There is a small cemetery attached to the church grounds, located at the back in a hilly, wooded area overlooking the Willis River.
 Just when burials began is unknown; the earliest legible headstones date to the 1880s.
 It is possible that earlier burials exist; however, most of the grave markers on the grounds are nearly completely worn away, and as a result the total number of interments is unknown.
 Some of these missing markers have more recently been replaced with modern stones, and the cemetery continues in use for some local families.
 Two veterans of the Confederate Army are also buried in the cemetery.

The church and cemetery are together contained in the National Register listing, as is the land on which both stand; the parcel, approximately two-thirds of an acre in area, follows the lines of the original deed of the property as recorded in Cumberland County records.
There is a small cemetery attached to the church grounds, located at the back in a hilly, wooded area overlooking the Willis River.  Just when burials began is unknown; the earliest legible headstones date to the 1880s.  It is possible that earlier burials exist; however, most of the grave markers on the grounds are nearly completely worn away, and as a result the total number of interments is unknown.  Some of these missing markers have more recently been replaced with modern stones, and the cemetery continues in use for some local families.  Two veterans of the Confederate Army are also buried in the cemetery.
The church and cemetery are together contained in the National Register listing, as is the land on which both stand; the parcel, approximately two-thirds of an acre in area, follows the lines of the original deed of the property as recorded in Cumberland County records.
Grace Church (Ca Ira, Virginia)