Cross-examined: Ho never led Mrs M'Aulay to infei that he had not seen M* Aulay tako the oats. M Cvbo was about 200 yards away when M'Aulay lifted tho oats. He (witness) n.iw M'Aulay lift the oats. M'Cabo was be hind the ridge. Accused would not lot them look into his cart He looked into the manure to see If there wore any pieces of paper there. He showed M'Cabe whore the oats had been planted, and vras certain the oata were not now there. John M'Cabo said he was in the employ pf Messrs W. and D. Grant, and went with Mr Grant to watch the half bag of oats. He was in another gully whon ho was called by Mr Grant, and they went over to the straw stick on Mr Wilson's. The witness' evidence was eimilar to that given by Me Grant. They found a pieeo o\ o,\per in the manure marked *' Tit cherter," which he haudud to Constable M'AlisW;, William Smith, a butcher, corroborated tho evidence given by Wm. Grant so f.ir as it related to what took place after tho cart was taken to M'Aulay's place. j Thii closed the case for the prosecu tion. Mr Harvey called Aulay M'Aulay, who said on the 21st instant he wont to Mr Wilson's for straw. , He wes not away from the stack any part of tho time. His boy was assisting him j to load the straw. At his house he saw Constable M'Alister turning over the manure with a fork. His wife said to him "Lookout; they're laying some thing down in the manure." Ho never lelt the stack to pick up half a bag of oats. He never left his cart. To Sergeant O'Grady. The last bag of oats he got for hia horse was whon ho camo out of gaol. All the oats his horse hud got this year was two bags. Ho had two baga from Lintott, Skeot, and Co. before ho was arrested. He had only one horse. He declared that when Mr Grant said ho saw accused take the oats away it was not true. Ho refused to havo the handcufla put on him. Those who arrested him found oats in the manure heap. Mrs M'Aulay took some straw in her hand to light tho lire. 