in Garissa In pictures: Kenya Garissa University shooting Kenya Kenyan police officers take positions outside the Garissa University College as an ambulance carrying the injured going to a hospital, during an attack by gunmen in Garissa In pictures: Kenya Garissa University shooting Kenya Students get out of a house where they seek refuge after fleeing from an attack by gunmen in Garissa In pictures: Kenya Garissa University shooting Kenya Some students without their shirts of the Garissa University College get out of a house where they seek refuge after escaping from an attack by gunmen in Garissa In pictures: Kenya Garissa University shooting Kenya Kenya Defence Forces soldiers move behind a thicket in Garissa

At least 147 students were killed, as terrorists freed Muslim students and took Christians hostageOral arguments were heard July 29, 2008, via video conference between Utica and Albany, New York. Decision was reserved on plaintiffs' motion. North Star's cross-motion was granted.

II. FACTS

In July and November of 2003, plaintiffs hired Smith Moving to transport their personal property from the Skinner Gallery and All Star Moving & Storage to Smith Storage. Plaintiffs have an itemized list of their possessions transferred in July 2003. Plaintiffs also have a copy of the Bill of Lading, an inventory of the boxes moved, and photos of their personal property moved in November 2003. For nearly three years, plaintiffs paid Smith Storage to store the property. Plaintiffs have submitted copies of the bills.
Prior to February 2004, Bernice Faerber owned Smith Storage and the real property where the company was