Chapter 2 - Beach Competition - The Dangers of Swinging

Notes - All characters in this story are the age of 18 or above. This means that if a character happens to be under this age in the show canonically, in this story they are to be depicted as an adult version of them. I do not want to nor wish to condone sexual intercourse with minors. 


A/N - I have a Discord Server available on my profile where you can receive updates whenever I post my stories, ask questions or receive an update where you are in the commission queue. There is also a Patreon available where you can submit/vote on community polls, receive discounts and shortened waiting times. 


This is an alternate version of the main story "Fairy Tails Partner Swapping Story", done out of necessity. The theme and plot deviates too heavily from the original chapter, and as a result I will be moving chapters 4 and what would have been 5 here, with the swapping/swinging aspect remaining prominent in the other story. 


Tags - Swinging, Creampie, Oral Sex, NTR.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


In the morning…


Lucy Heartfilia yawned after seemingly awakening from the greatest slumber. The night prior, and after spending a week’s worth of incredible, passionate, breathtaking sex with a muscular hunk that was admittedly too large to be compared to an average man’s body, the salacious blonde was sore and exhausted all over. The ten hours long sleep that felt like an eternity was induced by a rippling orgasm, one that she had discovered over the course of her time becoming the temporary lover of Elfman Strauss. Today marked the end of their relationship, if you will. This didn’t mean that they would be forbidden from having sex, as they encompassed the word fuckbuddies in their entirety, they just wouldn’t be living together any longer. That is because her actual boyfriend, Natsu Dragneel was on his way back home. Obviously, she missed him dearly, and was content with his return, just like how she would definitely miss Elfman, whom she was currently laying on top of, not a single shred of clothing separating their beautiful, naked bodies that were still recovering from their frequent, memorable bedtime activities. 


“Good morning~...” muttered the sexually satisfied woman, wiping her eyes and stretching before staring down at her tanned, ginormous lover. Never during their time together as guildmates would have imagined waking up to him in her bed like this, wild life changing experiences had taken place in such a short amount of time. Juggling between both of her partners was admittedly difficult to maintain, Natsu’s always her one and only, longtime comrade and bestfriend, her romantic companion. In bed, however, he had some serious competition, the thought put a harsh blush on her face, staring down at the nude frame of her fuckmate that made love to her like the beast that he is. 


“Oh…. Morning, sexy~...” he groaned, slowly opening his eyelids as he was greeted to the wonderful sight that was the most attractive woman in the entire country laying on top of him, her magnificent breasts squashed against his chiseled pectorals, bringing the humongous palm of his left hand and casually placing it behind her neck, meanwhile he gently held onto the marshmallowy assmeat of her big booty. 


“Mmuah~..” were the exaggerated lip smacking noises they made from their brief but strong kiss, really pushing their lips together, demonstrating their mutual affection for one another. 


“Last night was incredible, Elfman… I can’t believe we really did-.. You know… That…” whispered Lucy, embarrassed and bashful now that she thought hard about it, surrendering her anal virginity which was something that she’d never thought she’d ever taken an interest in doing. 


“Yeah… I couldn’t help myself… You have such a fat, juicy ass..” growled Elfman, giving her pale thickness a good shake by gripping it tightly within his fingers, making Lucy chuckle as she closed her eyes and dove in for another kiss, this time sticking out her tongue which was met with Elfman’s as he opened up, the two making out for a couple seconds unbothered by the lingering taste of morning breath, the distance that had closed between them was remarkable, falling deeper into a trance of their seemingly magnetic connection that was a product of their extraordinarily erotic bodies. A match made in heaven in terms of that regard, something that they frequently reminded each other whenever they could. 


“Mmmn!~... And your fat, juicy dick stretched it out so much~...” mewled Lucy, keeping her eyes open as she looked down towards their sloppy, saliva filled tongue connection, rolling them together as they lewdly intertwined, reaching down with her available hand that wasn’t caressing his muscles, and instead caressing and gently fondling the bulge of his morning wood. 


“Dirty girl.” he muttered, sliding his hand to cup her chin, and then stuck out his tongue.


“Sexy man.” she retorted in between breaths, rolling out her wet muscle and dragging it up along his.


“I had a lot of fun this week, we would have a lot of problems to deal with if we really became lovers, though..” he snickered, referring to how the majority of their time was spent doing nothing productive, unless you counted sweaty, neverending sex as being productive. 


“Mhm… I don’t think I’ve ever came that many times before… It was ridiculous…” commented Lucy.


“Me neither… That pussy of yours just kept begging and begging for me to cum inside of it… I almost want to never use a condom again…” teased Elfman.


“I know, right?... It felt so good doing it raw… I just couldn’t stop… Every time I was around you, I just wanted to get fucked!...” she admitted. 


“I’ll definitely miss this, I’d do anything to switch positions with Natsu. Hell, I don’t know a man that wouldn’t.” he smirked, watching as her mesmerizingly luscious figure came into clearer view as she pushed herself off his broad frame to sit on top of him, ogling her perfect nipples, those enormous milky breasts, smooth and plush thighs, with a round bountiful rump cushioning his hard muscles. They were contrasting in many ways, from the tone of their skin, their completely opposite sizes, one being freakishly tall and the other feeling tiny in comparison, while he felt rough, hard and rigid, Lucy’s body was nice and soft. They were total opposites but similar in various ways, that’s what made their chemistry in bed inconceivable. 


“That means a lot, Elfman… I’ll be thinking about our time together too… You know, at some point I was scared that you were gonna get me pregnant… Even though I’m on the pill, I’ve never had so much cum constantly filling me up like that…” joked Lucy, although half seriously. 


“You can’t blame me!... I was just making love to you, of course I would fuck you like I was trying to get you pregnant.” said Elfman.


“W-Wha?!... Alright, that’s enough teasing from you!..” gasped Lucy, blushing as he brought his hands to rub over her stomach.


“If we spent everyday together eventually we might accidentally have a kid, don’t you think?” he teased, delighting in her flustered reactions as she avoided eye contact and smacked him across the chest. 


“Hmph!.. Don’t talk about that, or I’ll have you start wearing condoms again!...” 


“No, no, no!... I was just teasing, don’t do that Lucy!...” he said in a panicked tone, wishing to backtrack on his statements to reverse the damage he’d done. 


“Idiot!... Don’t get cocky cause your dick is a little big.” 


“A little?... I recall you moaning how it was the biggest one you’ve ever seen.”


“Shut up!~... Don’t talk about that so nonchalantly…”


“If I knew any better, I’d think that you’d want to spend even more time getting spoiled by it~..” confidently claimed Elfman, nudging it up against her backside, which she playfully batted away with her hands that were covering her holes to deny him entrance. 


“Quit it, we can’t do it right now… We’ll meet up again sometime later this week.” sighed Lucy, having no idea where this boundless libido came from, having never seen him in the light of being a sex freak, it wasn’t often that he’d ever brought around a girl with him. 


“Oh, so you don’t want to see me more often?.. That’s not very manly of me, maybe I didn’t do a good enough job of pleasing you.” said Elfman.


“No, you did more than good enough.. It’s just-... Oh, gosh… This is getting a little out of hand, don’t you think?... Let me talk about it with Natsu, I need to know how he feels about all this… He knows that I-.. Um.. Fancy you, and he hasn’t been that bothered, but… I don’t know… We’ll see, okay?...” stuttered Lucy, unsure of where this was all heading. Sleeping with other men was a womanly experience, it made her feel hot and sexy, and if Natsu didn’t have a problem with it, then she didn’t mind indulging in those spicy sensations with Elfman, her new ideal for a sex partner. 


It seemed like he wasn’t paying much attention, with his eyes glued to something else as Elfman reached up and swiped his thumb across her bottom lip. Lucy went silent and kept her piercing gaze at him, knowing what he wanted. 


“I’ll suck it after we shower, we have to get ready soon.” she answered, wearing that sly slime she wore when her loins would heat up from how obsessively horny she’d become.


After they finished their shower, and Lucy sucked him off real nice and good, they were having a quick breakfast wearing nothing but their towels, until they finished and Lucy told Elfman that he should probably go home and get packed for the beach trip that she’d invited him to, that was set to take place in a couple of days. 
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


A couple days later, at the beach…


It was a private resort that was rented out for the famous Fairy Tail wizards that wanted a space to wind down and relax after having exerted so much of their time and energy protecting the country from disaster. Those that were able to make it were Elfman, Natsu and Gajeel for the boys. The ladies were Cana, Lucy and Levy. It was originally supposed to be a couples trip with Gajeel and Levy, but she felt like inviting her best friend Lucy along, who in turn invited her boyfriend, Natsu. After hearing about how Elfman was coming too due to Lucy's request, Cana asked to tag along, under the impression that this was going to be a double date at first.


Lucy Heartfilia sat in between both of her lovers, Natsu and Elfman by her side. Levy was sitting with Gajeel across from them, and Cana was the odd one out with being the only person not with a mate alongside them. Technically, Elfman was single, but it sure didn't seem like it.


"Ahhh!~... It feels so lonely over here, sitting by myself… It's not fair that Lucy has two boyfriends to herself…" jokingly pouted Cana, curling up in a ball like she was depressed. Her bikini was nonexistent, instead wearing a pair of pink laced, white bra and panties that looked straight out of a pornographic film. 


That sly comment made everyone jump slightly in their seats, with Lucy nearly spitting out her drink upon hearing it. After coughing slightly and clearing her throat, wiping her lips from the lemonade that spilled out, she made a complete recovery before wearing a teasing smile, sitting up tall to wrap her arms around the two men.


"Yup, these two are my boyfriends." she teased, with Elfman blushing slightly at the comment, and Natsu confused as he looked at her. 


Lucy immediately felt his sharp glare, and laughed as she turned towards him and pecked him on the lips as an apology, playing along with Cana's joke. Sharing a nice smooch before they separated, while the others awkwardly stared as Lucy turned in the other direction and looked at Elfman, noticing the look in her eyes never changed between the two. 


"Wooow, you're really going to show off like this, huh?" said Cana, crossing her arms underneath her tits as she watched Elfman cup Lucy's chin, closing the distance and then inserting his tongue into her willing mouth, swapping spit and saliva as the spectators flinched at the aggressiveness on display. 


"Hey!.." snarled Natsu, yanking Lucy away by the arm, and then repeating Elfman's actions and pulling her into a searing hot kiss, passionately smashing their lips together as she squeezed her thighs in response.


"Mmnph!~... Wait!~..." gasped Lucy when Elfman tugged on her back after a few seconds, holding her cheek as he swooped in and then tongued her deeper. 


"Hold on, Elfman!~..." said Natsu, his competitive fire lighting up as he interrupted their tongue tying session, and then pulled out a little something of his own as he sucked on Lucy's bottom lip, making her moan as the two began taking turns making out with her. 


"Jeez, Lucy.." muttered Levy, blushing and feeling the need to cover her eyes, as even Gajeel felt slightly embarrassed from watching.


Cana laughed and cheered, applauding at the sight of the two hypercompetitive males competing for her. Evidently, the trio was starting to get horny, noticeable, large bulges sporting on the front of their swimsuits. Natsu was wearing a fire patterned swim trunks that was typical of him, and Elfman wore a black speedo that was covered by a cloth covering the front, a necessity in order to hide his size when coming to the beach. 


"Wow… I didn't know you were actually dating both of them… When did you and Elfman start going out?... I heard somebody tell me you guys went out on a date." asked Cana.


Lucy had to push both of her palms against Elfman's chest to keep him at bay, as he was shoving his tongue down her throat. After gasping for breath, the flushed blonde wiped her mouth and glanced at Cana, breathing heavily from the constant lips and tongues attacking her mouth. 


"W-We're not going out… He was filling in for Natsu for a week, so… No, Natsu's my true lover… But Elfman, he's um-.. My sex friend, we meet up twice a week and-.. You know…" shyly muttered Lucy, talking about it out loud in front of both of them had her heart racing. 


“I can’t believe the rumours are true!. Even now, I see so many couples exchanging partners at the guild… Look at you, Lucy… You’re so naughty~...” teased Cana, having a lot of fun watching her friend turn bright red from her words, casually playing her like a fiddle in her fingers. 


“I-I’m not!~... Well, sort of..” muttered Lucy under her breath, knowing fully well that both Natsu and Elfman knew of her true nature. Not necessarily a nymphomaniac, but close to it when her flip was switched on.


“Hahaha!~... Don’t worry, you’re not the only one!... I heard that Levy's been around quite a bit herself.. " said Cana, redirecting her attention to the blushing brunette that was hiding behind her boyfriend's broad shoulders.


"H-Huh?!.. What are you saying, Cana!..."


"You've slept with everyone here, haven't you?.. If I remember right, Gajeel caught a couple bodies too, correct?" asked Cana.


"I-I did not!... Well, for the most part you're right… But I didn't have sex with Natsu, I just gave him a blowjob!.." exasperated Levy, hearing about their partners talking about the things they did with others wasn't something that they'd completely get used to, but while Gajeel wasn't surprised since he's seen her in the act, it was still awkward to talk about nonetheless. Levy was one of the only women who hadn’t slept around after the fact, compared to the rest who were having a blast being traded around. 


An exaggerated gasp snapped them away momentarily from their conversation, coming in the direction of Lucy Heartfilia who had barely managed to escape the grasps of her two horny sex craving beasts, freed from being groped and kissed all over her mouth. 


“What’s gotten into you two, there’s a time and place for that!..” she scolded, angrily wiping her lips with the back of her hand and readjusting her bikini top that had nearly slid off from how much they were fondling her huge tits. 


“Don’t be so stingy, Lucy!~...To tell you the truth, I find you guys pretty sexy.. I like muscular dudes, so all three of you check that area… Not only that, but~...” her words trailed off as she glanced down towards their crotches, licking her lips in anticipation and flying a seductive wink in their direction. 


There was a silence that fell the group from the sexual tension that had been rising as of late, and how the guys had all simultaneously taken notice that Cana Alberona was quite the slut. Meanwhile, all the girls had their own attention grabbed by the mountainous crotches threatening to poke holes through the boys shorts, Natsu Dragneel was sporting a painfully large erection, and Elfman’s was bulging uncontrollably despite his efforts to conceal himself. 


Gajeel wasn’t aroused by anything else that had happened, keeping to himself for the most part, wrapping his arm around the slim waist of his tiny girlfriend, who was returning the touch by placing her little hands over his penis, and cupping his balls lightly and feeling him harden up within her grasp.


“Levy… What are you planning on doing?...” he growled, staring at her affectionately as it seemed the miasma of lust began to intoxicate the group of six healthy, sexually active adults. 


“You know, that looks a little uncomfortable… I wouldn’t mind sucking you guys off to help get rid of it.. I don’t mean to brag but, I give pretty damn good blowjobs.” whispered Cana, wiping her glossy lips with her thumb to accentuate the fullness and beauty of them. 


They didn’t even need words to explain how they felt about that wonderful idea, all three of their faces simultaneously lighting up. Gajeel wasn’t one to outright admit it, but his excitement was apparent, and the party was a demonstration that while he certainly had a lot of fun with Levy’s small, slender body, he wasn’t adverse to testing the waters with other women either. 


"Gihee.." he chuckled when he felt his girlfriend grip his dick tighter.


"Gosh… Look what you two did, you big perverts…" sighed Lucy, sitting back down between them and then grabbing both of their junk, giving it a playful shake and earning a combined grunt that made her laugh.


"See?!.. No fair!... Poor Cana is all by herself~..." complained the hot, charming brunette, squeezing her arms together to accentuate her already mesmerizing cleavage.


"I had a feeling this was the reason you wanted to tag along." said Lucy, rolling her eyes at her perverted friend.


"Oh, you know me so well, Lucy!... I can't help it… It's not fair that everyone's having so much fun except me!..." complained Cana, who started scanning the boys before coming to a conclusion.


"Are you okay with this, Lev?" asked Gajeel, patting her in the thigh, she simply looked up at him and nodded, perhaps finding herself swept in the mood as well by glancing at the three behemoth cocks before her. 


"Hmm… Since Elfman is the only single guy here… We should probably start together?..." proposed Cana, with a wink in his direction.


"Hmph!..."


Lucy felt a vein pop out in her head, slightly irritated as she grabbed at his dick, making him wince a bit. She patted Elfman on his rock hard behind and told him to stand up, with the half naked giant listening to her request. Looking right at Cana, the seductive, voluptuous blonde lifted the cloth that was hardly covering his crotch, closing her eyes and bringing her face right up to it, pressing her nose against it, wiping his sweaty bulge as she smelled his intoxicating musk. It was such a dirty thing to do, and it was weirdly captivating watching this incredibly sexy, pretty woman completely smitten to the point of sniffing the body odor of his private regions.


"Geez… You really like smelling me like that…" he commented, lifting up his cloth so that his little whore had access to his absurdly lengthy meatpole that was jutting out from his speedo. The tanned mushroom tip and parts of the seemingly muscular shaft was visible at the top, and Lucy moaned as she let her tongue slip and started lapping at his grapefruit sized testicles, rolling the clothed balls on her tongue, while inhaling heavily through her nose that was resting against his shaft. There was sweat smeared on her face, panting heavily as she obsessively consumed his scent as Natsu would, like a dragon slayer with a sensitive nose and a powerful sense of smell.


Gajeel and Natsu were stunned at the display, both mentally noting that their own girlfriends have never done anything like that for them. A tinge of salt on Natsu's part, considering this was his girlfriend doing this in front of him.


"God…. Everyone probably thinks I'm such a whore right now…." thought Lucy, closing her eyes and dragging her tongue up and down with broad motions against his sweaty undershaft, drinking the salty liquid down before snaking her fingers underneath the tight speedo, yanking it down and allowing his humongous dick to whip out and slap her dead center of the face. The wave of virile musk that sprung out thanks to the boiling hot weather of the sun made her dizzy and salivate at the mouth, leaning in and placing a gentle kiss at each ball, pulling him down slightly so that she could place her soft lips against his ebony cockhead, before wrapping them around it and then expertly taking him down all the way to the root, stifling a gag and keeping still after a deep inhale, lasting several seconds with her esophagus stuffed before backing away, leaving behind a visible trail of thick saliva as Lucy gave him a few pumps of her hands to mark her territory, spitting on it for good measure before backing away and fixing her hair in a ponytail.


"He might be single, but… This dick belongs to me, okay?... I'll let you play around with it for a bit, but don't think you'll be able to steal it away just because we're not dating." explained Lucy, pointing at her greatest treasure which made Elfman grin widely at her compliments and boasting off his manly genitalia.


"You're so selfish!... You can't claim Natsu and Elfman!..." said Cana.


"Yes I can!... They're both mine, and I'm just letting you borrow them…" replied Lucy.


It was a bit weird to be referred to like an object, but Elfman felt flattered over Lucy's possessiveness. He made sure to show his gratitude by tapping her lips a few times, receiving a complimentary lick across the slit in response. 


"Come on, take it out baby." ushered Lucy, fiddling with Natsu swim trunks as he happily stepped out of them, turned on and in the mood as he growled animalistically, watching as his impossibly hot girlfriend untied her bra strap that was carrying her heavy hugs, letting her perfect, sagless boobs jiggle as she dropped onto her knees. 


"Ahh, I missed this, Luce.." he admitted, slightly distracted by the show she was putting on earlier.


"Me too." she spoke, grabbing ahold of her melony flesh and carrying them up towards his pole of meat.


"I guess that means you're stuck with me, huh Elfman?... I can tell that you like Lucy a lot, so don't feel so bad that she's reunited with her boyfriend… Don't worry, I know how to show you a good time…" purred Cana, beckoning at Elfman who walked towards her. 


"I wouldn't say you're a bad person to be stuck with, Cana… Yeah, I've got the hots for Lucy, but that doesn't mean I don't recognize a hot piece of ass when I see one." complimented Elfman, who reached full mast thanks to his cockhungry sex soul mate throating him.


"Come on, Levy… Do it for me…" urged Gajeel, holding onto the shorter girl's pert butt while she leaned over his lap and started untying his shorts in preparation to give him head. 


------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Natsu groaned and rested his head back, keeping his hands to himself as Lucy performed her trademark boobjob that served as the perfect soothing method. A week spent without fucking her has further decreased his resistance to Lucy, feeling extra sensitive to her every action. There wasn't a woman in the world that could give a better paizuri then her, utilizing her godsend assets to the fullest of their capabilities, engulfing his cock with her smooth heavenly caresses, the tip of his dick barely visible from the top as his toes curled and his hips started moving by themselves.


"Aghh, Luce!~... Jesus, it's been so long since we did this…" he gasped, staring down at her pretty face in admiration. 


"It really has been… I missed you!... Ah, I almost forgot how hot your penis is… You're not called a Fire Dragon for nothing…" she joked, skillfully lifting her heavy balloon like tits from the bottom and allowing them to slide against his length, masturbating with her cleavage while she stuck her tongue out and allowed spit to trickle down onto his slit. 


"We need to make up for that time we missed together… I'm all fired up now!..." said Natsu, making Lucy smile at him.


"Good… Then cum for me, baby~... I want to drink it again… Come on, cum!~..." she pleaded, tightening the hold that her velvety chest had on his spit slathered cock, bringing the manhood that she was so accustomed to a spasming ejaculation, turning her famous boobs into the perfect cocksleeve for him to thrust up against, watching as he disappeared and reappeared from the depths of her crevice, until his incessant groans grew twice fold and he blasted a shot of sperm directly against her chin. 


Lucy yelped and laughed it off, swiping whatever landed near her lips with her tongue, letting it bask on her tastebuds again before making a comment. 


"Tastes sweet, Natsu." was her final opinion, as if she were a professional cook tasting a fine dish, something that made Natsu laugh as he patted Lucy on the head for a job well done. 


------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Meanwhile, with Gajeel and Levy..


Levy McGarden wasn't nearly the innocent lady that she'd appeared to be on the surface, evident in the way her lips were lewdly working Gajeels excessively hard member, taking him deeper than anyone would expect her a tiny woman to handle. They were nearly as sex driven a couple compared to Lucy and Natsu, it's just they've never publicly displayed their affection. 


"God damn, Lev~... You're really hungry for it, aren'tcha?" he teased, massaging her cute butt with his big hands, staring down at the back of her head bob up and down his cock feverishly. Her mouth was hot and Gajeel loved how much saliva she would use, not afraid to get sloppy as her soft lips glided up and down his member. It was impressive how much she was capable of gobbling up, choking and persevering along the way, spurred on by her lovers touch that was rubbing and kneading her bum flesh. While not necessarily big compared to the others, it was really tight and soft, something that Gajeel seemed to love a lot. 


"Mmhhmm!~..." she moaned, jerking her head wildly as she loved sucking on Gajeel’s dick. There was something abnormal about all three of the lovely cocks that were being slobbered upon in the middle of the private beach, and the attributes of the Iron Dragon Slayer was certainly Levy’s favorite. A fabulously hard, rigid sturdy cock felt as if it were melting inside of her mouth, wiggling her butt from side to side when Gajeel demonstrated his appreciation by spanking her for it, quickly finding his stride and then suddenly erupting his spunk within that awesomely sticky wet orifice. 


He could feel her lips crack into a smile before Levy slurped it all up, taking a few gulps to swallow it down as she always felt a sense of pride whenever she would make a strong, brutish looking man like Gajeel cum. There was a sense of having power over him in that regard, and that was something that lit up an inexplicable fire within her.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


“Oh my God…. It’s way bigger than I thought it’d be…..” gasped Cana, coming face to face with the colossal cock before her. It wasn’t shocking whatsoever that she would react like this, Elfman Strauss wasn’t genetically built like the average man, closer to a Giant’s body than anything, which applied in more than one area.


“You’ve never seen one this big before?..” he asked, naught for the purposes of genuine curiosity, but perhaps to stroke his ego as a man, something he’s always been obsessed with keeping his image of. 


“Nope, you’re definitely the first!... Jesus, Lucy takes all this?... What the heck’s up with the size of this thing?...” she uttered in cockstrucken stupor, gently caressing his weighty ballsack within her hands that felt pale in comparison, giving them a light squeeze and noticing that there was no visible reaction on Elfman’s face. 


“Yeah… She’d been taking all of it for a whole week until a few days ago..” he bragged, watching as Cana mimicked Lucy and took a whiff of his manhood, trying to better comprehend why her best friend had become so attached. 


“The smell’s definitely strong, I’ll give you that… You want me to do this while you’re standing?..” she asked, tucking her hair gently behind her ear, looking up at the tall giant that was in turn looking down on her. 


“Show me what you got.” he responded, with Cana taking the invitation, keeping her eyes open as she wore a sultry smile on her face. Her hot tongue slid from her glossy dicksucking lips, and using her extensive experience at the art of fellatio, opened her maw impossible wide and stuffed herself full with the salty fuckrod, immediately noting the exotic taste as her nostrils flared slightly, fitting such a large object in her mouth was a challenge in itself. A complete deepthroat was generally her tactic in wooing the men that she’d sleep with, but such a task with Elfman was nearly impossible, only a few were capable, one woman being Lucy Heartfilia who sucked him off for her own personal enjoyment. 


Sluurp, schllrp, ggrrk, nngh, nggh!~..


There were some obscene noises escaping her tightly shut lips that refused to allow such a virile cock to slip away from her clutches, her jaw had grown sore after spending several minutes unsuccessfully trying to swallow him whole, failing multiple times and gagging profusely as a result, drooling from her chin from the persistent attempts. Elfman was impressed, and particularly enjoyed how his immense size didn’t deter her in any way, seeing it as a challenge as she showcased her talent by skillfully showering the veiny shaft with her tongue, gathering up all of her spit and saliva in the midst of choking herself on his dick.


“God… You’re damn good at this, Cana… You remind me of Lucy!...” he grunted, certainly high praise as the brunette eventually succeeded in stretching out her esophagus to constrict her throaty walls around his meat, face deprived of oxygen and leaving her cheeks pink as she stuck her tongue out to lick at the skin of his sack, immediately rewarded with her prize as nonstop splashed of white semen coursed down her throat, leaving her wide eyed from the copious amount, having never swallowed this amount of seed before, even noting the difference in texture from her usual male encounters. 


Cana squeezed his testicles that felt enormous in her hands, meanwhile sucking up all of the saliva and semen in her mouth, milking him for all he was worth, and rubbing her thighs together in the process.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


"Ha… Not bad, Lev… You get better every time… I've done a good job helping you practice, huh?" said Gajeel, making Levy blush as she clamped her hands around her mouth, finishing gulping down the rest of his load. 


"Natsu~...." muttered Lucy in a hushed voice, crawling up his lap and straddling him, clinging onto him affectionately as it appeared that her switch had been turned on.


"Sheesh, that was a TON of cum, Elfman… I can see why your balls are so big now.." commented Cana, keeping her fists against her lips as she coughed into them.


"My bad, was it too much?" he asked, visibly concerned as he patted her on the back.


"I'm fine!... I just wasn't expecting that… I can see why Lucy loves it so much now…" she teased, sending a shiver down Lucy's spine as she overheard Cana's comment.


"L-Let's move somewhere else, Natsu.. We should find a more suitable place to do this…" muttered Lucy with a heavy, beet red blush on her face.


"Hey, what's got you so embarrassed?.. Is it not true?.." asked Cana, waving in their direction and grabbing Elfman's junk and slapping it across her own cheek, playing around with it.


Lucy turned her head back in their direction and felt her heart jump with Elfman expectantly staring at her, waiting for a response.


"Y-Yes, it's true.. I love your cock, Elfman… Gosh, why'd you have to make me say that?!... You should know that already… You know, since I've already told you that.. " sighed Lucy, hiding her face in Natsu's neck who lifted her off the chair.


Even Elfman blushed at the confession, averting his gaze as Cana erupted in laughter before getting off her seat, approaching the two and nudging Lucy's side playfully with her elbow, leaning in and asking aloud but in a hushed manner.


"So?.. Which one's your favorite between the two?.." 


The question raised the hair on Elfman and Natsu's bodies, twitching slightly when they both heard it. Natsu wasn't completely dumb, getting a bit ticked off with the way things weren't shifting in his favor.


"T-There's no way I can answer that!.." spat out Lucy, blushing furiously as she looked away from Cana who was pushing all her buttons.


"Hey, hey.. What's been going on here?.. All day, it feels like you've been making it seem like Elfman is Lucy's boyfriend or something.. And that I'm losing.." said Natsu, showing a bit of spunk while getting his words off his chest, not out of malicious intent, but he was rightfully annoyed with all the teasing at his expense. 


"Jeez, Cana!... You're going to ruin the fun if they start taking you seriously!..." scolded Levy. 


"Oh?... You don't think you're losing, Natsu?.." asked Elfman, intrigued by his latter comment.


"No, I don't.. I let you stay with her for a week, but I've been with her for years." he snapped back, everyone stunned at the quarrel of men happening before them.


"I like that!... I admire your confidence, Natsu… That's what it takes to be a man!... Then let's see, who the better man is…" he challenged, reaching out to him for a handshake, which Natsu gladly returned.


"You're on!... I don't remember you ever winning a fight against me, Elfman!..." shouted Natsu, typically engaging in a lot of duels with the other fellow guildmates.


"This is completely different from a fight!... When you were gone, me and Lucy were getting lovey dovey while you were out with my sister!..." retorted Elfman.


"N-No fighting, you guys.." muttered Lucy, like a kitten trying to stop a clash of lions.


"Oh, yeah?.. I've been fucking her almost every day since we first did it.. You're just a substitute for me!.." yelled Natsu, fire lighting up his eyes as he confronted Elfman by standing up to him. While from the outside looking in, temperatures were certainly flaring, and boiling hot passion captured the two men, but there wasn't as much bad blood between them as it seemed.


Lucy was a high maintenance girl, with an exceptionally demanding sex drive, Natsu didn't mind having Elfman fill in for him when he wasn't around to keep her company, the fact that she seemed to love it wasn't a problem, so long as they kept their relationship primarily sexual. Although, what he wasn't about to do was back down and take the disrespect, wanting to prove a point by challenging Elfman in front of the others that weren't giving him his fair due.


"What a bunch of idiots." laughed Gajeel, standing beside Levy and cupping her butt.


"Oh, why are you so carefree about it, Gajeel?... If I recall correctly, Levy drank Natsu's sperm, and passed out after Elfman fucked her… Shouldn't you be a bit worried that you might not be her favorite choice in bed too?" taunted Cana, making Levy's jaw drop and Gajeel flare up with energy.


"Excuse me?... Alright, I see how it is… Hey, Natsu and Elfman!... Let me in on this too… I fucked Lucy too, remember?.." snarled Gajeel, the three of them coming to an agreement. 


"This'll be fun!... Why don't us girls all come together at the end of this and pick who our favorite is?" suggested Cana, with the guys nodding in agreement, a three way staring competition as Lucy sighed and covered her face anxiously.


"What did I get myself into?.." she thought.


"You can do this, Gajeel!..." whispered Levy, patting him on the back for encouragement.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


The three pairs relocated towards an area on the beach with rocks, untying their skimpy bikinis along the way that slid off of their pristine, buxom and slender figures. They were all gorgeous, and sexy in their own way. None of the guys had any complaints with what they were working with, hardly able to keep their hands off the prize as they strutted in front of their partners. Elfman himself was surprised by how captivated he was by Cana, believing that Lucy was the only woman that could turn him on like no other. 


Natsu was seemingly in a hurry as he flopped the towel down and let Lucy lay herself on top of it, sliding her bikini bottoms to the side and exposing her slickened, dripping wet cunt that was begging to be pounded. The couples remained the same from earlier, and were all getting set up for some much needed sex, the girls were horny, the guys were excited to prove what they were worth, and the tone was set. 


"Hhnngghh!~..." lewdly moaned Lucy, who was Natsu's hot girlfriend, one that he was wanting to mark as his, keeping her laying down on her sides, holding her legs apart and plunging deep into her cunt. The heat emanating from the sun left their bodies drenched in sweat much earlier than usual. 


"I've been thinking about doing this for a while, Luce… Sex with Mira is amazing, but with you, there's something different." he huskily whispered into her neck, making her shiver in sensitive delight as his hands clamped onto her plump breasts, hitting her womb from the back as he started picking up the pace with his fervent thrusts. Immediately, that fuzzy warmth filled her stomach, the one you felt whenever you'd become intimate with the man who'd you've always found yourself admiring since you've met, and transitioned from becoming best friends into lovers. It was an inexplicably cozy sensation, one that only Natsu himself could provide. Granted, his body heat was physically different, another attribute that could only be found with him.


"Mmnnghh!~... Mmm!~..." panted the voluptuous, busty blonde. 


Natsu was on a roll, grinding against her most pleasurable spots within her molten heat, motivated and fuelled by the sparks of competition as he surpassed his potential and gave Lucy perhaps one of the best sexual performances he's had in his life. It felt like her entire world was being rocked from his inhuman strength, stronger than any other person on the planet, and teasing it with his wholly thrusts. Her snatch was gushing and squirting juices like a leaking faucet, combined with the massage of her bouncy tits that wobbled with every rough slam of his hips. 


Lucy understood what brought this out of him, and wanted to poke at the ravaging beast within that hadn't yet come out to play. A risky decision, but the near teared moaning seductress wanted to reach even greater heights of euphoria. 


"O-ooh!~.. Natsu… Did you know?... Nnghh!... That Elfman has the biggest dick I've ever seen…" she muttered, feeling Natsu's movements halt for an instant as he processed what she said. 


"He's bigger?... So, what?... I'm not going to lose just because he's huge.." he retorted, slowly working himself back within her clinging depths as Lucy fought the urge to shut up and moan, believing that this would be the key to Natsu's primal lust becoming unshackled.


"Yeah.. But, when he was fucking me in bed… He made me moan so much… He made me yell that his cock was my favorite!..." confessed Lucy, which ignited Natsu's inner flames to the maximum, wanting to prove her wrong as jealousy struck him, tightening his grip over her busty body and furiously fucking her until her eyes rolled to the back of her head, and her tongue hung loosely as her spread legs were held higher and higher, stretching her as far out as possible without inflicting pain.


"Uunghhh!~.. Oooohooo!~..  Uuggghhh!~... Aaaahhnnn!~..." her feverish moans competed with the others surrounding them, forgetting that they weren't alone, unbothered by the taboo and lewdness of their conversation.


"Oh, yeah?.. So, Elfman's cock is your favorite?..." he growled, spanking her buttocks relentlessly as punishment, treating her like the drooling sow she was.


"Uhh-huh!~... He fucked me so good!~.. I couldn't stop cumming… We spent an entire day fucking until morning!~..." screamed Lucy, suffering from a series of orgasms when Natsu pumped her incredibly hard, his engorged cockhead hammering her womb, voice hitching from the roughness of their sex. He was never gentle, knowing that Lucy liked being manhandled, but he was taking the next step onto a different level, unbridled pleasure overcoming his lover that was spewing words that should never be admitted, and receiving grandiose punishment as deserved. 


"I can do that too!..." he yelled vehemently, entering a similar state during his mating season, showing his fangs and veins popping in his head as he ruthlessly wrecked Lucy's outstretched, aching folds. 


"Aaaahhhnnnn!~... He said he was trying to get me p-pregnaaantt!~... If I wasn't on the pill, then surely-... His baby would be inside of me!..." her voice exploded as Natsu converted his feelings of anger into a passionate flurry of perfectly overpowering thrusts. His hips snapped sharply, rutting senselessly deep within her insides as he cleaved it in and out. Her cervix was being pummeled by his lurching, strong shoves of the fat cockhead tearing her apart. Natsu wasn't going to pathetically back down from the words escaping Lucy's lips, he wasn't going to concede and accept defeat and walk away, he wanted to be the flawless lover, conquering whatever challenge was in his way. 


"Take the week off, Luce… We'll stay home, and I won't do anything but fuck you…" he promised, licking a hot trail along the back of her neck as he pinched her nipples, eliciting another eruption of juices from her nether regions as she nodded her head frantically.


"Ohkayy!~.. Yesh.. Yesh!~.." consented Lucy.


Natsu's animalistic grunts were almost as intimidating as they were sexy. Lucy felt so turned on at this moment. Talking about Elfman made her feel dirty, and the way Natsu was punishing her was exactly what her womanly urges were craving. This was the outcome she had so desired, nearly hyperventilating from the exceptional crushing thrusts by Natsu's thick cock. 


"I love him so much!~..." thought Lucy, staring up at Natsu with half lidded eyes as he cupped her cheek, kissing her aggressively in combination with his wildly unrestrained slams that left her feeling weak in the knees. His chiseled muscles were an understatement to the paramount power he truly possessed. It was cruel treatment for any other boyfriend not named Natsu, who didn't lack the gall to put up a fight, and he proved himself that he wasn't going to be surpassed so easily. 


"What else did you say to him?... What else did you do?..." whispered Natsu, biting her earlobe and digging his fingers into her bottom flesh, pancaking her ass against his manly hips as he made her spill everything that occurred in his absence. 


"Ahnnn!~... I started-... I started calling him daddy when we're alone and he cums inside of me!... My pussy was so full of his thick semen!~... We didn't wear a condom, he kept pumping me full with cum!..." confessed Lucy in the throes of passion.


"Yeah?.. Call me daddy, Lucy… I'm gonna fill your womb up with cum for being a bad girl!..." he threatened, intensifying the blistering speeds of his pistoning slab of meat that was lathered in her cream.


"Dadddyyyyy!~❤"


"Good girl… I can't believe you were so naughty when I was gone… You really think Elfman fucks better than me?..." he asked.


"I-I don't know anymore!.." gasped Lucy, recovering from an orgasm-induced spasm.


"Why?... I never thought I'd have competition… Is it because of how big it is?..." asked Natsu, wondering what areas gave him the boost to match his level, fondling her boobs heavily while he spoke.


"Mmhmm!~... That's not only why, though...I like how it smells!~... I love the taste!... I swallowed his load until I milked his balls dry… I promised that I'd suck his dick whenever he wanted!..." confessed Lucy, flipped over onto her stomach immediately after, hair gripped within his fingers as her face was shoved against the towels, her spine arching in acceptance. 


"Looks like I've got a lot of work to do this week…" spoke Natsu to himself, snickering as he took out his frustration against her sore, sopping wet pussy.


"Nnnghhh!~.. Even now, I'm still hurting from when he pummeled me with that huge, fat fucking COCK!~...." 


Lucy momentarily fell out of consciousness as a result of Natsu's hyper speed thrusts, her pussy greedily convulsing and clinging to his veiny shaft that constantly slipped in and out of her entrance. 


"I'll take everything back, Lucy.. I promise you.. I refuse to be your second favorite, I want an undisputed first place!.. Just you wait!.. I'll make you regret even thinking that Elfman had a chance!.." exclaimed Natsu, his throbbing man meat reaching uncharted temperatures of bodily heat that made it feel like Lucy's vaginal cavity felt warmed up from the inside.


A hickey started forming on her neck to replace the ones left by Elfman as Natsu was in the process of reclaiming his territory, having never believed he could ever lose, and vowed that he would erase her words.


"I love you, Natsu… But I also love Elfman's perfect cock!..." moaned Lucy at the top of her lungs, shuddering uncontrollably as her smushed buttcheeks clapped until they became a shade of bright red, tilting her head back and seeing Natsu look down on her as he held her neck. 


"Elfman… Elfman… Elfman!... That's all you keep saying!... Look at me, Lucy… I won't lose!..." thought Natsu, smashing their lips together as she exhaled from the collision, a pool of vaginal fluid already soaking into the towels beneath them.


"Amazing!.. This is so amazing!~... Natsu's fucking my brains out!..."


"Grr… I'm gonna cum, Lucy…" he let out a coarse voiced, feral growl. Her arm reached back to caress his pink hair and stroked it affectionately as they smooched. Lucy’s tight cleft convulsed and clenched in preparation, welcoming the load that was set to be released directly within her womb. 


“Do it inside of me!~.... Fill me up, Natsu!~... Come on, fuck me baby…” she pleaded with a look of elation, heart thumping loudly in her chest as he bottomed out fully to the brim before allowing his creamy gunk to implode within her baby making areas, coating it with his baby batter. Pulsating madly, his energized cock appeared as if it would never settle down, load after load, the volume and thickness comparable to what she’d become accustomed with for the past week or so. 


Lucy lost herself in the throes of passion, mind boggled as the tip of Natsu’s dick continuously carves against the insides of her womb, as if to scrape out Elfman’s presence within it. His pride wouldn’t allow Elfman to conquer his woman, re-establishing his place by thoroughly dominating, capturing her heart that had nearly forgotten how Natsu wasn’t a pushover in bed himself, a phenomenal sexual pleaser as well. After all, he was the guy that had awakened her kinky, perverted side. Their naked figures reeked with sweat, they panted and gasped for air as they embraced each other tightly, calming down from their sexual high that influenced several choice words to escape them, now leaving Lucy flushed from the realization of what she’d said. 


“You’re not mad at me, are you, Natsu?...” she asked in an adorable voice, fearing for the worst.


“Of course I’m not, I just made you cum really hard, didn’t I?..” he chuckled, rubbing his hands over her flat belly.


“Mhm!~... It was incredible… Maybe some of the best sex we’ve ever had..” muttered Lucy, staring back at Natsu and looking deeply into his eyes.
“I guess I’m mad about one thing… You said Elfman wanted to get you pregnant?..” he asked sternly, no hint of joking in his voice.


“N-No!.. I mean, he didn’t say he was actually trying to!... Ah, he just told me he was um.. Doing me like he was actually trying to make me pregnant, if that makes sense… I made sure not to miss taking my pills… I was really careful!... I’m sorry!...” Lucy apologized. 


“It’s okay, as long as you remember… I put Mirajane on the pill too, condoms get in the way of our fun, doesn’t it?...” said Natsu, smirking as he leaned in to place a heartwarming kiss on his girl’s lips. 


“They do… Oh, thank goodness.. I thought you were going to hate me… I don’t know if I would call it a bad idea, but letting Elfman stay over for that long was dangerous…” admitted Lucy.


“Did he make you do things you didn’t want to?..” asked Natsu.


“No!.. He didn’t.. Um, everything we did-... I wanted to do… It’s just, Elfman seems to like me a lot… The sex is so good, we’re inseparable.. It’s kind of like me and you when it comes to that… Just sometimes, he says stuff that goes a little too far… And sometimes I do too…” acknowledging and spilling the beans on everything that transpired.


“Okay… Let’s talk about it when we get home… I’ll chat with Elfman some other time… If we’re going to continue living a swinger lifestyle, there’s going to be some bumps along the way until we can both come to a compromise.” replied Natsu, slowly humping her buttcrack.


“Alright… I love you, Natsu…”


“I love you too, Luce..” 


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


 Cana and Elfman several minutes prior…


“Well, this is going to be a lot harder than I thought, huh?...” muttered Cana under her own breath, looking down at the enormous giant that was sitting on the ground, completely naked with his tanned muscles bulging as if he’d just completed an intense workout. He was vascular and felt hard as a rock, noticing this when Cana held onto his broad, wide shoulders as she carefully lowered herself upon the even sturdier object that was his ebony battering ram, looking as if it were ready to go into war. 


“Are you sure you want to be on top?..” he asked, noticing the nervous sweat trickling down her forehead.


“Yeah.. I want to try riding this big thing… Jesus, I’ve never seen one this thick and long before… Your cock looks like it belongs to a monster!..” gawked Cana, breath growing ragged the closer the moment approached when she’d be penetrated by his ungodly appendage.


“That’s kind of rude, isn’t it?...” joked Elfman, laughing as he tried calming Cana down, carefully palming her hips and aiding her down, hearing her whimper slightly when their crotches met together, and the painfully erect, glistening knob jabbed at her slickened, heated folds. Cautiously, they waited patiently as they slowly pushed the rest of the engorged cockhead inside of her, mouth hanging open as a silent gasp escaped her lips, grimacing slightly when her small pussy was forced apart, despite being sexually active, there wasn’t enough fucking that could have appropriately prepared her for this. Sex with a borderline giant was on a completely other stratosphere than what Cana’s previous experiences were like, trembling and twitching violently as inches of his dense, heavy shaft of his virile cockmeat entered her snatch. 


“Aaagghhh!~.. Shiiit!~... Gooooddd damnnn!~... You’re a big boy, Elfman… Fuckin hell’... I can’t believe Lucy gets fucked by this thing all the time… I feel like my pussy’s about to break!..” exasperated Cana, digging her nails into his shoulder with her left hand, as her right desperately tried to grip at his huge biceps. There was a lot of surface to hold onto, at least. Cana was actually a size queen, never settling for less when it came to penis size, and yet, there was no chance in hell that she was able to withstand it. 


“Take your time, Cana.. Nice and easy.. Normally, I’m too big for some girls, so let me know if it hurts too much…” he said kindly, casually running his hand up against her sides for comfort. 


For a woman that prided herself in taking control of the bedroom, Cana was being humbled by suffering such a one-sided loss, nearly cumming from the torturously pleasurable, yet difficult penetration of his superior erection. Having to wiggle around to find his way past her resistances, her vaginal walls constricting him impossibly tight as she squeezed and squirted around it, now hugging him for dear life as Elfman rubbed the back of her head to calm her down.


"It'll be okay.. Just a bit more, and I'll be completely inside of you.." he snickered, loving how much trouble he was putting Cana through.


"O-Ohkay!~..." she gasped, inhaling a deep breath and then taking a final plunge that shoved the remaining sloppy inches down in one motion, sending shockwaves of unbridled pleasure from within her inflamed pussy, experiencing a stretching that it wasn't physically designed to handle, pushing its limits. Her legs stretched and straightened out completely and her entire body spasmed, orgasming from the minutes-long process of jamming Elfman's being inside. Cana's head hung backwards as she panted like a bitch in heat, grinding her engorged clitoris against him in celebration, only serving to worsen the severity of her open mouthed orgasm as her triumphant moans faded away into the beach's windy air.


"You came?.. That's good.. So, how is it?.. Do you like it?.." asked Elfman, gently shifting his hands lower, until he cupped her plump buttcheeks. They fit quite nicely within his palms, noticing how firm they felt in his grasp, slightly more muscular than Lucy's that he was used to groping.


"Y-Yes… I like it a lot… It's painful, but it's starting to feel better…" admitted Cana, sweating like she'd just ran a couple miles, now face to face with Elfman who made her feel miniscule within his arms.


"Great… Can I start moving now?..." asked Elfman, waiting for her response as he checked out the rest of her naked figure. It wasn't a secret that many guys found her hot, because she'd always dress herself in skimpy, slutty outfits.


"Yeah… Just go slow, I don't know if I can take all that dick to be honest…" she whispered, not wanting to be heard by the others.


"Really?.. You know, I wasn't gentle with Levy either.. She’s so much smaller than you too, surely I thought you'd be able to fare better.. I guess you've never actually been with a real man before, have you?.." he teased, smacking her bum with his huge fingers, making her yelp.


"W-What?... Levy too?!... Fine… Let's see what you got then… It probably won't be as bad as it loo- AAAHHNN!~.. Aahhnn!~ Ahh!~.. Ooohh!~..." 


The busty brunette couldn't stop shaking as she clung to Elfman's muscular frame, having her nice ass groped as his chiseled cock rocketed his unbelievable length in and out of her grasping, recklessly throbbing cunt. Noisy orgasms swept through Cana's entire senses, bucking and throbbing against the burly freak of nature that left her pink pussy swollen red from the abuse, bouncing and jiggling in his lap, struggling to ride him and instead sat obediently in between his legs, Elfman grunting like a wild beast as he pummeled her sensitive cervix, unbearable shockwaves of pained pleasure surging through the shivering, leaking Cana who's indispensable words came out as nothing but moans. 


"Oh my fucking God!~... He's fucking me so hard!~.. I can't even speak!.. I'm completely full with cock, and he's stretching out my womb!..." mewled Cana, lungs wailing for oxygen as her womanly legs wrapped around his waist, tightening as her buttcheeks flexed as well as the rest of her muscles, her soaked clenching tunnel releasing portions of his hammering cock with slutty, airy pops as she lost herself into mindless pleasure, legs quivering with small pained gasps escaping her mouth after every time she would momentarily be brought down the earth after a series of violent orgasms. It was constant, and happened quickly, over and over Cana came as Elfman demonstrated the prowess of what a foot long appendage was capable of. 


Lasting any longer than she did without snapping seemed incomprehensible, luckily for both of them, Elfman let out his backed up, tar like sludge directly from his pisshole after enacting several thrusts, the past three days without Lucy allowing him the opportunity to restock his huge pouch with semen that was being emptied within Cana's vaginal cavity, seeping into her womb as she was nearly brought to tears, huffing and puffing as she rested her sweat clad titties against his front, in disbelief from the heavy jets of seed slamming against the back of her innards.


"........."


"Elfman… You just came inside of me…" 


"Oh, shit!... I'm sorry… I was just so used to doing it, I completely forgot!.. Is it a dangerous day?.." he asked, concerned in his voice.


"No, no… Don't worry… I was just surprised… I'm on the pill, I got ready for tonight… So, you creampie Lucy all the time?.." asked Cana curiously, still resting on top of him with his dick stuck inside of her.


"Yes.. I do.."


"Jeez, looks like she's already passed me.. I could barely keep up with you.." said Cana.


"Don't worry, she barely does either."


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Meanwhile…


Gajeel and Levy were attached by the hip, stuck together as if they'd been covered in superglue. Hands ravenously roaming each other's bodies, grabbing and holding whatever flesh or muscle they could, making out hotly with their lips and tongues working extensively as were their connected private areas. They didn't only have sex, they made love. It was what you would expect from watching a couple that have spent the majority of their nights learning each other sexually, knowing what they liked, what they loved, what they didn't like, what they hated. All of this came together to produce what was happening before them, the last couple to finish as Cana, Elfman, Lucy and Natsu watched them tussle, their concealed moans muffled from how their lips would hardly separate. Slightly red and sore from the constant sucking, nibbling and light teeth grazing that would be done. 


"Levy can really get dicked down, huh?.." commented Cana, trying to get a better image of Gajeel's size, coming to the conclusion that he was really big. Not quite like Elfman, but definitely larger than any other dick she'd taken deep inside of her.


"Yeah, she really can.. I was surprised myself.. I had sex with her at the party, and Levy felt amazing." said Elfman, with Cana sitting on his thigh and feeling up his abdomen.


The couple looked like they were in literal heaven, limbs attached to one another as Levy clenched her small, skinny legs around him, begging for more of his meat pole with her ample butt easily cupped while he ravaged her wonderfully tight walls. They were able to last several minutes longer compared to the rest, who haven't had sex as recently as both Gajeel and Levy, the loving couple doing it before they left the house the moment the pretty bluenette showed off her bikini to her hubby.


"I'm cumming, baby girl~... Take it!~..." urged Gajeel, swinging his hips back and completely penetrating her while he pushed her tight cleft full of cum, making Levy claw at his already marked back and sucking on his tongue while moaning fervently.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


A couple minutes later.. 


If the competition were to be even, then it only made sense that the couples would all need to shuffle around, having at least a single round with each other before being able to properly judge a clear cut winner. Natsu and Cana joined together, and Gajeel approached Lucy afterwards, perhaps reminiscent of their time at the party, meanwhile Elfman and Levy had a little reunion of their own. 


“To tell you the truth, Natsu… I’ve always thought that you’ve grown into quite the handsome guy, I was surprised.. Who knew that the little brat that would cause havoc and run around the guild would grow up to become such a stud..” flirted Cana, this time understanding that these men were nothing like her previous hookups, and assuming a more submissive role. Situated on her hands and knees, Cana’s arched back pushed out her glorious backside that was amongst the best for Fairy Tail women. 


Natsu wasn’t listening to much of anything, laser focused on proving once and for all that he was unrivaled in bed. His hands latched onto her slim sides, before situating around her wide hips, carefully angling his throbbing, cream lathered fuckrod that was a sloppy mess thanks to Lucy's vicious orgasms, directly at Cana's outstretched, aching hole. He slipped in with relative ease, with Elfman's girth already carving the way, grabbing and yanking onto her luscious brunette hair, and pounding her doggystyle.


"Oohhnnnggh!~... Natsu!~... Shit!~..." cursed Cana, her hanging breasts swaying back and forth as he demonstrated how fierce sleeping with a Dragon Slayer really was. The source of his strength wasn't only coming from his muscles, indulging in his carnal desires as he plowed the sexy brunette from the back and made her soft, pillowy rear end bounce and wobble from his onslaught of thrusts. They fucked like animals and Cana was able to slam her ass back against the ensuing ramming of his hips, delighted in the unnatural hotness currently residing in her pussy. 


Natsu growled as his tempo somehow escalated faster and faster, leaving Cana mewling and praising his exceptional skills, despite his huge cock being the second largest she'd taken, this honestly felt more natural than being taken by a giant like Elfman. That was completely overwhelming, hardly capable of breathing properly, let alone remaining conscious. It was important to feel like she was on equal ground with her partner, which was probably why Natsu was sexually satisfying her like no other.


"Hooonngghhg!~... Fuuckk!~.. Natsu, that's damn good..  Yes, right there!~... That's the spot!... Keep fucking me!~... Oohh, Lucy is soooo lucky… She gets to fuck two studs whenever she wants!!~..." moaned Cana, drooling and shaking her hips erratically as Natsu worked her tight cunt into overtime, still sensitive from somehow handling a foot long monster, and now welcoming in a dragon slayer's cock that defied human expectations in its own right. 


"You like that, Cana?.." asked Natsu, wanting to receive some reception on his talents in bed, searching for validation.


"Yesss!~.. It's soo goood!... Your hot dick fills me up just right!~...." complimented Cana, her legs trembling slightly as a waterfall of vaginal fluids escaped her narrow hole and trickled down the back of her thighs, filling Natsu with pride as he brought both himself and Cana to the promised land, tugging on her hair to pull her back against the shoving of his proud dick, that was pushing against the entrance of her womb and wonderfully smacking against her G-spot, hips bucking uncontrollably as they reached a fever pitch and ended up shooting his cock milk inside of her, forgetting to pull out as the only intention he had in his mind was to devour Cana whole and wreck her. 


"Natssuuuuuu!!!~.... Oh my fucking goooddd!~... You fucked the shit out of me!" gasped Cana, finally realizing why and how Lucy turned out to become the erotic woman she was today.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Meanwhile…


Gajeel had his girlfriend's busty best friend pinned underneath him, their chest smashing against one another as he could feel their marshmallowy softness against his hard pecs. 


"Aaagghhhh… Gajeel!~... I don't know if I could ever get used to this… Your cock is so hard!..." gasped Lucy, writhing and trashing underneath him as her tiny hands were gripping his toned arms, watching at the connection happening down low as the sensations his iron-like cock provided was completely different than her usual two lovers. 


"I'll help you get used to it, don't worry… I gotta admit, since we're already fucking… I think this lewd body of yours is pretty sexy when I get you dressed up in that slutty bunny outfit and have you dance for me… This is our second time, but I've always thought about doing this to you.." growled Gajeel, matching Natsu's ferociousness, perhaps a trait shared amongst Dragon Slayers. 


It never felt like they were having casual sex, but mating. It was like there was a deeper meaning to it all, even if there wasn't. Elfman was capable of producing those exact feelings too, however. Lucy wondered if it was because all of the guys she'd gotten dicked by were special, their magic abilities having a secondary effect on their bodies. Any way, her train of thought was snapped by Gajeel's meat stick that was the sturdiest of them all, rubbing against her walls and feeling her clit grind against him, a pleasant sensation that sent explosive signals of arousal throughout her body, squirting slightly as a result as their naked bodies collided together. 


He didn't weigh as much as Elfman, but Gajeel's metallic body felt heavy as he pushed down on her, leaving her with a slight sense of suffocation from the sun's boiling heat shining down upon them, trying to ease it slightly by keeping her hands pushing up against his chest, letting her moans to flow freely as they humped together for several minutes.


"You're not quite Levy, but Natsu got pretty lucky with you, huh?... You've got huge, fat tits!... I'm still a guy at the end of the day, so of course I'd find you attractive with those milk bags of yours being flaunted around." huskily teased Gajeel, looking at her facial expressions as he guided her through a range of emotions, elation, overjoyed, lust. 


He wasn't shy about delivering impactful blows, leaving Lucy to habitually roll her groin against his, half consciously searching for even deeper penetration. After having just slept with Natsu, she realized that there was something amiss. That was the connection shared between true lovers, what was making her moan in bliss was none other than lust, but what she felt for Natsu wasn't infatuation nor affection, but a romantic desire to be with him. Gajeel however, still made her cum, proof that she was a woman that was capable of drawing the line between her emotions, and able to be demolished by a cock that didn't belong to her boyfriend without feeling like she was betraying him. 


"Oh, Gajeel!~... You're being so rough!..." 


"You like it that way, don't you?.. Come on, everyone saw how you lost your mind at the party.. You were the one that started this all, remember?.. If you hadn't gotten horny and fucked Elfman that day, I wouldn't be lucky enough to be plowing you like this!..." he snarled, his balls flaring up as he grunted incessantly, pushing up against her with a final powerful slam and emptying a turgid load within her internal crevices. 


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Levy McGarden wasn't the bustiest, nor the tallest girl by any means. However, that didn't mean she wasn't attractive. Elfman in particular, had taken a liking to the tight bluenette. The way that her small, sticky pussy clung to his elongated shaft was unmatched. Not Lucy, nor Cana were a tighter squeeze than her. Elfman had her laying completely flat on her belly, her tiny white frame was hardly visible from the back, the only view you'd have was Elfman swallowing her up with his masculine body, demolishing her tight cunt to the point where her wet folds were screaming from how far they were expanding, stifling her groans by keeping her mouth over her forearms.


If the man wasn't Gajeel, Levy still felt shy about having her voice be heard. Elfman easily manhandled her, pushing his heavy weight on top of her nice buttocks, rugged empowered thrusts that left the pale skin of her backside pink from the constant slapping of their skin. Levy was nearing an empty headed state, nearly biting down on her arm as tears formed in her eyes, watering as their second time together felt just as devastatingly staggering as the first. Their builds were a complete mismatch, a lady as short as her wasn’t supposed to be pounded by a gigantic man of his stature, to the point until she started seeing stars. 


“Uuungghhh!~... Oooohhh!~... Aaaahhhnnn!~...” her voice crept out in between her frequent gasps for air, her aroused, sopping quim was pouring her tangy vaginal fluid, lingering over from her lovemaking with Gajeel. Levy grimaced as she tried and reached back, tapping him on the arm to signal for him to slow down while in the midst of a slight orgasm, Elfman quickly apologized as he fell into the bad habit of treating every woman like they were Lucy. 


“Was that too much for you, Levy?..” he asked, pausing his swift fucking motion and carefully rubbing along her inner walls, growling as he lounged in the paradise that was her heavenly pussy. 
“Just a little bit… Ha… You were going too fast… I was scared that I was going to break!...” giggled Levy, laughing it off as she carefully pushed herself up off the floor, wiping the sweat that was dripping into her eyes and rearranging her hair, looking back at him with a beaming smile. 


“I see… I can slow down for you, but can I thrust in deep then?... I want to see how much of me you can take..” he admitted, staring down at her back that shone with sweat, making her work for these bombastic climaxes.


“E-Eh?... You weren’t thrusting it all in?..” asked Levy.


“Nope, I was stopping a few inches back, I didn’t want to accidentally hurt you.” he said.


“Oh my… Elfman, that’s kind of scary!... I thought you were giving me all you got, I almost passed out again!...” admitted Levy.


“That would be bad!... You still have another round to go, so you have to stay awake… Here, let me give you a preview, and you can make up your mind if you want me to keep going.” he spoke, drawing his hips back until his painfully erect cockhead nearly slipped out of her gripping, soaked cunt. Realigning his hulking member within her tightness, and then packing her full with his enormous, exotic cock that left the gravid orbs of his balls swinging against the underside of her bum cheeks, an audible whap that was the result of the harsh collision, one that sent vibrations throughout Levy’s innards, right up against her guts as her womb was stretched to the brim, shuddering from the aftershock with her mouth agape, a delirious lust filled expression donned on her face as her nether lips pushed out her juice, spritzing his groin with her transparent, sweet looking fluids that continued to be extracted as he continued the momentum of his agonizingly slow, but severely penetrating drives of his hips, that felt like she was being punched by his prick helmet on the insides. 


“How’s that?... Feel good?... I see that you can’t stop cumming.” smirked Elfman, watching as he utilized Levy like a cocksleeve, nearly breaking her mind as he couldn’t stop himself from abusing her delicate hole, showing her an out of body experience that left a pressurized sensation deep within the recesses of her loins, these persistent orgasms building up towards a final, mighty one unlike any other. There was no audible response coming from Levy, whose head was jerking back and forth at the apex of the impact rendered by his crushing hips. The scent of sex emanating in the air was noticeable, made more potent by the fact they were all drenched in sweat and panting heavily for air. 


“Hnngghh!~...” every time he would thrust, rough noises escaped her lips.


“Nngggghhhoooo!~...” 


A second thrust.


“Aaaaahhnnnn!~.. Haaa!~... Ha!~....”


A third one. 


Levy felt like the strength in her legs were being sapped away every time his dangling, heavy testicles would slap against her skin like that, along with the fact that the pressure being put on her tender womb was nearly mind shattering. If she wasn’t adventurous in bed, she would have called it quits ages ago, perhaps the moment she laid her eyes upon the spectacle that was Elfman’s beasty man meat. In her mind, if she could somehow tame the mammoth appendage that was his cock, then there wasn’t any level of restraint Gajeel would need to show during their spicy private time at home. 


“Aagghh… You’re too much, Levy… I think I’m going to cum… Can I do it inside?...” he asked, his weight leaning down on her as he had just completed yet another swing of his hips, dipping them against the flesh of her ass that flattened against his hips, filling her to the brim and more as he spoke huskily near her ears. 


“I-Inside?...” her voice stuttered with her lips trembling, uncertain of what her response should be. It was a tempting offer, but her morals were vaguely different than Lucy's and the other couples participating in the swinging, having second thoughts to the point where she looked towards Gajeel who caught her gaze.


"What is it, Lev?.." he asked while breathing hot and hard, pulling out of Lucy with his cum strings attached to her puffed pink pussy.


"Oh… You came inside of her?..." asked Levy.


"Yeah.. I'm sorry, I couldn't help it… Why, what's up?.. You seem a little busy there.." he chuckled, watching as Levy was about to speak before letting a noisy moan slip when Elfman shoved against her once more. 


"C-Can he cum inside me?..." she asked for permission, a dazed look in her eyes as they spoke, exhilarated by the situation they were in, talking while another man fucked her felt so naughty. 


"Go ahead, Lev.. Just make sure to clean up properly when we're home, plus you're already on the pill." he said.


"Great… Then let's finish this with a bang!.." said Elfman, abruptly leaving Levy feeling empty when he pulled all of his lengthy cock out of her, flipping her over onto her back, and then raising her slender legs high into the air, pushing them over as he turned around and almost took a seat on top of her, assuming a difficult reverse piledrive position that left Levy's view blocked by his tanned muscular buttocks and his sweaty sack that contained his bulging, veiny balls that were carrying an abundance of semen ready to be dispersed. 


"H-Huh, what are you?-!!!... Aaaahhhnnnnn!~... Nnggghoooooooo!!~...." 


The howling moans that came out of her throat almost felt like it shouldn't have belonged to her, Levy screaming a cry of euphoric pleasure as her legs shook viciously as Elfman squatted over her and pumped her velvety insides full of his thick, viscous seed, his bloated nutsack carrying a stream of that white fluid that seeped out of her gaping hole, leaking all the way down onto her stomach and chest as he erupted within her for an entire minute, his deep manly voice releasing booming groans as he capped off their mating session that sullied Levy's angelic esque pussy, leaving her covered in cum from the oozing of her loosened vaginal tunnels, moaning as the greatest orgasm cascaded through her vaginal folds and sprayed extract from her cunt like a hose, landing all over the ground as their mixed juices served for an incredibly erotic substance produced by their intimate connection.


The creampie left her clocked out of reality for a good while, arms falling to her sides and limp as Levy closed her eyes for a couple seconds and gave out. 


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Evidently, the girls found themselves cumming uncontrollably without an end in sight, and for most of them, this meant that their stamina had already been depleted. That is precisely why the final round was excruciatingly pleasurable but strenuous to push through. Cana and Levy were already at their limits, but the competition wouldn't be decided unless it was seen the whole way through. Only Lucy was capable of more, trained by not only Natsu but Elfman, spending nearly the entirety of her weeks getting shot up with cum for hours upon hours on end. 


"I always knew you were a slut, Cana… You like getting railed by a bunch of different guys, don't you?" taunted Gajeel, holding her ankles apart and pounding her sex that admittedly couldn't handle much more, leaving her exhausted and drained as her brunette hair sprawled out underneath her, silken and glued to her skin as Cana's chest heaved for air, keeping herself spread apart so at the very least Gajeel could finish while her head was in the clouds.


Levy and Natsu were experiencing similar symptoms, except he wasn't close to being emptied in the slightest, on his knees and supporting Levy's featherweight by the butt, while she was propped up on her elbows and curling her legs behind them as they locked themselves together. He was good, very good, on par with Gajeel in terms of his technique and performance, and tightened up whenever she would come close to cumming, letting him bust inside when he was finished, confessing that she didn't have the energy to move much afterwards. 


This left the final pairing to be the one that started this all, Elfman and Lucy. It was almost awkward seeing each other again, only three days have passed since they've lived together for a week. They walked towards one another and met in the middle, both dripping with sweat, cum and other vaginal secretions scattered on their genital areas. 


"Looks like it's me and you again, huh?.." snickered Elfman, towering over her as he stepped closer to Lucy, who stood in place and tried fixing up her appearance a little, a faint blush on her face.


"Yup.. It's only been three days, though.." she laughed, looking up at him and making eye contact.


"You're already flooded.. You must be really turned on right now.." he commented, checking her goddess-like figure out that he would never get tired from.


"I am… Gosh, Natsu fucked me so good… And Gajeel did too, it's a lot of fun, this swinging thing.." admitted Lucy, wiping down her breasts with her hands, giving them a slight jiggle.


The big breasted blonde jumped slightly when she felt Elfman's thumb rub across her cheek, carefully lifting her up by the chin so that they were facing each other.


"Lucy… In this competition, you are the one I wanted to win over the most.." confessed Elfman, leaning closer as she remembered seeing his big lips moving in before she closed her eyes and met his kiss, hopping up into his muscular arms as he lifted her off the ground, his forearms strong enough to serve as a seat, wrapping her arms around his neck as they breathed through their noses, lips smashed together for a brief second before they separated.


"I couldn't stop thinking about what we did-" he was silenced by Lucy's finger that shushed him by pressing against his lips, stopping him mid sentence.


"Kiss me." she whispered, a sultry gaze that pierced his heart, looking up at him while she lewdly stuck out her tongue, eyes half lidded as a trail of saliva dripped from the tip of her pink wet muscle and onto his chest. 


"Who do you want to kiss?"


"You."


"That's not what I meant."


"Gosh… Kiss me, daddy!~❤" shamelessly pleaded Lucy, coming to terms with her emotions and establishing that no matter how slutty she'd become for Elfman, Natsu had already won over her heart, and that she shouldn't feel guilty for loving sex during the partner swapping, because the main reason they were doing it was to feel amazing. Leaving Natsu had never crossed her mind, only then would she sit back and think about distancing from Elfman, but for the time being, it was time for her to get fucked. Her mouth was opened wide like a bird waiting to be fed, and Elfman stuck his tongue inside of her orifice and gave her the sloppy, deep kiss that she wanted, making her moan as his right hand gripped her booty cheeks and dug into its mushy flesh. They let out a relieved gasp when their lips somewhat connected, their heads tilted in opposite sides with Elfman's tongue reaching the depths of her oral cavern, a kiss that most couples would find disturbing, but Lucy and Elfman thought it was incredibly sexy. They've kissed for a literal hour before, and never got tired of it even though their lips would get sore, and their tongues dry. Maybe they would have done that again, only if they were living under the same roof, and away from anyone else. Natsu and the rest probably didn't want to stick around for that long, so Elfman wrapped up the tongue fucking after several minutes, not before gathering a ball of spit and spitting it in her mouth, with Lucy swallowing it obediently. 


"Mmph!~.."


He was going to end it there, but Lucy dragged him back into her face, and started rolling her tongue in circles around her lips, kissing him like a filthy whore that didn't mind being one, and by now, everyone had already finished, leaving them as the last couple standing. Her stamina was ridiculous, her libido unmatched, even Elfman or Natsu would sometimes finish before her, their tank empty until they shot blanks. They could feel the eyes staring at them, as Cana and Levy chattered, with Gajeel and Natsu basking in the afterglow of impassioned sex.


"Lucy… They're all finished already… We should start now…" muttered Elfman, pulling away from her hot mouth and slimy tongue that was wiping around his lips like a windshield, thick strands of saliva connecting their chins as their chin and outer lips were smeared with spit. 


"Ohkay… Fuck me, Elfman… I want your dick right now…" seductively whispered Lucy into his ear, her pussy even more crowded with juices. 


"Everyone's already finished… Let's give them a show.." he whispered back, placing a quick gentle kiss on her lips, before shifting her around so that she was facing the others, leaving Lucy flustered beyond belief from the pair of eyes staring at them, like they were the final event of a show. It had just dawned on her that they were all waiting for them to finish, wasting a lot of time kissing and licking each other's tongue and mouth.


"H-Huh?.. Um, hi guys…" nervously muttered Lucy, waving at her friends and lover that was staring right at them, having to cover her face within her hands afterwards as she was sweating from anxiousness. Elfman slipped his pillar-like arms underneath her armpits, clamping his humongous hands behind her head, carrying her in a full Nelson that left her thick thighs spread apart and showing off her beautiful, freely flowing vagina. 


"Wow… Look how wet you are, Lucy… Is it because you're excited to see me, or did Gajeel and Natsu show you a good time?" he asked, his erect penis literally powerful enough to carry her weight, her engorged clitoris, inflamed pussy rubbing up against the shaft. 


"I-I don't know… A bit of both?... Don't make me say such embarrassing things, Elfman…" muttered Lucy, speaking quietly so the others don't hear her.


"Lucy's so adorable when she's shy!..." giggled Levy.


"Oh come on, Lucy… I heard you and Elfman spent all week fucking… Surely you won't be this bashful doing it in front of everyone… You already have in the past, remember?" teased Cana.


Gajeel seemed more interested in Levy, beginning to cuddle her as he hugged her from behind. Natsu kept watching, however, as if to gauge his sexual rival. Elfman purposefully exposed Lucy like this as a challenge, specifically to him. 


"I know, but… We've never done it like this before…" gasped Lucy, feeling the air grow thick as her boobs lifted and jiggled, nipples pointy as they were helplessly erect. Every inch of her body was on fire, turning into the highlight of the beach trip adding fuel onto it. Natsu had been in the same room when they fucked, but he never watched them like he was now. 


"You want this big cock, baby?.." he growled, trying to demonstrate how much of an Alpha he was. 


Lucy was well aware of the battle happening between Elfman and Natsu, who were competing over her, even though the winner wasn't actually winning anything. No matter what the outcome, she was going to live with Natsu and continue loving his personality, his attitude, his energy. Then she was going to continue loving Elfman's cock, and his ability in bed. 


"Mmm…. Stop teasing me, Elfman…" she muttered, covering her face in her palms.


"Come on, say it… If you don't want it, I could give it to Cana or Levy again…" threatened Elfman, licking a trail along her cheek, blowing into her ear and making her tremble.


"......" 


"You're really going to make me say it, aren't you?.." sighed Lucy, frustrated by the stress of it all. Natsu's reaction wasn't something she could predict, unsure of how okay he was with this, for the most part he didn't seem confrontational, but there was never any guarantee when it came to a sensitive topic and procedure like swinging, teetering the line of fun and cheating day in and day out with how intense Elfman and Lucy would get. Undeniably, their chemistry sexually was on par with hers and Natsu's.


"I definitely will." he growled.


Several seconds of silence passed, before Lucy dropped her hands and stared down at how his proud, dark, immense cock was jutting outwards underneath her. Elfman felt pride exuding from his junk, all thanks to the heavenly, mesmerizing beauty that he was carrying in his hands. He wanted to thank her for establishing his confidence as a man, and doing so by doing what they did best, which was fucking. 


"I have no choice then, do I?..." 


"Nope." he snickered, feeling Lucy take a deep breath with his chest pressed against her back.


"Fuck, fine!... Elfman… Give me that huge fucking cock!~..." 


"More," he demanded.


"I want your gigantic dick to fuck me up!~... Fuck me with my favorite cock!~.. I want you to shoot my womb up with your hot, thick cum!~... Ohh, what more do you want me to say, Elfman!~... Just stick it inside of me already!..." begged Lucy desperately, trying to think of whatever words would convince him to plow her already, stalling to the point where her labia was impatiently squirting. 


She made eye contact with Natsu and mentally apologized, making the excuse that he wouldn't fuck her otherwise. 


"Tell Natsu that you like getting fucked by me better." he commanded her, her face growing pale at the thought. 


Lucy shook her head in denial, and swiftly dipped her hips when her entrance was directly above the tip and shoved it inside of her pool of heat, feeding herself with greed and haste as she closed her eyes and started bobbing in his grasp. As usual, it was a heavenly experience. Obscene noises crept out of her lips, and Elfman clicked his tongue in frustration that he wasn't able to bribe her into sealing the deal. To take out his anger, he made her titmeat jiggle tempestuously, no rhyme or pattern to their movement as they bounced all over the pace, cleaving at her divine looking pussy, dampened and plump from arousal. Lucy was the embodiment of sexy, something that even Natsu could admire, always adoring how she responded whenever he was the one that dicked her down. 


The rush that surged through her veins was captivating, her sopping quim gushing and squirting juices without restraint, the creamy white undersides of her ass squishing against his broad hips. Lucy couldn't cover herself, unable to move now with her arms pinned in the air, the only part of her skin that wasn't visible was what was covered by his thick arms. Her generously wide, curvy sides, the turgid tip of her perfect nipples, the flatness of her toned stomach and the softness of her hourglass figure. She was captivating, even the women thought so. It didn't seem like Elfman was just fucking her, using her like a sex toy. He showcased his admiration and appreciation by mating her, his bestial instincts awakened by his magic were being utilized to best fuck Lucy into the disoriented, depraved orgasming slut that she'd currently become.


The only thing that sounded more perverted than her womanly, unfiltered moans was her impossibly wet pussy. Her tight, accepting snatch was constantly ejecting fluids, recklessly clenching and convulsing around his superior length and otherworldly thickness. Natsu was her boyfriend, and Elfman was officially her huge cocked stud. They were to separate entities, and Lucy never wanted to leave either of them, unable to choose one and instead choosing both. That was the final decision she came to, despite her mind entering a near emptied state, eyes drifting apart when her vaginal cavern was suctioned onto his hyper sized cock. Her legs quivered and shook like jello, nutsack flopping up against her ass, mushing against her plump lily rear, his unmatched shaft completely inside of her, small pained gasps escaping her ahegao face, spine arching as she was overcome with emotion, hitting her peak and spilling her essence all over the ground beneath them, the trail visible from how potent it was. 


"Oh my God, Lucy cums like a truck!..." commented Cana. 


"Tsk…" complained Natsu, knowing that he would have to utilize that week he promised with Lucy to the fullest, if he wanted to become her undisputed number one. If he truly wanted to keep her to himself, and told her that she couldn't see Elfman anymore, it would be unfair because of how much he also loved sleeping with Mira. He would feel less of a man if he accepted defeat and walked away from the battle that Elfman was proposing him. It wasn't Natsu's style to take the easy way out, obviously that he had his work cut out for him. 


"Beautiful, baby… Good job… Let's keep going, I'm not done with you yet…" spoke Elfman, carefully letting her down not after allowing the viewers to see how red her clitoris had become. His behemoth shaft was coated with her creamy fluids, holding her bridal style as they lowered to the floor, their foreheads pressed together as Elfman kept his palm flat up on the ground, and the other hand holding her back, sitting on one knee as he pounded into her sex with reckless abandon. 


"We're going again?.." asked Lucy breathlessly, eyes glazed with her sore lips appearing as temptingly plump as ever. Elfman closed his eyes and kissed her, always feeling magnetized towards the beautiful blonde and always having the urge to make out with her wherever they were. 


"Yes… I haven't cum yet, my naughty little slut~..." teased Elfman.


"Don't call me that!..." she protested.


"Sorry, sorry… I'll make it up to you, with this." he emphasized "this" by powering his veiny phallus inside of her yet again, hips slowly gliding forwards until they pressed right up against every doughy curve of her. A slim thick, soft figure that was irresistible. 


"Aaahhhnnn!~...."


"I fuck you so good, don't I?..." he asked.


"You do, daddy!~..." screamed Lucy, twitching viciously as she circled her legs around him.


"Natsu, this is the type of woman Lucy becomes when she's with me. Do you still think she'd choose you as the better man in bed?.." said Elfman, looking up at him.


"Maybe not now… But this isn't over, Elfman… It doesn't matter if she prefers your size, if I can master my technique, I know that Lucy would choose me." responded Natsu, arms crossed as he watched. 


"Lucy… Can we do some roleplay?.." asked Elfman.


"Roleplay?..." she asked, feeling her stomach flutter at having the two men in her life fight over her.


"Yes… Let's pretend like you and Natsu have never met… And that you aren't on birth control right now… I want to show everyone here what would happen if we had met earlier…" spoke Elfman.


"W-What do you mean?..." panted Lucy, hanging onto him by grasping the back of his neck and head. 


"It's just some cruel fun.. Maybe it'll motivate Natsu to surpass me, just like I surpassed him.. At one point, you told me he was your favorite, right?... Your answer has changed since then, hasn't it?.." he asked, with no response, as Lucy's lips trembled and she tried to look away. 


"Can I?..." she asked, looking at Natsu for approval.


There was no point in looking away now, if Natsu was going to suffer a defeat, he might as well take it on the chin. What Elfman was talking about was fantasy anyway, nothing like the real world. 


"S-Sure…"


"Alright… Then, I'm going to show everyone how I'm going to breed you…" said Elfman, letting her drop onto the ground, and then pillaging his insane number of inches within her quivering nether lips, making her howl as a turbulent orgasm shook her to the core.


"B-Breed me?..."


"Yes… If Natsu wasn't your boyfriend… If you weren't on the pill… I would do unspeakable things to you… I'm a man, and you are a woman… Naturally, I would want nothing more but to breed you… I want to knock you up with my baby, and fuck you until I can't feel my dick anymore!..." he yelled, all that forbidden, taboo dirty talk unleashing his sexual wrath. Elfman sent them both into a state of unparalleled ecstasy, even if it wasn't real, hearing a man confidently claim that they were going to impregnate you flared her pussy up beyond belief.


Lucy was submitted in a mating press, with Elfman wiggling his hips from side to side, digging her out from the inside and not leaving an inch of her glorious pussy unattended. His strong body casted a shadow entirely over hers, rummaging the towel underneath them as they slammed together in the clouds of lust.


"You're going to give me a baby?!!" asked Lucy, playing along with the charade, gasping and spitting for air, vibrating below him as her body was being rocked relentlessly. 


"Do you want me to?.. Would you like to be bred by your favorite, fat cock?" he asked, their noses touching as he stared into her eyes, wearing a victorious grin as he licked his lips.


"Uhn-huh!~..." immediately responded Lucy, out of pure primal reflex, nodding her head frantically in obedience.


He sank into her melting, velvety heat with every soul crushing thrust, securing tonight's victory more and more every time he would complete the forward motion of his humping against her crotch. Lucy's body was coursing with pleasure not thought possible until this moment, she had reached nirvana, a sexual high unlike any other as she grew drowsy in a dream like daze. 


"Say it clearly," he ordered.


"Cum… Cum!~.... Elfman, I want your baby!~... Knock me up, daddy!~❤… Give your filthy slut a baby!~... Make me pregnant!~... Oohh, we would have so many kids~... If I was single, and you showed me this stupid fat cock… Surely, there would be no stopping us!~..." screamed Lucy, and then sputtering nonsensically as wailing moans traversed through her vocal cords, grumbling and groaning incoherently as Elfman's stiff cockmeat jostled against her folds, pistoning in and out of her baby making areas, that they were fantasizing was eager and available to harbor their made-up, nonexistent child. 


Natsu held his palms against his face, sighing and realizing that he made a mistake. If they continued as is, surely, eventually he would lose Lucy to Elfman. Their bond was growing too powerful, and he had to put a stop to it, fully intent on dedicating himself to finding the cure to her insatiable desires. Swinging was a dangerous game, if one grew too comfortable and loose, it has the power to gobble you up whole. Even though the words they were spewing had no immediate meaning, that doesn't mean it wasn't imminent. Elfman was proving a point, and one of Natsu's biggest mistakes was letting them stay together for that week, giving them access to a lengthy preview of what their potential relationship would have been like.


"Oh, fuck!~.. Lucy!~.. Here it comes.. Get pregnant!~.." he growled, circling his hands and fingers around her neck, choking her slightly as a resounding slap from her jiggling flesh could be heard when his boiling hot balls rested comfortably against her asscheeks, flexing his legs and pushing into her voraciously, not leaving a centimeter separating them as he spewed the fattest, thickest, slimiest load of the night. A gooey warmth of sticky goo painting the insides of her womb, letting her womanly cries of euphoric heaven be heard before capturing her lips in an impassioned kiss, locking lips as they figuratively mated in front of Natsu. Without a doubt, they were making love, buying into the fantasies, acting like they were the only people on the planet. Lucy sifted her fingers through her blonde luscious hair, feeling exceptionally beautiful, like a real woman as she pressed her lips against Elfman's roughly, humping his cock and milking him for whatever was left in there, his bloated cumvein spasming as he splashed the back end of her womb with his potent seed. 


Their lips smacked together as they made out like lovers, changing the angles they were facing, slipping in and swapping tongues, sucking on them as well as each other's lips, spitting in each other's mouth, breathing each other's breath. An entire minute passed by, glued together, and he still never stopped cumming. There were bubbles formed by their spit as Lucy held his head tightly and kissed him deeply, eyes shut tight as she hummed and moaned against his big lips that were devouring hers. 


"I want to take you home tonight.." he grunted.


"Stop… Just keep kissing me…" whispered Lucy, knowing that they've gone too far, and there were consequences for this behavior. Living in the moment, she locked her legs tighter behind his, her fingers locking together behind his neck as she felt her soft strawberry lips being bitten lightly by his teeth, pulling it out slightly as she playfully giggled in response.


"So you want my baby, Lucy?.." he asked.


"I didn't say that… You told me to act like I was single, right?.." she responded, looking him in the eyes.


Her stomach felt full, producing an abnormal volume of cum even for Elfman. His virile seed was swimming inside of her, and he squeezed more out when he jabbed her carefully with his mushroom tip, still ejecting from his piss slit. 


"So if you were single, I'd be the father of your kids?" he teased, laughing as he stuck his tongue out to play with hers, duelling for dominance as they entangled and wrapped around each other, meanwhile her climaxing pussy tried to wring out all of his man milk. 


"I don't know, Elfman.." she responded, unsure how far she was going to test her limits.


"Maybe that's why you keep calling me daddy when I bust inside of you.. It's your body's way of telling me that we belong together.." he laughed, smiling as he placed a chaste kiss on her forehead, a first person view of her flushed aroused face, sticking his thumb inside her mouth, hooking it against her cheek as Lucy sucked on his digits, and then gently extracting himself from her body, feeling like they'd just spent hours connected in the most intimate form. The viciousness of his cum sludge was unreal, it was like solid liquid had been poured into the deepest reaches of her body, sending a shiver down her spine, filling her up from the inside out with his viscous nutslop bathing her nagging depths with hot, dense cream.


"Wow… You let out so much inside of me… That's amazing…" she exasperated in awe, sitting up on the back of her hands, keeping her legs spread and watching the jizz naturally flow out of her.


"Can you feel it here?.." asked Elfman, rubbing her stomach.


"Mhm… I can…" spoke Lucy, looking at him with smitten eyes.


"God damn it, Luce.." thought Natsu, clenching his fist. It was naive to assume he'd win solely because of the status of their relationship.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Several minutes later..


The guys were all lined up side by side, still sporting their lively erections as the time to choose everyone's personal winner had come. Levy's choice was obvious, romantically blowing Gajeel who filled her with warmth like no other. Cana was throating Natsu, who mentally seemed clocked out, hardly reacting to the brunette that was performing admirably. The reason she hadn't chosen Elfman was probably because it was a little too much, Natsu was her perfect size and fit, so she preferred him. Lucy’s choice, if it wasn't obvious already, was Elfman. 


The tanned giant was sitting cross legged, with Lucy in his lap, as he caressed her back softly, and roughly gripped her asscheeks. They were still kissing, unable to smell anything but each other's saliva, eventually their mouths turning dry as they couldn't keep up with the exchanging of spit. Natsu could see their pink tongues colliding together, and how they were gulping down each other's saliva. Elfman reached for her face and swiped his thumb to move strands of her hair blocking his view, inhaling one another's breath as they breathed from their mouth. 


"Sleep at my place… Let's continue there, it's too hot out here…" said Elfman, his iron rod jammed in between their sweaty bodies.


Natsu and Lucy looked at each other, and she cleared her throat before telling him.


"I'm going to take Elfman home tonight, Natsu…"


The erotic look in her eyes didn't turn him on as of that moment, because it wasn't meant for him.



































