In 1952, Norman Lamm, later president of Yeshiva University for over 25 years, was appointed to the role.
He would serve until 1958, before moving to the (unrelated) Upper West Side Jewish Center.

Solomon (Shlomo) Kahane, ordained in 1954 at Yeshiva University, was subsequently rabbi of the congregation for 38 years and widely considered the synagogue’s most prominent Rabbi.
He died in April, 2004.
He was a first cousin of Rabbi Meir Kahane, the founder of the Jewish Defense League and the Israeli political party Kach.
The Jewish Defense League's first meeting was held at the West Side Jewish Center on June 18, 1968.
In 1952, Norman Lamm, later president of Yeshiva University for over 25 years, was appointed to the role. He would serve until 1958, before moving to the (unrelated) Upper West Side Jewish Center. 
Solomon (Shlomo) Kahane, ordained in 1954 at Yeshiva University, was subsequently rabbi of the congregation for 38 years and widely considered the synagogue’s most prominent Rabbi.He died in April, 2004. He was a first cousin of Rabbi Meir Kahane, the founder of the Jewish Defense League and the Israeli political party Kach. The Jewish Defense League's first meeting was held at the West Side Jewish Center on June 18, 1968.
Congregation Beth Israel West Side Jewish Center