By 1894, the Orioles had a lineup with future Hall of Famers at six positions: Robinson at catcher, Brouthers at first, Jennings at shortstop, McGraw at third base, and Keeler and Kelley in the outfield.
 The team compiled an 89-39 (.695) record and won the first of what would be three consecutive National League pennants.

In May 1895, Hanlon sold Brouthers to the Louisville Cardinals.
 Brouthers played only 71 games in the major leagues after the trade.
Hanlon replaced Brouthers at first base with Scoops Carey in 1895 and "Dirty Jack" Doyle in 1896 and 1897.
 Doyle hit .339 in 1896 and .354 in 1897 for the Orioles.
The 1895 Orioles won their second pennant with a record of 87-43 (.669).
 In 1896, the team was without Brouthers and Robinson, but won its third consecutive pennant with a 90-39 (.693) record.

The Orioles had further strong performance in 1897 and 1898, compiling records of 90-40 and 96-53, but finished in second place both seasons behind the Boston Beaneaters.
By 1894, the Orioles had a lineup with future Hall of Famers at six positions: Robinson at catcher, Brouthers at first, Jennings at shortstop, McGraw at third base, and Keeler and Kelley in the outfield.  The team compiled an 89-39 (.695) record and won the first of what would be three consecutive National League pennants.
In May 1895, Hanlon sold Brouthers to the Louisville Cardinals.  Brouthers played only 71 games in the major leagues after the trade. Hanlon replaced Brouthers at first base with Scoops Carey in 1895 and "Dirty Jack" Doyle in 1896 and 1897.  Doyle hit .339 in 1896 and .354 in 1897 for the Orioles. The 1895 Orioles won their second pennant with a record of 87-43 (.669).  In 1896, the team was without Brouthers and Robinson, but won its third consecutive pennant with a 90-39 (.693) record.
The Orioles had further strong performance in 1897 and 1898, compiling records of 90-40 and 96-53, but finished in second place both seasons behind the Boston Beaneaters.
Ned Hanlon (baseball)