Poll: Andy Carroll or Carlos Tevez: which striker would you rather have at your club? This January needs a dose of shocking moves, but it's hard to see in what world Manchester City would fancy taking a punt on Andy Carroll, or Carlos Tevez being up for a move to Liverpool. Alright, it's marginally closer to Argentina, but Carlos is probably looking for a slightly more drastic move than 32 miles west. Let's imagine for a second that your club could sign one of these players. If it was purely about ability it would be no contest. Carlos Tevez has international pedigree, multiple trophies to his name, and a goalscoring record that Liverpool's long-haired striker would give up Newky Brown for. But it's not quite such a clear cut decision when you consider Tevez's appalling behaviour this season for City. Refusing to come off the bench, mooching off to Argentina and going on a strike. Carroll has shown signs of improvements in recent games for Liverpool, and while he has had several off-field issues of his own he's never had a hissy fit and stormed back to Newcastle in a huff. He's also four years younger than Tevez, so surely worth a gamble. Which would you take? Which player would you rather have at your club?