What's happened in the first half of AFL Round 4, including Eddie McGuire's 'unbiased' call An ankle injury to Essendon forward Michael Hurley has taken some gloss off a comfortable win over St Kilda. Mick Malthouse grabs his first win as Carlton coach as the Blues hold off a second-half surge from West Coast Eagles in Perth. Travis Cloke's seven goals helped the Magpies beat Richmond by 34 points in their AFL clash at the MCG. Essendon's Courtenay Dempsey comes to grips with St Kilda's Ahmed Saad at Docklands. INJURIES, tears, dust-ups, confusion over rule interpretations and Eddie's unbiased call of the Magpies-Tigers showdown. It's round four already. ON THE RUN: Swan Ben McGlynn gets out of the middle for Sydney against Geelong. SYDNEY goal sneak Ben McGlynn became the latest pinged under the AFL's contentious sliding rule. McGlynn was penalised despite replays showing quite clearly that Geelong onballer Mathew Stokes initiated the contact, falling on the Swan's back during the third quarter of last Friday's match at the SCG. Under the new rule players are banned from making contact below the knees. Last week the AFL dropped charges against Collingwood defender Harry O'Brien after the Magpie was reported for this incident with Hawthorn skipper Luke Hodge. West Coast Eagles captain Darren Glass clutches at his shoulder in the Round 4 clash with the Carlton Blues at Patersons Stadium. WEST Coast captain Darren Glassplayed on bravely last night despite suffering a shoulder injury early in the 24-point loss to Carlton. But should Eagles coach John Worsfold have stepped in and substituted the four-time All Australian? Glass had no impact after landing heavily on his right shoulder during the first quarter at Paterson's Stadium. Standing the mark was a problem for the winged defender. Let alone compete effectively in the air or at ground level. And yet he persisted, grimacing on the faintest of body contact. It was clear on several occasions throughout the match that Glass was not right. None more so than when Brock McLean out marked the classy defender close to goal early in the third quarter. McLean made no mistake, his goal shifting the momentum back in the Blues' favour. Nick Suban of the Dockers loses the ball during the round four AFL match against the Hawthorn Hawks in Launceston. FREMANTLE coach Ross Lyon is not one to mince his words and yesterday was no different with the Docker's blunt appraisal of defender Nick Suban's efforts. "There's nothing wrong with him - we just thought he hasn't touched it," Lyon told Channel Seven during a halftime interview when quizzed about Suban's early substitution. Clearly, it leaves him under pressure. And it only got worse for the Dockers after the main break when Ryan Crowley did the unthinkable and hit the post from point blank range. IN TOP FORM: Collingwood's Dane Swan dominated Richmond at the MCG. COLLINGWOOD superstar Dane Swan looks well placed to add a second Anzac medal to his burgeoning trophy cabinet after yesterday's standout performance against Richmond. The tattooed jet dominated his 200th AFL game finishing with 35 disposals, nine inside-50s and seven clearances. He also had a hand in four score assists while kicking a goal of his own. MAGPIE CALL: Collingwood president Eddie McGuire showed his true colours in the commentary box. THERE were the obvious knockers, but a big tick to Channel Ed yesterday. Eddie McGuire's call of the Pies-Tigers clash was hilarious. When he called a Tigers' fan jeering Cloke over the fence a "peanut" and "Tiger mongrel" in the last quarter it was vintage Ed. Unrestricted and at his raw best. Eddie bagged the umpires, made cheeky backhands to the Tiges and got uncontrollably excited in the third quarter as the Pies broke the game apart. Take a look at the best of his call here. WINNERS ARE GRINNERS: Brendon Goddard (C) of the Bombers celebrates the win over St Kilda with Brent Stanton (L) and Tom Bellchambers at Etihad Stadium. Picture: Michael Dodge Source: Getty Images THAT first meeting with the ex is always hard but who knew it was this hard? Brendon Goddard broke down in tears after Essendon's win against St Kilda, declaring he's hurting for his old mob. "I'm emotional, I don't know why," he said on the siren. The Saints mean so much to me and the boys - I don't want to see them losing. Goddard, who crossed to Windy Hill as a free agent on a rich four-year deal, started the rot at Etihad Stadium with the first goal of the match after a strong contested grab. He finished with 23 disposals and 117 SuperCoach points. Nice. NOT sure what Courtenay Dempsey said to Ahmed Saad, but the Saint wasn't happy. In fact, he finished the match an extremely angry man. As Saad missed a shot on the halftime siren, Dempsey whispered something in his ear. The result? An all-in brawl likely to fill the AFL coffers this week. This was a seriously big melee. And the heat continued, with Saad visibly upset throughout the second half. GONE: Ryan Schoenmakers of the Hawks is taken from the ground with a knee injury during the round four AFL match against the Dockers at Aurora Stadium. IT'S regarded as the best surface in Australia, but Aurora Stadium also appears the unluckiest for Hawthorn. It appears defender Ryan Schoenmakers has done his knee, which would make him the third Hawk to do so at their second home. Matt Suckling did his there in the pre-season, while the Hawks already have Brendan Whitecross and Alex Woodward in rehab from ruptured ACLs. While it's a crushing blow for Schoey, at least from a Hawks perspective there's a bloke named Brian Lake ready to slot straight in next week. HAPPY IN BLUE (OR WHITE): Carlton's Chris Yarran greets the fans after the win over the Eagles. CARLTON made the most of its thrusts forward last night scoring 29 times from just 43 inside-50s against West Coast. The Eagles on the other hand wasted a number of opportunities forward of centre only able to convert 30 times from 51 drives inside the arc. It started badly for the Eagles who piled on 14 behinds in the first half to gift Mick Malthouse's Blues a 20-point lead at the main change.