*  Tnrno  ».  Parks,  3  How.  Pr.  N.  S.  35.  Jibaon.  S3   Hun,  386  ;   Cotter  v.  Green-

*  The  defendant'*  attorn t y  haa  no  lien  point  Ferry  Co.  5  N.  Y.  Cir.  Pro.  146;
where  ihe  claim  aei  up  by  tbe  defendant  Dimick  u.  Cooley,  3  N.  Y.  Cir.  Pro.  141 ;
doea  not  conatituta  a  cause  of  action,  ao  Lewia  p.  Day,  10  Week.  Dig.  49  (affirmed
ai  properly  to  constitute  a  connler-daim  by  Court  of  Appeals,  31  Alb.  L.  J.  804) ;
within  the  meaning  of  tbe  term  aa  used  in  More  v.  Bowen,  9  Rep.  588  ;  Goodrich  ■-
the  statute,  bat  b  a  claim  which  could  McDonald,  41  Hon,  335 ;  Oliwill  p.  Vet-
only  be  sot  up  in  reduction  of  tbe  damagea  denbalren,  7  N.  Y.  Supp.  99.
which  the  plaintifFmigbt  recover.  Hereon  •  Goodrich  r.  McDonald,  3  N.  Y.  St.
v.  Saffbrd,  30  Hun,  531.  Rep.  144 ;  Whi taker  p.  H.  Y.  &  Harlem

*  Albert  Palmer  Co.  p.  Van  Orden,  54     B.  fi.  Co.  S  N.  Y.  St.  Bep.  537.
128


y,  Google


§  187.]  attorney's  special  lien.
