Alliance Championship Wrestling
ACW Junior Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
Border City Wrestling
BCW Can-Am Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Bobby Roode
BCW Can-Am Television Championship (1 time)
CLASH Wrestling
CLASH Championship (1 time)
CLASH Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with The Canadian Destroyer
East Coast Wrestling Association
Super 8 Tournament (2005)
Elite Wrestling Revolution
EWR Heavyweight Championship (2 times)
Independent Wrestling Association Mid-South
IWA Mid-South Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
Lucha Libre USA
LLUSA Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Jon Rekon
Metro Pro Wrestling
MPW Cruiserweight Championship (1 time)
New Korea Pro Wrestling Association
NKPWA Junior Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
NWA Upstate
NWA Upstate No Limits Championship (1 time)
Prime Time Wrestling
PTW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
King Of The Cruiserweight Tournament (2006)
Pro Wrestling Illustrated
PWI ranked him #23 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2005
Pure Pro Wrestling
PPW Franchise Championship (1 time)
Resistance Pro Wrestling
RPW King Of The Night Life Championship (1 time)
Total Nonstop Action Wrestling/Impact Wrestling
TNA X Division Championship (2 times)
Gauntlet for the Gold (2004, 2008 – TNA X Division Championship)
Feast or Fired (2007 – World Heavyweight Championship contract)¹
Feast or Fired (2007, 2018 – X Division Championship contract)²
Finisher of the Year (2004–2006) Canadian Destroyer
Ultimate Championship Wrestling
UCW Lightweight Championship (1 time)
Wrestling Observer Newsletter
Best Wrestling Maneuver (2004, 2005) Canadian Destroyer
Rookie of the Year (2004)
Xtreme Intense Championship Wrestling
XICW Light Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
¹ Scott Steiner won a match with the other Feast or Fired winners for an opportunity to trade his unopened case with someone else choosing Williams' case and when his new case was opened it contained the World Heavyweight Title match.
Later he was defeated by Steiner to win both cases.

² Steiner later gave back his original briefcase.
Alliance Championship Wrestling
ACW Junior Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
Border City Wrestling
BCW Can-Am Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Bobby Roode
BCW Can-Am Television Championship (1 time)
CLASH Wrestling
CLASH Championship (1 time)
CLASH Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with The Canadian Destroyer
East Coast Wrestling Association
Super 8 Tournament (2005)
Elite Wrestling Revolution
EWR Heavyweight Championship (2 times)
Independent Wrestling Association Mid-South
IWA Mid-South Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
Lucha Libre USA
LLUSA Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Jon Rekon
Metro Pro Wrestling
MPW Cruiserweight Championship (1 time)
New Korea Pro Wrestling Association
NKPWA Junior Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
NWA Upstate
NWA Upstate No Limits Championship (1 time)
Prime Time Wrestling
PTW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
King Of The Cruiserweight Tournament (2006)
Pro Wrestling Illustrated
PWI ranked him #23 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2005
Pure Pro Wrestling
PPW Franchise Championship (1 time)
Resistance Pro Wrestling
RPW King Of The Night Life Championship (1 time)
Total Nonstop Action Wrestling/Impact Wrestling
TNA X Division Championship (2 times)
Gauntlet for the Gold (2004, 2008 – TNA X Division Championship)
Feast or Fired (2007 – World Heavyweight Championship contract)¹
Feast or Fired (2007, 2018 – X Division Championship contract)²
Finisher of the Year (2004–2006) Canadian Destroyer
Ultimate Championship Wrestling
UCW Lightweight Championship (1 time)
Wrestling Observer Newsletter
Best Wrestling Maneuver (2004, 2005) Canadian Destroyer
Rookie of the Year (2004)
Xtreme Intense Championship Wrestling
XICW Light Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
¹ Scott Steiner won a match with the other Feast or Fired winners for an opportunity to trade his unopened case with someone else choosing Williams' case and when his new case was opened it contained the World Heavyweight Title match. Later he was defeated by Steiner to win both cases.
² Steiner later gave back his original briefcase.
Petey Williams