diff --git "a/data2021/eng.rst.gum/eng.rst.gum_dev.rels" "b/data2021/eng.rst.gum/eng.rst.gum_dev.rels" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/data2021/eng.rst.gum/eng.rst.gum_dev.rels" @@ -0,0 +1,2150 @@ +doc unit1_toks unit2_toks unit1_txt unit2_txt s1_toks s2_toks unit1_sent unit2_sent dir orig_label label +GUM_academic_exposure 1 186-208 Introduction In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : 1 186-262 Introduction In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_academic_exposure 2-6,10-17 82-104 Research on adult-learned second language <*> has provided considerable insight into the neurocognitive mechanisms Crucially , it is also desirable to retain them , even in the absence of continued practice or exposure to the L2 . 2-33 82-104 Research on adult-learned second language ( L2 ) has provided considerable insight into the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying the learning and processing of L2 grammar [ 1 ] – [ 11 ] . Crucially , it is also desirable to retain them , even in the absence of continued practice or exposure to the L2 . 1>2 background background +GUM_academic_exposure 2-6,10-17 7-9 Research on adult-learned second language <*> has provided considerable insight into the neurocognitive mechanisms ( L2 ) 2-33 2-33 Research on adult-learned second language ( L2 ) has provided considerable insight into the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying the learning and processing of L2 grammar [ 1 ] – [ 11 ] . Research on adult-learned second language ( L2 ) has provided considerable insight into the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying the learning and processing of L2 grammar [ 1 ] – [ 11 ] . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_academic_exposure 10-17 18-25 has provided considerable insight into the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying the learning and processing of L2 grammar 2-33 2-33 Research on adult-learned second language ( L2 ) has provided considerable insight into the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying the learning and processing of L2 grammar [ 1 ] – [ 11 ] . Research on adult-learned second language ( L2 ) has provided considerable insight into the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying the learning and processing of L2 grammar [ 1 ] – [ 11 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 2-6,10-17 26-33 Research on adult-learned second language <*> has provided considerable insight into the neurocognitive mechanisms [ 1 ] – [ 11 ] . 2-33 2-33 Research on adult-learned second language ( L2 ) has provided considerable insight into the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying the learning and processing of L2 grammar [ 1 ] – [ 11 ] . Research on adult-learned second language ( L2 ) has provided considerable insight into the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying the learning and processing of L2 grammar [ 1 ] – [ 11 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 34-39 40-41,50-60 Of interest here , studies suggest that , <*> adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing 34-68 34-68 Of interest here , studies suggest that , despite the difficulties in acquiring L2 grammar , adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing [ 12 ] – [ 15 ] . Of interest here , studies suggest that , despite the difficulties in acquiring L2 grammar , adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing [ 12 ] – [ 15 ] . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_academic_exposure 40-41,50-60 82-104 that , <*> adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing Crucially , it is also desirable to retain them , even in the absence of continued practice or exposure to the L2 . 34-68 82-104 Of interest here , studies suggest that , despite the difficulties in acquiring L2 grammar , adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing [ 12 ] – [ 15 ] . Crucially , it is also desirable to retain them , even in the absence of continued practice or exposure to the L2 . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_academic_exposure 42-44 50-60 despite the difficulties adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing 34-68 34-68 Of interest here , studies suggest that , despite the difficulties in acquiring L2 grammar , adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing [ 12 ] – [ 15 ] . Of interest here , studies suggest that , despite the difficulties in acquiring L2 grammar , adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing [ 12 ] – [ 15 ] . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_academic_exposure 42-44 45-49 despite the difficulties in acquiring L2 grammar , 34-68 34-68 Of interest here , studies suggest that , despite the difficulties in acquiring L2 grammar , adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing [ 12 ] – [ 15 ] . Of interest here , studies suggest that , despite the difficulties in acquiring L2 grammar , adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing [ 12 ] – [ 15 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 40-41,50-60 61-68 that , <*> adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing [ 12 ] – [ 15 ] . 34-68 34-68 Of interest here , studies suggest that , despite the difficulties in acquiring L2 grammar , adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing [ 12 ] – [ 15 ] . Of interest here , studies suggest that , despite the difficulties in acquiring L2 grammar , adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing [ 12 ] – [ 15 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 40-41,50-60 69-81 that , <*> adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing However , it is not enough to have attained such native-like levels . 34-68 69-81 Of interest here , studies suggest that , despite the difficulties in acquiring L2 grammar , adult learners can approximate native-like levels of use and neurocognitive processing [ 12 ] – [ 15 ] . However , it is not enough to have attained such native-like levels . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_academic_exposure 82-104 186-208 Crucially , it is also desirable to retain them , even in the absence of continued practice or exposure to the L2 . In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : 82-104 186-262 Crucially , it is also desirable to retain them , even in the absence of continued practice or exposure to the L2 . In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . 1>2 background background +GUM_academic_exposure 82-104 105-109,115-119,123-126 Crucially , it is also desirable to retain them , even in the absence of continued practice or exposure to the L2 . In fact , substantial periods <*> of limited or no exposure <*> are not uncommon , 82-104 105-136 Crucially , it is also desirable to retain them , even in the absence of continued practice or exposure to the L2 . In fact , substantial periods ( months to years ) of limited or no exposure following L2 training are not uncommon , and may even be the norm [ 16 ] . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_academic_exposure 105-109,115-119,123-126 110-114 In fact , substantial periods <*> of limited or no exposure <*> are not uncommon , ( months to years ) 105-136 105-136 In fact , substantial periods ( months to years ) of limited or no exposure following L2 training are not uncommon , and may even be the norm [ 16 ] . In fact , substantial periods ( months to years ) of limited or no exposure following L2 training are not uncommon , and may even be the norm [ 16 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 105-109,115-119,123-126 120-122 In fact , substantial periods <*> of limited or no exposure <*> are not uncommon , following L2 training 105-136 105-136 In fact , substantial periods ( months to years ) of limited or no exposure following L2 training are not uncommon , and may even be the norm [ 16 ] . In fact , substantial periods ( months to years ) of limited or no exposure following L2 training are not uncommon , and may even be the norm [ 16 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 105-109,115-119,123-126 127-132 In fact , substantial periods <*> of limited or no exposure <*> are not uncommon , and may even be the norm 105-136 105-136 In fact , substantial periods ( months to years ) of limited or no exposure following L2 training are not uncommon , and may even be the norm [ 16 ] . In fact , substantial periods ( months to years ) of limited or no exposure following L2 training are not uncommon , and may even be the norm [ 16 ] . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_exposure 105-109,115-119,123-126 133-136 In fact , substantial periods <*> of limited or no exposure <*> are not uncommon , [ 16 ] . 105-136 105-136 In fact , substantial periods ( months to years ) of limited or no exposure following L2 training are not uncommon , and may even be the norm [ 16 ] . In fact , substantial periods ( months to years ) of limited or no exposure following L2 training are not uncommon , and may even be the norm [ 16 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 105-109,115-119,123-126 137-146 In fact , substantial periods <*> of limited or no exposure <*> are not uncommon , Such a scenario may be found in different situations , 105-136 137-185 In fact , substantial periods ( months to years ) of limited or no exposure following L2 training are not uncommon , and may even be the norm [ 16 ] . Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 137-146 147-155 Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom 137-185 137-185 Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 147-155 156-160 including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes 137-185 137-185 Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_academic_exposure 147-155 161-167 including when one studies a language in a classroom [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] 137-185 137-185 Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 147-155 168-177 including when one studies a language in a classroom and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting 137-185 137-185 Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_exposure 168-177 178-181 and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away 137-185 137-185 Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_academic_exposure 168-177 182-185 and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting [ 19 ] . 137-185 137-185 Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . Such a scenario may be found in different situations , including when one studies a language in a classroom and then stops taking classes [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] and when one is immersed in a foreign language setting and then moves away [ 19 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 186-208 209-229 In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes 186-262 186-262 In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 209-229 230-233 that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it 186-262 186-262 In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_academic_exposure 230-233 234-237 ( “ use it or lose it ” 186-262 186-262 In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_academic_exposure 230-233 238-242 ( “ use it [ 20 ] ) , 186-262 186-262 In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 209-229 243-246 that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes no such changes , 186-262 186-262 In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_academic_exposure 209-229 247-262 that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . 186-262 186-262 In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_academic_exposure 186-208 263-266 In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : Additionally , we test 186-262 263-290 In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . Additionally , we test whether any such outcomes might vary as a function of the type of L2 training , in particular between classroom-like and immersion-like contexts . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_exposure 263-266 267-290 Additionally , we test whether any such outcomes might vary as a function of the type of L2 training , in particular between classroom-like and immersion-like contexts . 263-290 263-290 Additionally , we test whether any such outcomes might vary as a function of the type of L2 training , in particular between classroom-like and immersion-like contexts . Additionally , we test whether any such outcomes might vary as a function of the type of L2 training , in particular between classroom-like and immersion-like contexts . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 291-292 637-645,649-653 Previous Research A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition <*> of L2 performance or knowledge 291-292 637-669 Previous Research A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_academic_exposure 293-298 379-402 We are aware of six studies The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills 293-345 379-453 We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_academic_exposure 293-298 299 We are aware of six studies designed 293-345 293-345 We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 293-298 300-310 We are aware of six studies to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure 293-345 293-345 We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_exposure 300-310 311-314 to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training 293-345 293-345 We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 293-298 315-330 We are aware of six studies [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , 293-345 293-345 We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 293-298 331-340,344-345 We are aware of six studies all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral <*> outcomes . 293-345 293-345 We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 331-340,344-345 341-343 all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral <*> outcomes . ( performance ) 293-345 293-345 We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 346-347 348-363 ( Note that we do not consider case studies , purely observational data , or research on L2s 346-378 346-378 ( Note that we do not consider case studies , purely observational data , or research on L2s acquired by children ; for a comprehensive review , see [ 16 ] ) . ( Note that we do not consider case studies , purely observational data , or research on L2s acquired by children ; for a comprehensive review , see [ 16 ] ) . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_academic_exposure 348-363 368-378 that we do not consider case studies , purely observational data , or research on L2s for a comprehensive review , see [ 16 ] ) . 346-378 346-378 ( Note that we do not consider case studies , purely observational data , or research on L2s acquired by children ; for a comprehensive review , see [ 16 ] ) . ( Note that we do not consider case studies , purely observational data , or research on L2s acquired by children ; for a comprehensive review , see [ 16 ] ) . 1>2 solutionhood solutionhood +GUM_academic_exposure 348-363 364-367 that we do not consider case studies , purely observational data , or research on L2s acquired by children ; 346-378 346-378 ( Note that we do not consider case studies , purely observational data , or research on L2s acquired by children ; for a comprehensive review , see [ 16 ] ) . ( Note that we do not consider case studies , purely observational data , or research on L2s acquired by children ; for a comprehensive review , see [ 16 ] ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 293-298 368-378 We are aware of six studies for a comprehensive review , see [ 16 ] ) . 293-345 346-378 We are aware of six studies designed to investigate the effects of a substantial period of limited exposure following adult L2 training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] – [ 24 ] , all of which were restricted to the examination of behavioral ( performance ) outcomes . ( Note that we do not consider case studies , purely observational data , or research on L2s acquired by children ; for a comprehensive review , see [ 16 ] ) . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_academic_exposure 379-402 637-645,649-653 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition <*> of L2 performance or knowledge 379-453 637-669 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . 1>2 background background +GUM_academic_exposure 379-402 403-422 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , 379-453 379-453 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 379-402 423-428,443-445 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills though also on more specific paradigms <*> or lexical abilities 379-453 379-453 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_academic_exposure 423-428,443-445 429-435 though also on more specific paradigms <*> or lexical abilities meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities 379-453 379-453 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_exposure 423-428,443-445 436-442 though also on more specific paradigms <*> or lexical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] 379-453 379-453 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 443-445 446-453 or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . 379-453 379-453 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 379-402 454-471,497-504 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects <*> or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects 379-453 454-529 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 454-471,497-504 472-480 These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects <*> or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure 454-529 454-529 These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 454-471,497-504 481-496 These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects <*> or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , 454-529 454-529 These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 497-504 505-508 or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , 454-529 454-529 These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 454-471,497-504 509-513 These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects <*> or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects with only one longitudinal study 454-529 454-529 These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_academic_exposure 509-513 514-525 with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure 454-529 454-529 These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 509-513 526-529 with only one longitudinal study [ 24 ] . 454-529 454-529 These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . These language measures were compared in most studies to the same measures in a different set of subjects who had not experienced a period of limited exposure [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] , or to retrospective ratings of the same subjects [ 21 ] , with only one longitudinal study testing the same subjects before and after a period of limited exposure [ 24 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 379-402 530-542,558-563 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills Across the studies , the periods of limited exposure followed either classroom training <*> or mixed classroom and immersion training 379-453 530-575 The six studies tested L2 learners after periods of 1 month to 50 years of limited L2 exposure , mainly on general language skills [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] , though also on more specific paradigms meant to target aspects of grammatical abilities [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] or lexical abilities [ 22 ] , [ 23 ] . Across the studies , the periods of limited exposure followed either classroom training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 24 ] or mixed classroom and immersion training [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 530-542,558-563 543-557 Across the studies , the periods of limited exposure followed either classroom training <*> or mixed classroom and immersion training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 24 ] 530-575 530-575 Across the studies , the periods of limited exposure followed either classroom training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 24 ] or mixed classroom and immersion training [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] . Across the studies , the periods of limited exposure followed either classroom training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 24 ] or mixed classroom and immersion training [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 558-563 564-575 or mixed classroom and immersion training [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] . 530-575 530-575 Across the studies , the periods of limited exposure followed either classroom training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 24 ] or mixed classroom and immersion training [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] . Across the studies , the periods of limited exposure followed either classroom training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 24 ] or mixed classroom and immersion training [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 530-542,558-563 576-593 Across the studies , the periods of limited exposure followed either classroom training <*> or mixed classroom and immersion training The training lasted varying lengths of time , apparently usually in the range of a few years , 530-575 576-620 Across the studies , the periods of limited exposure followed either classroom training [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 22 ] , [ 24 ] or mixed classroom and immersion training [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] . The training lasted varying lengths of time , apparently usually in the range of a few years , and resulted in seemingly varying proficiency levels ( though not directly measured , except by [ 24 ] ) prior to the period of limited exposure . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 576-593 594-600,613-620 The training lasted varying lengths of time , apparently usually in the range of a few years , and resulted in seemingly varying proficiency levels <*> prior to the period of limited exposure . 576-620 576-620 The training lasted varying lengths of time , apparently usually in the range of a few years , and resulted in seemingly varying proficiency levels ( though not directly measured , except by [ 24 ] ) prior to the period of limited exposure . The training lasted varying lengths of time , apparently usually in the range of a few years , and resulted in seemingly varying proficiency levels ( though not directly measured , except by [ 24 ] ) prior to the period of limited exposure . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_exposure 594-600,613-620 601-612 and resulted in seemingly varying proficiency levels <*> prior to the period of limited exposure . ( though not directly measured , except by [ 24 ] ) 576-620 576-620 The training lasted varying lengths of time , apparently usually in the range of a few years , and resulted in seemingly varying proficiency levels ( though not directly measured , except by [ 24 ] ) prior to the period of limited exposure . The training lasted varying lengths of time , apparently usually in the range of a few years , and resulted in seemingly varying proficiency levels ( though not directly measured , except by [ 24 ] ) prior to the period of limited exposure . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_academic_exposure 621-636 637-645,649-653 Overall , the results of the six studies have been taken to suggest the following . A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition <*> of L2 performance or knowledge 621-636 637-669 Overall , the results of the six studies have been taken to suggest the following . A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_academic_exposure 186-208 637-645,649-653 In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition <*> of L2 performance or knowledge 186-262 637-669 In the present study , we examine the outcomes of such a period of no exposure on the neurocognition of L2 grammar : that is , whether a substantial period of no exposure leads to decreased proficiency and / or less native-like neural processes ( “ use it or lose it ” [ 20 ] ) , no such changes , or perhaps whether even higher proficiency and / or more native-like processing may be observed . A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_exposure 637-645,649-653 646-648 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition <*> of L2 performance or knowledge ( loss ) 637-669 637-669 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_academic_exposure 637-645,649-653 654-669 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition <*> of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . 637-669 637-669 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 637-645,649-653 670-693,697-700,705-710 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition <*> of L2 performance or knowledge Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month <*> or 6 month delay <*> as well as after 2 years 637-669 670-735 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month [ 23 ] or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 670-693,697-700,705-710 694-696 Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month <*> or 6 month delay <*> as well as after 2 years [ 23 ] 670-735 670-735 Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month [ 23 ] or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month [ 23 ] or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 697-700 701-704 or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , 670-735 670-735 Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month [ 23 ] or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month [ 23 ] or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 705-710 711-714 as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , 670-735 670-735 Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month [ 23 ] or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month [ 23 ] or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 670-693,697-700,705-710 715-731 Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month <*> or 6 month delay <*> as well as after 2 years though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier 670-735 670-735 Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month [ 23 ] or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month [ 23 ] or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_academic_exposure 715-731 732-735 though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . 670-735 670-735 Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month [ 23 ] or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . Such loss has been observed after as little as a few months of limited exposure , e.g. , after a 1 - 7 month [ 23 ] or 6 month delay [ 21 ] , as well as after 2 years [ 18 ] , though in one case it was observed only by 3 - 5 years , and not earlier [ 17 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 736-746 750-757 Although attrition may take place within the first few years , that it then appears to level off , 736-770 736-770 Although attrition may take place within the first few years , some studies suggest that it then appears to level off , with no further losses occurring [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] . Although attrition may take place within the first few years , some studies suggest that it then appears to level off , with no further losses occurring [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_academic_exposure 747-749 750-757 some studies suggest that it then appears to level off , 736-770 736-770 Although attrition may take place within the first few years , some studies suggest that it then appears to level off , with no further losses occurring [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] . Although attrition may take place within the first few years , some studies suggest that it then appears to level off , with no further losses occurring [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_academic_exposure 637-645,649-653 750-757 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition <*> of L2 performance or knowledge that it then appears to level off , 637-669 736-770 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . Although attrition may take place within the first few years , some studies suggest that it then appears to level off , with no further losses occurring [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 750-757 758-762 that it then appears to level off , with no further losses occurring 736-770 736-770 Although attrition may take place within the first few years , some studies suggest that it then appears to level off , with no further losses occurring [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] . Although attrition may take place within the first few years , some studies suggest that it then appears to level off , with no further losses occurring [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_academic_exposure 750-757 763-770 that it then appears to level off , [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] . 736-770 736-770 Although attrition may take place within the first few years , some studies suggest that it then appears to level off , with no further losses occurring [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] . Although attrition may take place within the first few years , some studies suggest that it then appears to level off , with no further losses occurring [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 637-645,649-653 771-774,779-784,800-805 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition <*> of L2 performance or knowledge Higher levels of proficiency <*> may be associated with less attrition <*> or even with no observed losses 637-669 771-809 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . Higher levels of proficiency ( or exposure ) may be associated with less attrition [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] or even with no observed losses [ 21 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 771-774,779-784,800-805 775-778 Higher levels of proficiency <*> may be associated with less attrition <*> or even with no observed losses ( or exposure ) 771-809 771-809 Higher levels of proficiency ( or exposure ) may be associated with less attrition [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] or even with no observed losses [ 21 ] . Higher levels of proficiency ( or exposure ) may be associated with less attrition [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] or even with no observed losses [ 21 ] . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_exposure 771-774,779-784,800-805 785-799 Higher levels of proficiency <*> may be associated with less attrition <*> or even with no observed losses [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] 771-809 771-809 Higher levels of proficiency ( or exposure ) may be associated with less attrition [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] or even with no observed losses [ 21 ] . Higher levels of proficiency ( or exposure ) may be associated with less attrition [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] or even with no observed losses [ 21 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 800-805 806-809 or even with no observed losses [ 21 ] . 771-809 771-809 Higher levels of proficiency ( or exposure ) may be associated with less attrition [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] or even with no observed losses [ 21 ] . Higher levels of proficiency ( or exposure ) may be associated with less attrition [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] or even with no observed losses [ 21 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 637-645,649-653 810-834 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition <*> of L2 performance or knowledge Moreover , one study found no changes at all in performance , across proficiency levels , after either 2 or 4 years of limited exposure 637-669 810-838 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . Moreover , one study found no changes at all in performance , across proficiency levels , after either 2 or 4 years of limited exposure [ 22 ] . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_academic_exposure 810-834 835-838 Moreover , one study found no changes at all in performance , across proficiency levels , after either 2 or 4 years of limited exposure [ 22 ] . 810-838 810-838 Moreover , one study found no changes at all in performance , across proficiency levels , after either 2 or 4 years of limited exposure [ 22 ] . Moreover , one study found no changes at all in performance , across proficiency levels , after either 2 or 4 years of limited exposure [ 22 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 637-645,649-653 839-851 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition <*> of L2 performance or knowledge Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : 637-669 839-900 A period of limited exposure generally leads to attrition ( loss ) of L2 performance or knowledge [ 17 ] , [ 18 ] , [ 21 ] , [ 23 ] . Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_academic_exposure 839-851 852-872 Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training 839-900 839-900 Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 852-872 873-876 after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , 839-900 839-900 Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 852-872 877-884 after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training and in another study after 2 years , 839-900 839-900 Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_exposure 877-884 885-896 and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension 839-900 839-900 Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_academic_exposure 877-884 897-900 and in another study after 2 years , [ 18 ] . 839-900 839-900 Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 839-851 901-909 Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : It remains unclear what might explain such gains , 839-900 901-949 Finally , in some cases a gain in performance has been observed : after 1.5 years of limited exposure in one study , particularly for L2 learners with immersion as well as classroom training [ 24 ] , and in another study after 2 years , though only for some abilities , such as listening and reading comprehension [ 18 ] . It remains unclear what might explain such gains , which have been attributed to motivation and to L2 experience during the period of ostensibly limited exposure [ 24 ] , or to factors related to general maturation , cognitive development , or continued academic training [ 18 ] . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_academic_exposure 901-909 910-926,931-933 It remains unclear what might explain such gains , which have been attributed to motivation and to L2 experience during the period of ostensibly limited exposure <*> or to factors 901-949 901-949 It remains unclear what might explain such gains , which have been attributed to motivation and to L2 experience during the period of ostensibly limited exposure [ 24 ] , or to factors related to general maturation , cognitive development , or continued academic training [ 18 ] . It remains unclear what might explain such gains , which have been attributed to motivation and to L2 experience during the period of ostensibly limited exposure [ 24 ] , or to factors related to general maturation , cognitive development , or continued academic training [ 18 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 910-926,931-933 927-930 which have been attributed to motivation and to L2 experience during the period of ostensibly limited exposure <*> or to factors [ 24 ] , 901-949 901-949 It remains unclear what might explain such gains , which have been attributed to motivation and to L2 experience during the period of ostensibly limited exposure [ 24 ] , or to factors related to general maturation , cognitive development , or continued academic training [ 18 ] . It remains unclear what might explain such gains , which have been attributed to motivation and to L2 experience during the period of ostensibly limited exposure [ 24 ] , or to factors related to general maturation , cognitive development , or continued academic training [ 18 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_exposure 931-933 934-945 or to factors related to general maturation , cognitive development , or continued academic training 901-949 901-949 It remains unclear what might explain such gains , which have been attributed to motivation and to L2 experience during the period of ostensibly limited exposure [ 24 ] , or to factors related to general maturation , cognitive development , or continued academic training [ 18 ] . It remains unclear what might explain such gains , which have been attributed to motivation and to L2 experience during the period of ostensibly limited exposure [ 24 ] , or to factors related to general maturation , cognitive development , or continued academic training [ 18 ] . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_exposure 931-933 946-949 or to factors [ 18 ] . 901-949 901-949 It remains unclear what might explain such gains , which have been attributed to motivation and to L2 experience during the period of ostensibly limited exposure [ 24 ] , or to factors related to general maturation , cognitive development , or continued academic training [ 18 ] . It remains unclear what might explain such gains , which have been attributed to motivation and to L2 experience during the period of ostensibly limited exposure [ 24 ] , or to factors related to general maturation , cognitive development , or continued academic training [ 18 ] . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_librarians 1-4 470-478 Digital Humanities Clinics - Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails 1-4 470-504 Digital Humanities Clinics - Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_academic_librarians 1-4 5-9 Digital Humanities Clinics - Leading Dutch Librarians into DH 1-4 5-9 Digital Humanities Clinics - Leading Dutch Librarians into DH 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 10-18 470-478 Michiel Cock m.p.cock@vu.nl Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam , the Netherlands Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails 10-18 470-504 Michiel Cock m.p.cock@vu.nl Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam , the Netherlands Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_academic_librarians 10-18 19-29 Michiel Cock m.p.cock@vu.nl Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam , the Netherlands Lotte Wilms lotte.wilms@kb.nl National Library of the Netherlands , the Netherlands 10-18 19-29 Michiel Cock m.p.cock@vu.nl Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam , the Netherlands Lotte Wilms lotte.wilms@kb.nl National Library of the Netherlands , the Netherlands 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 30-36 85-96 In 2015 , an initiative was started At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there 30-84 85-122 In 2015 , an initiative was started to set up a Dutch speaking DH+Lib community in the Netherlands and Belgium , based on the example of the American communal space of librarians , archivists , LIS graduate students , and information specialists to discuss topics ‘ Where the Digital Humanities and Libraries meet ’ . At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . 1>2 background background +GUM_academic_librarians 30-36 37-50 In 2015 , an initiative was started to set up a Dutch speaking DH+Lib community in the Netherlands and Belgium , 30-84 30-84 In 2015 , an initiative was started to set up a Dutch speaking DH+Lib community in the Netherlands and Belgium , based on the example of the American communal space of librarians , archivists , LIS graduate students , and information specialists to discuss topics ‘ Where the Digital Humanities and Libraries meet ’ . In 2015 , an initiative was started to set up a Dutch speaking DH+Lib community in the Netherlands and Belgium , based on the example of the American communal space of librarians , archivists , LIS graduate students , and information specialists to discuss topics ‘ Where the Digital Humanities and Libraries meet ’ . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_librarians 30-36 51-71 In 2015 , an initiative was started based on the example of the American communal space of librarians , archivists , LIS graduate students , and information specialists 30-84 30-84 In 2015 , an initiative was started to set up a Dutch speaking DH+Lib community in the Netherlands and Belgium , based on the example of the American communal space of librarians , archivists , LIS graduate students , and information specialists to discuss topics ‘ Where the Digital Humanities and Libraries meet ’ . In 2015 , an initiative was started to set up a Dutch speaking DH+Lib community in the Netherlands and Belgium , based on the example of the American communal space of librarians , archivists , LIS graduate students , and information specialists to discuss topics ‘ Where the Digital Humanities and Libraries meet ’ . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_academic_librarians 30-36 72-74 In 2015 , an initiative was started to discuss topics 30-84 30-84 In 2015 , an initiative was started to set up a Dutch speaking DH+Lib community in the Netherlands and Belgium , based on the example of the American communal space of librarians , archivists , LIS graduate students , and information specialists to discuss topics ‘ Where the Digital Humanities and Libraries meet ’ . In 2015 , an initiative was started to set up a Dutch speaking DH+Lib community in the Netherlands and Belgium , based on the example of the American communal space of librarians , archivists , LIS graduate students , and information specialists to discuss topics ‘ Where the Digital Humanities and Libraries meet ’ . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_librarians 72-74 75-84 to discuss topics ‘ Where the Digital Humanities and Libraries meet ’ . 30-84 30-84 In 2015 , an initiative was started to set up a Dutch speaking DH+Lib community in the Netherlands and Belgium , based on the example of the American communal space of librarians , archivists , LIS graduate students , and information specialists to discuss topics ‘ Where the Digital Humanities and Libraries meet ’ . In 2015 , an initiative was started to set up a Dutch speaking DH+Lib community in the Netherlands and Belgium , based on the example of the American communal space of librarians , archivists , LIS graduate students , and information specialists to discuss topics ‘ Where the Digital Humanities and Libraries meet ’ . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 85-96 207-211 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there Therefore both institutes joined forces 85-122 207-222 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . Therefore both institutes joined forces to develop a set of clinics on DH for librarians . 1>2 background background +GUM_academic_librarians 85-96 97-102 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities 85-122 85-122 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_librarians 85-96 103-105,109-111 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there and were not <*> in the situation 85-122 85-122 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 103-105,109-111 106-108 and were not <*> in the situation ( yet ) 85-122 85-122 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_academic_librarians 109-111 112-122 in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . 85-122 85-122 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 85-96 123-132,144-147 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there On the administrative level , the directors of the libraries <*> also expressed the wish 85-122 123-155 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . On the administrative level , the directors of the libraries participating in the consortium of Dutch academic libraries ( UKB ) also expressed the wish that librarians become more fluent in DH . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 123-132,144-147 133-140 On the administrative level , the directors of the libraries <*> also expressed the wish participating in the consortium of Dutch academic libraries 123-155 123-155 On the administrative level , the directors of the libraries participating in the consortium of Dutch academic libraries ( UKB ) also expressed the wish that librarians become more fluent in DH . On the administrative level , the directors of the libraries participating in the consortium of Dutch academic libraries ( UKB ) also expressed the wish that librarians become more fluent in DH . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 133-140 141-143 participating in the consortium of Dutch academic libraries ( UKB ) 123-155 123-155 On the administrative level , the directors of the libraries participating in the consortium of Dutch academic libraries ( UKB ) also expressed the wish that librarians become more fluent in DH . On the administrative level , the directors of the libraries participating in the consortium of Dutch academic libraries ( UKB ) also expressed the wish that librarians become more fluent in DH . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_academic_librarians 144-147 148-155 also expressed the wish that librarians become more fluent in DH . 123-155 123-155 On the administrative level , the directors of the libraries participating in the consortium of Dutch academic libraries ( UKB ) also expressed the wish that librarians become more fluent in DH . On the administrative level , the directors of the libraries participating in the consortium of Dutch academic libraries ( UKB ) also expressed the wish that librarians become more fluent in DH . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 156-165,171-181 182-186,194-196 A year later , the National Library of the Netherlands <*> and the University Library of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam again concluded that librarians at their institutes <*> needed more training 156-206 156-206 A year later , the National Library of the Netherlands ( Koninklijke Bibliotheek ) , and the University Library of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam again concluded that librarians at their institutes who wanted to get involved in DH needed more training to adequately support researchers and students in this field . A year later , the National Library of the Netherlands ( Koninklijke Bibliotheek ) , and the University Library of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam again concluded that librarians at their institutes who wanted to get involved in DH needed more training to adequately support researchers and students in this field . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_academic_librarians 156-165,171-181 166-170 A year later , the National Library of the Netherlands <*> and the University Library of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam again concluded ( Koninklijke Bibliotheek ) , 156-206 156-206 A year later , the National Library of the Netherlands ( Koninklijke Bibliotheek ) , and the University Library of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam again concluded that librarians at their institutes who wanted to get involved in DH needed more training to adequately support researchers and students in this field . A year later , the National Library of the Netherlands ( Koninklijke Bibliotheek ) , and the University Library of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam again concluded that librarians at their institutes who wanted to get involved in DH needed more training to adequately support researchers and students in this field . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_academic_librarians 85-96 182-186,194-196 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there that librarians at their institutes <*> needed more training 85-122 156-206 At the initial meeting it became apparent that most participants were there to learn more about digital humanities and were not ( yet ) in the situation where they were able to offer expertise on the subject . A year later , the National Library of the Netherlands ( Koninklijke Bibliotheek ) , and the University Library of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam again concluded that librarians at their institutes who wanted to get involved in DH needed more training to adequately support researchers and students in this field . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_academic_librarians 182-186,194-196 187-193 that librarians at their institutes <*> needed more training who wanted to get involved in DH 156-206 156-206 A year later , the National Library of the Netherlands ( Koninklijke Bibliotheek ) , and the University Library of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam again concluded that librarians at their institutes who wanted to get involved in DH needed more training to adequately support researchers and students in this field . A year later , the National Library of the Netherlands ( Koninklijke Bibliotheek ) , and the University Library of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam again concluded that librarians at their institutes who wanted to get involved in DH needed more training to adequately support researchers and students in this field . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 194-196 197-206 needed more training to adequately support researchers and students in this field . 156-206 156-206 A year later , the National Library of the Netherlands ( Koninklijke Bibliotheek ) , and the University Library of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam again concluded that librarians at their institutes who wanted to get involved in DH needed more training to adequately support researchers and students in this field . A year later , the National Library of the Netherlands ( Koninklijke Bibliotheek ) , and the University Library of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam again concluded that librarians at their institutes who wanted to get involved in DH needed more training to adequately support researchers and students in this field . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_librarians 207-211 266-282 Therefore both institutes joined forces In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH 207-222 266-308 Therefore both institutes joined forces to develop a set of clinics on DH for librarians . In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . 1>2 background background +GUM_academic_librarians 207-211 212-222 Therefore both institutes joined forces to develop a set of clinics on DH for librarians . 207-222 207-222 Therefore both institutes joined forces to develop a set of clinics on DH for librarians . Therefore both institutes joined forces to develop a set of clinics on DH for librarians . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_librarians 207-211 223-234 Therefore both institutes joined forces The two institutes were later joined by the Leiden University Libraries . 207-222 223-234 Therefore both institutes joined forces to develop a set of clinics on DH for librarians . The two institutes were later joined by the Leiden University Libraries . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_academic_librarians 207-211 235-241 Therefore both institutes joined forces We see this as the ideal opportunity 207-222 235-265 Therefore both institutes joined forces to develop a set of clinics on DH for librarians . We see this as the ideal opportunity to provide these educative sessions not only to our own librarians , but also to the academic librarians of other Dutch research libraries . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_academic_librarians 235-241 242-253 We see this as the ideal opportunity to provide these educative sessions not only to our own librarians , 235-265 235-265 We see this as the ideal opportunity to provide these educative sessions not only to our own librarians , but also to the academic librarians of other Dutch research libraries . We see this as the ideal opportunity to provide these educative sessions not only to our own librarians , but also to the academic librarians of other Dutch research libraries . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_librarians 242-253 254-265 to provide these educative sessions not only to our own librarians , but also to the academic librarians of other Dutch research libraries . 235-265 235-265 We see this as the ideal opportunity to provide these educative sessions not only to our own librarians , but also to the academic librarians of other Dutch research libraries . We see this as the ideal opportunity to provide these educative sessions not only to our own librarians , but also to the academic librarians of other Dutch research libraries . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 266-282 470-478 In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails 266-308 470-504 In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; 1>2 background background +GUM_academic_librarians 266-282 283-292 In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role 266-308 266-308 In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_librarians 283-292 293-297 in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research 266-308 266-308 In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 283-292 298-303 in order for them to take up their natural role and ideally become the research partner 266-308 266-308 In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 298-303 304-308 and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . 266-308 266-308 In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 266-282 309-332 In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH The aim of these clinics is to provide basic methodological competencies and technical skills in DH , for a diverse group of librarians , 266-308 309-344 In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . The aim of these clinics is to provide basic methodological competencies and technical skills in DH , for a diverse group of librarians , consisting of both subject and technical librarians with basic technical skills . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 309-332 333-344 The aim of these clinics is to provide basic methodological competencies and technical skills in DH , for a diverse group of librarians , consisting of both subject and technical librarians with basic technical skills . 309-344 309-344 The aim of these clinics is to provide basic methodological competencies and technical skills in DH , for a diverse group of librarians , consisting of both subject and technical librarians with basic technical skills . The aim of these clinics is to provide basic methodological competencies and technical skills in DH , for a diverse group of librarians , consisting of both subject and technical librarians with basic technical skills . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 309-332 345-367,379-385 The aim of these clinics is to provide basic methodological competencies and technical skills in DH , for a diverse group of librarians , The content of these sessions should enable them to provide services to researchers and students , identify remaining gaps in knowledge or skills <*> to automate their daily library work . 309-344 345-385 The aim of these clinics is to provide basic methodological competencies and technical skills in DH , for a diverse group of librarians , consisting of both subject and technical librarians with basic technical skills . The content of these sessions should enable them to provide services to researchers and students , identify remaining gaps in knowledge or skills that they could address by self-directed learning and ( perhaps ) to automate their daily library work . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_librarians 345-367,379-385 368-375 The content of these sessions should enable them to provide services to researchers and students , identify remaining gaps in knowledge or skills <*> to automate their daily library work . that they could address by self-directed learning and 345-385 345-385 The content of these sessions should enable them to provide services to researchers and students , identify remaining gaps in knowledge or skills that they could address by self-directed learning and ( perhaps ) to automate their daily library work . The content of these sessions should enable them to provide services to researchers and students , identify remaining gaps in knowledge or skills that they could address by self-directed learning and ( perhaps ) to automate their daily library work . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 376-378 379-385 ( perhaps ) to automate their daily library work . 345-385 345-385 The content of these sessions should enable them to provide services to researchers and students , identify remaining gaps in knowledge or skills that they could address by self-directed learning and ( perhaps ) to automate their daily library work . The content of these sessions should enable them to provide services to researchers and students , identify remaining gaps in knowledge or skills that they could address by self-directed learning and ( perhaps ) to automate their daily library work . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_academic_librarians 386-399 400-406 We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level 386-444 386-444 We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_academic_librarians 266-282 400-406 In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH but want to boost their knowledge level 266-308 386-444 In essence , we want to teach our country ’s librarians the ins and outs of DH in order for them to take up their natural role of facilitating and supporting research and ideally become the research partner needed in DH projects . We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 400-406 407-411 but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable 386-444 386-444 We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_academic_librarians 407-411 412-417 to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , 386-444 386-444 We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_academic_librarians 400-406 418-423 but want to boost their knowledge level follow the literature and research , 386-444 386-444 We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 400-406 424-426 but want to boost their knowledge level follow online tutorials 386-444 386-444 We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 400-406 427-432 but want to boost their knowledge level and hopefully take up the challenge 386-444 386-444 We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 427-432 433-437 and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development 386-444 386-444 We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 427-432 438-444 and hopefully take up the challenge by engaging with the DH community . 386-444 386-444 We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . We are not setting out to turn them into programmers or data crunchers , but want to boost their knowledge level to where they feel comfortable providing information about DH projects , follow the literature and research , follow online tutorials and hopefully take up the challenge of finishing this professional development by engaging with the DH community . 1<2 means means +GUM_academic_librarians 445-450 451-463 In order to design this curriculum we follow a four step approach with a Working Out Loud - principle 445-469 445-469 In order to design this curriculum we follow a four step approach with a Working Out Loud - principle ( Williams , 2010 ) : In order to design this curriculum we follow a four step approach with a Working Out Loud - principle ( Williams , 2010 ) : 1>2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_librarians 451-463 470-478 we follow a four step approach with a Working Out Loud - principle Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails 445-469 470-504 In order to design this curriculum we follow a four step approach with a Working Out Loud - principle ( Williams , 2010 ) : Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_academic_librarians 451-463 464-469 we follow a four step approach with a Working Out Loud - principle ( Williams , 2010 ) : 445-469 445-469 In order to design this curriculum we follow a four step approach with a Working Out Loud - principle ( Williams , 2010 ) : In order to design this curriculum we follow a four step approach with a Working Out Loud - principle ( Williams , 2010 ) : 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_academic_librarians 470-478 479-486 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; 470-504 470-504 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 479-486 487-490 ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; 470-504 470-504 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 479-486 491-504 ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; 470-504 470-504 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 470-478 505-508 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails Identify possible subjects , 470-504 505-552 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; Identify possible subjects , based on experience , a comparison of existing teaching material related to DH ( e.g. The Programming Historian , the Digital Scholarship Training Programme at the British Library and Columbia University 's Developing Librarian project ) and the TaDiRAH taxonomy of research activities ; 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 505-508 509-518,545-552 Identify possible subjects , based on experience , a comparison of existing teaching material <*> and the TaDiRAH taxonomy of research activities ; 505-552 505-552 Identify possible subjects , based on experience , a comparison of existing teaching material related to DH ( e.g. The Programming Historian , the Digital Scholarship Training Programme at the British Library and Columbia University 's Developing Librarian project ) and the TaDiRAH taxonomy of research activities ; Identify possible subjects , based on experience , a comparison of existing teaching material related to DH ( e.g. The Programming Historian , the Digital Scholarship Training Programme at the British Library and Columbia University 's Developing Librarian project ) and the TaDiRAH taxonomy of research activities ; 1<2 means means +GUM_academic_librarians 509-518,545-552 519-521 based on experience , a comparison of existing teaching material <*> and the TaDiRAH taxonomy of research activities ; related to DH 505-552 505-552 Identify possible subjects , based on experience , a comparison of existing teaching material related to DH ( e.g. The Programming Historian , the Digital Scholarship Training Programme at the British Library and Columbia University 's Developing Librarian project ) and the TaDiRAH taxonomy of research activities ; Identify possible subjects , based on experience , a comparison of existing teaching material related to DH ( e.g. The Programming Historian , the Digital Scholarship Training Programme at the British Library and Columbia University 's Developing Librarian project ) and the TaDiRAH taxonomy of research activities ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 519-521 522-544 related to DH ( e.g. The Programming Historian , the Digital Scholarship Training Programme at the British Library and Columbia University 's Developing Librarian project ) 505-552 505-552 Identify possible subjects , based on experience , a comparison of existing teaching material related to DH ( e.g. The Programming Historian , the Digital Scholarship Training Programme at the British Library and Columbia University 's Developing Librarian project ) and the TaDiRAH taxonomy of research activities ; Identify possible subjects , based on experience , a comparison of existing teaching material related to DH ( e.g. The Programming Historian , the Digital Scholarship Training Programme at the British Library and Columbia University 's Developing Librarian project ) and the TaDiRAH taxonomy of research activities ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 470-478 553-560 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails Get feedback from researchers on possible subjects , 470-504 553-571 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; Get feedback from researchers on possible subjects , based on the knowledge and skills they feel librarians need ; 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 553-560 561-566 Get feedback from researchers on possible subjects , based on the knowledge and skills 553-571 553-571 Get feedback from researchers on possible subjects , based on the knowledge and skills they feel librarians need ; Get feedback from researchers on possible subjects , based on the knowledge and skills they feel librarians need ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 567-568 569-571 they feel librarians need ; 553-571 553-571 Get feedback from researchers on possible subjects , based on the knowledge and skills they feel librarians need ; Get feedback from researchers on possible subjects , based on the knowledge and skills they feel librarians need ; 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_academic_librarians 561-566 569-571 based on the knowledge and skills librarians need ; 553-571 553-571 Get feedback from researchers on possible subjects , based on the knowledge and skills they feel librarians need ; Get feedback from researchers on possible subjects , based on the knowledge and skills they feel librarians need ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 470-478 572-579 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails Get feedback from librarians on possible subjects , 470-504 572-590 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; Get feedback from librarians on possible subjects , based on already known gaps in their knowledge and skills . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 572-579 580-590 Get feedback from librarians on possible subjects , based on already known gaps in their knowledge and skills . 572-590 572-590 Get feedback from librarians on possible subjects , based on already known gaps in their knowledge and skills . Get feedback from librarians on possible subjects , based on already known gaps in their knowledge and skills . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 470-478 591-603 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , 470-504 591-637 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , based on the method of ' constructive alignment ' ( Biggs et al. , 2011 ) , to make sure that the intended learning objectives and the teaching / learning activities stay aligned . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 591-603 604-612 With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , based on the method of ' constructive alignment ' 591-637 591-637 With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , based on the method of ' constructive alignment ' ( Biggs et al. , 2011 ) , to make sure that the intended learning objectives and the teaching / learning activities stay aligned . With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , based on the method of ' constructive alignment ' ( Biggs et al. , 2011 ) , to make sure that the intended learning objectives and the teaching / learning activities stay aligned . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_academic_librarians 604-612 613-620 based on the method of ' constructive alignment ' ( Biggs et al. , 2011 ) , 591-637 591-637 With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , based on the method of ' constructive alignment ' ( Biggs et al. , 2011 ) , to make sure that the intended learning objectives and the teaching / learning activities stay aligned . With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , based on the method of ' constructive alignment ' ( Biggs et al. , 2011 ) , to make sure that the intended learning objectives and the teaching / learning activities stay aligned . 1<2 background background +GUM_academic_librarians 621-623 624-637 to make sure that the intended learning objectives and the teaching / learning activities stay aligned . 591-637 591-637 With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , based on the method of ' constructive alignment ' ( Biggs et al. , 2011 ) , to make sure that the intended learning objectives and the teaching / learning activities stay aligned . With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , based on the method of ' constructive alignment ' ( Biggs et al. , 2011 ) , to make sure that the intended learning objectives and the teaching / learning activities stay aligned . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_academic_librarians 591-603 624-637 With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , that the intended learning objectives and the teaching / learning activities stay aligned . 591-637 591-637 With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , based on the method of ' constructive alignment ' ( Biggs et al. , 2011 ) , to make sure that the intended learning objectives and the teaching / learning activities stay aligned . With these in hand , we will design the curriculum of clinics , based on the method of ' constructive alignment ' ( Biggs et al. , 2011 ) , to make sure that the intended learning objectives and the teaching / learning activities stay aligned . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_academic_librarians 470-478 638-653 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails Our plan is to organize a maximum of 6 clinics , each one full day . 470-504 638-653 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; Our plan is to organize a maximum of 6 clinics , each one full day . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 638-653 654-664 Our plan is to organize a maximum of 6 clinics , each one full day . Each day starts with one or more lectures by researchers , 638-653 654-671 Our plan is to organize a maximum of 6 clinics , each one full day . Each day starts with one or more lectures by researchers , that address the conceptual knowledge needed . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 654-664 665-669 Each day starts with one or more lectures by researchers , that address the conceptual knowledge 654-671 654-671 Each day starts with one or more lectures by researchers , that address the conceptual knowledge needed . Each day starts with one or more lectures by researchers , that address the conceptual knowledge needed . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 665-669 670-671 that address the conceptual knowledge needed . 654-671 654-671 Each day starts with one or more lectures by researchers , that address the conceptual knowledge needed . Each day starts with one or more lectures by researchers , that address the conceptual knowledge needed . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 654-664 672-684 Each day starts with one or more lectures by researchers , The afternoon sessions will be devoted to the hands-on training of skills , 654-671 672-694 Each day starts with one or more lectures by researchers , that address the conceptual knowledge needed . The afternoon sessions will be devoted to the hands-on training of skills , following the Library Carpentry model as closely as possible . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_academic_librarians 672-684 685-694 The afternoon sessions will be devoted to the hands-on training of skills , following the Library Carpentry model as closely as possible . 672-694 672-694 The afternoon sessions will be devoted to the hands-on training of skills , following the Library Carpentry model as closely as possible . The afternoon sessions will be devoted to the hands-on training of skills , following the Library Carpentry model as closely as possible . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 695-702 703-719 By having researchers provide the lecture sessions , we hope to fuel the enthusiasm of the librarians with the inspiration of direct contact with researchers 695-731 695-731 By having researchers provide the lecture sessions , we hope to fuel the enthusiasm of the librarians with the inspiration of direct contact with researchers and to provide access to a network within and across universities . By having researchers provide the lecture sessions , we hope to fuel the enthusiasm of the librarians with the inspiration of direct contact with researchers and to provide access to a network within and across universities . 1>2 means means +GUM_academic_librarians 654-664 703-719 Each day starts with one or more lectures by researchers , we hope to fuel the enthusiasm of the librarians with the inspiration of direct contact with researchers 654-671 695-731 Each day starts with one or more lectures by researchers , that address the conceptual knowledge needed . By having researchers provide the lecture sessions , we hope to fuel the enthusiasm of the librarians with the inspiration of direct contact with researchers and to provide access to a network within and across universities . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 703-719 720-731 we hope to fuel the enthusiasm of the librarians with the inspiration of direct contact with researchers and to provide access to a network within and across universities . 695-731 695-731 By having researchers provide the lecture sessions , we hope to fuel the enthusiasm of the librarians with the inspiration of direct contact with researchers and to provide access to a network within and across universities . By having researchers provide the lecture sessions , we hope to fuel the enthusiasm of the librarians with the inspiration of direct contact with researchers and to provide access to a network within and across universities . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 470-478 732-748 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails With these clinics , we hope to initiate a stream of DH activities in Dutch universities , 470-504 732-758 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; With these clinics , we hope to initiate a stream of DH activities in Dutch universities , making access to support easier for new digital scholars . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 732-748 749-758 With these clinics , we hope to initiate a stream of DH activities in Dutch universities , making access to support easier for new digital scholars . 732-758 732-758 With these clinics , we hope to initiate a stream of DH activities in Dutch universities , making access to support easier for new digital scholars . With these clinics , we hope to initiate a stream of DH activities in Dutch universities , making access to support easier for new digital scholars . 1<2 result result +GUM_academic_librarians 470-478 759-773 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails The poster at DH2017 will present the curriculum , its position in the international context 470-504 759-788 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; The poster at DH2017 will present the curriculum , its position in the international context and offer the lessons learned from both the design process and the first clinics . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 759-773 774-777 The poster at DH2017 will present the curriculum , its position in the international context and offer the lessons 759-788 759-788 The poster at DH2017 will present the curriculum , its position in the international context and offer the lessons learned from both the design process and the first clinics . The poster at DH2017 will present the curriculum , its position in the international context and offer the lessons learned from both the design process and the first clinics . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 774-777 778-788 and offer the lessons learned from both the design process and the first clinics . 759-788 759-788 The poster at DH2017 will present the curriculum , its position in the international context and offer the lessons learned from both the design process and the first clinics . The poster at DH2017 will present the curriculum , its position in the international context and offer the lessons learned from both the design process and the first clinics . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_academic_librarians 470-478 789-797 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails We welcome discussion about our efforts and the possibilities 470-504 789-804 Desk research about what being a DH librarian entails ( e.g. Hartsell-Gundy et al. , 2015 ; Mulligan , 2016 ; also see the Zotero library of the LIBER Digital Humanities working group ) ; We welcome discussion about our efforts and the possibilities of applying this in other contexts . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_academic_librarians 789-797 798-804 We welcome discussion about our efforts and the possibilities of applying this in other contexts . 789-804 789-804 We welcome discussion about our efforts and the possibilities of applying this in other contexts . We welcome discussion about our efforts and the possibilities of applying this in other contexts . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 1-4 5-15 Education and early loves Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , 1-4 5-33 Education and early loves Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_bio_byron 5-15 16-30 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . 5-33 5-33 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_byron 5-15 31-33 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , [ 17 ] 5-33 5-33 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 34-42 43-49 Placed under the care of a Dr. Bailey , he was encouraged to exercise in moderation 34-68 34-68 Placed under the care of a Dr. Bailey , he was encouraged to exercise in moderation but not restrain himself from " violent " bouts in an attempt to overcompensate for his deformed foot . Placed under the care of a Dr. Bailey , he was encouraged to exercise in moderation but not restrain himself from " violent " bouts in an attempt to overcompensate for his deformed foot . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_bio_byron 5-15 43-49 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , he was encouraged to exercise in moderation 5-33 34-68 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] Placed under the care of a Dr. Bailey , he was encouraged to exercise in moderation but not restrain himself from " violent " bouts in an attempt to overcompensate for his deformed foot . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 43-49 50-61 he was encouraged to exercise in moderation but not restrain himself from " violent " bouts in an attempt 34-68 34-68 Placed under the care of a Dr. Bailey , he was encouraged to exercise in moderation but not restrain himself from " violent " bouts in an attempt to overcompensate for his deformed foot . Placed under the care of a Dr. Bailey , he was encouraged to exercise in moderation but not restrain himself from " violent " bouts in an attempt to overcompensate for his deformed foot . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_bio_byron 50-61 62-68 but not restrain himself from " violent " bouts in an attempt to overcompensate for his deformed foot . 34-68 34-68 Placed under the care of a Dr. Bailey , he was encouraged to exercise in moderation but not restrain himself from " violent " bouts in an attempt to overcompensate for his deformed foot . Placed under the care of a Dr. Bailey , he was encouraged to exercise in moderation but not restrain himself from " violent " bouts in an attempt to overcompensate for his deformed foot . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 43-49 69-75 he was encouraged to exercise in moderation His mother interfered with his studies , 34-68 69-95 Placed under the care of a Dr. Bailey , he was encouraged to exercise in moderation but not restrain himself from " violent " bouts in an attempt to overcompensate for his deformed foot . His mother interfered with his studies , often withdrawing him from school , with the result that he lacked discipline and his classical studies were neglected . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_byron 69-75 76-81 His mother interfered with his studies , often withdrawing him from school , 69-95 69-95 His mother interfered with his studies , often withdrawing him from school , with the result that he lacked discipline and his classical studies were neglected . His mother interfered with his studies , often withdrawing him from school , with the result that he lacked discipline and his classical studies were neglected . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 76-81 82-84 often withdrawing him from school , with the result 69-95 69-95 His mother interfered with his studies , often withdrawing him from school , with the result that he lacked discipline and his classical studies were neglected . His mother interfered with his studies , often withdrawing him from school , with the result that he lacked discipline and his classical studies were neglected . 1<2 result result +GUM_bio_byron 82-84 85-88 with the result that he lacked discipline 69-95 69-95 His mother interfered with his studies , often withdrawing him from school , with the result that he lacked discipline and his classical studies were neglected . His mother interfered with his studies , often withdrawing him from school , with the result that he lacked discipline and his classical studies were neglected . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 85-88 89-95 that he lacked discipline and his classical studies were neglected . 69-95 69-95 His mother interfered with his studies , often withdrawing him from school , with the result that he lacked discipline and his classical studies were neglected . His mother interfered with his studies , often withdrawing him from school , with the result that he lacked discipline and his classical studies were neglected . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_byron 5-15 96-104 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , In 1801 , he was sent to Harrow , 5-33 96-114 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] In 1801 , he was sent to Harrow , where he remained until July 1805 . [ 6 ] 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_byron 96-104 105-111 In 1801 , he was sent to Harrow , where he remained until July 1805 . 96-114 96-114 In 1801 , he was sent to Harrow , where he remained until July 1805 . [ 6 ] In 1801 , he was sent to Harrow , where he remained until July 1805 . [ 6 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 96-104 112-114 In 1801 , he was sent to Harrow , [ 6 ] 96-114 96-114 In 1801 , he was sent to Harrow , where he remained until July 1805 . [ 6 ] In 1801 , he was sent to Harrow , where he remained until July 1805 . [ 6 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 115-122 123-142 An undistinguished student and an unskilled cricketer , he did represent the school during the very first Eton v Harrow cricket match at Lord 's in 1805 . 115-145 115-145 An undistinguished student and an unskilled cricketer , he did represent the school during the very first Eton v Harrow cricket match at Lord 's in 1805 . [ 19 ] An undistinguished student and an unskilled cricketer , he did represent the school during the very first Eton v Harrow cricket match at Lord 's in 1805 . [ 19 ] 1>2 concession concession +GUM_bio_byron 5-15 123-142 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , he did represent the school during the very first Eton v Harrow cricket match at Lord 's in 1805 . 5-33 115-145 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] An undistinguished student and an unskilled cricketer , he did represent the school during the very first Eton v Harrow cricket match at Lord 's in 1805 . [ 19 ] 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_byron 123-142 143-145 he did represent the school during the very first Eton v Harrow cricket match at Lord 's in 1805 . [ 19 ] 115-145 115-145 An undistinguished student and an unskilled cricketer , he did represent the school during the very first Eton v Harrow cricket match at Lord 's in 1805 . [ 19 ] An undistinguished student and an unskilled cricketer , he did represent the school during the very first Eton v Harrow cricket match at Lord 's in 1805 . [ 19 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 146-156 157-164 His lack of moderation was not restricted to physical exercise . Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , 146-156 157-189 His lack of moderation was not restricted to physical exercise . Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_bio_byron 5-15 157-164 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , 5-33 157-189 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_byron 157-164 165-167 Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met 157-189 157-189 Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 165-167 168-171 whom he met while at school , 157-189 157-189 Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_bio_byron 157-164 172-174 Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , [ 6 ] 157-189 157-189 Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 175-179 180-189 and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . 157-189 157-189 Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_bio_byron 157-164 180-189 Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . 157-189 157-189 Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . 1<2 result result +GUM_bio_byron 190-193 194-198,203-231 His mother wrote , " He has no indisposition <*> but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " 190-234 190-234 His mother wrote , " He has no indisposition that I know of but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " [ 6 ] His mother wrote , " He has no indisposition that I know of but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " [ 6 ] 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_bio_byron 157-164 194-198,203-231 Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , " He has no indisposition <*> but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " 157-189 190-234 Byron fell in love with Mary Chaworth , whom he met while at school , [ 6 ] and she was the reason he refused to return to Harrow in September 1803 . His mother wrote , " He has no indisposition that I know of but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " [ 6 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 194-198,203-231 199-202 " He has no indisposition <*> but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " that I know of 190-234 190-234 His mother wrote , " He has no indisposition that I know of but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " [ 6 ] His mother wrote , " He has no indisposition that I know of but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " [ 6 ] 1<2 concession concession +GUM_bio_byron 194-198,203-231 232-234 " He has no indisposition <*> but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " [ 6 ] 190-234 190-234 His mother wrote , " He has no indisposition that I know of but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " [ 6 ] His mother wrote , " He has no indisposition that I know of but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " [ 6 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 194-198,203-231 235-256 " He has no indisposition <*> but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " In Byron 's later memoirs , " Mary Chaworth is portrayed as the first object of his adult sexual feelings . " 190-234 235-259 His mother wrote , " He has no indisposition that I know of but love , desperate love , the worst of all maladies in my opinion . In short , the boy is distractedly in love with Miss Chaworth . " [ 6 ] In Byron 's later memoirs , " Mary Chaworth is portrayed as the first object of his adult sexual feelings . " [ 20 ] 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_byron 235-256 257-259 In Byron 's later memoirs , " Mary Chaworth is portrayed as the first object of his adult sexual feelings . " [ 20 ] 235-259 235-259 In Byron 's later memoirs , " Mary Chaworth is portrayed as the first object of his adult sexual feelings . " [ 20 ] In Byron 's later memoirs , " Mary Chaworth is portrayed as the first object of his adult sexual feelings . " [ 20 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 5-15 260-266,270-274 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , Byron finally returned in January 1804 , <*> to a more settled period 5-33 260-316 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_byron 260-266,270-274 267-269 Byron finally returned in January 1804 , <*> to a more settled period [ 6 ] 260-316 260-316 Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 270-274 275-289 to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , 260-316 260-316 Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 275-289 290-296 which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : 260-316 260-316 Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 290-296 297-304 which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions 260-316 260-316 Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 297-304 305-313 " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " 260-316 260-316 Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] 1<2 cause cause +GUM_bio_byron 297-304 314-316 " My school friendships were with me passions [ 21 ] 260-316 260-316 Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 260-266,270-274 317-330 Byron finally returned in January 1804 , <*> to a more settled period The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare 260-316 317-355 Byron finally returned in January 1804 , [ 6 ] to a more settled period which saw the formation of a circle of emotional involvements with other Harrow boys , which he recalled with great vividness : " My school friendships were with me passions ( for I was always violent ) . " [ 21 ] The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 317-330 331-337 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — 317-355 317-355 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 317-330 338-348 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy 317-355 317-355 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 338-348 349-352 whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . 317-355 317-355 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 317-330 353-355 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare [ 22 ] 317-355 317-355 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 317-330 356-365,370-377 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare His nostalgic poems about his Harrow friendships , Childish Recollections <*> express a prescient " consciousness of sexual differences 317-355 356-392 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] His nostalgic poems about his Harrow friendships , Childish Recollections ( 1806 ) , express a prescient " consciousness of sexual differences that may in the end make England untenable to him . " [ 23 ] 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_byron 356-365,370-377 366-369 His nostalgic poems about his Harrow friendships , Childish Recollections <*> express a prescient " consciousness of sexual differences ( 1806 ) , 356-392 356-392 His nostalgic poems about his Harrow friendships , Childish Recollections ( 1806 ) , express a prescient " consciousness of sexual differences that may in the end make England untenable to him . " [ 23 ] His nostalgic poems about his Harrow friendships , Childish Recollections ( 1806 ) , express a prescient " consciousness of sexual differences that may in the end make England untenable to him . " [ 23 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 370-377 378-389 express a prescient " consciousness of sexual differences that may in the end make England untenable to him . " 356-392 356-392 His nostalgic poems about his Harrow friendships , Childish Recollections ( 1806 ) , express a prescient " consciousness of sexual differences that may in the end make England untenable to him . " [ 23 ] His nostalgic poems about his Harrow friendships , Childish Recollections ( 1806 ) , express a prescient " consciousness of sexual differences that may in the end make England untenable to him . " [ 23 ] 1<2 result result +GUM_bio_byron 356-365,370-377 390-392 His nostalgic poems about his Harrow friendships , Childish Recollections <*> express a prescient " consciousness of sexual differences [ 23 ] 356-392 356-392 His nostalgic poems about his Harrow friendships , Childish Recollections ( 1806 ) , express a prescient " consciousness of sexual differences that may in the end make England untenable to him . " [ 23 ] His nostalgic poems about his Harrow friendships , Childish Recollections ( 1806 ) , express a prescient " consciousness of sexual differences that may in the end make England untenable to him . " [ 23 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 317-330 393-406,409-421 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare Letters to Byron in the John Murray archive contain evidence of a previously unremarked <*> romantic relationship with a younger boy at Harrow , John Thomas Claridge . 317-355 393-421 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] Letters to Byron in the John Murray archive contain evidence of a previously unremarked if short-lived romantic relationship with a younger boy at Harrow , John Thomas Claridge . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_byron 393-406,409-421 407-408 Letters to Byron in the John Murray archive contain evidence of a previously unremarked <*> romantic relationship with a younger boy at Harrow , John Thomas Claridge . if short-lived 393-421 393-421 Letters to Byron in the John Murray archive contain evidence of a previously unremarked if short-lived romantic relationship with a younger boy at Harrow , John Thomas Claridge . Letters to Byron in the John Murray archive contain evidence of a previously unremarked if short-lived romantic relationship with a younger boy at Harrow , John Thomas Claridge . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_bio_byron 317-330 422-428 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare 317-355 422-428 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare 1<2 background background +GUM_bio_byron 429-430 431-437 Ah ! Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , 429-430 431-465 Ah ! Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , Which whispers friendship will be doubly dear To one , who thus for kindred hearts must roam , And seek abroad , the love denied at home . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_bio_byron 317-330 431-437 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , 317-355 431-465 The most enduring of those was with John FitzGibbon , 2nd Earl of Clare — four years Byron 's junior — whom he was to meet unexpectedly many years later in Italy ( 1821 ) . [ 22 ] Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , Which whispers friendship will be doubly dear To one , who thus for kindred hearts must roam , And seek abroad , the love denied at home . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 431-437 438-440 Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , Which whispers friendship 431-465 431-465 Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , Which whispers friendship will be doubly dear To one , who thus for kindred hearts must roam , And seek abroad , the love denied at home . Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , Which whispers friendship will be doubly dear To one , who thus for kindred hearts must roam , And seek abroad , the love denied at home . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 431-437 441-447 Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , will be doubly dear To one , 431-465 431-465 Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , Which whispers friendship will be doubly dear To one , who thus for kindred hearts must roam , And seek abroad , the love denied at home . Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , Which whispers friendship will be doubly dear To one , who thus for kindred hearts must roam , And seek abroad , the love denied at home . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_bio_byron 441-447 448-465 will be doubly dear To one , who thus for kindred hearts must roam , And seek abroad , the love denied at home . 431-465 431-465 Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , Which whispers friendship will be doubly dear To one , who thus for kindred hearts must roam , And seek abroad , the love denied at home . Sure some stronger impulse vibrates here , Which whispers friendship will be doubly dear To one , who thus for kindred hearts must roam , And seek abroad , the love denied at home . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 466-478 482-495 The following autumn , he went up to Trinity College , Cambridge , where he met and formed a close friendship with the younger John Edleston . 466-495 466-495 The following autumn , he went up to Trinity College , Cambridge , [ 24 ] where he met and formed a close friendship with the younger John Edleston . The following autumn , he went up to Trinity College , Cambridge , [ 24 ] where he met and formed a close friendship with the younger John Edleston . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_bio_byron 466-478 479-481 The following autumn , he went up to Trinity College , Cambridge , [ 24 ] 466-495 466-495 The following autumn , he went up to Trinity College , Cambridge , [ 24 ] where he met and formed a close friendship with the younger John Edleston . The following autumn , he went up to Trinity College , Cambridge , [ 24 ] where he met and formed a close friendship with the younger John Edleston . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 5-15 482-495 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , where he met and formed a close friendship with the younger John Edleston . 5-33 466-495 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] The following autumn , he went up to Trinity College , Cambridge , [ 24 ] where he met and formed a close friendship with the younger John Edleston . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_byron 496-503 504-516 About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , 496-545 496-545 About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_bio_byron 482-495 504-516 where he met and formed a close friendship with the younger John Edleston . " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , 466-495 496-545 The following autumn , he went up to Trinity College , Cambridge , [ 24 ] where he met and formed a close friendship with the younger John Edleston . About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 504-516 517-522 " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . 496-545 496-545 About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_bio_byron 504-516 523-529 " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , His voice first attracted my attention , 496-545 496-545 About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_byron 504-516 530-534 " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , his countenance fixed it , 496-545 496-545 About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_byron 504-516 535-545 " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " 496-545 496-545 About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_byron 504-516 546-557 " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , In his memory Byron composed Thyrza , a series of elegies . 496-545 546-560 About his " protégé " he wrote , " He has been my almost constant associate since October , 1805 , when I entered Trinity College . His voice first attracted my attention , his countenance fixed it , and his manners attached me to him for ever . " In his memory Byron composed Thyrza , a series of elegies . [ 25 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 546-557 558-560 In his memory Byron composed Thyrza , a series of elegies . [ 25 ] 546-560 546-560 In his memory Byron composed Thyrza , a series of elegies . [ 25 ] In his memory Byron composed Thyrza , a series of elegies . [ 25 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 546-557 561-580 In his memory Byron composed Thyrza , a series of elegies . In later years , he described the affair as " a violent , though pure love and passion " . 546-560 561-580 In his memory Byron composed Thyrza , a series of elegies . [ 25 ] In later years , he described the affair as " a violent , though pure love and passion " . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_byron 561-580 581-604,610-616 In later years , he described the affair as " a violent , though pure love and passion " . This statement , however , needs to be read in the context of hardening public attitudes toward homosexuality in England and the severe sanctions <*> against convicted or even suspected offenders . 561-580 581-619 In later years , he described the affair as " a violent , though pure love and passion " . This statement , however , needs to be read in the context of hardening public attitudes toward homosexuality in England and the severe sanctions ( including public hanging ) against convicted or even suspected offenders . [ 26 ] 1<2 background background +GUM_bio_byron 581-604,610-616 605-609 This statement , however , needs to be read in the context of hardening public attitudes toward homosexuality in England and the severe sanctions <*> against convicted or even suspected offenders . ( including public hanging ) 581-619 581-619 This statement , however , needs to be read in the context of hardening public attitudes toward homosexuality in England and the severe sanctions ( including public hanging ) against convicted or even suspected offenders . [ 26 ] This statement , however , needs to be read in the context of hardening public attitudes toward homosexuality in England and the severe sanctions ( including public hanging ) against convicted or even suspected offenders . [ 26 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 581-604,610-616 617-619 This statement , however , needs to be read in the context of hardening public attitudes toward homosexuality in England and the severe sanctions <*> against convicted or even suspected offenders . [ 26 ] 581-619 581-619 This statement , however , needs to be read in the context of hardening public attitudes toward homosexuality in England and the severe sanctions ( including public hanging ) against convicted or even suspected offenders . [ 26 ] This statement , however , needs to be read in the context of hardening public attitudes toward homosexuality in England and the severe sanctions ( including public hanging ) against convicted or even suspected offenders . [ 26 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 561-580 620-646,650-658 In later years , he described the affair as " a violent , though pure love and passion " . The liaison , on the other hand , may well have been " pure " out of respect for Edleston 's innocence , in contrast to the <*> more sexually overt relations experienced at Harrow School . 561-580 620-661 In later years , he described the affair as " a violent , though pure love and passion " . The liaison , on the other hand , may well have been " pure " out of respect for Edleston 's innocence , in contrast to the ( probably ) more sexually overt relations experienced at Harrow School . [ 27 ] 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_bio_byron 647-649 650-658 ( probably ) more sexually overt relations experienced at Harrow School . 620-661 620-661 The liaison , on the other hand , may well have been " pure " out of respect for Edleston 's innocence , in contrast to the ( probably ) more sexually overt relations experienced at Harrow School . [ 27 ] The liaison , on the other hand , may well have been " pure " out of respect for Edleston 's innocence , in contrast to the ( probably ) more sexually overt relations experienced at Harrow School . [ 27 ] 1>2 concession concession +GUM_bio_byron 620-646,650-658 659-661 The liaison , on the other hand , may well have been " pure " out of respect for Edleston 's innocence , in contrast to the <*> more sexually overt relations experienced at Harrow School . [ 27 ] 620-661 620-661 The liaison , on the other hand , may well have been " pure " out of respect for Edleston 's innocence , in contrast to the ( probably ) more sexually overt relations experienced at Harrow School . [ 27 ] The liaison , on the other hand , may well have been " pure " out of respect for Edleston 's innocence , in contrast to the ( probably ) more sexually overt relations experienced at Harrow School . [ 27 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 5-15 662-669 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , Byron spent three years at Trinity College , 5-33 662-684 Byron received his early formal education at Aberdeen Grammar School , and in August 1799 entered the school of Dr. William Glennie , in Dulwich . [ 17 ] Byron spent three years at Trinity College , engaging in sexual escapades , boxing , horse riding and gambling . [ 28 ] 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_byron 662-669 670-681 Byron spent three years at Trinity College , engaging in sexual escapades , boxing , horse riding and gambling . 662-684 662-684 Byron spent three years at Trinity College , engaging in sexual escapades , boxing , horse riding and gambling . [ 28 ] Byron spent three years at Trinity College , engaging in sexual escapades , boxing , horse riding and gambling . [ 28 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 670-681 682-684 engaging in sexual escapades , boxing , horse riding and gambling . [ 28 ] 662-684 662-684 Byron spent three years at Trinity College , engaging in sexual escapades , boxing , horse riding and gambling . [ 28 ] Byron spent three years at Trinity College , engaging in sexual escapades , boxing , horse riding and gambling . [ 28 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 685-688 689-700,718-728 Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , <*> and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , 685-744 685-744 Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , [ 28 ] and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , [ 28 ] and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_bio_byron 670-681 689-700,718-728 engaging in sexual escapades , boxing , horse riding and gambling . he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , <*> and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , 662-684 685-744 Byron spent three years at Trinity College , engaging in sexual escapades , boxing , horse riding and gambling . [ 28 ] Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , [ 28 ] and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_byron 689-700,718-728 701-709 he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , <*> and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , 685-744 685-744 Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , [ 28 ] and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , [ 28 ] and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 701-709 710-714 who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , 685-744 685-744 Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , [ 28 ] and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , [ 28 ] and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_byron 689-700,718-728 715-717 he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , <*> and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , [ 28 ] 685-744 685-744 Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , [ 28 ] and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , [ 28 ] and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_byron 718-728 729-744 and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . 685-744 685-744 Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , [ 28 ] and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . Also while at Cambridge he formed lifelong friendships with men such as John Cam Hobhouse , who initiated him into the Cambridge Whig Club , which endorsed liberal politics , [ 28 ] and Francis Hodgson , a Fellow at King 's College , with whom he corresponded on literary and other matters until the end of his life . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 1-2 3-5,21-29 Emperor Norton Joshua Abraham Norton <*> was a citizen of San Francisco , California , 1-2 3-45 Emperor Norton Joshua Abraham Norton ( c. 1818 – January 8 , 1880 ) , known as Emperor Norton , was a citizen of San Francisco , California , who in 1859 proclaimed himself " Norton I , Emperor of the United States " . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_bio_emperor 3-5,21-29 6-15 Joshua Abraham Norton <*> was a citizen of San Francisco , California , ( c. 1818 – January 8 , 1880 ) , 3-45 3-45 Joshua Abraham Norton ( c. 1818 – January 8 , 1880 ) , known as Emperor Norton , was a citizen of San Francisco , California , who in 1859 proclaimed himself " Norton I , Emperor of the United States " . Joshua Abraham Norton ( c. 1818 – January 8 , 1880 ) , known as Emperor Norton , was a citizen of San Francisco , California , who in 1859 proclaimed himself " Norton I , Emperor of the United States " . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 3-5,21-29 16-20 Joshua Abraham Norton <*> was a citizen of San Francisco , California , known as Emperor Norton , 3-45 3-45 Joshua Abraham Norton ( c. 1818 – January 8 , 1880 ) , known as Emperor Norton , was a citizen of San Francisco , California , who in 1859 proclaimed himself " Norton I , Emperor of the United States " . Joshua Abraham Norton ( c. 1818 – January 8 , 1880 ) , known as Emperor Norton , was a citizen of San Francisco , California , who in 1859 proclaimed himself " Norton I , Emperor of the United States " . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 21-29 30-45 was a citizen of San Francisco , California , who in 1859 proclaimed himself " Norton I , Emperor of the United States " . 3-45 3-45 Joshua Abraham Norton ( c. 1818 – January 8 , 1880 ) , known as Emperor Norton , was a citizen of San Francisco , California , who in 1859 proclaimed himself " Norton I , Emperor of the United States " . Joshua Abraham Norton ( c. 1818 – January 8 , 1880 ) , known as Emperor Norton , was a citizen of San Francisco , California , who in 1859 proclaimed himself " Norton I , Emperor of the United States " . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 3-5,21-29 46-50 Joshua Abraham Norton <*> was a citizen of San Francisco , California , He later expanded his pretense 3-45 46-62 Joshua Abraham Norton ( c. 1818 – January 8 , 1880 ) , known as Emperor Norton , was a citizen of San Francisco , California , who in 1859 proclaimed himself " Norton I , Emperor of the United States " . He later expanded his pretense by claiming to be " Protector of Mexico " as well . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 46-50 51-62 He later expanded his pretense by claiming to be " Protector of Mexico " as well . 46-62 46-62 He later expanded his pretense by claiming to be " Protector of Mexico " as well . He later expanded his pretense by claiming to be " Protector of Mexico " as well . 1<2 means means +GUM_bio_emperor 63-66 67-77 Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . 63-77 63-77 Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . 1>2 background background +GUM_bio_emperor 3-5,21-29 67-77 Joshua Abraham Norton <*> was a citizen of San Francisco , California , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . 3-45 63-77 Joshua Abraham Norton ( c. 1818 – January 8 , 1880 ) , known as Emperor Norton , was a citizen of San Francisco , California , who in 1859 proclaimed himself " Norton I , Emperor of the United States " . Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 67-77 78-95 Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . After the death of his mother in 1846 and his father in 1848 , he sailed west , 63-77 78-104 Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . After the death of his mother in 1846 and his father in 1848 , he sailed west , arriving in San Francisco possibly in November 1849 . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_emperor 67-77 96-104 Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . arriving in San Francisco possibly in November 1849 . 63-77 78-104 Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . After the death of his mother in 1846 and his father in 1848 , he sailed west , arriving in San Francisco possibly in November 1849 . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_emperor 67-77 105-113 Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . Norton initially made a living as a businessman , 63-77 105-123 Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . Norton initially made a living as a businessman , but he lost his fortune investing in Peruvian rice . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_emperor 105-113 114-118 Norton initially made a living as a businessman , but he lost his fortune 105-123 105-123 Norton initially made a living as a businessman , but he lost his fortune investing in Peruvian rice . Norton initially made a living as a businessman , but he lost his fortune investing in Peruvian rice . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_bio_emperor 114-118 119-123 but he lost his fortune investing in Peruvian rice . 105-123 105-123 Norton initially made a living as a businessman , but he lost his fortune investing in Peruvian rice . Norton initially made a living as a businessman , but he lost his fortune investing in Peruvian rice . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_bio_emperor 124-128 139-144 After he lost a lawsuit Norton 's public prominence faded . 124-144 124-144 After he lost a lawsuit in which he tried to void his rice contract , Norton 's public prominence faded . After he lost a lawsuit in which he tried to void his rice contract , Norton 's public prominence faded . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_bio_emperor 124-128 129-138 After he lost a lawsuit in which he tried to void his rice contract , 124-144 124-144 After he lost a lawsuit in which he tried to void his rice contract , Norton 's public prominence faded . After he lost a lawsuit in which he tried to void his rice contract , Norton 's public prominence faded . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 67-77 139-144 Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . Norton 's public prominence faded . 63-77 124-144 Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . After he lost a lawsuit in which he tried to void his rice contract , Norton 's public prominence faded . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_emperor 145-150 151-162 He reemerged in September 1859 , laying claim to the position of Emperor of the United States . 145-162 145-162 He reemerged in September 1859 , laying claim to the position of Emperor of the United States . He reemerged in September 1859 , laying claim to the position of Emperor of the United States . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_bio_emperor 67-77 151-162 Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . laying claim to the position of Emperor of the United States . 63-77 145-162 Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . He reemerged in September 1859 , laying claim to the position of Emperor of the United States . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_emperor 163-168 185-194 He had no political power , nevertheless , he was treated deferentially in San Francisco , 163-184 185-208 He had no political power , and his influence extended only so far as he was humored by those around him ; nevertheless , he was treated deferentially in San Francisco , and currency issued in his name was honored in the establishments he frequented . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_bio_emperor 163-168 169-175 He had no political power , and his influence extended only so far 163-184 163-184 He had no political power , and his influence extended only so far as he was humored by those around him ; He had no political power , and his influence extended only so far as he was humored by those around him ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 169-175 176-184 and his influence extended only so far as he was humored by those around him ; 163-184 163-184 He had no political power , and his influence extended only so far as he was humored by those around him ; He had no political power , and his influence extended only so far as he was humored by those around him ; 1<2 manner manner +GUM_bio_emperor 151-162 185-194 laying claim to the position of Emperor of the United States . nevertheless , he was treated deferentially in San Francisco , 145-162 185-208 He reemerged in September 1859 , laying claim to the position of Emperor of the United States . nevertheless , he was treated deferentially in San Francisco , and currency issued in his name was honored in the establishments he frequented . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 185-194 195-196,201-205 nevertheless , he was treated deferentially in San Francisco , and currency <*> was honored in the establishments 185-208 185-208 nevertheless , he was treated deferentially in San Francisco , and currency issued in his name was honored in the establishments he frequented . nevertheless , he was treated deferentially in San Francisco , and currency issued in his name was honored in the establishments he frequented . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_emperor 195-196,201-205 197-200 and currency <*> was honored in the establishments issued in his name 185-208 185-208 nevertheless , he was treated deferentially in San Francisco , and currency issued in his name was honored in the establishments he frequented . nevertheless , he was treated deferentially in San Francisco , and currency issued in his name was honored in the establishments he frequented . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_bio_emperor 201-205 206-208 was honored in the establishments he frequented . 185-208 185-208 nevertheless , he was treated deferentially in San Francisco , and currency issued in his name was honored in the establishments he frequented . nevertheless , he was treated deferentially in San Francisco , and currency issued in his name was honored in the establishments he frequented . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 209-216 217-232,242-245 Though some considered him insane or eccentric , citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order <*> and his numerous decrees 209-267 209-267 Though some considered him insane or eccentric , citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order that the United States Congress be dissolved by force and his numerous decrees calling for a bridge connecting San Francisco to Oakland , and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . Though some considered him insane or eccentric , citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order that the United States Congress be dissolved by force and his numerous decrees calling for a bridge connecting San Francisco to Oakland , and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_bio_emperor 67-77 217-232,242-245 Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order <*> and his numerous decrees 63-77 209-267 Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . Though some considered him insane or eccentric , citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order that the United States Congress be dissolved by force and his numerous decrees calling for a bridge connecting San Francisco to Oakland , and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_emperor 217-232,242-245 233-241 citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order <*> and his numerous decrees that the United States Congress be dissolved by force 209-267 209-267 Though some considered him insane or eccentric , citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order that the United States Congress be dissolved by force and his numerous decrees calling for a bridge connecting San Francisco to Oakland , and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . Though some considered him insane or eccentric , citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order that the United States Congress be dissolved by force and his numerous decrees calling for a bridge connecting San Francisco to Oakland , and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 242-245 246-249,256-267 and his numerous decrees calling for a bridge <*> and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . 209-267 209-267 Though some considered him insane or eccentric , citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order that the United States Congress be dissolved by force and his numerous decrees calling for a bridge connecting San Francisco to Oakland , and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . Though some considered him insane or eccentric , citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order that the United States Congress be dissolved by force and his numerous decrees calling for a bridge connecting San Francisco to Oakland , and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_bio_emperor 246-249,256-267 250-255 calling for a bridge <*> and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . connecting San Francisco to Oakland , 209-267 209-267 Though some considered him insane or eccentric , citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order that the United States Congress be dissolved by force and his numerous decrees calling for a bridge connecting San Francisco to Oakland , and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . Though some considered him insane or eccentric , citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order that the United States Congress be dissolved by force and his numerous decrees calling for a bridge connecting San Francisco to Oakland , and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 268-292 293-297 Long after his death , similar structures were built in the form of the San Francisco – Oakland Bay Bridge and the Transbay Tube , and there have been campaigns 268-308 268-308 Long after his death , similar structures were built in the form of the San Francisco – Oakland Bay Bridge and the Transbay Tube , and there have been campaigns to rename the bridge " The Emperor Norton Bridge " . Long after his death , similar structures were built in the form of the San Francisco – Oakland Bay Bridge and the Transbay Tube , and there have been campaigns to rename the bridge " The Emperor Norton Bridge " . 1>2 background background +GUM_bio_emperor 217-232,242-245 293-297 citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order <*> and his numerous decrees and there have been campaigns 209-267 268-308 Though some considered him insane or eccentric , citizens of San Francisco celebrated his regal presence and his proclamations , such as his order that the United States Congress be dissolved by force and his numerous decrees calling for a bridge connecting San Francisco to Oakland , and a corresponding tunnel to be built under San Francisco Bay . Long after his death , similar structures were built in the form of the San Francisco – Oakland Bay Bridge and the Transbay Tube , and there have been campaigns to rename the bridge " The Emperor Norton Bridge " . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_emperor 293-297 298-308 and there have been campaigns to rename the bridge " The Emperor Norton Bridge " . 268-308 268-308 Long after his death , similar structures were built in the form of the San Francisco – Oakland Bay Bridge and the Transbay Tube , and there have been campaigns to rename the bridge " The Emperor Norton Bridge " . Long after his death , similar structures were built in the form of the San Francisco – Oakland Bay Bridge and the Transbay Tube , and there have been campaigns to rename the bridge " The Emperor Norton Bridge " . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_bio_emperor 67-77 309-323,328 Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont <*> streets 63-77 309-338 Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont ( now Grant ) streets and died before he could be given medical treatment . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_emperor 309-323,328 324-327 On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont <*> streets ( now Grant ) 309-338 309-338 On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont ( now Grant ) streets and died before he could be given medical treatment . On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont ( now Grant ) streets and died before he could be given medical treatment . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 309-323,328 329-330 On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont <*> streets and died 309-338 309-338 On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont ( now Grant ) streets and died before he could be given medical treatment . On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont ( now Grant ) streets and died before he could be given medical treatment . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_emperor 329-330 331-338 and died before he could be given medical treatment . 309-338 309-338 On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont ( now Grant ) streets and died before he could be given medical treatment . On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont ( now Grant ) streets and died before he could be given medical treatment . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_bio_emperor 309-323,328 339-347 On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont <*> streets Nearly 30,000 people packed the streets of San Francisco 309-338 339-355 On January 8 , 1880 , Norton collapsed at the corner of California and Dupont ( now Grant ) streets and died before he could be given medical treatment . Nearly 30,000 people packed the streets of San Francisco to pay him homage at his funeral . 1<2 result result +GUM_bio_emperor 339-347 348-355 Nearly 30,000 people packed the streets of San Francisco to pay him homage at his funeral . 339-355 339-355 Nearly 30,000 people packed the streets of San Francisco to pay him homage at his funeral . Nearly 30,000 people packed the streets of San Francisco to pay him homage at his funeral . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_bio_emperor 67-77 356-390 Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . Norton has been immortalized as the basis of characters in the literature of writers Mark Twain , Robert Louis Stevenson , Christopher Moore , Morris and Goscinny , Selma Lagerlöf , and Neil Gaiman . 63-77 356-390 Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . Norton has been immortalized as the basis of characters in the literature of writers Mark Twain , Robert Louis Stevenson , Christopher Moore , Morris and Goscinny , Selma Lagerlöf , and Neil Gaiman . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_emperor 67-77 391-405 Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . Norton I , Emperor of the United States , photograph , c. 1871 – 72 63-77 391-405 Born in England , Norton spent most of his early life in South Africa . Norton I , Emperor of the United States , photograph , c. 1871 – 72 1<2 background background +GUM_bio_emperor 406-408 460-470 Declares himself emperor and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , 406-408 447-480 Declares himself emperor On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_bio_emperor 409-421 460-470 Emperor Joshua Norton , in full military regalia , circa 1880 or earlier and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , 409-421 447-480 Emperor Joshua Norton , in full military regalia , circa 1880 or earlier On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : 1>2 background background +GUM_bio_emperor 422-446 460-470 By 1859 , Norton had become completely disgruntled with what he considered the inadequacies of the legal and political structures of the United States . and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , 422-446 447-480 By 1859 , Norton had become completely disgruntled with what he considered the inadequacies of the legal and political structures of the United States . On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : 1>2 cause cause +GUM_bio_emperor 447-459 460-470 On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , 447-480 447-480 On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_bio_emperor 3-5,21-29 460-470 Joshua Abraham Norton <*> was a citizen of San Francisco , California , and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , 3-45 447-480 Joshua Abraham Norton ( c. 1818 – January 8 , 1880 ) , known as Emperor Norton , was a citizen of San Francisco , California , who in 1859 proclaimed himself " Norton I , Emperor of the United States " . On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 460-470 471-480 and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : 447-480 447-480 On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 460-470 481-538 and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , At the peremptory request and desire of a large majority of the citizens of these United States , I , Joshua Norton , formerly of Algoa Bay , Cape of Good Hope , and now for the last 9 years and 10 months past of S.F. , Cal. , declare and proclaim myself Emperor of these U.S. ; 447-480 481-538 On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : At the peremptory request and desire of a large majority of the citizens of these United States , I , Joshua Norton , formerly of Algoa Bay , Cape of Good Hope , and now for the last 9 years and 10 months past of S.F. , Cal. , declare and proclaim myself Emperor of these U.S. ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 539-581 582-595 and in virtue of the authority thereby in me vested , do hereby order and direct the representatives of the different States of the Union to assemble in Musical Hall , of this city , on the 1st day of Feb. next , then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union 539-626 539-626 and in virtue of the authority thereby in me vested , do hereby order and direct the representatives of the different States of the Union to assemble in Musical Hall , of this city , on the 1st day of Feb. next , then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union as may ameliorate the evils under which the country is laboring , and thereby cause confidence to exist , both at home and abroad , in our stability and integrity . and in virtue of the authority thereby in me vested , do hereby order and direct the representatives of the different States of the Union to assemble in Musical Hall , of this city , on the 1st day of Feb. next , then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union as may ameliorate the evils under which the country is laboring , and thereby cause confidence to exist , both at home and abroad , in our stability and integrity . 1>2 purpose purpose +GUM_bio_emperor 481-538 582-595 At the peremptory request and desire of a large majority of the citizens of these United States , I , Joshua Norton , formerly of Algoa Bay , Cape of Good Hope , and now for the last 9 years and 10 months past of S.F. , Cal. , declare and proclaim myself Emperor of these U.S. ; then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union 481-538 539-626 At the peremptory request and desire of a large majority of the citizens of these United States , I , Joshua Norton , formerly of Algoa Bay , Cape of Good Hope , and now for the last 9 years and 10 months past of S.F. , Cal. , declare and proclaim myself Emperor of these U.S. ; and in virtue of the authority thereby in me vested , do hereby order and direct the representatives of the different States of the Union to assemble in Musical Hall , of this city , on the 1st day of Feb. next , then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union as may ameliorate the evils under which the country is laboring , and thereby cause confidence to exist , both at home and abroad , in our stability and integrity . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_emperor 582-595 596-600 then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union as may ameliorate the evils 539-626 539-626 and in virtue of the authority thereby in me vested , do hereby order and direct the representatives of the different States of the Union to assemble in Musical Hall , of this city , on the 1st day of Feb. next , then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union as may ameliorate the evils under which the country is laboring , and thereby cause confidence to exist , both at home and abroad , in our stability and integrity . and in virtue of the authority thereby in me vested , do hereby order and direct the representatives of the different States of the Union to assemble in Musical Hall , of this city , on the 1st day of Feb. next , then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union as may ameliorate the evils under which the country is laboring , and thereby cause confidence to exist , both at home and abroad , in our stability and integrity . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_bio_emperor 596-600 601-607 as may ameliorate the evils under which the country is laboring , 539-626 539-626 and in virtue of the authority thereby in me vested , do hereby order and direct the representatives of the different States of the Union to assemble in Musical Hall , of this city , on the 1st day of Feb. next , then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union as may ameliorate the evils under which the country is laboring , and thereby cause confidence to exist , both at home and abroad , in our stability and integrity . and in virtue of the authority thereby in me vested , do hereby order and direct the representatives of the different States of the Union to assemble in Musical Hall , of this city , on the 1st day of Feb. next , then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union as may ameliorate the evils under which the country is laboring , and thereby cause confidence to exist , both at home and abroad , in our stability and integrity . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 582-595 608-626 then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union and thereby cause confidence to exist , both at home and abroad , in our stability and integrity . 539-626 539-626 and in virtue of the authority thereby in me vested , do hereby order and direct the representatives of the different States of the Union to assemble in Musical Hall , of this city , on the 1st day of Feb. next , then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union as may ameliorate the evils under which the country is laboring , and thereby cause confidence to exist , both at home and abroad , in our stability and integrity . and in virtue of the authority thereby in me vested , do hereby order and direct the representatives of the different States of the Union to assemble in Musical Hall , of this city , on the 1st day of Feb. next , then and there to make such alterations in the existing laws of the Union as may ameliorate the evils under which the country is laboring , and thereby cause confidence to exist , both at home and abroad , in our stability and integrity . 1<2 result result +GUM_bio_emperor 481-538 627-636 At the peremptory request and desire of a large majority of the citizens of these United States , I , Joshua Norton , formerly of Algoa Bay , Cape of Good Hope , and now for the last 9 years and 10 months past of S.F. , Cal. , declare and proclaim myself Emperor of these U.S. ; — NORTON I , Emperor of the United States . 481-538 627-636 At the peremptory request and desire of a large majority of the citizens of these United States , I , Joshua Norton , formerly of Algoa Bay , Cape of Good Hope , and now for the last 9 years and 10 months past of S.F. , Cal. , declare and proclaim myself Emperor of these U.S. ; — NORTON I , Emperor of the United States . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_bio_emperor 460-470 637-653 and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , The announcement was first reprinted for humorous effect by the editor of the San Francisco Bulletin . 447-480 637-653 On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : The announcement was first reprinted for humorous effect by the editor of the San Francisco Bulletin . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 460-470 654-666 and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , Norton would later add " Protector of Mexico " to this title . 447-480 654-666 On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : Norton would later add " Protector of Mexico " to this title . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_emperor 460-470 667-679 and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , Thus commenced his unprecedented and whimsical 21-year " reign " over America . 447-480 667-679 On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : Thus commenced his unprecedented and whimsical 21-year " reign " over America . 1<2 result result +GUM_bio_emperor 680-685 686-702 One of Norton 's undated proclamations In his self-appointed role of emperor , Norton issued numerous decrees on matters of the state . 680-685 686-702 One of Norton 's undated proclamations In his self-appointed role of emperor , Norton issued numerous decrees on matters of the state . 1>2 evidence evidence +GUM_bio_emperor 460-470 686-702 and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , In his self-appointed role of emperor , Norton issued numerous decrees on matters of the state . 447-480 686-702 On September 17 , 1859 , he took matters into his own hands and distributed letters to the various newspapers in the city , proclaiming himself " Emperor of these United States " : In his self-appointed role of emperor , Norton issued numerous decrees on matters of the state . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_emperor 703-710 711-719 After assuming absolute control over the country , he saw no further need for a legislature , 703-737 703-737 After assuming absolute control over the country , he saw no further need for a legislature , and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree formally abolishing the United States Congress . After assuming absolute control over the country , he saw no further need for a legislature , and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree formally abolishing the United States Congress . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_bio_emperor 711-719 720-730 he saw no further need for a legislature , and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree 703-737 703-737 After assuming absolute control over the country , he saw no further need for a legislature , and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree formally abolishing the United States Congress . After assuming absolute control over the country , he saw no further need for a legislature , and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree formally abolishing the United States Congress . 1>2 motivation motivation +GUM_bio_emperor 686-702 720-730 In his self-appointed role of emperor , Norton issued numerous decrees on matters of the state . and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree 686-702 703-737 In his self-appointed role of emperor , Norton issued numerous decrees on matters of the state . After assuming absolute control over the country , he saw no further need for a legislature , and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree formally abolishing the United States Congress . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 720-730 731-737 and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree formally abolishing the United States Congress . 703-737 703-737 After assuming absolute control over the country , he saw no further need for a legislature , and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree formally abolishing the United States Congress . After assuming absolute control over the country , he saw no further need for a legislature , and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree formally abolishing the United States Congress . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 738-743 744-758 In it , Norton observed : ... fraud and corruption prevent a fair and proper expression of the public voice ; 738-743 744-758 In it , Norton observed : ... fraud and corruption prevent a fair and proper expression of the public voice ; 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_bio_emperor 720-730 744-758 and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree ... fraud and corruption prevent a fair and proper expression of the public voice ; 703-737 744-758 After assuming absolute control over the country , he saw no further need for a legislature , and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree formally abolishing the United States Congress . ... fraud and corruption prevent a fair and proper expression of the public voice ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 744-758 759-768 ... fraud and corruption prevent a fair and proper expression of the public voice ; that open violation of the laws are constantly occurring , 744-758 759-782 ... fraud and corruption prevent a fair and proper expression of the public voice ; that open violation of the laws are constantly occurring , caused by mobs , parties , factions and undue influence of political sects ; 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_emperor 759-768 769-782 that open violation of the laws are constantly occurring , caused by mobs , parties , factions and undue influence of political sects ; 759-782 759-782 that open violation of the laws are constantly occurring , caused by mobs , parties , factions and undue influence of political sects ; that open violation of the laws are constantly occurring , caused by mobs , parties , factions and undue influence of political sects ; 1<2 cause cause +GUM_bio_emperor 744-758 783-793 ... fraud and corruption prevent a fair and proper expression of the public voice ; that the citizen has not that protection of person and property 744-758 783-798 ... fraud and corruption prevent a fair and proper expression of the public voice ; that the citizen has not that protection of person and property which he is entitled . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_emperor 783-793 794-798 that the citizen has not that protection of person and property which he is entitled . 783-798 783-798 that the citizen has not that protection of person and property which he is entitled . that the citizen has not that protection of person and property which he is entitled . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 720-730 799-816 and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree Norton ordered all interested parties to assemble at Platt 's Music Hall in San Francisco in February 1860 703-737 799-825 After assuming absolute control over the country , he saw no further need for a legislature , and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree formally abolishing the United States Congress . Norton ordered all interested parties to assemble at Platt 's Music Hall in San Francisco in February 1860 to " remedy the evil complained of " . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_bio_emperor 799-816 817-821 Norton ordered all interested parties to assemble at Platt 's Music Hall in San Francisco in February 1860 to " remedy the evil 799-825 799-825 Norton ordered all interested parties to assemble at Platt 's Music Hall in San Francisco in February 1860 to " remedy the evil complained of " . Norton ordered all interested parties to assemble at Platt 's Music Hall in San Francisco in February 1860 to " remedy the evil complained of " . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_bio_emperor 817-821 822-825 to " remedy the evil complained of " . 799-825 799-825 Norton ordered all interested parties to assemble at Platt 's Music Hall in San Francisco in February 1860 to " remedy the evil complained of " . Norton ordered all interested parties to assemble at Platt 's Music Hall in San Francisco in February 1860 to " remedy the evil complained of " . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 826-847 907-947 In an imperial decree the following month , Norton summoned the Army to depose the elected officials of the U.S. Congress : NOW , THEREFORE , we do hereby Order and Direct Major-General Scott , the Command-in-Chief of our Armies , immediately upon receipt of this , our Decree , to proceed with a suitable force and clear the Halls of Congress . 826-847 907-947 In an imperial decree the following month , Norton summoned the Army to depose the elected officials of the U.S. Congress : NOW , THEREFORE , we do hereby Order and Direct Major-General Scott , the Command-in-Chief of our Armies , immediately upon receipt of this , our Decree , to proceed with a suitable force and clear the Halls of Congress . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_bio_emperor 848-853,859-879 907-947 WHEREAS , a body of men <*> are now in session in Washington City , in violation of our Imperial edict of the 12th of October last , NOW , THEREFORE , we do hereby Order and Direct Major-General Scott , the Command-in-Chief of our Armies , immediately upon receipt of this , our Decree , to proceed with a suitable force and clear the Halls of Congress . 848-885 907-947 WHEREAS , a body of men calling themselves the National Congress are now in session in Washington City , in violation of our Imperial edict of the 12th of October last , declaring the said Congress abolished ; NOW , THEREFORE , we do hereby Order and Direct Major-General Scott , the Command-in-Chief of our Armies , immediately upon receipt of this , our Decree , to proceed with a suitable force and clear the Halls of Congress . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_bio_emperor 848-853,859-879 854-858 WHEREAS , a body of men <*> are now in session in Washington City , in violation of our Imperial edict of the 12th of October last , calling themselves the National Congress 848-885 848-885 WHEREAS , a body of men calling themselves the National Congress are now in session in Washington City , in violation of our Imperial edict of the 12th of October last , declaring the said Congress abolished ; WHEREAS , a body of men calling themselves the National Congress are now in session in Washington City , in violation of our Imperial edict of the 12th of October last , declaring the said Congress abolished ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 859-879 880-885 are now in session in Washington City , in violation of our Imperial edict of the 12th of October last , declaring the said Congress abolished ; 848-885 848-885 WHEREAS , a body of men calling themselves the National Congress are now in session in Washington City , in violation of our Imperial edict of the 12th of October last , declaring the said Congress abolished ; WHEREAS , a body of men calling themselves the National Congress are now in session in Washington City , in violation of our Imperial edict of the 12th of October last , declaring the said Congress abolished ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_bio_emperor 848-853,859-879 886-906 WHEREAS , a body of men <*> are now in session in Washington City , in violation of our Imperial edict of the 12th of October last , WHEREAS , it is necessary for the repose of our Empire that the said decree should be strictly complied with ; 848-885 886-906 WHEREAS , a body of men calling themselves the National Congress are now in session in Washington City , in violation of our Imperial edict of the 12th of October last , declaring the said Congress abolished ; WHEREAS , it is necessary for the repose of our Empire that the said decree should be strictly complied with ; 1<2 joint joint +GUM_bio_emperor 720-730 907-947 and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree NOW , THEREFORE , we do hereby Order and Direct Major-General Scott , the Command-in-Chief of our Armies , immediately upon receipt of this , our Decree , to proceed with a suitable force and clear the Halls of Congress . 703-737 907-947 After assuming absolute control over the country , he saw no further need for a legislature , and on October 12 , 1859 , he issued a decree formally abolishing the United States Congress . NOW , THEREFORE , we do hereby Order and Direct Major-General Scott , the Command-in-Chief of our Armies , immediately upon receipt of this , our Decree , to proceed with a suitable force and clear the Halls of Congress . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_conversation_grounded 1-6 7-8 What 'd you do Sabrina ? Nothing . 1-6 7-8 What 'd you do Sabrina ? Nothing . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 9-18 Nothing . I left the phone in my bedroom last night , 7-8 9-27 Nothing . I left the phone in my bedroom last night , and so I 'm grounded from the phone . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 9-18 19-27 I left the phone in my bedroom last night , and so I 'm grounded from the phone . 9-27 9-27 I left the phone in my bedroom last night , and so I 'm grounded from the phone . I left the phone in my bedroom last night , and so I 'm grounded from the phone . 1<2 result result +GUM_conversation_grounded 9-18 28-32 I left the phone in my bedroom last night , It was an accident . 9-27 28-32 I left the phone in my bedroom last night , and so I 'm grounded from the phone . It was an accident . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 33-39 40-45 You guys are always in trouble . What 's up with that ? 33-39 40-45 You guys are always in trouble . What 's up with that ? 1>2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 40-45 46-50 What 's up with that ? Mom 's a bitch . 40-45 46-50 What 's up with that ? Mom 's a bitch . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 46-50 Nothing . Mom 's a bitch . 7-8 46-50 Nothing . Mom 's a bitch . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 51-57 Nothing . Get your feet off of there . 7-8 51-57 Nothing . Get your feet off of there . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 51-57 58-64 Get your feet off of there . Get your feet off of there . 51-57 58-64 Get your feet off of there . Get your feet off of there . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 65-68 70-74 You 're so stupid I spent the night . 65-74 65-74 You 're so stupid thinking I spent the night . You 're so stupid thinking I spent the night . 1>2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 69 70-74 thinking I spent the night . 65-74 65-74 You 're so stupid thinking I spent the night . You 're so stupid thinking I spent the night . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 70-74 75-79 I spent the night . I came home last night 65-74 75-83 You 're so stupid thinking I spent the night . I came home last night and told you . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 75-79 Nothing . I came home last night 7-8 75-83 Nothing . I came home last night and told you . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 75-79 80-83 I came home last night and told you . 75-83 75-83 I came home last night and told you . I came home last night and told you . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_conversation_grounded 75-79 84-90 I came home last night Kendra , just let it go . 75-83 84-90 I came home last night and told you . Kendra , just let it go . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 84-90 91-92 Kendra , just let it go . You — 84-90 91-92 Kendra , just let it go . You — 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 84-90 93-94 Kendra , just let it go . No , 84-90 93-99 Kendra , just let it go . No , because she does n't — 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_conversation_grounded 93-94 95-99 No , because she does n't — 93-99 93-99 No , because she does n't — No , because she does n't — 1<2 justify justify +GUM_conversation_grounded 75-79 100,105-106 I came home last night All <*> was — 75-83 100-106 I came home last night and told you . All you said last night was — 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_conversation_grounded 100,105-106 101-104 All <*> was — you said last night 100-106 100-106 All you said last night was — All you said last night was — 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 107-108 109-116 She thinks I spent the night in my jeans — 107-116 107-116 She thinks I spent the night in my jeans — She thinks I spent the night in my jeans — 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 109-116 157-164 I spent the night in my jeans — But I did n't spend the night , 107-116 157-171 She thinks I spent the night in my jeans — But I did n't spend the night , and I do n't deserve this . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_conversation_grounded 117-123 157-164 Kim was n't staying the night . But I did n't spend the night , 117-123 157-171 Kim was n't staying the night . But I did n't spend the night , and I do n't deserve this . 1>2 evidence evidence +GUM_conversation_grounded 124-130 138-142 If I did spend the night , I would give up , 124-156 124-156 If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , I would give up , cause then I would n't care , cause I knew I deserved it . If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , I would give up , cause then I would n't care , cause I knew I deserved it . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_conversation_grounded 124-130 131-137 If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , 124-156 124-156 If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , I would give up , cause then I would n't care , cause I knew I deserved it . If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , I would give up , cause then I would n't care , cause I knew I deserved it . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 117-123 138-142 Kim was n't staying the night . I would give up , 117-123 124-156 Kim was n't staying the night . If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , I would give up , cause then I would n't care , cause I knew I deserved it . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 138-142 143-149 I would give up , cause then I would n't care , 124-156 124-156 If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , I would give up , cause then I would n't care , cause I knew I deserved it . If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , I would give up , cause then I would n't care , cause I knew I deserved it . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_conversation_grounded 150-152 153-156 cause I knew I deserved it . 124-156 124-156 If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , I would give up , cause then I would n't care , cause I knew I deserved it . If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , I would give up , cause then I would n't care , cause I knew I deserved it . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 143-149 153-156 cause then I would n't care , I deserved it . 124-156 124-156 If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , I would give up , cause then I would n't care , cause I knew I deserved it . If I did spend the night , and I was trying to lie , I would give up , cause then I would n't care , cause I knew I deserved it . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_conversation_grounded 75-79 157-164 I came home last night But I did n't spend the night , 75-83 157-171 I came home last night and told you . But I did n't spend the night , and I do n't deserve this . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 157-164 165-171 But I did n't spend the night , and I do n't deserve this . 157-171 157-171 But I did n't spend the night , and I do n't deserve this . But I did n't spend the night , and I do n't deserve this . 1<2 result result +GUM_conversation_grounded 157-164 172-178 But I did n't spend the night , Kim could n't spend the night , 157-171 172-182 But I did n't spend the night , and I do n't deserve this . Kim could n't spend the night , I told you . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_conversation_grounded 172-178 179-182 Kim could n't spend the night , I told you . 172-182 172-182 Kim could n't spend the night , I told you . Kim could n't spend the night , I told you . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 183-185 190-198 She could , I wanted to stay at the game longer . 183-198 183-198 She could , but then af- — I wanted to stay at the game longer . She could , but then af- — I wanted to stay at the game longer . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_conversation_grounded 186-189 190-198 but then af- — I wanted to stay at the game longer . 183-198 183-198 She could , but then af- — I wanted to stay at the game longer . She could , but then af- — I wanted to stay at the game longer . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 190-198 214-219 I wanted to stay at the game longer . no let 's stay longer . 183-198 199-219 She could , but then af- — I wanted to stay at the game longer . And her mom wanted to take her home early , and I 'm like , no let 's stay longer . 1>2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 190-198 199-208 I wanted to stay at the game longer . And her mom wanted to take her home early , 183-198 199-219 She could , but then af- — I wanted to stay at the game longer . And her mom wanted to take her home early , and I 'm like , no let 's stay longer . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 209-213 214-219 and I 'm like , no let 's stay longer . 199-219 199-219 And her mom wanted to take her home early , and I 'm like , no let 's stay longer . And her mom wanted to take her home early , and I 'm like , no let 's stay longer . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 172-178 214-219 Kim could n't spend the night , no let 's stay longer . 172-182 199-219 Kim could n't spend the night , I told you . And her mom wanted to take her home early , and I 'm like , no let 's stay longer . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 214-219 220-227 no let 's stay longer . But her mom would n't let her . 199-219 220-227 And her mom wanted to take her home early , and I 'm like , no let 's stay longer . But her mom would n't let her . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_conversation_grounded 220-227 228-232 But her mom would n't let her . And so she went home 220-227 228-253 But her mom would n't let her . And so she went home and , I was like , I 'll call you when I get home , and then you come over . 1<2 result result +GUM_conversation_grounded 233-238 239-242 and , I was like , I 'll call you 228-253 228-253 And so she went home and , I was like , I 'll call you when I get home , and then you come over . And so she went home and , I was like , I 'll call you when I get home , and then you come over . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 214-219 239-242 no let 's stay longer . I 'll call you 199-219 228-253 And her mom wanted to take her home early , and I 'm like , no let 's stay longer . And so she went home and , I was like , I 'll call you when I get home , and then you come over . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_conversation_grounded 239-242 243-247 I 'll call you when I get home , 228-253 228-253 And so she went home and , I was like , I 'll call you when I get home , and then you come over . And so she went home and , I was like , I 'll call you when I get home , and then you come over . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_conversation_grounded 239-242 248-253 I 'll call you and then you come over . 228-253 228-253 And so she went home and , I was like , I 'll call you when I get home , and then you come over . And so she went home and , I was like , I 'll call you when I get home , and then you come over . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_conversation_grounded 254-257 258-263 And she goes , no just spend the night . 254-263 254-263 And she goes , no just spend the night . And she goes , no just spend the night . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 214-219 258-263 no let 's stay longer . no just spend the night . 199-219 254-263 And her mom wanted to take her home early , and I 'm like , no let 's stay longer . And she goes , no just spend the night . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_conversation_grounded 258-263 264-271 no just spend the night . We 'll do this some other weekend . 254-263 264-271 And she goes , no just spend the night . We 'll do this some other weekend . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 258-263 272-274 no just spend the night . Okay cool , 254-263 272-284 And she goes , no just spend the night . Okay cool , cause she had to go bowling in the morning . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 272-274 275-284 Okay cool , cause she had to go bowling in the morning . 272-284 272-284 Okay cool , cause she had to go bowling in the morning . Okay cool , cause she had to go bowling in the morning . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_conversation_grounded 172-178 285-290 Kim could n't spend the night , Talk to Melanie 's mom . 172-182 285-290 Kim could n't spend the night , I told you . Talk to Melanie 's mom . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 285-290 291-295 Talk to Melanie 's mom . Her mom would know . 285-290 291-295 Talk to Melanie 's mom . Her mom would know . 1<2 motivation motivation +GUM_conversation_grounded 291-295 296-302 Her mom would know . I 'll have Melanie call you . 291-295 296-302 Her mom would know . I 'll have Melanie call you . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 296-302 303-304 I 'll have Melanie call you . Oh . 296-302 303-304 I 'll have Melanie call you . Oh . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 296-302 305-309 I 'll have Melanie call you . Her mom call you , 296-302 305-309 I 'll have Melanie call you . Her mom call you , 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 305-309 310-313 Her mom call you , Right , right . 305-309 310-313 Her mom call you , Right , right . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 291-295 314-319 Her mom would know . Her mom would n't lie . 291-295 314-319 Her mom would know . Her mom would n't lie . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 285-290 320-325 Talk to Melanie 's mom . Right , Melanie will call me 285-290 320-330 Talk to Melanie 's mom . Right , Melanie will call me to confirm your lie . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 320-325 326-330 Right , Melanie will call me to confirm your lie . 320-330 320-330 Right , Melanie will call me to confirm your lie . Right , Melanie will call me to confirm your lie . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_conversation_grounded 331-332 333-334 Melanie lies but — 331-334 331-334 Melanie lies but — Melanie lies but — 1>2 concession concession +GUM_conversation_grounded 320-325 333-334 Right , Melanie will call me but — 320-330 331-334 Right , Melanie will call me to confirm your lie . Melanie lies but — 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_conversation_grounded 333-334 335-343 but — You 'll get a hold of her first . 331-334 335-343 Melanie lies but — You 'll get a hold of her first . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_conversation_grounded 344-345 346-349 I know how that works . 344-349 344-349 I know how that works . I know how that works . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 335-343 346-349 You 'll get a hold of her first . how that works . 335-343 344-349 You 'll get a hold of her first . I know how that works . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 285-290 350-355 Talk to Melanie 's mom . No , Melanie 's mom . 285-290 350-355 Talk to Melanie 's mom . No , Melanie 's mom . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 356-357 358-364 I thought Melanie did n't have a phone . 356-364 356-364 I thought Melanie did n't have a phone . I thought Melanie did n't have a phone . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 350-355 358-364 No , Melanie 's mom . Melanie did n't have a phone . 350-355 356-364 No , Melanie 's mom . I thought Melanie did n't have a phone . 1<2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 358-364 365-374 Melanie did n't have a phone . But I 'm supposed to call Melanie 's mom . 356-364 365-374 I thought Melanie did n't have a phone . But I 'm supposed to call Melanie 's mom . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_conversation_grounded 358-364 375-385 Melanie did n't have a phone . I did n't want you to have her phone number . 356-364 375-385 I thought Melanie did n't have a phone . I did n't want you to have her phone number . 1<2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 375-385 386-390 I did n't want you to have her phone number . Yeah , another lie . 375-385 386-390 I did n't want you to have her phone number . Yeah , another lie . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 391-392 393-399 Remember ? That was a long time ago . 391-392 393-399 Remember ? That was a long time ago . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 386-390 393-399 Yeah , another lie . That was a long time ago . 386-390 393-399 Yeah , another lie . That was a long time ago . 1<2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 400-406 407-416 Now I 'm supposed to re- — A- and I 'm supposed to trust you every time 400-406 407-421 Now I 'm supposed to re- — A- and I 'm supposed to trust you every time you tell the truth . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 407-416 429-435 A- and I 'm supposed to trust you every time when you 're telling the truth ? 407-421 422-435 A- and I 'm supposed to trust you every time you tell the truth . But how am I supposed to know when you 're telling the truth ? 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_conversation_grounded 407-416 417-421 A- and I 'm supposed to trust you every time you tell the truth . 407-421 407-421 A- and I 'm supposed to trust you every time you tell the truth . A- and I 'm supposed to trust you every time you tell the truth . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 422-428 429-435 But how am I supposed to know when you 're telling the truth ? 422-435 422-435 But how am I supposed to know when you 're telling the truth ? But how am I supposed to know when you 're telling the truth ? 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 429-435 436-440 when you 're telling the truth ? That was a joke . 422-435 436-440 But how am I supposed to know when you 're telling the truth ? That was a joke . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 386-390 436-440 Yeah , another lie . That was a joke . 386-390 436-440 Yeah , another lie . That was a joke . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 436-440 441-445 That was a joke . That was a joke . 436-440 441-445 That was a joke . That was a joke . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 446-447 464 Yeah , No 446-463 464-471 Yeah , and I 'm supposed to read your mind and know what you 're joking about . No but , it was a joke . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 448-455 456-463 and I 'm supposed to read your mind and know what you 're joking about . 446-463 446-463 Yeah , and I 'm supposed to read your mind and know what you 're joking about . Yeah , and I 'm supposed to read your mind and know what you 're joking about . 1>2 means means +GUM_conversation_grounded 446-447 456-463 Yeah , and know what you 're joking about . 446-463 446-463 Yeah , and I 'm supposed to read your mind and know what you 're joking about . Yeah , and I 'm supposed to read your mind and know what you 're joking about . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 464 465-471 No but , it was a joke . 464-471 464-471 No but , it was a joke . No but , it was a joke . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_conversation_grounded 436-440 465-471 That was a joke . but , it was a joke . 436-440 464-471 That was a joke . No but , it was a joke . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 472-476 505-510 You know Kendra , y- You lose th- complete trust . 472-498 505-510 You know Kendra , y- — I do n't know how many times I got ta tell you , once you lie , once you lie — You lose th- complete trust . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 477-481 482-490 — I do n't know how many times I got ta tell you , 472-498 472-498 You know Kendra , y- — I do n't know how many times I got ta tell you , once you lie , once you lie — You know Kendra , y- — I do n't know how many times I got ta tell you , once you lie , once you lie — 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_conversation_grounded 482-490 505-510 how many times I got ta tell you , You lose th- complete trust . 472-498 505-510 You know Kendra , y- — I do n't know how many times I got ta tell you , once you lie , once you lie — You lose th- complete trust . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 491-494 505-510 once you lie , You lose th- complete trust . 472-498 505-510 You know Kendra , y- — I do n't know how many times I got ta tell you , once you lie , once you lie — You lose th- complete trust . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_conversation_grounded 491-494 495-498 once you lie , once you lie — 472-498 472-498 You know Kendra , y- — I do n't know how many times I got ta tell you , once you lie , once you lie — You know Kendra , y- — I do n't know how many times I got ta tell you , once you lie , once you lie — 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 499-504 505-510 Are they having a carwash ? You lose th- complete trust . 499-504 505-510 Are they having a carwash ? You lose th- complete trust . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 386-390 505-510 Yeah , another lie . You lose th- complete trust . 386-390 505-510 Yeah , another lie . You lose th- complete trust . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 511-512 Nothing . No . 7-8 511-512 Nothing . No . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 511-512 513-516 No . Yeah they are . 511-512 513-516 No . Yeah they are . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_conversation_grounded 513-516 517-524 Yeah they are . Yeah that 's what it is a — 513-516 517-524 Yeah they are . Yeah that 's what it is a — 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 513-516 525-531 Yeah they are . We should have a carwash there . 513-516 525-531 Yeah they are . We should have a carwash there . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 525-531 532-536 We should have a carwash there . Carwash and a bakesale . 525-531 532-536 We should have a carwash there . Carwash and a bakesale . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 513-516 537-544 Yeah they are . They 're not getting any people though . 513-516 537-544 Yeah they are . They 're not getting any people though . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 537-544 545-546 They 're not getting any people though . Mm . 537-544 545-546 They 're not getting any people though . Mm . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 537-544 547-549 They 're not getting any people though . Hot out . 537-544 547-549 They 're not getting any people though . Hot out . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_conversation_grounded 550-556 573-577 What 's that supposed to be ? It 's a bookstore . 550-556 573-577 What 's that supposed to be ? It 's a bookstore . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 557-563 573-577 They 're making it into something . It 's a bookstore . 557-563 573-577 They 're making it into something . It 's a bookstore . 1>2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 557-563 564-572 They 're making it into something . You 're not going anywhere for a while . 557-563 564-572 They 're making it into something . You 're not going anywhere for a while . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 511-512 573-577 No . It 's a bookstore . 511-512 573-577 No . It 's a bookstore . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 573-577 578-579 It 's a bookstore . Really ? 573-577 578-579 It 's a bookstore . Really ? 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 580-588 589-596 God , I did n't spend the night , that 's what makes me so mad , 580-602 580-602 God , I did n't spend the night , that 's what makes me so mad , I 'm grounded for nothing . God , I did n't spend the night , that 's what makes me so mad , I 'm grounded for nothing . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_conversation_grounded 589-596 597-602 that 's what makes me so mad , I 'm grounded for nothing . 580-602 580-602 God , I did n't spend the night , that 's what makes me so mad , I 'm grounded for nothing . God , I did n't spend the night , that 's what makes me so mad , I 'm grounded for nothing . 1>2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 597-602 Nothing . I 'm grounded for nothing . 7-8 580-602 Nothing . God , I did n't spend the night , that 's what makes me so mad , I 'm grounded for nothing . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 597-602 603-610 I 'm grounded for nothing . I was home all night last night , 580-602 603-617 God , I did n't spend the night , that 's what makes me so mad , I 'm grounded for nothing . I was home all night last night , I came home and told you . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_conversation_grounded 603-610 611-613 I was home all night last night , I came home 603-617 603-617 I was home all night last night , I came home and told you . I was home all night last night , I came home and told you . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_conversation_grounded 611-613 614-617 I came home and told you . 603-617 603-617 I was home all night last night , I came home and told you . I was home all night last night , I came home and told you . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_conversation_grounded 611-613 618-628 I came home And even my cuffs and everything 's on my bed . 603-617 618-628 I was home all night last night , I came home and told you . And even my cuffs and everything 's on my bed . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 597-602 629-631 I 'm grounded for nothing . So stupid . 580-602 629-631 God , I did n't spend the night , that 's what makes me so mad , I 'm grounded for nothing . So stupid . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 597-602 632-633,641-646 I 'm grounded for nothing . Next time <*> I 'll wake you up . 580-602 632-646 God , I did n't spend the night , that 's what makes me so mad , I 'm grounded for nothing . Next time if I leave in the morning , I 'll wake you up . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 634-640 641-646 if I leave in the morning , I 'll wake you up . 632-646 632-646 Next time if I leave in the morning , I 'll wake you up . Next time if I leave in the morning , I 'll wake you up . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_conversation_grounded 632-633,641-646 647-652 Next time <*> I 'll wake you up . Mom I 'm awake now , 632-646 647-656 Next time if I leave in the morning , I 'll wake you up . Mom I 'm awake now , I 'm leaving . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 647-652 653-656 Mom I 'm awake now , I 'm leaving . 647-656 647-656 Mom I 'm awake now , I 'm leaving . Mom I 'm awake now , I 'm leaving . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_conversation_grounded 657-664 679-689 Well you woke me up last night , why you could n't wake me up in the morning , 657-674 675-697 Well you woke me up last night , to tell me Kim was n't spending the night . I do n't know why you could n't wake me up in the morning , to tell me that you were going . 1>2 justify justify +GUM_conversation_grounded 665-667 668-674 to tell me Kim was n't spending the night . 657-674 657-674 Well you woke me up last night , to tell me Kim was n't spending the night . Well you woke me up last night , to tell me Kim was n't spending the night . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 657-664 668-674 Well you woke me up last night , Kim was n't spending the night . 657-674 657-674 Well you woke me up last night , to tell me Kim was n't spending the night . Well you woke me up last night , to tell me Kim was n't spending the night . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_conversation_grounded 675-678 679-689 I do n't know why you could n't wake me up in the morning , 675-697 675-697 I do n't know why you could n't wake me up in the morning , to tell me that you were going . I do n't know why you could n't wake me up in the morning , to tell me that you were going . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 632-633,641-646 679-689 Next time <*> I 'll wake you up . why you could n't wake me up in the morning , 632-646 675-697 Next time if I leave in the morning , I 'll wake you up . I do n't know why you could n't wake me up in the morning , to tell me that you were going . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 690-692 693-697 to tell me that you were going . 675-697 675-697 I do n't know why you could n't wake me up in the morning , to tell me that you were going . I do n't know why you could n't wake me up in the morning , to tell me that you were going . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 679-689 693-697 why you could n't wake me up in the morning , that you were going . 675-697 675-697 I do n't know why you could n't wake me up in the morning , to tell me that you were going . I do n't know why you could n't wake me up in the morning , to tell me that you were going . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_conversation_grounded 679-689 698-704 why you could n't wake me up in the morning , You guys wake me up every time 675-697 698-713 I do n't know why you could n't wake me up in the morning , to tell me that you were going . You guys wake me up every time I 'm trying to take a little nap . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_conversation_grounded 698-704 705-713 You guys wake me up every time I 'm trying to take a little nap . 698-713 698-713 You guys wake me up every time I 'm trying to take a little nap . You guys wake me up every time I 'm trying to take a little nap . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 679-689 714-719 why you could n't wake me up in the morning , What if we are awake ? 675-697 714-719 I do n't know why you could n't wake me up in the morning , to tell me that you were going . What if we are awake ? 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_conversation_grounded 720-725 744-749 I was tired this morning . I did n't even have time 720-725 737-754 I was tired this morning . I left it in a ponytail , I did n't even have time to take a shower . 1>2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 720-725 726-729 I was tired this morning . So much fun . 720-725 726-729 I was tired this morning . So much fun . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 720-725 730-736 I was tired this morning . My hair looks like a mess . 720-725 730-736 I was tired this morning . My hair looks like a mess . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 730-736 737-743 My hair looks like a mess . I left it in a ponytail , 730-736 737-754 My hair looks like a mess . I left it in a ponytail , I did n't even have time to take a shower . 1<2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 744-749 762-768 I did n't even have time I would 've took a shower . 737-754 755-768 I left it in a ponytail , I did n't even have time to take a shower . I think if I spent the night I would 've took a shower . 1>2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 744-749 750-754 I did n't even have time to take a shower . 737-754 737-754 I left it in a ponytail , I did n't even have time to take a shower . I left it in a ponytail , I did n't even have time to take a shower . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 755-756 762-768 I think I would 've took a shower . 755-768 755-768 I think if I spent the night I would 've took a shower . I think if I spent the night I would 've took a shower . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 757-761 762-768 if I spent the night I would 've took a shower . 755-768 755-768 I think if I spent the night I would 've took a shower . I think if I spent the night I would 've took a shower . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_conversation_grounded 597-602 762-768 I 'm grounded for nothing . I would 've took a shower . 580-602 755-768 God , I did n't spend the night , that 's what makes me so mad , I 'm grounded for nothing . I think if I spent the night I would 've took a shower . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_conversation_grounded 769,772-774 787-788 All <*> is your signature No . 769-781 787-788 All I need is your signature so I can play the volleyball . No . 1>2 solutionhood solutionhood +GUM_conversation_grounded 769,772-774 770-771 All <*> is your signature I need 769-781 769-781 All I need is your signature so I can play the volleyball . All I need is your signature so I can play the volleyball . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 769,772-774 775-781 All <*> is your signature so I can play the volleyball . 769-781 769-781 All I need is your signature so I can play the volleyball . All I need is your signature so I can play the volleyball . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_conversation_grounded 775-781 782-786 so I can play the volleyball . On the volleyball team . 769-781 782-786 All I need is your signature so I can play the volleyball . On the volleyball team . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 787-788 Nothing . No . 7-8 787-788 Nothing . No . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 787-788 789-790 No . No . 787-788 789-790 No . No . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 791-792 816-821 Why ? You have practice every Wednesday . 791-792 816-821 Why ? You have practice every Wednesday . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 791-792 793-797 Why ? It 's just volleyball . 791-792 793-797 Why ? It 's just volleyball . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_conversation_grounded 793-797 798-806 It 's just volleyball . It 's f- like on Saturdays and Wednesdays . 793-797 798-806 It 's just volleyball . It 's f- like on Saturdays and Wednesdays . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 793-797 807-811 It 's just volleyball . It 's for church . 793-797 807-811 It 's just volleyball . It 's for church . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 793-797 812-815 It 's just volleyball . It 's fun . 793-797 812-815 It 's just volleyball . It 's fun . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 787-788 816-821 No . You have practice every Wednesday . 787-788 816-821 No . You have practice every Wednesday . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_conversation_grounded 822 829-834 Yeah This is at six thirty . 822-828 829-834 Yeah but , not at uh — This is at six thirty . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_conversation_grounded 823-828 829-834 but , not at uh — This is at six thirty . 822-828 829-834 Yeah but , not at uh — This is at six thirty . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 816-821 829-834 You have practice every Wednesday . This is at six thirty . 816-821 829-834 You have practice every Wednesday . This is at six thirty . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_conversation_grounded 829-834 835-839 This is at six thirty . I do n't care . 829-834 835-839 This is at six thirty . I do n't care . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 787-788 840-847 No . And Susan 's going to it too . 787-788 840-847 No . And Susan 's going to it too . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_conversation_grounded 840-847 848-849 And Susan 's going to it too . Mm . 840-847 848-849 And Susan 's going to it too . Mm . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 850-854 855-858 Who cut the grass ? Marlena did it . 850-854 855-858 Who cut the grass ? Marlena did it . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 855-858 Nothing . Marlena did it . 7-8 855-858 Nothing . Marlena did it . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 859-866 867-873 Marlena did it a long time ago , but it has n't been watered . 859-873 859-873 Marlena did it a long time ago , but it has n't been watered . Marlena did it a long time ago , but it has n't been watered . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_conversation_grounded 855-858 867-873 Marlena did it . but it has n't been watered . 855-858 859-873 Marlena did it . Marlena did it a long time ago , but it has n't been watered . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 867-873 874-877 but it has n't been watered . It 's dying . 859-873 874-877 Marlena did it a long time ago , but it has n't been watered . It 's dying . 1<2 result result +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 878-880 Nothing . I know . 7-8 878-880 Nothing . I know . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 878-880 881-886 I know . Gon na rip your purse . 878-880 881-886 I know . Gon na rip your purse . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 878-880 887-889 I know . I know . 878-880 887-889 I know . I know . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 890 901-908 See I 'd still be in my uniform ? 890-908 890-908 See if I spent the night mom , you 'd think I 'd still be in my uniform ? See if I spent the night mom , you 'd think I 'd still be in my uniform ? 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 891-897 901-908 if I spent the night mom , I 'd still be in my uniform ? 890-908 890-908 See if I spent the night mom , you 'd think I 'd still be in my uniform ? See if I spent the night mom , you 'd think I 'd still be in my uniform ? 1>2 condition condition +GUM_conversation_grounded 898-900 901-908 you 'd think I 'd still be in my uniform ? 890-908 890-908 See if I spent the night mom , you 'd think I 'd still be in my uniform ? See if I spent the night mom , you 'd think I 'd still be in my uniform ? 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 901-908 Nothing . I 'd still be in my uniform ? 7-8 890-908 Nothing . See if I spent the night mom , you 'd think I 'd still be in my uniform ? 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 909-910 911-913 I know she 's — 909-913 909-913 I know she 's — I know she 's — 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 911-913 918-925 she 's — now she 's trying to think of ways 909-913 917-930 I know she 's — See now she 's trying to think of ways to cover her tracks . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 911-913 914-916 she 's — J- she — 909-913 914-916 I know she 's — J- she — 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 917 918-925 See now she 's trying to think of ways 917-930 917-930 See now she 's trying to think of ways to cover her tracks . See now she 's trying to think of ways to cover her tracks . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 901-908 918-925 I 'd still be in my uniform ? now she 's trying to think of ways 890-908 917-930 See if I spent the night mom , you 'd think I 'd still be in my uniform ? See now she 's trying to think of ways to cover her tracks . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 918-925 926-930 now she 's trying to think of ways to cover her tracks . 917-930 917-930 See now she 's trying to think of ways to cover her tracks . See now she 's trying to think of ways to cover her tracks . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 918-925 931-937 now she 's trying to think of ways I know what you 're doing . 917-930 931-937 See now she 's trying to think of ways to cover her tracks . I know what you 're doing . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_conversation_grounded 931-937 938-941 I know what you 're doing . Seen this before . 931-937 938-941 I know what you 're doing . Seen this before . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 942-945 Nothing . I 'm hungry . 7-8 942-945 Nothing . I 'm hungry . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 942-945 946-947 I 'm hungry . Shit . 942-945 946-947 I 'm hungry . Shit . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 948-952 Nothing . I love your jeans . 7-8 948-952 Nothing . I love your jeans . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 953-960 Nothing . Cause I wanted to go to the bathroom 7-8 953-965 Nothing . Cause I wanted to go to the bathroom when you 're done . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 953-960 961-965 Cause I wanted to go to the bathroom when you 're done . 953-965 953-965 Cause I wanted to go to the bathroom when you 're done . Cause I wanted to go to the bathroom when you 're done . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 966-971 Nothing . Anyways , they were not . 7-8 966-971 Nothing . Anyways , they were not . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 972-977 978-984 Did you get a sawsall ? Yes , it 's right here . 972-977 978-984 Did you get a sawsall ? Yes , it 's right here . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 978-984 Nothing . Yes , it 's right here . 7-8 978-984 Nothing . Yes , it 's right here . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 978-984 985-986 Yes , it 's right here . Oh . 978-984 985-986 Yes , it 's right here . Oh . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 978-984 987-991 Yes , it 's right here . I got the blades . 978-984 987-991 Yes , it 's right here . I got the blades . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 987-991 992-996 I got the blades . They 're right here . 987-991 992-996 I got the blades . They 're right here . 1<2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 997-1009 1010-1013 Do you remember the uh , program on TV , about Hantavirus ? About what virus ? 997-1009 1010-1013 Do you remember the uh , program on TV , about Hantavirus ? About what virus ? 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 1010-1013 1014-1015 About what virus ? Hantavirus . 1010-1013 1014-1015 About what virus ? Hantavirus . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 1014-1015 1080-1087 Hantavirus . it was in like eighteen different states . 1014-1015 1074-1087 Hantavirus . They said , they already determined it was in like eighteen different states . 1>2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 1016-1017 1033-1041 Hutter ? It 's the one from the dead mice . 1016-1017 1033-1041 Hutter ? It 's the one from the dead mice . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 1016-1017 1018-1022 Hutter ? What 's that about ? 1016-1017 1018-1022 Hutter ? What 's that about ? 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 1016-1017 1023-1027 Hutter ? I do n't re- – 1016-1017 1023-1032 Hutter ? I do n't re- – I do n't remember . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_conversation_grounded 1023-1027 1028-1032 I do n't re- – I do n't remember . 1023-1032 1023-1032 I do n't re- – I do n't remember . I do n't re- – I do n't remember . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 1014-1015 1033-1041 Hantavirus . It 's the one from the dead mice . 1014-1015 1033-1041 Hantavirus . It 's the one from the dead mice . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 1033-1041 1042-1045 It 's the one from the dead mice . Oh , yeah . 1033-1041 1042-1045 It 's the one from the dead mice . Oh , yeah . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 1046-1054 1080-1087 Is it , is it all over now ? it was in like eighteen different states . 1046-1054 1074-1087 Is it , is it all over now ? They said , they already determined it was in like eighteen different states . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 1046-1054 1055-1060 Is it , is it all over now ? Is it for real now ? 1046-1054 1055-1060 Is it , is it all over now ? Is it for real now ? 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 1046-1054 1061-1065 Is it , is it all over now ? Is it in here ? 1046-1054 1061-1065 Is it , is it all over now ? Is it in here ? 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 1061-1065 1066-1073 Is it in here ? Is it in the United States now ? 1061-1065 1066-1073 Is it in here ? Is it in the United States now ? 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 1074-1076 1080-1087 They said , it was in like eighteen different states . 1074-1087 1074-1087 They said , they already determined it was in like eighteen different states . They said , they already determined it was in like eighteen different states . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 1077-1079 1080-1087 they already determined it was in like eighteen different states . 1074-1087 1074-1087 They said , they already determined it was in like eighteen different states . They said , they already determined it was in like eighteen different states . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_conversation_grounded 1080-1087 1152-1163 it was in like eighteen different states . Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . 1074-1087 1152-1163 They said , they already determined it was in like eighteen different states . Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . 1>2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 1080-1087 1088-1089 it was in like eighteen different states . What ? 1074-1087 1088-1089 They said , they already determined it was in like eighteen different states . What ? 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 1088-1089 1090-1091 What ? So ? 1088-1089 1090-1091 What ? So ? 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 1080-1087 1092-1094 it was in like eighteen different states . The Hantavirus . 1074-1087 1092-1094 They said , they already determined it was in like eighteen different states . The Hantavirus . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_conversation_grounded 1095-1101 1104-1110 What , what are you g- — So what 're you getting at ? 1095-1101 1104-1110 What , what are you g- — So what 're you getting at ? 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 1095-1101 1102-1103 What , what are you g- — Well — 1095-1101 1102-1103 What , what are you g- — Well — 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 1104-1110 1129-1132 So what 're you getting at ? Really bothers me . 1104-1110 1129-1132 So what 're you getting at ? Really bothers me . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 1111-1121 1129-1132 That insulation out there with the mice shit in it ? Really bothers me . 1111-1121 1129-1132 That insulation out there with the mice shit in it ? Really bothers me . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 1122-1126 1127-1128 Did you just wash — Yes . 1122-1126 1127-1128 Did you just wash — Yes . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 1111-1121 1127-1128 That insulation out there with the mice shit in it ? Yes . 1111-1121 1127-1128 That insulation out there with the mice shit in it ? Yes . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 1129-1132 1152-1163 Really bothers me . Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . 1129-1132 1152-1163 Really bothers me . Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . 1>2 background background +GUM_conversation_grounded 1133-1135 1136-1140 I kn- — Oh oh I know . 1133-1135 1136-1140 I kn- — Oh oh I know . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 1129-1132 1136-1140 Really bothers me . Oh oh I know . 1129-1132 1136-1140 Really bothers me . Oh oh I know . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 1141-1142 1143-1146 I mean that 's the thing 1141-1151 1141-1151 I mean that 's the thing I thought of too . I mean that 's the thing I thought of too . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_conversation_grounded 1136-1140 1143-1146 Oh oh I know . that 's the thing 1136-1140 1141-1151 Oh oh I know . I mean that 's the thing I thought of too . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 1143-1146 1147-1151 that 's the thing I thought of too . 1141-1151 1141-1151 I mean that 's the thing I thought of too . I mean that 's the thing I thought of too . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 7-8 1152-1163 Nothing . Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . 7-8 1152-1163 Nothing . Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 1164-1170 1175-1177 I did n't even touch it . stuffed it . 1164-1170 1171-1177 I did n't even touch it . Used a hoe , stuffed it . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_conversation_grounded 1171-1174 1175-1177 Used a hoe , stuffed it . 1171-1177 1171-1177 Used a hoe , stuffed it . Used a hoe , stuffed it . 1>2 means means +GUM_conversation_grounded 1152-1163 1175-1177 Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . stuffed it . 1152-1163 1171-1177 Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . Used a hoe , stuffed it . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 1175-1177 1178-1183 stuffed it . I did n't touch anything . 1171-1177 1178-1183 Used a hoe , stuffed it . I did n't touch anything . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_conversation_grounded 1152-1163 1184-1189 Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . Do n't touch anything yellow . 1152-1163 1184-1189 Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . Do n't touch anything yellow . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_conversation_grounded 1184-1189 1190-1191 Do n't touch anything yellow . Okay ? 1184-1189 1190-1191 Do n't touch anything yellow . Okay ? 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 1192-1198 1199-1201 Not with your gloves or anything . Find something else 1192-1198 1199-1207 Not with your gloves or anything . Find something else to pick it up with . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_conversation_grounded 1184-1189 1199-1201 Do n't touch anything yellow . Find something else 1184-1189 1199-1207 Do n't touch anything yellow . Find something else to pick it up with . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_conversation_grounded 1199-1201 1202-1207 Find something else to pick it up with . 1199-1207 1199-1207 Find something else to pick it up with . Find something else to pick it up with . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 1184-1189 1208-1209 Do n't touch anything yellow . Mhm . 1184-1189 1208-1209 Do n't touch anything yellow . Mhm . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_conversation_grounded 1210-1221 1222-1228 Did you — did you put it in a trash bag ? I took that brown trash thing , 1210-1221 1222-1235 Did you — did you put it in a trash bag ? I took that brown trash thing , and tucked a bag in it . 1>2 question question +GUM_conversation_grounded 1152-1163 1222-1228 Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . I took that brown trash thing , 1152-1163 1222-1235 Well , it 's all packed up in garbage bags now . I took that brown trash thing , and tucked a bag in it . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_conversation_grounded 1222-1228 1229-1235 I took that brown trash thing , and tucked a bag in it . 1222-1235 1222-1235 I took that brown trash thing , and tucked a bag in it . I took that brown trash thing , and tucked a bag in it . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_conversation_grounded 1222-1228 1236-1243 I took that brown trash thing , And then I put them in there . 1222-1235 1236-1243 I took that brown trash thing , and tucked a bag in it . And then I put them in there . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_conversation_grounded 1236-1243 1244-1247 And then I put them in there . Squashed em down . 1236-1243 1244-1247 And then I put them in there . Squashed em down . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_fiction_beast 1-2 155-165 The Beast My father put his hand on top of my hair , 1-2 155-193 The Beast My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_fiction_beast 3-6 136-144 I was thirteen . My father and I were going to mass — 3-6 136-154 I was thirteen . My father and I were going to mass — my mother did not go ; she was Protestant . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_beast 3-6 7-15 I was thirteen . It was spring , the barren time in March 3-6 7-78 I was thirteen . It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 16-21 22-27 when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , 7-78 7-78 It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_beast 7-15 22-27 It was spring , the barren time in March if it is really warmer , 7-78 7-78 It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 28-34 35-38 but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself 7-78 7-78 It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_fiction_beast 35-38 39-51 that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud 7-78 7-78 It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_beast 22-27 39-51 if it is really warmer , the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud 7-78 7-78 It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_fiction_beast 52-55 56-78 and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . 7-78 7-78 It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_beast 22-27 56-78 if it is really warmer , that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . 7-78 7-78 It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_fiction_beast 56-78 79-82 that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . And it has , 7-78 79-94 It was spring , the barren time in March when you can not be sure if it is really warmer , but you are so desperate for change that you tell yourself the mud at the edge of the sidewalk is different from winter mud and you are sure that the smell of wet soil has suddenly a bit of the scent of summer rains , of grass and drowned earthworms . And it has , because it is spring and inside the ground something is stirring . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_beast 79-82 83-86 And it has , because it is spring 79-94 79-94 And it has , because it is spring and inside the ground something is stirring . And it has , because it is spring and inside the ground something is stirring . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_fiction_beast 83-86 87-94 because it is spring and inside the ground something is stirring . 79-94 79-94 And it has , because it is spring and inside the ground something is stirring . And it has , because it is spring and inside the ground something is stirring . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 3-6 95-101 I was thirteen . I was wearing a yellow linen dress 3-6 95-119 I was thirteen . I was wearing a yellow linen dress which my mother had picked out and which I therefore disliked although I knew it flattered me . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 95-101 102-107 I was wearing a yellow linen dress which my mother had picked out 95-119 95-119 I was wearing a yellow linen dress which my mother had picked out and which I therefore disliked although I knew it flattered me . I was wearing a yellow linen dress which my mother had picked out and which I therefore disliked although I knew it flattered me . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 102-107 108-112 which my mother had picked out and which I therefore disliked 95-119 95-119 I was wearing a yellow linen dress which my mother had picked out and which I therefore disliked although I knew it flattered me . I was wearing a yellow linen dress which my mother had picked out and which I therefore disliked although I knew it flattered me . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_fiction_beast 113-115 116-119 although I knew it flattered me . 95-119 95-119 I was wearing a yellow linen dress which my mother had picked out and which I therefore disliked although I knew it flattered me . I was wearing a yellow linen dress which my mother had picked out and which I therefore disliked although I knew it flattered me . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_beast 108-112 116-119 and which I therefore disliked it flattered me . 95-119 95-119 I was wearing a yellow linen dress which my mother had picked out and which I therefore disliked although I knew it flattered me . I was wearing a yellow linen dress which my mother had picked out and which I therefore disliked although I knew it flattered me . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_fiction_beast 95-101 120-123 I was wearing a yellow linen dress My shoes were white 95-119 120-135 I was wearing a yellow linen dress which my mother had picked out and which I therefore disliked although I knew it flattered me . My shoes were white and I was concentrating on keeping them out of the mud . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 120-123 124-135 My shoes were white and I was concentrating on keeping them out of the mud . 120-135 120-135 My shoes were white and I was concentrating on keeping them out of the mud . My shoes were white and I was concentrating on keeping them out of the mud . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_fiction_beast 136-144 155-165 My father and I were going to mass — My father put his hand on top of my hair , 136-154 155-193 My father and I were going to mass — my mother did not go ; she was Protestant . My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_beast 136-144 145-150 My father and I were going to mass — my mother did not go ; 136-154 136-154 My father and I were going to mass — my mother did not go ; she was Protestant . My father and I were going to mass — my mother did not go ; she was Protestant . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_fiction_beast 145-150 151-154 my mother did not go ; she was Protestant . 136-154 136-154 My father and I were going to mass — my mother did not go ; she was Protestant . My father and I were going to mass — my mother did not go ; she was Protestant . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 166-171 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , 155-193 155-193 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 172-193 My father put his hand on top of my hair , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . 155-193 155-193 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 194-200 201-205 When I was a little girl , he did that often , 194-210 194-210 When I was a little girl , he did that often , and called me Muscles . When I was a little girl , he did that often , and called me Muscles . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 201-205 My father put his hand on top of my hair , he did that often , 155-193 194-210 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . When I was a little girl , he did that often , and called me Muscles . 1<2 background background +GUM_fiction_beast 201-205 206-210 he did that often , and called me Muscles . 194-210 194-210 When I was a little girl , he did that often , and called me Muscles . When I was a little girl , he did that often , and called me Muscles . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 201-205 211-216 he did that often , He had not called me Muscles 194-210 211-228 When I was a little girl , he did that often , and called me Muscles . He had not called me Muscles or put his hand on my head for a long time . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_fiction_beast 211-216 217-228 He had not called me Muscles or put his hand on my head for a long time . 211-228 211-228 He had not called me Muscles or put his hand on my head for a long time . He had not called me Muscles or put his hand on my head for a long time . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 229-238 338-344 I could not help arching my back a little , Instead I went into the church , 229-277 338-357 I could not help arching my back a little , I wanted to push against his hand like a cat but the instinct that comes with being thirteen , the half-understood caution that makes a girl timid , or wild , the shyness told me to just walk . Instead I went into the church , took a Bulletin , dipped my finger in Holy Water and genuflected . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_fiction_beast 229-238 239-248 I could not help arching my back a little , I wanted to push against his hand like a cat 229-277 229-277 I could not help arching my back a little , I wanted to push against his hand like a cat but the instinct that comes with being thirteen , the half-understood caution that makes a girl timid , or wild , the shyness told me to just walk . I could not help arching my back a little , I wanted to push against his hand like a cat but the instinct that comes with being thirteen , the half-understood caution that makes a girl timid , or wild , the shyness told me to just walk . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_fiction_beast 239-248 249-277 I wanted to push against his hand like a cat but the instinct that comes with being thirteen , the half-understood caution that makes a girl timid , or wild , the shyness told me to just walk . 229-277 229-277 I could not help arching my back a little , I wanted to push against his hand like a cat but the instinct that comes with being thirteen , the half-understood caution that makes a girl timid , or wild , the shyness told me to just walk . I could not help arching my back a little , I wanted to push against his hand like a cat but the instinct that comes with being thirteen , the half-understood caution that makes a girl timid , or wild , the shyness told me to just walk . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_fiction_beast 229-238 278-294 I could not help arching my back a little , I wanted to feel the rough edge of the pocket of his coat against my cheek , 229-277 278-300 I could not help arching my back a little , I wanted to push against his hand like a cat but the instinct that comes with being thirteen , the half-understood caution that makes a girl timid , or wild , the shyness told me to just walk . I wanted to feel the rough edge of the pocket of his coat against my cheek , but I was too tall . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 278-294 295-300 I wanted to feel the rough edge of the pocket of his coat against my cheek , but I was too tall . 278-300 278-300 I wanted to feel the rough edge of the pocket of his coat against my cheek , but I was too tall . I wanted to feel the rough edge of the pocket of his coat against my cheek , but I was too tall . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_fiction_beast 301-310 311-337 I wanted to be seven again , and safe . But I still wanted to push against his hand and put my hand in his pocket and steal the leather palmed glove , that secret animal . 301-310 311-337 I wanted to be seven again , and safe . But I still wanted to push against his hand and put my hand in his pocket and steal the leather palmed glove , that secret animal . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_fiction_beast 229-238 311-337 I could not help arching my back a little , But I still wanted to push against his hand and put my hand in his pocket and steal the leather palmed glove , that secret animal . 229-277 311-337 I could not help arching my back a little , I wanted to push against his hand like a cat but the instinct that comes with being thirteen , the half-understood caution that makes a girl timid , or wild , the shyness told me to just walk . But I still wanted to push against his hand and put my hand in his pocket and steal the leather palmed glove , that secret animal . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 338-344 My father put his hand on top of my hair , Instead I went into the church , 155-193 338-357 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . Instead I went into the church , took a Bulletin , dipped my finger in Holy Water and genuflected . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 338-344 345-348 Instead I went into the church , took a Bulletin , 338-357 338-357 Instead I went into the church , took a Bulletin , dipped my finger in Holy Water and genuflected . Instead I went into the church , took a Bulletin , dipped my finger in Holy Water and genuflected . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 338-344 349-354 Instead I went into the church , dipped my finger in Holy Water 338-357 338-357 Instead I went into the church , took a Bulletin , dipped my finger in Holy Water and genuflected . Instead I went into the church , took a Bulletin , dipped my finger in Holy Water and genuflected . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 338-344 355-357 Instead I went into the church , and genuflected . 338-357 338-357 Instead I went into the church , took a Bulletin , dipped my finger in Holy Water and genuflected . Instead I went into the church , took a Bulletin , dipped my finger in Holy Water and genuflected . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 338-344 358-375 Instead I went into the church , The inside of the church smelled like damp wood and furniture polish , not alive at all . 338-357 358-375 Instead I went into the church , took a Bulletin , dipped my finger in Holy Water and genuflected . The inside of the church smelled like damp wood and furniture polish , not alive at all . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_beast 376-381 391,398-402 My father took off his coat and <*> I stole his glove . 376-402 376-402 My father took off his coat and draped it over the edge of the pew and when I came back from communion I stole his glove . My father took off his coat and draped it over the edge of the pew and when I came back from communion I stole his glove . 1>2 background background +GUM_fiction_beast 376-381 382-390 My father took off his coat and draped it over the edge of the pew 376-402 376-402 My father took off his coat and draped it over the edge of the pew and when I came back from communion I stole his glove . My father took off his coat and draped it over the edge of the pew and when I came back from communion I stole his glove . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 391,398-402 My father put his hand on top of my hair , and <*> I stole his glove . 155-193 376-402 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . My father took off his coat and draped it over the edge of the pew and when I came back from communion I stole his glove . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 392-397 398-402 when I came back from communion I stole his glove . 376-402 376-402 My father took off his coat and draped it over the edge of the pew and when I came back from communion I stole his glove . My father took off his coat and draped it over the edge of the pew and when I came back from communion I stole his glove . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_beast 403-413 414-423 The paper taste of the wafer was still in my mouth and I took a deep breath of the leather . 403-423 403-423 The paper taste of the wafer was still in my mouth and I took a deep breath of the leather . The paper taste of the wafer was still in my mouth and I took a deep breath of the leather . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 414-423 My father put his hand on top of my hair , and I took a deep breath of the leather . 155-193 403-423 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . The paper taste of the wafer was still in my mouth and I took a deep breath of the leather . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 414-423 424-428 and I took a deep breath of the leather . It smelled like March . 403-423 424-428 The paper taste of the wafer was still in my mouth and I took a deep breath of the leather . It smelled like March . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 429-434 My father put his hand on top of my hair , We walked back through the school 155-193 429-455 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . We walked back through the school because it was drizzling , my father tall in his navy suit and my shoes going click on the linoleum . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 429-434 435-439 We walked back through the school because it was drizzling , 429-455 429-455 We walked back through the school because it was drizzling , my father tall in his navy suit and my shoes going click on the linoleum . We walked back through the school because it was drizzling , my father tall in his navy suit and my shoes going click on the linoleum . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_fiction_beast 429-434 440-446 We walked back through the school my father tall in his navy suit 429-455 429-455 We walked back through the school because it was drizzling , my father tall in his navy suit and my shoes going click on the linoleum . We walked back through the school because it was drizzling , my father tall in his navy suit and my shoes going click on the linoleum . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_fiction_beast 440-446 447-455 my father tall in his navy suit and my shoes going click on the linoleum . 429-455 429-455 We walked back through the school because it was drizzling , my father tall in his navy suit and my shoes going click on the linoleum . We walked back through the school because it was drizzling , my father tall in his navy suit and my shoes going click on the linoleum . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 456-463 481-488 There were two classes of each grade , and we went left through the gym , 456-474 475-507 There were two classes of each grade , starting at the sixth and going down to the first . The hall ended in a T and we went left through the gym , walked underneath the bleachers and stood next to the side door , waiting for the rain to stop . 1>2 background background +GUM_fiction_beast 456-463 464-467 There were two classes of each grade , starting at the sixth 456-474 456-474 There were two classes of each grade , starting at the sixth and going down to the first . There were two classes of each grade , starting at the sixth and going down to the first . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 464-467 468-474 starting at the sixth and going down to the first . 456-474 456-474 There were two classes of each grade , starting at the sixth and going down to the first . There were two classes of each grade , starting at the sixth and going down to the first . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 456-463 475-480 There were two classes of each grade , The hall ended in a T 456-474 475-507 There were two classes of each grade , starting at the sixth and going down to the first . The hall ended in a T and we went left through the gym , walked underneath the bleachers and stood next to the side door , waiting for the rain to stop . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 481-488 My father put his hand on top of my hair , and we went left through the gym , 155-193 475-507 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . The hall ended in a T and we went left through the gym , walked underneath the bleachers and stood next to the side door , waiting for the rain to stop . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 481-488 489-492 and we went left through the gym , walked underneath the bleachers 475-507 475-507 The hall ended in a T and we went left through the gym , walked underneath the bleachers and stood next to the side door , waiting for the rain to stop . The hall ended in a T and we went left through the gym , walked underneath the bleachers and stood next to the side door , waiting for the rain to stop . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 481-488 493-500 and we went left through the gym , and stood next to the side door , 475-507 475-507 The hall ended in a T and we went left through the gym , walked underneath the bleachers and stood next to the side door , waiting for the rain to stop . The hall ended in a T and we went left through the gym , walked underneath the bleachers and stood next to the side door , waiting for the rain to stop . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 493-500 501-507 and stood next to the side door , waiting for the rain to stop . 475-507 475-507 The hall ended in a T and we went left through the gym , walked underneath the bleachers and stood next to the side door , waiting for the rain to stop . The hall ended in a T and we went left through the gym , walked underneath the bleachers and stood next to the side door , waiting for the rain to stop . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_fiction_beast 481-488 508-514 and we went left through the gym , It was dark under the bleachers . 475-507 508-514 The hall ended in a T and we went left through the gym , walked underneath the bleachers and stood next to the side door , waiting for the rain to stop . It was dark under the bleachers . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_beast 515-521 548-549 My father was a young man , He stood 515-547 548-568 My father was a young man , thirty-five , younger because he liked to be outside , to play softball on Saturday and to take my mother and me camping on vacation . He stood rocked back on his heels with his coat thrown over his shoulders and his hands in his pockets . 1>2 background background +GUM_fiction_beast 515-521 522-523 My father was a young man , thirty-five , 515-547 515-547 My father was a young man , thirty-five , younger because he liked to be outside , to play softball on Saturday and to take my mother and me camping on vacation . My father was a young man , thirty-five , younger because he liked to be outside , to play softball on Saturday and to take my mother and me camping on vacation . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 522-523 524 thirty-five , younger 515-547 515-547 My father was a young man , thirty-five , younger because he liked to be outside , to play softball on Saturday and to take my mother and me camping on vacation . My father was a young man , thirty-five , younger because he liked to be outside , to play softball on Saturday and to take my mother and me camping on vacation . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_fiction_beast 515-521 525-547 My father was a young man , because he liked to be outside , to play softball on Saturday and to take my mother and me camping on vacation . 515-547 515-547 My father was a young man , thirty-five , younger because he liked to be outside , to play softball on Saturday and to take my mother and me camping on vacation . My father was a young man , thirty-five , younger because he liked to be outside , to play softball on Saturday and to take my mother and me camping on vacation . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 548-549 My father put his hand on top of my hair , He stood 155-193 548-568 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . He stood rocked back on his heels with his coat thrown over his shoulders and his hands in his pockets . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 548-549 550-554 He stood rocked back on his heels 548-568 548-568 He stood rocked back on his heels with his coat thrown over his shoulders and his hands in his pockets . He stood rocked back on his heels with his coat thrown over his shoulders and his hands in his pockets . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_fiction_beast 550-554 555-561 rocked back on his heels with his coat thrown over his shoulders 548-568 548-568 He stood rocked back on his heels with his coat thrown over his shoulders and his hands in his pockets . He stood rocked back on his heels with his coat thrown over his shoulders and his hands in his pockets . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 550-554 562-568 rocked back on his heels and his hands in his pockets . 548-568 548-568 He stood rocked back on his heels with his coat thrown over his shoulders and his hands in his pockets . He stood rocked back on his heels with his coat thrown over his shoulders and his hands in his pockets . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 548-549 569-584 He stood I thought of bacon and eggs , toast with peach jam out of the jar . 548-568 569-584 He stood rocked back on his heels with his coat thrown over his shoulders and his hands in his pockets . I thought of bacon and eggs , toast with peach jam out of the jar . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 569-584 585-589 I thought of bacon and eggs , toast with peach jam out of the jar . I was so hungry . 569-584 585-589 I thought of bacon and eggs , toast with peach jam out of the jar . I was so hungry . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_fiction_beast 590-599 690-699 The space under the bleachers was secret and dark . I heard the rain and the faint rustle of paper 590-599 690-704 The space under the bleachers was secret and dark . I heard the rain and the faint rustle of paper and smelled damp concrete . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_beast 590-599 600-606 The space under the bleachers was secret and dark . There were things in the shadows ; 590-599 600-615 The space under the bleachers was secret and dark . There were things in the shadows ; a metal pail , a mop , rags . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 600-606 607-615 There were things in the shadows ; a metal pail , a mop , rags . 600-615 600-615 There were things in the shadows ; a metal pail , a mop , rags . There were things in the shadows ; a metal pail , a mop , rags . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 590-599 616-626 The space under the bleachers was secret and dark . Next to the door was a tall wrought-iron candle holder — 590-599 616-637 The space under the bleachers was secret and dark . Next to the door was a tall wrought-iron candle holder — the kind that stood at either end of the altar . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 616-626 627-628 Next to the door was a tall wrought-iron candle holder — the kind 616-637 616-637 Next to the door was a tall wrought-iron candle holder — the kind that stood at either end of the altar . Next to the door was a tall wrought-iron candle holder — the kind that stood at either end of the altar . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 627-628 629-637 the kind that stood at either end of the altar . 616-637 616-637 Next to the door was a tall wrought-iron candle holder — the kind that stood at either end of the altar . Next to the door was a tall wrought-iron candle holder — the kind that stood at either end of the altar . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 616-626 638-641 Next to the door was a tall wrought-iron candle holder — There was no holder 616-637 638-647 Next to the door was a tall wrought-iron candle holder — the kind that stood at either end of the altar . There was no holder and the end was jagged . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 638-641 642-647 There was no holder and the end was jagged . 638-647 638-647 There was no holder and the end was jagged . There was no holder and the end was jagged . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 590-599 648-658 The space under the bleachers was secret and dark . On the floor was a wrapper from a French Chew . 590-599 648-658 The space under the bleachers was secret and dark . On the floor was a wrapper from a French Chew . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 648-658 659-669 On the floor was a wrapper from a French Chew . They were sold at eighth-grade basketball games on Friday nights . 648-658 659-669 On the floor was a wrapper from a French Chew . They were sold at eighth-grade basketball games on Friday nights . 1<2 background background +GUM_fiction_beast 590-599 670-682 The space under the bleachers was secret and dark . The light from the door made the shadows under the bleachers darker , 590-599 670-689 The space under the bleachers was secret and dark . The light from the door made the shadows under the bleachers darker , the long space stretched far away . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 670-682 683-689 The light from the door made the shadows under the bleachers darker , the long space stretched far away . 670-689 670-689 The light from the door made the shadows under the bleachers darker , the long space stretched far away . The light from the door made the shadows under the bleachers darker , the long space stretched far away . 1<2 result result +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 690-699 My father put his hand on top of my hair , I heard the rain and the faint rustle of paper 155-193 690-704 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . I heard the rain and the faint rustle of paper and smelled damp concrete . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 690-699 700-704 I heard the rain and the faint rustle of paper and smelled damp concrete . 690-704 690-704 I heard the rain and the faint rustle of paper and smelled damp concrete . I heard the rain and the faint rustle of paper and smelled damp concrete . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 705-711 712-719 I did not go near my father but kept my hand in my pocket , 705-725 705-725 I did not go near my father but kept my hand in my pocket , feeling the soft leather glove . I did not go near my father but kept my hand in my pocket , feeling the soft leather glove . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 712-719 My father put his hand on top of my hair , but kept my hand in my pocket , 155-193 705-725 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . I did not go near my father but kept my hand in my pocket , feeling the soft leather glove . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 712-719 720-725 but kept my hand in my pocket , feeling the soft leather glove . 705-725 705-725 I did not go near my father but kept my hand in my pocket , feeling the soft leather glove . I did not go near my father but kept my hand in my pocket , feeling the soft leather glove . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 726-739 742-750 There was a rustling on the concrete and the drizzle of soft rain . if anyone ever went back under the bleachers , 726-739 740-758 There was a rustling on the concrete and the drizzle of soft rain . I wondered if anyone ever went back under the bleachers , if there were crickets or mice there . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_beast 740-741 742-750 I wondered if anyone ever went back under the bleachers , 740-758 740-758 I wondered if anyone ever went back under the bleachers , if there were crickets or mice there . I wondered if anyone ever went back under the bleachers , if there were crickets or mice there . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 742-750 My father put his hand on top of my hair , if anyone ever went back under the bleachers , 155-193 740-758 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . I wondered if anyone ever went back under the bleachers , if there were crickets or mice there . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 742-750 751-758 if anyone ever went back under the bleachers , if there were crickets or mice there . 740-758 740-758 I wondered if anyone ever went back under the bleachers , if there were crickets or mice there . I wondered if anyone ever went back under the bleachers , if there were crickets or mice there . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_fiction_beast 751-758 759-765 if there were crickets or mice there . The rustling might have been mice . 740-758 759-765 I wondered if anyone ever went back under the bleachers , if there were crickets or mice there . The rustling might have been mice . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 766-772 My father put his hand on top of my hair , I wished the rain would stop . 155-193 766-772 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . I wished the rain would stop . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 766-772 773-778 I wished the rain would stop . I wanted to go home . 766-772 773-778 I wished the rain would stop . I wanted to go home . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 779-784 My father put his hand on top of my hair , I made noises with my heels 155-193 779-793 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . I made noises with my heels but they were too loud so I stopped . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 785-789 790-793 but they were too loud so I stopped . 779-793 779-793 I made noises with my heels but they were too loud so I stopped . I made noises with my heels but they were too loud so I stopped . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_fiction_beast 779-784 790-793 I made noises with my heels so I stopped . 779-793 779-793 I made noises with my heels but they were too loud so I stopped . I made noises with my heels but they were too loud so I stopped . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_fiction_beast 779-784 794-796 I made noises with my heels Something else clicked 779-793 794-810 I made noises with my heels but they were too loud so I stopped . Something else clicked and I tried to see what it was but could n’t see anything . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 794-796 797-804 Something else clicked and I tried to see what it was 794-810 794-810 Something else clicked and I tried to see what it was but could n’t see anything . Something else clicked and I tried to see what it was but could n’t see anything . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 797-804 805-810 and I tried to see what it was but could n’t see anything . 794-810 794-810 Something else clicked and I tried to see what it was but could n’t see anything . Something else clicked and I tried to see what it was but could n’t see anything . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_fiction_beast 794-796 811-819 Something else clicked It was n’t as loud as my heels . 794-810 811-819 Something else clicked and I tried to see what it was but could n’t see anything . It was n’t as loud as my heels . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_beast 779-784 820-825 I made noises with my heels My father cleared his throat , 779-793 820-830 I made noises with my heels but they were too loud so I stopped . My father cleared his throat , looking out the door . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 820-825 826-830 My father cleared his throat , looking out the door . 820-830 820-830 My father cleared his throat , looking out the door . My father cleared his throat , looking out the door . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_fiction_beast 779-784 831-847 I made noises with my heels I imagined a man down there in the dark , an escaped convict or a madman . 779-793 831-847 I made noises with my heels but they were too loud so I stopped . I imagined a man down there in the dark , an escaped convict or a madman . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 848-853 854-860 It had nearly stopped raining . In fifteen minutes we would be home 848-853 854-867 It had nearly stopped raining . In fifteen minutes we would be home and my mother would fry eggs . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_beast 854-860 868-874 In fifteen minutes we would be home I heard a noise like paper . 854-867 868-874 In fifteen minutes we would be home and my mother would fry eggs . I heard a noise like paper . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_beast 854-860 861-867 In fifteen minutes we would be home and my mother would fry eggs . 854-867 854-867 In fifteen minutes we would be home and my mother would fry eggs . In fifteen minutes we would be home and my mother would fry eggs . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 868-874 My father put his hand on top of my hair , I heard a noise like paper . 155-193 868-874 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . I heard a noise like paper . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 868-874 875-881 I heard a noise like paper . My father heard it , too , 868-874 875-896 I heard a noise like paper . My father heard it , too , but he pretended not to , at least he did n’t turn his head . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 875-881 882-887 My father heard it , too , but he pretended not to , 875-896 875-896 My father heard it , too , but he pretended not to , at least he did n’t turn his head . My father heard it , too , but he pretended not to , at least he did n’t turn his head . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_fiction_beast 882-887 888-896 but he pretended not to , at least he did n’t turn his head . 875-896 875-896 My father heard it , too , but he pretended not to , at least he did n’t turn his head . My father heard it , too , but he pretended not to , at least he did n’t turn his head . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_fiction_beast 868-874 897-909 I heard a noise like paper . And there was a heavier sound , a rasp , like a box 868-874 897-913 I heard a noise like paper . And there was a heavier sound , a rasp , like a box pulled over concrete . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_beast 897-909 910-913 And there was a heavier sound , a rasp , like a box pulled over concrete . 897-913 897-913 And there was a heavier sound , a rasp , like a box pulled over concrete . And there was a heavier sound , a rasp , like a box pulled over concrete . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 868-874 914-918 I heard a noise like paper . I looked at my father 868-874 914-926 I heard a noise like paper . I looked at my father but he did n’t turn his head . 1<2 result result +GUM_fiction_beast 914-918 919-926 I looked at my father but he did n’t turn his head . 914-926 914-926 I looked at my father but he did n’t turn his head . I looked at my father but he did n’t turn his head . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_fiction_beast 919-926 927-934 but he did n’t turn his head . I wished he would turn his head . 914-926 927-934 I looked at my father but he did n’t turn his head . I wished he would turn his head . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_beast 155-165 935-943 My father put his hand on top of my hair , There was a click again and the rustle , 155-193 935-954 My father put his hand on top of my hair , his palm on my head , and I could feel the bone of my skull and my skin and his hot palm , so dry and strong . There was a click again and the rustle , and I could not think of what it could be . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 935-943 944-954 There was a click again and the rustle , and I could not think of what it could be . 935-954 935-954 There was a click again and the rustle , and I could not think of what it could be . There was a click again and the rustle , and I could not think of what it could be . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_beast 944-954 955-965 and I could not think of what it could be . I had no explanation for the particular combination of sounds . 935-954 955-965 There was a click again and the rustle , and I could not think of what it could be . I had no explanation for the particular combination of sounds . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_fiction_beast 935-943 966-973 There was a click again and the rustle , No doubt there was , some two things 935-954 966-984 There was a click again and the rustle , and I could not think of what it could be . No doubt there was , some two things that happened to be making noises at the same time . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_beast 966-973 974-984 No doubt there was , some two things that happened to be making noises at the same time . 966-984 966-984 No doubt there was , some two things that happened to be making noises at the same time . No doubt there was , some two things that happened to be making noises at the same time . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_beast 985-996 997-1000 Once in a fever I heard thousands of birds outside my window and I was terrified 985-1022 985-1022 Once in a fever I heard thousands of birds outside my window and I was terrified that they would fling themselves through the glass and attack me , but it was only the rain on the eaves . Once in a fever I heard thousands of birds outside my window and I was terrified that they would fling themselves through the glass and attack me , but it was only the rain on the eaves . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_beast 966-973 997-1000 No doubt there was , some two things and I was terrified 966-984 985-1022 No doubt there was , some two things that happened to be making noises at the same time . Once in a fever I heard thousands of birds outside my window and I was terrified that they would fling themselves through the glass and attack me , but it was only the rain on the eaves . 1<2 background background +GUM_fiction_beast 997-1000 1001-1008 and I was terrified that they would fling themselves through the glass 985-1022 985-1022 Once in a fever I heard thousands of birds outside my window and I was terrified that they would fling themselves through the glass and attack me , but it was only the rain on the eaves . Once in a fever I heard thousands of birds outside my window and I was terrified that they would fling themselves through the glass and attack me , but it was only the rain on the eaves . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_fiction_beast 1001-1008 1009-1012 that they would fling themselves through the glass and attack me , 985-1022 985-1022 Once in a fever I heard thousands of birds outside my window and I was terrified that they would fling themselves through the glass and attack me , but it was only the rain on the eaves . Once in a fever I heard thousands of birds outside my window and I was terrified that they would fling themselves through the glass and attack me , but it was only the rain on the eaves . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_beast 997-1000 1013-1022 and I was terrified but it was only the rain on the eaves . 985-1022 985-1022 Once in a fever I heard thousands of birds outside my window and I was terrified that they would fling themselves through the glass and attack me , but it was only the rain on the eaves . Once in a fever I heard thousands of birds outside my window and I was terrified that they would fling themselves through the glass and attack me , but it was only the rain on the eaves . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_fiction_lunre 1-3 4-5 Chapter Two : Master Lunre 1-5 1-5 Chapter Two : Master Lunre Chapter Two : Master Lunre 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_fiction_lunre 4-5 129-134 Master Lunre We stood by the gate , 1-5 129-161 Chapter Two : Master Lunre We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_fiction_lunre 6-15 76-78 My father ’s actions were largely incomprehensible to me , even the one 6-24 64-100 My father ’s actions were largely incomprehensible to me , guided by his own secret and labyrinthine calculations . No doubt his decisions were perfectly logical in his own eyes — even the one that prompted him , a patriotic islander , to bring me a tutor from Bain : Master Lunre , an Olondrian . 1>2 background background +GUM_fiction_lunre 6-15 16-24 My father ’s actions were largely incomprehensible to me , guided by his own secret and labyrinthine calculations . 6-24 6-24 My father ’s actions were largely incomprehensible to me , guided by his own secret and labyrinthine calculations . My father ’s actions were largely incomprehensible to me , guided by his own secret and labyrinthine calculations . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_fiction_lunre 6-15 25-48 My father ’s actions were largely incomprehensible to me , He dwelt in another world , a world of intrigue , bargains , contracts and clandestine purchases of land all over the island . 6-24 25-48 My father ’s actions were largely incomprehensible to me , guided by his own secret and labyrinthine calculations . He dwelt in another world , a world of intrigue , bargains , contracts and clandestine purchases of land all over the island . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 6-15 49-63 My father ’s actions were largely incomprehensible to me , He was in many ways a world in himself , whole as a sphere . 6-24 49-63 My father ’s actions were largely incomprehensible to me , guided by his own secret and labyrinthine calculations . He was in many ways a world in himself , whole as a sphere . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_lunre 6-15 64-75 My father ’s actions were largely incomprehensible to me , No doubt his decisions were perfectly logical in his own eyes — 6-24 64-100 My father ’s actions were largely incomprehensible to me , guided by his own secret and labyrinthine calculations . No doubt his decisions were perfectly logical in his own eyes — even the one that prompted him , a patriotic islander , to bring me a tutor from Bain : Master Lunre , an Olondrian . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_fiction_lunre 76-78 129-134 even the one We stood by the gate , 64-100 129-161 No doubt his decisions were perfectly logical in his own eyes — even the one that prompted him , a patriotic islander , to bring me a tutor from Bain : Master Lunre , an Olondrian . We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . 1>2 background background +GUM_fiction_lunre 76-78 79-94 even the one that prompted him , a patriotic islander , to bring me a tutor from Bain : 64-100 64-100 No doubt his decisions were perfectly logical in his own eyes — even the one that prompted him , a patriotic islander , to bring me a tutor from Bain : Master Lunre , an Olondrian . No doubt his decisions were perfectly logical in his own eyes — even the one that prompted him , a patriotic islander , to bring me a tutor from Bain : Master Lunre , an Olondrian . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 79-94 95-100 that prompted him , a patriotic islander , to bring me a tutor from Bain : Master Lunre , an Olondrian . 64-100 64-100 No doubt his decisions were perfectly logical in his own eyes — even the one that prompted him , a patriotic islander , to bring me a tutor from Bain : Master Lunre , an Olondrian . No doubt his decisions were perfectly logical in his own eyes — even the one that prompted him , a patriotic islander , to bring me a tutor from Bain : Master Lunre , an Olondrian . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 101-103 118-122 The day began the house festooned with flowers 101-128 101-128 The day began as it usually did when my father was expected home from his travels , the house festooned with flowers and stocked with coconut liquor . The day began as it usually did when my father was expected home from his travels , the house festooned with flowers and stocked with coconut liquor . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_fiction_lunre 101-103 104-107 The day began as it usually did 101-128 101-128 The day began as it usually did when my father was expected home from his travels , the house festooned with flowers and stocked with coconut liquor . The day began as it usually did when my father was expected home from his travels , the house festooned with flowers and stocked with coconut liquor . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_fiction_lunre 104-107 108-117 as it usually did when my father was expected home from his travels , 101-128 101-128 The day began as it usually did when my father was expected home from his travels , the house festooned with flowers and stocked with coconut liquor . The day began as it usually did when my father was expected home from his travels , the house festooned with flowers and stocked with coconut liquor . 1<2 condition condition +GUM_fiction_lunre 118-122 129-134 the house festooned with flowers We stood by the gate , 101-128 129-161 The day began as it usually did when my father was expected home from his travels , the house festooned with flowers and stocked with coconut liquor . We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_lunre 118-122 123-128 the house festooned with flowers and stocked with coconut liquor . 101-128 101-128 The day began as it usually did when my father was expected home from his travels , the house festooned with flowers and stocked with coconut liquor . The day began as it usually did when my father was expected home from his travels , the house festooned with flowers and stocked with coconut liquor . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 129-134 135 We stood by the gate , washed 129-161 129-161 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 135 136-137 washed and perfumed 129-161 129-161 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 135 138-144 washed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , 129-161 129-161 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 135 145-153 washed my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , 129-161 129-161 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 135 154-161 washed my father ’s wife with red eyes . 129-161 129-161 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 135 162-163,172-176 washed Jom , <*> moaned gently to himself , 129-161 162-190 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . Jom , grown taller and broad in the shoulders , moaned gently to himself , while I stood nervously rubbing the heel of one sandal on the flagstones . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 162-163,172-176 164-171 Jom , <*> moaned gently to himself , grown taller and broad in the shoulders , 162-190 162-190 Jom , grown taller and broad in the shoulders , moaned gently to himself , while I stood nervously rubbing the heel of one sandal on the flagstones . Jom , grown taller and broad in the shoulders , moaned gently to himself , while I stood nervously rubbing the heel of one sandal on the flagstones . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 162-163,172-176 177-180 Jom , <*> moaned gently to himself , while I stood nervously 162-190 162-190 Jom , grown taller and broad in the shoulders , moaned gently to himself , while I stood nervously rubbing the heel of one sandal on the flagstones . Jom , grown taller and broad in the shoulders , moaned gently to himself , while I stood nervously rubbing the heel of one sandal on the flagstones . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_fiction_lunre 177-180 181-190 while I stood nervously rubbing the heel of one sandal on the flagstones . 162-190 162-190 Jom , grown taller and broad in the shoulders , moaned gently to himself , while I stood nervously rubbing the heel of one sandal on the flagstones . Jom , grown taller and broad in the shoulders , moaned gently to himself , while I stood nervously rubbing the heel of one sandal on the flagstones . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_fiction_lunre 191-204 205-209 We scanned the deep blue valley for the first sign of the company , but before we saw them 191-221 191-221 We scanned the deep blue valley for the first sign of the company , but before we saw them we heard the children shouting : “ A yellow man ! ” We scanned the deep blue valley for the first sign of the company , but before we saw them we heard the children shouting : “ A yellow man ! ” 1>2 concession concession +GUM_fiction_lunre 205-209 216-221 but before we saw them “ A yellow man ! ” 191-221 191-221 We scanned the deep blue valley for the first sign of the company , but before we saw them we heard the children shouting : “ A yellow man ! ” We scanned the deep blue valley for the first sign of the company , but before we saw them we heard the children shouting : “ A yellow man ! ” 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_lunre 210-215 216-221 we heard the children shouting : “ A yellow man ! ” 191-221 191-221 We scanned the deep blue valley for the first sign of the company , but before we saw them we heard the children shouting : “ A yellow man ! ” We scanned the deep blue valley for the first sign of the company , but before we saw them we heard the children shouting : “ A yellow man ! ” 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_lunre 129-134 216-221 We stood by the gate , “ A yellow man ! ” 129-161 191-221 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . We scanned the deep blue valley for the first sign of the company , but before we saw them we heard the children shouting : “ A yellow man ! ” 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 216-221 222-225 “ A yellow man ! ” A yellow man ! 191-221 222-225 We scanned the deep blue valley for the first sign of the company , but before we saw them we heard the children shouting : “ A yellow man ! ” A yellow man ! 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_lunre 216-221 226-233 “ A yellow man ! ” We glanced at one another in confusion . 191-221 226-233 We scanned the deep blue valley for the first sign of the company , but before we saw them we heard the children shouting : “ A yellow man ! ” We glanced at one another in confusion . 1<2 result result +GUM_fiction_lunre 226-233 234-240 We glanced at one another in confusion . My mother bit her lower lip ; 226-233 234-247 We glanced at one another in confusion . My mother bit her lower lip ; Jom gave a groan of alarm . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 226-233 241-247 We glanced at one another in confusion . Jom gave a groan of alarm . 226-233 234-247 We glanced at one another in confusion . My mother bit her lower lip ; Jom gave a groan of alarm . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 248-251 252-257 At first I thought the children meant my father , 248-300 248-300 At first I thought the children meant my father , whose golden skin , the color of the night-monkey ’s pelt , was a rarity in the islands ; but certainly the children of Tyom were familiar with my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . At first I thought the children meant my father , whose golden skin , the color of the night-monkey ’s pelt , was a rarity in the islands ; but certainly the children of Tyom were familiar with my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_lunre 216-221 252-257 “ A yellow man ! ” the children meant my father , 191-221 248-300 We scanned the deep blue valley for the first sign of the company , but before we saw them we heard the children shouting : “ A yellow man ! ” At first I thought the children meant my father , whose golden skin , the color of the night-monkey ’s pelt , was a rarity in the islands ; but certainly the children of Tyom were familiar with my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 252-257 258-276 the children meant my father , whose golden skin , the color of the night-monkey ’s pelt , was a rarity in the islands ; 248-300 248-300 At first I thought the children meant my father , whose golden skin , the color of the night-monkey ’s pelt , was a rarity in the islands ; but certainly the children of Tyom were familiar with my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . At first I thought the children meant my father , whose golden skin , the color of the night-monkey ’s pelt , was a rarity in the islands ; but certainly the children of Tyom were familiar with my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_fiction_lunre 277-288 289-300 but certainly the children of Tyom were familiar with my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . 248-300 248-300 At first I thought the children meant my father , whose golden skin , the color of the night-monkey ’s pelt , was a rarity in the islands ; but certainly the children of Tyom were familiar with my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . At first I thought the children meant my father , whose golden skin , the color of the night-monkey ’s pelt , was a rarity in the islands ; but certainly the children of Tyom were familiar with my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_fiction_lunre 252-257 289-300 the children meant my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . 248-300 248-300 At first I thought the children meant my father , whose golden skin , the color of the night-monkey ’s pelt , was a rarity in the islands ; but certainly the children of Tyom were familiar with my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . At first I thought the children meant my father , whose golden skin , the color of the night-monkey ’s pelt , was a rarity in the islands ; but certainly the children of Tyom were familiar with my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_fiction_lunre 252-257 301-309,315-319 the children meant my father , Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” <*> an Olondrian wizard and doctor 248-300 301-357 At first I thought the children meant my father , whose golden skin , the color of the night-monkey ’s pelt , was a rarity in the islands ; but certainly the children of Tyom were familiar with my father , and would never have greeted a council-member with such ill-mannered yells . Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 301-309,315-319 310-314 Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” <*> an Olondrian wizard and doctor I had ever seen , 301-357 301-357 Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_fiction_lunre 315-319 320-327 an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , 301-357 301-357 Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 320-327 328-337 who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , 301-357 301-357 Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 328-337 338-344 who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , 301-357 301-357 Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 320-327 345-351 who had visited Tyom in my childhood , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , 301-357 301-357 Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 345-351 352-357 and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . 301-357 301-357 Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 358-361 362-381 I have since learned that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , 358-409 358-409 I have since learned that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , and died a respected man in his native city of Deinivel ; but at the time I felt certain he had returned with his sack of tree-cuttings . I have since learned that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , and died a respected man in his native city of Deinivel ; but at the time I felt certain he had returned with his sack of tree-cuttings . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_lunre 301-309,315-319 362-381 Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” <*> an Olondrian wizard and doctor that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , 301-357 358-409 Then I remembered the only “ yellow man ” I had ever seen , an Olondrian wizard and doctor who had visited Tyom in my childhood , who wore two pieces of glass on his eyes , attached to his ears with wires , and roamed the hills of Tinimavet , cutting bits off the trees . I have since learned that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , and died a respected man in his native city of Deinivel ; but at the time I felt certain he had returned with his sack of tree-cuttings . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_lunre 362-381 382-393 that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , and died a respected man in his native city of Deinivel ; 358-409 358-409 I have since learned that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , and died a respected man in his native city of Deinivel ; but at the time I felt certain he had returned with his sack of tree-cuttings . I have since learned that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , and died a respected man in his native city of Deinivel ; but at the time I felt certain he had returned with his sack of tree-cuttings . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 394-400 401-409 but at the time I felt certain he had returned with his sack of tree-cuttings . 358-409 358-409 I have since learned that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , and died a respected man in his native city of Deinivel ; but at the time I felt certain he had returned with his sack of tree-cuttings . I have since learned that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , and died a respected man in his native city of Deinivel ; but at the time I felt certain he had returned with his sack of tree-cuttings . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_lunre 362-381 401-409 that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , he had returned with his sack of tree-cuttings . 358-409 358-409 I have since learned that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , and died a respected man in his native city of Deinivel ; but at the time I felt certain he had returned with his sack of tree-cuttings . I have since learned that that doctor wrote a well-received treatise , On the Medicinal Properties of the Juice of the Young Coconut , and died a respected man in his native city of Deinivel ; but at the time I felt certain he had returned with his sack of tree-cuttings . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_fiction_lunre 129-134 410-415 We stood by the gate , “ There they are , ” 129-161 410-427 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . “ There they are , ” said Pavit , the head house-servant , in a strained voice . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 410-415 416-427 “ There they are , ” said Pavit , the head house-servant , in a strained voice . 410-427 410-427 “ There they are , ” said Pavit , the head house-servant , in a strained voice . “ There they are , ” said Pavit , the head house-servant , in a strained voice . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_lunre 410-415 428-432 “ There they are , ” And there they were : 410-427 428-441 “ There they are , ” said Pavit , the head house-servant , in a strained voice . And there they were : a chain of riders weaving among the trees . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_fiction_lunre 428-432 433-436 And there they were : a chain of riders 428-441 428-441 And there they were : a chain of riders weaving among the trees . And there they were : a chain of riders weaving among the trees . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 433-436 437-441 a chain of riders weaving among the trees . 428-441 428-441 And there they were : a chain of riders weaving among the trees . And there they were : a chain of riders weaving among the trees . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 433-436 442-469 a chain of riders My father ’s plaited umbrella appeared , his still , imposing figure , and beside him another man , tall and lean , astride an island mule . 428-441 442-469 And there they were : a chain of riders weaving among the trees . My father ’s plaited umbrella appeared , his still , imposing figure , and beside him another man , tall and lean , astride an island mule . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 470-482 483-490 The hectic screams of the children preceded the company into the village , so that they advanced like a festival , 470-497 470-497 The hectic screams of the children preceded the company into the village , so that they advanced like a festival , drawing people out of their houses . The hectic screams of the children preceded the company into the village , so that they advanced like a festival , drawing people out of their houses . 1>2 justify justify +GUM_fiction_lunre 129-134 483-490 We stood by the gate , so that they advanced like a festival , 129-161 470-497 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . The hectic screams of the children preceded the company into the village , so that they advanced like a festival , drawing people out of their houses . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 483-490 491-497 so that they advanced like a festival , drawing people out of their houses . 470-497 470-497 The hectic screams of the children preceded the company into the village , so that they advanced like a festival , drawing people out of their houses . The hectic screams of the children preceded the company into the village , so that they advanced like a festival , drawing people out of their houses . 1<2 result result +GUM_fiction_lunre 498-500 501-512 As they approached I saw that my father ’s face was shining with pride , 498-530 498-530 As they approached I saw that my father ’s face was shining with pride , and his bearing had in it a new hauteur , like that of the old island kings . As they approached I saw that my father ’s face was shining with pride , and his bearing had in it a new hauteur , like that of the old island kings . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_lunre 483-490 501-512 so that they advanced like a festival , I saw that my father ’s face was shining with pride , 470-497 498-530 The hectic screams of the children preceded the company into the village , so that they advanced like a festival , drawing people out of their houses . As they approached I saw that my father ’s face was shining with pride , and his bearing had in it a new hauteur , like that of the old island kings . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 501-512 513-530 I saw that my father ’s face was shining with pride , and his bearing had in it a new hauteur , like that of the old island kings . 498-530 498-530 As they approached I saw that my father ’s face was shining with pride , and his bearing had in it a new hauteur , like that of the old island kings . As they approached I saw that my father ’s face was shining with pride , and his bearing had in it a new hauteur , like that of the old island kings . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 501-512 531-532,545-558 I saw that my father ’s face was shining with pride , The man <*> kept his gaze lowered and fixed between the ears of his plodding mule . 498-530 531-558 As they approached I saw that my father ’s face was shining with pride , and his bearing had in it a new hauteur , like that of the old island kings . The man who rode beside him , looking uncomfortable with his long legs , kept his gaze lowered and fixed between the ears of his plodding mule . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 531-532,545-558 533-537 The man <*> kept his gaze lowered and fixed between the ears of his plodding mule . who rode beside him , 531-558 531-558 The man who rode beside him , looking uncomfortable with his long legs , kept his gaze lowered and fixed between the ears of his plodding mule . The man who rode beside him , looking uncomfortable with his long legs , kept his gaze lowered and fixed between the ears of his plodding mule . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 531-532,545-558 538-544 The man <*> kept his gaze lowered and fixed between the ears of his plodding mule . looking uncomfortable with his long legs , 531-558 531-558 The man who rode beside him , looking uncomfortable with his long legs , kept his gaze lowered and fixed between the ears of his plodding mule . The man who rode beside him , looking uncomfortable with his long legs , kept his gaze lowered and fixed between the ears of his plodding mule . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_lunre 559-563 564-574 He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; 559-592 559-592 He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_fiction_lunre 531-532,545-558 564-574 The man <*> kept his gaze lowered and fixed between the ears of his plodding mule . but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; 531-558 559-592 The man who rode beside him , looking uncomfortable with his long legs , kept his gaze lowered and fixed between the ears of his plodding mule . He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 564-574 575-579 but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , 559-592 559-592 He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 575-579 580 he had silver hair , worn 559-592 559-592 He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 580 581-585 worn cropped close to the skull 559-592 559-592 He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_fiction_lunre 575-579 586-592 he had silver hair , so that it resembled a cap . 559-592 559-592 He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_fiction_lunre 593-599 600-617 He was not the leaf-collecting doctor , but an altogether strange man , with silver eyebrows in his smooth face and long fine-knuckled hands . 593-617 593-617 He was not the leaf-collecting doctor , but an altogether strange man , with silver eyebrows in his smooth face and long fine-knuckled hands . He was not the leaf-collecting doctor , but an altogether strange man , with silver eyebrows in his smooth face and long fine-knuckled hands . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_fiction_lunre 564-574 600-617 but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; but an altogether strange man , with silver eyebrows in his smooth face and long fine-knuckled hands . 559-592 593-617 He was not yellow , but very pale brown , the color of raw cashews ; he had silver hair , worn cropped close to the skull so that it resembled a cap . He was not the leaf-collecting doctor , but an altogether strange man , with silver eyebrows in his smooth face and long fine-knuckled hands . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_fiction_lunre 618-625 626-631 As he dismounted in front of the house I heard my mother whispering : 618-651 618-651 As he dismounted in front of the house I heard my mother whispering : “ Protect us , God with the Black-and-White Tail , from that which is not of this earth . ” As he dismounted in front of the house I heard my mother whispering : “ Protect us , God with the Black-and-White Tail , from that which is not of this earth . ” 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_fiction_lunre 626-631 632-651 I heard my mother whispering : “ Protect us , God with the Black-and-White Tail , from that which is not of this earth . ” 618-651 618-651 As he dismounted in front of the house I heard my mother whispering : “ Protect us , God with the Black-and-White Tail , from that which is not of this earth . ” As he dismounted in front of the house I heard my mother whispering : “ Protect us , God with the Black-and-White Tail , from that which is not of this earth . ” 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_lunre 129-134 632-651 We stood by the gate , “ Protect us , God with the Black-and-White Tail , from that which is not of this earth . ” 129-161 618-651 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . As he dismounted in front of the house I heard my mother whispering : “ Protect us , God with the Black-and-White Tail , from that which is not of this earth . ” 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 129-134 652-657 We stood by the gate , My father dismounted from his mule 129-161 652-664 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . My father dismounted from his mule and strutted toward us , grinning . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 652-657 658-662 My father dismounted from his mule and strutted toward us , 652-664 652-664 My father dismounted from his mule and strutted toward us , grinning . My father dismounted from his mule and strutted toward us , grinning . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 658-662 663-664 and strutted toward us , grinning . 652-664 652-664 My father dismounted from his mule and strutted toward us , grinning . My father dismounted from his mule and strutted toward us , grinning . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_fiction_lunre 665-666 667-680 I thought I caught an odor off him , of fish , sea-sickness and sweat . 665-680 665-680 I thought I caught an odor off him , of fish , sea-sickness and sweat . I thought I caught an odor off him , of fish , sea-sickness and sweat . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_fiction_lunre 129-134 667-680 We stood by the gate , I caught an odor off him , of fish , sea-sickness and sweat . 129-161 665-680 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . I thought I caught an odor off him , of fish , sea-sickness and sweat . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 129-134 681-682 We stood by the gate , We knelt 129-161 681-710 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . We knelt and stared down at the bald ground , murmuring ritual greetings , until he touched the tops of our heads with the palm of his fleshy hand . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 681-682 683-690 We knelt and stared down at the bald ground , 681-710 681-710 We knelt and stared down at the bald ground , murmuring ritual greetings , until he touched the tops of our heads with the palm of his fleshy hand . We knelt and stared down at the bald ground , murmuring ritual greetings , until he touched the tops of our heads with the palm of his fleshy hand . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 681-682 691-694 We knelt murmuring ritual greetings , 681-710 681-710 We knelt and stared down at the bald ground , murmuring ritual greetings , until he touched the tops of our heads with the palm of his fleshy hand . We knelt and stared down at the bald ground , murmuring ritual greetings , until he touched the tops of our heads with the palm of his fleshy hand . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 681-682 695-710 We knelt until he touched the tops of our heads with the palm of his fleshy hand . 681-710 681-710 We knelt and stared down at the bald ground , murmuring ritual greetings , until he touched the tops of our heads with the palm of his fleshy hand . We knelt and stared down at the bald ground , murmuring ritual greetings , until he touched the tops of our heads with the palm of his fleshy hand . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 129-134 711-714 We stood by the gate , Then we stood , 129-161 711-736 We stood by the gate , washed and perfumed and arrayed in our brightest clothes , my mother twisting her hands in her skirt , my father ’s wife with red eyes . Then we stood , unable to keep from staring at the stranger , who faced us awkwardly , half-smiling , taller than any man there . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_fiction_lunre 711-714 715-723 Then we stood , unable to keep from staring at the stranger , 711-736 711-736 Then we stood , unable to keep from staring at the stranger , who faced us awkwardly , half-smiling , taller than any man there . Then we stood , unable to keep from staring at the stranger , who faced us awkwardly , half-smiling , taller than any man there . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_fiction_lunre 715-723 724-728,731-736 unable to keep from staring at the stranger , who faced us awkwardly , <*> taller than any man there . 711-736 711-736 Then we stood , unable to keep from staring at the stranger , who faced us awkwardly , half-smiling , taller than any man there . Then we stood , unable to keep from staring at the stranger , who faced us awkwardly , half-smiling , taller than any man there . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_fiction_lunre 724-728,731-736 729-730 who faced us awkwardly , <*> taller than any man there . half-smiling , 711-736 711-736 Then we stood , unable to keep from staring at the stranger , who faced us awkwardly , half-smiling , taller than any man there . Then we stood , unable to keep from staring at the stranger , who faced us awkwardly , half-smiling , taller than any man there . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_interview_cyclone 1-7 46-58 Wikinews interviews meteorological experts on Cyclone Phalin Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . 1-7 46-58 Wikinews interviews meteorological experts on Cyclone Phalin Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_interview_cyclone 8-14 46-58 File photo of interviewee David Titley . Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . 8-14 46-58 File photo of interviewee David Titley . Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . 1>2 background background +GUM_interview_cyclone 15-16 17-19 Image : David Titley . 15-19 15-19 Image : David Titley . Image : David Titley . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_interview_cyclone 8-14 17-19 File photo of interviewee David Titley . David Titley . 8-14 15-19 File photo of interviewee David Titley . Image : David Titley . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_interview_cyclone 20-23 39-45 Cyclone Phailin has winds will it begin to lose strength ? 20-45 20-45 Cyclone Phailin has winds that have been measured at 200 km / h , as it surges over land will it begin to lose strength ? Cyclone Phailin has winds that have been measured at 200 km / h , as it surges over land will it begin to lose strength ? 1>2 background background +GUM_interview_cyclone 20-23 24-33 Cyclone Phailin has winds that have been measured at 200 km / h , 20-45 20-45 Cyclone Phailin has winds that have been measured at 200 km / h , as it surges over land will it begin to lose strength ? Cyclone Phailin has winds that have been measured at 200 km / h , as it surges over land will it begin to lose strength ? 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 34-38 39-45 as it surges over land will it begin to lose strength ? 20-45 20-45 Cyclone Phailin has winds that have been measured at 200 km / h , as it surges over land will it begin to lose strength ? Cyclone Phailin has winds that have been measured at 200 km / h , as it surges over land will it begin to lose strength ? 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 39-45 46-58 will it begin to lose strength ? Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . 20-45 46-58 Cyclone Phailin has winds that have been measured at 200 km / h , as it surges over land will it begin to lose strength ? Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . 1>2 question question +GUM_interview_cyclone 59-70 71-75 Once a storm moves over any appreciably sized piece of land , the moisture source is removed 59-82 59-82 Once a storm moves over any appreciably sized piece of land , the moisture source is removed and the storm begins to dissipate . Once a storm moves over any appreciably sized piece of land , the moisture source is removed and the storm begins to dissipate . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 46-58 71-75 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . the moisture source is removed 46-58 59-82 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . Once a storm moves over any appreciably sized piece of land , the moisture source is removed and the storm begins to dissipate . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 71-75 76-82 the moisture source is removed and the storm begins to dissipate . 59-82 59-82 Once a storm moves over any appreciably sized piece of land , the moisture source is removed and the storm begins to dissipate . Once a storm moves over any appreciably sized piece of land , the moisture source is removed and the storm begins to dissipate . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_interview_cyclone 71-75 83-98 the moisture source is removed As of the last advisory , T C Phailin has winds of 190 kilometers per hour 59-82 83-109 Once a storm moves over any appreciably sized piece of land , the moisture source is removed and the storm begins to dissipate . As of the last advisory , T C Phailin has winds of 190 kilometers per hour and has moved inland , headed on a northwest track . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 83-98 99-103 As of the last advisory , T C Phailin has winds of 190 kilometers per hour and has moved inland , 83-109 83-109 As of the last advisory , T C Phailin has winds of 190 kilometers per hour and has moved inland , headed on a northwest track . As of the last advisory , T C Phailin has winds of 190 kilometers per hour and has moved inland , headed on a northwest track . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 99-103 104-109 and has moved inland , headed on a northwest track . 83-109 83-109 As of the last advisory , T C Phailin has winds of 190 kilometers per hour and has moved inland , headed on a northwest track . As of the last advisory , T C Phailin has winds of 190 kilometers per hour and has moved inland , headed on a northwest track . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_interview_cyclone 83-98 110-116 As of the last advisory , T C Phailin has winds of 190 kilometers per hour That is a Category 3 storm . 83-109 110-116 As of the last advisory , T C Phailin has winds of 190 kilometers per hour and has moved inland , headed on a northwest track . That is a Category 3 storm . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 83-98 117-140 As of the last advisory , T C Phailin has winds of 190 kilometers per hour The forecast is for a continued decline in strength to a tropical storm within 24 hours and a tropical depression within 36 hours . 83-109 117-140 As of the last advisory , T C Phailin has winds of 190 kilometers per hour and has moved inland , headed on a northwest track . The forecast is for a continued decline in strength to a tropical storm within 24 hours and a tropical depression within 36 hours . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 117-140 141-154 The forecast is for a continued decline in strength to a tropical storm within 24 hours and a tropical depression within 36 hours . However , there will be very heavy rains and flooding along its path . 117-140 141-154 The forecast is for a continued decline in strength to a tropical storm within 24 hours and a tropical depression within 36 hours . However , there will be very heavy rains and flooding along its path . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_interview_cyclone 46-58 155-161 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . Yes , it will loose strength steadily 46-58 155-179 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . Yes , it will loose strength steadily as more and more of this swirling system moves from being over ocean to being over land . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 155-161 162-179 Yes , it will loose strength steadily as more and more of this swirling system moves from being over ocean to being over land . 155-179 155-179 Yes , it will loose strength steadily as more and more of this swirling system moves from being over ocean to being over land . Yes , it will loose strength steadily as more and more of this swirling system moves from being over ocean to being over land . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 180-185 192-200 This occurs for two reasons : it is cut off from the source of energy 180-185 186-217 This occurs for two reasons : As it moves over land , it is cut off from the source of energy driving the storm [ which is ] the evaporation of water from the warm sea surface ; 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_interview_cyclone 186-191 192-200 As it moves over land , it is cut off from the source of energy 186-217 186-217 As it moves over land , it is cut off from the source of energy driving the storm [ which is ] the evaporation of water from the warm sea surface ; As it moves over land , it is cut off from the source of energy driving the storm [ which is ] the evaporation of water from the warm sea surface ; 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 155-161 192-200 Yes , it will loose strength steadily it is cut off from the source of energy 155-179 186-217 Yes , it will loose strength steadily as more and more of this swirling system moves from being over ocean to being over land . As it moves over land , it is cut off from the source of energy driving the storm [ which is ] the evaporation of water from the warm sea surface ; 1<2 cause cause +GUM_interview_cyclone 192-200 201-203 it is cut off from the source of energy driving the storm 186-217 186-217 As it moves over land , it is cut off from the source of energy driving the storm [ which is ] the evaporation of water from the warm sea surface ; As it moves over land , it is cut off from the source of energy driving the storm [ which is ] the evaporation of water from the warm sea surface ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 192-200 204-217 it is cut off from the source of energy [ which is ] the evaporation of water from the warm sea surface ; 186-217 186-217 As it moves over land , it is cut off from the source of energy driving the storm [ which is ] the evaporation of water from the warm sea surface ; As it moves over land , it is cut off from the source of energy driving the storm [ which is ] the evaporation of water from the warm sea surface ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 192-200 218-220 it is cut off from the source of energy Increased friction - 186-217 218-233 As it moves over land , it is cut off from the source of energy driving the storm [ which is ] the evaporation of water from the warm sea surface ; Increased friction - the ocean surface is much , much smoother than the land surface . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 218-220 221-233 Increased friction - the ocean surface is much , much smoother than the land surface . 218-233 218-233 Increased friction - the ocean surface is much , much smoother than the land surface . Increased friction - the ocean surface is much , much smoother than the land surface . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 234-242 275-279 Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy and they rapidly lose strength 234-261 262-285 Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean that condenses to form rain . As tropical cyclones make landfall , this energy source is cut - off and they rapidly lose strength as they move over land . 1>2 background background +GUM_interview_cyclone 234-242 243-246 Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , 234-261 234-261 Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean that condenses to form rain . Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean that condenses to form rain . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 243-246 247-251 called latent heat , which is released by moisture 234-261 234-261 Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean that condenses to form rain . Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean that condenses to form rain . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 247-251 252-255 which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean 234-261 234-261 Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean that condenses to form rain . Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean that condenses to form rain . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 247-251 256-257 which is released by moisture that condenses 234-261 234-261 Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean that condenses to form rain . Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean that condenses to form rain . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 256-257 258-261 that condenses to form rain . 234-261 234-261 Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean that condenses to form rain . Tropical cyclones are sustained by a form of energy called latent heat , which is released by moisture evaporated from the ocean that condenses to form rain . 1<2 result result +GUM_interview_cyclone 262-267 275-279 As tropical cyclones make landfall , and they rapidly lose strength 262-285 262-285 As tropical cyclones make landfall , this energy source is cut - off and they rapidly lose strength as they move over land . As tropical cyclones make landfall , this energy source is cut - off and they rapidly lose strength as they move over land . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 268-274 275-279 this energy source is cut - off and they rapidly lose strength 262-285 262-285 As tropical cyclones make landfall , this energy source is cut - off and they rapidly lose strength as they move over land . As tropical cyclones make landfall , this energy source is cut - off and they rapidly lose strength as they move over land . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_interview_cyclone 46-58 275-279 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . and they rapidly lose strength 46-58 262-285 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . As tropical cyclones make landfall , this energy source is cut - off and they rapidly lose strength as they move over land . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 275-279 280-285 and they rapidly lose strength as they move over land . 262-285 262-285 As tropical cyclones make landfall , this energy source is cut - off and they rapidly lose strength as they move over land . As tropical cyclones make landfall , this energy source is cut - off and they rapidly lose strength as they move over land . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 46-58 286-295 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . Yes , the Cyclone is almost certain to lose strength 46-58 286-301 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . Yes , the Cyclone is almost certain to lose strength as it surges over land . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 286-295 296-301 Yes , the Cyclone is almost certain to lose strength as it surges over land . 286-301 286-301 Yes , the Cyclone is almost certain to lose strength as it surges over land . Yes , the Cyclone is almost certain to lose strength as it surges over land . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 286-295 302-305 Yes , the Cyclone is almost certain to lose strength Cyclones gather their strength 286-301 302-323 Yes , the Cyclone is almost certain to lose strength as it surges over land . Cyclones gather their strength through scraping moisture and heat from warm ocean water that it is not the case over land . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 302-305 306-314 Cyclones gather their strength through scraping moisture and heat from warm ocean water 302-323 302-323 Cyclones gather their strength through scraping moisture and heat from warm ocean water that it is not the case over land . Cyclones gather their strength through scraping moisture and heat from warm ocean water that it is not the case over land . 1<2 means means +GUM_interview_cyclone 306-314 315-323 through scraping moisture and heat from warm ocean water that it is not the case over land . 302-323 302-323 Cyclones gather their strength through scraping moisture and heat from warm ocean water that it is not the case over land . Cyclones gather their strength through scraping moisture and heat from warm ocean water that it is not the case over land . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 302-305 324-338 Cyclones gather their strength In the mean time , much stronger friction over land quickly reduces their strength . 302-323 324-338 Cyclones gather their strength through scraping moisture and heat from warm ocean water that it is not the case over land . In the mean time , much stronger friction over land quickly reduces their strength . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 46-58 339-340 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . Yes . 46-58 339-340 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . Yes . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 339-340 341-345 Yes . All tropical cyclones lose strength 339-340 341-350 Yes . All tropical cyclones lose strength once they make landfall . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 341-345 346-350 All tropical cyclones lose strength once they make landfall . 341-350 341-350 All tropical cyclones lose strength once they make landfall . All tropical cyclones lose strength once they make landfall . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 341-345 351-370 All tropical cyclones lose strength However , they can remain dangerous storms due to very heavy rains and subsequent landslides , and river flooding . 341-350 351-370 All tropical cyclones lose strength once they make landfall . However , they can remain dangerous storms due to very heavy rains and subsequent landslides , and river flooding . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_interview_cyclone 46-58 371-376 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . Phailin 's winds will rapidly weaken 46-58 371-381 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . Phailin 's winds will rapidly weaken as it pushes inland . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 371-376 377-381 Phailin 's winds will rapidly weaken as it pushes inland . 371-381 371-381 Phailin 's winds will rapidly weaken as it pushes inland . Phailin 's winds will rapidly weaken as it pushes inland . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 382-387 388-395 Once Cyclone Phailin comes on shore it will immediately begin to lose strength . 382-395 382-395 Once Cyclone Phailin comes on shore it will immediately begin to lose strength . Once Cyclone Phailin comes on shore it will immediately begin to lose strength . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 46-58 388-395 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . it will immediately begin to lose strength . 46-58 382-395 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . Once Cyclone Phailin comes on shore it will immediately begin to lose strength . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 388-395 396-397,403-409 it will immediately begin to lose strength . However , <*> it still will contain lots of rainfall 382-395 396-415 Once Cyclone Phailin comes on shore it will immediately begin to lose strength . However , and this is important , it still will contain lots of rainfall making flooding an almost certainty . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_interview_cyclone 398-402 403-409 and this is important , it still will contain lots of rainfall 396-415 396-415 However , and this is important , it still will contain lots of rainfall making flooding an almost certainty . However , and this is important , it still will contain lots of rainfall making flooding an almost certainty . 1>2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_interview_cyclone 396-397,403-409 410-415 However , <*> it still will contain lots of rainfall making flooding an almost certainty . 396-415 396-415 However , and this is important , it still will contain lots of rainfall making flooding an almost certainty . However , and this is important , it still will contain lots of rainfall making flooding an almost certainty . 1<2 result result +GUM_interview_cyclone 416-422 498-510 File photo of interviewee R Saravanan . The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , 416-422 498-546 File photo of interviewee R Saravanan . The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . 1>2 background background +GUM_interview_cyclone 423-424 425-427 Image : R Saravanan . 423-427 423-427 Image : R Saravanan . Image : R Saravanan . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_interview_cyclone 416-422 425-427 File photo of interviewee R Saravanan . R Saravanan . 416-422 423-427 File photo of interviewee R Saravanan . Image : R Saravanan . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_interview_cyclone 428-445 446-457 A previous cyclone in 1999 in the Bay of Bengal area of India left 10,000 people dead . Is the Indian government well prepared to deal with this cyclone ? 428-445 446-457 A previous cyclone in 1999 in the Bay of Bengal area of India left 10,000 people dead . Is the Indian government well prepared to deal with this cyclone ? 1>2 background background +GUM_interview_cyclone 446-457 498-510 Is the Indian government well prepared to deal with this cyclone ? The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , 446-457 498-546 Is the Indian government well prepared to deal with this cyclone ? The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . 1>2 question question +GUM_interview_cyclone 458-472 498-510 I have not followed that aspect of the societal response for the present storm . The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , 458-472 498-546 I have not followed that aspect of the societal response for the present storm . The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_interview_cyclone 473-481 498-510 However , historically , there have been several events The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , 473-488 498-546 However , historically , there have been several events that should cause a societal response . The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . 1>2 background background +GUM_interview_cyclone 473-481 482-488 However , historically , there have been several events that should cause a societal response . 473-488 473-488 However , historically , there have been several events that should cause a societal response . However , historically , there have been several events that should cause a societal response . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 473-481 489-497 However , historically , there have been several events Hopefully , we all learn from past mistakes . 473-488 489-497 However , historically , there have been several events that should cause a societal response . Hopefully , we all learn from past mistakes . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_interview_cyclone 46-58 498-510 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , 46-58 498-546 Yes , all tropical cyclones are driven by high heat content waters . The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 498-510 511-532 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , 498-546 498-546 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_interview_cyclone 511-532 533-535 with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless 498-546 498-546 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 511-532 536-546 with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . 498-546 498-546 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 498-510 547-552 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , I do n't have enough information 498-546 547-563 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . I do n't have enough information to answer this question , one way or the other . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 547-552 553-563 I do n't have enough information to answer this question , one way or the other . 547-563 547-563 I do n't have enough information to answer this question , one way or the other . I do n't have enough information to answer this question , one way or the other . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_interview_cyclone 498-510 564-568,574-589 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , From all the press reports <*> the Indian government appears to have taken the threat of Cyclone Phailin very seriously indeed . 498-546 564-589 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . From all the press reports that I have read , the Indian government appears to have taken the threat of Cyclone Phailin very seriously indeed . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 564-568,574-589 569-573 From all the press reports <*> the Indian government appears to have taken the threat of Cyclone Phailin very seriously indeed . that I have read , 564-589 564-589 From all the press reports that I have read , the Indian government appears to have taken the threat of Cyclone Phailin very seriously indeed . From all the press reports that I have read , the Indian government appears to have taken the threat of Cyclone Phailin very seriously indeed . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 564-568,574-589 590-596 From all the press reports <*> the Indian government appears to have taken the threat of Cyclone Phailin very seriously indeed . The government has been much more pro-active 564-589 590-606 From all the press reports that I have read , the Indian government appears to have taken the threat of Cyclone Phailin very seriously indeed . The government has been much more pro-active in preparing for this cyclone than in the past . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_interview_cyclone 590-596 597-606 The government has been much more pro-active in preparing for this cyclone than in the past . 590-606 590-606 The government has been much more pro-active in preparing for this cyclone than in the past . The government has been much more pro-active in preparing for this cyclone than in the past . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 590-596 607-618 The government has been much more pro-active The forecasts of cyclone track and intensity have been fairly accurate . 590-606 607-618 The government has been much more pro-active in preparing for this cyclone than in the past . The forecasts of cyclone track and intensity have been fairly accurate . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_interview_cyclone 607-618 619-626 The forecasts of cyclone track and intensity have been fairly accurate . Mandatory mass evacuations have been carried out , 607-618 619-638 The forecasts of cyclone track and intensity have been fairly accurate . Mandatory mass evacuations have been carried out , which is essential to minimize loss of life in these situations . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 619-626 627-629 Mandatory mass evacuations have been carried out , which is essential 619-638 619-638 Mandatory mass evacuations have been carried out , which is essential to minimize loss of life in these situations . Mandatory mass evacuations have been carried out , which is essential to minimize loss of life in these situations . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_interview_cyclone 627-629 630-638 which is essential to minimize loss of life in these situations . 619-638 619-638 Mandatory mass evacuations have been carried out , which is essential to minimize loss of life in these situations . Mandatory mass evacuations have been carried out , which is essential to minimize loss of life in these situations . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_interview_cyclone 564-568,574-589 639-653 From all the press reports <*> the Indian government appears to have taken the threat of Cyclone Phailin very seriously indeed . Unfortunately , extensive property damage is bound to occur even with the best preparation . 564-589 639-653 From all the press reports that I have read , the Indian government appears to have taken the threat of Cyclone Phailin very seriously indeed . Unfortunately , extensive property damage is bound to occur even with the best preparation . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_interview_cyclone 498-510 654-672 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , My knowledge of the responsiveness of the Indian government to this storm is purely from the cyber space . 498-546 654-672 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . My knowledge of the responsiveness of the Indian government to this storm is purely from the cyber space . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 673-674 675-689 I heard that they orchestrated the largest people evacuation to a natural disaster in Indian history . 673-689 673-689 I heard that they orchestrated the largest people evacuation to a natural disaster in Indian history . I heard that they orchestrated the largest people evacuation to a natural disaster in Indian history . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_interview_cyclone 654-672 675-689 My knowledge of the responsiveness of the Indian government to this storm is purely from the cyber space . that they orchestrated the largest people evacuation to a natural disaster in Indian history . 654-672 673-689 My knowledge of the responsiveness of the Indian government to this storm is purely from the cyber space . I heard that they orchestrated the largest people evacuation to a natural disaster in Indian history . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 675-689 690-693 that they orchestrated the largest people evacuation to a natural disaster in Indian history . This shall be applauded 673-689 690-701 I heard that they orchestrated the largest people evacuation to a natural disaster in Indian history . This shall be applauded given the size and strength of Phailin . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_interview_cyclone 690-693 694-701 This shall be applauded given the size and strength of Phailin . 690-701 690-701 This shall be applauded given the size and strength of Phailin . This shall be applauded given the size and strength of Phailin . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 702-730 754-760 I visited the damaged area of the 1999 storm near Bhubaneshwar in the summer of 2012 for an invited symposium and summer school on tropical cyclones [ ... ] the evacuation is certainly necessary and essential 702-736 737-764 I visited the damaged area of the 1999 storm near Bhubaneshwar in the summer of 2012 for an invited symposium and summer school on tropical cyclones [ ... ] sponsored by the Indian government . Given the living standard and residence of people living near the coastal areas in this region , the evacuation is certainly necessary and essential to save lives . 1>2 justify justify +GUM_interview_cyclone 702-730 731-736 I visited the damaged area of the 1999 storm near Bhubaneshwar in the summer of 2012 for an invited symposium and summer school on tropical cyclones [ ... ] sponsored by the Indian government . 702-736 702-736 I visited the damaged area of the 1999 storm near Bhubaneshwar in the summer of 2012 for an invited symposium and summer school on tropical cyclones [ ... ] sponsored by the Indian government . I visited the damaged area of the 1999 storm near Bhubaneshwar in the summer of 2012 for an invited symposium and summer school on tropical cyclones [ ... ] sponsored by the Indian government . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 737-753 754-760 Given the living standard and residence of people living near the coastal areas in this region , the evacuation is certainly necessary and essential 737-764 737-764 Given the living standard and residence of people living near the coastal areas in this region , the evacuation is certainly necessary and essential to save lives . Given the living standard and residence of people living near the coastal areas in this region , the evacuation is certainly necessary and essential to save lives . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_cyclone 675-689 754-760 that they orchestrated the largest people evacuation to a natural disaster in Indian history . the evacuation is certainly necessary and essential 673-689 737-764 I heard that they orchestrated the largest people evacuation to a natural disaster in Indian history . Given the living standard and residence of people living near the coastal areas in this region , the evacuation is certainly necessary and essential to save lives . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_interview_cyclone 754-760 761-764 the evacuation is certainly necessary and essential to save lives . 737-764 737-764 Given the living standard and residence of people living near the coastal areas in this region , the evacuation is certainly necessary and essential to save lives . Given the living standard and residence of people living near the coastal areas in this region , the evacuation is certainly necessary and essential to save lives . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_interview_cyclone 765-780 781-785,790-792 I can not comment directly on how the Indian government was prepared for this cyclone . However , the news reports <*> were very encouraging 765-780 781-817 I can not comment directly on how the Indian government was prepared for this cyclone . However , the news reports ( BBC etc. ) were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_interview_cyclone 498-510 781-785,790-792 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , However , the news reports <*> were very encouraging 498-546 781-817 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . However , the news reports ( BBC etc. ) were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 781-785,790-792 786-789 However , the news reports <*> were very encouraging ( BBC etc. ) 781-817 781-817 However , the news reports ( BBC etc. ) were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . However , the news reports ( BBC etc. ) were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 781-785,790-792 793-801 However , the news reports <*> were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts 781-817 781-817 However , the news reports ( BBC etc. ) were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . However , the news reports ( BBC etc. ) were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_interview_cyclone 793-801 802-811 in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas 781-817 781-817 However , the news reports ( BBC etc. ) were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . However , the news reports ( BBC etc. ) were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_interview_cyclone 802-811 812-817 to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . 781-817 781-817 However , the news reports ( BBC etc. ) were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . However , the news reports ( BBC etc. ) were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 793-801 818-826 in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts Water is the main killer in these storms . 781-817 818-826 However , the news reports ( BBC etc. ) were very encouraging in that the authorities were reportedly making strenuous efforts to evacuate the population from near the coast and areas that are prone to flooding . Water is the main killer in these storms . 1<2 background background +GUM_interview_cyclone 498-510 827-829,835-843 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , From all reports <*> the government was well prepared for this cyclone . 498-546 827-843 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . From all reports that I have seen , the government was well prepared for this cyclone . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 827-829,835-843 830-834 From all reports <*> the government was well prepared for this cyclone . that I have seen , 827-843 827-843 From all reports that I have seen , the government was well prepared for this cyclone . From all reports that I have seen , the government was well prepared for this cyclone . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_cyclone 498-510 844-858 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , For this question I do n't know the ' preparedness ' of the Indian gov't 498-546 844-863 The history of strong cyclones and death in the region is notable , with at least 5 large cyclone events in the past 35 years with 10,000 and as many as 300,000 people killed , millions left homeless and estimated damages as high as US $ 10 billion . For this question I do n't know the ' preparedness ' of the Indian gov't to deal with this . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_cyclone 844-858 859-863 For this question I do n't know the ' preparedness ' of the Indian gov't to deal with this . 844-863 844-863 For this question I do n't know the ' preparedness ' of the Indian gov't to deal with this . For this question I do n't know the ' preparedness ' of the Indian gov't to deal with this . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_interview_gaming 1-12 21-29 Wikinews interviews Mario J. Lucero and Isabel Ruiz of Heaven Sent Gaming Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , 1-12 21-35 Wikinews interviews Mario J. Lucero and Isabel Ruiz of Heaven Sent Gaming Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , I 'm Mario J. Lucero . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_interview_gaming 13-14 21-29 General questions Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , 13-14 21-35 General questions Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , I 'm Mario J. Lucero . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_interview_gaming 15-20 21-29 What is Heaven Sent Gaming ? Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , 15-20 21-35 What is Heaven Sent Gaming ? Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , I 'm Mario J. Lucero . 1>2 question question +GUM_interview_gaming 21-29 30-35 Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , I 'm Mario J. Lucero . 21-35 21-35 Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , I 'm Mario J. Lucero . Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , I 'm Mario J. Lucero . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 30-35 36-42 I 'm Mario J. Lucero . And , I 'm Isabel Ruiz . 21-35 36-42 Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , I 'm Mario J. Lucero . And , I 'm Isabel Ruiz . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 21-29 43-50 Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , And , together we formed this thing , 21-35 43-59 Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , I 'm Mario J. Lucero . And , together we formed this thing , it 's sort of like an entertainment team . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 43-50 51-59 And , together we formed this thing , it 's sort of like an entertainment team . 43-59 43-59 And , together we formed this thing , it 's sort of like an entertainment team . And , together we formed this thing , it 's sort of like an entertainment team . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 43-50 60-64 And , together we formed this thing , We started it basically , 43-59 60-87 And , together we formed this thing , it 's sort of like an entertainment team . We started it basically , because I wanted to - I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects that we had going on together . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_interview_gaming 65-69 70-80 because I wanted to - I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects 60-87 60-87 We started it basically , because I wanted to - I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects that we had going on together . We started it basically , because I wanted to - I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects that we had going on together . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_interview_gaming 60-64 70-80 We started it basically , I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects 60-87 60-87 We started it basically , because I wanted to - I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects that we had going on together . We started it basically , because I wanted to - I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects that we had going on together . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_interview_gaming 70-80 81-87 I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects that we had going on together . 60-87 60-87 We started it basically , because I wanted to - I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects that we had going on together . We started it basically , because I wanted to - I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects that we had going on together . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 60-64 88-99 We started it basically , We were coming with comics , like , left and right , 60-87 88-151 We started it basically , because I wanted to - I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects that we had going on together . We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 88-99 100-108 We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , 88-151 88-151 We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 100-108 109-118 we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , 88-151 88-151 We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_interview_gaming 100-108 119-125 we were coming up with things like Karis , I came up with an individual story 88-151 88-151 We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 119-125 126-130 I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction 88-151 88-151 We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 119-125 131-138 I came up with an individual story and , she wanted to illustrate it , 88-151 88-151 We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_interview_gaming 119-125 139-145 I came up with an individual story and so , that 's the way 88-151 88-151 We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . 1<2 result result +GUM_interview_gaming 139-145 146-151 and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . 88-151 88-151 We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . We were coming with comics , like , left and right , we were coming up with things like Karis , in high school she came up with that one , I came up with an individual story called Thad 's World Destruction and , she wanted to illustrate it , and so , that 's the way we ended up doing it . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 60-64 152-163 We started it basically , Yep , we like to just make our own original content , 60-87 152-175 We started it basically , because I wanted to - I wanted to work with Isabel on a lot of projects that we had going on together . Yep , we like to just make our own original content , and , yep , that 's what we wanted to do . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_interview_gaming 152-163 164-175 Yep , we like to just make our own original content , and , yep , that 's what we wanted to do . 152-175 152-175 Yep , we like to just make our own original content , and , yep , that 's what we wanted to do . Yep , we like to just make our own original content , and , yep , that 's what we wanted to do . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_interview_gaming 176-181 182-188 How did you two meet ? We met back in high school . 176-181 182-188 How did you two meet ? We met back in high school . 1>2 question question +GUM_interview_gaming 21-29 182-188 Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , We met back in high school . 21-35 182-188 Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , I 'm Mario J. Lucero . We met back in high school . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 182-188 189-199 We met back in high school . In this private , tiny-tiny private school of 50 students . 182-188 189-199 We met back in high school . In this private , tiny-tiny private school of 50 students . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 200-214 260-268 But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy So before hand I kinda knew about him , 200-230 260-274 But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy named Mario , and he kept on hearing about me , this girl named Isabel . So before hand I kinda knew about him , but I never met him . 1>2 background background +GUM_interview_gaming 200-214 215-217 But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy named Mario , 200-230 200-230 But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy named Mario , and he kept on hearing about me , this girl named Isabel . But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy named Mario , and he kept on hearing about me , this girl named Isabel . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 200-214 218-227 But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy and he kept on hearing about me , this girl 200-230 200-230 But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy named Mario , and he kept on hearing about me , this girl named Isabel . But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy named Mario , and he kept on hearing about me , this girl named Isabel . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 218-227 228-230 and he kept on hearing about me , this girl named Isabel . 200-230 200-230 But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy named Mario , and he kept on hearing about me , this girl named Isabel . But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy named Mario , and he kept on hearing about me , this girl named Isabel . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 231-246 247-259 And , everyone , all of our friends and all of our acquaintances would say , " Hey , you 'd get along with him really well . " 231-259 231-259 And , everyone , all of our friends and all of our acquaintances would say , " Hey , you 'd get along with him really well . " And , everyone , all of our friends and all of our acquaintances would say , " Hey , you 'd get along with him really well . " 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_interview_gaming 200-214 247-259 But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy " Hey , you 'd get along with him really well . " 200-230 231-259 But , before hand in middle school , I kept on hearing about this guy named Mario , and he kept on hearing about me , this girl named Isabel . And , everyone , all of our friends and all of our acquaintances would say , " Hey , you 'd get along with him really well . " 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_interview_gaming 182-188 260-268 We met back in high school . So before hand I kinda knew about him , 182-188 260-274 We met back in high school . So before hand I kinda knew about him , but I never met him . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_interview_gaming 260-268 269-274 So before hand I kinda knew about him , but I never met him . 260-274 260-274 So before hand I kinda knew about him , but I never met him . So before hand I kinda knew about him , but I never met him . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_interview_gaming 182-188 275-291 We met back in high school . And one of our friends , our common friends , he introduced us during study hall , 182-188 275-302 We met back in high school . And one of our friends , our common friends , he introduced us during study hall , and we just kind of hit it off from there . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 275-291 292-302 And one of our friends , our common friends , he introduced us during study hall , and we just kind of hit it off from there . 275-302 275-302 And one of our friends , our common friends , he introduced us during study hall , and we just kind of hit it off from there . And one of our friends , our common friends , he introduced us during study hall , and we just kind of hit it off from there . 1<2 result result +GUM_interview_gaming 275-291 303-306 And one of our friends , our common friends , he introduced us during study hall , It 's true . 275-302 303-306 And one of our friends , our common friends , he introduced us during study hall , and we just kind of hit it off from there . It 's true . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_interview_gaming 307-314 315-323 Who else is involved in this project ? Currently , we 're in talks with people . 307-314 315-323 Who else is involved in this project ? Currently , we 're in talks with people . 1>2 question question +GUM_interview_gaming 21-29 315-323 Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , Currently , we 're in talks with people . 21-35 315-323 Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , I 'm Mario J. Lucero . Currently , we 're in talks with people . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 315-323 324-330 Currently , we 're in talks with people . There 's Jeff [ Drake ] , 315-323 324-336 Currently , we 're in talks with people . There 's Jeff [ Drake ] , who is behind the camera . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 324-330 331-336 There 's Jeff [ Drake ] , who is behind the camera . 324-336 324-336 There 's Jeff [ Drake ] , who is behind the camera . There 's Jeff [ Drake ] , who is behind the camera . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 324-330 337-348 There 's Jeff [ Drake ] , Right now , yeah , he 's helping us right now . 324-336 337-348 There 's Jeff [ Drake ] , who is behind the camera . Right now , yeah , he 's helping us right now . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 337-348 349-361 Right now , yeah , he 's helping us right now . We 're talking about doing some individual web series , video series . 337-348 349-361 Right now , yeah , he 's helping us right now . We 're talking about doing some individual web series , video series . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 324-330 362-370 There 's Jeff [ Drake ] , Josh Kindig , he 's coming on board , 324-336 362-392 There 's Jeff [ Drake ] , who is behind the camera . Josh Kindig , he 's coming on board , he has some ideas for that too , he wants to take over " aywv " and do more gaming news . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 362-370 371-378 Josh Kindig , he 's coming on board , he has some ideas for that too , 362-392 362-392 Josh Kindig , he 's coming on board , he has some ideas for that too , he wants to take over " aywv " and do more gaming news . Josh Kindig , he 's coming on board , he has some ideas for that too , he wants to take over " aywv " and do more gaming news . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 371-378 379-392 he has some ideas for that too , he wants to take over " aywv " and do more gaming news . 362-392 362-392 Josh Kindig , he 's coming on board , he has some ideas for that too , he wants to take over " aywv " and do more gaming news . Josh Kindig , he 's coming on board , he has some ideas for that too , he wants to take over " aywv " and do more gaming news . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 324-330 393-398 There 's Jeff [ Drake ] , There 's of course Jason , 324-336 393-411 There 's Jeff [ Drake ] , who is behind the camera . There 's of course Jason , who is our editor and he 's the one who writes dD . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 393-398 399-402 There 's of course Jason , who is our editor 393-411 393-411 There 's of course Jason , who is our editor and he 's the one who writes dD . There 's of course Jason , who is our editor and he 's the one who writes dD . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 393-398 403-407 There 's of course Jason , and he 's the one 393-411 393-411 There 's of course Jason , who is our editor and he 's the one who writes dD . There 's of course Jason , who is our editor and he 's the one who writes dD . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 403-407 408-411 and he 's the one who writes dD . 393-411 393-411 There 's of course Jason , who is our editor and he 's the one who writes dD . There 's of course Jason , who is our editor and he 's the one who writes dD . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 408-411 412-413 who writes dD . Digital Domain 393-411 412-413 There 's of course Jason , who is our editor and he 's the one who writes dD . Digital Domain 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_interview_gaming 414-421 469-479 What is your purpose behind this venture ? Basically , she came up with a few class projects , 414-421 469-489 What is your purpose behind this venture ? Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; 1>2 question question +GUM_interview_gaming 422-439,443-447 469-479 Well , back in college , back in Collins College , Isabel and I , we had met <*> at Sandia View Academy , Basically , she came up with a few class projects , 422-457 469-489 Well , back in college , back in Collins College , Isabel and I , we had met like she said at Sandia View Academy , and we went off to college together in Arizona ; Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; 1>2 background background +GUM_interview_gaming 422-439,443-447 440-442 Well , back in college , back in Collins College , Isabel and I , we had met <*> at Sandia View Academy , like she said 422-457 422-457 Well , back in college , back in Collins College , Isabel and I , we had met like she said at Sandia View Academy , and we went off to college together in Arizona ; Well , back in college , back in Collins College , Isabel and I , we had met like she said at Sandia View Academy , and we went off to college together in Arizona ; 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_interview_gaming 422-439,443-447 448-457 Well , back in college , back in Collins College , Isabel and I , we had met <*> at Sandia View Academy , and we went off to college together in Arizona ; 422-457 422-457 Well , back in college , back in Collins College , Isabel and I , we had met like she said at Sandia View Academy , and we went off to college together in Arizona ; Well , back in college , back in Collins College , Isabel and I , we had met like she said at Sandia View Academy , and we went off to college together in Arizona ; 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_interview_gaming 458-459 469-479 and ... Basically , she came up with a few class projects , 458-468 469-489 and ... ( how do I best explain this ? ) Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_interview_gaming 460-468 469-479 ( how do I best explain this ? ) Basically , she came up with a few class projects , 458-468 469-489 and ... ( how do I best explain this ? ) Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_interview_gaming 21-29 469-479 Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , Basically , she came up with a few class projects , 21-35 469-489 Heaven Sent Gaming is basically me and Isabel , I 'm Mario J. Lucero . Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 469-479 480-489 Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; 469-489 469-489 Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 469-479 490-504 Basically , she came up with a few class projects , we started working with a few of our friends , and colleagues and whatnot . 469-489 490-504 Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; we started working with a few of our friends , and colleagues and whatnot . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 490-504 505-516 we started working with a few of our friends , and colleagues and whatnot . Those included Drew Cass , Devin Thurlow , people like that . 490-504 505-516 we started working with a few of our friends , and colleagues and whatnot . Those included Drew Cass , Devin Thurlow , people like that . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 469-479 517-521 Basically , she came up with a few class projects , She had several ideas , 469-489 517-559 Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; She had several ideas , and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , she used to have this thick sketchbook that she used to carry around with her everywhere , where she 'd draw these different characters and whatnot ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 517-521 522-532 She had several ideas , and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , 517-559 517-559 She had several ideas , and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , she used to have this thick sketchbook that she used to carry around with her everywhere , where she 'd draw these different characters and whatnot ; She had several ideas , and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , she used to have this thick sketchbook that she used to carry around with her everywhere , where she 'd draw these different characters and whatnot ; 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 522-532 533-539 and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , she used to have this thick sketchbook 517-559 517-559 She had several ideas , and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , she used to have this thick sketchbook that she used to carry around with her everywhere , where she 'd draw these different characters and whatnot ; She had several ideas , and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , she used to have this thick sketchbook that she used to carry around with her everywhere , where she 'd draw these different characters and whatnot ; 1<2 background background +GUM_interview_gaming 533-539 540-549 she used to have this thick sketchbook that she used to carry around with her everywhere , 517-559 517-559 She had several ideas , and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , she used to have this thick sketchbook that she used to carry around with her everywhere , where she 'd draw these different characters and whatnot ; She had several ideas , and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , she used to have this thick sketchbook that she used to carry around with her everywhere , where she 'd draw these different characters and whatnot ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 540-549 550-559 that she used to carry around with her everywhere , where she 'd draw these different characters and whatnot ; 517-559 517-559 She had several ideas , and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , she used to have this thick sketchbook that she used to carry around with her everywhere , where she 'd draw these different characters and whatnot ; She had several ideas , and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , she used to have this thick sketchbook that she used to carry around with her everywhere , where she 'd draw these different characters and whatnot ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 560-572 573-582 and she was always really shy to show that off to people , and I wanted to help her show that stuff , 560-593 560-593 and she was always really shy to show that off to people , and I wanted to help her show that stuff , and I wanted to bring it out to the world . and she was always really shy to show that off to people , and I wanted to help her show that stuff , and I wanted to bring it out to the world . 1>2 background background +GUM_interview_gaming 522-532 573-582 and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , and I wanted to help her show that stuff , 517-559 560-593 She had several ideas , and she used to draw a lot in the sketchbook , she used to have this thick sketchbook that she used to carry around with her everywhere , where she 'd draw these different characters and whatnot ; and she was always really shy to show that off to people , and I wanted to help her show that stuff , and I wanted to bring it out to the world . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 573-582 583-593 and I wanted to help her show that stuff , and I wanted to bring it out to the world . 560-593 560-593 and she was always really shy to show that off to people , and I wanted to help her show that stuff , and I wanted to bring it out to the world . and she was always really shy to show that off to people , and I wanted to help her show that stuff , and I wanted to bring it out to the world . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_interview_gaming 594-598 611-620 I was a writer , let 's just get both of our things together , 594-627 594-627 I was a writer , and she always liked my writings , so I was like , let 's just get both of our things together , and let 's get this done . I was a writer , and she always liked my writings , so I was like , let 's just get both of our things together , and let 's get this done . 1>2 background background +GUM_interview_gaming 594-598 599-605 I was a writer , and she always liked my writings , 594-627 594-627 I was a writer , and she always liked my writings , so I was like , let 's just get both of our things together , and let 's get this done . I was a writer , and she always liked my writings , so I was like , let 's just get both of our things together , and let 's get this done . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 606-610 611-620 so I was like , let 's just get both of our things together , 594-627 594-627 I was a writer , and she always liked my writings , so I was like , let 's just get both of our things together , and let 's get this done . I was a writer , and she always liked my writings , so I was like , let 's just get both of our things together , and let 's get this done . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_interview_gaming 469-479 611-620 Basically , she came up with a few class projects , let 's just get both of our things together , 469-489 594-627 Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; I was a writer , and she always liked my writings , so I was like , let 's just get both of our things together , and let 's get this done . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_interview_gaming 611-620 621-627 let 's just get both of our things together , and let 's get this done . 594-627 594-627 I was a writer , and she always liked my writings , so I was like , let 's just get both of our things together , and let 's get this done . I was a writer , and she always liked my writings , so I was like , let 's just get both of our things together , and let 's get this done . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_interview_gaming 469-479 628-644 Basically , she came up with a few class projects , And for me , what I want the purpose to be , is to inspire people . 469-489 628-644 Basically , she came up with a few class projects , and I came up with a few class projects ; And for me , what I want the purpose to be , is to inspire people . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_interview_gaming 628-644 645-664 And for me , what I want the purpose to be , is to inspire people . To bring a little more light to the world is what I want , out of all of this . 628-644 645-664 And for me , what I want the purpose to be , is to inspire people . To bring a little more light to the world is what I want , out of all of this . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_interview_gaming 665-669 674-679 And what was the verse First Corinthians 9 : 25 ? 665-673 674-679 And what was the verse that we have ? First Corinthians 9 : 25 ? 1>2 question question +GUM_interview_gaming 665-669 670-673 And what was the verse that we have ? 665-673 665-673 And what was the verse that we have ? And what was the verse that we have ? 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 645-664 674-679 To bring a little more light to the world is what I want , out of all of this . First Corinthians 9 : 25 ? 645-664 674-679 To bring a little more light to the world is what I want , out of all of this . First Corinthians 9 : 25 ? 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_interview_gaming 674-679 680-681 First Corinthians 9 : 25 ? Yes . 674-679 680-681 First Corinthians 9 : 25 ? Yes . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_interview_gaming 674-679 682-685 First Corinthians 9 : 25 ? Yeah , exactly . 674-679 682-685 First Corinthians 9 : 25 ? Yeah , exactly . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_interview_gaming 628-644 686-694,699-715 And for me , what I want the purpose to be , is to inspire people . We just want to be able to bring , <*> bring light into the entertainment and into the media industry , specifically is what we do . 628-644 686-715 And for me , what I want the purpose to be , is to inspire people . We just want to be able to bring , like she said , bring light into the entertainment and into the media industry , specifically is what we do . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_interview_gaming 686-694,699-715 695-698 We just want to be able to bring , <*> bring light into the entertainment and into the media industry , specifically is what we do . like she said , 686-715 686-715 We just want to be able to bring , like she said , bring light into the entertainment and into the media industry , specifically is what we do . We just want to be able to bring , like she said , bring light into the entertainment and into the media industry , specifically is what we do . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_interview_gaming 686-694,699-715 716-717 We just want to be able to bring , <*> bring light into the entertainment and into the media industry , specifically is what we do . Yeah . 686-715 716-717 We just want to be able to bring , like she said , bring light into the entertainment and into the media industry , specifically is what we do . Yeah . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_news_homeopathic 1-2 17-52 Parents prosecuted Thomas Sam , 42 , and his wife Manju Sam , 36 , from Sydney , Australia , are undergoing trial for manslaughter by gross negligence for the death of their nine-month-old child , Gloria . 1-10 17-52 Parents prosecuted after homeopathic treatment leads to daughter 's death Thomas Sam , 42 , and his wife Manju Sam , 36 , from Sydney , Australia , are undergoing trial for manslaughter by gross negligence for the death of their nine-month-old child , Gloria . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_news_homeopathic 1-2 3-10 Parents prosecuted after homeopathic treatment leads to daughter 's death 1-10 1-10 Parents prosecuted after homeopathic treatment leads to daughter 's death Parents prosecuted after homeopathic treatment leads to daughter 's death 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_news_homeopathic 11-16 17-52 Friday , May 8 , 2009 Thomas Sam , 42 , and his wife Manju Sam , 36 , from Sydney , Australia , are undergoing trial for manslaughter by gross negligence for the death of their nine-month-old child , Gloria . 11-16 17-52 Friday , May 8 , 2009 Thomas Sam , 42 , and his wife Manju Sam , 36 , from Sydney , Australia , are undergoing trial for manslaughter by gross negligence for the death of their nine-month-old child , Gloria . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_news_homeopathic 17-52 53-56 Thomas Sam , 42 , and his wife Manju Sam , 36 , from Sydney , Australia , are undergoing trial for manslaughter by gross negligence for the death of their nine-month-old child , Gloria . She died from infection 17-52 53-82 Thomas Sam , 42 , and his wife Manju Sam , 36 , from Sydney , Australia , are undergoing trial for manslaughter by gross negligence for the death of their nine-month-old child , Gloria . She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 53-56 57-60 She died from infection caused by severe eczema 53-82 53-82 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 53-56 61-75 She died from infection after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine 53-82 53-82 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_news_homeopathic 61-75 76-82 after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . 53-82 53-82 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 61-75 83-87,93-101 after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine Articles in peer-reviewed academic journals <*> have characterized homeopathy as a form of quackery . 53-82 83-101 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . Articles in peer-reviewed academic journals including Social Science & Medicine have characterized homeopathy as a form of quackery . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_news_homeopathic 83-87,93-101 88-92 Articles in peer-reviewed academic journals <*> have characterized homeopathy as a form of quackery . including Social Science & Medicine 83-101 83-101 Articles in peer-reviewed academic journals including Social Science & Medicine have characterized homeopathy as a form of quackery . Articles in peer-reviewed academic journals including Social Science & Medicine have characterized homeopathy as a form of quackery . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 53-56 102-107 She died from infection An example of severe eczema . 53-82 102-107 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . An example of severe eczema . 1<2 background background +GUM_news_homeopathic 108-109 110-111 Image : Jambula . 108-111 108-111 Image : Jambula . Image : Jambula . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_news_homeopathic 102-107 110-111 An example of severe eczema . Jambula . 102-107 108-111 An example of severe eczema . Image : Jambula . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_homeopathic 112-121 122-135 Gloria developed severe eczema at the age of four months and the parents were advised to send the child to a skin specialist . 112-135 112-135 Gloria developed severe eczema at the age of four months and the parents were advised to send the child to a skin specialist . Gloria developed severe eczema at the age of four months and the parents were advised to send the child to a skin specialist . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_news_homeopathic 53-56 122-135 She died from infection and the parents were advised to send the child to a skin specialist . 53-82 112-135 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . Gloria developed severe eczema at the age of four months and the parents were advised to send the child to a skin specialist . 1<2 background background +GUM_news_homeopathic 122-135 136-150 and the parents were advised to send the child to a skin specialist . Thomas Sam , a practising homeopath , instead decided to treat his daughter himself . 112-135 136-150 Gloria developed severe eczema at the age of four months and the parents were advised to send the child to a skin specialist . Thomas Sam , a practising homeopath , instead decided to treat his daughter himself . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_news_homeopathic 136-150 151-159 Thomas Sam , a practising homeopath , instead decided to treat his daughter himself . His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point 136-150 151-189 Thomas Sam , a practising homeopath , instead decided to treat his daughter himself . His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point that the baby spent all her energy battling the infections caused by the constant breaking of the skin , leading to severe malnutrition and , eventually , her death . 1<2 result result +GUM_news_homeopathic 151-159 160-166 His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point that the baby spent all her energy 151-189 151-189 His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point that the baby spent all her energy battling the infections caused by the constant breaking of the skin , leading to severe malnutrition and , eventually , her death . His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point that the baby spent all her energy battling the infections caused by the constant breaking of the skin , leading to severe malnutrition and , eventually , her death . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 160-166 167-169 that the baby spent all her energy battling the infections 151-189 151-189 His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point that the baby spent all her energy battling the infections caused by the constant breaking of the skin , leading to severe malnutrition and , eventually , her death . His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point that the baby spent all her energy battling the infections caused by the constant breaking of the skin , leading to severe malnutrition and , eventually , her death . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_news_homeopathic 167-169 170-178 battling the infections caused by the constant breaking of the skin , 151-189 151-189 His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point that the baby spent all her energy battling the infections caused by the constant breaking of the skin , leading to severe malnutrition and , eventually , her death . His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point that the baby spent all her energy battling the infections caused by the constant breaking of the skin , leading to severe malnutrition and , eventually , her death . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_news_homeopathic 151-159 179-189 His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point leading to severe malnutrition and , eventually , her death . 151-189 151-189 His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point that the baby spent all her energy battling the infections caused by the constant breaking of the skin , leading to severe malnutrition and , eventually , her death . His daughter 's condition deteriorated , to the point that the baby spent all her energy battling the infections caused by the constant breaking of the skin , leading to severe malnutrition and , eventually , her death . 1<2 result result +GUM_news_homeopathic 53-56 190-199 She died from infection By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe 53-82 190-263 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 190-199 200-203 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke 190-263 190-263 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " 1<2 manner manner +GUM_news_homeopathic 190-199 204-213 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , 190-263 190-263 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_news_homeopathic 214-227 228-240 and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life 190-263 190-263 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_homeopathic 190-199 228-240 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life 190-263 190-263 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 228-240 241-242 " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , 190-263 190-263 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " 1<2 manner manner +GUM_news_homeopathic 241-242 243-244 crying , irritable , 190-263 190-263 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 241-242 245 crying , scratching 190-263 190-263 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 228-240 246-249,254-263 " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life and the only thing <*> was to suck on her mother 's breast . " 190-263 190-263 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 246-249,254-263 250-253 and the only thing <*> was to suck on her mother 's breast . " that gave her solace 190-263 190-263 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 190-199 264-272 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe Gloria also became unable to move her legs . 190-263 264-272 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " Gloria also became unable to move her legs . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 273-278 279-301 Mr. Tedeschi also told the court that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health 273-322 273-322 Mr. Tedeschi also told the court that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health and it is asserted by the Crown that both her parents knew this and discussed it with each other . " Mr. Tedeschi also told the court that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health and it is asserted by the Crown that both her parents knew this and discussed it with each other . " 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_homeopathic 190-199 279-301 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health 190-263 273-322 By the end , Gloria 's eczema was so severe that her skin broke every time her parents changed her clothes or nappy , and in the words of the Crown prosecutor , Mark Tedeschi , QC , " Gloria spent a lot of the last five months of her life crying , irritable , scratching and the only thing that gave her solace was to suck on her mother 's breast . " Mr. Tedeschi also told the court that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health and it is asserted by the Crown that both her parents knew this and discussed it with each other . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 302-308 309-314 and it is asserted by the Crown that both her parents knew this 273-322 273-322 Mr. Tedeschi also told the court that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health and it is asserted by the Crown that both her parents knew this and discussed it with each other . " Mr. Tedeschi also told the court that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health and it is asserted by the Crown that both her parents knew this and discussed it with each other . " 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_homeopathic 279-301 309-314 that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health that both her parents knew this 273-322 273-322 Mr. Tedeschi also told the court that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health and it is asserted by the Crown that both her parents knew this and discussed it with each other . " Mr. Tedeschi also told the court that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health and it is asserted by the Crown that both her parents knew this and discussed it with each other . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 309-314 315-322 that both her parents knew this and discussed it with each other . " 273-322 273-322 Mr. Tedeschi also told the court that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health and it is asserted by the Crown that both her parents knew this and discussed it with each other . " Mr. Tedeschi also told the court that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health and it is asserted by the Crown that both her parents knew this and discussed it with each other . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 309-314 323-324,338-346 that both her parents knew this However , <*> the Sams continued to shun conventional medical treatment , 273-322 323-355 Mr. Tedeschi also told the court that , over the last five months of her life , " Gloria 's eczema played a devastating role in her overall health and it is asserted by the Crown that both her parents knew this and discussed it with each other . " However , despite their child 's severe illness , and her lack of improvement , the Sams continued to shun conventional medical treatment , instead seeking help from other homeopaths and naturopaths . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_news_homeopathic 323-324,338-346 325-337 However , <*> the Sams continued to shun conventional medical treatment , despite their child 's severe illness , and her lack of improvement , 323-355 323-355 However , despite their child 's severe illness , and her lack of improvement , the Sams continued to shun conventional medical treatment , instead seeking help from other homeopaths and naturopaths . However , despite their child 's severe illness , and her lack of improvement , the Sams continued to shun conventional medical treatment , instead seeking help from other homeopaths and naturopaths . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_news_homeopathic 323-324,338-346 347-355 However , <*> the Sams continued to shun conventional medical treatment , instead seeking help from other homeopaths and naturopaths . 323-355 323-355 However , despite their child 's severe illness , and her lack of improvement , the Sams continued to shun conventional medical treatment , instead seeking help from other homeopaths and naturopaths . However , despite their child 's severe illness , and her lack of improvement , the Sams continued to shun conventional medical treatment , instead seeking help from other homeopaths and naturopaths . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 53-56 356-362 She died from infection Gloria temporarily improved during the rare times 53-82 356-382 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . Gloria temporarily improved during the rare times they used conventional treatments , but they soon dropped them in favour of homeopathy , and she consistently worsened . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 356-362 363-367 Gloria temporarily improved during the rare times they used conventional treatments , 356-382 356-382 Gloria temporarily improved during the rare times they used conventional treatments , but they soon dropped them in favour of homeopathy , and she consistently worsened . Gloria temporarily improved during the rare times they used conventional treatments , but they soon dropped them in favour of homeopathy , and she consistently worsened . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 356-362 368-377 Gloria temporarily improved during the rare times but they soon dropped them in favour of homeopathy , 356-382 356-382 Gloria temporarily improved during the rare times they used conventional treatments , but they soon dropped them in favour of homeopathy , and she consistently worsened . Gloria temporarily improved during the rare times they used conventional treatments , but they soon dropped them in favour of homeopathy , and she consistently worsened . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_news_homeopathic 368-377 378-382 but they soon dropped them in favour of homeopathy , and she consistently worsened . 356-382 356-382 Gloria temporarily improved during the rare times they used conventional treatments , but they soon dropped them in favour of homeopathy , and she consistently worsened . Gloria temporarily improved during the rare times they used conventional treatments , but they soon dropped them in favour of homeopathy , and she consistently worsened . 1<2 result result +GUM_news_homeopathic 53-56 383-399 She died from infection Allegedly , Thomas ' sister pleaded with him to send Gloria to a conventional medical doctor , 53-82 383-412 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . Allegedly , Thomas ' sister pleaded with him to send Gloria to a conventional medical doctor , but he replied " I am not able to do that " . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 400-402 403-412 but he replied " I am not able to do that " . 383-412 383-412 Allegedly , Thomas ' sister pleaded with him to send Gloria to a conventional medical doctor , but he replied " I am not able to do that " . Allegedly , Thomas ' sister pleaded with him to send Gloria to a conventional medical doctor , but he replied " I am not able to do that " . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_homeopathic 383-399 403-412 Allegedly , Thomas ' sister pleaded with him to send Gloria to a conventional medical doctor , " I am not able to do that " . 383-412 383-412 Allegedly , Thomas ' sister pleaded with him to send Gloria to a conventional medical doctor , but he replied " I am not able to do that " . Allegedly , Thomas ' sister pleaded with him to send Gloria to a conventional medical doctor , but he replied " I am not able to do that " . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_news_homeopathic 53-56 413-427 She died from infection The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , 53-82 413-463 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 413-427 428-434 The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India 413-463 413-463 The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_news_homeopathic 428-434 435-439 taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants 413-463 413-463 The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 435-439 440-447 and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , 413-463 413-463 The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_news_homeopathic 413-427 448-452 The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , and giving her homeopathic drops 413-463 413-463 The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 448-452 453-458 and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams 413-463 413-463 The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_news_homeopathic 453-458 459-463 instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . 413-463 413-463 The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . The parents are also accused of putting their social life ahead of their child , taking her on a trip to India and leaving her to servants while embarking on a busy social schedule , and giving her homeopathic drops instead of using the prescription creams they had been given . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 53-56 464-476 She died from infection Gloria was finally taken to the emergency department shortly before her death . 53-82 464-476 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . Gloria was finally taken to the emergency department shortly before her death . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 464-476 477-486 Gloria was finally taken to the emergency department shortly before her death . By this time , " her skin was weeping , 464-476 477-502 Gloria was finally taken to the emergency department shortly before her death . By this time , " her skin was weeping , her body malnourished and her corneas melting " , according to the Sydney Morning Herald . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 477-486 487-489 By this time , " her skin was weeping , her body malnourished 477-502 477-502 By this time , " her skin was weeping , her body malnourished and her corneas melting " , according to the Sydney Morning Herald . By this time , " her skin was weeping , her body malnourished and her corneas melting " , according to the Sydney Morning Herald . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 477-486 490-495 By this time , " her skin was weeping , and her corneas melting " , 477-502 477-502 By this time , " her skin was weeping , her body malnourished and her corneas melting " , according to the Sydney Morning Herald . By this time , " her skin was weeping , her body malnourished and her corneas melting " , according to the Sydney Morning Herald . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 464-476 496-502 Gloria was finally taken to the emergency department shortly before her death . according to the Sydney Morning Herald . 464-476 477-502 Gloria was finally taken to the emergency department shortly before her death . By this time , " her skin was weeping , her body malnourished and her corneas melting " , according to the Sydney Morning Herald . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_homeopathic 503-509 516-517,532-542 Speaking in the parents ' defense , that , <*> they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . 503-542 503-542 Speaking in the parents ' defense , Tom Molomby , SC , said that , as the parents came from India , where homeopathy is in common use , they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . Speaking in the parents ' defense , Tom Molomby , SC , said that , as the parents came from India , where homeopathy is in common use , they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . 1>2 manner manner +GUM_news_homeopathic 510-515 516-517,532-542 Tom Molomby , SC , said that , <*> they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . 503-542 503-542 Speaking in the parents ' defense , Tom Molomby , SC , said that , as the parents came from India , where homeopathy is in common use , they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . Speaking in the parents ' defense , Tom Molomby , SC , said that , as the parents came from India , where homeopathy is in common use , they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_homeopathic 53-56 516-517,532-542 She died from infection that , <*> they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . 53-82 503-542 She died from infection caused by severe eczema after they shunned effective conventional medical treatments for homeopathy , a form of alternative medicine that has been described as pseudoscience . Speaking in the parents ' defense , Tom Molomby , SC , said that , as the parents came from India , where homeopathy is in common use , they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_homeopathic 518-524 532-542 as the parents came from India , they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . 503-542 503-542 Speaking in the parents ' defense , Tom Molomby , SC , said that , as the parents came from India , where homeopathy is in common use , they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . Speaking in the parents ' defense , Tom Molomby , SC , said that , as the parents came from India , where homeopathy is in common use , they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . 1>2 evidence evidence +GUM_news_homeopathic 518-524 525-531 as the parents came from India , where homeopathy is in common use , 503-542 503-542 Speaking in the parents ' defense , Tom Molomby , SC , said that , as the parents came from India , where homeopathy is in common use , they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . Speaking in the parents ' defense , Tom Molomby , SC , said that , as the parents came from India , where homeopathy is in common use , they should be declared not guilty due to cultural differences . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 17-52 543-549 Thomas Sam , 42 , and his wife Manju Sam , 36 , from Sydney , Australia , are undergoing trial for manslaughter by gross negligence for the death of their nine-month-old child , Gloria . Homeopathy is a form of alternative medicine 17-52 543-576 Thomas Sam , 42 , and his wife Manju Sam , 36 , from Sydney , Australia , are undergoing trial for manslaughter by gross negligence for the death of their nine-month-old child , Gloria . Homeopathy is a form of alternative medicine which treats patients with massively diluted forms of substances that , if given to a healthy person undiluted , would cause symptoms similar to the disease . 1<2 background background +GUM_news_homeopathic 543-549 550-558 Homeopathy is a form of alternative medicine which treats patients with massively diluted forms of substances 543-576 543-576 Homeopathy is a form of alternative medicine which treats patients with massively diluted forms of substances that , if given to a healthy person undiluted , would cause symptoms similar to the disease . Homeopathy is a form of alternative medicine which treats patients with massively diluted forms of substances that , if given to a healthy person undiluted , would cause symptoms similar to the disease . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 550-558 559-560,569-576 which treats patients with massively diluted forms of substances that , <*> would cause symptoms similar to the disease . 543-576 543-576 Homeopathy is a form of alternative medicine which treats patients with massively diluted forms of substances that , if given to a healthy person undiluted , would cause symptoms similar to the disease . Homeopathy is a form of alternative medicine which treats patients with massively diluted forms of substances that , if given to a healthy person undiluted , would cause symptoms similar to the disease . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 561-568 569-576 if given to a healthy person undiluted , would cause symptoms similar to the disease . 543-576 543-576 Homeopathy is a form of alternative medicine which treats patients with massively diluted forms of substances that , if given to a healthy person undiluted , would cause symptoms similar to the disease . Homeopathy is a form of alternative medicine which treats patients with massively diluted forms of substances that , if given to a healthy person undiluted , would cause symptoms similar to the disease . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_news_homeopathic 543-549 577-595 Homeopathy is a form of alternative medicine Typical treatments take the dilutions , with ritualised shaking between each step of the dilution , past the level 543-576 577-626 Homeopathy is a form of alternative medicine which treats patients with massively diluted forms of substances that , if given to a healthy person undiluted , would cause symptoms similar to the disease . Typical treatments take the dilutions , with ritualised shaking between each step of the dilution , past the level where any molecules of the original substance are likely to remain ; for homeopathic treatments to work , basic well-understood concepts in chemistry and physics would have to be wrong . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 577-595 596-607 Typical treatments take the dilutions , with ritualised shaking between each step of the dilution , past the level where any molecules of the original substance are likely to remain ; 577-626 577-626 Typical treatments take the dilutions , with ritualised shaking between each step of the dilution , past the level where any molecules of the original substance are likely to remain ; for homeopathic treatments to work , basic well-understood concepts in chemistry and physics would have to be wrong . Typical treatments take the dilutions , with ritualised shaking between each step of the dilution , past the level where any molecules of the original substance are likely to remain ; for homeopathic treatments to work , basic well-understood concepts in chemistry and physics would have to be wrong . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_homeopathic 608-613 614-626 for homeopathic treatments to work , basic well-understood concepts in chemistry and physics would have to be wrong . 577-626 577-626 Typical treatments take the dilutions , with ritualised shaking between each step of the dilution , past the level where any molecules of the original substance are likely to remain ; for homeopathic treatments to work , basic well-understood concepts in chemistry and physics would have to be wrong . Typical treatments take the dilutions , with ritualised shaking between each step of the dilution , past the level where any molecules of the original substance are likely to remain ; for homeopathic treatments to work , basic well-understood concepts in chemistry and physics would have to be wrong . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_news_homeopathic 577-595 614-626 Typical treatments take the dilutions , with ritualised shaking between each step of the dilution , past the level basic well-understood concepts in chemistry and physics would have to be wrong . 577-626 577-626 Typical treatments take the dilutions , with ritualised shaking between each step of the dilution , past the level where any molecules of the original substance are likely to remain ; for homeopathic treatments to work , basic well-understood concepts in chemistry and physics would have to be wrong . Typical treatments take the dilutions , with ritualised shaking between each step of the dilution , past the level where any molecules of the original substance are likely to remain ; for homeopathic treatments to work , basic well-understood concepts in chemistry and physics would have to be wrong . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_news_homeopathic 614-626 627-630 basic well-understood concepts in chemistry and physics would have to be wrong . There is no evidence 577-626 627-641 Typical treatments take the dilutions , with ritualised shaking between each step of the dilution , past the level where any molecules of the original substance are likely to remain ; for homeopathic treatments to work , basic well-understood concepts in chemistry and physics would have to be wrong . There is no evidence that homeopathy is more effective than placebo for any condition . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_news_homeopathic 627-630 631-641 There is no evidence that homeopathy is more effective than placebo for any condition . 627-641 627-641 There is no evidence that homeopathy is more effective than placebo for any condition . There is no evidence that homeopathy is more effective than placebo for any condition . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 1-6 13-27 Australian children suffering from iodine deficiency Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , 1-6 13-30 Australian children suffering from iodine deficiency Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_news_iodine 7-12 13-27 Thursday , February 23 , 2006 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , 7-12 13-30 Thursday , February 23 , 2006 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 28-30 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . 13-30 13-30 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 31-33,42-43 44-49 A new study <*> has revealed many are not getting enough iodine 31-59 31-59 A new study documenting iodine nutritional status in Australian school children has revealed many are not getting enough iodine - which can lead to mental and growth retardation . A new study documenting iodine nutritional status in Australian school children has revealed many are not getting enough iodine - which can lead to mental and growth retardation . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 31-33,42-43 34-41 A new study <*> has revealed documenting iodine nutritional status in Australian school children 31-59 31-59 A new study documenting iodine nutritional status in Australian school children has revealed many are not getting enough iodine - which can lead to mental and growth retardation . A new study documenting iodine nutritional status in Australian school children has revealed many are not getting enough iodine - which can lead to mental and growth retardation . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 44-49 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , many are not getting enough iodine 13-30 31-59 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . A new study documenting iodine nutritional status in Australian school children has revealed many are not getting enough iodine - which can lead to mental and growth retardation . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 44-49 50-59 many are not getting enough iodine - which can lead to mental and growth retardation . 31-59 31-59 A new study documenting iodine nutritional status in Australian school children has revealed many are not getting enough iodine - which can lead to mental and growth retardation . A new study documenting iodine nutritional status in Australian school children has revealed many are not getting enough iodine - which can lead to mental and growth retardation . 1<2 result result +GUM_news_iodine 60-64 65-83 The report 's authors say iodine deficiency is " the sleeper health issue in Australia " , and potentially a very serious one . 60-83 60-83 The report 's authors say iodine deficiency is " the sleeper health issue in Australia " , and potentially a very serious one . The report 's authors say iodine deficiency is " the sleeper health issue in Australia " , and potentially a very serious one . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 65-83 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , iodine deficiency is " the sleeper health issue in Australia " , and potentially a very serious one . 13-30 60-83 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . The report 's authors say iodine deficiency is " the sleeper health issue in Australia " , and potentially a very serious one . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 84-92,104-113 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , The results of the Australian National Iodine Nutrition Study <*> that children in mainland Australia are borderline iodine deficient . 13-30 84-113 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . The results of the Australian National Iodine Nutrition Study published in the Medical Journal of Australia this week , revealed that children in mainland Australia are borderline iodine deficient . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_news_iodine 84-92,104-113 93-102 The results of the Australian National Iodine Nutrition Study <*> that children in mainland Australia are borderline iodine deficient . published in the Medical Journal of Australia this week , 84-113 84-113 The results of the Australian National Iodine Nutrition Study published in the Medical Journal of Australia this week , revealed that children in mainland Australia are borderline iodine deficient . The results of the Australian National Iodine Nutrition Study published in the Medical Journal of Australia this week , revealed that children in mainland Australia are borderline iodine deficient . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 103 104-113 revealed that children in mainland Australia are borderline iodine deficient . 84-113 84-113 The results of the Australian National Iodine Nutrition Study published in the Medical Journal of Australia this week , revealed that children in mainland Australia are borderline iodine deficient . The results of the Australian National Iodine Nutrition Study published in the Medical Journal of Australia this week , revealed that children in mainland Australia are borderline iodine deficient . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 114-126 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , The report has prompted calls for all edible salt to be iodised . 13-30 114-126 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . The report has prompted calls for all edible salt to be iodised . 1<2 result result +GUM_news_iodine 127-128 129-140 They say adding the mineral to salt is the simplest and most effective method 127-146 127-146 They say adding the mineral to salt is the simplest and most effective method of preventing iodine deficiency disorders . They say adding the mineral to salt is the simplest and most effective method of preventing iodine deficiency disorders . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 114-126 129-140 The report has prompted calls for all edible salt to be iodised . adding the mineral to salt is the simplest and most effective method 114-126 127-146 The report has prompted calls for all edible salt to be iodised . They say adding the mineral to salt is the simplest and most effective method of preventing iodine deficiency disorders . 1<2 background background +GUM_news_iodine 129-140 141-146 adding the mineral to salt is the simplest and most effective method of preventing iodine deficiency disorders . 127-146 127-146 They say adding the mineral to salt is the simplest and most effective method of preventing iodine deficiency disorders . They say adding the mineral to salt is the simplest and most effective method of preventing iodine deficiency disorders . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 147-152,164-188 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , A cross-sectional survey of 1709 schoolchildren <*> was carried out in New South Wales , Victoria , South Australia , Western Australia and Queensland , between July 2003 and December 2004 . 13-30 147-188 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . A cross-sectional survey of 1709 schoolchildren - aged 8 – 10 years , from 88 schools - was carried out in New South Wales , Victoria , South Australia , Western Australia and Queensland , between July 2003 and December 2004 . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 147-152,164-188 153-163 A cross-sectional survey of 1709 schoolchildren <*> was carried out in New South Wales , Victoria , South Australia , Western Australia and Queensland , between July 2003 and December 2004 . - aged 8 – 10 years , from 88 schools - 147-188 147-188 A cross-sectional survey of 1709 schoolchildren - aged 8 – 10 years , from 88 schools - was carried out in New South Wales , Victoria , South Australia , Western Australia and Queensland , between July 2003 and December 2004 . A cross-sectional survey of 1709 schoolchildren - aged 8 – 10 years , from 88 schools - was carried out in New South Wales , Victoria , South Australia , Western Australia and Queensland , between July 2003 and December 2004 . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 147-152,164-188 189-194 A cross-sectional survey of 1709 schoolchildren <*> was carried out in New South Wales , Victoria , South Australia , Western Australia and Queensland , between July 2003 and December 2004 . Tasmania was excluded from the study 147-188 189-210 A cross-sectional survey of 1709 schoolchildren - aged 8 – 10 years , from 88 schools - was carried out in New South Wales , Victoria , South Australia , Western Australia and Queensland , between July 2003 and December 2004 . Tasmania was excluded from the study - where an voluntary iodine fortification program using iodised salt in bread , is ongoing . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 189-194 195-201,208-210 Tasmania was excluded from the study - where an voluntary iodine fortification program <*> is ongoing . 189-210 189-210 Tasmania was excluded from the study - where an voluntary iodine fortification program using iodised salt in bread , is ongoing . Tasmania was excluded from the study - where an voluntary iodine fortification program using iodised salt in bread , is ongoing . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_news_iodine 195-201,208-210 202-207 - where an voluntary iodine fortification program <*> is ongoing . using iodised salt in bread , 189-210 189-210 Tasmania was excluded from the study - where an voluntary iodine fortification program using iodised salt in bread , is ongoing . Tasmania was excluded from the study - where an voluntary iodine fortification program using iodised salt in bread , is ongoing . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 211-213 214-227 The authors say the results confirm the existence of inadequate iodine intake in the Australian population . 211-227 211-227 The authors say the results confirm the existence of inadequate iodine intake in the Australian population . The authors say the results confirm the existence of inadequate iodine intake in the Australian population . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 214-227 228-244 the results confirm the existence of inadequate iodine intake in the Australian population . They call for " urgent implementation of mandatory iodisation of all edible salt in Australia . " 211-227 228-244 The authors say the results confirm the existence of inadequate iodine intake in the Australian population . They call for " urgent implementation of mandatory iodisation of all edible salt in Australia . " 1>2 justify justify +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 228-244 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , They call for " urgent implementation of mandatory iodisation of all edible salt in Australia . " 13-30 228-244 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . They call for " urgent implementation of mandatory iodisation of all edible salt in Australia . " 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 245-257 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , Most iodine in food comes from seafood , milk and iodised salt . 13-30 245-257 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . Most iodine in food comes from seafood , milk and iodised salt . 1<2 background background +GUM_news_iodine 258-283 284-300 Professor Cres Eastman , Director of the National Iodine Nutrition study , and Chairman of the Australian Centre for Control of Iodine Deficiency Disorders , says it is crucial that children and pregnant women in particular have an adequate intake of iodine . 258-300 258-300 Professor Cres Eastman , Director of the National Iodine Nutrition study , and Chairman of the Australian Centre for Control of Iodine Deficiency Disorders , says it is crucial that children and pregnant women in particular have an adequate intake of iodine . Professor Cres Eastman , Director of the National Iodine Nutrition study , and Chairman of the Australian Centre for Control of Iodine Deficiency Disorders , says it is crucial that children and pregnant women in particular have an adequate intake of iodine . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 284-300 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , it is crucial that children and pregnant women in particular have an adequate intake of iodine . 13-30 258-300 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . Professor Cres Eastman , Director of the National Iodine Nutrition study , and Chairman of the Australian Centre for Control of Iodine Deficiency Disorders , says it is crucial that children and pregnant women in particular have an adequate intake of iodine . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 284-300 301-308 it is crucial that children and pregnant women in particular have an adequate intake of iodine . Iodine deficiency can lead to serious health problems 258-300 301-317 Professor Cres Eastman , Director of the National Iodine Nutrition study , and Chairman of the Australian Centre for Control of Iodine Deficiency Disorders , says it is crucial that children and pregnant women in particular have an adequate intake of iodine . Iodine deficiency can lead to serious health problems including brain damage , stunted growth and deafness . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_news_iodine 301-308 309-317 Iodine deficiency can lead to serious health problems including brain damage , stunted growth and deafness . 301-317 301-317 Iodine deficiency can lead to serious health problems including brain damage , stunted growth and deafness . Iodine deficiency can lead to serious health problems including brain damage , stunted growth and deafness . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 318-320 321-326 Professor Eastman says manufacturers could easily remedy the situation 318-344 318-344 Professor Eastman says manufacturers could easily remedy the situation by using iodised salt in their products in line with the United States and most European countries . Professor Eastman says manufacturers could easily remedy the situation by using iodised salt in their products in line with the United States and most European countries . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 321-326 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , manufacturers could easily remedy the situation 13-30 318-344 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . Professor Eastman says manufacturers could easily remedy the situation by using iodised salt in their products in line with the United States and most European countries . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 321-326 327-344 manufacturers could easily remedy the situation by using iodised salt in their products in line with the United States and most European countries . 318-344 318-344 Professor Eastman says manufacturers could easily remedy the situation by using iodised salt in their products in line with the United States and most European countries . Professor Eastman says manufacturers could easily remedy the situation by using iodised salt in their products in line with the United States and most European countries . 1<2 means means +GUM_news_iodine 345-347 348-357 " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , 345-391 345-391 " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 321-326 348-357 manufacturers could easily remedy the situation they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , 318-344 345-391 Professor Eastman says manufacturers could easily remedy the situation by using iodised salt in their products in line with the United States and most European countries . " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_news_iodine 348-357 358-362 they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far 345-391 345-391 " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 358-362 363-367 we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , 345-391 345-391 " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_news_iodine 368-380 381-388 so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " 345-391 345-391 " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 348-357 381-388 they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , that all salt should be iodised , " 345-391 345-391 " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . 1<2 result result +GUM_news_iodine 348-357 389-391 they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , he said . 345-391 345-391 " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . " I suspect they wo n't do that on a voluntary basis , we 've tried so far and have n't succeeded , so we 've convinced the Food Standards of Australia and New Zealand | that all salt should be iodised , " he said . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 392-394 395-410 The report says the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , 392-418 392-418 The report says the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , where chlorine-containing sanitisers have replaced iodine-containing sanitisers . The report says the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , where chlorine-containing sanitisers have replaced iodine-containing sanitisers . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 395-410 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , 13-30 392-418 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . The report says the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , where chlorine-containing sanitisers have replaced iodine-containing sanitisers . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 395-410 411-418 the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , where chlorine-containing sanitisers have replaced iodine-containing sanitisers . 392-418 392-418 The report says the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , where chlorine-containing sanitisers have replaced iodine-containing sanitisers . The report says the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , where chlorine-containing sanitisers have replaced iodine-containing sanitisers . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 395-410 419,426-441 the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , Iodine <*> has been the major source of dietary iodine in Australia for at least four decades , 392-418 419-446 The report says the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , where chlorine-containing sanitisers have replaced iodine-containing sanitisers . Iodine released from these chemicals into milk has been the major source of dietary iodine in Australia for at least four decades , but is now declining . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_news_iodine 419,426-441 420-425 Iodine <*> has been the major source of dietary iodine in Australia for at least four decades , released from these chemicals into milk 419-446 419-446 Iodine released from these chemicals into milk has been the major source of dietary iodine in Australia for at least four decades , but is now declining . Iodine released from these chemicals into milk has been the major source of dietary iodine in Australia for at least four decades , but is now declining . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 419,426-441 442-446 Iodine <*> has been the major source of dietary iodine in Australia for at least four decades , but is now declining . 419-446 419-446 Iodine released from these chemicals into milk has been the major source of dietary iodine in Australia for at least four decades , but is now declining . Iodine released from these chemicals into milk has been the major source of dietary iodine in Australia for at least four decades , but is now declining . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_news_iodine 395-410 447-457 the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , Another contributory factor has been the decreasing consumption of iodised salt 392-418 447-461 The report says the decline in iodine intake appears to be due to changes in the dairy industry , where chlorine-containing sanitisers have replaced iodine-containing sanitisers . Another contributory factor has been the decreasing consumption of iodised salt used in foods . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 447-457 458-461 Another contributory factor has been the decreasing consumption of iodised salt used in foods . 447-461 447-461 Another contributory factor has been the decreasing consumption of iodised salt used in foods . Another contributory factor has been the decreasing consumption of iodised salt used in foods . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 462-464 465-481 The report states that few if any food manufacturers use iodised salt in the preparation and manufacture of foods . 462-481 462-481 The report states that few if any food manufacturers use iodised salt in the preparation and manufacture of foods . The report states that few if any food manufacturers use iodised salt in the preparation and manufacture of foods . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 447-457 465-481 Another contributory factor has been the decreasing consumption of iodised salt that few if any food manufacturers use iodised salt in the preparation and manufacture of foods . 447-461 462-481 Another contributory factor has been the decreasing consumption of iodised salt used in foods . The report states that few if any food manufacturers use iodised salt in the preparation and manufacture of foods . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_news_iodine 482-484 485-503 Professor Eastman says iodine is added to only 10 per cent of Australian salt in contravention of a World Health Organisation recommendation 482-509 482-509 Professor Eastman says iodine is added to only 10 per cent of Australian salt in contravention of a World Health Organisation recommendation that all salt be iodised . Professor Eastman says iodine is added to only 10 per cent of Australian salt in contravention of a World Health Organisation recommendation that all salt be iodised . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 485-503 512-524 iodine is added to only 10 per cent of Australian salt in contravention of a World Health Organisation recommendation authorities are reacting slowly to his urgent calls for mandatory iodised salt . 482-509 510-524 Professor Eastman says iodine is added to only 10 per cent of Australian salt in contravention of a World Health Organisation recommendation that all salt be iodised . He says authorities are reacting slowly to his urgent calls for mandatory iodised salt . 1>2 background background +GUM_news_iodine 485-503 504-509 iodine is added to only 10 per cent of Australian salt in contravention of a World Health Organisation recommendation that all salt be iodised . 482-509 482-509 Professor Eastman says iodine is added to only 10 per cent of Australian salt in contravention of a World Health Organisation recommendation that all salt be iodised . Professor Eastman says iodine is added to only 10 per cent of Australian salt in contravention of a World Health Organisation recommendation that all salt be iodised . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 510-511 512-524 He says authorities are reacting slowly to his urgent calls for mandatory iodised salt . 510-524 510-524 He says authorities are reacting slowly to his urgent calls for mandatory iodised salt . He says authorities are reacting slowly to his urgent calls for mandatory iodised salt . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 512-524 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , authorities are reacting slowly to his urgent calls for mandatory iodised salt . 13-30 510-524 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . He says authorities are reacting slowly to his urgent calls for mandatory iodised salt . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 525-542 543,559-566 " The effects of iodine deficiency are dependent upon how severe it is and when it occurs . So <*> she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , 525-542 543-614 " The effects of iodine deficiency are dependent upon how severe it is and when it occurs . So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . 1>2 background background +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 543,559-566 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , So <*> she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , 13-30 543-614 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 544-551 559-566 if we go to the pregnant woman , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , 543-614 543-614 So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_news_iodine 552-558 559-566 she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , 543-614 543-614 So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_news_iodine 559-566 567-577 she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone 543-614 543-614 So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . 1<2 result result +GUM_news_iodine 567-577 578-588 and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , 543-614 543-614 So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 567-577 589-610 and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " 543-614 543-614 So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . 1<2 result result +GUM_news_iodine 543,559-566 611-614 So <*> she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , Professor Eastman said . 543-614 543-614 So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 615-624 625-630 " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed 615-680 615-680 " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " 1>2 condition condition +GUM_news_iodine 543,559-566 625-630 So <*> she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , brain development wo n't be completed 543-614 615-680 So if we go to the pregnant woman , she does n't get enough iodine , she wo n't make enough thyroid hormone , and the foetus wo n't get the amount of thyroid hormone it needs for adequate and proper development of the brain , so you 'll then see consequences being loss of IQ , learning difficulties , hearing difficulties and other neurological problems , " Professor Eastman said . " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 625-630 631-637 brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , 615-680 615-680 " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 638-642 643-652 and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter 615-680 615-680 " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_news_iodine 625-630 643-652 brain development wo n't be completed the problem will be that you will develop a goiter 615-680 615-680 " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_news_iodine 643-652 653-660 the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well 615-680 615-680 " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 653-660 661-664 and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , 615-680 615-680 " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " 1<2 manner manner +GUM_news_iodine 625-630 665-680 brain development wo n't be completed so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " 615-680 615-680 " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " " If an infant 's not getting enough iodine ... brain development wo n't be completed and they wo n't grow normally , and as you get older the problem will be that you will develop a goiter and your thyroid wo n't function as well as it should , so that may have all sorts of pernicious effects upon normal function in life . " 1<2 result result +GUM_news_iodine 681-696 713-721 More than two billion people around the world live in areas prone to iodine deficiency , that every country should iodise all edible salt . 681-704 705-721 More than two billion people around the world live in areas prone to iodine deficiency , and yet the problem is easily fixed . The World Health Organisation ( WHO ) recommends that every country should iodise all edible salt . 1>2 background background +GUM_news_iodine 681-696 697-704 More than two billion people around the world live in areas prone to iodine deficiency , and yet the problem is easily fixed . 681-704 681-704 More than two billion people around the world live in areas prone to iodine deficiency , and yet the problem is easily fixed . More than two billion people around the world live in areas prone to iodine deficiency , and yet the problem is easily fixed . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_news_iodine 705-708,712 713-721 The World Health Organisation <*> recommends that every country should iodise all edible salt . 705-721 705-721 The World Health Organisation ( WHO ) recommends that every country should iodise all edible salt . The World Health Organisation ( WHO ) recommends that every country should iodise all edible salt . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 705-708,712 709-711 The World Health Organisation <*> recommends ( WHO ) 705-721 705-721 The World Health Organisation ( WHO ) recommends that every country should iodise all edible salt . The World Health Organisation ( WHO ) recommends that every country should iodise all edible salt . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 713-721 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , that every country should iodise all edible salt . 13-30 705-721 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . The World Health Organisation ( WHO ) recommends that every country should iodise all edible salt . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 713-721 722-736 that every country should iodise all edible salt . The most well known effects of IDD are visible goiter and cretinism , a condition 705-721 722-747 The World Health Organisation ( WHO ) recommends that every country should iodise all edible salt . The most well known effects of IDD are visible goiter and cretinism , a condition characterised by severe brain damage occurring in very early life . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_news_iodine 722-736 737-741 The most well known effects of IDD are visible goiter and cretinism , a condition characterised by severe brain damage 722-747 722-747 The most well known effects of IDD are visible goiter and cretinism , a condition characterised by severe brain damage occurring in very early life . The most well known effects of IDD are visible goiter and cretinism , a condition characterised by severe brain damage occurring in very early life . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 737-741 742-747 characterised by severe brain damage occurring in very early life . 722-747 722-747 The most well known effects of IDD are visible goiter and cretinism , a condition characterised by severe brain damage occurring in very early life . The most well known effects of IDD are visible goiter and cretinism , a condition characterised by severe brain damage occurring in very early life . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 748-749 750-767 WHO say Iodine deficiency is the world ’s most prevalent , yet easily preventable , cause of brain damage . 748-767 748-767 WHO say Iodine deficiency is the world ’s most prevalent , yet easily preventable , cause of brain damage . WHO say Iodine deficiency is the world ’s most prevalent , yet easily preventable , cause of brain damage . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 722-736 750-767 The most well known effects of IDD are visible goiter and cretinism , a condition Iodine deficiency is the world ’s most prevalent , yet easily preventable , cause of brain damage . 722-747 748-767 The most well known effects of IDD are visible goiter and cretinism , a condition characterised by severe brain damage occurring in very early life . WHO say Iodine deficiency is the world ’s most prevalent , yet easily preventable , cause of brain damage . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 768-770 771-778 Professor Eastman said he is alarmed by what they found . 768-778 768-778 Professor Eastman said he is alarmed by what they found . Professor Eastman said he is alarmed by what they found . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 771-778 779-789 he is alarmed by what they found . " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much 768-778 779-798 Professor Eastman said he is alarmed by what they found . " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much as what they require on a daily basis . 1>2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 779-789 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much 13-30 779-798 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much as what they require on a daily basis . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 779-789 790-798 " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much as what they require on a daily basis . 779-798 779-798 " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much as what they require on a daily basis . " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much as what they require on a daily basis . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_news_iodine 779-789 799-803 " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much So that alarms me , 779-798 799-830 " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much as what they require on a daily basis . So that alarms me , because there 's quite serious potential for adverse effects and brain damage in the next generation of children born in this country , " he said . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_news_iodine 799-803 804-821 So that alarms me , because there 's quite serious potential for adverse effects and brain damage in the next generation of children 799-830 799-830 So that alarms me , because there 's quite serious potential for adverse effects and brain damage in the next generation of children born in this country , " he said . So that alarms me , because there 's quite serious potential for adverse effects and brain damage in the next generation of children born in this country , " he said . 1<2 result result +GUM_news_iodine 804-821 822-827 because there 's quite serious potential for adverse effects and brain damage in the next generation of children born in this country , " 799-830 799-830 So that alarms me , because there 's quite serious potential for adverse effects and brain damage in the next generation of children born in this country , " he said . So that alarms me , because there 's quite serious potential for adverse effects and brain damage in the next generation of children born in this country , " he said . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 779-789 828-830 " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much he said . 779-798 799-830 " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much as what they require on a daily basis . So that alarms me , because there 's quite serious potential for adverse effects and brain damage in the next generation of children born in this country , " he said . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 831-836 837-845 " If Iodine deficiency is serious you lose 15 IQ points , on average . 831-845 831-845 " If Iodine deficiency is serious you lose 15 IQ points , on average . " If Iodine deficiency is serious you lose 15 IQ points , on average . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_news_iodine 837-845 846-850 you lose 15 IQ points , on average . There should n't be anyone 831-845 846-862 " If Iodine deficiency is serious you lose 15 IQ points , on average . There should n't be anyone suffering from iodine deficiency in a developed country like Australia . " 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_news_iodine 779-789 846-850 " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much There should n't be anyone 779-798 846-862 " Pregnant women in Australia are getting about half as much as what they require on a daily basis . There should n't be anyone suffering from iodine deficiency in a developed country like Australia . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 846-850 851-862 There should n't be anyone suffering from iodine deficiency in a developed country like Australia . " 846-862 846-862 There should n't be anyone suffering from iodine deficiency in a developed country like Australia . " There should n't be anyone suffering from iodine deficiency in a developed country like Australia . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 863-872 873-887 Lydia Buchtmann for Food Standards Australia New Zealand , says they are looking at mandatory guidelines on iodine by the end of the year . 863-887 863-887 Lydia Buchtmann for Food Standards Australia New Zealand , says they are looking at mandatory guidelines on iodine by the end of the year . Lydia Buchtmann for Food Standards Australia New Zealand , says they are looking at mandatory guidelines on iodine by the end of the year . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 873-887 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , they are looking at mandatory guidelines on iodine by the end of the year . 13-30 863-887 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . Lydia Buchtmann for Food Standards Australia New Zealand , says they are looking at mandatory guidelines on iodine by the end of the year . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 888-889 890-893 She says the issue is complicated 888-901 888-901 She says the issue is complicated and will take time to get right . She says the issue is complicated and will take time to get right . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 873-887 890-893 they are looking at mandatory guidelines on iodine by the end of the year . the issue is complicated 863-887 888-901 Lydia Buchtmann for Food Standards Australia New Zealand , says they are looking at mandatory guidelines on iodine by the end of the year . She says the issue is complicated and will take time to get right . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_news_iodine 890-893 894-901 the issue is complicated and will take time to get right . 888-901 888-901 She says the issue is complicated and will take time to get right . She says the issue is complicated and will take time to get right . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 873-887 902-911 they are looking at mandatory guidelines on iodine by the end of the year . We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine 863-887 902-925 Lydia Buchtmann for Food Standards Australia New Zealand , says they are looking at mandatory guidelines on iodine by the end of the year . We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine added into the food supply , to help those people with a deficiency . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 902-911 912-917 We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine added into the food supply , 902-925 902-925 We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine added into the food supply , to help those people with a deficiency . We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine added into the food supply , to help those people with a deficiency . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 902-911 918-925 We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine to help those people with a deficiency . 902-925 902-925 We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine added into the food supply , to help those people with a deficiency . We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine added into the food supply , to help those people with a deficiency . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_news_iodine 902-911 926-941,968-975 We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people <*> that those people do n't get too much 902-925 926-984 We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine added into the food supply , to help those people with a deficiency . But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_news_iodine 926-941,968-975 942-947 But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people <*> that those people do n't get too much who eat a lot of food 926-984 926-984 But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 926-941,968-975 948-954 But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people <*> that those people do n't get too much - we all know the teenage boy 926-984 926-984 But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_news_iodine 948-954 955-959 - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school 926-984 926-984 But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 955-959 960-967 who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - 926-984 926-984 But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 926-941,968-975 976-980 But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people <*> that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " 926-984 926-984 But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . 1<2 result result +GUM_news_iodine 902-911 981-984 We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine Ms Bauchtman said . 902-925 926-984 We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine added into the food supply , to help those people with a deficiency . But at the other end of the scale we 've got to make sure the people who eat a lot of food - we all know the teenage boy who comes home from school and eats a whole loaf of bread - that those people do n't get too much and get overdose , " Ms Bauchtman said . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_news_iodine 985-989,995-1004 1005-1012 " One of the reasons <*> is because people are taking that good healthy eating message and not adding salt during cooking . " 985-1012 985-1012 " One of the reasons that iodine is going down is because people are taking that good healthy eating message and not adding salt during cooking . " " One of the reasons that iodine is going down is because people are taking that good healthy eating message and not adding salt during cooking . " 1>2 cause cause +GUM_news_iodine 985-989,995-1004 990-994 " One of the reasons <*> is because people are taking that good healthy eating message that iodine is going down 985-1012 985-1012 " One of the reasons that iodine is going down is because people are taking that good healthy eating message and not adding salt during cooking . " " One of the reasons that iodine is going down is because people are taking that good healthy eating message and not adding salt during cooking . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 902-911 1005-1012 We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine and not adding salt during cooking . " 902-925 985-1012 We need to " make sure there 's sufficient iodine added into the food supply , to help those people with a deficiency . " One of the reasons that iodine is going down is because people are taking that good healthy eating message and not adding salt during cooking . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_news_iodine 1013-1029 1030-1046 Senior researcher Mu Li , of the University of NSW 's school of public health , said " it is reasonable to assume that pregnant women and breastfeeding mothers are also iodine deficient , 1013-1067 1013-1067 Senior researcher Mu Li , of the University of NSW 's school of public health , said " it is reasonable to assume that pregnant women and breastfeeding mothers are also iodine deficient , putting the next generation of children born in this country at risk of the neuropsychological consequences of iodine deficiency . " Senior researcher Mu Li , of the University of NSW 's school of public health , said " it is reasonable to assume that pregnant women and breastfeeding mothers are also iodine deficient , putting the next generation of children born in this country at risk of the neuropsychological consequences of iodine deficiency . " 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_news_iodine 13-27 1030-1046 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , " it is reasonable to assume that pregnant women and breastfeeding mothers are also iodine deficient , 13-30 1013-1067 Almost half of all Australian primary school children are mild to moderately iodine deficient , researchers say . Senior researcher Mu Li , of the University of NSW 's school of public health , said " it is reasonable to assume that pregnant women and breastfeeding mothers are also iodine deficient , putting the next generation of children born in this country at risk of the neuropsychological consequences of iodine deficiency . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_news_iodine 1030-1046 1047-1052,1057-1067 " it is reasonable to assume that pregnant women and breastfeeding mothers are also iodine deficient , putting the next generation of children <*> at risk of the neuropsychological consequences of iodine deficiency . " 1013-1067 1013-1067 Senior researcher Mu Li , of the University of NSW 's school of public health , said " it is reasonable to assume that pregnant women and breastfeeding mothers are also iodine deficient , putting the next generation of children born in this country at risk of the neuropsychological consequences of iodine deficiency . " Senior researcher Mu Li , of the University of NSW 's school of public health , said " it is reasonable to assume that pregnant women and breastfeeding mothers are also iodine deficient , putting the next generation of children born in this country at risk of the neuropsychological consequences of iodine deficiency . " 1<2 result result +GUM_news_iodine 1047-1052,1057-1067 1053-1056 putting the next generation of children <*> at risk of the neuropsychological consequences of iodine deficiency . " born in this country 1013-1067 1013-1067 Senior researcher Mu Li , of the University of NSW 's school of public health , said " it is reasonable to assume that pregnant women and breastfeeding mothers are also iodine deficient , putting the next generation of children born in this country at risk of the neuropsychological consequences of iodine deficiency . " Senior researcher Mu Li , of the University of NSW 's school of public health , said " it is reasonable to assume that pregnant women and breastfeeding mothers are also iodine deficient , putting the next generation of children born in this country at risk of the neuropsychological consequences of iodine deficiency . " 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1-2 18-23 ____ _ _____ ___ ____ _________ ____ _ 1-2 3-23 ____ _ __ _____ _____ _______ __ __ ________ _ __ ___ _________ _ __ ____ _ _____ ___ ____ _________ ____ _ 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 3-9,15-17 18-23 __ _____ _____ _______ __ __ ________ <*> __ ____ _ _____ ___ ____ _________ ____ _ 3-23 3-23 __ _____ _____ _______ __ __ ________ _ __ ___ _________ _ __ ____ _ _____ ___ ____ _________ ____ _ __ _____ _____ _______ __ __ ________ _ __ ___ _________ _ __ ____ _ _____ ___ ____ _________ ____ _ 1>2 background background +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 3-9,15-17 10-14 __ _____ _____ _______ __ __ ________ <*> __ ____ _ _ __ ___ _________ _ 3-23 3-23 __ _____ _____ _______ __ __ ________ _ __ ___ _________ _ __ ____ _ _____ ___ ____ _________ ____ _ __ _____ _____ _______ __ __ ________ _ __ ___ _________ _ __ ____ _ _____ ___ ____ _________ ____ _ 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 18-23 24-31 _____ ___ ____ _________ ____ _ ___ ___ ______ ____ ____ ___ ______ _ 3-23 24-31 __ _____ _____ _______ __ __ ________ _ __ ___ _________ _ __ ____ _ _____ ___ ____ _________ ____ _ ___ ___ ______ ____ ____ ___ ______ _ 1>2 question question +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 24-31 32-33,37-39,46 ___ ___ ______ ____ ____ ___ ______ _ ___ _____ <*> __ _______ _______ <*> _____ 24-31 32-84 ___ ___ ______ ____ ____ ___ ______ _ ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 32-33,37-39,46 34-36 ___ _____ <*> __ _______ _______ <*> _____ ____ __ _______ 32-84 32-84 ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 37-39 40-45 __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ 32-84 32-84 ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 32-33,37-39,46 47-61 ___ _____ <*> __ _______ _______ <*> _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ 32-84 32-84 ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 47-61 62-72 __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ 32-84 32-84 ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 62-72 73-84 _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ 32-84 32-84 ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ 1<2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 85-90 91-98 ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ _ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ 85-104 85-104 ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ _ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ __ _______ __ ___________ _ ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ _ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ __ _______ __ ___________ _ 1>2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 32-33,37-39,46 91-98 ___ _____ <*> __ _______ _______ <*> _____ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ 32-84 85-104 ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ _ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ __ _______ __ ___________ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 91-98 99-104 ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ __ _______ __ ___________ _ 85-104 85-104 ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ _ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ __ _______ __ ___________ _ ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ _ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ __ _______ __ ___________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 91-98 105-107,128-137 ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ _____ ____ <*> ___ _____ __ ___ ______ _____ ________ _____ ______ ____ 85-104 105-142 ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ _ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ __ _______ __ ___________ _ ____ _____ ____ __ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _ _______________________ _ _ ___________ _______ _ __ ___ ____ __ _ ____ _ ___ _____ __ ___ ______ _____ ________ _____ ______ ____ _ ________ ___ _ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 108-115,121-127 128-137 __ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _ _______________________ <*> __ ___ ____ __ _ ____ _ ___ _____ __ ___ ______ _____ ________ _____ ______ ____ 105-142 105-142 ____ _____ ____ __ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _ _______________________ _ _ ___________ _______ _ __ ___ ____ __ _ ____ _ ___ _____ __ ___ ______ _____ ________ _____ ______ ____ _ ________ ___ _ _ ____ _____ ____ __ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _ _______________________ _ _ ___________ _______ _ __ ___ ____ __ _ ____ _ ___ _____ __ ___ ______ _____ ________ _____ ______ ____ _ ________ ___ _ _ 1>2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 108-115,121-127 116-120 __ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _ _______________________ <*> __ ___ ____ __ _ ____ _ _ _ ___________ _______ _ 105-142 105-142 ____ _____ ____ __ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _ _______________________ _ _ ___________ _______ _ __ ___ ____ __ _ ____ _ ___ _____ __ ___ ______ _____ ________ _____ ______ ____ _ ________ ___ _ _ ____ _____ ____ __ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _ _______________________ _ _ ___________ _______ _ __ ___ ____ __ _ ____ _ ___ _____ __ ___ ______ _____ ________ _____ ______ ____ _ ________ ___ _ _ 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 105-107,128-137 138-142 ____ _____ ____ <*> ___ _____ __ ___ ______ _____ ________ _____ ______ ____ _ ________ ___ _ _ 105-142 105-142 ____ _____ ____ __ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _ _______________________ _ _ ___________ _______ _ __ ___ ____ __ _ ____ _ ___ _____ __ ___ ______ _____ ________ _____ ______ ____ _ ________ ___ _ _ ____ _____ ____ __ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _ _______________________ _ _ ___________ _______ _ __ ___ ____ __ _ ____ _ ___ _____ __ ___ ______ _____ ________ _____ ______ ____ _ ________ ___ _ _ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 91-98 143-145 ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ __ _______ 85-104 143-166 ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ _ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ __ _______ __ ___________ _ ____ __ _______ _______ ______ ___ _____ __ ___ __ ____ __ __ ___ _______ ___ __ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ______ _ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 143-145 146-149 ____ __ _______ _______ ______ ___ _____ 143-166 143-166 ____ __ _______ _______ ______ ___ _____ __ ___ __ ____ __ __ ___ _______ ___ __ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ______ _ ____ __ _______ _______ ______ ___ _____ __ ___ __ ____ __ __ ___ _______ ___ __ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ______ _ 1<2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 146-149 150-153 _______ ______ ___ _____ __ ___ __ ____ 143-166 143-166 ____ __ _______ _______ ______ ___ _____ __ ___ __ ____ __ __ ___ _______ ___ __ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ______ _ ____ __ _______ _______ ______ ___ _____ __ ___ __ ____ __ __ ___ _______ ___ __ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ______ _ 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 146-149 154-163 _______ ______ ___ _____ __ __ ___ _______ ___ __ ____ ___ ____ _____ 143-166 143-166 ____ __ _______ _______ ______ ___ _____ __ ___ __ ____ __ __ ___ _______ ___ __ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ______ _ ____ __ _______ _______ ______ ___ _____ __ ___ __ ____ __ __ ___ _______ ___ __ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ______ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 154-163 164-166 __ __ ___ _______ ___ __ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ______ _ 143-166 143-166 ____ __ _______ _______ ______ ___ _____ __ ___ __ ____ __ __ ___ _______ ___ __ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ______ _ ____ __ _______ _______ ______ ___ _____ __ ___ __ ____ __ __ ___ _______ ___ __ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ______ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 91-98 167-169,176-184 ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ___ ____ ______ <*> __ _______ ______ ___ ____ ___ _____ _____ ___ 85-104 167-196 ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ _ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ __ _______ __ ___________ _ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ _______ __ ________ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ ____ ___ _____ _____ ___ ___ ____ _____ ________ __________ _________ _____ _ ___ ______ _ ____ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 167-169,176-184 170-175 ___ ____ ______ <*> __ _______ ______ ___ ____ ___ _____ _____ ___ ____ ____ _______ __ ________ _________ 167-196 167-196 ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ _______ __ ________ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ ____ ___ _____ _____ ___ ___ ____ _____ ________ __________ _________ _____ _ ___ ______ _ ____ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ _______ __ ________ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ ____ ___ _____ _____ ___ ___ ____ _____ ________ __________ _________ _____ _ ___ ______ _ ____ 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 176-184 185-196 __ _______ ______ ___ ____ ___ _____ _____ ___ ___ ____ _____ ________ __________ _________ _____ _ ___ ______ _ ____ 167-196 167-196 ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ _______ __ ________ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ ____ ___ _____ _____ ___ ___ ____ _____ ________ __________ _________ _____ _ ___ ______ _ ____ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ _______ __ ________ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ ____ ___ _____ _____ ___ ___ ____ _____ ________ __________ _________ _____ _ ___ ______ _ ____ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 197-206 207-210 __ ___ ___ _ ________ ____ __ _____ ____ _ _____ __ _ ______ 197-219 197-219 __ ___ ___ _ ________ ____ __ _____ ____ _ _____ __ _ ______ __ _____ __ _____ _ ___ __ _____ _ __ ___ ___ _ ________ ____ __ _____ ____ _ _____ __ _ ______ __ _____ __ _____ _ ___ __ _____ _ 1>2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 207-210 330-336 _____ __ _ ______ __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ 197-219 330-351 __ ___ ___ _ ________ ____ __ _____ ____ _ _____ __ _ ______ __ _____ __ _____ _ ___ __ _____ _ __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ __ _ _ __ ____ ___ __ _____ _______ __ __ _ 1>2 justify justify +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 207-210 211-219 _____ __ _ ______ __ _____ __ _____ _ ___ __ _____ _ 197-219 197-219 __ ___ ___ _ ________ ____ __ _____ ____ _ _____ __ _ ______ __ _____ __ _____ _ ___ __ _____ _ __ ___ ___ _ ________ ____ __ _____ ____ _ _____ __ _ ______ __ _____ __ _____ _ ___ __ _____ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 220-221 222-237 ___ _______ __ ___ ____ _______ ____ _____ _ _____ ____ ____ __ _____ ______ __ _______ _ 220-237 220-237 ___ _______ __ ___ ____ _______ ____ _____ _ _____ ____ ____ __ _____ ______ __ _______ _ ___ _______ __ ___ ____ _______ ____ _____ _ _____ ____ ____ __ _____ ______ __ _______ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 222-237 238-246 __ ___ ____ _______ ____ _____ _ _____ ____ ____ __ _____ ______ __ _______ _ ____ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _______ 220-237 238-259 ___ _______ __ ___ ____ _______ ____ _____ _ _____ ____ ____ __ _____ ______ __ _______ _ ____ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ ________ ___ __ ___ _ 1>2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 207-210 238-246 _____ __ _ ______ ____ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _______ 197-219 238-259 __ ___ ___ _ ________ ____ __ _____ ____ _ _____ __ _ ______ __ _____ __ _____ _ ___ __ _____ _ ____ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ ________ ___ __ ___ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 238-246 247-253 ____ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ 238-259 238-259 ____ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ ________ ___ __ ___ _ ____ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ ________ ___ __ ___ _ 1<2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 247-253 254-259 _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ ________ ___ __ ___ _ 238-259 238-259 ____ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ ________ ___ __ ___ _ ____ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ ________ ___ __ ___ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 260-261 262-268 ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _______ _ __ ________ 260-283 260-283 ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _______ _ __ ________ __ ___ _____ _______ ____ ______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ _ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _______ _ __ ________ __ ___ _____ _______ ____ ______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 262-268 269-274 __ ____ ______ _______ _ __ ________ __ ___ _____ _______ ____ ______ 260-283 260-283 ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _______ _ __ ________ __ ___ _____ _______ ____ ______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ _ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _______ _ __ ________ __ ___ _____ _______ ____ ______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ _ 1>2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 207-210 269-274 _____ __ _ ______ __ ___ _____ _______ ____ ______ 197-219 260-283 __ ___ ___ _ ________ ____ __ _____ ____ _ _____ __ _ ______ __ _____ __ _____ _ ___ __ _____ _ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _______ _ __ ________ __ ___ _____ _______ ____ ______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 269-274 275-283 __ ___ _____ _______ ____ ______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ _ 260-283 260-283 ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _______ _ __ ________ __ ___ _____ _______ ____ ______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ _ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _______ _ __ ________ __ ___ _____ _______ ____ ______ _______ _____ ___ __ ____ __ ____ ___ _ 1<2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 284-291 330-336 ____ __ ___ ____ ____ ____ _____ _ __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ 284-291 330-351 ____ __ ___ ____ ____ ____ _____ _ __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ __ _ _ __ ____ ___ __ _____ _______ __ __ _ 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 292-298 330-336 ___ __ ___ ____ ________ ____ _____ __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ 292-307 330-351 ___ __ ___ ____ ________ ____ _____ __ ____ ___ _____ __ __ ____ ___________ _ __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ __ _ _ __ ____ ___ __ _____ _______ __ __ _ 1>2 background background +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 292-298 299-307 ___ __ ___ ____ ________ ____ _____ __ ____ ___ _____ __ __ ____ ___________ _ 292-307 292-307 ___ __ ___ ____ ________ ____ _____ __ ____ ___ _____ __ __ ____ ___________ _ ___ __ ___ ____ ________ ____ _____ __ ____ ___ _____ __ __ ____ ___________ _ 1<2 justify justify +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 292-298 308-314 ___ __ ___ ____ ________ ____ _____ ___ ___ _____ _____ _______ ____ ____ 292-307 308-329 ___ __ ___ ____ ________ ____ _____ __ ____ ___ _____ __ __ ____ ___________ _ ___ ___ _____ _____ _______ ____ ____ ___ __ _____ ____ __ _ __ ____ __ __ _ __ _ _____ _ 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 308-314 315-327 ___ ___ _____ _____ _______ ____ ____ ___ __ _____ ____ __ _ __ ____ __ __ _ __ _ 308-329 308-329 ___ ___ _____ _____ _______ ____ ____ ___ __ _____ ____ __ _ __ ____ __ __ _ __ _ _____ _ ___ ___ _____ _____ _______ ____ ____ ___ __ _____ ____ __ _ __ ____ __ __ _ __ _ _____ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 315-327 328-329 ___ __ _____ ____ __ _ __ ____ __ __ _ __ _ _____ _ 308-329 308-329 ___ ___ _____ _____ _______ ____ ____ ___ __ _____ ____ __ _ __ ____ __ __ _ __ _ _____ _ ___ ___ _____ _____ _______ ____ ____ ___ __ _____ ____ __ _ __ ____ __ __ _ __ _ _____ _ 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 91-98 330-336 ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ 85-104 330-351 ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ _ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ __ ___ ________ ____ __ _______ __ ___________ _ __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ __ _ _ __ ____ ___ __ _____ _______ __ __ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 337-344 345-351 ____ __ ____ __ _ _ __ ____ ___ __ _____ _______ __ __ _ 330-351 330-351 __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ __ _ _ __ ____ ___ __ _____ _______ __ __ _ __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ __ _ _ __ ____ ___ __ _____ _______ __ __ _ 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 330-336 345-351 __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ ___ __ _____ _______ __ __ _ 330-351 330-351 __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ __ _ _ __ ____ ___ __ _____ _______ __ __ _ __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ __ _ _ __ ____ ___ __ _____ _______ __ __ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 330-336 352-357 __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ ________ __ ________ 330-351 352-370 __________ _ _____ _____ ____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ __ _ _ __ ____ ___ __ _____ _______ __ __ _ ____ __ ____ ________ __ ________ _____ _ _______ ______ ___________ _____ ______ ___ _ ____ __ _____ _ 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 352-357 358-370 ____ __ ____ ________ __ ________ _____ _ _______ ______ ___________ _____ ______ ___ _ ____ __ _____ _ 352-370 352-370 ____ __ ____ ________ __ ________ _____ _ _______ ______ ___________ _____ ______ ___ _ ____ __ _____ _ ____ __ ____ ________ __ ________ _____ _ _______ ______ ___________ _____ ______ ___ _ ____ __ _____ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 371-375 391-401 ____ _______ __ ____ _____ __ ____ _______ __ ____ ________ ___ _______ __ _____ ________ 371-390 391-409 ____ _______ __ ____ _____ _ _______ ______ ______ _______ __ ___ _____ _ ____ __ ____ ______ _________ _ __ ____ _______ __ ____ ________ ___ _______ __ _____ ________ __ ___ ___ ________ ___ ___ _________ _ 1>2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 371-375 376-384 ____ _______ __ ____ _____ _ _______ ______ ______ _______ __ ___ _____ _ 371-390 371-390 ____ _______ __ ____ _____ _ _______ ______ ______ _______ __ ___ _____ _ ____ __ ____ ______ _________ _ ____ _______ __ ____ _____ _ _______ ______ ______ _______ __ ___ _____ _ ____ __ ____ ______ _________ _ 1<2 manner manner +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 371-375 385-390 ____ _______ __ ____ _____ ____ __ ____ ______ _________ _ 371-390 371-390 ____ _______ __ ____ _____ _ _______ ______ ______ _______ __ ___ _____ _ ____ __ ____ ______ _________ _ ____ _______ __ ____ _____ _ _______ ______ ______ _______ __ ___ _____ _ ____ __ ____ ______ _________ _ 1<2 result result +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 352-357 391-401 ____ __ ____ ________ __ ________ __ ____ _______ __ ____ ________ ___ _______ __ _____ ________ 352-370 391-409 ____ __ ____ ________ __ ________ _____ _ _______ ______ ___________ _____ ______ ___ _ ____ __ _____ _ __ ____ _______ __ ____ ________ ___ _______ __ _____ ________ __ ___ ___ ________ ___ ___ _________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 391-401 402-409 __ ____ _______ __ ____ ________ ___ _______ __ _____ ________ __ ___ ___ ________ ___ ___ _________ _ 391-409 391-409 __ ____ _______ __ ____ ________ ___ _______ __ _____ ________ __ ___ ___ ________ ___ ___ _________ _ __ ____ _______ __ ____ ________ ___ _______ __ _____ ________ __ ___ ___ ________ ___ ___ _________ _ 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 410-418 419-427 _______ ___ _____ _____________ ____ ___ __________ _____ _ ____ _____ _____ __ _ ___________ __ ____ _ 410-427 410-427 _______ ___ _____ _____________ ____ ___ __________ _____ _ ____ _____ _____ __ _ ___________ __ ____ _ _______ ___ _____ _____________ ____ ___ __________ _____ _ ____ _____ _____ __ _ ___________ __ ____ _ 1>2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 32-33,37-39,46 419-427 ___ _____ <*> __ _______ _______ <*> _____ ____ _____ _____ __ _ ___________ __ ____ _ 32-84 410-427 ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ _______ ___ _____ _____________ ____ ___ __________ _____ _ ____ _____ _____ __ _ ___________ __ ____ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 428-436 444-447 ___ _____ ___ ____ __________ ____ __ ___ ____ ___ ___ ___ _________ 428-455 428-455 ___ _____ ___ ____ __________ ____ __ ___ ____ ___ ______ _________ __ ______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _________ ____ _________ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _ ___ _____ ___ ____ __________ ____ __ ___ ____ ___ ______ _________ __ ______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _________ ____ _________ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _ 1>2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 428-436 437-443 ___ _____ ___ ____ __________ ____ __ ___ ____ ___ ______ _________ __ ______ ___ _____ 428-455 428-455 ___ _____ ___ ____ __________ ____ __ ___ ____ ___ ______ _________ __ ______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _________ ____ _________ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _ ___ _____ ___ ____ __________ ____ __ ___ ____ ___ ______ _________ __ ______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _________ ____ _________ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _ 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 419-427 444-447 ____ _____ _____ __ _ ___________ __ ____ _ ___ ___ ___ _________ 410-427 428-455 _______ ___ _____ _____________ ____ ___ __________ _____ _ ____ _____ _____ __ _ ___________ __ ____ _ ___ _____ ___ ____ __________ ____ __ ___ ____ ___ ______ _________ __ ______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _________ ____ _________ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 444-447 448-455 ___ ___ ___ _________ ____ _________ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _ 428-455 428-455 ___ _____ ___ ____ __________ ____ __ ___ ____ ___ ______ _________ __ ______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _________ ____ _________ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _ ___ _____ ___ ____ __________ ____ __ ___ ____ ___ ______ _________ __ ______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _________ ____ _________ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 456-462 463-467 __ ___ ____ ___ _ _______ _ ____ ___ ___ ____ _____ 456-479 456-479 __ ___ ____ ___ _ _______ _ ____ ___ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ ___ ______ ____ __ _ __ ___ ____ ___ _ _______ _ ____ ___ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ ___ ______ ____ __ _ 1>2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 444-447 463-467 ___ ___ ___ _________ ____ ___ ___ ____ _____ 428-455 456-479 ___ _____ ___ ____ __________ ____ __ ___ ____ ___ ______ _________ __ ______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _________ ____ _________ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _ __ ___ ____ ___ _ _______ _ ____ ___ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ ___ ______ ____ __ _ 1<2 background background +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 463-467 468-471 ____ ___ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ___ _____ 456-479 456-479 __ ___ ____ ___ _ _______ _ ____ ___ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ ___ ______ ____ __ _ __ ___ ____ ___ _ _______ _ ____ ___ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ ___ ______ ____ __ _ 1<2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 468-471 472-479 _______ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ ___ ______ ____ __ _ 456-479 456-479 __ ___ ____ ___ _ _______ _ ____ ___ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ ___ ______ ____ __ _ __ ___ ____ ___ _ _______ _ ____ ___ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ ___ ______ ____ __ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 444-447 480-482,486 ___ ___ ___ _________ ___ ____ ______ <*> __ 428-455 480-494 ___ _____ ___ ____ __________ ____ __ ___ ____ ___ ______ _________ __ ______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _________ ____ _________ ___ _______ __ ____ ______ _ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ __ _______ ___ __ _____ ____ __ ____ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 480-482,486 483-485 ___ ____ ______ <*> __ __ ___ _____ 480-494 480-494 ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ __ _______ ___ __ _____ ____ __ ____ _ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ __ _______ ___ __ _____ ____ __ ____ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 480-482,486 487,492-494 ___ ____ ______ <*> __ _______ <*> __ ____ _ 480-494 480-494 ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ __ _______ ___ __ _____ ____ __ ____ _ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ __ _______ ___ __ _____ ____ __ ____ _ 1<2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 488-491 492-494 ___ __ _____ ____ __ ____ _ 480-494 480-494 ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ __ _______ ___ __ _____ ____ __ ____ _ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ __ _______ ___ __ _____ ____ __ ____ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 480-482,486 495-504 ___ ____ ______ <*> __ ___ ___ ___ _____________ ____ ___ _____ ____ ___ _____ 480-494 495-517 ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ __ _______ ___ __ _____ ____ __ ____ _ ___ ___ ___ _____________ ____ ___ _____ ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ ___ _______ ___ _____ __ ____________ _ ______ ______ __ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 495-504 505-506 ___ ___ ___ _____________ ____ ___ _____ ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ 495-517 495-517 ___ ___ ___ _____________ ____ ___ _____ ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ ___ _______ ___ _____ __ ____________ _ ______ ______ __ _ ___ ___ ___ _____________ ____ ___ _____ ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ ___ _______ ___ _____ __ ____________ _ ______ ______ __ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 495-504 507,514-517 ___ ___ ___ _____________ ____ ___ _____ ____ ___ _____ ___ <*> ______ ______ __ _ 495-517 495-517 ___ ___ ___ _____________ ____ ___ _____ ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ ___ _______ ___ _____ __ ____________ _ ______ ______ __ _ ___ ___ ___ _____________ ____ ___ _____ ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ ___ _______ ___ _____ __ ____________ _ ______ ______ __ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 508-513 514-517 _______ ___ _____ __ ____________ _ ______ ______ __ _ 495-517 495-517 ___ ___ ___ _____________ ____ ___ _____ ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ ___ _______ ___ _____ __ ____________ _ ______ ______ __ _ ___ ___ ___ _____________ ____ ___ _____ ____ ___ _____ ____ _____ ___ _______ ___ _____ __ ____________ _ ______ ______ __ _ 1>2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 518-523 524-529 __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ 518-555 518-555 __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ 1>2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 480-482,486 524-529 ___ ____ ______ <*> __ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ 480-494 518-555 ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ __ _______ ___ __ _____ ____ __ ____ _ __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 524-529 530-532 __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ 518-555 518-555 __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 524-529 533-534 __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ___ ______ 518-555 518-555 __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 524-529 535-541 __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ 518-555 518-555 __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ 1<2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 542-544 547-555 ___ ___ _ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ 518-555 518-555 __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 545-546 547-555 _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ 518-555 518-555 __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ 1>2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 535-541 547-555 _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ 518-555 518-555 __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ __ ___ _____ ___ ________ _ __ ___ _____ _____ ___ _______ ____ _____ _____ ___ ______ _______ ___ _____ _____ ____ ____ ___ ___ ___ _ _ _____ __ ___ ___ ______ ___ ____ ____ _ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 556-563 572-577 ____ ____ _____ ____ __ ______ ____ _ __ ____ __ __ ____ _ 556-563 572-577 ____ ____ _____ ____ __ ______ ____ _ __ ____ __ __ ____ _ 1>2 question question +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 556-563 564-571 ____ ____ _____ ____ __ ______ ____ _ __ ____ ___ ____ ______ ____ __ _ 556-563 564-571 ____ ____ _____ ____ __ ______ ____ _ __ ____ ___ ____ ______ ____ __ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 572-577 578,586-590 __ ____ __ __ ____ _ ___ <*> __ ___ ___ __ ____ 572-577 578-604 __ ____ __ __ ____ _ ___ __ __ ____ __ _ ______ _ __ ___ ___ __ ____ __ ____ _____ ______ ____ ___ __ ____ ______ _ _________ __ ______ _ 1>2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 578,586-590 605-613 ___ <*> __ ___ ___ __ ____ _____ _ ____ ________ _ _ _____ __ _____ 578-604 605-624 ___ __ __ ____ __ _ ______ _ __ ___ ___ __ ____ __ ____ _____ ______ ____ ___ __ ____ ______ _ _________ __ ______ _ _____ _ ____ ________ _ _ _____ __ _____ ____ _____ _______ ______ ____ ___ _____ ____ __ _____ _ 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 579-585 586-590 __ __ ____ __ _ ______ _ __ ___ ___ __ ____ 578-604 578-604 ___ __ __ ____ __ _ ______ _ __ ___ ___ __ ____ __ ____ _____ ______ ____ ___ __ ____ ______ _ _________ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ ____ __ _ ______ _ __ ___ ___ __ ____ __ ____ _____ ______ ____ ___ __ ____ ______ _ _________ __ ______ _ 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 586-590 591-595 __ ___ ___ __ ____ __ ____ _____ ______ ____ 578-604 578-604 ___ __ __ ____ __ _ ______ _ __ ___ ___ __ ____ __ ____ _____ ______ ____ ___ __ ____ ______ _ _________ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ ____ __ _ ______ _ __ ___ ___ __ ____ __ ____ _____ ______ ____ ___ __ ____ ______ _ _________ __ ______ _ 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 578,586-590 596-604 ___ <*> __ ___ ___ __ ____ ___ __ ____ ______ _ _________ __ ______ _ 578-604 578-604 ___ __ __ ____ __ _ ______ _ __ ___ ___ __ ____ __ ____ _____ ______ ____ ___ __ ____ ______ _ _________ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ ____ __ _ ______ _ __ ___ ___ __ ____ __ ____ _____ ______ ____ ___ __ ____ ______ _ _________ __ ______ _ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 605-613 755-759 _____ _ ____ ________ _ _ _____ __ _____ __________ _ ____ ____ ___ 605-624 755-781 _____ _ ____ ________ _ _ _____ __ _____ ____ _____ _______ ______ ____ ___ _____ ____ __ _____ _ __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ______ _______ _______ ___ ______ ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ ____ _______ ___ ____ _________ __ ____ _____ _ 1>2 background background +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 605-613 614-616 _____ _ ____ ________ _ _ _____ __ _____ ____ _____ _______ 605-624 605-624 _____ _ ____ ________ _ _ _____ __ _____ ____ _____ _______ ______ ____ ___ _____ ____ __ _____ _ _____ _ ____ ________ _ _ _____ __ _____ ____ _____ _______ ______ ____ ___ _____ ____ __ _____ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 614-616 617-618,622-624 ____ _____ _______ ______ ____ <*> __ _____ _ 605-624 605-624 _____ _ ____ ________ _ _ _____ __ _____ ____ _____ _______ ______ ____ ___ _____ ____ __ _____ _ _____ _ ____ ________ _ _ _____ __ _____ ____ _____ _______ ______ ____ ___ _____ ____ __ _____ _ 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 619-621 622-624 ___ _____ ____ __ _____ _ 605-624 605-624 _____ _ ____ ________ _ _ _____ __ _____ ____ _____ _______ ______ ____ ___ _____ ____ __ _____ _ _____ _ ____ ________ _ _ _____ __ _____ ____ _____ _______ ______ ____ ___ _____ ____ __ _____ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 625-640 683-689 ______ ____ __ __ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _______ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ____ __ ____ ____ __ _____ _ 625-640 683-689 ______ ____ __ __ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _______ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ____ __ ____ ____ __ _____ _ 1>2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 625-640 641-647 ______ ____ __ __ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _______ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ _____ _____ _________ ____ _____ ____ 625-640 641-664 ______ ____ __ __ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _______ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ _____ _____ _________ ____ _____ ____ ___ ____ ____ __ ___________ ____ ____ ____ ___ _ _____ __ ____ __ _____ ______ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 641-647 648-652 ___ _____ _____ _________ ____ _____ ____ ___ ____ ____ __ ___________ 641-664 641-664 ___ _____ _____ _________ ____ _____ ____ ___ ____ ____ __ ___________ ____ ____ ____ ___ _ _____ __ ____ __ _____ ______ _ ___ _____ _____ _________ ____ _____ ____ ___ ____ ____ __ ___________ ____ ____ ____ ___ _ _____ __ ____ __ _____ ______ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 653-654 655-664 ____ ____ ____ ___ _ _____ __ ____ __ _____ ______ _ 641-664 641-664 ___ _____ _____ _________ ____ _____ ____ ___ ____ ____ __ ___________ ____ ____ ____ ___ _ _____ __ ____ __ _____ ______ _ ___ _____ _____ _________ ____ _____ ____ ___ ____ ____ __ ___________ ____ ____ ____ ___ _ _____ __ ____ __ _____ ______ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 648-652 655-664 ___ ____ ____ __ ___________ ____ ___ _ _____ __ ____ __ _____ ______ _ 641-664 641-664 ___ _____ _____ _________ ____ _____ ____ ___ ____ ____ __ ___________ ____ ____ ____ ___ _ _____ __ ____ __ _____ ______ _ ___ _____ _____ _________ ____ _____ ____ ___ ____ ____ __ ___________ ____ ____ ____ ___ _ _____ __ ____ __ _____ ______ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 665-673 674-682 __ ______ _______ ____ ___________ __ ___ ____ _ ____ _____ ______ __ _______ ____ ___ __ _ 665-682 665-682 __ ______ _______ ____ ___________ __ ___ ____ _ ____ _____ ______ __ _______ ____ ___ __ _ __ ______ _______ ____ ___________ __ ___ ____ _ ____ _____ ______ __ _______ ____ ___ __ _ 1>2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 625-640 674-682 ______ ____ __ __ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _______ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ____ _____ ______ __ _______ ____ ___ __ _ 625-640 665-682 ______ ____ __ __ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _______ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ __ ______ _______ ____ ___________ __ ___ ____ _ ____ _____ ______ __ _______ ____ ___ __ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 683-689 744-747 ____ __ ____ ____ __ _____ _ _______ ________ _____ ____ 683-689 744-754 ____ __ ____ ____ __ _____ _ _______ ________ _____ ____ ___ ________ ________ ____ ___ _____ _ 1>2 result result +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 690-692 693-698 ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ 690-741 690-741 ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 693-698 699-713 ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ 690-741 690-741 ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 683-689 699-713 ____ __ ____ ____ __ _____ _ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ 683-689 690-741 ____ __ ____ ____ __ _____ _ ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 699-713 714-719 ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ 690-741 690-741 ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 714-719 720-722 __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ 690-741 690-741 ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 720-722 723-730 ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ 690-741 690-741 ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ 1<2 manner manner +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 723-730 731-741 ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ 690-741 690-741 ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ ___ _____ ___ ___ ____ ____ ______ __ ________ ___ __ ___ __ ___ _ _ __ ____ ____ ___ _______ __ ___ ___________ __ __ _____ ____ ____ __ ___ ___ __ ____ ____ ___ ______ ___ ______ ___ __ _ _____ _ __ ___ _________ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 742-743 744-747 ___ _ _______ ________ _____ ____ 742-743 744-754 ___ _ _______ ________ _____ ____ ___ ________ ________ ____ ___ _____ _ 1>2 question question +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 744-747 755-759 _______ ________ _____ ____ __________ _ ____ ____ ___ 744-754 755-781 _______ ________ _____ ____ ___ ________ ________ ____ ___ _____ _ __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ______ _______ _______ ___ ______ ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ ____ _______ ___ ____ _________ __ ____ _____ _ 1>2 background background +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 748-750 751-754 ___ ________ ________ ____ ___ _____ _ 744-754 744-754 _______ ________ _____ ____ ___ ________ ________ ____ ___ _____ _ _______ ________ _____ ____ ___ ________ ________ ____ ___ _____ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 744-747 751-754 _______ ________ _____ ____ ____ ___ _____ _ 744-754 744-754 _______ ________ _____ ____ ___ ________ ________ ____ ___ _____ _ _______ ________ _____ ____ ___ ________ ________ ____ ___ _____ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 32-33,37-39,46 755-759 ___ _____ <*> __ _______ _______ <*> _____ __________ _ ____ ____ ___ 32-84 755-781 ___ _____ ____ __ _______ __ _______ _______ _ ______ ___ ___ ___________ _ _____ __ __ __ ___________ _ ____ ____ ___ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ________ _____ ____ ___ ___________ ________ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ ____ __ _____ ___ _______ _____ ____ ________ _ _ __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ______ _______ _______ ___ ______ ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ ____ _______ ___ ____ _________ __ ____ _____ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 755-759 760-765 __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ______ _______ _______ ___ ______ 755-781 755-781 __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ______ _______ _______ ___ ______ ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ ____ _______ ___ ____ _________ __ ____ _____ _ __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ______ _______ _______ ___ ______ ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ ____ _______ ___ ____ _________ __ ____ _____ _ 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 755-759 766-772 __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ 755-781 755-781 __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ______ _______ _______ ___ ______ ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ ____ _______ ___ ____ _________ __ ____ _____ _ __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ______ _______ _______ ___ ______ ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ ____ _______ ___ ____ _________ __ ____ _____ _ 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 766-772 773-781 ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ ____ _______ ___ ____ _________ __ ____ _____ _ 755-781 755-781 __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ______ _______ _______ ___ ______ ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ ____ _______ ___ ____ _________ __ ____ _____ _ __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ______ _______ _______ ___ ______ ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ ____ _______ ___ ____ _________ __ ____ _____ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 782-786 800-804 __ ___ _____ _____ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ 782-824 782-824 __ ___ _____ _____ _ _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ __ ___ _____ _____ _ _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 787-799 800-804 _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ 782-824 782-824 __ ___ _____ _____ _ _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ __ ___ _____ _____ _ _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 800-804 825-831 ___ __ __ _____ ________ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ____ _ 782-824 825-831 __ ___ _____ _____ _ _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ____ _ 1>2 question question +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 805-809 810-812 ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ 782-824 782-824 __ ___ _____ _____ _ _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ __ ___ _____ _____ _ _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 800-804 810-812 ___ __ __ _____ ________ __ __ _ 782-824 782-824 __ ___ _____ _____ _ _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ __ ___ _____ _____ _ _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 800-804 813-824 ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ 782-824 782-824 __ ___ _____ _____ _ _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ __ ___ _____ _____ _ _ ____ _ ___ ____ _____ __ ___ ____ ______ __ ______ _ ___ __ __ _____ ________ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ __ __ _ ____ __ ___ ____ __ ________ __ ______ ___ __ _ _ 1<2 justify justify +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 755-759 825-831 __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ____ _ 755-781 825-831 __________ _ ____ ____ ___ ___ ______ _______ _______ ___ ______ ___ __ _________ ________ ____ ____________ ______ ____ _______ ___ ____ _________ __ ____ _____ _ ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ____ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 825-831 832-835 ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ____ _ __ ___ _____ ____ 825-831 832-841 ___ ____ _____ _______ __ ____ _ __ ___ _____ ____ ______ _____ ______ ____ ____ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 832-835 836-841 __ ___ _____ ____ ______ _____ ______ ____ ____ _ 832-841 832-841 __ ___ _____ ____ ______ _____ ______ ____ ____ _ __ ___ _____ ____ ______ _____ ______ ____ ____ _ 1<2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 842-853 854-860 __ ___ __ ___ __________ _____ ____ ____ ___ _________ ____ _ ____ ____ _____ ____ __ ____ _ 842-860 842-860 __ ___ __ ___ __________ _____ ____ ____ ___ _________ ____ _ ____ ____ _____ ____ __ ____ _ __ ___ __ ___ __________ _____ ____ ____ ___ _________ ____ _ ____ ____ _____ ____ __ ____ _ 1>2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 832-835 854-860 __ ___ _____ ____ ____ ____ _____ ____ __ ____ _ 832-841 842-860 __ ___ _____ ____ ______ _____ ______ ____ ____ _ __ ___ __ ___ __________ _____ ____ ____ ___ _________ ____ _ ____ ____ _____ ____ __ ____ _ 1<2 justify justify +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 861-865 866-873 _ _______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ 861-891 861-891 _ _______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ___ _____ __ _ ____ ____ _________ ____ ______ __ __ _ ___ ____ __ __ ___ _ _ _______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ___ _____ __ _ ____ ____ _________ ____ ______ __ __ _ ___ ____ __ __ ___ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 832-835 866-873 __ ___ _____ ____ ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ 832-841 861-891 __ ___ _____ ____ ______ _____ ______ ____ ____ _ _ _______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ___ _____ __ _ ____ ____ _________ ____ ______ __ __ _ ___ ____ __ __ ___ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 866-873 874-877 ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ___ _____ __ _ 861-891 861-891 _ _______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ___ _____ __ _ ____ ____ _________ ____ ______ __ __ _ ___ ____ __ __ ___ _ _ _______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ___ _____ __ _ ____ ____ _________ ____ ______ __ __ _ ___ ____ __ __ ___ _ 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 866-873 878-885 ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ____ ____ _________ ____ ______ __ __ _ 861-891 861-891 _ _______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ___ _____ __ _ ____ ____ _________ ____ ______ __ __ _ ___ ____ __ __ ___ _ _ _______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ___ _____ __ _ ____ ____ _________ ____ ______ __ __ _ ___ ____ __ __ ___ _ 1<2 manner manner +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 866-873 886-891 ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ___ ____ __ __ ___ _ 861-891 861-891 _ _______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ___ _____ __ _ ____ ____ _________ ____ ______ __ __ _ ___ ____ __ __ ___ _ _ _______ ___ _____ ___ ___ ___ _____ ____ ______ ____ ____ _____ ___ _____ __ _ ____ ____ _________ ____ ______ __ __ _ ___ ____ __ __ ___ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 892-900 901-917 __ ____ __ ______ ________ __ _____ _______ _ __ ____ ___ ______ ____ __ __ _____ _ ____ ____ _______ ______ ___ ______ ____ _ 892-917 892-917 __ ____ __ ______ ________ __ _____ _______ _ __ ____ ___ ______ ____ __ __ _____ _ ____ ____ _______ ______ ___ ______ ____ _ __ ____ __ ______ ________ __ _____ _______ _ __ ____ ___ ______ ____ __ __ _____ _ ____ ____ _______ ______ ___ ______ ____ _ 1>2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 832-835 901-917 __ ___ _____ ____ __ ____ ___ ______ ____ __ __ _____ _ ____ ____ _______ ______ ___ ______ ____ _ 832-841 892-917 __ ___ _____ ____ ______ _____ ______ ____ ____ _ __ ____ __ ______ ________ __ _____ _______ _ __ ____ ___ ______ ____ __ __ _____ _ ____ ____ _______ ______ ___ ______ ____ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 832-835 918-926 __ ___ _____ ____ __ ____ __ __ _________ __ ____ ______ _ 832-841 918-926 __ ___ _____ ____ ______ _____ ______ ____ ____ _ __ ____ __ __ _________ __ ____ ______ _ 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 832-835 927-949 __ ___ _____ ____ ___ ___ __________ _______ _____ ________ ___ ____ __ ____ _ _______ __ ____ ______ _ ___ ____ ____ _ _______ __ ____ 832-841 927-958 __ ___ _____ ____ ______ _____ ______ ____ ____ _ ___ ___ __________ _______ _____ ________ ___ ____ __ ____ _ _______ __ ____ ______ _ ___ ____ ____ _ _______ __ ____ ___ __ _ ___ ______ __ ____ ___ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 927-949 950-958 ___ ___ __________ _______ _____ ________ ___ ____ __ ____ _ _______ __ ____ ______ _ ___ ____ ____ _ _______ __ ____ ___ __ _ ___ ______ __ ____ ___ _ 927-958 927-958 ___ ___ __________ _______ _____ ________ ___ ____ __ ____ _ _______ __ ____ ______ _ ___ ____ ____ _ _______ __ ____ ___ __ _ ___ ______ __ ____ ___ _ ___ ___ __________ _______ _____ ________ ___ ____ __ ____ _ _______ __ ____ ______ _ ___ ____ ____ _ _______ __ ____ ___ __ _ ___ ______ __ ____ ___ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 959-960 961-965 ____ _ _ ____ ____ ______ _________ 959-960 961-982 ____ _ _ ____ ____ ______ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ __ ___ ___ ______ ______ ______ __ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ _ 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 24-31 961-965 ___ ___ ______ ____ ____ ___ ______ _ _ ____ ____ ______ _________ 24-31 961-982 ___ ___ ______ ____ ____ ___ ______ _ _ ____ ____ ______ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ __ ___ ___ ______ ______ ______ __ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 961-965 966-968 _ ____ ____ ______ _________ __ _______ ______ 961-982 961-982 _ ____ ____ ______ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ __ ___ ___ ______ ______ ______ __ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ _ _ ____ ____ ______ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ __ ___ ___ ______ ______ ______ __ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ _ 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 966-968 969-982 __ _______ ______ ___ __ ___ ___ ______ ______ ______ __ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ _ 961-982 961-982 _ ____ ____ ______ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ __ ___ ___ ______ ______ ______ __ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ _ _ ____ ____ ______ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ __ ___ ___ ______ ______ ______ __ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 961-965 983-989 _ ____ ____ ______ _________ _____ _ _ _____ _______ ________ _ 961-982 983-989 _ ____ ____ ______ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ __ ___ ___ ______ ______ ______ __ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ _ _____ _ _ _____ _______ ________ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 961-965 990-998 _ ____ ____ ______ _________ _ ____ ____ ______ _____ __ ________ __ _____________ 961-982 990-1020 _ ____ ____ ______ _________ __ _______ ______ ___ __ ___ ___ ______ ______ ______ __ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ _ _ ____ ____ ______ _____ __ ________ __ _____________ __ _______ __ ______ ___ _______ ____ __ _ ______ ___ _______ ______ ___ __ _____ ______ ____ ____ ____ _________ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 990-998 999-1002 _ ____ ____ ______ _____ __ ________ __ _____________ __ _______ __ ______ 990-1020 990-1020 _ ____ ____ ______ _____ __ ________ __ _____________ __ _______ __ ______ ___ _______ ____ __ _ ______ ___ _______ ______ ___ __ _____ ______ ____ ____ ____ _________ _ _ ____ ____ ______ _____ __ ________ __ _____________ __ _______ __ ______ ___ _______ ____ __ _ ______ ___ _______ ______ ___ __ _____ ______ ____ ____ ____ _________ _ 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 999-1002 1003-1011 __ _______ __ ______ ___ _______ ____ __ _ ______ ___ _______ ______ 990-1020 990-1020 _ ____ ____ ______ _____ __ ________ __ _____________ __ _______ __ ______ ___ _______ ____ __ _ ______ ___ _______ ______ ___ __ _____ ______ ____ ____ ____ _________ _ _ ____ ____ ______ _____ __ ________ __ _____________ __ _______ __ ______ ___ _______ ____ __ _ ______ ___ _______ ______ ___ __ _____ ______ ____ ____ ____ _________ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 990-998 1012-1020 _ ____ ____ ______ _____ __ ________ __ _____________ ___ __ _____ ______ ____ ____ ____ _________ _ 990-1020 990-1020 _ ____ ____ ______ _____ __ ________ __ _____________ __ _______ __ ______ ___ _______ ____ __ _ ______ ___ _______ ______ ___ __ _____ ______ ____ ____ ____ _________ _ _ ____ ____ ______ _____ __ ________ __ _____________ __ _______ __ ______ ___ _______ ____ __ _ ______ ___ _______ ______ ___ __ _____ ______ ____ ____ ____ _________ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1021-1027 1028-1036 ____ _____ _____ ___ ____ ___ _____ ___ __ ______ __ ____ _______ ___________ ___ _______ 1021-1047 1021-1047 ____ _____ _____ ___ ____ ___ _____ ___ __ ______ __ ____ _______ ___________ ___ _______ ______ __ __________ ____ _______ ___ ______________ _ __ _______ _ ____ _____ _____ ___ ____ ___ _____ ___ __ ______ __ ____ _______ ___________ ___ _______ ______ __ __________ ____ _______ ___ ______________ _ __ _______ _ 1>2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1028-1036 1048-1055 ___ __ ______ __ ____ _______ ___________ ___ _______ ________ ______ ___ ____ ___ ______ ____________ _ 1021-1047 1048-1065 ____ _____ _____ ___ ____ ___ _____ ___ __ ______ __ ____ _______ ___________ ___ _______ ______ __ __________ ____ _______ ___ ______________ _ __ _______ _ ________ ______ ___ ____ ___ ______ ____________ _ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _______ ___ ____ _____ _ 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1028-1036 1037-1047 ___ __ ______ __ ____ _______ ___________ ___ _______ ______ __ __________ ____ _______ ___ ______________ _ __ _______ _ 1021-1047 1021-1047 ____ _____ _____ ___ ____ ___ _____ ___ __ ______ __ ____ _______ ___________ ___ _______ ______ __ __________ ____ _______ ___ ______________ _ __ _______ _ ____ _____ _____ ___ ____ ___ _____ ___ __ ______ __ ____ _______ ___________ ___ _______ ______ __ __________ ____ _______ ___ ______________ _ __ _______ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 24-31 1048-1055 ___ ___ ______ ____ ____ ___ ______ _ ________ ______ ___ ____ ___ ______ ____________ _ 24-31 1048-1065 ___ ___ ______ ____ ____ ___ ______ _ ________ ______ ___ ____ ___ ______ ____________ _ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _______ ___ ____ _____ _ 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1048-1055 1056-1065 ________ ______ ___ ____ ___ ______ ____________ _ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _______ ___ ____ _____ _ 1048-1065 1048-1065 ________ ______ ___ ____ ___ ______ ____________ _ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _______ ___ ____ _____ _ ________ ______ ___ ____ ___ ______ ____________ _ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _______ ___ ____ _____ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1048-1055 1066-1076 ________ ______ ___ ____ ___ ______ ____________ _ ______ ___ ____ _______ _________ _________ ___ ___________ __ ____ ________ 1048-1065 1066-1087 ________ ______ ___ ____ ___ ______ ____________ _ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _______ ___ ____ _____ _ ______ ___ ____ _______ _________ _________ ___ ___________ __ ____ ________ _____ __________ _______ ___ ____ __ ________ _ __ _______ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1066-1076 1077-1087 ______ ___ ____ _______ _________ _________ ___ ___________ __ ____ ________ _____ __________ _______ ___ ____ __ ________ _ __ _______ _ 1066-1087 1066-1087 ______ ___ ____ _______ _________ _________ ___ ___________ __ ____ ________ _____ __________ _______ ___ ____ __ ________ _ __ _______ _ ______ ___ ____ _______ _________ _________ ___ ___________ __ ____ ________ _____ __________ _______ ___ ____ __ ________ _ __ _______ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1066-1076 1088-1097 ______ ___ ____ _______ _________ _________ ___ ___________ __ ____ ________ __ __ ______ __________ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ 1066-1087 1088-1122 ______ ___ ____ _______ _________ _________ ___ ___________ __ ____ ________ _____ __________ _______ ___ ____ __ ________ _ __ _______ _ __ __ ______ __________ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ __ __________ _____ _______ ___ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ _______ ____________ ___ ________ ____ _______ ________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1088-1097 1098-1101 __ __ ______ __________ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ __ __________ _____ 1088-1122 1088-1122 __ __ ______ __________ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ __ __________ _____ _______ ___ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ _______ ____________ ___ ________ ____ _______ ________ _ __ __ ______ __________ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ __ __________ _____ _______ ___ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ _______ ____________ ___ ________ ____ _______ ________ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1098-1101 1102,1106-1108 ___ __ __________ _____ _______ <*> __ ___ _____ 1088-1122 1088-1122 __ __ ______ __________ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ __ __________ _____ _______ ___ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ _______ ____________ ___ ________ ____ _______ ________ _ __ __ ______ __________ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ __ __________ _____ _______ ___ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ _______ ____________ ___ ________ ____ _______ ________ _ 1<2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1103-1105 1106-1108 ___ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ 1088-1122 1088-1122 __ __ ______ __________ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ __ __________ _____ _______ ___ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ _______ ____________ ___ ________ ____ _______ ________ _ __ __ ______ __________ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ __ __________ _____ _______ ___ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ _______ ____________ ___ ________ ____ _______ ________ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1106-1108 1109-1122 __ ___ _____ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ _______ ____________ ___ ________ ____ _______ ________ _ 1088-1122 1088-1122 __ __ ______ __________ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ __ __________ _____ _______ ___ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ _______ ____________ ___ ________ ____ _______ ________ _ __ __ ______ __________ _ _____ _ ___ __ _ ___ __ __________ _____ _______ ___ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ____ ______ __ ___ _____ _______ ____________ ___ ________ ____ _______ ________ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_macroeconomics 1048-1055 1123-1133 ________ ______ ___ ____ ___ ______ ____________ _ ____ _ __ ___ ___ __ _______ __ ___ ___________ _ 1048-1065 1123-1133 ________ ______ ___ ____ ___ ______ ____________ _ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _______ ___ ____ _____ _ ____ _ __ ___ ___ __ _______ __ ___ ___________ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 8-14 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ 1-14 1-14 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 15-19 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ ______ __ _ ____ ___ 1-14 15-25 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ ______ __ _ ____ ___ __ ________ ____________ _ ___ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_pandas 15-19 20-25 ______ __ _ ____ ___ __ ________ ____________ _ ___ _ 15-25 15-25 ______ __ _ ____ ___ __ ________ ____________ _ ___ _ ______ __ _ ____ ___ __ ________ ____________ _ ___ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 15-19 26-29 ______ __ _ ____ ___ ___ ____ ________ _ 15-25 26-29 ______ __ _ ____ ___ __ ________ ____________ _ ___ _ ___ ____ ________ _ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_pandas 30-34 40-41 _ ____ _ ____ ______ _____ ______ 30-52 30-52 _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_pandas 30-34 35-39 _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ 30-52 30-52 _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 40-41 42-52 _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ 30-52 30-52 _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_pandas 15-19 42-52 ______ __ _ ____ ___ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ 15-25 30-52 ______ __ _ ____ ___ __ ________ ____________ _ ___ _ _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_pandas 42-52 53-67 ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ __ __ ____ ____ _______ ___ _______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ _ 30-52 53-82 _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ __ __ ____ ____ _______ ___ _______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ _ __ ____ __ ___ _______ ______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ ___ _ 1<2 justify justify +GUM_reddit_pandas 53-67 68-82 __ __ ____ ____ _______ ___ _______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ _ __ ____ __ ___ _______ ______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ ___ _ 53-82 53-82 __ __ ____ ____ _______ ___ _______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ _ __ ____ __ ___ _______ ______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ ___ _ __ __ ____ ____ _______ ___ _______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ _ __ ____ __ ___ _______ ______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ ___ _ 1<2 result result +GUM_reddit_pandas 53-67 83-92 __ __ ____ ____ _______ ___ _______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ _ ___ __ ___ ____ ____ _____ _________ ____ ____ _ 53-82 83-114 __ __ ____ ____ _______ ___ _______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ _ __ ____ __ ___ _______ ______ __ _________ __ _________ __ _ _________ ___ _ ___ __ ___ ____ ____ _____ _________ ____ ____ _ ___ _______ ______ __ _____ ____________ __ ___ _________ __ _____ __________ __ ______ _ ___ _____ ____ ______ __ ___________ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_pandas 42-52 93-114 ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ ___ _______ ______ __ _____ ____________ __ ___ _________ __ _____ __________ __ ______ _ ___ _____ ____ ______ __ ___________ _ 30-52 83-114 _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ ___ __ ___ ____ ____ _____ _________ ____ ____ _ ___ _______ ______ __ _____ ____________ __ ___ _________ __ _____ __________ __ ______ _ ___ _____ ____ ______ __ ___________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 42-52 115-118 ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ __ __ ____ _ 30-52 115-118 _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ __ __ ____ _ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_pandas 115-118 119-135 __ __ ____ _ ____ __ _____ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ ____ ___ _____ ________ _______ ____ __ _____ _ 115-118 119-135 __ __ ____ _ ____ __ _____ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ ____ ___ _____ ________ _______ ____ __ _____ _ 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_reddit_pandas 119-135 136-144 ____ __ _____ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ ____ ___ _____ ________ _______ ____ __ _____ _ _ ______ ___ __ ____ ___________ ______ _____ _ 119-135 136-144 ____ __ _____ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ ____ ___ _____ ________ _______ ____ __ _____ _ _ ______ ___ __ ____ ___________ ______ _____ _ 1<2 justify justify +GUM_reddit_pandas 115-118 145-146 __ __ ____ _ ___ ___ 115-118 145-149 __ __ ____ _ ___ ___ ____ __ __ 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_reddit_pandas 145-146 147-149 ___ ___ ____ __ __ 145-149 145-149 ___ ___ ____ __ __ ___ ___ ____ __ __ 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_reddit_pandas 150-164 167-172 __ _____ __ ____ ____ ____________ _ _____ ____ ____ ____ _ ____ ____________ _ ____ __ ____ _______ _________ _ 150-164 165-172 __ _____ __ ____ ____ ____________ _ _____ ____ ____ ____ _ ____ ____________ _ _ ______ ____ __ ____ _______ _________ _ 1>2 background background +GUM_reddit_pandas 165-166 167-172 _ ______ ____ __ ____ _______ _________ _ 165-172 165-172 _ ______ ____ __ ____ _______ _________ _ _ ______ ____ __ ____ _______ _________ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_pandas 42-52 167-172 ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ ____ __ ____ _______ _________ _ 30-52 165-172 _ ____ _ ____ ______ _ _______ ______ _______ _ _____ ______ ____ ______ _____ ___________ ____ __ ___________ __ _ ____ _ _ ______ ____ __ ____ _______ _________ _ 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_reddit_pandas 173-176 200-203 _____ ___ __ __________ ___ __________ ____ _______ 173-199 200-236 _____ ___ __ __________ ____ ___ ____ ____ _ ___ __________ _____ ___ ______ __ __ ___________ __ __________ ____ _________ __ ____ _ _____ _ ____ ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ 1>2 background background +GUM_reddit_pandas 173-176 177-183 _____ ___ __ __________ ____ ___ ____ ____ _ ___ __________ 173-199 173-199 _____ ___ __ __________ ____ ___ ____ ____ _ ___ __________ _____ ___ ______ __ __ ___________ __ __________ ____ _________ __ ____ _ _____ _ ____ _____ ___ __ __________ ____ ___ ____ ____ _ ___ __________ _____ ___ ______ __ __ ___________ __ __________ ____ _________ __ ____ _ _____ _ ____ 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_reddit_pandas 177-183 184-199 ____ ___ ____ ____ _ ___ __________ _____ ___ ______ __ __ ___________ __ __________ ____ _________ __ ____ _ _____ _ ____ 173-199 173-199 _____ ___ __ __________ ____ ___ ____ ____ _ ___ __________ _____ ___ ______ __ __ ___________ __ __________ ____ _________ __ ____ _ _____ _ ____ _____ ___ __ __________ ____ ___ ____ ____ _ ___ __________ _____ ___ ______ __ __ ___________ __ __________ ____ _________ __ ____ _ _____ _ ____ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 167-172 200-203 ____ __ ____ _______ _________ _ ___ __________ ____ _______ 165-172 200-236 _ ______ ____ __ ____ _______ _________ _ ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_reddit_pandas 200-203 204-208 ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ 200-236 200-236 ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ 1<2 result result +GUM_reddit_pandas 200-203 209-220 ___ __________ ____ _______ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ 200-236 200-236 ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_reddit_pandas 209-220 221-222 ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ 200-236 200-236 ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 221-222 223-228 _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ 200-236 200-236 ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_reddit_pandas 209-220 229-236 ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ 200-236 200-236 ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ 1<2 result result +GUM_reddit_pandas 200-203 237-239 ___ __________ ____ _______ _ ____ _ 200-236 237-239 ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ _ ____ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_pandas 200-203 240-241 ___ __________ ____ _______ __________ ____ 200-236 240-241 ___ __________ ____ _______ _____ _____ ______ ______ _ ____ ____ __ ___ ____ _________ ________ ___________ __ ___ _ ____________ _____ _________ ____ __ __________ ____ _________ _ _______ _ ________ __ ___ ___ _______ _ __________ ____ 1<2 justify justify +GUM_reddit_pandas 15-19 242-243 ______ __ _ ____ ___ ___ ________ 15-25 242-243 ______ __ _ ____ ___ __ ________ ____________ _ ___ _ ___ ________ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_pandas 242-243 244-245 ___ ________ ________ ___ 242-243 244-245 ___ ________ ________ ___ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_pandas 244-245 246-250 ________ ___ __ ____ _ ____ ____ 244-245 246-250 ________ ___ __ ____ _ ____ ____ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_pandas 246-250 251-256 __ ____ _ ____ ____ ___ ____ ___ ___ ______ _ 246-250 251-256 __ ____ _ ____ ____ ___ ____ ___ ___ ______ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_pandas 15-19 257-261 ______ __ _ ____ ___ _ ____ ___ _____ ________ 15-25 257-267 ______ __ _ ____ ___ __ ________ ____________ _ ___ _ _ ____ ___ _____ ________ _______ __ __ __ _____ _ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_pandas 262-263 264-267 _______ __ __ __ _____ _ 257-267 257-267 _ ____ ___ _____ ________ _______ __ __ __ _____ _ _ ____ ___ _____ ________ _______ __ __ __ _____ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_pandas 257-261 264-267 _ ____ ___ _____ ________ __ __ _____ _ 257-267 257-267 _ ____ ___ _____ ________ _______ __ __ __ _____ _ _ ____ ___ _____ ________ _______ __ __ __ _____ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 268-269 270-271 _ _____ _ ____ 268-286 268-286 _ _____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ ___ ________ ____ _ _ _____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ ___ ________ ____ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_pandas 270-271 278-282 _ ____ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ 268-286 268-286 _ _____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ ___ ________ ____ _ _ _____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ ___ ________ ____ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_pandas 272-277 278-282 ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ 268-286 268-286 _ _____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ ___ ________ ____ _ _ _____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ ___ ________ ____ _ 1>2 condition condition +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 278-282 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ 1-14 268-286 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ _ _____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ ___ ________ ____ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_pandas 278-282 283-286 _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ ___ ________ ____ _ 268-286 268-286 _ _____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ ___ ________ ____ _ _ _____ _ ____ ____ __ ____ ___ ___ _ _______ ____ _____ _____ _____ ___ ________ ____ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 287-291 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ 1-14 287-296 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ __ ___________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 287-291 292-296 __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ __ ___________ _ 287-296 287-296 __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ __ ___________ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ __ ___________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 287-291 297-301 __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ __ ____ __ _ 287-296 297-301 __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ __ ___________ _ ____ __ ____ __ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_pandas 302-306 307-311 ___ __ __ ____ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ 302-320 302-320 ___ __ __ ____ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ ________ ___________ _____ ________ ____ ________ _ ___ __ __ ____ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ ________ ___________ _____ ________ ____ ________ _ 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_reddit_pandas 297-301 307-311 ____ __ ____ __ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ 297-301 302-320 ____ __ ____ __ _ ___ __ __ ____ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ ________ ___________ _____ ________ ____ ________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 307-311 312-315 __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ ________ ___________ 302-320 302-320 ___ __ __ ____ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ ________ ___________ _____ ________ ____ ________ _ ___ __ __ ____ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ ________ ___________ _____ ________ ____ ________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 312-315 316-320 ____ ____ ________ ___________ _____ ________ ____ ________ _ 302-320 302-320 ___ __ __ ____ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ ________ ___________ _____ ________ ____ ________ _ ___ __ __ ____ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ ________ ___________ _____ ________ ____ ________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 307-311 321-325 __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ __ ____ __ _ 302-320 321-325 ___ __ __ ____ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ ________ ___________ _____ ________ ____ ________ _ ____ __ ____ __ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_pandas 326-328 329-335 ____ _____ _ ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ 326-348 326-348 ____ _____ _ ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ ___ ____ _________ ______ ____ __ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _ ____ _____ _ ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ ___ ____ _________ ______ ____ __ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _ 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_reddit_pandas 307-311 329-335 __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ 302-320 326-348 ___ __ __ ____ _ __ ___ ___ ____ ______ ____ ____ ________ ___________ _____ ________ ____ ________ _ ____ _____ _ ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ ___ ____ _________ ______ ____ __ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_pandas 329-335 336-339 ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ ___ ____ _________ ______ 326-348 326-348 ____ _____ _ ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ ___ ____ _________ ______ ____ __ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _ ____ _____ _ ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ ___ ____ _________ ______ ____ __ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_pandas 336-339 340-342 ___ ____ _________ ______ ____ __ _______ 326-348 326-348 ____ _____ _ ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ ___ ____ _________ ______ ____ __ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _ ____ _____ _ ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ ___ ____ _________ ______ ____ __ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _ 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_reddit_pandas 340-342 343-348 ____ __ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _ 326-348 326-348 ____ _____ _ ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ ___ ____ _________ ______ ____ __ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _ ____ _____ _ ____ ___ ___ ________ _______ __ _____ ___ ____ _________ ______ ____ __ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ ________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 349-354 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ ___ ___ ___ ____ ______ _ 1-14 349-354 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ ___ ___ ___ ____ ______ _ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 355-358 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ ____ _____ ___ __ 1-14 355-365 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ ____ _____ ___ __ _________ _____________ _______ ___ ________ ________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 355-358 359-365 ____ _____ ___ __ _________ _____________ _______ ___ ________ ________ _ 355-365 355-365 ____ _____ ___ __ _________ _____________ _______ ___ ________ ________ _ ____ _____ ___ __ _________ _____________ _______ ___ ________ ________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 355-358 366-372 ____ _____ ___ __ __ ___ ____ _____ _ _ _ 355-365 366-372 ____ _____ ___ __ _________ _____________ _______ ___ ________ ________ _ __ ___ ____ _____ _ _ _ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_pandas 366-372 373-380 __ ___ ____ _____ _ _ _ _____ __ ____ _____ _ _ _ _ 366-372 373-380 __ ___ ____ _____ _ _ _ _____ __ ____ _____ _ _ _ _ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_pandas 355-358 381-388 ____ _____ ___ __ __ ___ ___ _______ ____ __ __ _ 355-365 381-388 ____ _____ ___ __ _________ _____________ _______ ___ ________ ________ _ __ ___ ___ _______ ____ __ __ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_pandas 389-393 394-398 ___ _____ __ ____ _ _______ _____ _______ ____ _______ 389-393 394-403 ___ _____ __ ____ _ _______ _____ _______ ____ _______ _______ ____ _______ ___________ _ 1>2 justify justify +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 394-398 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _______ _____ _______ ____ _______ 1-14 394-403 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ _______ _____ _______ ____ _______ _______ ____ _______ ___________ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_pandas 394-398 399-403 _______ _____ _______ ____ _______ _______ ____ _______ ___________ _ 394-403 394-403 _______ _____ _______ ____ _______ _______ ____ _______ ___________ _ _______ _____ _______ ____ _______ _______ ____ _______ ___________ _ 1<2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_pandas 394-398 404-410 _______ _____ _______ ____ _______ ___ ___ ____ __ __ __________ _ 394-403 404-410 _______ _____ _______ ____ _______ _______ ____ _______ ___________ _ ___ ___ ____ __ __ __________ _ 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 411-412 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ ___ ______ 1-14 411-412 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ ___ ______ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 413-419 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ ___ __ _____ ____ __ ________ _ 1-14 413-419 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ ___ __ _____ ____ __ ________ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 420-430 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ _ _____ __ __ _______ ____ ____ ____ __ _______ _____ 1-14 420-443 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ _ _____ __ __ _______ ____ ____ ____ __ _______ _____ ___ ______ ___ _________ __ ______ __ __ ____ __ ____ _________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 420-430 431-434 _ _____ __ __ _______ ____ ____ ____ __ _______ _____ ___ ______ ___ _________ 420-443 420-443 _ _____ __ __ _______ ____ ____ ____ __ _______ _____ ___ ______ ___ _________ __ ______ __ __ ____ __ ____ _________ _ _ _____ __ __ _______ ____ ____ ____ __ _______ _____ ___ ______ ___ _________ __ ______ __ __ ____ __ ____ _________ _ 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_reddit_pandas 420-430 435-443 _ _____ __ __ _______ ____ ____ ____ __ _______ _____ __ ______ __ __ ____ __ ____ _________ _ 420-443 420-443 _ _____ __ __ _______ ____ ____ ____ __ _______ _____ ___ ______ ___ _________ __ ______ __ __ ____ __ ____ _________ _ _ _____ __ __ _______ ____ ____ ____ __ _______ _____ ___ ______ ___ _________ __ ______ __ __ ____ __ ____ _________ _ 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_reddit_pandas 444-445 446-452 ___ ____ __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ 444-465 444-465 ___ ____ __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ __ ____ __ ____ ____ _____ ____ ___ ___ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ____ __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ __ ____ __ ____ ____ _____ ____ ___ ___ __ ___ ____ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_pandas 420-430 446-452 _ _____ __ __ _______ ____ ____ ____ __ _______ _____ __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ 420-443 444-465 _ _____ __ __ _______ ____ ____ ____ __ _______ _____ ___ ______ ___ _________ __ ______ __ __ ____ __ ____ _________ _ ___ ____ __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ __ ____ __ ____ ____ _____ ____ ___ ___ __ ___ ____ _ 1<2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_pandas 446-452 453-454 __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ __ ____ 444-465 444-465 ___ ____ __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ __ ____ __ ____ ____ _____ ____ ___ ___ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ____ __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ __ ____ __ ____ ____ _____ ____ ___ ___ __ ___ ____ _ 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_reddit_pandas 446-452 455-460 __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ __ ____ ____ _____ ____ ___ 444-465 444-465 ___ ____ __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ __ ____ __ ____ ____ _____ ____ ___ ___ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ____ __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ __ ____ __ ____ ____ _____ ____ ___ ___ __ ___ ____ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_pandas 455-460 461-465 __ ____ ____ _____ ____ ___ ___ __ ___ ____ _ 444-465 444-465 ___ ____ __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ __ ____ __ ____ ____ _____ ____ ___ ___ __ ___ ____ _ ___ ____ __ ____ _____ ____ __ _________ ____ __ ____ __ ____ ____ _____ ____ ___ ___ __ ___ ____ _ 1<2 joint joint +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 466-478 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ _______ _____ ______ ___ ___ _____ __ ___ ___ _______ _ 1-14 466-478 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ __ ___ _______ _____ ______ ___ ___ _____ __ ___ ___ _______ _ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_pandas 479-482 483-487 ___ _____ __ ____ ____ ____ ___ ___ _ 479-487 479-487 ___ _____ __ ____ ____ ____ ___ ___ _ ___ _____ __ ____ ____ ____ ___ ___ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_pandas 483-487 499-504 ____ ____ ___ ___ _ ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ 479-487 488-504 ___ _____ __ ____ ____ ____ ___ ___ _ __ __ ___ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _ ____ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ 1>2 question question +GUM_reddit_pandas 488-496 499-504 __ __ ___ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _ ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ 488-504 488-504 __ __ ___ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _ ____ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ __ __ ___ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _ ____ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ 1>2 concession concession +GUM_reddit_pandas 497-498 499-504 ____ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ 488-504 488-504 __ __ ___ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _ ____ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ __ __ ___ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _ ____ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 499-504 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ 1-14 488-504 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ __ __ ___ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _ ____ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_pandas 499-504 505-511 ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ __ __ ___ ________ __ __________ _ 488-504 505-511 __ __ ___ __ _____ ____ ____ ___ _ ____ _______ ____ ___ ______ __ _____ _ __ __ ___ ________ __ __________ _ 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 512-518 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ ____ _____ _______ ____ ___ _____ ______ 1-14 512-518 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ ____ _____ _______ ____ ___ _____ ______ 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_reddit_pandas 1-7 519-525 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ ____ ___ __ __ ____ ___ ____ 1-14 519-535 ______ ___ ___ ____ _______ __ _____ __ ___ ___ ____ __________ ____ ___________ ____ ___ __ __ ____ ___ ____ ____ _______ ___ _________ __ _____ ___ ________ _________ _ 1<2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_pandas 519-525 526-535 ____ ___ __ __ ____ ___ ____ ____ _______ ___ _________ __ _____ ___ ________ _________ _ 519-535 519-535 ____ ___ __ __ ____ ___ ____ ____ _______ ___ _________ __ _____ ___ ________ _________ _ ____ ___ __ __ ____ ___ ____ ____ _______ ___ _________ __ _____ ___ ________ _________ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 519-525 536-543 ____ ___ __ __ ____ ___ ____ ____ _______ ___ ____ _______ _____ _____ _ 519-535 536-543 ____ ___ __ __ ____ ___ ____ ____ _______ ___ _________ __ _____ ___ ________ _________ _ ____ _______ ___ ____ _______ _____ _____ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 536-543 544-565 ____ _______ ___ ____ _______ _____ _____ _ ___ __ ___ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ _____ _ ______ ___ ____ __________ _________ _ 536-543 544-565 ____ _______ ___ ____ _______ _____ _____ _ ___ __ ___ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ _____ _ ______ ___ ____ __________ _________ _ 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_reddit_pandas 544-565 566-576 ___ __ ___ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ _____ _ ______ ___ ____ __________ _________ _ _____ ________ ____ ____ __ __ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ 544-565 566-586 ___ __ ___ ____ __ ___ _____ ___ ___ _______ ____ __ ___ _____ _____ _ ______ ___ ____ __________ _________ _ _____ ________ ____ ____ __ __ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ______ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ ___ __________ _ 1<2 result result +GUM_reddit_pandas 566-576 577-586 _____ ________ ____ ____ __ __ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ______ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ ___ __________ _ 566-586 566-586 _____ ________ ____ ____ __ __ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ______ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ ___ __________ _ _____ ________ ____ ____ __ __ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ______ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ ___ __________ _ 1<2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_pandas 566-576 587-594 _____ ________ ____ ____ __ __ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ____ __ ____ ____ __________ __ __________ _________ 566-586 587-614 _____ ________ ____ ____ __ __ _____ ____ __ ___ _____ ______ ____ ___ ____ _____ __ ____ ___ __________ _ ____ __ ____ ____ __________ __ __________ _________ _____ ____ ___ __ ___ ________ ___ ____ ______ ___ __ ___ ____________ ______ ___ __ ____ ________ ____ _ 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_reddit_pandas 595-603 604-614 _____ ____ ___ __ ___ ________ ___ ____ ______ ___ __ ___ ____________ ______ ___ __ ____ ________ ____ _ 587-614 587-614 ____ __ ____ ____ __________ __ __________ _________ _____ ____ ___ __ ___ ________ ___ ____ ______ ___ __ ___ ____________ ______ ___ __ ____ ________ ____ _ ____ __ ____ ____ __________ __ __________ _________ _____ ____ ___ __ ___ ________ ___ ____ ______ ___ __ ___ ____________ ______ ___ __ ____ ________ ____ _ 1>2 cause cause +GUM_reddit_pandas 587-594 604-614 ____ __ ____ ____ __________ __ __________ _________ ___ __ ___ ____________ ______ ___ __ ____ ________ ____ _ 587-614 587-614 ____ __ ____ ____ __________ __ __________ _________ _____ ____ ___ __ ___ ________ ___ ____ ______ ___ __ ___ ____________ ______ ___ __ ____ ________ ____ _ ____ __ ____ ____ __________ __ __________ _________ _____ ____ ___ __ ___ ________ ___ ____ ______ ___ __ ___ ____________ ______ ___ __ ____ ________ ____ _ 1<2 justify justify +GUM_speech_impeachment 1-3 208-211,218-222 Madam Speaker , They are required , <*> to " do impartial justice 1-45 208-230 Madam Speaker , " I solemnly swear that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " They are required , as the oath plainly states , to " do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_speech_impeachment 4-7 8-11,33-37 " I solemnly swear that in all things <*> I will do impartial justice 1-45 1-45 Madam Speaker , " I solemnly swear that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " Madam Speaker , " I solemnly swear that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 8-11,33-37 159,169-178 that in all things <*> I will do impartial justice that <*> it calls them away from their role as partisans . 1-45 152-178 Madam Speaker , " I solemnly swear that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " The words chosen for this oath recognize that when our Constitution calls Senators to try impeachment , it calls them away from their role as partisans . 1>2 background background +GUM_speech_impeachment 8-11,33-37 12-29 that in all things <*> I will do impartial justice appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , 1-45 1-45 Madam Speaker , " I solemnly swear that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " Madam Speaker , " I solemnly swear that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 12-29 30-32 appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , 1-45 1-45 Madam Speaker , " I solemnly swear that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " Madam Speaker , " I solemnly swear that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 33-37 38-45 I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " 1-45 1-45 Madam Speaker , " I solemnly swear that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " Madam Speaker , " I solemnly swear that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " 1<2 manner manner +GUM_speech_impeachment 8-11,33-37 46-49 that in all things <*> I will do impartial justice That is the oath 1-45 46-55 Madam Speaker , " I solemnly swear that in all things appertaining to the trial of the impeachment of Donald John Trump , President of the United States , now pending , I will do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " That is the oath Senators swore on January 16 . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 46-49 50-55 That is the oath Senators swore on January 16 . 46-55 46-55 That is the oath Senators swore on January 16 . That is the oath Senators swore on January 16 . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 46-49 56-59 That is the oath It is the oath 46-55 56-74 That is the oath Senators swore on January 16 . It is the oath created by Senators when they tried the first impeachment of a President in 1868 . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 56-59 60-62 It is the oath created by Senators 56-74 56-74 It is the oath created by Senators when they tried the first impeachment of a President in 1868 . It is the oath created by Senators when they tried the first impeachment of a President in 1868 . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 60-62 63-74 created by Senators when they tried the first impeachment of a President in 1868 . 56-74 56-74 It is the oath created by Senators when they tried the first impeachment of a President in 1868 . It is the oath created by Senators when they tried the first impeachment of a President in 1868 . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_speech_impeachment 46-49 75-78 That is the oath It is an oath 46-55 75-96 That is the oath Senators swore on January 16 . It is an oath rooted in the Revolution fought by their grandparents to create a republic of laws , not kings . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 75-78 79-82 It is an oath rooted in the Revolution 75-96 75-96 It is an oath rooted in the Revolution fought by their grandparents to create a republic of laws , not kings . It is an oath rooted in the Revolution fought by their grandparents to create a republic of laws , not kings . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 79-82 83-86 rooted in the Revolution fought by their grandparents 75-96 75-96 It is an oath rooted in the Revolution fought by their grandparents to create a republic of laws , not kings . It is an oath rooted in the Revolution fought by their grandparents to create a republic of laws , not kings . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 83-86 87-96 fought by their grandparents to create a republic of laws , not kings . 75-96 75-96 It is an oath rooted in the Revolution fought by their grandparents to create a republic of laws , not kings . It is an oath rooted in the Revolution fought by their grandparents to create a republic of laws , not kings . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_speech_impeachment 46-49 97-100 That is the oath It is an oath 46-55 97-122 That is the oath Senators swore on January 16 . It is an oath whose power derives from its common sense : that a juror must always be impartial for a trial to be fair . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 97-100 101-108 It is an oath whose power derives from its common sense : 97-122 97-122 It is an oath whose power derives from its common sense : that a juror must always be impartial for a trial to be fair . It is an oath whose power derives from its common sense : that a juror must always be impartial for a trial to be fair . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 101-108 109-115 whose power derives from its common sense : that a juror must always be impartial 97-122 97-122 It is an oath whose power derives from its common sense : that a juror must always be impartial for a trial to be fair . It is an oath whose power derives from its common sense : that a juror must always be impartial for a trial to be fair . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 109-115 116-122 that a juror must always be impartial for a trial to be fair . 97-122 97-122 It is an oath whose power derives from its common sense : that a juror must always be impartial for a trial to be fair . It is an oath whose power derives from its common sense : that a juror must always be impartial for a trial to be fair . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_speech_impeachment 46-49 123-127 That is the oath And it is an oath 46-55 123-151 That is the oath Senators swore on January 16 . And it is an oath made necessary by the fact that Senators are not , as we are not , under normal circumstances , impartial in our work . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 123-127 128-132 And it is an oath made necessary by the fact 123-151 123-151 And it is an oath made necessary by the fact that Senators are not , as we are not , under normal circumstances , impartial in our work . And it is an oath made necessary by the fact that Senators are not , as we are not , under normal circumstances , impartial in our work . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 128-132 133-137,143-151 made necessary by the fact that Senators are not , <*> under normal circumstances , impartial in our work . 123-151 123-151 And it is an oath made necessary by the fact that Senators are not , as we are not , under normal circumstances , impartial in our work . And it is an oath made necessary by the fact that Senators are not , as we are not , under normal circumstances , impartial in our work . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 133-137,143-151 138-142 that Senators are not , <*> under normal circumstances , impartial in our work . as we are not , 123-151 123-151 And it is an oath made necessary by the fact that Senators are not , as we are not , under normal circumstances , impartial in our work . And it is an oath made necessary by the fact that Senators are not , as we are not , under normal circumstances , impartial in our work . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_speech_impeachment 152-153,158 159,169-178 The words <*> recognize that <*> it calls them away from their role as partisans . 152-178 152-178 The words chosen for this oath recognize that when our Constitution calls Senators to try impeachment , it calls them away from their role as partisans . The words chosen for this oath recognize that when our Constitution calls Senators to try impeachment , it calls them away from their role as partisans . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 152-153,158 154-157 The words <*> recognize chosen for this oath 152-178 152-178 The words chosen for this oath recognize that when our Constitution calls Senators to try impeachment , it calls them away from their role as partisans . The words chosen for this oath recognize that when our Constitution calls Senators to try impeachment , it calls them away from their role as partisans . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 159,169-178 208-211,218-222 that <*> it calls them away from their role as partisans . They are required , <*> to " do impartial justice 152-178 208-230 The words chosen for this oath recognize that when our Constitution calls Senators to try impeachment , it calls them away from their role as partisans . They are required , as the oath plainly states , to " do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " 1>2 justify justify +GUM_speech_impeachment 160-168 169-178 when our Constitution calls Senators to try impeachment , it calls them away from their role as partisans . 152-178 152-178 The words chosen for this oath recognize that when our Constitution calls Senators to try impeachment , it calls them away from their role as partisans . The words chosen for this oath recognize that when our Constitution calls Senators to try impeachment , it calls them away from their role as partisans . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_speech_impeachment 179-184 185-207 When that oath is taken , Senators are supposed to step back from the affiliation of party or political kinship with or opposition to the President on trial . 179-207 179-207 When that oath is taken , Senators are supposed to step back from the affiliation of party or political kinship with or opposition to the President on trial . When that oath is taken , Senators are supposed to step back from the affiliation of party or political kinship with or opposition to the President on trial . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_speech_impeachment 159,169-178 185-207 that <*> it calls them away from their role as partisans . Senators are supposed to step back from the affiliation of party or political kinship with or opposition to the President on trial . 152-178 179-207 The words chosen for this oath recognize that when our Constitution calls Senators to try impeachment , it calls them away from their role as partisans . When that oath is taken , Senators are supposed to step back from the affiliation of party or political kinship with or opposition to the President on trial . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_speech_impeachment 208-211,218-222 359-370 They are required , <*> to " do impartial justice that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , 208-230 337-387 They are required , as the oath plainly states , to " do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . 1>2 background background +GUM_speech_impeachment 208-211,218-222 212-217 They are required , <*> to " do impartial justice as the oath plainly states , 208-230 208-230 They are required , as the oath plainly states , to " do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " They are required , as the oath plainly states , to " do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_speech_impeachment 208-211,218-222 223-230 They are required , <*> to " do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " 208-230 208-230 They are required , as the oath plainly states , to " do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " They are required , as the oath plainly states , to " do impartial justice according to the Constitution and laws . " 1<2 manner manner +GUM_speech_impeachment 231-248,252-261 283-290 Madam Speaker , this afternoon , Senators will be asked to vote on the two Articles of Impeachment <*> on abuse of power and the obstruction of Congress . that they will vote against the articles . 231-261 262-290 Madam Speaker , this afternoon , Senators will be asked to vote on the two Articles of Impeachment the House presented on abuse of power and the obstruction of Congress . After voting to refuse to hear evidence and call witnesses with pertinent information , nearly all Republican Senators have already announced that they will vote against the articles . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_speech_impeachment 231-248,252-261 249-251 Madam Speaker , this afternoon , Senators will be asked to vote on the two Articles of Impeachment <*> on abuse of power and the obstruction of Congress . the House presented 231-261 231-261 Madam Speaker , this afternoon , Senators will be asked to vote on the two Articles of Impeachment the House presented on abuse of power and the obstruction of Congress . Madam Speaker , this afternoon , Senators will be asked to vote on the two Articles of Impeachment the House presented on abuse of power and the obstruction of Congress . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 262-275 276-282 After voting to refuse to hear evidence and call witnesses with pertinent information , nearly all Republican Senators have already announced 262-290 262-290 After voting to refuse to hear evidence and call witnesses with pertinent information , nearly all Republican Senators have already announced that they will vote against the articles . After voting to refuse to hear evidence and call witnesses with pertinent information , nearly all Republican Senators have already announced that they will vote against the articles . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_speech_impeachment 276-282 283-290 nearly all Republican Senators have already announced that they will vote against the articles . 262-290 262-290 After voting to refuse to hear evidence and call witnesses with pertinent information , nearly all Republican Senators have already announced that they will vote against the articles . After voting to refuse to hear evidence and call witnesses with pertinent information , nearly all Republican Senators have already announced that they will vote against the articles . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 283-290 359-370 that they will vote against the articles . that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , 262-290 337-387 After voting to refuse to hear evidence and call witnesses with pertinent information , nearly all Republican Senators have already announced that they will vote against the articles . The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . 1>2 background background +GUM_speech_impeachment 291-294 295-298 In doing so , many of them acknowledge 291-308 291-308 In doing so , many of them acknowledge that what President Trump did was wrong and inappropriate . In doing so , many of them acknowledge that what President Trump did was wrong and inappropriate . 1>2 manner manner +GUM_speech_impeachment 295-298 299-308 many of them acknowledge that what President Trump did was wrong and inappropriate . 291-308 291-308 In doing so , many of them acknowledge that what President Trump did was wrong and inappropriate . In doing so , many of them acknowledge that what President Trump did was wrong and inappropriate . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 283-290 299-308 that they will vote against the articles . that what President Trump did was wrong and inappropriate . 262-290 291-308 After voting to refuse to hear evidence and call witnesses with pertinent information , nearly all Republican Senators have already announced that they will vote against the articles . In doing so , many of them acknowledge that what President Trump did was wrong and inappropriate . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_speech_impeachment 309-310 311-322 They accept that it was wrong for him to withhold military aid to Ukraine 309-336 309-336 They accept that it was wrong for him to withhold military aid to Ukraine until the President of that country promised to interfere in the American elections . They accept that it was wrong for him to withhold military aid to Ukraine until the President of that country promised to interfere in the American elections . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 299-308 311-322 that what President Trump did was wrong and inappropriate . that it was wrong for him to withhold military aid to Ukraine 291-308 309-336 In doing so , many of them acknowledge that what President Trump did was wrong and inappropriate . They accept that it was wrong for him to withhold military aid to Ukraine until the President of that country promised to interfere in the American elections . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 311-322 323-336 that it was wrong for him to withhold military aid to Ukraine until the President of that country promised to interfere in the American elections . 309-336 309-336 They accept that it was wrong for him to withhold military aid to Ukraine until the President of that country promised to interfere in the American elections . They accept that it was wrong for him to withhold military aid to Ukraine until the President of that country promised to interfere in the American elections . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_speech_impeachment 337-347,356-358 359-370 The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt <*> is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , 337-387 337-387 The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_speech_impeachment 337-347,356-358 348-355 The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt <*> is clear enough to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections 337-387 337-387 The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 359-370 371-380 that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President 337-387 337-387 The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_speech_impeachment 371-380 381-387 yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . 337-387 337-387 The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 388-392,405-415 418-424 The Senator from Alaska , <*> tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , " I have come to the conclusion 388-436 388-436 The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " 1>2 background background +GUM_speech_impeachment 388-392,405-415 393-396 The Senator from Alaska , <*> tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , in explaining her decision 388-436 388-436 The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_speech_impeachment 393-396 397-404 in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , 388-436 388-436 The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 416-417 418-424 writing : " I have come to the conclusion 388-436 388-436 The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 418-424 467-475 " I have come to the conclusion Madam Speaker , the Congress has not failed . 388-436 467-475 The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " Madam Speaker , the Congress has not failed . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_speech_impeachment 418-424 425-436 " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " 388-436 388-436 The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 418-424 437-441 " I have come to the conclusion I agree with that . 388-436 437-441 The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " I agree with that . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_speech_impeachment 442-445 455-466 She further said : that , as an institution , the Congress has failed . " 442-466 442-466 She further said : " It is sad for me today to admit that , as an institution , the Congress has failed . " She further said : " It is sad for me today to admit that , as an institution , the Congress has failed . " 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 446-454 455-466 " It is sad for me today to admit that , as an institution , the Congress has failed . " 442-466 442-466 She further said : " It is sad for me today to admit that , as an institution , the Congress has failed . " She further said : " It is sad for me today to admit that , as an institution , the Congress has failed . " 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 418-424 455-466 " I have come to the conclusion that , as an institution , the Congress has failed . " 388-436 442-466 The Senator from Alaska , in explaining her decision to vote to block witnesses and evidence , tried to deflect responsibility from the consequences of her actions , writing : " I have come to the conclusion that there will be no fair trial in the Senate . " She further said : " It is sad for me today to admit that , as an institution , the Congress has failed . " 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 359-370 467-475 that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , Madam Speaker , the Congress has not failed . 337-387 467-475 The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . Madam Speaker , the Congress has not failed . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_speech_impeachment 467-475 476-481 Madam Speaker , the Congress has not failed . The House did its job , 467-475 476-487 Madam Speaker , the Congress has not failed . The House did its job , whether you agree or not . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_speech_impeachment 476-481 482-487 The House did its job , whether you agree or not . 476-487 476-487 The House did its job , whether you agree or not . The House did its job , whether you agree or not . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_speech_impeachment 476-481 488-506 The House did its job , In regular order , by a vote of this House , we impeached the President of the United States 476-487 488-521 The House did its job , whether you agree or not . In regular order , by a vote of this House , we impeached the President of the United States based upon our oath to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_speech_impeachment 488-506 507-510 In regular order , by a vote of this House , we impeached the President of the United States based upon our oath 488-521 488-521 In regular order , by a vote of this House , we impeached the President of the United States based upon our oath to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States . In regular order , by a vote of this House , we impeached the President of the United States based upon our oath to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_speech_impeachment 507-510 511-521 based upon our oath to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States . 488-521 488-521 In regular order , by a vote of this House , we impeached the President of the United States based upon our oath to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States . In regular order , by a vote of this House , we impeached the President of the United States based upon our oath to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 476-481 522-526 The House did its job , The House did its job 476-487 522-554 The House did its job , whether you agree or not . The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_speech_impeachment 522-526 527-532 The House did its job and did so with the solemnity 522-554 522-554 The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_speech_impeachment 527-532 533 and did so with the solemnity required 522-554 522-554 The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 533 534-540 required when undertaking the process of impeachment , 522-554 522-554 The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_speech_impeachment 534-540 541-545 when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek 522-554 522-554 The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 541-545 546-554 which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . 522-554 522-554 The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_speech_impeachment 522-526 555-558 The House did its job We held hearings , 522-554 555-565 The House did its job and did so with the solemnity required when undertaking the process of impeachment , which we did not seek but accepted as our responsibility under the Constitution . We held hearings , called witnesses , and subpoenaed documents . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_speech_impeachment 555-558 559-561 We held hearings , called witnesses , 555-565 555-565 We held hearings , called witnesses , and subpoenaed documents . We held hearings , called witnesses , and subpoenaed documents . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 555-558 562-565 We held hearings , and subpoenaed documents . 555-565 555-565 We held hearings , called witnesses , and subpoenaed documents . We held hearings , called witnesses , and subpoenaed documents . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 555-558 566-582 We held hearings , Many of the witnesses and documents , of course , were withheld by the White House . 555-565 566-582 We held hearings , called witnesses , and subpoenaed documents . Many of the witnesses and documents , of course , were withheld by the White House . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_speech_impeachment 467-475 583-589 Madam Speaker , the Congress has not failed . It is the Senate that will fail 467-475 583-600 Madam Speaker , the Congress has not failed . It is the Senate that will fail if Senators do not uphold their oaths to impartial justice . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_speech_impeachment 583-589 590-600 It is the Senate that will fail if Senators do not uphold their oaths to impartial justice . 583-600 583-600 It is the Senate that will fail if Senators do not uphold their oaths to impartial justice . It is the Senate that will fail if Senators do not uphold their oaths to impartial justice . 1<2 condition condition +GUM_speech_impeachment 583-589 601-611 It is the Senate that will fail It is the Senate , Madam Speaker , that will fail 583-600 601-641 It is the Senate that will fail if Senators do not uphold their oaths to impartial justice . It is the Senate , Madam Speaker , that will fail if it does not hold this President accountable for using a hold on military aid to compel an ally to interfere in our election for his own personal gain . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_speech_impeachment 601-611 612-619 It is the Senate , Madam Speaker , that will fail if it does not hold this President accountable 601-641 601-641 It is the Senate , Madam Speaker , that will fail if it does not hold this President accountable for using a hold on military aid to compel an ally to interfere in our election for his own personal gain . It is the Senate , Madam Speaker , that will fail if it does not hold this President accountable for using a hold on military aid to compel an ally to interfere in our election for his own personal gain . 1<2 condition condition +GUM_speech_impeachment 612-619 620-626 if it does not hold this President accountable for using a hold on military aid 601-641 601-641 It is the Senate , Madam Speaker , that will fail if it does not hold this President accountable for using a hold on military aid to compel an ally to interfere in our election for his own personal gain . It is the Senate , Madam Speaker , that will fail if it does not hold this President accountable for using a hold on military aid to compel an ally to interfere in our election for his own personal gain . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_speech_impeachment 620-626 627-641 for using a hold on military aid to compel an ally to interfere in our election for his own personal gain . 601-641 601-641 It is the Senate , Madam Speaker , that will fail if it does not hold this President accountable for using a hold on military aid to compel an ally to interfere in our election for his own personal gain . It is the Senate , Madam Speaker , that will fail if it does not hold this President accountable for using a hold on military aid to compel an ally to interfere in our election for his own personal gain . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_speech_impeachment 359-370 642-646 that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , History will judge poorly those 337-387 642-661 The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . History will judge poorly those who choose fear of their party over the courage to do the right thing . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 642-646 647-655 History will judge poorly those who choose fear of their party over the courage 642-661 642-661 History will judge poorly those who choose fear of their party over the courage to do the right thing . History will judge poorly those who choose fear of their party over the courage to do the right thing . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 647-655 656-661 who choose fear of their party over the courage to do the right thing . 642-661 642-661 History will judge poorly those who choose fear of their party over the courage to do the right thing . History will judge poorly those who choose fear of their party over the courage to do the right thing . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 662-687 698-709 Neither the Speaker nor myself , nor the whip , Jim Clyburn , urged any member in our party to vote any way on impeachment . Our members voted consistent with their oath of office and the conviction 662-687 698-724 Neither the Speaker nor myself , nor the whip , Jim Clyburn , urged any member in our party to vote any way on impeachment . Our members voted consistent with their oath of office and the conviction that that vote was required by that oath to protect and defend the Constitution . 1>2 justify justify +GUM_speech_impeachment 662-687 688-692 Neither the Speaker nor myself , nor the whip , Jim Clyburn , urged any member in our party to vote any way on impeachment . There was no lobbying . 662-687 688-692 Neither the Speaker nor myself , nor the whip , Jim Clyburn , urged any member in our party to vote any way on impeachment . There was no lobbying . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_speech_impeachment 688-692 693-697 There was no lobbying . There was no pressure . 688-692 693-697 There was no lobbying . There was no pressure . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 642-646 698-709 History will judge poorly those Our members voted consistent with their oath of office and the conviction 642-661 698-724 History will judge poorly those who choose fear of their party over the courage to do the right thing . Our members voted consistent with their oath of office and the conviction that that vote was required by that oath to protect and defend the Constitution . 1<2 background background +GUM_speech_impeachment 698-709 710-717 Our members voted consistent with their oath of office and the conviction that that vote was required by that oath 698-724 698-724 Our members voted consistent with their oath of office and the conviction that that vote was required by that oath to protect and defend the Constitution . Our members voted consistent with their oath of office and the conviction that that vote was required by that oath to protect and defend the Constitution . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 710-717 718-724 that that vote was required by that oath to protect and defend the Constitution . 698-724 698-724 Our members voted consistent with their oath of office and the conviction that that vote was required by that oath to protect and defend the Constitution . Our members voted consistent with their oath of office and the conviction that that vote was required by that oath to protect and defend the Constitution . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 642-646 725-728 History will judge poorly those Americans will judge . 642-661 725-728 History will judge poorly those who choose fear of their party over the courage to do the right thing . Americans will judge . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_speech_impeachment 729-732 733-739 I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment 729-761 729-761 I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment even knowing that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment even knowing that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 733-739 762-764,767-780 why the House passed Articles of Impeachment It is because <*> future generations will look back on this chapter in our history and ask : 729-761 762-780 I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment even knowing that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . It is because I know future generations will look back on this chapter in our history and ask : 1>2 question question +GUM_speech_impeachment 740-741 742-746 even knowing that the odds were slim 729-761 729-761 I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment even knowing that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment even knowing that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 733-739 742-746 why the House passed Articles of Impeachment that the odds were slim 729-761 729-761 I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment even knowing that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment even knowing that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_speech_impeachment 742-746 747-753 that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship 729-761 729-761 I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment even knowing that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment even knowing that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 747-753 754-761 that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . 729-761 729-761 I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment even knowing that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . I am often asked why the House passed Articles of Impeachment even knowing that the odds were slim that Senate Republicans would set aside partisanship and hear the case as impartial jurors . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 642-646 762-764,767-780 History will judge poorly those It is because <*> future generations will look back on this chapter in our history and ask : 642-661 762-780 History will judge poorly those who choose fear of their party over the courage to do the right thing . It is because I know future generations will look back on this chapter in our history and ask : 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 765-766 767-780 I know future generations will look back on this chapter in our history and ask : 762-780 762-780 It is because I know future generations will look back on this chapter in our history and ask : It is because I know future generations will look back on this chapter in our history and ask : 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 762-764,767-780 781-790 It is because <*> future generations will look back on this chapter in our history and ask : Who stood up for the Constitution and the laws ? 762-780 781-790 It is because I know future generations will look back on this chapter in our history and ask : Who stood up for the Constitution and the laws ? 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 781-790 791-796 Who stood up for the Constitution and the laws ? Who stood up for the values 781-790 791-803 Who stood up for the Constitution and the laws ? Who stood up for the values our Founders charged us to keep ? 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 791-796 797-803 Who stood up for the values our Founders charged us to keep ? 791-803 791-803 Who stood up for the values our Founders charged us to keep ? Who stood up for the values our Founders charged us to keep ? 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 781-790 804-815 Who stood up for the Constitution and the laws ? Who refused to shrink from the heavy responsibilities of their oath ? 781-790 804-815 Who stood up for the Constitution and the laws ? Who refused to shrink from the heavy responsibilities of their oath ? 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 816-819 820-826 I can be proud that the House did its job , 816-834 816-834 I can be proud that the House did its job , followed the law , defended our Constitution . I can be proud that the House did its job , followed the law , defended our Constitution . 1>2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_speech_impeachment 642-646 820-826 History will judge poorly those that the House did its job , 642-661 816-834 History will judge poorly those who choose fear of their party over the courage to do the right thing . I can be proud that the House did its job , followed the law , defended our Constitution . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_speech_impeachment 820-826 827-830 that the House did its job , followed the law , 816-834 816-834 I can be proud that the House did its job , followed the law , defended our Constitution . I can be proud that the House did its job , followed the law , defended our Constitution . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 820-826 831-834 that the House did its job , defended our Constitution . 816-834 816-834 I can be proud that the House did its job , followed the law , defended our Constitution . I can be proud that the House did its job , followed the law , defended our Constitution . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 835-839 846-855,861-863 We did not convict ; Essentially , what we said was there was probable cause <*> and certainly cause 835-845 846-881 We did not convict ; that is not our role . Essentially , what we said was there was probable cause that powers had been abused and certainly cause to see that the President refused to cooperate with the constitutional responsibilities of the House of Representatives . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_speech_impeachment 835-839 840-845 We did not convict ; that is not our role . 835-845 835-845 We did not convict ; that is not our role . We did not convict ; that is not our role . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_speech_impeachment 820-826 846-855,861-863 that the House did its job , Essentially , what we said was there was probable cause <*> and certainly cause 816-834 846-881 I can be proud that the House did its job , followed the law , defended our Constitution . Essentially , what we said was there was probable cause that powers had been abused and certainly cause to see that the President refused to cooperate with the constitutional responsibilities of the House of Representatives . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 846-855,861-863 856-860 Essentially , what we said was there was probable cause <*> and certainly cause that powers had been abused 846-881 846-881 Essentially , what we said was there was probable cause that powers had been abused and certainly cause to see that the President refused to cooperate with the constitutional responsibilities of the House of Representatives . Essentially , what we said was there was probable cause that powers had been abused and certainly cause to see that the President refused to cooperate with the constitutional responsibilities of the House of Representatives . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 864-865 866-881 to see that the President refused to cooperate with the constitutional responsibilities of the House of Representatives . 846-881 846-881 Essentially , what we said was there was probable cause that powers had been abused and certainly cause to see that the President refused to cooperate with the constitutional responsibilities of the House of Representatives . Essentially , what we said was there was probable cause that powers had been abused and certainly cause to see that the President refused to cooperate with the constitutional responsibilities of the House of Representatives . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 861-863 866-881 and certainly cause that the President refused to cooperate with the constitutional responsibilities of the House of Representatives . 846-881 846-881 Essentially , what we said was there was probable cause that powers had been abused and certainly cause to see that the President refused to cooperate with the constitutional responsibilities of the House of Representatives . Essentially , what we said was there was probable cause that powers had been abused and certainly cause to see that the President refused to cooperate with the constitutional responsibilities of the House of Representatives . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 820-826 882-890 that the House did its job , I am also proud of the House managers , 816-834 882-912 I can be proud that the House did its job , followed the law , defended our Constitution . I am also proud of the House managers , as all of my colleagues on the Democratic side of the aisle are proud of our managers who made their case . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 882-890 891-907 I am also proud of the House managers , as all of my colleagues on the Democratic side of the aisle are proud of our managers 882-912 882-912 I am also proud of the House managers , as all of my colleagues on the Democratic side of the aisle are proud of our managers who made their case . I am also proud of the House managers , as all of my colleagues on the Democratic side of the aisle are proud of our managers who made their case . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_speech_impeachment 891-907 908-912 as all of my colleagues on the Democratic side of the aisle are proud of our managers who made their case . 882-912 882-912 I am also proud of the House managers , as all of my colleagues on the Democratic side of the aisle are proud of our managers who made their case . I am also proud of the House managers , as all of my colleagues on the Democratic side of the aisle are proud of our managers who made their case . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 882-890 913-919 I am also proud of the House managers , They made their case with intellect . 882-912 913-919 I am also proud of the House managers , as all of my colleagues on the Democratic side of the aisle are proud of our managers who made their case . They made their case with intellect . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_speech_impeachment 913-919 920-925 They made their case with intellect . They made their case with evidence 913-919 920-934 They made their case with intellect . They made their case with evidence that had been adduced here in the House . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 920-925 926-934 They made their case with evidence that had been adduced here in the House . 920-934 920-934 They made their case with evidence that had been adduced here in the House . They made their case with evidence that had been adduced here in the House . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 913-919 935-938 They made their case with intellect . They made their case 913-919 935-953 They made their case with intellect . They made their case and appealed to Senators to hold this President accountable , as our Founders intended . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 935-938 939-942 They made their case and appealed to Senators 935-953 935-953 They made their case and appealed to Senators to hold this President accountable , as our Founders intended . They made their case and appealed to Senators to hold this President accountable , as our Founders intended . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 939-942 943-948 and appealed to Senators to hold this President accountable , 935-953 935-953 They made their case and appealed to Senators to hold this President accountable , as our Founders intended . They made their case and appealed to Senators to hold this President accountable , as our Founders intended . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_speech_impeachment 943-948 949-953 to hold this President accountable , as our Founders intended . 935-953 935-953 They made their case and appealed to Senators to hold this President accountable , as our Founders intended . They made their case and appealed to Senators to hold this President accountable , as our Founders intended . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_speech_impeachment 954-966 967-982 Almost everybody has watched a trial either in person or on television . A trial is not an opening argument and a closing argument with nothing in between . 954-966 967-982 Almost everybody has watched a trial either in person or on television . A trial is not an opening argument and a closing argument with nothing in between . 1>2 justify justify +GUM_speech_impeachment 967-982 1046-1054 A trial is not an opening argument and a closing argument with nothing in between . Nevertheless , the House managers proved their case . 967-982 1046-1054 A trial is not an opening argument and a closing argument with nothing in between . Nevertheless , the House managers proved their case . 1>2 background background +GUM_speech_impeachment 967-982 983-991 A trial is not an opening argument and a closing argument with nothing in between . Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses 967-982 983-1027 A trial is not an opening argument and a closing argument with nothing in between . Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_speech_impeachment 983-991 992-996 Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding 983-1027 983-1027 Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_speech_impeachment 992-996 997-1002 because that was their understanding of what a trial is , 983-1027 983-1027 Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 992-996 1003-1014 because that was their understanding not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , 983-1027 983-1027 Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 1003-1014 1015-1018 not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors 983-1027 983-1027 Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_speech_impeachment 1015-1018 1019-1027 but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . 983-1027 983-1027 Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_speech_impeachment 1028-1034 1035-1045 Any judge in this country would agree that opening and closing statements alone are not a trial . 1028-1045 1028-1045 Any judge in this country would agree that opening and closing statements alone are not a trial . Any judge in this country would agree that opening and closing statements alone are not a trial . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 1003-1014 1035-1045 not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , that opening and closing statements alone are not a trial . 983-1027 1028-1045 Seventy-five percent of our people wanted to have witnesses because that was their understanding of what a trial is , not just argument at the beginning and argument at the end , but evidence for jurors who have pledged to be impartial to consider . Any judge in this country would agree that opening and closing statements alone are not a trial . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_speech_impeachment 359-370 1046-1054 that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , Nevertheless , the House managers proved their case . 337-387 1046-1054 The evidence of President Trump 's abuse of power and attempt to solicit foreign interference in the 2020 elections is clear enough that Republican Senators can not and have not denied the facts , yet they can not bring themselves to confront this President and are choosing party over country . Nevertheless , the House managers proved their case . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 1046-1054 1055-1059 Nevertheless , the House managers proved their case . The truth is clear . 1046-1054 1055-1059 Nevertheless , the House managers proved their case . The truth is clear . 1<2 result result +GUM_speech_impeachment 1060-1063 1064-1067 The American people know what that truth is 1060-1075 1060-1075 The American people know what that truth is and know what this President has done . The American people know what that truth is and know what this President has done . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 1046-1054 1064-1067 Nevertheless , the House managers proved their case . what that truth is 1046-1054 1060-1075 Nevertheless , the House managers proved their case . The American people know what that truth is and know what this President has done . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 1068-1069 1070-1075 and know what this President has done . 1060-1075 1060-1075 The American people know what that truth is and know what this President has done . The American people know what that truth is and know what this President has done . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 1064-1067 1070-1075 what that truth is what this President has done . 1060-1075 1060-1075 The American people know what that truth is and know what this President has done . The American people know what that truth is and know what this President has done . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_speech_impeachment 1076-1079 1080-1098 And they will remember who on this day abided by the truth , the whole truth , and nothing but the truth . 1076-1098 1076-1098 And they will remember who on this day abided by the truth , the whole truth , and nothing but the truth . And they will remember who on this day abided by the truth , the whole truth , and nothing but the truth . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_speech_impeachment 1064-1067 1080-1098 what that truth is who on this day abided by the truth , the whole truth , and nothing but the truth . 1060-1075 1076-1098 The American people know what that truth is and know what this President has done . And they will remember who on this day abided by the truth , the whole truth , and nothing but the truth . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 1-2 16-17 Learning Objectives Describe cognition 1-2 16-17 Learning Objectives Describe cognition 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_textbook_cognition 3-15 16-17 By the end of this section , you will be able to : Describe cognition 3-15 16-17 By the end of this section , you will be able to : Describe cognition 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_textbook_cognition 16-17 275-286 Describe cognition Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , 16-17 275-296 Describe cognition Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , yet not all aspects of cognition are consciously experienced . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_textbook_cognition 16-17 18-21 Describe cognition Distinguish concepts and prototypes 16-17 18-21 Describe cognition Distinguish concepts and prototypes 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 16-17 22-29 Describe cognition Explain the difference between natural and artificial concepts 16-17 22-29 Describe cognition Explain the difference between natural and artificial concepts 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 30-34 72-77 Imagine all of your thoughts The brain is endlessly perceiving , 30-47 72-91 Imagine all of your thoughts as if they were physical entities , swirling rapidly inside your mind . The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_textbook_cognition 30-34 35-41 Imagine all of your thoughts as if they were physical entities , 30-47 30-47 Imagine all of your thoughts as if they were physical entities , swirling rapidly inside your mind . Imagine all of your thoughts as if they were physical entities , swirling rapidly inside your mind . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_textbook_cognition 35-41 42-47 as if they were physical entities , swirling rapidly inside your mind . 30-47 30-47 Imagine all of your thoughts as if they were physical entities , swirling rapidly inside your mind . Imagine all of your thoughts as if they were physical entities , swirling rapidly inside your mind . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 48-71 72-77 How is it possible that the brain is able to move from one thought to the next in an organized , orderly fashion ? The brain is endlessly perceiving , 48-71 72-91 How is it possible that the brain is able to move from one thought to the next in an organized , orderly fashion ? The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . 1>2 question question +GUM_textbook_cognition 72-77 275-286 The brain is endlessly perceiving , Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , 72-91 275-296 The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , yet not all aspects of cognition are consciously experienced . 1>2 background background +GUM_textbook_cognition 72-77 78-79 The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , 72-91 72-91 The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 72-77 80-81 The brain is endlessly perceiving , planning , 72-91 72-91 The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 72-77 82-83 The brain is endlessly perceiving , organizing , 72-91 72-91 The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 72-77 84-86 The brain is endlessly perceiving , and remembering — 72-91 72-91 The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 72-77 87-91 The brain is endlessly perceiving , it is always active . 72-91 72-91 The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_textbook_cognition 72-77 92-103 The brain is endlessly perceiving , Yet , you do n’t notice most of your brain ’s activity 72-91 92-111 The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . Yet , you do n’t notice most of your brain ’s activity as you move throughout your daily routine . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_textbook_cognition 92-103 104-111 Yet , you do n’t notice most of your brain ’s activity as you move throughout your daily routine . 92-111 92-111 Yet , you do n’t notice most of your brain ’s activity as you move throughout your daily routine . Yet , you do n’t notice most of your brain ’s activity as you move throughout your daily routine . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 72-77 112-120 The brain is endlessly perceiving , This is only one facet of the complex processes 72-91 112-124 The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . This is only one facet of the complex processes involved in cognition . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 112-120 121-124 This is only one facet of the complex processes involved in cognition . 112-124 112-124 This is only one facet of the complex processes involved in cognition . This is only one facet of the complex processes involved in cognition . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 72-77 125-131 The brain is endlessly perceiving , Simply put , cognition is thinking , 72-91 125-152 The brain is endlessly perceiving , processing , planning , organizing , and remembering — it is always active . Simply put , cognition is thinking , and it encompasses the processes associated with perception , knowledge , problem solving , judgment , language , and memory . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 125-131 132-136 Simply put , cognition is thinking , and it encompasses the processes 125-152 125-152 Simply put , cognition is thinking , and it encompasses the processes associated with perception , knowledge , problem solving , judgment , language , and memory . Simply put , cognition is thinking , and it encompasses the processes associated with perception , knowledge , problem solving , judgment , language , and memory . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 132-136 137-152 and it encompasses the processes associated with perception , knowledge , problem solving , judgment , language , and memory . 125-152 125-152 Simply put , cognition is thinking , and it encompasses the processes associated with perception , knowledge , problem solving , judgment , language , and memory . Simply put , cognition is thinking , and it encompasses the processes associated with perception , knowledge , problem solving , judgment , language , and memory . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 125-131 153,157-160 Simply put , cognition is thinking , Scientists <*> are searching for ways 125-152 153-197 Simply put , cognition is thinking , and it encompasses the processes associated with perception , knowledge , problem solving , judgment , language , and memory . Scientists who study cognition are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 153,157-160 154-156 Scientists <*> are searching for ways who study cognition 153-197 153-197 Scientists who study cognition are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . Scientists who study cognition are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 157-160 161-174 are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences 153-197 153-197 Scientists who study cognition are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . Scientists who study cognition are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 161-174 175-183 to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work 153-197 153-197 Scientists who study cognition are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . Scientists who study cognition are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_textbook_cognition 175-183 184-188 without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing 153-197 153-197 Scientists who study cognition are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . Scientists who study cognition are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 153,157-160 189-197 Scientists <*> are searching for ways ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . 153-197 153-197 Scientists who study cognition are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . Scientists who study cognition are searching for ways to understand how we integrate , organize , and utilize our conscious cognitive experiences without being aware of all of the unconscious work that our brains are doing ( for example , Kahneman , 2011 ) . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_textbook_cognition 198 275-286 Cognition Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , 198 275-296 Cognition Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , yet not all aspects of cognition are consciously experienced . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_textbook_cognition 199-203 204-206 Upon waking each morning , you begin thinking 199-217 199-217 Upon waking each morning , you begin thinking — contemplating the tasks that you must complete that day . Upon waking each morning , you begin thinking — contemplating the tasks that you must complete that day . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_textbook_cognition 204-206 275-286 you begin thinking Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , 199-217 275-296 Upon waking each morning , you begin thinking — contemplating the tasks that you must complete that day . Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , yet not all aspects of cognition are consciously experienced . 1>2 background background +GUM_textbook_cognition 204-206 207-210 you begin thinking — contemplating the tasks 199-217 199-217 Upon waking each morning , you begin thinking — contemplating the tasks that you must complete that day . Upon waking each morning , you begin thinking — contemplating the tasks that you must complete that day . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 207-210 211-217 — contemplating the tasks that you must complete that day . 199-217 199-217 Upon waking each morning , you begin thinking — contemplating the tasks that you must complete that day . Upon waking each morning , you begin thinking — contemplating the tasks that you must complete that day . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 207-210 218-226 — contemplating the tasks In what order should you run your errands ? 199-217 218-226 Upon waking each morning , you begin thinking — contemplating the tasks that you must complete that day . In what order should you run your errands ? 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 218-226 227-242 In what order should you run your errands ? Should you go to the bank , the cleaners , or the grocery store first ? 218-226 227-242 In what order should you run your errands ? Should you go to the bank , the cleaners , or the grocery store first ? 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 218-226 243-248 In what order should you run your errands ? Can you get these things done 218-226 243-264 In what order should you run your errands ? Can you get these things done before you head to class or will they need to wait until school is done ? 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 243-248 249-253 Can you get these things done before you head to class 243-264 243-264 Can you get these things done before you head to class or will they need to wait until school is done ? Can you get these things done before you head to class or will they need to wait until school is done ? 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_textbook_cognition 243-248 254-259 Can you get these things done or will they need to wait 243-264 243-264 Can you get these things done before you head to class or will they need to wait until school is done ? Can you get these things done before you head to class or will they need to wait until school is done ? 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_textbook_cognition 254-259 260-264 or will they need to wait until school is done ? 243-264 243-264 Can you get these things done before you head to class or will they need to wait until school is done ? Can you get these things done before you head to class or will they need to wait until school is done ? 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_textbook_cognition 204-206 265-274 you begin thinking These thoughts are one example of cognition at work . 199-217 265-274 Upon waking each morning , you begin thinking — contemplating the tasks that you must complete that day . These thoughts are one example of cognition at work . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 275-286 287-296 Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , yet not all aspects of cognition are consciously experienced . 275-296 275-296 Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , yet not all aspects of cognition are consciously experienced . Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , yet not all aspects of cognition are consciously experienced . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_textbook_cognition 275-286 297-303 Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , Cognitive psychology is the field of psychology 275-296 297-310 Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , yet not all aspects of cognition are consciously experienced . Cognitive psychology is the field of psychology dedicated to examining how people think . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 297-303 304-310 Cognitive psychology is the field of psychology dedicated to examining how people think . 297-310 297-310 Cognitive psychology is the field of psychology dedicated to examining how people think . Cognitive psychology is the field of psychology dedicated to examining how people think . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 297-303 311-321 Cognitive psychology is the field of psychology It attempts to explain how and why we think the way 297-310 311-348 Cognitive psychology is the field of psychology dedicated to examining how people think . It attempts to explain how and why we think the way we do by studying the interactions among human thinking , emotion , creativity , language , and problem solving , in addition to other cognitive processes . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 311-321 322-323 It attempts to explain how and why we think the way we do 311-348 311-348 It attempts to explain how and why we think the way we do by studying the interactions among human thinking , emotion , creativity , language , and problem solving , in addition to other cognitive processes . It attempts to explain how and why we think the way we do by studying the interactions among human thinking , emotion , creativity , language , and problem solving , in addition to other cognitive processes . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 311-321 324-348 It attempts to explain how and why we think the way by studying the interactions among human thinking , emotion , creativity , language , and problem solving , in addition to other cognitive processes . 311-348 311-348 It attempts to explain how and why we think the way we do by studying the interactions among human thinking , emotion , creativity , language , and problem solving , in addition to other cognitive processes . It attempts to explain how and why we think the way we do by studying the interactions among human thinking , emotion , creativity , language , and problem solving , in addition to other cognitive processes . 1<2 means means +GUM_textbook_cognition 297-303 349-386 Cognitive psychology is the field of psychology Cognitive psychologists strive to determine and measure different types of intelligence , why some people are better at problem solving than others , and how emotional intelligence affects success in the workplace , among countless other topics . 297-310 349-386 Cognitive psychology is the field of psychology dedicated to examining how people think . Cognitive psychologists strive to determine and measure different types of intelligence , why some people are better at problem solving than others , and how emotional intelligence affects success in the workplace , among countless other topics . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 349-386 387-397,402-407 Cognitive psychologists strive to determine and measure different types of intelligence , why some people are better at problem solving than others , and how emotional intelligence affects success in the workplace , among countless other topics . They also sometimes focus on how we organize thoughts and information <*> into meaningful categories of thought , 349-386 387-413 Cognitive psychologists strive to determine and measure different types of intelligence , why some people are better at problem solving than others , and how emotional intelligence affects success in the workplace , among countless other topics . They also sometimes focus on how we organize thoughts and information gathered from our environments into meaningful categories of thought , which will be discussed later . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 387-397,402-407 398-401 They also sometimes focus on how we organize thoughts and information <*> into meaningful categories of thought , gathered from our environments 387-413 387-413 They also sometimes focus on how we organize thoughts and information gathered from our environments into meaningful categories of thought , which will be discussed later . They also sometimes focus on how we organize thoughts and information gathered from our environments into meaningful categories of thought , which will be discussed later . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 387-397,402-407 408-413 They also sometimes focus on how we organize thoughts and information <*> into meaningful categories of thought , which will be discussed later . 387-413 387-413 They also sometimes focus on how we organize thoughts and information gathered from our environments into meaningful categories of thought , which will be discussed later . They also sometimes focus on how we organize thoughts and information gathered from our environments into meaningful categories of thought , which will be discussed later . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 414-416 597-617 Concepts and Prototypes Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . 414-416 597-617 Concepts and Prototypes Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_textbook_cognition 417-422 597-617 The human nervous system is capable Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . 417-429 597-617 The human nervous system is capable of handling endless streams of information . Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . 1>2 background background +GUM_textbook_cognition 417-422 423-429 The human nervous system is capable of handling endless streams of information . 417-429 417-429 The human nervous system is capable of handling endless streams of information . The human nervous system is capable of handling endless streams of information . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 417-422 430-443 The human nervous system is capable The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , 417-429 430-458 The human nervous system is capable of handling endless streams of information . The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , receiving stimuli and translating it into nervous impulses that are transmitted to the brain . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 430-443 444-445 The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , receiving stimuli 430-458 430-458 The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , receiving stimuli and translating it into nervous impulses that are transmitted to the brain . The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , receiving stimuli and translating it into nervous impulses that are transmitted to the brain . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 444-445 446-451 receiving stimuli and translating it into nervous impulses 430-458 430-458 The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , receiving stimuli and translating it into nervous impulses that are transmitted to the brain . The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , receiving stimuli and translating it into nervous impulses that are transmitted to the brain . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 446-451 452-458 and translating it into nervous impulses that are transmitted to the brain . 430-458 430-458 The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , receiving stimuli and translating it into nervous impulses that are transmitted to the brain . The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , receiving stimuli and translating it into nervous impulses that are transmitted to the brain . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 430-443 459-464 The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , The brain then processes this information 430-458 459-488 The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , receiving stimuli and translating it into nervous impulses that are transmitted to the brain . The brain then processes this information and uses the relevant pieces to create thoughts , which can then be expressed through language or stored in memory for future use . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_textbook_cognition 459-464 465-469 The brain then processes this information and uses the relevant pieces 459-488 459-488 The brain then processes this information and uses the relevant pieces to create thoughts , which can then be expressed through language or stored in memory for future use . The brain then processes this information and uses the relevant pieces to create thoughts , which can then be expressed through language or stored in memory for future use . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 465-469 470-473 and uses the relevant pieces to create thoughts , 459-488 459-488 The brain then processes this information and uses the relevant pieces to create thoughts , which can then be expressed through language or stored in memory for future use . The brain then processes this information and uses the relevant pieces to create thoughts , which can then be expressed through language or stored in memory for future use . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_textbook_cognition 470-473 474-480 to create thoughts , which can then be expressed through language 459-488 459-488 The brain then processes this information and uses the relevant pieces to create thoughts , which can then be expressed through language or stored in memory for future use . The brain then processes this information and uses the relevant pieces to create thoughts , which can then be expressed through language or stored in memory for future use . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 474-480 481-488 which can then be expressed through language or stored in memory for future use . 459-488 459-488 The brain then processes this information and uses the relevant pieces to create thoughts , which can then be expressed through language or stored in memory for future use . The brain then processes this information and uses the relevant pieces to create thoughts , which can then be expressed through language or stored in memory for future use . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_textbook_cognition 489-495 496-506 To make this process more complex , the brain does not gather information from external environments only . 489-506 489-506 To make this process more complex , the brain does not gather information from external environments only . To make this process more complex , the brain does not gather information from external environments only . 1>2 result result +GUM_textbook_cognition 430-443 496-506 The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , the brain does not gather information from external environments only . 430-458 489-506 The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , receiving stimuli and translating it into nervous impulses that are transmitted to the brain . To make this process more complex , the brain does not gather information from external environments only . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 507-511 512-520 When thoughts are formed , the brain also pulls information from emotions and memories 507-525 507-525 When thoughts are formed , the brain also pulls information from emotions and memories ( Figure 7.2 ) . When thoughts are formed , the brain also pulls information from emotions and memories ( Figure 7.2 ) . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_textbook_cognition 496-506 512-520 the brain does not gather information from external environments only . the brain also pulls information from emotions and memories 489-506 507-525 To make this process more complex , the brain does not gather information from external environments only . When thoughts are formed , the brain also pulls information from emotions and memories ( Figure 7.2 ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 512-520 521-525 the brain also pulls information from emotions and memories ( Figure 7.2 ) . 507-525 507-525 When thoughts are formed , the brain also pulls information from emotions and memories ( Figure 7.2 ) . When thoughts are formed , the brain also pulls information from emotions and memories ( Figure 7.2 ) . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_textbook_cognition 512-520 526-538 the brain also pulls information from emotions and memories Emotion and memory are powerful influences on both our thoughts and behaviors . 507-525 526-538 When thoughts are formed , the brain also pulls information from emotions and memories ( Figure 7.2 ) . Emotion and memory are powerful influences on both our thoughts and behaviors . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 539-540 541-549 Figure 7.2 Sensations and information are received by our brains , 539-540 541-561 Figure 7.2 Sensations and information are received by our brains , filtered through emotions and memories , and processed to become thoughts . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_textbook_cognition 430-443 541-549 The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , Sensations and information are received by our brains , 430-458 541-561 The senses serve as the interface between the mind and the external environment , receiving stimuli and translating it into nervous impulses that are transmitted to the brain . Sensations and information are received by our brains , filtered through emotions and memories , and processed to become thoughts . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_textbook_cognition 541-549 550-555 Sensations and information are received by our brains , filtered through emotions and memories , 541-561 541-561 Sensations and information are received by our brains , filtered through emotions and memories , and processed to become thoughts . Sensations and information are received by our brains , filtered through emotions and memories , and processed to become thoughts . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_textbook_cognition 541-549 556-557 Sensations and information are received by our brains , and processed 541-561 541-561 Sensations and information are received by our brains , filtered through emotions and memories , and processed to become thoughts . Sensations and information are received by our brains , filtered through emotions and memories , and processed to become thoughts . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_textbook_cognition 556-557 558-561 and processed to become thoughts . 541-561 541-561 Sensations and information are received by our brains , filtered through emotions and memories , and processed to become thoughts . Sensations and information are received by our brains , filtered through emotions and memories , and processed to become thoughts . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_textbook_cognition 562-571 572-584 In order to organize this staggering amount of information , the brain has developed a file cabinet of sorts in the mind . 562-584 562-584 In order to organize this staggering amount of information , the brain has developed a file cabinet of sorts in the mind . In order to organize this staggering amount of information , the brain has developed a file cabinet of sorts in the mind . 1>2 purpose purpose +GUM_textbook_cognition 572-584 597-617 the brain has developed a file cabinet of sorts in the mind . Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . 562-584 597-617 In order to organize this staggering amount of information , the brain has developed a file cabinet of sorts in the mind . Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . 1>2 background background +GUM_textbook_cognition 572-584 585-587,593-596 the brain has developed a file cabinet of sorts in the mind . The different files <*> are called concepts . 562-584 585-596 In order to organize this staggering amount of information , the brain has developed a file cabinet of sorts in the mind . The different files stored in the file cabinet are called concepts . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 585-587,593-596 588-592 The different files <*> are called concepts . stored in the file cabinet 585-596 585-596 The different files stored in the file cabinet are called concepts . The different files stored in the file cabinet are called concepts . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 275-286 597-617 Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . 275-296 597-617 Exceptionally complex , cognition is an essential feature of human consciousness , yet not all aspects of cognition are consciously experienced . Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 597-617 618-626 Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . Concepts are , in many ways , big ideas 597-617 618-643 Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . Concepts are , in many ways , big ideas that are generated by observing details , and categorizing and combining these details into cognitive structures . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 618-626 627-629 Concepts are , in many ways , big ideas that are generated 618-643 618-643 Concepts are , in many ways , big ideas that are generated by observing details , and categorizing and combining these details into cognitive structures . Concepts are , in many ways , big ideas that are generated by observing details , and categorizing and combining these details into cognitive structures . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 627-629 630-633 that are generated by observing details , 618-643 618-643 Concepts are , in many ways , big ideas that are generated by observing details , and categorizing and combining these details into cognitive structures . Concepts are , in many ways , big ideas that are generated by observing details , and categorizing and combining these details into cognitive structures . 1<2 means means +GUM_textbook_cognition 630-633 634-643 by observing details , and categorizing and combining these details into cognitive structures . 618-643 618-643 Concepts are , in many ways , big ideas that are generated by observing details , and categorizing and combining these details into cognitive structures . Concepts are , in many ways , big ideas that are generated by observing details , and categorizing and combining these details into cognitive structures . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_textbook_cognition 597-617 644-646 Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . You use concepts 597-617 644-669 Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . You use concepts to see the relationships among the different elements of your experiences and to keep the information in your mind organized and accessible . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 644-646 647-657 You use concepts to see the relationships among the different elements of your experiences 644-669 644-669 You use concepts to see the relationships among the different elements of your experiences and to keep the information in your mind organized and accessible . You use concepts to see the relationships among the different elements of your experiences and to keep the information in your mind organized and accessible . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_textbook_cognition 647-657 658-669 to see the relationships among the different elements of your experiences and to keep the information in your mind organized and accessible . 644-669 644-669 You use concepts to see the relationships among the different elements of your experiences and to keep the information in your mind organized and accessible . You use concepts to see the relationships among the different elements of your experiences and to keep the information in your mind organized and accessible . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 670-676 700-706,710-714 Concepts are informed by our semantic memory however , one of the easiest places <*> is inside a classroom , 670-720 670-720 Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_textbook_cognition 670-676 677-689 Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) 670-720 670-720 Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 670-676 690-699 Concepts are informed by our semantic memory and are present in every aspect of our lives ; 670-720 670-720 Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 597-617 700-706,710-714 Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . however , one of the easiest places <*> is inside a classroom , 597-617 670-720 Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 700-706,710-714 707-709 however , one of the easiest places <*> is inside a classroom , to notice concepts 670-720 670-720 Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 710-714 715-720 is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . 670-720 670-720 Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 721-730 731-738 When you study United States history , for example , you learn about more than just individual events 721-746 721-746 When you study United States history , for example , you learn about more than just individual events that have happened in America ’s past . When you study United States history , for example , you learn about more than just individual events that have happened in America ’s past . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_textbook_cognition 700-706,710-714 731-738 however , one of the easiest places <*> is inside a classroom , you learn about more than just individual events 670-720 721-746 Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . When you study United States history , for example , you learn about more than just individual events that have happened in America ’s past . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_textbook_cognition 731-738 739-746 you learn about more than just individual events that have happened in America ’s past . 721-746 721-746 When you study United States history , for example , you learn about more than just individual events that have happened in America ’s past . When you study United States history , for example , you learn about more than just individual events that have happened in America ’s past . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 731-738 747-753 you learn about more than just individual events You absorb a large quantity of information 721-746 747-773 When you study United States history , for example , you learn about more than just individual events that have happened in America ’s past . You absorb a large quantity of information by listening to and participating in discussions , examining maps , and reading first-hand accounts of people ’s lives . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 747-753 754-761 You absorb a large quantity of information by listening to and participating in discussions , 747-773 747-773 You absorb a large quantity of information by listening to and participating in discussions , examining maps , and reading first-hand accounts of people ’s lives . You absorb a large quantity of information by listening to and participating in discussions , examining maps , and reading first-hand accounts of people ’s lives . 1<2 means means +GUM_textbook_cognition 754-761 762-764 by listening to and participating in discussions , examining maps , 747-773 747-773 You absorb a large quantity of information by listening to and participating in discussions , examining maps , and reading first-hand accounts of people ’s lives . You absorb a large quantity of information by listening to and participating in discussions , examining maps , and reading first-hand accounts of people ’s lives . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 754-761 765-773 by listening to and participating in discussions , and reading first-hand accounts of people ’s lives . 747-773 747-773 You absorb a large quantity of information by listening to and participating in discussions , examining maps , and reading first-hand accounts of people ’s lives . You absorb a large quantity of information by listening to and participating in discussions , examining maps , and reading first-hand accounts of people ’s lives . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 747-753 774-778 You absorb a large quantity of information Your brain analyzes these details 747-773 774-787 You absorb a large quantity of information by listening to and participating in discussions , examining maps , and reading first-hand accounts of people ’s lives . Your brain analyzes these details and develops an overall understanding of American history . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_textbook_cognition 747-753 779-787 You absorb a large quantity of information and develops an overall understanding of American history . 747-773 774-787 You absorb a large quantity of information by listening to and participating in discussions , examining maps , and reading first-hand accounts of people ’s lives . Your brain analyzes these details and develops an overall understanding of American history . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_textbook_cognition 747-753 788-795 You absorb a large quantity of information In the process , your brain gathers details 747-773 788-812 You absorb a large quantity of information by listening to and participating in discussions , examining maps , and reading first-hand accounts of people ’s lives . In the process , your brain gathers details that inform and refine your understanding of related concepts like democracy , power , and freedom . 1<2 result result +GUM_textbook_cognition 788-795 796-812 In the process , your brain gathers details that inform and refine your understanding of related concepts like democracy , power , and freedom . 788-812 788-812 In the process , your brain gathers details that inform and refine your understanding of related concepts like democracy , power , and freedom . In the process , your brain gathers details that inform and refine your understanding of related concepts like democracy , power , and freedom . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 700-706,710-714 813-831 however , one of the easiest places <*> is inside a classroom , Concepts can be complex and abstract , like justice , or more concrete , like types of birds . 670-720 813-831 Concepts are informed by our semantic memory ( you will learn more about semantic memory in a later chapter ) and are present in every aspect of our lives ; however , one of the easiest places to notice concepts is inside a classroom , where they are discussed explicitly . Concepts can be complex and abstract , like justice , or more concrete , like types of birds . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 813-831 832-846 Concepts can be complex and abstract , like justice , or more concrete , like types of birds . In psychology , for example , Piaget ’s stages of development are abstract concepts . 813-831 832-846 Concepts can be complex and abstract , like justice , or more concrete , like types of birds . In psychology , for example , Piaget ’s stages of development are abstract concepts . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_textbook_cognition 832-846 847-859 In psychology , for example , Piaget ’s stages of development are abstract concepts . Some concepts , like tolerance , are agreed upon by many people , 832-846 847-871 In psychology , for example , Piaget ’s stages of development are abstract concepts . Some concepts , like tolerance , are agreed upon by many people , because they have been used in various ways over many years . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 847-859 860-871 Some concepts , like tolerance , are agreed upon by many people , because they have been used in various ways over many years . 847-871 847-871 Some concepts , like tolerance , are agreed upon by many people , because they have been used in various ways over many years . Some concepts , like tolerance , are agreed upon by many people , because they have been used in various ways over many years . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_textbook_cognition 847-859 872-893 Some concepts , like tolerance , are agreed upon by many people , Other concepts , like the characteristics of your ideal friend or your family ’s birthday traditions , are personal and individualized . 847-871 872-893 Some concepts , like tolerance , are agreed upon by many people , because they have been used in various ways over many years . Other concepts , like the characteristics of your ideal friend or your family ’s birthday traditions , are personal and individualized . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_textbook_cognition 813-831 894-905 Concepts can be complex and abstract , like justice , or more concrete , like types of birds . In this way , concepts touch every aspect of our lives , 813-831 894-920 Concepts can be complex and abstract , like justice , or more concrete , like types of birds . In this way , concepts touch every aspect of our lives , from our many daily routines to the guiding principles behind the way governments function . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_textbook_cognition 894-905 906-917 In this way , concepts touch every aspect of our lives , from our many daily routines to the guiding principles behind the way 894-920 894-920 In this way , concepts touch every aspect of our lives , from our many daily routines to the guiding principles behind the way governments function . In this way , concepts touch every aspect of our lives , from our many daily routines to the guiding principles behind the way governments function . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 906-917 918-920 from our many daily routines to the guiding principles behind the way governments function . 894-920 894-920 In this way , concepts touch every aspect of our lives , from our many daily routines to the guiding principles behind the way governments function . In this way , concepts touch every aspect of our lives , from our many daily routines to the guiding principles behind the way governments function . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 921-922,930-937 942-953 Another technique <*> is the identification of prototypes for the concepts A prototype is the best example or representation of a concept . 921-941 942-953 Another technique used by your brain to organize information is the identification of prototypes for the concepts you have developed . A prototype is the best example or representation of a concept . 1>2 background background +GUM_textbook_cognition 921-922,930-937 923-926 Another technique <*> is the identification of prototypes for the concepts used by your brain 921-941 921-941 Another technique used by your brain to organize information is the identification of prototypes for the concepts you have developed . Another technique used by your brain to organize information is the identification of prototypes for the concepts you have developed . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 923-926 927-929 used by your brain to organize information 921-941 921-941 Another technique used by your brain to organize information is the identification of prototypes for the concepts you have developed . Another technique used by your brain to organize information is the identification of prototypes for the concepts you have developed . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_textbook_cognition 930-937 938-941 is the identification of prototypes for the concepts you have developed . 921-941 921-941 Another technique used by your brain to organize information is the identification of prototypes for the concepts you have developed . Another technique used by your brain to organize information is the identification of prototypes for the concepts you have developed . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 597-617 942-953 Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . A prototype is the best example or representation of a concept . 597-617 942-953 Concepts are categories or groupings of linguistic information , images , ideas , or memories , such as life experiences . A prototype is the best example or representation of a concept . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 942-953 954-970 A prototype is the best example or representation of a concept . For example , for the category of civil disobedience , your prototype could be Rosa Parks . 942-953 954-970 A prototype is the best example or representation of a concept . For example , for the category of civil disobedience , your prototype could be Rosa Parks . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 954-970 971-992 For example , for the category of civil disobedience , your prototype could be Rosa Parks . Her peaceful resistance to segregation on a city bus in Montgomery , Alabama , is a recognizable example of civil disobedience . 954-970 971-992 For example , for the category of civil disobedience , your prototype could be Rosa Parks . Her peaceful resistance to segregation on a city bus in Montgomery , Alabama , is a recognizable example of civil disobedience . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_textbook_cognition 954-970 993-1000 For example , for the category of civil disobedience , your prototype could be Rosa Parks . Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , 954-970 993-1018 For example , for the category of civil disobedience , your prototype could be Rosa Parks . Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , sometimes called Mahatma Gandhi ( “ Mahatma ” is an honorific title ) ( Figure 7.3 ) . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_textbook_cognition 993-1000 1001-1004 Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , sometimes called Mahatma Gandhi 993-1018 993-1018 Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , sometimes called Mahatma Gandhi ( “ Mahatma ” is an honorific title ) ( Figure 7.3 ) . Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , sometimes called Mahatma Gandhi ( “ Mahatma ” is an honorific title ) ( Figure 7.3 ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 1001-1004 1005-1013 sometimes called Mahatma Gandhi ( “ Mahatma ” is an honorific title ) 993-1018 993-1018 Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , sometimes called Mahatma Gandhi ( “ Mahatma ” is an honorific title ) ( Figure 7.3 ) . Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , sometimes called Mahatma Gandhi ( “ Mahatma ” is an honorific title ) ( Figure 7.3 ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 993-1000 1014-1018 Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , ( Figure 7.3 ) . 993-1018 993-1018 Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , sometimes called Mahatma Gandhi ( “ Mahatma ” is an honorific title ) ( Figure 7.3 ) . Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , sometimes called Mahatma Gandhi ( “ Mahatma ” is an honorific title ) ( Figure 7.3 ) . 1<2 background background +GUM_textbook_cognition 1019-1020 1021-1040 Figure 7.3 In 1930 , Mohandas Gandhi led a group in peaceful protest against a British tax on salt in India . 1019-1020 1021-1040 Figure 7.3 In 1930 , Mohandas Gandhi led a group in peaceful protest against a British tax on salt in India . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_textbook_cognition 993-1000 1021-1040 Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , In 1930 , Mohandas Gandhi led a group in peaceful protest against a British tax on salt in India . 993-1018 1021-1040 Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , sometimes called Mahatma Gandhi ( “ Mahatma ” is an honorific title ) ( Figure 7.3 ) . In 1930 , Mohandas Gandhi led a group in peaceful protest against a British tax on salt in India . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_textbook_cognition 993-1000 1041-1051 Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , Mohandas Gandhi served as a nonviolent force for independence for India 993-1018 1041-1073 Or your prototype could be Mohandas Gandhi , sometimes called Mahatma Gandhi ( “ Mahatma ” is an honorific title ) ( Figure 7.3 ) . Mohandas Gandhi served as a nonviolent force for independence for India while simultaneously demanding that Buddhist , Hindu , Muslim , and Christian leaders — both Indian and British — collaborate peacefully . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_textbook_cognition 1041-1051 1052-1064,1071-1073 Mohandas Gandhi served as a nonviolent force for independence for India while simultaneously demanding that Buddhist , Hindu , Muslim , and Christian leaders <*> collaborate peacefully . 1041-1073 1041-1073 Mohandas Gandhi served as a nonviolent force for independence for India while simultaneously demanding that Buddhist , Hindu , Muslim , and Christian leaders — both Indian and British — collaborate peacefully . Mohandas Gandhi served as a nonviolent force for independence for India while simultaneously demanding that Buddhist , Hindu , Muslim , and Christian leaders — both Indian and British — collaborate peacefully . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_textbook_cognition 1052-1064,1071-1073 1065-1070 while simultaneously demanding that Buddhist , Hindu , Muslim , and Christian leaders <*> collaborate peacefully . — both Indian and British — 1041-1073 1041-1073 Mohandas Gandhi served as a nonviolent force for independence for India while simultaneously demanding that Buddhist , Hindu , Muslim , and Christian leaders — both Indian and British — collaborate peacefully . Mohandas Gandhi served as a nonviolent force for independence for India while simultaneously demanding that Buddhist , Hindu , Muslim , and Christian leaders — both Indian and British — collaborate peacefully . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 1074-1079 1086-1096 Although he was not always successful his life provides a steadfast example of the civil disobedience prototype 1074-1104 1074-1104 Although he was not always successful in preventing violence around him , his life provides a steadfast example of the civil disobedience prototype ( Constitutional Rights Foundation , 2013 ) . Although he was not always successful in preventing violence around him , his life provides a steadfast example of the civil disobedience prototype ( Constitutional Rights Foundation , 2013 ) . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_textbook_cognition 1074-1079 1080-1085 Although he was not always successful in preventing violence around him , 1074-1104 1074-1104 Although he was not always successful in preventing violence around him , his life provides a steadfast example of the civil disobedience prototype ( Constitutional Rights Foundation , 2013 ) . Although he was not always successful in preventing violence around him , his life provides a steadfast example of the civil disobedience prototype ( Constitutional Rights Foundation , 2013 ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 1041-1051 1086-1096 Mohandas Gandhi served as a nonviolent force for independence for India his life provides a steadfast example of the civil disobedience prototype 1041-1073 1074-1104 Mohandas Gandhi served as a nonviolent force for independence for India while simultaneously demanding that Buddhist , Hindu , Muslim , and Christian leaders — both Indian and British — collaborate peacefully . Although he was not always successful in preventing violence around him , his life provides a steadfast example of the civil disobedience prototype ( Constitutional Rights Foundation , 2013 ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 1041-1051 1097-1104 Mohandas Gandhi served as a nonviolent force for independence for India ( Constitutional Rights Foundation , 2013 ) . 1041-1073 1074-1104 Mohandas Gandhi served as a nonviolent force for independence for India while simultaneously demanding that Buddhist , Hindu , Muslim , and Christian leaders — both Indian and British — collaborate peacefully . Although he was not always successful in preventing violence around him , his life provides a steadfast example of the civil disobedience prototype ( Constitutional Rights Foundation , 2013 ) . 1<2 attribution attribution +GUM_textbook_cognition 1105-1113 1114-1120,1131-1132 Just as concepts can be abstract or concrete , we can make a distinction between concepts <*> and those 1105-1139 1105-1139 Just as concepts can be abstract or concrete , we can make a distinction between concepts that are functions of our direct experience with the world and those that are more artificial in nature . Just as concepts can be abstract or concrete , we can make a distinction between concepts that are functions of our direct experience with the world and those that are more artificial in nature . 1>2 manner manner +GUM_textbook_cognition 942-953 1114-1120,1131-1132 A prototype is the best example or representation of a concept . we can make a distinction between concepts <*> and those 942-953 1105-1139 A prototype is the best example or representation of a concept . Just as concepts can be abstract or concrete , we can make a distinction between concepts that are functions of our direct experience with the world and those that are more artificial in nature . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 1114-1120,1131-1132 1121-1130 we can make a distinction between concepts <*> and those that are functions of our direct experience with the world 1105-1139 1105-1139 Just as concepts can be abstract or concrete , we can make a distinction between concepts that are functions of our direct experience with the world and those that are more artificial in nature . Just as concepts can be abstract or concrete , we can make a distinction between concepts that are functions of our direct experience with the world and those that are more artificial in nature . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_textbook_cognition 1131-1132 1133-1139 and those that are more artificial in nature . 1105-1139 1105-1139 Just as concepts can be abstract or concrete , we can make a distinction between concepts that are functions of our direct experience with the world and those that are more artificial in nature . Just as concepts can be abstract or concrete , we can make a distinction between concepts that are functions of our direct experience with the world and those that are more artificial in nature . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 1-5 114-125,136-139 What 's up YouTube ? So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine 1-5 114-175 What 's up YouTube ? So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_vlog_radiology 6-13 52-60 So we are going to do a week and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , 6-17 26-67 So we are going to do a week of me vlogging . I bounced around here and there , so I have to kind of show you guys around and show you what it 's all about , and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , so let 's start the day . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_vlog_radiology 6-13 14-17 So we are going to do a week of me vlogging . 6-17 6-17 So we are going to do a week of me vlogging . So we are going to do a week of me vlogging . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 6-13 18-25 So we are going to do a week It 's kind of an interesting week . 6-17 18-25 So we are going to do a week of me vlogging . It 's kind of an interesting week . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_vlog_radiology 26-32 33-42 I bounced around here and there , so I have to kind of show you guys around 26-67 26-67 I bounced around here and there , so I have to kind of show you guys around and show you what it 's all about , and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , so let 's start the day . I bounced around here and there , so I have to kind of show you guys around and show you what it 's all about , and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , so let 's start the day . 1>2 background background +GUM_vlog_radiology 33-42 52-60 so I have to kind of show you guys around and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , 26-67 26-67 I bounced around here and there , so I have to kind of show you guys around and show you what it 's all about , and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , so let 's start the day . I bounced around here and there , so I have to kind of show you guys around and show you what it 's all about , and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , so let 's start the day . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_vlog_radiology 33-42 43-51 so I have to kind of show you guys around and show you what it 's all about , 26-67 26-67 I bounced around here and there , so I have to kind of show you guys around and show you what it 's all about , and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , so let 's start the day . I bounced around here and there , so I have to kind of show you guys around and show you what it 's all about , and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , so let 's start the day . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_vlog_radiology 52-60 114-125,136-139 and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine 26-67 114-175 I bounced around here and there , so I have to kind of show you guys around and show you what it 's all about , and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , so let 's start the day . So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . 1>2 background background +GUM_vlog_radiology 61-67 114-125,136-139 so let 's start the day . So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine 26-67 114-175 I bounced around here and there , so I have to kind of show you guys around and show you what it 's all about , and today I 'm on general nuclear medicine , so let 's start the day . So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_vlog_radiology 68-72 73-83 So like I said , I 'm on my general nuclear medicine rotation this week . 68-83 68-83 So like I said , I 'm on my general nuclear medicine rotation this week . So like I said , I 'm on my general nuclear medicine rotation this week . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_vlog_radiology 73-83 114-125,136-139 I 'm on my general nuclear medicine rotation this week . So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine 68-83 114-175 So like I said , I 'm on my general nuclear medicine rotation this week . So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . 1>2 background background +GUM_vlog_radiology 84-88 103-113 I get switched around -- so I 'll be at other spots later this week . 84-113 84-113 I get switched around -- moved around a few times to cover some residents who are on vacation , so I 'll be at other spots later this week . I get switched around -- moved around a few times to cover some residents who are on vacation , so I 'll be at other spots later this week . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_vlog_radiology 84-88 89-93 I get switched around -- moved around a few times 84-113 84-113 I get switched around -- moved around a few times to cover some residents who are on vacation , so I 'll be at other spots later this week . I get switched around -- moved around a few times to cover some residents who are on vacation , so I 'll be at other spots later this week . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_vlog_radiology 84-88 94-97 I get switched around -- to cover some residents 84-113 84-113 I get switched around -- moved around a few times to cover some residents who are on vacation , so I 'll be at other spots later this week . I get switched around -- moved around a few times to cover some residents who are on vacation , so I 'll be at other spots later this week . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_vlog_radiology 94-97 98-102 to cover some residents who are on vacation , 84-113 84-113 I get switched around -- moved around a few times to cover some residents who are on vacation , so I 'll be at other spots later this week . I get switched around -- moved around a few times to cover some residents who are on vacation , so I 'll be at other spots later this week . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 73-83 103-113 I 'm on my general nuclear medicine rotation this week . so I 'll be at other spots later this week . 68-83 84-113 So like I said , I 'm on my general nuclear medicine rotation this week . I get switched around -- moved around a few times to cover some residents who are on vacation , so I 'll be at other spots later this week . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_vlog_radiology 114-125,136-139 126-135 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) 114-175 114-175 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_vlog_radiology 114-125,136-139 140-146 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time 114-175 114-175 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_vlog_radiology 140-146 147-159 because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ 114-175 114-175 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_vlog_radiology 147-159 160-163 for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , 114-175 114-175 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 140-146 164-175 because a lot of stuff takes time so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . 114-175 114-175 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . 1<2 result result +GUM_vlog_radiology 114-125,136-139 176-182 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine So I 've done three lymphoscintigraphies . 114-175 176-182 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . So I 've done three lymphoscintigraphies . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 176-182 183-190 So I 've done three lymphoscintigraphies . For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin 176-182 183-233 So I 've done three lymphoscintigraphies . For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . 1<2 background background +GUM_vlog_radiology 183-190 191-193 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma 183-233 183-233 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 194-197 198-211 and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , 183-233 183-233 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_vlog_radiology 183-190 198-211 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , 183-233 183-233 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 198-211 212-224 we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node 183-233 183-233 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_vlog_radiology 212-224 225-233 and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . 183-233 183-233 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 183-190 234-243 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin What we do is we mark it under our cameras 183-233 234-293 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . What we do is we mark it under our cameras and then the patient will go up to the OR , have the melanoma , a wide excision of the melanoma , and then they will try to find the lymph node that we marked and take that one out as well to make sure there 's no metastasis . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 183-190 244-254 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin and then the patient will go up to the OR , 183-233 234-293 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . What we do is we mark it under our cameras and then the patient will go up to the OR , have the melanoma , a wide excision of the melanoma , and then they will try to find the lymph node that we marked and take that one out as well to make sure there 's no metastasis . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 183-190 255-265 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin have the melanoma , a wide excision of the melanoma , 183-233 234-293 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . What we do is we mark it under our cameras and then the patient will go up to the OR , have the melanoma , a wide excision of the melanoma , and then they will try to find the lymph node that we marked and take that one out as well to make sure there 's no metastasis . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 183-190 266-275 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin and then they will try to find the lymph node 183-233 234-293 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . What we do is we mark it under our cameras and then the patient will go up to the OR , have the melanoma , a wide excision of the melanoma , and then they will try to find the lymph node that we marked and take that one out as well to make sure there 's no metastasis . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 266-275 276-278 and then they will try to find the lymph node that we marked 234-293 234-293 What we do is we mark it under our cameras and then the patient will go up to the OR , have the melanoma , a wide excision of the melanoma , and then they will try to find the lymph node that we marked and take that one out as well to make sure there 's no metastasis . What we do is we mark it under our cameras and then the patient will go up to the OR , have the melanoma , a wide excision of the melanoma , and then they will try to find the lymph node that we marked and take that one out as well to make sure there 's no metastasis . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 183-190 279-285 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin and take that one out as well 183-233 234-293 For lymphoscintigraphies we basically inject technetium in skin surrounding a melanoma and after we inject we wait about 15 - 20 minutes , maybe up to an hour , and wait for that radio tracer to travel to the closest lymph node which we would call the sentinel lymph node . What we do is we mark it under our cameras and then the patient will go up to the OR , have the melanoma , a wide excision of the melanoma , and then they will try to find the lymph node that we marked and take that one out as well to make sure there 's no metastasis . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 279-285 286-293 and take that one out as well to make sure there 's no metastasis . 234-293 234-293 What we do is we mark it under our cameras and then the patient will go up to the OR , have the melanoma , a wide excision of the melanoma , and then they will try to find the lymph node that we marked and take that one out as well to make sure there 's no metastasis . What we do is we mark it under our cameras and then the patient will go up to the OR , have the melanoma , a wide excision of the melanoma , and then they will try to find the lymph node that we marked and take that one out as well to make sure there 's no metastasis . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_vlog_radiology 176-182 294-303 So I 've done three lymphoscintigraphies . So I 've done three of those this morning . 176-182 294-303 So I 've done three lymphoscintigraphies . So I 've done three of those this morning . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_vlog_radiology 114-125,136-139 304-310 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine I will read a few more scans 114-175 304-329 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . I will read a few more scans coming up here shortly and just trying to tie up some loose ends before I go to conference . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 304-310 311-314 I will read a few more scans coming up here shortly 304-329 304-329 I will read a few more scans coming up here shortly and just trying to tie up some loose ends before I go to conference . I will read a few more scans coming up here shortly and just trying to tie up some loose ends before I go to conference . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 304-310 315-323 I will read a few more scans and just trying to tie up some loose ends 304-329 304-329 I will read a few more scans coming up here shortly and just trying to tie up some loose ends before I go to conference . I will read a few more scans coming up here shortly and just trying to tie up some loose ends before I go to conference . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_vlog_radiology 315-323 324-329 and just trying to tie up some loose ends before I go to conference . 304-329 304-329 I will read a few more scans coming up here shortly and just trying to tie up some loose ends before I go to conference . I will read a few more scans coming up here shortly and just trying to tie up some loose ends before I go to conference . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_vlog_radiology 304-310 330-336 I will read a few more scans I 'll check back in afterwards . 304-329 330-336 I will read a few more scans coming up here shortly and just trying to tie up some loose ends before I go to conference . I 'll check back in afterwards . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 337-347 358-364 Ah , the sun feels so good on the face . We get to head home early today 337-347 358-409 Ah , the sun feels so good on the face . We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . 1>2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_vlog_radiology 348-352 358-364 I 'm officially done . We get to head home early today 348-352 358-409 I 'm officially done . We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_vlog_radiology 353-357 358-364 It is about 4:00 p.m. We get to head home early today 353-357 358-409 It is about 4:00 p.m. We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_vlog_radiology 114-125,136-139 358-364 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine We get to head home early today 114-175 358-409 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 358-364 365-371 We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , 358-409 358-409 We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_vlog_radiology 358-364 372-378 We get to head home early today and I 'm gon na go home 358-409 358-409 We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . 1<2 result result +GUM_vlog_radiology 372-378 379-381 and I 'm gon na go home and work out 358-409 358-409 We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 379-381 382-391 and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning 358-409 358-409 We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_vlog_radiology 382-391 392-398 because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired 358-409 358-409 We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_vlog_radiology 392-398 399-404 because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , 358-409 358-409 We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_vlog_radiology 392-398 405-409 because for some reason I was tired which makes no sense . 358-409 358-409 We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_vlog_radiology 372-378 410-418 and I 'm gon na go home But I 'm gon na go work out , 358-409 410-430 We get to head home early today because we finished off the scans , and I 'm gon na go home and work out because I was too lazy to do it this morning because for some reason I was tired from having a weekend off , which makes no sense . But I 'm gon na go work out , cook something for dinner and do this all over again tomorrow . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_vlog_radiology 410-418 419-422 But I 'm gon na go work out , cook something for dinner 410-430 410-430 But I 'm gon na go work out , cook something for dinner and do this all over again tomorrow . But I 'm gon na go work out , cook something for dinner and do this all over again tomorrow . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 410-418 423-430 But I 'm gon na go work out , and do this all over again tomorrow . 410-430 410-430 But I 'm gon na go work out , cook something for dinner and do this all over again tomorrow . But I 'm gon na go work out , cook something for dinner and do this all over again tomorrow . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 431-437 438-440 We 're on a different rotation tomorrow so stay tuned 431-446 431-446 We 're on a different rotation tomorrow so stay tuned to find out which one . We 're on a different rotation tomorrow so stay tuned to find out which one . 1>2 motivation motivation +GUM_vlog_radiology 438-440 456-463 so stay tuned and today I got pulled to ultrasound . 431-446 453-463 We 're on a different rotation tomorrow so stay tuned to find out which one . It is Tuesday and today I got pulled to ultrasound . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_vlog_radiology 438-440 441-446 so stay tuned to find out which one . 431-446 431-446 We 're on a different rotation tomorrow so stay tuned to find out which one . We 're on a different rotation tomorrow so stay tuned to find out which one . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_vlog_radiology 447-452 456-463 Alright it is day two . and today I got pulled to ultrasound . 447-452 453-463 Alright it is day two . It is Tuesday and today I got pulled to ultrasound . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_vlog_radiology 453-455 456-463 It is Tuesday and today I got pulled to ultrasound . 453-463 453-463 It is Tuesday and today I got pulled to ultrasound . It is Tuesday and today I got pulled to ultrasound . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_vlog_radiology 114-125,136-139 456-463 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine and today I got pulled to ultrasound . 114-175 453-463 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . It is Tuesday and today I got pulled to ultrasound . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 464-469 470-476 Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , 464-495 464-495 Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , but I did , so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds and get out early . Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , but I did , so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds and get out early . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_vlog_radiology 470-476 477-480 why I got pulled on today , but I did , 464-495 464-495 Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , but I did , so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds and get out early . Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , but I did , so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds and get out early . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_vlog_radiology 456-463 477-480 and today I got pulled to ultrasound . but I did , 453-463 464-495 It is Tuesday and today I got pulled to ultrasound . Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , but I did , so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds and get out early . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_vlog_radiology 477-480 481-487 but I did , so probably just sit in there , 464-495 464-495 Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , but I did , so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds and get out early . Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , but I did , so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds and get out early . 1<2 result result +GUM_vlog_radiology 481-487 488-490 so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds 464-495 464-495 Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , but I did , so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds and get out early . Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , but I did , so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds and get out early . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 481-487 491-495 so probably just sit in there , and get out early . 464-495 464-495 Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , but I did , so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds and get out early . Yes , I do n't know why I got pulled on today , but I did , so probably just sit in there , read some ultrasounds and get out early . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 456-463 496-503 and today I got pulled to ultrasound . I need to film another YouTube video . 453-463 496-503 It is Tuesday and today I got pulled to ultrasound . I need to film another YouTube video . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_vlog_radiology 504-509 510-513 Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , 504-554 504-554 Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_vlog_radiology 114-125,136-139 510-513 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine just crushing ultrasounds , 114-175 504-554 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 510-513 514-524 just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather 504-554 504-554 Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_vlog_radiology 525-533 534-542 so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today 504-554 504-554 Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_vlog_radiology 510-513 534-542 just crushing ultrasounds , I 've been like crushing these all day today 504-554 504-554 Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_vlog_radiology 534-542 543-554 I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . 504-554 504-554 Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 555-558 588-592 I picked these up they 're cough drops , 555-565 577-603 I picked these up when I was in Amsterdam for ... I have no idea what it says , but I think they 're cough drops , so if anybody knows what this says let me know . 1>2 background background +GUM_vlog_radiology 555-558 559-565 I picked these up when I was in Amsterdam for ... 555-565 555-565 I picked these up when I was in Amsterdam for ... I picked these up when I was in Amsterdam for ... 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_vlog_radiology 555-558 566-568 I picked these up I got sick 555-565 566-576 I picked these up when I was in Amsterdam for ... I got sick when I was on Croatia for vacation . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_vlog_radiology 566-568 569-576 I got sick when I was on Croatia for vacation . 566-576 566-576 I got sick when I was on Croatia for vacation . I got sick when I was on Croatia for vacation . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_vlog_radiology 577-584 588-592 I have no idea what it says , they 're cough drops , 577-603 577-603 I have no idea what it says , but I think they 're cough drops , so if anybody knows what this says let me know . I have no idea what it says , but I think they 're cough drops , so if anybody knows what this says let me know . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_vlog_radiology 585-587 588-592 but I think they 're cough drops , 577-603 577-603 I have no idea what it says , but I think they 're cough drops , so if anybody knows what this says let me know . I have no idea what it says , but I think they 're cough drops , so if anybody knows what this says let me know . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_vlog_radiology 510-513 588-592 just crushing ultrasounds , they 're cough drops , 504-554 577-603 Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . I have no idea what it says , but I think they 're cough drops , so if anybody knows what this says let me know . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_vlog_radiology 588-592 593,600-603 they 're cough drops , so <*> let me know . 577-603 577-603 I have no idea what it says , but I think they 're cough drops , so if anybody knows what this says let me know . I have no idea what it says , but I think they 're cough drops , so if anybody knows what this says let me know . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_vlog_radiology 594-599 600-603 if anybody knows what this says let me know . 577-603 577-603 I have no idea what it says , but I think they 're cough drops , so if anybody knows what this says let me know . I have no idea what it says , but I think they 're cough drops , so if anybody knows what this says let me know . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_vlog_radiology 604-608 609-620 But I 'm pretty sure it 's just cough drops with some vitamin C in it . 604-620 604-620 But I 'm pretty sure it 's just cough drops with some vitamin C in it . But I 'm pretty sure it 's just cough drops with some vitamin C in it . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_vlog_radiology 588-592 609-620 they 're cough drops , it 's just cough drops with some vitamin C in it . 577-603 604-620 I have no idea what it says , but I think they 're cough drops , so if anybody knows what this says let me know . But I 'm pretty sure it 's just cough drops with some vitamin C in it . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_vlog_radiology 621-630 631-633 So this is what I have been doing all day is crushing ultrasounds 621-639 621-639 So this is what I have been doing all day is crushing ultrasounds and having Dutch cough drops . So this is what I have been doing all day is crushing ultrasounds and having Dutch cough drops . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_vlog_radiology 510-513 631-633 just crushing ultrasounds , is crushing ultrasounds 504-554 621-639 Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . So this is what I have been doing all day is crushing ultrasounds and having Dutch cough drops . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_vlog_radiology 631-633 634-639 is crushing ultrasounds and having Dutch cough drops . 621-639 621-639 So this is what I have been doing all day is crushing ultrasounds and having Dutch cough drops . So this is what I have been doing all day is crushing ultrasounds and having Dutch cough drops . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_vlog_radiology 634-639 640,645-650 and having Dutch cough drops . So <*> tell me what that means . 621-639 640-650 So this is what I have been doing all day is crushing ultrasounds and having Dutch cough drops . So if anybody speaks Dutch tell me what that means . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_vlog_radiology 641-644 645-650 if anybody speaks Dutch tell me what that means . 640-650 640-650 So if anybody speaks Dutch tell me what that means . So if anybody speaks Dutch tell me what that means . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_vlog_radiology 651-661 670-682 Oh and PS , I usually try to avoid taking medicines but I had someone help me at the pharmacy in the airport . 651-682 651-682 Oh and PS , I usually try to avoid taking medicines that I ca n't read the name of but I had someone help me at the pharmacy in the airport . Oh and PS , I usually try to avoid taking medicines that I ca n't read the name of but I had someone help me at the pharmacy in the airport . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_vlog_radiology 651-661 662-669 Oh and PS , I usually try to avoid taking medicines that I ca n't read the name of 651-682 651-682 Oh and PS , I usually try to avoid taking medicines that I ca n't read the name of but I had someone help me at the pharmacy in the airport . Oh and PS , I usually try to avoid taking medicines that I ca n't read the name of but I had someone help me at the pharmacy in the airport . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 670-682 699-705 but I had someone help me at the pharmacy in the airport . so , that 's the only reason 651-682 683-712 Oh and PS , I usually try to avoid taking medicines that I ca n't read the name of but I had someone help me at the pharmacy in the airport . She spoke a little bit of English and I think those are actually cough drops , so , that 's the only reason I 'm still eating them today . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_vlog_radiology 670-682 683-689 but I had someone help me at the pharmacy in the airport . She spoke a little bit of English 651-682 683-712 Oh and PS , I usually try to avoid taking medicines that I ca n't read the name of but I had someone help me at the pharmacy in the airport . She spoke a little bit of English and I think those are actually cough drops , so , that 's the only reason I 'm still eating them today . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 690-692 693-698 and I think those are actually cough drops , 683-712 683-712 She spoke a little bit of English and I think those are actually cough drops , so , that 's the only reason I 'm still eating them today . She spoke a little bit of English and I think those are actually cough drops , so , that 's the only reason I 'm still eating them today . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_vlog_radiology 670-682 693-698 but I had someone help me at the pharmacy in the airport . those are actually cough drops , 651-682 683-712 Oh and PS , I usually try to avoid taking medicines that I ca n't read the name of but I had someone help me at the pharmacy in the airport . She spoke a little bit of English and I think those are actually cough drops , so , that 's the only reason I 'm still eating them today . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_vlog_radiology 634-639 699-705 and having Dutch cough drops . so , that 's the only reason 621-639 683-712 So this is what I have been doing all day is crushing ultrasounds and having Dutch cough drops . She spoke a little bit of English and I think those are actually cough drops , so , that 's the only reason I 'm still eating them today . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_vlog_radiology 699-705 706-712 so , that 's the only reason I 'm still eating them today . 683-712 683-712 She spoke a little bit of English and I think those are actually cough drops , so , that 's the only reason I 'm still eating them today . She spoke a little bit of English and I think those are actually cough drops , so , that 's the only reason I 'm still eating them today . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 713-718 719-727 You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today 713-757 713-757 You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better because , I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better because , I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . 1>2 evidence evidence +GUM_vlog_radiology 719-727 728-732 it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better 713-757 713-757 You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better because , I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better because , I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . 1>2 solutionhood solutionhood +GUM_vlog_radiology 510-513 728-732 just crushing ultrasounds , so hopefully I get better 504-554 713-757 Alright so I 've been here just crushing ultrasounds , and today I 've been feeling a little under the weather so I 've been , like , yeah , I 've been like crushing these all day today and then I 'll show you what else I 've been . You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better because , I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 728-732 733-734,743-749 so hopefully I get better because , <*> but I 'm going somewhere this weekend 713-757 713-757 You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better because , I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better because , I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_vlog_radiology 735-742 743-749 I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend 713-757 713-757 You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better because , I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better because , I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_vlog_radiology 733-734,743-749 750-757 because , <*> but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . 713-757 713-757 You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better because , I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . You can tell by my voice it 's a little on the sore side today so hopefully I get better because , I have n't told you guys yet , but I 'm going somewhere this weekend and it 's gon na be fun . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_vlog_radiology 114-125,136-139 758-767 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine Now it 's time to get back to work . 114-175 758-767 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . Now it 's time to get back to work . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 114-125,136-139 768-776 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine So I 'm officially going home right now . 114-175 768-776 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . So I 'm officially going home right now . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_vlog_radiology 777-787 804,812-823 Yeah , normally I would go home and work out , But <*> I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest 777-803 804-832 Yeah , normally I would go home and work out , especially since it 's , like , a beautiful day I would probably go running . But since I feel kind of crappy today I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest ( ambulance was a little loud sorry ) . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_vlog_radiology 788-797 798-803 especially since it 's , like , a beautiful day I would probably go running . 777-803 777-803 Yeah , normally I would go home and work out , especially since it 's , like , a beautiful day I would probably go running . Yeah , normally I would go home and work out , especially since it 's , like , a beautiful day I would probably go running . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_vlog_radiology 777-787 798-803 Yeah , normally I would go home and work out , I would probably go running . 777-803 777-803 Yeah , normally I would go home and work out , especially since it 's , like , a beautiful day I would probably go running . Yeah , normally I would go home and work out , especially since it 's , like , a beautiful day I would probably go running . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 768-776 804,812-823 So I 'm officially going home right now . But <*> I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest 768-776 804-832 So I 'm officially going home right now . But since I feel kind of crappy today I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest ( ambulance was a little loud sorry ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 805-811 812-823 since I feel kind of crappy today I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest 804-832 804-832 But since I feel kind of crappy today I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest ( ambulance was a little loud sorry ) . But since I feel kind of crappy today I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest ( ambulance was a little loud sorry ) . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_vlog_radiology 824-829 830-832 ( ambulance was a little loud sorry ) . 804-832 804-832 But since I feel kind of crappy today I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest ( ambulance was a little loud sorry ) . But since I feel kind of crappy today I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest ( ambulance was a little loud sorry ) . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_vlog_radiology 804,812-823 830-832 But <*> I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest sorry ) . 804-832 804-832 But since I feel kind of crappy today I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest ( ambulance was a little loud sorry ) . But since I feel kind of crappy today I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest ( ambulance was a little loud sorry ) . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_vlog_radiology 804,812-823 833-843 But <*> I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest So I 'm probably just gon na go home and rest 804-832 833-859 But since I feel kind of crappy today I 'm just going to go home , hang out , rest ( ambulance was a little loud sorry ) . So I 'm probably just gon na go home and rest and I have to get my hair cut today for my big trip coming up . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_vlog_radiology 768-776 844-856 So I 'm officially going home right now . and I have to get my hair cut today for my big trip 768-776 833-859 So I 'm officially going home right now . So I 'm probably just gon na go home and rest and I have to get my hair cut today for my big trip coming up . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_vlog_radiology 844-856 857-859 and I have to get my hair cut today for my big trip coming up . 833-859 833-859 So I 'm probably just gon na go home and rest and I have to get my hair cut today for my big trip coming up . So I 'm probably just gon na go home and rest and I have to get my hair cut today for my big trip coming up . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 860-865 866-870 But you still do n't know where I 'm going . 860-870 860-870 But you still do n't know where I 'm going . But you still do n't know where I 'm going . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_vlog_radiology 844-856 866-870 and I have to get my hair cut today for my big trip where I 'm going . 833-859 860-870 So I 'm probably just gon na go home and rest and I have to get my hair cut today for my big trip coming up . But you still do n't know where I 'm going . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_vlog_radiology 114-125,136-139 871-878 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies <*> of general nuclear medicine But yeah that 's pretty much it , 114-175 871-919 So so far this morning I 've just read a few studies ( it 's a little slow in the morning ) of general nuclear medicine because a lot of stuff takes time for the radio tracers to go into the body or the specific organ we are targeting , so we have to wait a little bit in the morning . But yeah that 's pretty much it , hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog that I 'm doing , but I just wanted to show you guys kind of loosely like how a week is and the life of a radiology resident . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_vlog_radiology 871-878 879-890 But yeah that 's pretty much it , hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog 871-919 871-919 But yeah that 's pretty much it , hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog that I 'm doing , but I just wanted to show you guys kind of loosely like how a week is and the life of a radiology resident . But yeah that 's pretty much it , hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog that I 'm doing , but I just wanted to show you guys kind of loosely like how a week is and the life of a radiology resident . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_vlog_radiology 879-890 891-895 hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog that I 'm doing , 871-919 871-919 But yeah that 's pretty much it , hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog that I 'm doing , but I just wanted to show you guys kind of loosely like how a week is and the life of a radiology resident . But yeah that 's pretty much it , hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog that I 'm doing , but I just wanted to show you guys kind of loosely like how a week is and the life of a radiology resident . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_vlog_radiology 879-890 896-919 hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog but I just wanted to show you guys kind of loosely like how a week is and the life of a radiology resident . 871-919 871-919 But yeah that 's pretty much it , hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog that I 'm doing , but I just wanted to show you guys kind of loosely like how a week is and the life of a radiology resident . But yeah that 's pretty much it , hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog that I 'm doing , but I just wanted to show you guys kind of loosely like how a week is and the life of a radiology resident . 1<2 motivation motivation +GUM_vlog_radiology 879-890 920-928 hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog So hopefully you guys find it somewhat interesting , 871-919 920-938 But yeah that 's pretty much it , hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog that I 'm doing , but I just wanted to show you guys kind of loosely like how a week is and the life of a radiology resident . So hopefully you guys find it somewhat interesting , and if you do I 'll keep doing it . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_vlog_radiology 920-928 929,933-938 So hopefully you guys find it somewhat interesting , and <*> I 'll keep doing it . 920-938 920-938 So hopefully you guys find it somewhat interesting , and if you do I 'll keep doing it . So hopefully you guys find it somewhat interesting , and if you do I 'll keep doing it . 1<2 result result +GUM_vlog_radiology 930-932 933-938 if you do I 'll keep doing it . 920-938 920-938 So hopefully you guys find it somewhat interesting , and if you do I 'll keep doing it . So hopefully you guys find it somewhat interesting , and if you do I 'll keep doing it . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_vlog_radiology 871-878 939-943 But yeah that 's pretty much it , So heading home now . 871-919 939-943 But yeah that 's pretty much it , hope you guys do n't mind this kind of like random vlog that I 'm doing , but I just wanted to show you guys kind of loosely like how a week is and the life of a radiology resident . So heading home now . 1<2 result result +GUM_voyage_athens 1,10-24 45-59 Athens <*> is the capital city of Greece with a metropolitan population of 3.7 million inhabitants . The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . 1-24 45-59 Athens ( Greek : Αθήνα , Athína ) , is the capital city of Greece with a metropolitan population of 3.7 million inhabitants . The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . 1>2 background background +GUM_voyage_athens 1,10-24 2-9 Athens <*> is the capital city of Greece with a metropolitan population of 3.7 million inhabitants . ( Greek : Αθήνα , Athína ) , 1-24 1-24 Athens ( Greek : Αθήνα , Athína ) , is the capital city of Greece with a metropolitan population of 3.7 million inhabitants . Athens ( Greek : Αθήνα , Athína ) , is the capital city of Greece with a metropolitan population of 3.7 million inhabitants . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 1,10-24 25-41 Athens <*> is the capital city of Greece with a metropolitan population of 3.7 million inhabitants . It is in many ways the birthplace of Classical Greece , and therefore of Western civilization . 1-24 25-41 Athens ( Greek : Αθήνα , Athína ) , is the capital city of Greece with a metropolitan population of 3.7 million inhabitants . It is in many ways the birthplace of Classical Greece , and therefore of Western civilization . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 42 45-59 Understand The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . 42 45-59 Understand The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_voyage_athens 43-44 45-59 Old Athens The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . 43-44 45-59 Old Athens The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_voyage_athens 60-62 63-79 The legend says that the King of Athens , Theseus unified the ten tribes of early Athens into one kingdom 60-85 60-85 The legend says that the King of Athens , Theseus unified the ten tribes of early Athens into one kingdom ( c. 1230 BC ) . The legend says that the King of Athens , Theseus unified the ten tribes of early Athens into one kingdom ( c. 1230 BC ) . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_voyage_athens 63-79 86-89,97-107 that the King of Athens , Theseus unified the ten tribes of early Athens into one kingdom This process of synoikismos <*> created the largest and wealthiest state on the Greek mainland , 60-85 86-124 The legend says that the King of Athens , Theseus unified the ten tribes of early Athens into one kingdom ( c. 1230 BC ) . This process of synoikismos – bringing together in one home – created the largest and wealthiest state on the Greek mainland , but it also created a larger class of people excluded from political life by the nobility . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_voyage_athens 63-79 80-85 that the King of Athens , Theseus unified the ten tribes of early Athens into one kingdom ( c. 1230 BC ) . 60-85 60-85 The legend says that the King of Athens , Theseus unified the ten tribes of early Athens into one kingdom ( c. 1230 BC ) . The legend says that the King of Athens , Theseus unified the ten tribes of early Athens into one kingdom ( c. 1230 BC ) . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_voyage_athens 45-59 86-89,97-107 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . This process of synoikismos <*> created the largest and wealthiest state on the Greek mainland , 45-59 86-124 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . This process of synoikismos – bringing together in one home – created the largest and wealthiest state on the Greek mainland , but it also created a larger class of people excluded from political life by the nobility . 1<2 background background +GUM_voyage_athens 86-89,97-107 90-96 This process of synoikismos <*> created the largest and wealthiest state on the Greek mainland , – bringing together in one home – 86-124 86-124 This process of synoikismos – bringing together in one home – created the largest and wealthiest state on the Greek mainland , but it also created a larger class of people excluded from political life by the nobility . This process of synoikismos – bringing together in one home – created the largest and wealthiest state on the Greek mainland , but it also created a larger class of people excluded from political life by the nobility . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_voyage_athens 86-89,97-107 108-124 This process of synoikismos <*> created the largest and wealthiest state on the Greek mainland , but it also created a larger class of people excluded from political life by the nobility . 86-124 86-124 This process of synoikismos – bringing together in one home – created the largest and wealthiest state on the Greek mainland , but it also created a larger class of people excluded from political life by the nobility . This process of synoikismos – bringing together in one home – created the largest and wealthiest state on the Greek mainland , but it also created a larger class of people excluded from political life by the nobility . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_voyage_athens 125-136 137-141 By the 7th century BC , social unrest had become widespread , and the Areopagus appointed Draco 125-155 125-155 By the 7th century BC , social unrest had become widespread , and the Areopagus appointed Draco to draft a strict new law code ( hence " draconian " ) . By the 7th century BC , social unrest had become widespread , and the Areopagus appointed Draco to draft a strict new law code ( hence " draconian " ) . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_voyage_athens 45-59 137-141 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . and the Areopagus appointed Draco 45-59 125-155 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . By the 7th century BC , social unrest had become widespread , and the Areopagus appointed Draco to draft a strict new law code ( hence " draconian " ) . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 137-141 142-148 and the Areopagus appointed Draco to draft a strict new law code 125-155 125-155 By the 7th century BC , social unrest had become widespread , and the Areopagus appointed Draco to draft a strict new law code ( hence " draconian " ) . By the 7th century BC , social unrest had become widespread , and the Areopagus appointed Draco to draft a strict new law code ( hence " draconian " ) . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_voyage_athens 137-141 149-155 and the Areopagus appointed Draco ( hence " draconian " ) . 125-155 125-155 By the 7th century BC , social unrest had become widespread , and the Areopagus appointed Draco to draft a strict new law code ( hence " draconian " ) . By the 7th century BC , social unrest had become widespread , and the Areopagus appointed Draco to draft a strict new law code ( hence " draconian " ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 156-159 160-171 When this failed , they appointed Solon , with a mandate to create a new constitution 156-175 156-175 When this failed , they appointed Solon , with a mandate to create a new constitution ( 594 ) . When this failed , they appointed Solon , with a mandate to create a new constitution ( 594 ) . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_voyage_athens 160-171 176-186 they appointed Solon , with a mandate to create a new constitution This was the great beginning of a new social revolution , 156-175 176-200 When this failed , they appointed Solon , with a mandate to create a new constitution ( 594 ) . This was the great beginning of a new social revolution , which was the result of the democracy under Clisthenes ( 508 BC ) . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_voyage_athens 160-171 172-175 they appointed Solon , with a mandate to create a new constitution ( 594 ) . 156-175 156-175 When this failed , they appointed Solon , with a mandate to create a new constitution ( 594 ) . When this failed , they appointed Solon , with a mandate to create a new constitution ( 594 ) . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_voyage_athens 45-59 176-186 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . This was the great beginning of a new social revolution , 45-59 176-200 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . This was the great beginning of a new social revolution , which was the result of the democracy under Clisthenes ( 508 BC ) . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 176-186 187-195 This was the great beginning of a new social revolution , which was the result of the democracy under Clisthenes 176-200 176-200 This was the great beginning of a new social revolution , which was the result of the democracy under Clisthenes ( 508 BC ) . This was the great beginning of a new social revolution , which was the result of the democracy under Clisthenes ( 508 BC ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 187-195 196-200 which was the result of the democracy under Clisthenes ( 508 BC ) . 176-200 176-200 This was the great beginning of a new social revolution , which was the result of the democracy under Clisthenes ( 508 BC ) . This was the great beginning of a new social revolution , which was the result of the democracy under Clisthenes ( 508 BC ) . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_voyage_athens 45-59 201-210 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . During the Middle Ages , Athens experienced a decline , 45-59 201-216 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . During the Middle Ages , Athens experienced a decline , but re-emerged under Byzantian rule . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 201-210 211-216 During the Middle Ages , Athens experienced a decline , but re-emerged under Byzantian rule . 201-216 201-216 During the Middle Ages , Athens experienced a decline , but re-emerged under Byzantian rule . During the Middle Ages , Athens experienced a decline , but re-emerged under Byzantian rule . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_voyage_athens 45-59 217-225 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . Athens was thriving and prosperous during the Crusades , 45-59 217-235 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . Athens was thriving and prosperous during the Crusades , actually benefiting from the Italian trade during this period . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 217-225 226-235 Athens was thriving and prosperous during the Crusades , actually benefiting from the Italian trade during this period . 217-235 217-235 Athens was thriving and prosperous during the Crusades , actually benefiting from the Italian trade during this period . Athens was thriving and prosperous during the Crusades , actually benefiting from the Italian trade during this period . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_voyage_athens 217-225 236-243 Athens was thriving and prosperous during the Crusades , However , this fruitful period was short-lived , 217-235 236-266 Athens was thriving and prosperous during the Crusades , actually benefiting from the Italian trade during this period . However , this fruitful period was short-lived , as Greece suffered badly under the Ottoman Empire , only to recover in the 19th century as the capital of independent Greece . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_voyage_athens 236-243 244-252 However , this fruitful period was short-lived , as Greece suffered badly under the Ottoman Empire , 236-266 236-266 However , this fruitful period was short-lived , as Greece suffered badly under the Ottoman Empire , only to recover in the 19th century as the capital of independent Greece . However , this fruitful period was short-lived , as Greece suffered badly under the Ottoman Empire , only to recover in the 19th century as the capital of independent Greece . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_voyage_athens 236-243 253-266 However , this fruitful period was short-lived , only to recover in the 19th century as the capital of independent Greece . 236-266 236-266 However , this fruitful period was short-lived , as Greece suffered badly under the Ottoman Empire , only to recover in the 19th century as the capital of independent Greece . However , this fruitful period was short-lived , as Greece suffered badly under the Ottoman Empire , only to recover in the 19th century as the capital of independent Greece . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_voyage_athens 267-269 270-277 Modern Olympic Games Athens hosted the 2004 Summer Olympic Games . 267-269 270-277 Modern Olympic Games Athens hosted the 2004 Summer Olympic Games . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_voyage_athens 45-59 270-277 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . Athens hosted the 2004 Summer Olympic Games . 45-59 270-277 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . Athens hosted the 2004 Summer Olympic Games . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_athens 278-289 297-306 While most of the sporting venues were located outside the city proper the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes 278-319 278-319 While most of the sporting venues were located outside the city proper - in various locations throughout Attica - the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes that have improved the quality of life for visitors and residents alike . While most of the sporting venues were located outside the city proper - in various locations throughout Attica - the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes that have improved the quality of life for visitors and residents alike . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_voyage_athens 278-289 290-296 While most of the sporting venues were located outside the city proper - in various locations throughout Attica - 278-319 278-319 While most of the sporting venues were located outside the city proper - in various locations throughout Attica - the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes that have improved the quality of life for visitors and residents alike . While most of the sporting venues were located outside the city proper - in various locations throughout Attica - the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes that have improved the quality of life for visitors and residents alike . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 270-277 297-306 Athens hosted the 2004 Summer Olympic Games . the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes 270-277 278-319 Athens hosted the 2004 Summer Olympic Games . While most of the sporting venues were located outside the city proper - in various locations throughout Attica - the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes that have improved the quality of life for visitors and residents alike . 1<2 result result +GUM_voyage_athens 297-306 307-319 the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes that have improved the quality of life for visitors and residents alike . 278-319 278-319 While most of the sporting venues were located outside the city proper - in various locations throughout Attica - the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes that have improved the quality of life for visitors and residents alike . While most of the sporting venues were located outside the city proper - in various locations throughout Attica - the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes that have improved the quality of life for visitors and residents alike . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 297-306 320-325,345-353 the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes Aside from the excellent transportation infrastructure <*> the city 's historic center underwent serious renovation . 278-319 320-353 While most of the sporting venues were located outside the city proper - in various locations throughout Attica - the entire urban area of Athens underwent major lasting changes that have improved the quality of life for visitors and residents alike . Aside from the excellent transportation infrastructure that was completed in time for the 2004 Olympics ( from new freeways to light rail systems ) , the city 's historic center underwent serious renovation . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_voyage_athens 320-325,345-353 326-334 Aside from the excellent transportation infrastructure <*> the city 's historic center underwent serious renovation . that was completed in time for the 2004 Olympics 320-353 320-353 Aside from the excellent transportation infrastructure that was completed in time for the 2004 Olympics ( from new freeways to light rail systems ) , the city 's historic center underwent serious renovation . Aside from the excellent transportation infrastructure that was completed in time for the 2004 Olympics ( from new freeways to light rail systems ) , the city 's historic center underwent serious renovation . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 326-334 335-344 that was completed in time for the 2004 Olympics ( from new freeways to light rail systems ) , 320-353 320-353 Aside from the excellent transportation infrastructure that was completed in time for the 2004 Olympics ( from new freeways to light rail systems ) , the city 's historic center underwent serious renovation . Aside from the excellent transportation infrastructure that was completed in time for the 2004 Olympics ( from new freeways to light rail systems ) , the city 's historic center underwent serious renovation . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 320-325,345-353 354-367,391-402 Aside from the excellent transportation infrastructure <*> the city 's historic center underwent serious renovation . Most notable among the city 's facelift projects are the Unification of Archaeological Sites <*> and the restoration of the picturesque neoclassical Thissio and Pláka districts . 320-353 354-402 Aside from the excellent transportation infrastructure that was completed in time for the 2004 Olympics ( from new freeways to light rail systems ) , the city 's historic center underwent serious renovation . Most notable among the city 's facelift projects are the Unification of Archaeological Sites - which connects the city 's classical - era ruins and monuments to each other through a network of pleasant pedestrianized streets - and the restoration of the picturesque neoclassical Thissio and Pláka districts . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 354-367,391-402 368-390 Most notable among the city 's facelift projects are the Unification of Archaeological Sites <*> and the restoration of the picturesque neoclassical Thissio and Pláka districts . - which connects the city 's classical - era ruins and monuments to each other through a network of pleasant pedestrianized streets - 354-402 354-402 Most notable among the city 's facelift projects are the Unification of Archaeological Sites - which connects the city 's classical - era ruins and monuments to each other through a network of pleasant pedestrianized streets - and the restoration of the picturesque neoclassical Thissio and Pláka districts . Most notable among the city 's facelift projects are the Unification of Archaeological Sites - which connects the city 's classical - era ruins and monuments to each other through a network of pleasant pedestrianized streets - and the restoration of the picturesque neoclassical Thissio and Pláka districts . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 270-277 403-417 Athens hosted the 2004 Summer Olympic Games . The ancient Olympic Games took place in Olympia from 776 BCE to 394 AD . 270-277 403-417 Athens hosted the 2004 Summer Olympic Games . The ancient Olympic Games took place in Olympia from 776 BCE to 394 AD . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_athens 418-429 430-433 It is a lengthy day trip from Athens to visit Olympia , but quite interesting . 418-433 418-433 It is a lengthy day trip from Athens to visit Olympia , but quite interesting . It is a lengthy day trip from Athens to visit Olympia , but quite interesting . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_voyage_athens 403-417 430-433 The ancient Olympic Games took place in Olympia from 776 BCE to 394 AD . but quite interesting . 403-417 418-433 The ancient Olympic Games took place in Olympia from 776 BCE to 394 AD . It is a lengthy day trip from Athens to visit Olympia , but quite interesting . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_voyage_athens 434 559-567 Architecture The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , 434 559-590 Architecture The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_voyage_athens 435-441 497-499,510-515 Athens was just a small provincial village With the decision <*> architects and city planners were hired 435-460 497-558 Athens was just a small provincial village when it was chosen in the 1830s to serve as the national capital of the modern Greek State . With the decision to move the national capital from Nafplio to Athens , architects and city planners were hired to build a new city next to the classical ruins , with grand neoclassical homes and public buildings , large city squares , green spaces , and wide avenues , making a conscious , decisive turn from the city 's Ottoman past . 1>2 background background +GUM_voyage_athens 435-441 442-460 Athens was just a small provincial village when it was chosen in the 1830s to serve as the national capital of the modern Greek State . 435-460 435-460 Athens was just a small provincial village when it was chosen in the 1830s to serve as the national capital of the modern Greek State . Athens was just a small provincial village when it was chosen in the 1830s to serve as the national capital of the modern Greek State . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_voyage_athens 461-467 468-483 Although it had a prestigious past , the city 's political , economic , and cultural importance had declined over the centuries , 461-496 461-496 Although it had a prestigious past , the city 's political , economic , and cultural importance had declined over the centuries , leaving behind only its classical ruins as a reminder of better times . Although it had a prestigious past , the city 's political , economic , and cultural importance had declined over the centuries , leaving behind only its classical ruins as a reminder of better times . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_voyage_athens 435-441 468-483 Athens was just a small provincial village the city 's political , economic , and cultural importance had declined over the centuries , 435-460 461-496 Athens was just a small provincial village when it was chosen in the 1830s to serve as the national capital of the modern Greek State . Although it had a prestigious past , the city 's political , economic , and cultural importance had declined over the centuries , leaving behind only its classical ruins as a reminder of better times . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_athens 468-483 484-496 the city 's political , economic , and cultural importance had declined over the centuries , leaving behind only its classical ruins as a reminder of better times . 461-496 461-496 Although it had a prestigious past , the city 's political , economic , and cultural importance had declined over the centuries , leaving behind only its classical ruins as a reminder of better times . Although it had a prestigious past , the city 's political , economic , and cultural importance had declined over the centuries , leaving behind only its classical ruins as a reminder of better times . 1<2 result result +GUM_voyage_athens 497-499,510-515 559-567 With the decision <*> architects and city planners were hired The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , 497-558 559-590 With the decision to move the national capital from Nafplio to Athens , architects and city planners were hired to build a new city next to the classical ruins , with grand neoclassical homes and public buildings , large city squares , green spaces , and wide avenues , making a conscious , decisive turn from the city 's Ottoman past . The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . 1>2 background background +GUM_voyage_athens 497-499,510-515 500-509 With the decision <*> architects and city planners were hired to move the national capital from Nafplio to Athens , 497-558 497-558 With the decision to move the national capital from Nafplio to Athens , architects and city planners were hired to build a new city next to the classical ruins , with grand neoclassical homes and public buildings , large city squares , green spaces , and wide avenues , making a conscious , decisive turn from the city 's Ottoman past . With the decision to move the national capital from Nafplio to Athens , architects and city planners were hired to build a new city next to the classical ruins , with grand neoclassical homes and public buildings , large city squares , green spaces , and wide avenues , making a conscious , decisive turn from the city 's Ottoman past . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 497-499,510-515 516-545 With the decision <*> architects and city planners were hired to build a new city next to the classical ruins , with grand neoclassical homes and public buildings , large city squares , green spaces , and wide avenues , 497-558 497-558 With the decision to move the national capital from Nafplio to Athens , architects and city planners were hired to build a new city next to the classical ruins , with grand neoclassical homes and public buildings , large city squares , green spaces , and wide avenues , making a conscious , decisive turn from the city 's Ottoman past . With the decision to move the national capital from Nafplio to Athens , architects and city planners were hired to build a new city next to the classical ruins , with grand neoclassical homes and public buildings , large city squares , green spaces , and wide avenues , making a conscious , decisive turn from the city 's Ottoman past . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_voyage_athens 516-545 546-558 to build a new city next to the classical ruins , with grand neoclassical homes and public buildings , large city squares , green spaces , and wide avenues , making a conscious , decisive turn from the city 's Ottoman past . 497-558 497-558 With the decision to move the national capital from Nafplio to Athens , architects and city planners were hired to build a new city next to the classical ruins , with grand neoclassical homes and public buildings , large city squares , green spaces , and wide avenues , making a conscious , decisive turn from the city 's Ottoman past . With the decision to move the national capital from Nafplio to Athens , architects and city planners were hired to build a new city next to the classical ruins , with grand neoclassical homes and public buildings , large city squares , green spaces , and wide avenues , making a conscious , decisive turn from the city 's Ottoman past . 1<2 result result +GUM_voyage_athens 45-59 559-567 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , 45-59 559-590 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_athens 559-567 568-583 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture 559-590 559-590 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_athens 568-583 584-590 and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . 559-590 559-590 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 559-567 591-602 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , The 20th century however , marked the rapid development of Athens . 559-590 591-602 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . The 20th century however , marked the rapid development of Athens . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 591-602 603-610 The 20th century however , marked the rapid development of Athens . The city suffered minor damage during WWII , 591-602 603-629 The 20th century however , marked the rapid development of Athens . The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 603-610 611-618 The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades 603-629 603-629 The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 611-618 619-621 and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , 603-629 603-629 The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 611-618 622-626 and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades as the nation rapidly industrialized 603-629 603-629 The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_voyage_athens 622-626 627-629 as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . 603-629 603-629 The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_athens 603-610 630-648 The city suffered minor damage during WWII , In the 1960s and 1970s , many 19th century neoclassical buildings , often small and private , were demolished 603-629 630-662 The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . In the 1960s and 1970s , many 19th century neoclassical buildings , often small and private , were demolished to make way for office buildings , often designed by great Greek architects . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 630-648 649-655 In the 1960s and 1970s , many 19th century neoclassical buildings , often small and private , were demolished to make way for office buildings , 630-662 630-662 In the 1960s and 1970s , many 19th century neoclassical buildings , often small and private , were demolished to make way for office buildings , often designed by great Greek architects . In the 1960s and 1970s , many 19th century neoclassical buildings , often small and private , were demolished to make way for office buildings , often designed by great Greek architects . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_voyage_athens 649-655 656-662 to make way for office buildings , often designed by great Greek architects . 630-662 630-662 In the 1960s and 1970s , many 19th century neoclassical buildings , often small and private , were demolished to make way for office buildings , often designed by great Greek architects . In the 1960s and 1970s , many 19th century neoclassical buildings , often small and private , were demolished to make way for office buildings , often designed by great Greek architects . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 603-610 663-676 The city suffered minor damage during WWII , The city also expanded outward through rash development , particularly towards the west , 603-629 663-687 The city suffered minor damage during WWII , and suffered extensive urban planning in the decades that followed , as the nation rapidly industrialized and urbanized . The city also expanded outward through rash development , particularly towards the west , as its population grew by absorbing job-seekers from the provinces . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 663-676 677-680 The city also expanded outward through rash development , particularly towards the west , as its population grew 663-687 663-687 The city also expanded outward through rash development , particularly towards the west , as its population grew by absorbing job-seekers from the provinces . The city also expanded outward through rash development , particularly towards the west , as its population grew by absorbing job-seekers from the provinces . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_voyage_athens 677-680 681-687 as its population grew by absorbing job-seekers from the provinces . 663-687 663-687 The city also expanded outward through rash development , particularly towards the west , as its population grew by absorbing job-seekers from the provinces . The city also expanded outward through rash development , particularly towards the west , as its population grew by absorbing job-seekers from the provinces . 1<2 means means +GUM_voyage_athens 559-567 688-703 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , With the onset of the automobile , public officials reduced the city 's public transportation services 559-590 688-719 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . With the onset of the automobile , public officials reduced the city 's public transportation services without foreseeing the traffic gridlock and smog that would menace the city by the 1980s . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 688-703 704-710 With the onset of the automobile , public officials reduced the city 's public transportation services without foreseeing the traffic gridlock and smog 688-719 688-719 With the onset of the automobile , public officials reduced the city 's public transportation services without foreseeing the traffic gridlock and smog that would menace the city by the 1980s . With the onset of the automobile , public officials reduced the city 's public transportation services without foreseeing the traffic gridlock and smog that would menace the city by the 1980s . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_voyage_athens 704-710 711-719 without foreseeing the traffic gridlock and smog that would menace the city by the 1980s . 688-719 688-719 With the onset of the automobile , public officials reduced the city 's public transportation services without foreseeing the traffic gridlock and smog that would menace the city by the 1980s . With the onset of the automobile , public officials reduced the city 's public transportation services without foreseeing the traffic gridlock and smog that would menace the city by the 1980s . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 559-567 720-741 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , By the late 1980s and early 1990s , the city 's reality led to a rude awakening among local and national officials 559-590 720-772 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . By the late 1980s and early 1990s , the city 's reality led to a rude awakening among local and national officials and , coupled with the country 's new found remarkable prosperity , large scale projects began to slowly regenerate the city and undo some of the damages of recent decades . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 720-741 742-743,754-772 By the late 1980s and early 1990s , the city 's reality led to a rude awakening among local and national officials and , <*> large scale projects began to slowly regenerate the city and undo some of the damages of recent decades . 720-772 720-772 By the late 1980s and early 1990s , the city 's reality led to a rude awakening among local and national officials and , coupled with the country 's new found remarkable prosperity , large scale projects began to slowly regenerate the city and undo some of the damages of recent decades . By the late 1980s and early 1990s , the city 's reality led to a rude awakening among local and national officials and , coupled with the country 's new found remarkable prosperity , large scale projects began to slowly regenerate the city and undo some of the damages of recent decades . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_athens 744-753 754-772 coupled with the country 's new found remarkable prosperity , large scale projects began to slowly regenerate the city and undo some of the damages of recent decades . 720-772 720-772 By the late 1980s and early 1990s , the city 's reality led to a rude awakening among local and national officials and , coupled with the country 's new found remarkable prosperity , large scale projects began to slowly regenerate the city and undo some of the damages of recent decades . By the late 1980s and early 1990s , the city 's reality led to a rude awakening among local and national officials and , coupled with the country 's new found remarkable prosperity , large scale projects began to slowly regenerate the city and undo some of the damages of recent decades . 1>2 background background +GUM_voyage_athens 559-567 773-819 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , Over the course of the next 15 years , money was poured into new transportation infrastructure projects , the restoration of surviving neoclassical buildings , the gentrification of the city 's historical center and the renovation of many former industrial areas and the city 's coastline . 559-590 773-819 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . Over the course of the next 15 years , money was poured into new transportation infrastructure projects , the restoration of surviving neoclassical buildings , the gentrification of the city 's historical center and the renovation of many former industrial areas and the city 's coastline . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 773-819 820-845 Over the course of the next 15 years , money was poured into new transportation infrastructure projects , the restoration of surviving neoclassical buildings , the gentrification of the city 's historical center and the renovation of many former industrial areas and the city 's coastline . The restoration of charming neoclassical buildings in the city 's historical center has been accompanied by the construction of attractive post-modern buildings in newer districts ; 773-819 820-859 Over the course of the next 15 years , money was poured into new transportation infrastructure projects , the restoration of surviving neoclassical buildings , the gentrification of the city 's historical center and the renovation of many former industrial areas and the city 's coastline . The restoration of charming neoclassical buildings in the city 's historical center has been accompanied by the construction of attractive post-modern buildings in newer districts ; both of which have begun to improve the aesthetic essence of the city . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_athens 820-845 846-859 The restoration of charming neoclassical buildings in the city 's historical center has been accompanied by the construction of attractive post-modern buildings in newer districts ; both of which have begun to improve the aesthetic essence of the city . 820-859 820-859 The restoration of charming neoclassical buildings in the city 's historical center has been accompanied by the construction of attractive post-modern buildings in newer districts ; both of which have begun to improve the aesthetic essence of the city . The restoration of charming neoclassical buildings in the city 's historical center has been accompanied by the construction of attractive post-modern buildings in newer districts ; both of which have begun to improve the aesthetic essence of the city . 1<2 result result +GUM_voyage_athens 559-567 860-865 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , Athens today is ever evolving , 559-590 860-875 The city regained its importance in Greek civilization , and by 1900 had evolved into a very attractive cosmopolitan city , with abundant neoclassical architecture harking to the nation 's past . Athens today is ever evolving , forging a brand new identity for the 21st century . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_athens 860-865 866-875 Athens today is ever evolving , forging a brand new identity for the 21st century . 860-875 860-875 Athens today is ever evolving , forging a brand new identity for the 21st century . Athens today is ever evolving , forging a brand new identity for the 21st century . 1<2 result result +GUM_voyage_athens 876 877-888 Climate Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . 876 877-888 Climate Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_voyage_athens 45-59 877-888 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . 45-59 877-888 The first pre-historic settlements was constructed in 3000 BC around the hill of Acropolis . Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_athens 877-888 889-898 Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . Summer can be extremely hot and dry during heatwaves , 877-888 889-903 Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . Summer can be extremely hot and dry during heatwaves , but this rarely happens . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_voyage_athens 889-898 899-903 Summer can be extremely hot and dry during heatwaves , but this rarely happens . 889-903 889-903 Summer can be extremely hot and dry during heatwaves , but this rarely happens . Summer can be extremely hot and dry during heatwaves , but this rarely happens . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_voyage_athens 904-917 918-922 Winter is definitely low season , with the occasional rainy or snowy day , but also an ideal time 904-936 904-936 Winter is definitely low season , with the occasional rainy or snowy day , but also an ideal time to save money while enjoying the city without countless other travelers and tourists . Winter is definitely low season , with the occasional rainy or snowy day , but also an ideal time to save money while enjoying the city without countless other travelers and tourists . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_voyage_athens 877-888 918-922 Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . but also an ideal time 877-888 904-936 Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . Winter is definitely low season , with the occasional rainy or snowy day , but also an ideal time to save money while enjoying the city without countless other travelers and tourists . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_voyage_athens 918-922 923-925 but also an ideal time to save money 904-936 904-936 Winter is definitely low season , with the occasional rainy or snowy day , but also an ideal time to save money while enjoying the city without countless other travelers and tourists . Winter is definitely low season , with the occasional rainy or snowy day , but also an ideal time to save money while enjoying the city without countless other travelers and tourists . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_voyage_athens 923-925 926-936 to save money while enjoying the city without countless other travelers and tourists . 904-936 904-936 Winter is definitely low season , with the occasional rainy or snowy day , but also an ideal time to save money while enjoying the city without countless other travelers and tourists . Winter is definitely low season , with the occasional rainy or snowy day , but also an ideal time to save money while enjoying the city without countless other travelers and tourists . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_voyage_athens 937-950 951-960 Whilst peak traffic hour can be a bit smoggy on the main roads , on most sunny days the skies are azure blue . 937-960 937-960 Whilst peak traffic hour can be a bit smoggy on the main roads , on most sunny days the skies are azure blue . Whilst peak traffic hour can be a bit smoggy on the main roads , on most sunny days the skies are azure blue . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_voyage_athens 877-888 951-960 Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . on most sunny days the skies are azure blue . 877-888 937-960 Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . Whilst peak traffic hour can be a bit smoggy on the main roads , on most sunny days the skies are azure blue . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_athens 961-980 989-1002,1007-1017 The main reason attributed for the pollution of Athens is because the city is enclosed by mountains in a basin The government 's ban on diesel vehicles within Athens and the early 1990s initiatives <*> have greatly contributed to better atmospheric conditions in the basin . 961-988 989-1017 The main reason attributed for the pollution of Athens is because the city is enclosed by mountains in a basin which does not let the smog leave . The government 's ban on diesel vehicles within Athens and the early 1990s initiatives to improve car emissions have greatly contributed to better atmospheric conditions in the basin . 1>2 solutionhood solutionhood +GUM_voyage_athens 961-980 981-988 The main reason attributed for the pollution of Athens is because the city is enclosed by mountains in a basin which does not let the smog leave . 961-988 961-988 The main reason attributed for the pollution of Athens is because the city is enclosed by mountains in a basin which does not let the smog leave . The main reason attributed for the pollution of Athens is because the city is enclosed by mountains in a basin which does not let the smog leave . 1<2 result result +GUM_voyage_athens 877-888 989-1002,1007-1017 Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . The government 's ban on diesel vehicles within Athens and the early 1990s initiatives <*> have greatly contributed to better atmospheric conditions in the basin . 877-888 989-1017 Spring and late autumn are the best times to visit Athens . The government 's ban on diesel vehicles within Athens and the early 1990s initiatives to improve car emissions have greatly contributed to better atmospheric conditions in the basin . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_athens 989-1002,1007-1017 1003-1006 The government 's ban on diesel vehicles within Athens and the early 1990s initiatives <*> have greatly contributed to better atmospheric conditions in the basin . to improve car emissions 989-1017 989-1017 The government 's ban on diesel vehicles within Athens and the early 1990s initiatives to improve car emissions have greatly contributed to better atmospheric conditions in the basin . The government 's ban on diesel vehicles within Athens and the early 1990s initiatives to improve car emissions have greatly contributed to better atmospheric conditions in the basin . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 1 59-70 Coron The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , 1 59-87 Coron The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , and the site has been named in many lists of top dive spots in the world . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_voyage_coron 2-14 59-70 Coron is in the province of Palawan , Philippines on Busuanga Island . The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , 2-14 59-87 Coron is in the province of Palawan , Philippines on Busuanga Island . The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , and the site has been named in many lists of top dive spots in the world . 1>2 background background +GUM_voyage_coron 2-14 15-22 Coron is in the province of Palawan , Philippines on Busuanga Island . It is the largest town on the island 2-14 15-30 Coron is in the province of Palawan , Philippines on Busuanga Island . It is the largest town on the island and has the largest share of accommodations . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 15-22 23-30 It is the largest town on the island and has the largest share of accommodations . 15-30 15-30 It is the largest town on the island and has the largest share of accommodations . It is the largest town on the island and has the largest share of accommodations . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_coron 31 59-70 Background The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , 31 59-87 Background The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , and the site has been named in many lists of top dive spots in the world . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_voyage_coron 32-58 59-70 Coron is both the name of the largest town on the island of Busuanga , and the name of a different , smaller island just offshore . The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , 32-58 59-87 Coron is both the name of the largest town on the island of Busuanga , and the name of a different , smaller island just offshore . The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , and the site has been named in many lists of top dive spots in the world . 1>2 background background +GUM_voyage_coron 59-70 71-87 The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , and the site has been named in many lists of top dive spots in the world . 59-87 59-87 The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , and the site has been named in many lists of top dive spots in the world . The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , and the site has been named in many lists of top dive spots in the world . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_voyage_coron 59-70 88-96,101-111 The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , In September 1944 , a fleet of Japanese ships <*> were sunk in a daring raid by the US navy . 59-87 88-111 The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , and the site has been named in many lists of top dive spots in the world . In September 1944 , a fleet of Japanese ships hiding in the harbor were sunk in a daring raid by the US navy . 1<2 background background +GUM_voyage_coron 88-96,101-111 97-100 In September 1944 , a fleet of Japanese ships <*> were sunk in a daring raid by the US navy . hiding in the harbor 88-111 88-111 In September 1944 , a fleet of Japanese ships hiding in the harbor were sunk in a daring raid by the US navy . In September 1944 , a fleet of Japanese ships hiding in the harbor were sunk in a daring raid by the US navy . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 88-96,101-111 112-120 In September 1944 , a fleet of Japanese ships <*> were sunk in a daring raid by the US navy . The result is around ten well preserved underwater shipwrecks 88-111 112-125 In September 1944 , a fleet of Japanese ships hiding in the harbor were sunk in a daring raid by the US navy . The result is around ten well preserved underwater shipwrecks surrounded with coral reef . 1<2 result result +GUM_voyage_coron 112-120 121-125 The result is around ten well preserved underwater shipwrecks surrounded with coral reef . 112-125 112-125 The result is around ten well preserved underwater shipwrecks surrounded with coral reef . The result is around ten well preserved underwater shipwrecks surrounded with coral reef . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 59-70 126-134 The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , There are also attractions on Coron Island itself . 59-87 126-134 The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , and the site has been named in many lists of top dive spots in the world . There are also attractions on Coron Island itself . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_coron 126-134 135-142 There are also attractions on Coron Island itself . There are many beautiful white sand beaches , 126-134 135-153 There are also attractions on Coron Island itself . There are many beautiful white sand beaches , mostly tiny and surrounded by large limestone cliffs and wildlife . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 135-142 143-144 There are many beautiful white sand beaches , mostly tiny 135-153 135-153 There are many beautiful white sand beaches , mostly tiny and surrounded by large limestone cliffs and wildlife . There are many beautiful white sand beaches , mostly tiny and surrounded by large limestone cliffs and wildlife . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 143-144 145-153 mostly tiny and surrounded by large limestone cliffs and wildlife . 135-153 135-153 There are many beautiful white sand beaches , mostly tiny and surrounded by large limestone cliffs and wildlife . There are many beautiful white sand beaches , mostly tiny and surrounded by large limestone cliffs and wildlife . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_coron 135-142 154-167 There are many beautiful white sand beaches , Barracuda and Kayangan lakes are both stunning locations , and good for snorkeling , 135-153 154-198 There are many beautiful white sand beaches , mostly tiny and surrounded by large limestone cliffs and wildlife . Barracuda and Kayangan lakes are both stunning locations , and good for snorkeling , and the island is the ancestral domain of an indigenous tribe who are managing the island in a sustainable way and keeping outsiders at a distance and offshore at night . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_coron 135-142 168-178 There are many beautiful white sand beaches , and the island is the ancestral domain of an indigenous tribe 135-153 154-198 There are many beautiful white sand beaches , mostly tiny and surrounded by large limestone cliffs and wildlife . Barracuda and Kayangan lakes are both stunning locations , and good for snorkeling , and the island is the ancestral domain of an indigenous tribe who are managing the island in a sustainable way and keeping outsiders at a distance and offshore at night . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_coron 168-178 179-187 and the island is the ancestral domain of an indigenous tribe who are managing the island in a sustainable way 154-198 154-198 Barracuda and Kayangan lakes are both stunning locations , and good for snorkeling , and the island is the ancestral domain of an indigenous tribe who are managing the island in a sustainable way and keeping outsiders at a distance and offshore at night . Barracuda and Kayangan lakes are both stunning locations , and good for snorkeling , and the island is the ancestral domain of an indigenous tribe who are managing the island in a sustainable way and keeping outsiders at a distance and offshore at night . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 179-187 188-198 who are managing the island in a sustainable way and keeping outsiders at a distance and offshore at night . 154-198 154-198 Barracuda and Kayangan lakes are both stunning locations , and good for snorkeling , and the island is the ancestral domain of an indigenous tribe who are managing the island in a sustainable way and keeping outsiders at a distance and offshore at night . Barracuda and Kayangan lakes are both stunning locations , and good for snorkeling , and the island is the ancestral domain of an indigenous tribe who are managing the island in a sustainable way and keeping outsiders at a distance and offshore at night . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_coron 199 270-283 History Today , the Tagbanuas remain the dominant if not entire population of Coron . 199 270-283 History Today , the Tagbanuas remain the dominant if not entire population of Coron . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_voyage_coron 200-207 226-233 The first inhabitants of Coron were the Tagbanuas They were a nomadic , seafaring people , 200-225 226-241 The first inhabitants of Coron were the Tagbanuas who belong to the second wave of Indonesians who migrated to this area some 5,000 years ago . They were a nomadic , seafaring people , living mainly by fishing and subsistence agriculture . 1>2 background background +GUM_voyage_coron 200-207 208-215 The first inhabitants of Coron were the Tagbanuas who belong to the second wave of Indonesians 200-225 200-225 The first inhabitants of Coron were the Tagbanuas who belong to the second wave of Indonesians who migrated to this area some 5,000 years ago . The first inhabitants of Coron were the Tagbanuas who belong to the second wave of Indonesians who migrated to this area some 5,000 years ago . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 208-215 216-225 who belong to the second wave of Indonesians who migrated to this area some 5,000 years ago . 200-225 200-225 The first inhabitants of Coron were the Tagbanuas who belong to the second wave of Indonesians who migrated to this area some 5,000 years ago . The first inhabitants of Coron were the Tagbanuas who belong to the second wave of Indonesians who migrated to this area some 5,000 years ago . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 226-233 258-269 They were a nomadic , seafaring people , they maintain many of their old customs , traditions and beliefs . 226-241 242-269 They were a nomadic , seafaring people , living mainly by fishing and subsistence agriculture . Although they are now sedentary ( with the young using cell phones , etc. ) , they maintain many of their old customs , traditions and beliefs . 1>2 background background +GUM_voyage_coron 226-233 234-235 They were a nomadic , seafaring people , living mainly 226-241 226-241 They were a nomadic , seafaring people , living mainly by fishing and subsistence agriculture . They were a nomadic , seafaring people , living mainly by fishing and subsistence agriculture . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 234-235 236-237 living mainly by fishing 226-241 226-241 They were a nomadic , seafaring people , living mainly by fishing and subsistence agriculture . They were a nomadic , seafaring people , living mainly by fishing and subsistence agriculture . 1<2 means means +GUM_voyage_coron 236-237 238-241 by fishing and subsistence agriculture . 226-241 226-241 They were a nomadic , seafaring people , living mainly by fishing and subsistence agriculture . They were a nomadic , seafaring people , living mainly by fishing and subsistence agriculture . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_coron 242-246 258-269 Although they are now sedentary they maintain many of their old customs , traditions and beliefs . 242-269 242-269 Although they are now sedentary ( with the young using cell phones , etc. ) , they maintain many of their old customs , traditions and beliefs . Although they are now sedentary ( with the young using cell phones , etc. ) , they maintain many of their old customs , traditions and beliefs . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_voyage_coron 242-246 247-257 Although they are now sedentary ( with the young using cell phones , etc. ) , 242-269 242-269 Although they are now sedentary ( with the young using cell phones , etc. ) , they maintain many of their old customs , traditions and beliefs . Although they are now sedentary ( with the young using cell phones , etc. ) , they maintain many of their old customs , traditions and beliefs . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 258-269 270-283 they maintain many of their old customs , traditions and beliefs . Today , the Tagbanuas remain the dominant if not entire population of Coron . 242-269 270-283 Although they are now sedentary ( with the young using cell phones , etc. ) , they maintain many of their old customs , traditions and beliefs . Today , the Tagbanuas remain the dominant if not entire population of Coron . 1>2 background background +GUM_voyage_coron 59-70 270-283 The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , Today , the Tagbanuas remain the dominant if not entire population of Coron . 59-87 270-283 The area is famous for its World War II wreck diving , and the site has been named in many lists of top dive spots in the world . Today , the Tagbanuas remain the dominant if not entire population of Coron . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_coron 270-283 284-292 Today , the Tagbanuas remain the dominant if not entire population of Coron . In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town 270-283 284-308 Today , the Tagbanuas remain the dominant if not entire population of Coron . In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_coron 284-292 293-308 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . 284-308 284-308 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_coron 284-292 309-325 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town From 1939 to the outbreak of World War II , the municipality experienced the mining boom . 284-308 309-325 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . From 1939 to the outbreak of World War II , the municipality experienced the mining boom . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_coron 309-325 326-332 From 1939 to the outbreak of World War II , the municipality experienced the mining boom . Labor shifted from farming to mining . 309-325 326-332 From 1939 to the outbreak of World War II , the municipality experienced the mining boom . Labor shifted from farming to mining . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_voyage_coron 284-292 333-341 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town In July 1942 the Japanese occupied the mining camps 284-308 333-349 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . In July 1942 the Japanese occupied the mining camps and resumed operation of the manganese mines . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_coron 333-341 342-349 In July 1942 the Japanese occupied the mining camps and resumed operation of the manganese mines . 333-349 333-349 In July 1942 the Japanese occupied the mining camps and resumed operation of the manganese mines . In July 1942 the Japanese occupied the mining camps and resumed operation of the manganese mines . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_voyage_coron 284-292 350-368 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town On September 24 , 1944 , a group of Japanese ships were sunk by American warplanes in Coron waters 284-308 350-376 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . On September 24 , 1944 , a group of Japanese ships were sunk by American warplanes in Coron waters as the ships retreated from Manila Bay . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_coron 350-368 369-376 On September 24 , 1944 , a group of Japanese ships were sunk by American warplanes in Coron waters as the ships retreated from Manila Bay . 350-376 350-376 On September 24 , 1944 , a group of Japanese ships were sunk by American warplanes in Coron waters as the ships retreated from Manila Bay . On September 24 , 1944 , a group of Japanese ships were sunk by American warplanes in Coron waters as the ships retreated from Manila Bay . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_voyage_coron 350-368 377-405 On September 24 , 1944 , a group of Japanese ships were sunk by American warplanes in Coron waters To this day , about 10 or 12 of these World War II Japanese shipwrecks comprise what is considered one of the best dive sites in the world . 350-376 377-405 On September 24 , 1944 , a group of Japanese ships were sunk by American warplanes in Coron waters as the ships retreated from Manila Bay . To this day , about 10 or 12 of these World War II Japanese shipwrecks comprise what is considered one of the best dive sites in the world . 1<2 result result +GUM_voyage_coron 284-292 406-418 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town In 1947 , large scale deep sea fishing was introduced to Coron , 284-308 406-429 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . In 1947 , large scale deep sea fishing was introduced to Coron , and the town experienced another boom , a fishing boom . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_coron 406-418 419-429 In 1947 , large scale deep sea fishing was introduced to Coron , and the town experienced another boom , a fishing boom . 406-429 406-429 In 1947 , large scale deep sea fishing was introduced to Coron , and the town experienced another boom , a fishing boom . In 1947 , large scale deep sea fishing was introduced to Coron , and the town experienced another boom , a fishing boom . 1<2 result result +GUM_voyage_coron 419-429 430-433 and the town experienced another boom , a fishing boom . The population increased , 406-429 430-450 In 1947 , large scale deep sea fishing was introduced to Coron , and the town experienced another boom , a fishing boom . The population increased , as many people from Luzon and the Visayas came to work either as fishermen or miners . 1<2 result result +GUM_voyage_coron 430-433 434-442 The population increased , as many people from Luzon and the Visayas came 430-450 430-450 The population increased , as many people from Luzon and the Visayas came to work either as fishermen or miners . The population increased , as many people from Luzon and the Visayas came to work either as fishermen or miners . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_voyage_coron 434-442 443-450 as many people from Luzon and the Visayas came to work either as fishermen or miners . 430-450 430-450 The population increased , as many people from Luzon and the Visayas came to work either as fishermen or miners . The population increased , as many people from Luzon and the Visayas came to work either as fishermen or miners . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_voyage_coron 284-292 451-466 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town On June 17 , 1950 , Busuanga was officially created as a separate municipality from Coron 284-308 451-484 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . On June 17 , 1950 , Busuanga was officially created as a separate municipality from Coron and in 1954 , Coron was further reduced by the official creation of the Municipality of Linapacan . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_coron 284-292 467-484 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and in 1954 , Coron was further reduced by the official creation of the Municipality of Linapacan . 284-308 451-484 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . On June 17 , 1950 , Busuanga was officially created as a separate municipality from Coron and in 1954 , Coron was further reduced by the official creation of the Municipality of Linapacan . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_coron 284-292 485-504 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town On September 12 , 1992 , Coron was finally reduced by the official creation of the Municipality of Culion . 284-308 485-504 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . On September 12 , 1992 , Coron was finally reduced by the official creation of the Municipality of Culion . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_coron 505-516 529-541 In the past , Coron was virtually unknown outside of Palawan . but with increasing media exposure it is growing , slowly but steadily , 505-516 517-541 In the past , Coron was virtually unknown outside of Palawan . It remains a small , quaint fishing town with laid back charm but with increasing media exposure it is growing , slowly but steadily , 1>2 background background +GUM_voyage_coron 517-528 529-541 It remains a small , quaint fishing town with laid back charm but with increasing media exposure it is growing , slowly but steadily , 517-541 517-541 It remains a small , quaint fishing town with laid back charm but with increasing media exposure it is growing , slowly but steadily , It remains a small , quaint fishing town with laid back charm but with increasing media exposure it is growing , slowly but steadily , 1>2 concession concession +GUM_voyage_coron 284-292 529-541 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town but with increasing media exposure it is growing , slowly but steadily , 284-308 517-541 In 1902 that Coron was registered as a town and the name of the town was officially changed from Penon de Coron to Coron . It remains a small , quaint fishing town with laid back charm but with increasing media exposure it is growing , slowly but steadily , 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_voyage_coron 529-541 542-552 but with increasing media exposure it is growing , slowly but steadily , Coron has taken an important position in the tourism industry . 517-541 542-552 It remains a small , quaint fishing town with laid back charm but with increasing media exposure it is growing , slowly but steadily , Coron has taken an important position in the tourism industry . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_voyage_coron 542-552 553-572 Coron has taken an important position in the tourism industry . In the past decade , there has been a rapid influx of scuba divers and other tourists coming in , 542-552 553-582 Coron has taken an important position in the tourism industry . In the past decade , there has been a rapid influx of scuba divers and other tourists coming in , making tourism the major industry player in Coron today . 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_voyage_coron 553-572 573-582 In the past decade , there has been a rapid influx of scuba divers and other tourists coming in , making tourism the major industry player in Coron today . 553-582 553-582 In the past decade , there has been a rapid influx of scuba divers and other tourists coming in , making tourism the major industry player in Coron today . In the past decade , there has been a rapid influx of scuba divers and other tourists coming in , making tourism the major industry player in Coron today . 1<2 result result +GUM_whow_joke 1-5 168-176 How to Tell a Joke so there are no hard and fast rules . 1-5 163-176 How to Tell a Joke Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 6-8 9-12 Two Parts : Getting the Material Right 6-8 9-12 Two Parts : Getting the Material Right 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 9-12 168-176 Getting the Material Right so there are no hard and fast rules . 9-12 163-176 Getting the Material Right Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 9-12 13-16 Getting the Material Right Getting the Delivery Right 9-12 13-16 Getting the Material Right Getting the Delivery Right 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_whow_joke 17-36 168-176 From one-liners to classic three-liners to the one-minute gag you tell your friends , a good joke pleases everyone . so there are no hard and fast rules . 17-36 163-176 From one-liners to classic three-liners to the one-minute gag you tell your friends , a good joke pleases everyone . Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . 1>2 background background +GUM_whow_joke 17-36 37-43 From one-liners to classic three-liners to the one-minute gag you tell your friends , a good joke pleases everyone . Joke-telling is one of the best ways 17-36 37-58 From one-liners to classic three-liners to the one-minute gag you tell your friends , a good joke pleases everyone . Joke-telling is one of the best ways to ease tension , make a new friend , or light up a room . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 37-43 44-47 Joke-telling is one of the best ways to ease tension , 37-58 37-58 Joke-telling is one of the best ways to ease tension , make a new friend , or light up a room . Joke-telling is one of the best ways to ease tension , make a new friend , or light up a room . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_whow_joke 44-47 48-52 to ease tension , make a new friend , 37-58 37-58 Joke-telling is one of the best ways to ease tension , make a new friend , or light up a room . Joke-telling is one of the best ways to ease tension , make a new friend , or light up a room . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_joke 44-47 53-58 to ease tension , or light up a room . 37-58 37-58 Joke-telling is one of the best ways to ease tension , make a new friend , or light up a room . Joke-telling is one of the best ways to ease tension , make a new friend , or light up a room . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_joke 37-43 59-64 Joke-telling is one of the best ways That is , of course , 37-58 59-71 Joke-telling is one of the best ways to ease tension , make a new friend , or light up a room . That is , of course , if you can get a laugh . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_whow_joke 59-64 65-71 That is , of course , if you can get a laugh . 59-71 59-71 That is , of course , if you can get a laugh . That is , of course , if you can get a laugh . 1<2 condition condition +GUM_whow_joke 17-36 72-77 From one-liners to classic three-liners to the one-minute gag you tell your friends , a good joke pleases everyone . Telling good jokes is an art 17-36 72-94 From one-liners to classic three-liners to the one-minute gag you tell your friends , a good joke pleases everyone . Telling good jokes is an art that comes naturally to some people , but for others it takes practice and hard work . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 72-77 78-84 Telling good jokes is an art that comes naturally to some people , 72-94 72-94 Telling good jokes is an art that comes naturally to some people , but for others it takes practice and hard work . Telling good jokes is an art that comes naturally to some people , but for others it takes practice and hard work . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 72-77 85-94 Telling good jokes is an art but for others it takes practice and hard work . 72-94 72-94 Telling good jokes is an art that comes naturally to some people , but for others it takes practice and hard work . Telling good jokes is an art that comes naturally to some people , but for others it takes practice and hard work . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_joke 95-99 100-103 Part 1 of 2 : Getting the Material Right 95-99 100-103 Part 1 of 2 : Getting the Material Right 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 100-103 168-176 Getting the Material Right so there are no hard and fast rules . 100-103 163-176 Getting the Material Right Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 104-107 168-176 Know your audience . so there are no hard and fast rules . 104-107 163-176 Know your audience . Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 108-112,116-130 168-176 All aspects of the joke <*> from the content to the length , need to be suited to your audience . so there are no hard and fast rules . 108-130 163-176 All aspects of the joke you tell , from the content to the length , need to be suited to your audience . Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . 1>2 background background +GUM_whow_joke 108-112,116-130 113-115 All aspects of the joke <*> from the content to the length , need to be suited to your audience . you tell , 108-130 108-130 All aspects of the joke you tell , from the content to the length , need to be suited to your audience . All aspects of the joke you tell , from the content to the length , need to be suited to your audience . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 108-112,116-130 131-154 All aspects of the joke <*> from the content to the length , need to be suited to your audience . What ’s funny to a group of 20-year old college students may be very different from what makes your 70-year old - uncle laugh 108-130 131-162 All aspects of the joke you tell , from the content to the length , need to be suited to your audience . What ’s funny to a group of 20-year old college students may be very different from what makes your 70-year old - uncle laugh ( then again , maybe not ) . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_whow_joke 131-154 155-162 What ’s funny to a group of 20-year old college students may be very different from what makes your 70-year old - uncle laugh ( then again , maybe not ) . 131-162 131-162 What ’s funny to a group of 20-year old college students may be very different from what makes your 70-year old - uncle laugh ( then again , maybe not ) . What ’s funny to a group of 20-year old college students may be very different from what makes your 70-year old - uncle laugh ( then again , maybe not ) . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_whow_joke 163-167 168-176 Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . 163-176 163-176 Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . 1>2 cause cause +GUM_whow_joke 177-178,189-198 199-206 But , <*> here are some good rules of thumb to follow : elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; 177-198 199-206 But , unless you personally know the members of your audience , here are some good rules of thumb to follow : elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 179-188 189-198 unless you personally know the members of your audience , here are some good rules of thumb to follow : 177-198 177-198 But , unless you personally know the members of your audience , here are some good rules of thumb to follow : But , unless you personally know the members of your audience , here are some good rules of thumb to follow : 1>2 condition condition +GUM_whow_joke 168-176 199-206 so there are no hard and fast rules . elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; 163-176 199-206 Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_joke 199-206 207-211 elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; stay away from misogynist jokes 199-206 207-221 elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; stay away from misogynist jokes if you ’ve got an audience full of women ; 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 207-211 212-221 stay away from misogynist jokes if you ’ve got an audience full of women ; 207-221 207-221 stay away from misogynist jokes if you ’ve got an audience full of women ; stay away from misogynist jokes if you ’ve got an audience full of women ; 1<2 condition condition +GUM_whow_joke 199-206 222-233 elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; people of a specific ethnic or racial group wo n’t enjoy jokes 199-206 222-239 elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; people of a specific ethnic or racial group wo n’t enjoy jokes making fun of their group ; 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 222-233 234-239 people of a specific ethnic or racial group wo n’t enjoy jokes making fun of their group ; 222-239 222-239 people of a specific ethnic or racial group wo n’t enjoy jokes making fun of their group ; people of a specific ethnic or racial group wo n’t enjoy jokes making fun of their group ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 199-206 240-244,256-261 elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; and jokes requiring specialized knowledge <*> will only be appreciated by people 199-206 240-266 elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; and jokes requiring specialized knowledge ( of , for example , science or old movies ) will only be appreciated by people who possess that knowledge . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 240-244,256-261 245-255 and jokes requiring specialized knowledge <*> will only be appreciated by people ( of , for example , science or old movies ) 240-266 240-266 and jokes requiring specialized knowledge ( of , for example , science or old movies ) will only be appreciated by people who possess that knowledge . and jokes requiring specialized knowledge ( of , for example , science or old movies ) will only be appreciated by people who possess that knowledge . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 256-261 262-266 will only be appreciated by people who possess that knowledge . 240-266 240-266 and jokes requiring specialized knowledge ( of , for example , science or old movies ) will only be appreciated by people who possess that knowledge . and jokes requiring specialized knowledge ( of , for example , science or old movies ) will only be appreciated by people who possess that knowledge . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 267-273 274-286 The more you know about your audience the better you ’ll be able to tailor your jokes to them . 267-286 267-286 The more you know about your audience the better you ’ll be able to tailor your jokes to them . The more you know about your audience the better you ’ll be able to tailor your jokes to them . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_whow_joke 199-206 274-286 elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; the better you ’ll be able to tailor your jokes to them . 199-206 267-286 elderly people wo n’t like crude jokes ; The more you know about your audience the better you ’ll be able to tailor your jokes to them . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 287-290 291-298 Choose great material . You can find fodder lots of places — 287-290 291-320 Choose great material . You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , joke files online , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , and so on . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 168-176 291-298 so there are no hard and fast rules . You can find fodder lots of places — 163-176 291-320 Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , joke files online , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , and so on . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 291-298 299-302 You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , 291-320 291-320 You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , joke files online , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , and so on . You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , joke files online , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , and so on . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 299-302 303-306 from your life , joke files online , 291-320 291-320 You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , joke files online , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , and so on . You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , joke files online , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , and so on . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 299-302 307-316 from your life , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , 291-320 291-320 You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , joke files online , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , and so on . You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , joke files online , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , and so on . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 299-302 317-320 from your life , and so on . 291-320 291-320 You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , joke files online , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , and so on . You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , joke files online , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , and so on . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 291-298 321-330 You can find fodder lots of places — You may want to start your own joke file . 291-320 321-330 You can find fodder lots of places — from your life , joke files online , by repurposing jokes you ’ve heard in the past , and so on . You may want to start your own joke file . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 321-330 331-339 You may want to start your own joke file . You can write your jokes down on index cards 321-330 331-355 You may want to start your own joke file . You can write your jokes down on index cards to keep them handy or use a document file on your computer . [ 1 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 331-339 340-343 You can write your jokes down on index cards to keep them handy 331-355 331-355 You can write your jokes down on index cards to keep them handy or use a document file on your computer . [ 1 ] You can write your jokes down on index cards to keep them handy or use a document file on your computer . [ 1 ] 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_whow_joke 331-339 344-352 You can write your jokes down on index cards or use a document file on your computer . 331-355 331-355 You can write your jokes down on index cards to keep them handy or use a document file on your computer . [ 1 ] You can write your jokes down on index cards to keep them handy or use a document file on your computer . [ 1 ] 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_joke 344-352 353-355 or use a document file on your computer . [ 1 ] 331-355 331-355 You can write your jokes down on index cards to keep them handy or use a document file on your computer . [ 1 ] You can write your jokes down on index cards to keep them handy or use a document file on your computer . [ 1 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_whow_joke 344-352 356-364 or use a document file on your computer . The latter option may allow for easier revision . 331-355 356-364 You can write your jokes down on index cards to keep them handy or use a document file on your computer . [ 1 ] The latter option may allow for easier revision . 1<2 motivation motivation +GUM_whow_joke 365-369 386-393,403-408 Decide on a target . It ’s important that the joke ’s target <*> be suited to your audience . 365-369 386-408 Decide on a target . It ’s important that the joke ’s target ( the most basic element of your material ) be suited to your audience . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 370-377 386-393,403-408 Every joke has a “ target , ” It ’s important that the joke ’s target <*> be suited to your audience . 370-385 386-408 Every joke has a “ target , ” which is what the joke is about . It ’s important that the joke ’s target ( the most basic element of your material ) be suited to your audience . 1>2 background background +GUM_whow_joke 370-377 378-385 Every joke has a “ target , ” which is what the joke is about . 370-385 370-385 Every joke has a “ target , ” which is what the joke is about . Every joke has a “ target , ” which is what the joke is about . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 168-176 386-393,403-408 so there are no hard and fast rules . It ’s important that the joke ’s target <*> be suited to your audience . 163-176 386-408 Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . It ’s important that the joke ’s target ( the most basic element of your material ) be suited to your audience . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 386-393,403-408 394-402 It ’s important that the joke ’s target <*> be suited to your audience . ( the most basic element of your material ) 386-408 386-408 It ’s important that the joke ’s target ( the most basic element of your material ) be suited to your audience . It ’s important that the joke ’s target ( the most basic element of your material ) be suited to your audience . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_whow_joke 386-393,403-408 409-414,421-422 It ’s important that the joke ’s target <*> be suited to your audience . Make sure it ’s a target <*> and something 386-408 409-433 It ’s important that the joke ’s target ( the most basic element of your material ) be suited to your audience . Make sure it ’s a target your audience will be interested in and something they ’re likely willing to laugh at . [ 2 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 409-414,421-422 415-420 Make sure it ’s a target <*> and something your audience will be interested in 409-433 409-433 Make sure it ’s a target your audience will be interested in and something they ’re likely willing to laugh at . [ 2 ] Make sure it ’s a target your audience will be interested in and something they ’re likely willing to laugh at . [ 2 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 421-422 423-430 and something they ’re likely willing to laugh at . 409-433 409-433 Make sure it ’s a target your audience will be interested in and something they ’re likely willing to laugh at . [ 2 ] Make sure it ’s a target your audience will be interested in and something they ’re likely willing to laugh at . [ 2 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 409-414,421-422 431-433 Make sure it ’s a target <*> and something [ 2 ] 409-433 409-433 Make sure it ’s a target your audience will be interested in and something they ’re likely willing to laugh at . [ 2 ] Make sure it ’s a target your audience will be interested in and something they ’re likely willing to laugh at . [ 2 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_whow_joke 409-414,421-422 434-449 Make sure it ’s a target <*> and something For example , husbands are likely to laugh at jokes about wives and vice versa ; 409-433 434-449 Make sure it ’s a target your audience will be interested in and something they ’re likely willing to laugh at . [ 2 ] For example , husbands are likely to laugh at jokes about wives and vice versa ; 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 434-449 450-460 For example , husbands are likely to laugh at jokes about wives and vice versa ; students will typically find jokes about school and teachers humorous . 434-449 450-460 For example , husbands are likely to laugh at jokes about wives and vice versa ; students will typically find jokes about school and teachers humorous . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 461-467 468-472,477-484 Have a realistic but exaggerated setup . The opening of the joke <*> should have a basis in the real world 461-467 468-512 Have a realistic but exaggerated setup . The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 168-176 468-472,477-484 so there are no hard and fast rules . The opening of the joke <*> should have a basis in the real world 163-176 468-512 Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 468-472,477-484 473-476 The opening of the joke <*> should have a basis in the real world — or setup — 468-512 468-512 The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_whow_joke 468-472,477-484 485-492 The opening of the joke <*> should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , 468-512 468-512 The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_whow_joke 468-472,477-484 493-498 The opening of the joke <*> should have a basis in the real world but it should also include exaggeration 468-512 468-512 The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_joke 493-498 499-509 but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . 468-512 468-512 The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] 1<2 justify justify +GUM_whow_joke 468-472,477-484 510-512 The opening of the joke <*> should have a basis in the real world [ 3 ] 468-512 468-512 The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_whow_joke 468-472,477-484 513-523 The opening of the joke <*> should have a basis in the real world Think of the setup as the foundation of a story . 468-512 513-523 The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] Think of the setup as the foundation of a story . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 513-523 524-532 Think of the setup as the foundation of a story . It ’s a fundamental part of the joke ; 513-523 524-532 Think of the setup as the foundation of a story . It ’s a fundamental part of the joke ; 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_whow_joke 533-542 543-552 if you do n’t lay a good foundation here , then the punchline wo n’t make sense to the audience 533-560 533-560 if you do n’t lay a good foundation here , then the punchline wo n’t make sense to the audience or they wo n’t find it humorous . if you do n’t lay a good foundation here , then the punchline wo n’t make sense to the audience or they wo n’t find it humorous . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_whow_joke 513-523 543-552 Think of the setup as the foundation of a story . then the punchline wo n’t make sense to the audience 513-523 533-560 Think of the setup as the foundation of a story . if you do n’t lay a good foundation here , then the punchline wo n’t make sense to the audience or they wo n’t find it humorous . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_whow_joke 543-552 553-560 then the punchline wo n’t make sense to the audience or they wo n’t find it humorous . 533-560 533-560 if you do n’t lay a good foundation here , then the punchline wo n’t make sense to the audience or they wo n’t find it humorous . if you do n’t lay a good foundation here , then the punchline wo n’t make sense to the audience or they wo n’t find it humorous . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_joke 468-472,477-484 561-569 The opening of the joke <*> should have a basis in the real world Your setup needs to be both realistic and exaggerated 468-512 561-575 The opening of the joke — or setup — should have a basis in the real world so your audience can relate to it , but it should also include exaggeration because this is what gives a joke its humorous edge . [ 3 ] Your setup needs to be both realistic and exaggerated in order to be funny — 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_whow_joke 561-569 570-575 Your setup needs to be both realistic and exaggerated in order to be funny — 561-575 561-575 Your setup needs to be both realistic and exaggerated in order to be funny — Your setup needs to be both realistic and exaggerated in order to be funny — 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_whow_joke 561-569 576-591 Your setup needs to be both realistic and exaggerated it ’s placing these two incongruous elements side by side that makes the joke funny . 561-575 576-594 Your setup needs to be both realistic and exaggerated in order to be funny — it ’s placing these two incongruous elements side by side that makes the joke funny . [ 4 ] 1<2 justify justify +GUM_whow_joke 561-569 592-594 Your setup needs to be both realistic and exaggerated [ 4 ] 561-575 576-594 Your setup needs to be both realistic and exaggerated in order to be funny — it ’s placing these two incongruous elements side by side that makes the joke funny . [ 4 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_whow_joke 561-569 595-602 Your setup needs to be both realistic and exaggerated The exaggeration can be slight or considerable — 561-575 595-602 Your setup needs to be both realistic and exaggerated in order to be funny — The exaggeration can be slight or considerable — 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 595-602 603-610 The exaggeration can be slight or considerable — it just depends on the individual joke . 595-602 603-610 The exaggeration can be slight or considerable — it just depends on the individual joke . 1<2 condition condition +GUM_whow_joke 611-615 616-624 Surprise with the punchline . The ending of the joke is obviously crucial . 611-615 616-624 Surprise with the punchline . The ending of the joke is obviously crucial . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 168-176 616-624 so there are no hard and fast rules . The ending of the joke is obviously crucial . 163-176 616-624 Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . The ending of the joke is obviously crucial . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 616-624 625-640 The ending of the joke is obviously crucial . This is where the payoff comes in , what makes the joke succeed or fail . 616-624 625-640 The ending of the joke is obviously crucial . This is where the payoff comes in , what makes the joke succeed or fail . 1<2 justify justify +GUM_whow_joke 641-649 650-656 If you want to make the audience laugh , your punchline needs to be surprising . 641-656 641-656 If you want to make the audience laugh , your punchline needs to be surprising . If you want to make the audience laugh , your punchline needs to be surprising . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_whow_joke 616-624 650-656 The ending of the joke is obviously crucial . your punchline needs to be surprising . 616-624 641-656 The ending of the joke is obviously crucial . If you want to make the audience laugh , your punchline needs to be surprising . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 616-624 657-668 The ending of the joke is obviously crucial . Some jokes also have what is called a tag or topper , 616-624 657-674 The ending of the joke is obviously crucial . Some jokes also have what is called a tag or topper , which is an additional punchline . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 657-668 669-674 Some jokes also have what is called a tag or topper , which is an additional punchline . 657-674 657-674 Some jokes also have what is called a tag or topper , which is an additional punchline . Some jokes also have what is called a tag or topper , which is an additional punchline . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 657-668 675-691 Some jokes also have what is called a tag or topper , The tag builds on the original punchline or twists back on it in a surprising way . 657-674 675-691 Some jokes also have what is called a tag or topper , which is an additional punchline . The tag builds on the original punchline or twists back on it in a surprising way . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 692-697 724-733 Make the joke your own . it has to surprise the audience in some way , 692-697 717-743 Make the joke your own . For your joke to be funny , it has to surprise the audience in some way , which means it has to seem original or new . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 698-704 724-733 Lots of jokes rehash the same ground it has to surprise the audience in some way , 698-716 717-743 Lots of jokes rehash the same ground and sometimes they retell a story countless other jokes have told . For your joke to be funny , it has to surprise the audience in some way , which means it has to seem original or new . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_whow_joke 698-704 705-710 Lots of jokes rehash the same ground and sometimes they retell a story 698-716 698-716 Lots of jokes rehash the same ground and sometimes they retell a story countless other jokes have told . Lots of jokes rehash the same ground and sometimes they retell a story countless other jokes have told . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_whow_joke 705-710 711-716 and sometimes they retell a story countless other jokes have told . 698-716 698-716 Lots of jokes rehash the same ground and sometimes they retell a story countless other jokes have told . Lots of jokes rehash the same ground and sometimes they retell a story countless other jokes have told . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 717-723 724-733 For your joke to be funny , it has to surprise the audience in some way , 717-743 717-743 For your joke to be funny , it has to surprise the audience in some way , which means it has to seem original or new . For your joke to be funny , it has to surprise the audience in some way , which means it has to seem original or new . 1>2 result result +GUM_whow_joke 168-176 724-733 so there are no hard and fast rules . it has to surprise the audience in some way , 163-176 717-743 Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . For your joke to be funny , it has to surprise the audience in some way , which means it has to seem original or new . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 724-733 734-743 it has to surprise the audience in some way , which means it has to seem original or new . 717-743 717-743 For your joke to be funny , it has to surprise the audience in some way , which means it has to seem original or new . For your joke to be funny , it has to surprise the audience in some way , which means it has to seem original or new . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 724-733 744-745,750-755 it has to surprise the audience in some way , One way <*> is to change the ending . 717-743 744-758 For your joke to be funny , it has to surprise the audience in some way , which means it has to seem original or new . One way to personalize a joke is to change the ending . [ 5 ] 1<2 means means +GUM_whow_joke 744-745,750-755 746-749 One way <*> is to change the ending . to personalize a joke 744-758 744-758 One way to personalize a joke is to change the ending . [ 5 ] One way to personalize a joke is to change the ending . [ 5 ] 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_whow_joke 744-745,750-755 756-758 One way <*> is to change the ending . [ 5 ] 744-758 744-758 One way to personalize a joke is to change the ending . [ 5 ] One way to personalize a joke is to change the ending . [ 5 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_whow_joke 744-745,750-755 759-774 One way <*> is to change the ending . Another option is to dress the joke up as a story about your own life . 744-758 759-774 One way to personalize a joke is to change the ending . [ 5 ] Another option is to dress the joke up as a story about your own life . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_joke 759-774 775-782 Another option is to dress the joke up as a story about your own life . This will make a familiar joke unrecognizable . 759-774 775-782 Another option is to dress the joke up as a story about your own life . This will make a familiar joke unrecognizable . 1<2 result result +GUM_whow_joke 775-782 783-789 This will make a familiar joke unrecognizable . It may also make it particularly interesting 775-782 783-799 This will make a familiar joke unrecognizable . It may also make it particularly interesting if your audience is your friend(s) . [ 6 ] 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 783-789 790-796 It may also make it particularly interesting if your audience is your friend(s) . 783-799 783-799 It may also make it particularly interesting if your audience is your friend(s) . [ 6 ] It may also make it particularly interesting if your audience is your friend(s) . [ 6 ] 1<2 condition condition +GUM_whow_joke 759-774 797-799 Another option is to dress the joke up as a story about your own life . [ 6 ] 759-774 783-799 Another option is to dress the joke up as a story about your own life . It may also make it particularly interesting if your audience is your friend(s) . [ 6 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_whow_joke 800-803 804-809 Know your material . Practicing your joke is crucial . 800-803 804-809 Know your material . Practicing your joke is crucial . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_joke 168-176 804-809 so there are no hard and fast rules . Practicing your joke is crucial . 163-176 804-809 Everyone ’s an individual , so there are no hard and fast rules . Practicing your joke is crucial . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 804-809 810-818 Practicing your joke is crucial . You do n’t need to have it completely memorized 804-809 810-871 Practicing your joke is crucial . You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 819-830 831-840 — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , 810-871 810-871 You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . 1>2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_whow_joke 810-818 831-840 You do n’t need to have it completely memorized but you need to be really comfortable with it , 810-871 810-871 You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_joke 831-840 841-842 but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable 810-871 810-871 You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 841-842 843-850 so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it 810-871 810-871 You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_whow_joke 843-850 851-858 that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , 810-871 810-871 You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . 1<2 condition condition +GUM_whow_joke 851-858 859-862 even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible 810-871 810-871 You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_whow_joke 859-862 863-871 which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . 810-871 810-871 You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . You do n’t need to have it completely memorized — in fact , you " should n’t " memorize it — but you need to be really comfortable with it , so comfortable that you can continue on with telling it even if you get nervous or sidetracked , which is very possible once you ’re in front of an audience . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_whow_joke 804-809 872-876 Practicing your joke is crucial . Memorized jokes sound wooden , 804-809 872-893 Practicing your joke is crucial . Memorized jokes sound wooden , like they are being read off a script instead of relayed by a friend or entertainer . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 872-876 877-884 Memorized jokes sound wooden , like they are being read off a script 872-893 872-893 Memorized jokes sound wooden , like they are being read off a script instead of relayed by a friend or entertainer . Memorized jokes sound wooden , like they are being read off a script instead of relayed by a friend or entertainer . 1<2 evaluation evaluation +GUM_whow_joke 877-884 885-893 like they are being read off a script instead of relayed by a friend or entertainer . 872-893 872-893 Memorized jokes sound wooden , like they are being read off a script instead of relayed by a friend or entertainer . Memorized jokes sound wooden , like they are being read off a script instead of relayed by a friend or entertainer . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_whow_joke 894-903 904-911 Good jokes have a lot of details and personality , so do n’t be afraid to embellish . 894-914 894-914 Good jokes have a lot of details and personality , so do n’t be afraid to embellish . [ 7 ] Good jokes have a lot of details and personality , so do n’t be afraid to embellish . [ 7 ] 1>2 motivation motivation +GUM_whow_joke 872-876 904-911 Memorized jokes sound wooden , so do n’t be afraid to embellish . 872-893 894-914 Memorized jokes sound wooden , like they are being read off a script instead of relayed by a friend or entertainer . Good jokes have a lot of details and personality , so do n’t be afraid to embellish . [ 7 ] 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_joke 904-911 912-914 so do n’t be afraid to embellish . [ 7 ] 894-914 894-914 Good jokes have a lot of details and personality , so do n’t be afraid to embellish . [ 7 ] Good jokes have a lot of details and personality , so do n’t be afraid to embellish . [ 7 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_whow_joke 804-809 915-918 Practicing your joke is crucial . Try different things out 804-809 915-928 Practicing your joke is crucial . Try different things out and see what feels right , what sounds best . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 915-918 919-928 Try different things out and see what feels right , what sounds best . 915-928 915-928 Try different things out and see what feels right , what sounds best . Try different things out and see what feels right , what sounds best . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_whow_joke 804-809 929-933 Practicing your joke is crucial . Do n’t use a joke 804-809 929-941 Practicing your joke is crucial . Do n’t use a joke until you ’re completely comfortable with it . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 929-933 934-941 Do n’t use a joke until you ’re completely comfortable with it . 929-941 929-941 Do n’t use a joke until you ’re completely comfortable with it . Do n’t use a joke until you ’re completely comfortable with it . 1<2 condition condition +GUM_whow_joke 804-809 942-956 Practicing your joke is crucial . Try recording your joke on a tape player and playing it back to yourself . 804-809 942-956 Practicing your joke is crucial . Try recording your joke on a tape player and playing it back to yourself . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 957-969 970-974 If you hear a lot of awkward pauses or “ah”s or “um”s , your joke is n’t ready 957-984 957-984 If you hear a lot of awkward pauses or “ah”s or “um”s , your joke is n’t ready and you need to practice more . [ 8 ] If you hear a lot of awkward pauses or “ah”s or “um”s , your joke is n’t ready and you need to practice more . [ 8 ] 1>2 condition condition +GUM_whow_joke 942-956 970-974 Try recording your joke on a tape player and playing it back to yourself . your joke is n’t ready 942-956 957-984 Try recording your joke on a tape player and playing it back to yourself . If you hear a lot of awkward pauses or “ah”s or “um”s , your joke is n’t ready and you need to practice more . [ 8 ] 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_joke 970-974 975-981 your joke is n’t ready and you need to practice more . 957-984 957-984 If you hear a lot of awkward pauses or “ah”s or “um”s , your joke is n’t ready and you need to practice more . [ 8 ] If you hear a lot of awkward pauses or “ah”s or “um”s , your joke is n’t ready and you need to practice more . [ 8 ] 1<2 result result +GUM_whow_joke 942-956 982-984 Try recording your joke on a tape player and playing it back to yourself . [ 8 ] 942-956 957-984 Try recording your joke on a tape player and playing it back to yourself . If you hear a lot of awkward pauses or “ah”s or “um”s , your joke is n’t ready and you need to practice more . [ 8 ] 1<2 evidence evidence +GUM_whow_joke 804-809 985-998 Practicing your joke is crucial . You can also try practicing in front of a sympathetic friend or family member 804-809 985-1009 Practicing your joke is crucial . You can also try practicing in front of a sympathetic friend or family member once you ’re ready for a “ real ” audience . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_joke 985-998 999-1009 You can also try practicing in front of a sympathetic friend or family member once you ’re ready for a “ real ” audience . 985-1009 985-1009 You can also try practicing in front of a sympathetic friend or family member once you ’re ready for a “ real ” audience . You can also try practicing in front of a sympathetic friend or family member once you ’re ready for a “ real ” audience . 1<2 condition condition +GUM_whow_overalls 1-8 117-125 How to Wash Overalls in a Washing Machine Wash alone or with " like " clothing . 1-8 117-125 How to Wash Overalls in a Washing Machine Wash alone or with " like " clothing . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_overalls 9-19 25-35 Whether you are a working man or just a little cutie those overalls are going to need washing sooner or later . 9-35 9-35 Whether you are a working man or just a little cutie trying to stay cute , those overalls are going to need washing sooner or later . Whether you are a working man or just a little cutie trying to stay cute , those overalls are going to need washing sooner or later . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_whow_overalls 9-19 20-24 Whether you are a working man or just a little cutie trying to stay cute , 9-35 9-35 Whether you are a working man or just a little cutie trying to stay cute , those overalls are going to need washing sooner or later . Whether you are a working man or just a little cutie trying to stay cute , those overalls are going to need washing sooner or later . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_overalls 25-35 36-48 those overalls are going to need washing sooner or later . The straps on adults ’ overalls often get so twisted during the wash 9-35 36-61 Whether you are a working man or just a little cutie trying to stay cute , those overalls are going to need washing sooner or later . The straps on adults ’ overalls often get so twisted during the wash that one wishes she had just used an old fashioned washboard instead . 1>2 background background +GUM_whow_overalls 36-48 90-93 The straps on adults ’ overalls often get so twisted during the wash how to save time 36-61 85-115 The straps on adults ’ overalls often get so twisted during the wash that one wishes she had just used an old fashioned washboard instead . This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . 1>2 background background +GUM_whow_overalls 36-48 49-51 The straps on adults ’ overalls often get so twisted during the wash that one wishes 36-61 36-61 The straps on adults ’ overalls often get so twisted during the wash that one wishes she had just used an old fashioned washboard instead . The straps on adults ’ overalls often get so twisted during the wash that one wishes she had just used an old fashioned washboard instead . 1<2 result result +GUM_whow_overalls 49-51 52-61 that one wishes she had just used an old fashioned washboard instead . 36-61 36-61 The straps on adults ’ overalls often get so twisted during the wash that one wishes she had just used an old fashioned washboard instead . The straps on adults ’ overalls often get so twisted during the wash that one wishes she had just used an old fashioned washboard instead . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_overalls 36-48 62-70 The straps on adults ’ overalls often get so twisted during the wash Your appliances are also murder on the straps , 36-61 62-84 The straps on adults ’ overalls often get so twisted during the wash that one wishes she had just used an old fashioned washboard instead . Your appliances are also murder on the straps , which are almost always the first things to wear out on your overalls . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_overalls 62-70 71-84 Your appliances are also murder on the straps , which are almost always the first things to wear out on your overalls . 62-84 62-84 Your appliances are also murder on the straps , which are almost always the first things to wear out on your overalls . Your appliances are also murder on the straps , which are almost always the first things to wear out on your overalls . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_overalls 85-89 90-93 This article will show you how to save time 85-115 85-115 This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_whow_overalls 90-93 117-125 how to save time Wash alone or with " like " clothing . 85-115 117-125 This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . Wash alone or with " like " clothing . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_overalls 90-93 94-97 how to save time and prevent wear , 85-115 85-115 This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_overalls 90-93 98-103 how to save time extending the life of your overalls 85-115 85-115 This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . 1<2 result result +GUM_whow_overalls 90-93 104-108 how to save time until they are so soft 85-115 85-115 This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . 1<2 result result +GUM_whow_overalls 104-108 109-115 until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . 85-115 85-115 This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . This article will show you how to save time and prevent wear , extending the life of your overalls until they are so soft you could wear them to bed . 1<2 manner manner +GUM_whow_overalls 116 117-125 Steps Wash alone or with " like " clothing . 116 117-125 Steps Wash alone or with " like " clothing . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_overalls 117-125 126-139 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . It ’s best to wash adults ’ overalls alone , especially men ’s . 117-125 126-139 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . It ’s best to wash adults ’ overalls alone , especially men ’s . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_overalls 126-139 140-157 It ’s best to wash adults ’ overalls alone , especially men ’s . However , it is okay to wash just a few items with them , like blue jeans . 126-139 140-157 It ’s best to wash adults ’ overalls alone , especially men ’s . However , it is okay to wash just a few items with them , like blue jeans . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_whow_overalls 126-139 158-168 It ’s best to wash adults ’ overalls alone , especially men ’s . What you do n’t want to wash with them is anything 126-139 158-188 It ’s best to wash adults ’ overalls alone , especially men ’s . What you do n’t want to wash with them is anything that can get twisted up with the straps , like women ’s long sleeve shirts or kids ’ blankets . 1<2 antithesis antithesis +GUM_whow_overalls 158-168 169-188 What you do n’t want to wash with them is anything that can get twisted up with the straps , like women ’s long sleeve shirts or kids ’ blankets . 158-188 158-188 What you do n’t want to wash with them is anything that can get twisted up with the straps , like women ’s long sleeve shirts or kids ’ blankets . What you do n’t want to wash with them is anything that can get twisted up with the straps , like women ’s long sleeve shirts or kids ’ blankets . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_overalls 126-139 189-196 It ’s best to wash adults ’ overalls alone , especially men ’s . Think similar clothing , minus the twisty-ness . 126-139 189-196 It ’s best to wash adults ’ overalls alone , especially men ’s . Think similar clothing , minus the twisty-ness . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_overalls 189-196 197-205 Think similar clothing , minus the twisty-ness . Just do the denim and canvas stuff together . 189-196 197-205 Think similar clothing , minus the twisty-ness . Just do the denim and canvas stuff together . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_overalls 117-125 206-212 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . Fasten the straps to the bib . 117-125 206-212 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . Fasten the straps to the bib . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_whow_overalls 213-219 220-231 If you did n’t know already , the bib is the top front part with the breast pockets . 213-231 213-231 If you did n’t know already , the bib is the top front part with the breast pockets . If you did n’t know already , the bib is the top front part with the breast pockets . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_overalls 206-212 220-231 Fasten the straps to the bib . the bib is the top front part with the breast pockets . 206-212 213-231 Fasten the straps to the bib . If you did n’t know already , the bib is the top front part with the breast pockets . 1<2 background background +GUM_whow_overalls 206-212 232-237 Fasten the straps to the bib . Go ahead and fasten both straps 206-212 232-241 Fasten the straps to the bib . Go ahead and fasten both straps before you wash . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_whow_overalls 232-237 238-241 Go ahead and fasten both straps before you wash . 232-241 232-241 Go ahead and fasten both straps before you wash . Go ahead and fasten both straps before you wash . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_whow_overalls 206-212 242-253 Fasten the straps to the bib . This will help keep them from twisting up during the wash . 206-212 242-253 Fasten the straps to the bib . This will help keep them from twisting up during the wash . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_whow_overalls 206-212 254-256 Fasten the straps to the bib . Use twist ties 206-212 254-262 Fasten the straps to the bib . Use twist ties to keep the straps fastened . 1<2 means means +GUM_whow_overalls 254-256 257-262 Use twist ties to keep the straps fastened . 254-262 254-262 Use twist ties to keep the straps fastened . Use twist ties to keep the straps fastened . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_whow_overalls 263-275 276-280 This step will reapportion years of your life in the long run . Do n’t skip it . 263-275 276-280 This step will reapportion years of your life in the long run . Do n’t skip it . 1>2 motivation motivation +GUM_whow_overalls 206-212 276-280 Fasten the straps to the bib . Do n’t skip it . 206-212 276-280 Fasten the straps to the bib . Do n’t skip it . 1<2 motivation motivation +GUM_whow_overalls 276-280 281-284 Do n’t skip it . Take the 20 seconds 276-280 281-302 Do n’t skip it . Take the 20 seconds to use a couple twist ties on the fasteners to make sure they do n’t come loose . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_whow_overalls 281-284 285-293 Take the 20 seconds to use a couple twist ties on the fasteners 281-302 281-302 Take the 20 seconds to use a couple twist ties on the fasteners to make sure they do n’t come loose . Take the 20 seconds to use a couple twist ties on the fasteners to make sure they do n’t come loose . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_whow_overalls 281-284 294-302 Take the 20 seconds to make sure they do n’t come loose . 281-302 281-302 Take the 20 seconds to use a couple twist ties on the fasteners to make sure they do n’t come loose . Take the 20 seconds to use a couple twist ties on the fasteners to make sure they do n’t come loose . 1<2 purpose purpose +GUM_whow_overalls 303-311 312-319 If your washing machine is worth its salt , it will undo those straps in a heartbeat 303-331 303-331 If your washing machine is worth its salt , it will undo those straps in a heartbeat and tie them in a sheet bend unless you prevent it . If your washing machine is worth its salt , it will undo those straps in a heartbeat and tie them in a sheet bend unless you prevent it . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_whow_overalls 276-280 312-319 Do n’t skip it . it will undo those straps in a heartbeat 276-280 303-331 Do n’t skip it . If your washing machine is worth its salt , it will undo those straps in a heartbeat and tie them in a sheet bend unless you prevent it . 1<2 motivation motivation +GUM_whow_overalls 312-319 320-326 it will undo those straps in a heartbeat and tie them in a sheet bend 303-331 303-331 If your washing machine is worth its salt , it will undo those straps in a heartbeat and tie them in a sheet bend unless you prevent it . If your washing machine is worth its salt , it will undo those straps in a heartbeat and tie them in a sheet bend unless you prevent it . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_whow_overalls 312-319 327-331 it will undo those straps in a heartbeat unless you prevent it . 303-331 303-331 If your washing machine is worth its salt , it will undo those straps in a heartbeat and tie them in a sheet bend unless you prevent it . If your washing machine is worth its salt , it will undo those straps in a heartbeat and tie them in a sheet bend unless you prevent it . 1<2 condition condition +GUM_whow_overalls 276-280 332-345 Do n’t skip it . All it takes is two twist ties and a few seconds of patience . 276-280 332-345 Do n’t skip it . All it takes is two twist ties and a few seconds of patience . 1<2 motivation motivation +GUM_whow_overalls 117-125 346-349 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . Empty the pockets . 117-125 346-349 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . Empty the pockets . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_whow_overalls 346-349 350-356 Empty the pockets . Overalls have more pockets than pants . 346-349 350-356 Empty the pockets . Overalls have more pockets than pants . 1<2 background background +GUM_whow_overalls 350-356 357-367 Overalls have more pockets than pants . The bib has a wallet pocket and a watch pocket . 350-356 357-367 Overalls have more pockets than pants . The bib has a wallet pocket and a watch pocket . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_overalls 346-349 368-378 Empty the pockets . Kids put rocks , candy , and bugs in these . 346-349 368-378 Empty the pockets . Kids put rocks , candy , and bugs in these . 1<2 motivation motivation +GUM_whow_overalls 368-378 379-388 Kids put rocks , candy , and bugs in these . Men put cell phones and small tools in them . 368-378 379-388 Kids put rocks , candy , and bugs in these . Men put cell phones and small tools in them . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_overalls 389-395 396,404-409 Women defy the laws of purse-space , so <*> the sky is the limit . 389-409 389-409 Women defy the laws of purse-space , so when it comes to bib pockets , the sky is the limit . Women defy the laws of purse-space , so when it comes to bib pockets , the sky is the limit . 1>2 background background +GUM_whow_overalls 368-378 396,404-409 Kids put rocks , candy , and bugs in these . so <*> the sky is the limit . 368-378 389-409 Kids put rocks , candy , and bugs in these . Women defy the laws of purse-space , so when it comes to bib pockets , the sky is the limit . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_overalls 397-403 404-409 when it comes to bib pockets , the sky is the limit . 389-409 389-409 Women defy the laws of purse-space , so when it comes to bib pockets , the sky is the limit . Women defy the laws of purse-space , so when it comes to bib pockets , the sky is the limit . 1>2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_whow_overalls 346-349 410-417 Empty the pockets . Make sure all the pockets are empty . 346-349 410-417 Empty the pockets . Make sure all the pockets are empty . 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_whow_overalls 117-125 418-423 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . Move the strap adjusters around . 117-125 418-423 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . Move the strap adjusters around . 1<2 sequence sequence +GUM_whow_overalls 424-435 450-455 You ’ve probably got them just the way you like them , the straps will last longer . 424-455 424-455 You ’ve probably got them just the way you like them , but if you move the adjusters up or down on the straps occasionally , the straps will last longer . You ’ve probably got them just the way you like them , but if you move the adjusters up or down on the straps occasionally , the straps will last longer . 1>2 concession concession +GUM_whow_overalls 436-449 450-455 but if you move the adjusters up or down on the straps occasionally , the straps will last longer . 424-455 424-455 You ’ve probably got them just the way you like them , but if you move the adjusters up or down on the straps occasionally , the straps will last longer . You ’ve probably got them just the way you like them , but if you move the adjusters up or down on the straps occasionally , the straps will last longer . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_whow_overalls 418-423 450-455 Move the strap adjusters around . the straps will last longer . 418-423 424-455 Move the strap adjusters around . You ’ve probably got them just the way you like them , but if you move the adjusters up or down on the straps occasionally , the straps will last longer . 1<2 motivation motivation +GUM_whow_overalls 456-460 461-472 Depending on the adjusters , you may be able to leave them a little loose too . 456-472 456-472 Depending on the adjusters , you may be able to leave them a little loose too . Depending on the adjusters , you may be able to leave them a little loose too . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_whow_overalls 450-455 461-472 the straps will last longer . you may be able to leave them a little loose too . 424-455 456-472 You ’ve probably got them just the way you like them , but if you move the adjusters up or down on the straps occasionally , the straps will last longer . Depending on the adjusters , you may be able to leave them a little loose too . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_overalls 473-489 506-515 The straps wear out fastest around the adjusters over the course of numerous wash and dry cycles Moving them distributes the wear and tear of washing . 473-505 506-515 The straps wear out fastest around the adjusters over the course of numerous wash and dry cycles ( not to mention being out in the elements if they are work clothes ) . Moving them distributes the wear and tear of washing . 1>2 background background +GUM_whow_overalls 473-489 490-498 The straps wear out fastest around the adjusters over the course of numerous wash and dry cycles ( not to mention being out in the elements 473-505 473-505 The straps wear out fastest around the adjusters over the course of numerous wash and dry cycles ( not to mention being out in the elements if they are work clothes ) . The straps wear out fastest around the adjusters over the course of numerous wash and dry cycles ( not to mention being out in the elements if they are work clothes ) . 1<2 elaboration elaboration +GUM_whow_overalls 490-498 499-505 ( not to mention being out in the elements if they are work clothes ) . 473-505 473-505 The straps wear out fastest around the adjusters over the course of numerous wash and dry cycles ( not to mention being out in the elements if they are work clothes ) . The straps wear out fastest around the adjusters over the course of numerous wash and dry cycles ( not to mention being out in the elements if they are work clothes ) . 1<2 condition condition +GUM_whow_overalls 450-455 506-515 the straps will last longer . Moving them distributes the wear and tear of washing . 424-455 506-515 You ’ve probably got them just the way you like them , but if you move the adjusters up or down on the straps occasionally , the straps will last longer . Moving them distributes the wear and tear of washing . 1<2 cause cause +GUM_whow_overalls 450-455 516-524 the straps will last longer . This is the same idea as rotating tires . 424-455 516-524 You ’ve probably got them just the way you like them , but if you move the adjusters up or down on the straps occasionally , the straps will last longer . This is the same idea as rotating tires . 1<2 background background +GUM_whow_overalls 525-526 527-531 You know about rotating your tires , 525-535 525-535 You know about rotating your tires , do n't you ? You know about rotating your tires , do n't you ? 1>2 attribution attribution +GUM_whow_overalls 516-524 527-531 This is the same idea as rotating tires . about rotating your tires , 516-524 525-535 This is the same idea as rotating tires . You know about rotating your tires , do n't you ? 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_whow_overalls 527-531 532-535 about rotating your tires , do n't you ? 525-535 525-535 You know about rotating your tires , do n't you ? You know about rotating your tires , do n't you ? 1<2 restatement restatement +GUM_whow_overalls 536 549-559 Tips use about half the detergent called for and less water . 536 537-559 Tips If you wash your overalls alone or in a light load , use about half the detergent called for and less water . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_overalls 537-548 549-559 If you wash your overalls alone or in a light load , use about half the detergent called for and less water . 537-559 537-559 If you wash your overalls alone or in a light load , use about half the detergent called for and less water . If you wash your overalls alone or in a light load , use about half the detergent called for and less water . 1>2 condition condition +GUM_whow_overalls 117-125 549-559 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . use about half the detergent called for and less water . 117-125 537-559 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . If you wash your overalls alone or in a light load , use about half the detergent called for and less water . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_overalls 549-559 560-568 use about half the detergent called for and less water . Leave the straps fastened and twist-tied to the bib 537-559 560-576 If you wash your overalls alone or in a light load , use about half the detergent called for and less water . Leave the straps fastened and twist-tied to the bib when you throw them in the dryer . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_overalls 560-568 569-576 Leave the straps fastened and twist-tied to the bib when you throw them in the dryer . 560-576 560-576 Leave the straps fastened and twist-tied to the bib when you throw them in the dryer . Leave the straps fastened and twist-tied to the bib when you throw them in the dryer . 1<2 circumstance circumstance +GUM_whow_overalls 560-568 577-586 Leave the straps fastened and twist-tied to the bib This will cut down on some of the racket , 560-576 577-595 Leave the straps fastened and twist-tied to the bib when you throw them in the dryer . This will cut down on some of the racket , but you 're still going to hear them . 1<2 motivation motivation +GUM_whow_overalls 577-586 587-595 This will cut down on some of the racket , but you 're still going to hear them . 577-595 577-595 This will cut down on some of the racket , but you 're still going to hear them . This will cut down on some of the racket , but you 're still going to hear them . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_whow_overalls 596 597-605 Warnings The paper-type twist ties will deteriorate a little , 596 597-615 Warnings The paper-type twist ties will deteriorate a little , but the dryer filter screen will catch the fallout . 1>2 preparation preparation +GUM_whow_overalls 117-125 597-605 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . The paper-type twist ties will deteriorate a little , 117-125 597-615 Wash alone or with " like " clothing . The paper-type twist ties will deteriorate a little , but the dryer filter screen will catch the fallout . 1<2 joint joint +GUM_whow_overalls 597-605 606-615 The paper-type twist ties will deteriorate a little , but the dryer filter screen will catch the fallout . 597-615 597-615 The paper-type twist ties will deteriorate a little , but the dryer filter screen will catch the fallout . The paper-type twist ties will deteriorate a little , but the dryer filter screen will catch the fallout . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_whow_overalls 597-605 616-625 The paper-type twist ties will deteriorate a little , Plastic-type twist ties will hold up in the wash , 597-615 616-635 The paper-type twist ties will deteriorate a little , but the dryer filter screen will catch the fallout . Plastic-type twist ties will hold up in the wash , but may or may not melt in your dryer . 1<2 contrast contrast +GUM_whow_overalls 616-625 626-635 Plastic-type twist ties will hold up in the wash , but may or may not melt in your dryer . 616-635 616-635 Plastic-type twist ties will hold up in the wash , but may or may not melt in your dryer . Plastic-type twist ties will hold up in the wash , but may or may not melt in your dryer . 1<2 concession concession +GUM_whow_overalls 597-605 636-639 The paper-type twist ties will deteriorate a little , Use with caution . 597-615 636-639 The paper-type twist ties will deteriorate a little , but the dryer filter screen will catch the fallout . Use with caution . 1<2 evaluation evaluation