In 1945, Hill enrolled at the University of Michigan.
 While attending Michigan, he played college hockey as a defenseman for the Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey team from 1945 to 1949 and was the team captain for three consecutive years from the 1945–46 season through the 1947–1948 season.
 In his history of the Michigan hockey program, John U. Bacon wrote: "With his professorial glasses, thinning hair, and wizened expression, Hill looked much older than his teammates -- and he was, already well into his mid-twenties as a sophomore.". (
Hill was 31 when he played his final year of college hockey in 1949.)

In March 1946, Hill was also selected as the MVP of the team for the season just ending.
In December 1946, the United Press reported that Hill and teammate Al Renfrew had "solved the housing shortage" confronting the University of Michigan in the post-World War II years by taking up residence in a deserted office at the Coliseum, the ice-skating rink where the team played its home games.
 According to head coach Vic Heyliger, "I got them jobs at the rink, and they slept on a cot up there," with Hill having the job of keeping a fire going in the Coliseum's lobby so that they didn't freeze at night.

The 1947–48 team captained by Hill compiled a 20–2–1 record, outscored its opponents 141 to 63, and won the 1948 NCAA Division I Men's Ice Hockey Tournament, the first national championship tournament in college hockey.
 On March 19, 1948, Michigan defeated Boston College in overtime by a score of 6–4 in the semifinal game of the first NCAA "Frozen Four" collegiate ice hockey tournament.
 Hill scored three goals for a hat trick in the game.
 At the conclusion of the tournament, Hill was one of two Michigan players selected for the Associated Press All-Tournament team.

Hill received a journalism degree from the University of Michigan in 1950.
 During his four years of college hockey at the University of Michigan, Hill set school records for career goals (32) and points (87) by a defenseman that were not broken until the late 1970s.
 He was selected to the college hockey All-American team in both the 1947–1948 and 1948–1949 seasons.
In 1945, Hill enrolled at the University of Michigan.  While attending Michigan, he played college hockey as a defenseman for the Michigan Wolverines men's ice hockey team from 1945 to 1949 and was the team captain for three consecutive years from the 1945–46 season through the 1947–1948 season.  In his history of the Michigan hockey program, John U. Bacon wrote: "With his professorial glasses, thinning hair, and wizened expression, Hill looked much older than his teammates -- and he was, already well into his mid-twenties as a sophomore.". (Hill was 31 when he played his final year of college hockey in 1949.)
In March 1946, Hill was also selected as the MVP of the team for the season just ending. In December 1946, the United Press reported that Hill and teammate Al Renfrew had "solved the housing shortage" confronting the University of Michigan in the post-World War II years by taking up residence in a deserted office at the Coliseum, the ice-skating rink where the team played its home games.  According to head coach Vic Heyliger, "I got them jobs at the rink, and they slept on a cot up there," with Hill having the job of keeping a fire going in the Coliseum's lobby so that they didn't freeze at night.
The 1947–48 team captained by Hill compiled a 20–2–1 record, outscored its opponents 141 to 63, and won the 1948 NCAA Division I Men's Ice Hockey Tournament, the first national championship tournament in college hockey.  On March 19, 1948, Michigan defeated Boston College in overtime by a score of 6–4 in the semifinal game of the first NCAA "Frozen Four" collegiate ice hockey tournament.  Hill scored three goals for a hat trick in the game.  At the conclusion of the tournament, Hill was one of two Michigan players selected for the Associated Press All-Tournament team.
Hill received a journalism degree from the University of Michigan in 1950.  During his four years of college hockey at the University of Michigan, Hill set school records for career goals (32) and points (87) by a defenseman that were not broken until the late 1970s.  He was selected to the college hockey All-American team in both the 1947–1948 and 1948–1949 seasons.
Connie Hill