Chapter 2 - Costume Confusion - Lucy & Gray

Notes - All characters featured in this story are the age of 18 or above. I have my details to my Discord Server & Patreon available on my profile. 


A/N - This story contains multiple chapters that aren't necessarily linked to the previous ones. Each chapter will be a different story, with varying tags and pairings with Lucy.


Contains - Netorare, Anal Sex, Creampie. 


------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


It was the annual Halloween-themed costume party celebrated by all the members of Fairy Tail. Having a reputation of throwing the best parties around, all of the members always went all-out when dressing up and enjoying a wonderful time. The costumes for the most part were unique, highly detailed and extravagant. Meanwhile all of the other couples and members in attendance wore different outfits, unfortunately Lucy and Natsu, Juvia and Gray happened to be dressed in the same matching combination. The men were dressed as male Dracula, and the ladies as Dracula mistresses. Of course, given their competitive nature and confrontational relationship, Natsu and Gray were at each other's throats when they encountered one another.


"Hey!.. Why are you copying us, Flame Brain?!.."


"I could ask you the same, Droopy Eyes!"


They shouted at one another while the girlfriends looked on in disappointment, shrugging and sighing at what's become a daily occurrence. Lucy didn't harbour any ill feelings towards Juvia for coincidentally bringing the same costume, instead finding it amusing that they'd both shared the same taste.


"Let's just leave those two alone, what do you say, Juvia?" asked Lucy, linking their arms and dragging her away into the crowd.


"Eh?.. But, Gray-sama…"


"It'll be okay!.. Those two idiots are busy fighting anyways.. Why not go out for some drinks and have fun with the girls for once!" cheered Lucy, with a beaming smile on her face. When Natsu and Gray got riled up like that, there was no end to their arguing and battles.


"A-Alright.." meekly responded Juvia, not completely on board with the idea considering how clingy she was with her boyfriend, Gray. 


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


An hour later….


“Woo!~... Ah, I think i’m a little bit drunk now… One second, ladies!.. I’ll be right back!..” cheered Lucy, whose face was slightly flushed red after helping herself to a few drinks. Whenever the hot blonde was relatively drunk, she had the tendency of becoming overly touchy and especially affectionate. Juvia was yet another victim of her ways, blushing slightly while being constantly embraced and pulled around. Breathing a sigh of relief when Lucy finally gave her a break, it wasn’t like they weren’t especially close or anything, but it was a bit draining for the typically shy and timid woman. 


“Hmm?.. Where’s my boyfriend?!.. Natsu?!.. Where are you?!...” shouted Lucy amongst the crowd of partying people, loud music blaring in the room and the dark lighting of the halloween theme party making it difficult to see. Searching around the dance floor and around the tables where Natsu and Gray were fighting prior, she pouted when he hadn’t left a trace. Her outfit was rather revealing, failing to contain her absurd proportions with her absurdly huge tits spilling from her top. If she weren’t dating the all powerful Fire Dragon Slayer, there for sure would’ve been numerous men hitting and flirting with her. There were times during the night where drunk men would try and score a dance with her, only to back off when realizing who the busty blonde was that they were talking to. 


“Oh!.. There he is!..” thought Lucy, staring at the back of the head of a person who was dressed as Dracula. Figuring it was Natsu, the playfully drunk girl wore a mischievous smile on her face, deciding to follow her boyfriend and ambush him when he’d least expected it. It appeared that he was leaving the guild momentarily, perhaps for some fresh air. Trailing his steps, Lucy ended up slipping out of the party and noticed her man unlocking the door to the storage room. There wasn’t much sensible thought running through her head, consumed by the alcohol and overcome with emotions that made her act differently. Biting down on her bottom lip, Lucy sneakily crept up behind the man and lunged forward and pulled him into an embrace. He gasped in surprise as he was caught off guard, having only taken a step inside the completely dark room before being ambushed from behind. 


“Baby~.. I haven’t seen you in a while!.. Your poor girlfriend is feeling all lonely with you..” whispered Lucy into his ear, her marshmallowy breasts smothering against his back. The unidentified man heading over towards the storeroom to grab something to complete his outfit, assumed that this was his overly attached girlfriend hugging him from behind. The alcohol running in their systems weakened their cognitive abilities, oblivious to the identities of the attractive member of the opposite gender clinging to each other’s form. 


“My bad, I was busy dealing with that idiot for far too long.” responded the man.


“I know~.. And now your girlfriend is all horny and excited waiting for you..” purred Lucy in a soothing voice.


“You’re horny?.. That’s nothing new..” he cheekily responded, having already gotten used to his girlfriends advances whenever they were alone. It certainly didn’t help that Juvia was quite assertive when her motor was running. 


“Mhm~.. I am.. So much so that I want you to fuck me.. Right here, right now.. I don’t have the time to wait until we’re home.. I missed you so much~..” seductively whispered Lucy, her warm breath tickling the sides of his neck as she sensuously ran her hand across his chest and chiseled abdomen. Gray was normally cool and calm under moments like this, not necessarily the type of man who could be attributed as being excessively horny. However, the feeling of humongous breasts pressing against him and the sexy tone of her voice sent tingles down his spine.
 
“If you want it so badly, then I wouldn’t be a man if I turned you down, right?..” growled Gray, turning around and immediately closing the distance, clamping his hand down on the back of her neck, assertively pulling her into a kiss and smashing their lips together as they exhaled heavily from their nose. There was so much sexual tension filling the room, and they’ve only occupied the room for under a minute. Lucy’s breath hitched as their eyes shut closed, circling her arms around his neck as her tits smashed against his chest. Hardly an inch of space between them as Gray’s hands roamed her voluptuous body, sliding down and grabbing two handfuls of the plumpness of her cheeks. 


“What’s with her today?.. Something feels different about her... “ thought Gray, inhaling the unfamiliar scent of Lucy’s perfume. He was drunk, but he wasn’t completely oblivious that there was something a little different. Although he somehow missed or didn't care about the fact that she wasn't referring to herself in third person. Juvia’s ass was nice and firm, but it felt much bigger and softer than normal. And the way their tongues meshed together wasn’t the same either, Lucy’s technique was far lewder than what he was accustomed to. He didn’t really pay it much attention, figuring that it was a result of all the alcohol in his system. Gray couldn’t quite pinpoint why, but assumed that her increased sexiness was related to how incredibly turned on they were. They swapped saliva as their wet muscles intertwined lewdly, enjoying the softness and sweetness of her strawberry tasting lips, occasionally planting kisses in the midst of their erotic duel of tongues. 


"Oh, Natsu!~.. Holy fuck, have you always been this good?..." thought Lucy, having never felt this aroused by a mere kiss, hiking her leg up his sides as Gray held her thick thighs in place, hooking it against his hip. His usual hotness wasn't there, lips much cooler than usual, but the heat of her arousal made up for it. They grinded their cores together, his slight bulge rubbing against her crotch. Lucy squirmed in his grasp when he aggressively cupped her ass, digging his fingers into the plumpness of her cheeks. Bringing his left hand up her sides and palming her mountainous flesh, eliciting a sweet moan from her lips as he tongued her deep. 


"Mmn, mmh!~..." her hips buckled while they were on the verge of dry humping, clutching each other tightly as Gray couldn't help himself but fondle her perfect hourglass figure. They were practically inseparable, making out and feeling up on each other's bodies, several minutes passing by with their heads switching sides and attacking each other's lips from various angles. 


"Fuck!.. Her lips tastes so good!.." he mentally noted, locking their lips by biting on it lightly, swiping his thumb underneath her shirt and caressing her tits. Juvia's boobs weren't anything to scoff at, they were definitely large compared to other women. But, Lucy was overwhelmingly stacked in that department, the best pair of tits in Magnolia that Gray couldn't keep his hands off of. They’d grown so passionate and enamoured in their bout of kisses that they both had practically forgotten to breathe, finally taking a break after being glued to each other’s lips. Their foreheads pressed together while panting heavily, losing themselves in the moment and riding on the adrenaline of messing around outside in the public. 


“The way you work your tongue… God damn, that turned me on..” commented Gray, tempted to drag her back into another kiss, his movement halted when Lucy stopped him in place with her fingers pressed against his lips.


“We can save that for later~... I want more… I want to suck you so badly, baby..” purred Lucy, always turning into a confident seductress whenever alcohol and arousal was involved. Gray couldn’t believe that they were actually going through with this, his heart racing wildly with his blood pumped with adrenaline. Juvia had always tried to either touch him in certain areas, and was never afraid to lust over him in public, but never had he actually given in to her advances. The sensible part of his brain that was hardly working urged him to stop her, the possibility that they’d be walked into and interrupted was very much possible. Lucy didn’t even give him the time of day to respond, popping a square and digging her nails into his hips, as if she were possessively claiming him as his. It was difficult to see with the lights turned off, and they both silently agreed on keeping them off, finding the darkness was spicing things up. Unable to properly see, Lucy ran both of her hands up and down from his abdomen towards his crotch, searching and fondling the area, eyes glimmering when she felt the massive bulge in her grasp, clutching and holding his hardness tightly. 


“Huh?.. Was Natsu’s dick always like this?..” she questioned, noticing that the proportions felt slightly different. Having troubles locating the zipper and fiddling with his trousers, breathing heavily in anticipation as Lucy didn't crave anything else more than this man's cock. The hot blonde yelped when their close proximities caused his turgid erection to lunge out and slap her face, hitting her forehead and resting against her lips. Lucy yelped in surprise from being unintentionally cockslapped, having trouble gauging the distance between each other with the low brightness. Gray panted heavily while he reached down and searched for her hair, clutching her blonde blocks and allowing his cock to rest on her pretty face. He pulled his hips back and poked his dick against her lips, Lucy engaging in his teasing foreplay by humming and rubbing up and down the length. Juvia practically worshipped Gray's cock, acting out of habit considering he was under the impression that the buxom on her knees was none other than his girlfriend.


Lucy, on the other hand, wasn't used to being treated in such a depraved way. Although, that didn't turn her off by any means, in fact lighting a fire underneath her that she didn't know existed. Natsu had always treated her with such care, although he'd get wild when that beast of passion awakened. It felt hot being treated like a whore, running the hard meatstick along her cheek, and then showering it with kisses. Starting from the side and circling around, lifting the hefty rod up towards the ceiling and pressing it against his stomach. Lucy's tongue slid out as she breathed from her mouth and dragged herself all the way up to the tip. Unable to rely on her eyes to see, Lucy worked his cock by always keeping in contact, rolling her wet muscle in circles around the bulbous head. Gray moaned as his grip on her hair tightened, growing impatient with all the teasing build up. He was used to being rough with Juvia, who was almost considered a masochist when it came to her sexual tendencies. They were somehow adapting and conforming to each other's erotic preferences on the fly, unknowingly at that. Dismissing any differences as acting experimentally rather than believing they were hooking up with a completely other person.


Lucy whimpered when Gray thrusted his cock past the entrance of her sealed lips, eyes widening in surprise from his uncharacteristic aggressiveness. When it came to blowjobs, Natsu typically controlled his libido, figuring Lucy wouldn't be able to handle him when he got too hot and ready. "Mmpnh?!.." she murmured with a mouthful of meat, holding onto his hips while he started humping her face. Lucy sucked hard with her full lips around his shaft while lovingly bobbing her head, spurred on by her supposed lovers actions, breathing rapidly through her nose. The empty room was slowly filled with nothing but Gray's constant groans and slurping from Lucy's lewd mouth. Caressing the sensitive skin with her lips while her tongue played with the salty member diving back and forth inside her orifice. Reaching deeper than ever before as she had to fight her gag reflex to continue, having the jerking motion of her head guided by Gray's forceful hands in combination with his slight thrusts. 


"Oh, fuck!.. Natsu!.. He's fucking my face!.. What's gotten into him?.. He's so rough!.." thought Lucy, trying her best to shield her teeth so as to not inflict accidental pain. The horny blonde trembled with arousal, dropping the tight grip she had on his hips and allowed her hands to settle on her milky thighs. Squeezing them together to clench her aching pussy while Gray had full control over her head, fucking her face with reckless abandon and forcing a gag out of her throat. Lucy had slight tears in her eyes as she coped with the pain, panties soaked wet from the harsh treatment. Persevering through the hardships of such an intense blowjob, face slightly disgruntled while the tight seal of her vacuum lips slurped the excess saliva dripping down her chin. 


"Yes.. That's it~... Keep sucking, sexy!.." he urged her on, shuddering with delight as the fellatio was magnificent. Gray could feel his orgasm coming on way quicker than usual, unsure what exactly was making him this hard and eager to cum. Lucy hummed and moaned a response that fell on deaf ears, overpowered by the sounds of her sucking. Enthusiastically shoving herself against his thrusts, pressing against the entrance of her throat repeatedly and drawing him closer to release each time. 


"Agh, I'm gonna cum.. You want to swallow it all up, don't you?.." exasperated Gray.


"Mmhmm!!~..." boisterously moaned Lucy, nodding her head in the midst of the assault on her mouth, dipping her fingers inside her crotch and pressing against the heat of her arousal. Gray's frantic breathing ramped up with every thrust, nearly an entire minute passing by while he focused entirely on his erection. It throbbed once, then twice as Lucy moaned in anticipation. "Here it comes!.. He's going to release it inside my mouth!.." 
she thought while swooning over his virility, heart racing wildly as Gray's erection spasmed out of control, a geyser of semen splashing the insides of her mouth while Lucy rubbed herself through the fabric of her panties. Moaning loudly as one hand reached up and affectionately grasped the root of his cock, keeping her head still and lapping with her tongue as the continuous bursts of tasty liquid filled her mouth. The taste was different, the texture too. She had no idea why, but "Natsu" wasn't the same. 


Gray sighed heavily after emptying the load out for a near minute, hearing Lucy gulp him down voraciously as he wiped the bead of sweat off his forehead. The cockhungry blonde slowly breathed through her nostrils as the room grew silent, only the occasional noise of their heavy breathing, and wet noises emanating from the smacking of her lips. He pulled his meat out with a plop, resting his glistening member on her face as Lucy angled her head back and stuck out her tongue. 


"You're so fucking sexy…" he complimented, in a state of awe from the woman's dedicated display of oral sex. "Stand up.. I'm gonna fuck the shit out of you.." growled Gray, a bit reminiscent of Natsu's raspy voice when he'd get aroused. Lucy wiped the saliva off her face and rose to her feet, grabbed by the wrist and dragged across the room. A beaming smile on her face knowing fully well that she was going to get absolutely drilled. There was a nearby crate along the wall, as Gray led her by the hand before pushing her in front of him, bending her over and spanking her loudly after swinging his arm all the way back. 


"Ahn!~.." squealed Lucy from the impact of his palm colliding with her ass. Possessively clutching her flesh before hiking the fabric of her costume, revealing her panty-clad rump. He hurriedly peeled the undergarments right off, dropping them down towards her ankles as he squeezed her cheeks once more. Marvelling at its softness and how it felt like pudding in his hands, he could've sworn it was slightly fatter than usual.  


"Yeah?.. You're gonna bend me over and fuck me, aren't you Darling?.." teased Lucy, wiggling her big ass from side to side, like a puppy waiting for it's treat. It was difficult to locate her pussy with the dim lighting, poking several times in search of her heavenly hole. Lucy dipped her fingers in between her legs, arching her back and spreading her pussy apart. Reaching around back and grabbing a hold of his girthy length, helping him aim it properly towards her entrance.


"You're soaking wet.."


"All because of you~.."


Gray grinned smugly at her response, never figuring that Juvia had it in her to talk this dirty. Seductive wasn't necessarily the word to call her, more so she was very submissive and infatuated with both him and his cock. With his bulbous head rubbing at her slit, Lucy could hardly contain herself from all the teasing.


"Ugh, just stick it in already!~..." pleaded Lucy, holding herself still by balancing her hands on the crate. It was almost a tradition having Juvia beg for his cock, treating Lucy similarly due to the illusion of her identity. "I can't take this teasing anymore!" she thought, slamming her plump ass against his crotch, penetrating her cunt with the engorged cockhead and a few inches slipping in. Lucy moaned loudly with her head tilted upwards, biting down on her bottom lip and in an attempt futilely to conceal her moans in order to avoid causing too much ruckus. Gray grunted profusely while affectionately clinging onto her wide hips, responding with a thrust of his own that forced the rest of his length inside. 


"Oh, God!.. It's so fucking tight.." gasped Gray in disbelief, her wet tunnel clinging tightly around his shaft, finding how drenched her pussy was too be immensely arousing. Growling and spanking her bubble butt and eliciting a pained moan from her lips. He started working the motion of his hips as their skin collided together, steadily increasing with ferocity as the slapping noises and breathless moans grew louder. Lucy was in complete ecstasy, drunk and insanely horny. After receiving her first taste of sex, the beautiful blonde had become quite the sexual person. Masturbating frequently and fucking her boyfriend whenever they'd had the time and Natsu was in the mood. One issue was how loud she'd get, and the sounds of her big butt clapping at his every thrust didn't help either. "Unnghhh, fuckk!!!~..." screamed Lucy, forgetting entirely about their surroundings. 


They were on fire, having never felt this physically compatible in their lives. Under the assumption that their lovers were in peak condition, when in reality they were unintentionally engaging in an act of infidelity. One that neither regretted at the moment, with how absurdly pleasurable their fucking felt. Gray embarrassingly moaned when Lucy threw her ass back against him in tandem when his thrusts, addicted to the incredibly tight fit that left his cock with the sensation of being permanently squeezed. Her massive jiggling tits bounced from the impact of his thrusts, which packed enough power to rock her figure back and forth. They slammed against each other's sex as if they were in a hurry, wasting no time and seizing the moment. Lucy mentally recovered from her near orgasm and clasped her left hand around her mouth, panting heavily and shuddering from arousal when Gray's cockhead reached particularly deep. He felt as if he could pound her drenched cunt with little regard for safety as her round ass cushioned his strong hips wonderfully. 


Minutes passed by as Lucy's immaculate pussy was being pistoned by his sturdy erection, now arching his back and slowing down his thrusts but shoving himself as deep as humanly possible. He reached her G-spot without fail as shockwaves of pleasure ran throughout her curvaceous figure, the unbearable itch in her crotch disappeared as she was overcome with pure lust and arousal. Lucy's head yanked back when Gray had tugged on her hair, that was roughly the same length as Juvia's after being tied up and styled. 


"Ungh!~.. I'm going to fucking cum!~.. Ha!... Come on baby, HARDER!~" Lucy cried aloud, nearly cumming right then and there when Gray immediately responded by spanking her naked ass. Literally clapping her cheeks while also pulling at her hair, intensifying their already excessively passionate session of rough sex.


"Me too!.. I'm about to burst!.. Can I do it inside?!.." he panted frantically, mere seconds away from blowing his load.


"Mhm!~.. Fill me up with your hot cum, baby!" she urged, shivering the instant his grunt echoed throughout the room and powerful gushing of thick semen filled her insides to the brim. His ejaculation lasted far longer than usual, spasming uncontrollably as the waves kept on coming without a near ending in sight. Lucy came around his throbbing cock as her juices squirted before dripping down onto the floor, as if it were a dam leaking clear liquid from how powerful her orgasm was with her vehement moans filling the room. Gray let out a sigh of relief after pumping her cunt full of his cum, worrying about the consequences of not using protection at a later date and instead living in the moment.


Instead of letting go of her hips, Gray lowered his grip and dug his palms into the flesh of her enormous ass that was driving him wicked during their sex. The backshots that reduced this unbelievably proportioned seductress emanated ridiculously loud noises from their slapping skin. He felt more enamoured with booty than ever before, carefully extracting himself from her sopping wet pussy and immediately shifting his attention over towards her butt. Lucy was in the midst of recovering from a violent orgasm when her asscheeks were spread apart, a wet cock clumsily finding its way towards her puckered hole.


"E-Eh?!.. You want to do it with my butt?.." asked Lucy confusedly, having never been done in that hole before. Natsu was always using her pussy and occasionally playing with her ass, but his focus was largely on her tits. 


"Yeah.. I'll fuck it nice and good, don't worry.." assured Gray, grabbing ahold of her thick thighs and lifting her leg in the air, making Lucy blush and whimpered, allowing herself to be taken on this wild journey. Creating a better angle for themselves and deeper penetration, Gray pushed himself against the barrier of her ass, the puckered hole slowly expanding and familiarizing itself with the well-proportioned length that spread her apart. 


"Nngh!~... Agh, what is this?!.. It feels so different… I don't know-.. I don't know what this is like!.." exasperated Lucy, face disgruntled while the hefty object was carefully inserted inside, causing her to groan with her breath ragged as several inches pushed its way in. Gray's dick was huge, but Natsu’s was too. The difference in size in terms of length wasn't significant enough where the feeling of his cock could be easily discernible, especially under the influence of alcohol where all of her senses were directed towards easing the aching of her hot pussy. Gray raised an eyebrow as Lucy were making it seem like this was her first time having anal. Striking him odd as both him and Juvia's adventures in bed led to them experiencing a variety of different positions and possibilities. Regardless, the thought wasn't enough to lead his flailing hips to falter, making good on his promise of delivering a mind-boggling pounding. 


The foreign sensation of having her asshole fucked led towards unpredictable reactions, Lucy's sexual arousal had been so prominent that she was willing to try anything, accepting his proposal in the heat of the moment. Now, her eyes were practically rolling to the back of her head, tongue sticking out during her open-mouthed moans that rang like music to his ears. It definitely sounded like she was loving it, finding new things about herself as their time together progressed along. Gray was pummeling her butt with significant force that made her bouncy cheeks ripple. Lucy shook her head in the midst of her entire body shuddering in delight, almost as if to deny the emotions of embarrassment that came with enjoying how depraved of a woman she'd become. It was all happening too much, too fast. A cry of pleasure serving as the last straw before Lucy's silky legs trembled in his grasp and an orgasm washed through her body.


"Did you just cum again?.." asked Gray, controlling his breathing while repeatedly spearing her back entrance with his eager cock. 


"Oh, fuck yes, I did!~.." she panted, finding the immense amount of pleasure overwhelming. It was as if even breathing was difficult, and the fact that he never stopped thrusting even while she came only amplified those sensations. Gray grabbed onto her womanly curves before flipping her over, flat on her back so that they were facing each other as he lifted her up into the air, carrying by the thickness of her ass. Extending his arm to help locate the wall before pinning her back against it, still lodged deep within her anal cavity and maintaining slight thrusts all the while. Gray was too good, showering and spoiling the blonde with incomparable emotion. Their faces were so close that their lips were practically touching, while Lucy continuously moaned while wrapping both her arms and legs around the man's waist and neck. 


"You can't stop cumming, can you?.."


"When did you become such a tease?.. Nngh!~.. Just shut up and kiss me already.." she whimpered in between moans, pulling him into a heated kiss where their tongues clashed before their lips. Lucy and Gray's kisses were filled with fiery and passion, truly encapsulating how they felt about each other sexually. A fact that has been laid dormant once their relationships with their current lovers developed. In terms of physical appearance, they were secretly each other's ideal. Gray had always found the busty blonde to be enticingly attractive. Well, who didn't? Lucy is typically considered one of the hottest women around. And Gray possessed the looks of a male model himself, not that Lucy ever had a crush or swooned over him, but he was definitely a good looking member of the opposite sex. Even though their first shared sexual experience has been a mere accident, they hadn't known and rode the waves of this overbearingly erotic encounter. Gray drove his tongue deep and was unbothered by the taste, alternating between making out with pure lust while absorbing her moans when his huge cock reached uncharted territory within her anal tunnels. 


Lucy bounced up and down against the walls as her boobs followed suit, blushing slightly when Gray cupped her cheek and kissed her like lovers. Juvia would always lose control when things would turn romantic, as did Lucy as she felt butterflies in her stomach and a turgid cock in her asshole. The wonderfully distinct range of emotions led towards an arousing conclusion, melting into each other's lips as her moans escaped during their exchange of tongues. Gray thrusting upwards balls deep within the tightness of her butthole, clutching the flesh of her ass like his life depended on it. They swallowed each other's moans and groans as their releases came crashing like a truck, frantic breathing with their bodies slowly sweating as they were both approaching a violent orgasm. In a last ditch effort to maximize the wonderful bliss that would overtake her senses, Lucy held onto his shoulder and dipped her free hand down towards her clit, fingering and playing with the pink nub furiously while Gray's hips buckled while ramming into her squishy figure. 


"Mmnh, mmm!!.. I'm cumming!.. I'm cumming!!~..."


They both shook wildly as they climaxed in perfect unison, shooting multiple waves of hot seed within her puckered hole, while Lucy came all over his crotch and abdomen. Gray groaned into her lips as their kiss grew lazy, slowly moving their tongues and instead placing numerous soft kisses while carefully extracting themselves out of her narrow butthole. Cum oozing out both of her holes, trickling onto the floor as Gray cautiously lowered her to her feet. Lucy limped slightly upon landing, a pained feeling in her gut that served as a mark for a great fucking. Leaning back against the wall as Gray toppled over her, breathing heavily as they both required ample time to recover. Multiple hot orgasms had the tendency to drain people, after all. 


"Oh, wow.. That might've been the best sex we've ever had.." complimented Gray, hugging Lucy tightly in admiration for her performance.


"I know, right?.. I can't remember the last time it felt that amazing.." replied Lucy, returning his embrace as they took a few more seconds resting on each other's form.


"We better get going.. It'll be bad if someone walks in on us." said Gray, separating from Lucy's half-naked figure, walking over towards the wall to flip the light switch on, needing to see to clothe themselves accordingly. 


Immediately after the bright lights filled the room, Gray heard Lucy gasp behind him. Turning around in confusion as staring at the flustered blonde who was covering her soaked pussy with her hands. His face turned pale after quickly realizing what was going on. Lucy's heart sank with guilt and shame upon the shocking revelation, unable to choke so much of a word out as there was hardly anything she could say. 


"L-Lucy?.. That was you?!.. Oh, shit.. What have we done?.." exasperated Gray in disbelief, feeling terrible after calming down from one of his biggest highs. It all started to make sense, the slight differences, tendencies, voices, everything. His head thumped with pain, feeling the effects of the alcohol running through his system.


"Don't tell anyone about this, please.. We'll never speak on it again.. What happened tonight was an accident, nothing more.. " coldly responded Lucy, still having troubles overcoming her own mistakes. 


Silence overcame the room as they clothed themselves and tidied their appearance, Gray stayed back and allowed her to be the first person to leave. Lucy's eyes were watering simply remembering all of the words that escaped her mouth, and in hindsight, was awful and insulting to Natsu. A one night stand with her hot friend wasn't enough to deter her feelings for her best friend and lover. All that was left was the sense of guilt that accompanied their fervent night of shameful passion.


"I'm sorry.." apologized Gray.


"Don't be.. It was my fault too.." responded Lucy, sliding her panties back up her legs. Waving him goodbye and keeping her head down when walking past him, leaving the storeroom and heading straight back towards the dance floor.


------------------------------------------------------------


"Lucy!.. Where have you been?.. I was looking all over for you!.." said Natsu with a cheerful smile, one that contrasted the look on Lucy's face. 


"Lucy?... What's up?.. You smell kind of funny."


"Natsu.. Natsu, I'm sorry.. Just now.. I-"






The End…












