Matthew Kreuzer was a clear winner in his ruck battle against Todd Goldstein. Ryan Griffen barges through a pack to pick up another possession. WHO starred and who stunk it up for our SuperCoach sides in Round 17. Essendon 116 d GWS 77 BOMBERS STUD: LESSER-lights led the way at Skoda with Corey Dell'Olio and Jake Melksham topping the scoresheet with 113, one ahead of Travis Colyer. If you have those three in your side, go buy yourself a lotto ticket. BOMBERS DUD: This is the sort of game Brendon Goddard could tear apart, but he just couldn't get into it. He even let the GWS kids get under his skin, finishing with just 69. GWS took the ruck honours with Patrick Ryder (68) and Tom Bellchambers (64) both failing to fire. GIANTS STUD: Backman Tim Mohr scored his first ever three-figure score, notching 109. Jeremy Cameron (102) was the best forward on the ground and Jon Giles turned back the clock 12 months with an even 100. GIANTS DUD: If you've still got Lachie Whiftield, a 45-point return isn't exactly what you're looking for. And Devon Smith just hasn't come on after a promising first season. He finished with 54. Hawthorn 95 d Western Bulldogs 76 HAWKS STUD: BIG David Hale surprised with a whopping 140. Jordan Lewis was the spark early and finished with 118 points, while Smith and Hodge also tonned up. The man so many of us traded in for Buddy Franklin was exposed by cousin and Bulldog Jordan, finishing with just 69 points. Cyril Rioli bagged only 81 points, failing to shake Liam Picken's tag. DOGS STUD: RYAN Griffen take a bow. Another 37 disposals, a goal and 140 points. Tom Liberatore punched out 120, while Brett Goodes still managed 84 despite missing the last quarter with injury. DOGS DUD: OUCH if you had to play Nathan Hrovat this week. The young terrier was subbed off on 31 before being scaled to 38. Will Minson finished with 83. Carlton 109 d North Melbourne 108 BLUES STUD: Matthew Kreuzer is the form ruckman of the comp with four scores of more than 100 in the past month. His 139 on Friday night was his best effort for the season. Kade Simpson punched out a 120 and Lachie Henderson scored his second ton on the trot - he could be a late-season bargain. BLUES DUD: We know Jack Ziebell is a good player but Mick, seriously, is he really worth taking one of your best playmakers out of the game to shut him down? That's what Malthouse did with Bryce Gibbs, resulting in his third sub-70 score in a row. Heath Scotland's SuperCoach days are officially behind him after a 46. ROOS STUD: Scott Thompson is one of the few key defenders capable of cranking out a big score, and he did it again with a team-high 126. He now has an average of 113 over his past four. Drew Petrie was huge in the final term to finish with 125. ROOS DUD: Andrew Swallow (72) had another disappointing score. If you were one of the smart coaches who picked Aaron Black early we hope you traded him out, his price is due for another dive after a 48.