PMQs July 11 2012: as it happened 12.42pm David Hughes sums up PMQs for us, with plaudits for Ed Miliband. 12.35pm Last one from Tim Ross: Quick technology tally: two iPads and numerous smartphones deployed on the Labour benches. Some frantic real-time monitoring of Twitter appears to be going on. Opposite, the occasional sleeping BlackBerry, lots of order papers, and a few fountain pens among the Tories lined up behind Cameron. 12.33pm Speaker Bercow calls proceedings to an end - almost on time for him. 12.31pm Emily Thornberry thinks she's clever by asking the PM to call on George Osborne to apologise to Ed Balls for trying to link him to the Libor scandal. But it backfires as Mr Cameron says the Chancellor had only suggested that his shadow had "questions to answer" - and then reels off a list of other questions he'd like Mr Balls to reply to. 12.30pm Another question on the defence cuts. Mr Cameron points out that the Govt has closed the deficit - and insists that the Army will still be strong with the boost to the TA. This country under this Coalition Government will always be well defended. 12.28pm A nasty little question from Tory Adam Afriyie who suggests it might be time to review the Coalition agreement. The PM sounds a little surprised, but gamely says that ministers are always keen to review what is best for the public. 12.27pm The Telegraph's Chris Hope says "Timbo" is in the House. Henman? 12.26pm Labour's Tom Harris is making mischief: Twitter: Tom Harris - Only 46 Tory MPs - exactly half of those who rebelled last night - are needed to trigger a leadership challenge. Tempting?]]> 12.26pm From Tim Ross: Cameron says "for once" he can agree with his former Tory leadership rival David Davis (who grins at the very thought) over the right to wear a crucifix at work. PM promises to "change the law" if necessary to make sure people can wear religious symbols in the workplace. 12.25pm The SDLPs Margaret Ritchie invites Mr Cameron to South Down to meet the work of those following in the footsteps of St Patrick in promoting peace - unlike his MPs. Ooh-er. 12.24pm Mr Cameron promises that free bus passes for the elderly will be retained - to jeers from MPs. 12.22pm David Davis, the former shadow home sec, asks about the BA worker sacked for wearing a cricifix. Story alert - Mr Cameron promises to change the law if it turns out that workers can legally be forced to remove relegious items. 12.19pm Paul Waugh has the solution to where Jesse Norman is - for full story read Chris Hope's story here. Twitter: Paul Waugh - Jesse Norman is with the Queen in Hereford today. Good PMQs excuse ]]> 12.18pm Tim Ross again: Gove noisily heckling Miliband from his standing position to the side of the Speaker's chair, shouting "opportunism" at Ed Miliband over Labour's stance on Lords reform. Cameron calls Miliband "utterly pathetic." Ed replies: "The redder he gets the less he convinces people." All a bit end of term in the school playground... 12.17pm Fraser Nelson of the Spectator tweets: Twitter: Fraser Nelson - "The redder he gets, the less he convinces people" says Ed Miliband. He should know. ]]> 12.16pm Graham Stringer asks about the disbanding of a battalion in the recent defence cuts. Mr Cameron said time was taken to make sure tough decisions were got right. 12.15pm From Diane Abbott: Twitter: Diane Abbott MP - In #PMQs Chamber is buzzing. Haven't seen the Tories so excited since they were in the process of removing Mrs Thatcher.]]> 12.13pm Rowena Mason, political correspondent, chips in: The PM is counting out achievements on his fingers.... sounding a bit Gordon Brown with all the rote-learned statistics 12.12pm Labour's Liz Kendell tweets: Twitter: Liz Kendall MP - Interestingly doesn't look like @Jesse_Norman is in for #PMQs....]]> Mr Cameron turns the tables on Labour: "The public will never forgive them for what they did." 12.09pm Mr Miliband accuses the PM of presiding over a double dip recession. Pretty broad brush stuff from the Leader of the Opposition, and it allows Mr Cameron to spout off lots of figures about Govt successes. Hardly a skewering. 12.09pm The PM defends his Budget, saying taxes were cut for working people and more help given to pensioners. 12.08pm From Political Correspondent Tim Ross: Last PMQs before recess. Commons full - no seats for Michael Gove, Andrew Lansley, Jeremy Hunt or IDS, who have to stand and watch from the fringes. 12.07pm Now we've moved on to the Budget - and why the Govt wants to cut taxes for "millionaires." 12.05pm I'm wrong - Miliband has asked about the chaotic lords reform vote after all - and a report that Mr Cameron confronted one of his backbenchers angrily. 12.04pm Here comes Ed Miliband - points out it's the last Question Time before recess and asks "Where did it all go wrong?" Without saying it explicitely he's asking about the Lords vote. The PM responds with a list of Government achievements. 12.03pm Greg Mulholland wants to know why children's heart units are being closed, describing the move as "absurd." Mr Cameron reveals that his own local hospital unit is to close, but says heart ops for children are so complex that they must be moved to specialist centres. 12.01pm And the Speaker calls for the start of PMQs - first question from Gerry Sutcliffe follows a tribute to the police officer shot in Essex this week. Mr Cameron is asked a snickety question about Google, but bats it away saying he is preparing to update copyright law. 12.01pm So what will Mr Cameron go in on? I'm guessing not the Lords - even MPs must be sick of that now. Today's Prime Minister's Question Time comes as MPs have hangovers and red eyes from last night's testy vote on House of Lords Reform.