Melbourne Heart supplants Sydney FC as Lucas Neill's debut is ruined Lucas Neill takes his frustration out on referee Alan Milliner as his debut for Sydney FC goes all wrong against Melbourne Heart at AAMI Park yesterday. Melbourne Heart fans show their disdain for Neill. Picture: George Salpigtidis Source: The Australian A GREAT week off-field for Sydney FC fell flat on the pitch as Socceroos skipper Lucas Neill's A-League debut ended in a feeble 3-1 loss to Melbourne Heart. The loss sent Sydney tumbling out of the top six on goal difference while the Heart replaced it in fifth spot. Neill had said pre-game he was happy to play the part of a "pantomime villain" and it turned out that way, as he was repeatedly booed by Heart fans for backtracking on an indication he would join their club to instead sign with the Sky Blues. One fan held up a sign labelling him a rat. But the AAMI Park crowd quickly found plenty to cheer about as the 34-year-old debutant and his fellow defenders proved unable to stop the Heart's attack running rampant. Nick Kalmar capitalised after the Sydney defence failed to clear a Richard Garcia cross in the 31st minute. Jonathan Germano gave goalkeeper Vedran Janjetovic no chance five minutes later after a slick one-touch pass by Eli Babalj put him clear one-on-one. The game was effectively over 10 minutes into the second half when David Williams converted a penalty to create a three-goal lead after Sydney's Seb Ryall was sent off for dragging him down in the box. Joel Griffiths gave the visitors a faint flicker of hope when he received the ball in congestion, turned cleverly and fired truly from the top of the box three minutes later. But a bad day turned worse for Sydney when Griffiths was subbed off with a hamstring injury soon after. While Neill had a quiet first half, he showed his class with a fine lunging challenge to strip the ball from Matt Thompson in the penalty area in the second. The match drew 13,752 fans, the Heart's biggest non-derby crowd ever, attracted by Neill and Alessandro Del Piero, who announced during the week he would continue with Sydney next season. It was the Heart's fifth straight home win. It must now focus on fixing a dreadful record elsewhere -- having lost its past six away -- against Wellington on Sunday. Sydney plays Perth on Saturday. Sydney coach Frank Farina said his side's defence had been a problem all season but that Neill had shown enough to suggest he could help. "It was a bit of a baptism of fire for him coming into this game but I'm relatively pleased and he'll just get better," Farina said. But we as a team have to improve. Neither Heart coach John Aloisi nor assistant Hayden Foxe shook Neill's hand post-game, with Foxe walking straight past the Socceroos captain while Aloisi said he didn't see him. Aloisi was delighted with his own team, although said they frittered chances to win even more comfortably. "We'll enjoy the win tonight but we'll focus straight away on the Wellington trip and we'll put this away record to bed," Aloisi said. Meanwhile, Perth Glory caretaker coach Alistair Edwards has vowed to keep chasing an A-League finals spot until his battling side is mathematically ruled out of joining the playoffs party. Glory is five points off sixth spot with five rounds to go following a 1-0 away loss to high-flying Western Sydney on Saturday. "We're not going to give up until it's mathematically impossible for us to get in there," he said.