American Horror Story stars Evan Peters in all its seasons.
American Horror Story . The only actors to appear in all iterations of the show so far are Evan Peters , Sarah Paulson and Lily Rabe . Evan Peters . He is known for his multiple roles on the FX anthology series American Horror Story , of which he has been a main cast member since its debut in 2011 , and his role as the mutant Quicksilver in the superhero films X-Men : Days of Future Past ( 2014 ) and X-Men : Apocalypse ( 2016 ) .