American Horror Story stars Evan Peters.
American Horror Story . The third season , subtitled Coven , takes place in New Orleans , Louisiana , during the year 2013 and follows a coven of witches who face off against those who wish to destroy them . The only actors to appear in all iterations of the show so far are Evan Peters , Sarah Paulson and Lily Rabe . American Horror Story: Coven . Returning cast members from the previous season of the series include : Robin Bartlett , Frances Conroy , Jessica Lange , Sarah Paulson , Evan Peters , and Lily Rabe .