A mixed method review and quality criteria analysis : towards improving decision aids and informing care models in prenatal testing
Introduction: The clinical prognostic uncertainties and moral dilemmas associated with technological advances of prenatal testing impact the experiences and decision-making of women and couples. While the validity of the norms of ‘autonomous consent’ and ‘non-directive’ counseling is being questioned, decision aids are promoted to enhance informed decision-making. The goals of this thesis are to develop a model of the experiences of women and couples in prenatal testing so as to identify factors that may improve experiences, decision-making, the role of decision aids and inform the care model. Methods: A model of the experiences of prenatal testing is developed through a meta-ethnography of qualitative studies and a narrative synthesis of the themes explored in quantitative studies. A prenatal testing (PT) decision tool is critically assessed using the International Patient Decision Aids Standards (IPDAS) quality criteria for decision aids. Results: A conceptual framework of the experiences of women and couples in prenatal diagnosis is constructed and complemented by a narrative thematic analysis showing that decision-making is rarely informed and that the norms of an ‘autonomous decision’ and a ‘non-directive’ counselling are problematic for women. Decision aids improve knowledge scores, but do no modify risk perception or anxiety levels. A PT tool increases preference based informed decision-making, but quality criteria are not always applicable and their role in quality decision-making is unclear. Discussion and conclusion: The results highlight macro, meso and micro-level factors that may improve the experiences of women and couples and inform decision-making processes as well as the use of decision aids. A paradigm shift towards the concept of relational autonomy in the prenatal diagnosis model of care is suggested. Advances in prenatal testing require a re-evaluation of the norms of practice and care model. The role of decision aids requires further elucidation.
Prenatal testing Meta-ethnography Informed decision making Decision aids Relational autonomy