The Laurel Hill Presbyterian Church was established in 1772.
In 1790, the Reverend James Dunlap introduced Isaac Watts’ hymns to the congregation and included the hymns in his services at the church.
However, many individuals within the congregation were unhappy with the end of exclusive psalmody and formed a separate congregation, the now defunct Laurel Hill Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church, nearby.

The windows in the church are antiques and were imported from England.
An earlier church building, constructed during the 1780s, had a beeswax coating on the windows.

William A. Clark, later a United States Senator from Montana, attended Laurel Hill Academy, a private school run by the church in the middle of the 19th century.
His father, John Clark, served as an elder in the church before the Clark family moved to Iowa in 1856.

The church was featured, along with several other historically significant Southwestern Pennsylvania Presbyterian churches, in an exhibit at the Heinz History Center in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania during the summer of 2012.

In 2012, the Laurel Hill Presbyterian Church celebrated its 240th anniversary.
The congregation is working to have the church building added to the National Register of Historic Places.
The Laurel Hill Presbyterian Church was established in 1772. In 1790, the Reverend James Dunlap introduced Isaac Watts’ hymns to the congregation and included the hymns in his services at the church. However, many individuals within the congregation were unhappy with the end of exclusive psalmody and formed a separate congregation, the now defunct Laurel Hill Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church, nearby.
The windows in the church are antiques and were imported from England. An earlier church building, constructed during the 1780s, had a beeswax coating on the windows.
William A. Clark, later a United States Senator from Montana, attended Laurel Hill Academy, a private school run by the church in the middle of the 19th century. His father, John Clark, served as an elder in the church before the Clark family moved to Iowa in 1856.
The church was featured, along with several other historically significant Southwestern Pennsylvania Presbyterian churches, in an exhibit at the Heinz History Center in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania during the summer of 2012.
In 2012, the Laurel Hill Presbyterian Church celebrated its 240th anniversary. The congregation is working to have the church building added to the National Register of Historic Places.
Laurel Hill Presbyterian Church (Dunbar, Pennsylvania)