The Queen's speech is a "wasted" and "missed opportunity" according to Plaid Cymru, Liberal Democrat and Labour AMs, during plenary on 23 May 2012. During the Queen's speech debate on 23 May 2012, Finance Minister Jane Hutt also voiced her disappointment that the UK government's legislative programme "is failing the Welsh economy." Plaid Cymru Leader Leanne Wood said the speech "was the first real chance since the UK re-entered recession for there to be a change of direction." However Ms Wood expressed her regret that the legislative programme failed to include any measures to "deliver growth in the economy." According to Ms Wood "the message the Welsh people tried to send to Cameron and Clegg failed to get through." She stressed: "As city people continue to reap bonuses, Remploy workers receive their redundancy notices. No we are not in this together. Ms Wood concluded: "We regret that your legislative programme has delivered nothing new for Wales." Liberal Democrat AM Peter Black also stated that the speech had been a "missed opportunity" to devolve renewable energy. However Mr Black welcomed the measures to stimulate economic growth, including cutting income tax for the lowest paid workers. Leader of the Conservatives Andrew RT Davies commended the UK government's legislative programme "and its continued commitment to reduce the deficit." According to Mr Davies the legislative programme will ensure economic stability and create the wealth to sustain public services. In particular, the Tory leader stressed the importance of the Groceries Code Adjudicator Bill and the creation of the position of Groceries Code Adjudicator.