman’s mouth. Romeo was trying his hardest to play it cool, but eventually ended up allowing a pleasured moan to escape, biting his bottom lip shortly after to silence the following sounds as he could feel Mirajane giggle with his member still lodged past her lips. 

“So cute~..” whispered Lucy hotly onto his sensitive skin, encasing her lips on the hardened skin with her tongue caressing the underside of his meatpole, occasionally colliding with Erza who was doing the same, unbothered by the fact that their mouths and wet muscles were touching. 

Romeo had his head tilted upwards with his eyes shut in ecstasy for the most part, almost feeling like they were too dirty for him to look at. But like most men, his perverted nature obviously seeped through, losing to the urge of opening his eyes and staring down towards the three competing heads that were servicing, no, worshipping his cock with their eager lips and voracious tongues. This wasn’t like the regular blowjobs, these three women individually were already out of this world in terms of how passionate, skillful and hungry their fellatio is. Drool, and lots and lots of saliva trickled down his length from the numerous tongues lathering him with their spit, glistening and shiny because of it. It was almost indescribable, everything felt very slippery but most of all it was incredibly warm. 

“Oh my god!.... This is too much!...” panted Romeo, finding his hips buckling all by themselves, not a say or word in his body’s response to the unparalleled level of ecstasy these three beautiful women were granting him. Their loud slurping was gnawing at his sanity, wondering how much longer he can keep up his restraint, wishing to hurry things up and fuck them despite how perfect their triple blowjob was. 

Lucy trailed all the way down until her plump lips stopped at the top of his ballsack, moaning to send vibrations directly towards his sensitive area as she suckled lightly on his skin, eliciting louder groans as Mirajane rolled her tongue up and down the leaking slit, with Erza coating the shaft with her tongue. 

There was no way that Romeo would feel better than this, right?

Unfair was possibly an accurate word to describe what transpired next. Mirajane was thoroughly working the musky tasting cockhead with her vacuuming lips and slithery tongue, while the available inches were up for grabs. Without voicing her plan of attack, Lucy struck first. Sneakily untying the back of her bra-strap that trapped her enormous milkers, the busty blonde grabbed two handfuls of her bountiful flesh and squeezed them against the shaft. 

“Unnnggghhhh!~... What is this?!..” gasped Romeo, having never seen so much tits spill out at once, and it was only getting better from there. 

Erza took her cue, freeing herself from confinement and slamming her impressively proportioned bust head-on with Lucy’s. It was honestly mesmerizing that Erza managed to stack up fairly, considering the luscious blonde was often heralded as possessing the best tits in the Guild. Romeo practically lost his mind being absolutely smothered by their impossibly soft, and supple flesh that nearly devoured the entirety of his cock. Despite how significantly longer his dick was compared to the average man, only a portion nearing the tip escaped, leaving enough room for Mirajane to work her magic as her thorough sucking of her lips continued.

“No fair, Mira!~.. We want our turn too!~..” pouted Lucy, noticing how there wasn’t much room for their tongues to travel after being replaced by the caress of their tits. Who was growing hornier by the second, understanding Erza was too with the way their perky nipples rubbed together. Mirajane pouted, knowing that acting selfishly during a foursome wasn’t the proper bedroom etiquette, and almost forcing herself to peel her sweet lips away from his salty tasting spear. A strand of saliva separating the two signifying her dedicated effort towards sucking him to completion, placing her lips against it for a final kiss before conceding her tight lock of his member, watching as the other two darted in and essentially made out with his bulbous tip in the middle, sliding their tongues lewdly as Romeo felt his heat throb with arousal.

"O-Ohh god!....."

Mirajane somehow managed to shove her tits into the mix, colossal proportions of heavenly tits sending the young man into a frenzy. He couldn’t help but thrust his hips upwards towards the area granting him bliss, sliding against Lucy and Erza's noses accidentally as they moaned and swiftly recovered to lap at the sizable head, the trio of cockhungry whores salivating and caressing him with their unfairly seductive bodies forced him past his limit. There wasn’t enough time to even warn them about the impending eruption, not even able to process it himself because it felt so good. His powerful orgasm led his entire lower half to shudder wildly, thighs smacking against the underside of their weight breasts that devoured his manhood, spraying a torrent of white semen high into the air as the ladies gasped in pleasant astonishment. 

“Romeo!~... There’s so much!..” gasped Mirajane in awe, receiving quite the face wash of cum. 

Erza wasn’t expecting the load so soon and instinctively closed her eyes and lips, perhaps the least experienced of the bunch but still lewd enough to realize her faults, eventually bringing her lips closer on the second burst and willingly becoming a landing spot for his seed. 

On the other hand, Lucy was in her element, already sticking out her tongue far and catching whatever possible with her mouth hung wide, wanting to swallow him full. Her eyebrow raising in slight anger when Mirajane irresistibly lunged forward and directly consumed the third and final load, each spurt was comparably massive compared to the rest, one shot was more than most men’s entire ejaculations. 

“Ha… Ha… Ugh, holy fuck….” cursed Romeo under his breath, chest heaving as his iron grip on the blanketsheets caused them to shift slightly, opening his eyes and looking down towards the absolute white mess of a titty sandwich. There were too many naked breasts that he couldn’t even tell who they belonged to less he could see their faces, or were familiar with their sizes. The immensely lewd sight alone was enough to keep his erection revitalized, not that he was planning on calling it quits anytime soon. If anything, cumming this much only motivated him to prolong the night further. At first there were lingering, hesitant thoughts about engaging with his comrades sexually, but now that was the only thing on his mind. 

"What a delicious meal, Romeo.. Thank you~.." purred Mirajane, swiping a glob of semen that landed on her cheek and licking it cleanly with her tongue, as if she were a cat tending to her fur. Teasingly giving him a final squeeze with her breasts before leaning forward and placing a kiss on the head, taking charge of cleaning his oozing slit. 

Lucy and Erza groaned at being beaten to the punch, with the redhead immediately catching the leaking spunk trickling down the shaft. Seeing as there was less room for her to operate, Lucy remained enamoured with the thick spunk that coated her mesmerizing breasts, backing away and lifting them from their sides, dragging her tongue along the cracks of her cleavage where the majority of it spilled.

"Agh.. I-It's still a little sensitive.. "

"Sorry about that, I got carried away~.."

"Me too.. Your penis is so huge, Romeo!.. I didn't expect you'd cum so much."

"Impressive.. I've seen one this sturdy and hard before…" 

From the exterior, it appeared as if they were all under control, calm and composed despite having been showered by Romeo’s virile cum. In reality, they were beside themselves with lust. Breathing heavily in anticipation with their nether regions heating up with desire, engorged clitoris with their pussy practically throbbing for penetration. Without a doubt, Romeo was the most sexually gifted man either of them had ever encountered, nd their bodies were screaming at them to claim this man as theirs and fuck.

Lucy impatiently lunged towards Romeo, straddling his lap immediately before anyone had the chance to move let alone react.  Holding onto his broad shoulders as she popped a squat directly over his dick, his heart racing watching the beautiful blonde align her dripping wet snatch. Plunging with enough force to completely penetrate the entirety of his length in one swift motion, eliciting a loud boisterous moan from both of their lips. It was evident that the horny blonde was the type to like a rough fucking, meeting the thrusting of his hips with her slow grinds and occasional bouncing on his lap. 

"Oy, Lucy!.. That’s not playing fair.. We're supposed to share him!" complained Mira, patting Romeo on the shoulder to grab his attention, before cupping his chin and stealing his lips with an impassioned kiss. There was a slight lingering taste of himself left behind, but he didn't seem to mind considering how the sweet strawberry taste of her lips canceled it out.

"Don't leave me behind!.." uttered Erza, frantically glancing around and finding out what to do. Noticing that there was still a few inches left that weren't fed inside of Lucy's pussy, due to the girth making it difficult to properly fit the entirety of him inside, Erza found herself tending to the available length by licking with her tongue, noticing an unfamiliar tangy taste that had to have been Lucy's leaking cunt, all the while fingering herself while waiting her turn. 

The clingy blonde wrapped her arms around his neck, but avoided pulling against him too hard to avoid interrupting his kiss with Mirajane. Exhaling heavily as her stomach felt full with cock, resting her chin on the crook of his neck and losing herself in moans directly next to his ear. She stirred his length deep within her aching cunt, feeling it briefly touch her womb, causing her to spasm and lose herself at the effectively pleasuring sensation. A few minutes of repeating the same motion that drove her crazy, occasionally hitting Erza with her butt who was steadily working the shaft and waiting for his leaking cum, wishing to scoop it up with her willing tongue. Meanwhile, Mirajane continued to swirl tongues and trade kisses with Romeo, who was absorbed into the overwhelming euphoria taking him over. He wouldn't consider himself perverted, but his sex drive was running rampant. Lasting long was more than a task, but his dick would simply rise back up after ejaculating, just as last time. 

"I'm gonna blow, Lucy!.. Oh, fuck!.." he cursed, unable to handle all the bouncing on his lap. He briefly separated from Mirajane's kiss and watched as Lucy's lewd huge tits swung around from how intensely she was riding his cock, refusing to let him go despite his frequent warnings. Crying in pleasure when Romeo busted and filled her womb with pumping hot cum, their moans in unison as the others watched in jealousy. But feeling relief at the same time, considering it was their turn coming up next. Her pussy selfishly refused to let go, only deciding to move once Romeo tapped her butt and slowly lifted her off of him by the hips. Not that he didn't want to fuck her all night, but there were others he needed to please.

He briefly made eye contact with Mirajane, who had him smitten by the kiss. All of the girls were competing who the better lover was, and he couldn't make up his mind until the very end. Erza Scarlet was assertive enough to demand her spot next, bending over doggy style and invitingly beckoning for Romeo to come closer, as he scooted behind her and held tightly around her lovely curves, drawing his hips back and swinging forward with a hard thrust.

"Unnghhh!~...."

A loud moan that rang through the room as she twitched, slamming against her thick ass and making it ripple. Erza reached back and held onto his hips, matching his thrusts by pressing back against him hard. Lucy hugged Romeo from behind and started to trail kisses up his neck, caressing his muscles with her wandering hands. Mirajane sat in front of Erza and had some fun of her own, making out with her as Romeo's aggressiveness colliding with her own movements made her moan uncontrollably. He made her ass clap, unable to dominate her as Erza put up a valiant fight of her own, squeezing his cock with her tight pussy, making him wonder how many men imagined to do this with the strongest female wizard in the country. 

Lucy tilted his head to the side as she claimed his lips, a lot more sexual than Mirajane's as their opened mouth kiss contained a lot of tongue. Fifteen minutes passing by, Erza finding herself unbelievably horny being drilled from behind and getting kissed by Mira's skillful tongue. Climaxing upon reaching her limit as Romeo followed suit shortly after, confident that none of the ladies were trying to even pull out, and willingly accepted his load. Assuming correctly as being creampied only intensified Erza's orgasm.

One by one each participant fulfilled their turn, leaving only Mirajane Strauss at last. If Romeo had to be honest, she was the one that caught his interest. Always finding himself staring her way, while he definitely found other ladies sexy, Mirajane was mesmerizingly beautiful too. He felt his heart pounding in his chest, being carefully laid down on the bed with his head resting against the pillows, having Mirajane lay down on top of him with her chest smothering his. Lucy and Erza were tired out and left sweating from their respective orgasms, opting to take a break as they sat back and watched. Romeo reached down and grasped two handfuls of her bubbly ass, gripping it tightly so that her flesh clung to his fingers, forgetting about concealing his groans as he allowed his voice to be heard, competing with Mirajane's vehement moans that sounded brilliant with her seductive voice. 

It was obvious. Lucy and Erza were top-tier, but in this competition, the winner was clear. No verbal confirmation needed, a mere glance was more than enough to give their answer. Disappointed in the results of the competition, but perhaps too far gone into the clouds of lust and the afterglow of sex to care. Mirajane showered Romeo's lips in sweet wet kisses, lovingly moaning as she thrusted her core against him, their thighs slapping together as his upward thrusts sent shockwaves of ecstasy throughout her body. The bed creaked underneath their weight, fucking like lovers, almost as if they were built for each other. Perfectly compatible as they greatly delighted in each others company, groaning and moaning profusely into their heated kiss, pistoning in and out of her sopping wet, pink pussy that's been craving this for such a long time, having to patiently wait and conquer the final round of sex that was given to her. In an essence, saving best for last, as Romeo felt himself completely lost by her body's warmth and mind-boggling voluptuousness. Enamoured by everything about her, her addicting scent, the softness of her flesh, the sounds of her moans, and the wetness of her warm pussy that wrapped around him ever so tightly. 

"Mira… Oh, Mira… You're incredible… I can't stop moving my hips!.."

"I can't either, Romeo.. Your penis is amazing!~..." 

An undefined amount of time passed by, with nobody in the room having a clue how long they were going for. Mirajane cried slight tears of pleasure as she rode him furiously, with her big buttcheeks being held tightly as if Romeo's life depended on it. 

"Inside!~.. Cum inside of me, Romeo!~.. I can't take it…" pleaded Mirajane, gasping loudly from her violent orgasm that reduced her to a moaning mess, sweaty from having fucked for this long, the motions of her grinding hips slowing down as she spasmed and squirted intensely all over the mattress. Vaginal juices staining the covers as she came, Romeo couldn't handle the vibration of her cunt, his throbbing erection pumping her full of his thick spunk. He sucked on her bottom lip as he absorbed her moans, leaving her breathless and sweaty as Mirajane nearly passed out from experiencing overpowering ecstasy. 

The long night had gone on for too long, as the exhaustion from partying and drinking prior also took a toll on their drained bodies. Still lodged within her vagina, Romeo slowly drifted to sleep shortly after glancing around and noticing the others slump onto the mattress, everyone had fallen asleep after the tiring bout of amazing sex. Their competition came to an end, but everyone's sexual desires had been fulfilled. 






 