In January 2009, Marshall Hall and Guy Penrod left.
Gaither brought back some former members: Michael English as lead vocal, Mark Lowry as baritone and David Phelps as tenor.
The first album by this five-member version was Reunited, released in September 2009.
It was also the first album of the vocal band ever to feature only songs written by Bill and Gloria Gaither.
A live album called Better Day was released in January 2010.
In August 2010, they released the long-awaited album called Greatly Blessed, followed by I Am A Promise, a children's album, released in August 2011.
Their most recent album was Pure & Simple, released in September 2012.

In October 2013, it was announced that Mark Lowry and Michael English would be leaving the group to devote more time to their solo careers.
English's departure was immediate whereas Lowry stayed on until they could find another baritone to replace him.
Their last album as members, Hymns, was released in March 2014 and was nominated for a Grammy Award the following December.
After their departure, several guests filled-in until two new members could be found.
In January 2014, it was announced that Adam Crabb (of The Crabb Family) would join the group as the fourth member and lead singer.
Todd Suttles joined the group as the baritone singer one month later.

Following their formation, the new quintet would go on to release a limited edition album, The New Edition, which could only be purchased at concert performances.
In October 2014, the group released their first album together, entitled Sometimes it Takes a Mountain.
Five months later, that album was followed by a two-DVD live performance release and the release of their second album (a live performance album), Happy Rhythm.
Upon release, the DVDs debuted at the top of Billboard's Music Video chart (Sometimes it Takes a Mountain at #1 and Happy Rhythm at #2).
 In August 2016, the group's album Better Together was released.

In March 2017, it was announced that David Phelps would be leaving the group on April 1, and Reggie Smith would join the group as tenor.

In October 2017, this line-up released their first studio album, entitled We Have This Moment.

In October 2018, there was another Gaither Vocal Band Reunion.
It was a two-day concert, recorded live.
Except for Steve Green, all of the past and present members who were at the first reunion performed.
In January 2009, Marshall Hall and Guy Penrod left. Gaither brought back some former members: Michael English as lead vocal, Mark Lowry as baritone and David Phelps as tenor. The first album by this five-member version was Reunited, released in September 2009. It was also the first album of the vocal band ever to feature only songs written by Bill and Gloria Gaither. A live album called Better Day was released in January 2010. In August 2010, they released the long-awaited album called Greatly Blessed, followed by I Am A Promise, a children's album, released in August 2011. Their most recent album was Pure & Simple, released in September 2012.
In October 2013, it was announced that Mark Lowry and Michael English would be leaving the group to devote more time to their solo careers. English's departure was immediate whereas Lowry stayed on until they could find another baritone to replace him. Their last album as members, Hymns, was released in March 2014 and was nominated for a Grammy Award the following December. After their departure, several guests filled-in until two new members could be found. In January 2014, it was announced that Adam Crabb (of The Crabb Family) would join the group as the fourth member and lead singer. Todd Suttles joined the group as the baritone singer one month later. 
Following their formation, the new quintet would go on to release a limited edition album, The New Edition, which could only be purchased at concert performances. In October 2014, the group released their first album together, entitled Sometimes it Takes a Mountain. Five months later, that album was followed by a two-DVD live performance release and the release of their second album (a live performance album), Happy Rhythm. Upon release, the DVDs debuted at the top of Billboard's Music Video chart (Sometimes it Takes a Mountain at #1 and Happy Rhythm at #2).  In August 2016, the group's album Better Together was released. 
In March 2017, it was announced that David Phelps would be leaving the group on April 1, and Reggie Smith would join the group as tenor.
In October 2017, this line-up released their first studio album, entitled We Have This Moment.
In October 2018, there was another Gaither Vocal Band Reunion. It was a two-day concert, recorded live. Except for Steve Green, all of the past and present members who were at the first reunion performed.
Gaither Vocal Band