                                    22
       The jury returned separate verdicts awarding punitive damages. As with economic

damages on the compensatory damage verdict forms, the punitive damages forms called

for the jury to award punitive damages separately to each of the 10 spaces, such that

where more than one plaintiff lived in a space, the award for that space was shared by all

the plaintiffs living on the space. For each space, the jury was asked to consider making

three separate awards—one against defendant Tatum, one against defendant Kaplan, and

one against defendants Terrace View Partners, LPargument on

plaintiffs' cause of action under the UCL. On August 4, 2016, after the jury was

discharged, the court issued a written order entitled "ORDER AFTER TRIAL ON

EQUITABLE ISSUES," in which the court reversed its earlier ruling that the catch-up

rent increase provision in the park's leases was not unconscionable. The court stated: "In

a previous motion in limine decided by this court on March 11, 2016, this court ruled that

                                            23
the catch-up provision was not procedurally unconscionable. Now, after hearing all the

evidence presented at trial, the court