The following lists were compiled from information in collections of sheet music, Lawrence Gilman's Edward MacDowell: A Study (1908), Oscar Sonneck's Catalogue of First Editions of Edward MacDowell (1917), and John F. Porte's Edward MacDowell (1922).

Published compositions for piano, a complete listing
Op.
1 Amourette (1896) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op.
2 In Lilting Rhythm (1897) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op.
4 Forgotten Fairy Tales (1897) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op.
7 Six Fancies (1898) (as Edgar Thorn)
In 1895, an "Op.
8 Waltz" for piano by MacDowell was listed by Breitkopf & Härtel, but no price was shown, and the piece was not published.

Op.
10 First Modern Suite (1883)
Op.
13 Prelude and Fugue (1883)
Op.
14 Second Modern Suite (1883)
Op.
15 Piano Concerto No.
1 (1885)
Op.
16 Serenata (1883)
Op.
17 Two Fantastic Pieces (1884)
Op.
18 Two Compositions (1884)
Op.
19 Forest Idylls (1884)
Op.
20 Three Poems (1886) duets
Op.
21 Moon Pictures (1886) duets after Hans Christian Andersen's "Picture-book without Pictures"
Op.
23 Piano Concerto No.
2 (1890)
Op.
24 Four Compositions (1887)
Op.
28 Six Idylls after Goethe (1887)
Op.
31 Six Poems after Heine (1887,1901)
Op.
32 Four Little Poems (1888)
Op.
36 Etude de Concert (1889)
Op.
37 Les Orientales (1889)
Op.
38 Marionettes (1888,1901)
Op.
39 Twelve Studies (1890)
Op.
45 Sonata Tragica (1893)
Op.
46 Twelve Virtuoso Studies (1894)
Op.
49 Air and Rigaudon (1894)
Op.
50 Sonata Eroica (1895) "Flos regum Arthurus"
Op.
51 Woodland Sketches (1896) (for Robert La Fosse's ballet, see Woodland Sketches)
Op.
55 Sea Pieces (1898)
Op.
57 Third Sonata (1900)
Op.
59 Fourth Sonata (1901)
Op.
61 Fireside Tales (1902)
Op.
62 New England Idylls (1902)
MacDowell published two books of Technical Exercises for piano; piano duet transcriptions of Hamlet and Ophelia for orchestra (Op.
22); First Suite for orchestra (Op.
42); and a piano solo version of Op.
42, No.
4, The Shepherdess' Song, renamed The Song of the Shepherdess.

Published compositions for orchestra (complete)
Op.
15 Piano Concerto No.
1 (1885)
Op.
22 Hamlet and Ophelia (1885)
Op.
23 Piano Concerto No.
2 (1890)
Op.
25 Lancelot and Elaine (1888)
Op.
29 Lamia (1908)
Op.
30 Two Fragments after the Song of Roland (1891) I. The Saracens - II.
The Lovely Alda
Op.
35 Romance for Violoncello and Orchestra (1888)
Op.
42 First Suite (1891–1893) I. In a Haunted Forest - II.
Summer Idyl - III.
In October - IV.
The Shepherdess' Song - V. Forest Spirits
Op.
48 Second ("Indian") Suite (1897) I. Legend - II.
Love Song - III.
In War-time - IV.
Dirge - V. Village Festival
Published songs
Op.
3 Love and Time and The Rose and the Gardener, for male chorus (1897) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op.
5 The Witch, for male chorus (1898) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op.
6 War Song, for male chorus (1898) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op.
9 Two Old Songs, for voice and piano (1894) I. Deserted - II.
Slumber Song
Op.
11 and 12 An Album of Five Songs, for voice and piano (1883) I. My Love and I - II.
You Love Me Not - III.
In the Skies - IV.
Night-Song - V. Bands of Roses
Op.
26 From an Old Garden, for voice and piano (1887) I. The Pansy - II.
The Myrtle - III.
The Clover - IV.
The Yellow Daisy - V. The Blue Bell - VI.
The Mignonette
Op.
27 Three Songs, for male chorus (1890) I. In the Starry Sky Above Us - II.
Springtime - III.
The Fisherboy
Op.
33 Three Songs, for voice and piano (1894) I. Prayer - II.
Cradle Hymn - III.
Idyl
Op.
34 Two Songs, for voice and piano (1889) I. Menie - II.
My Jean
Op.
40 Six Love Songs, for voice and piano (1890) I. Sweet, Blue-eyed Maid - II.
Sweetheart, Tell Me - III.
Thy Beaming Eyes - IV.
For Love's Sweet Sake - V. O Lovely Rose - VI.
I Ask but This
Op.
41 Two Songs, for male chorus (1890) I. Cradle Song - II.
Dance of the Gnomes
Op.
43 Two Northern Songs, for mixed chorus (1891) I. The Brook - II.
Slumber Song
Op.
44 Barcarolle, for mixed chorus with four-hand piano accompaniment (1892)
Op.
47 Eight Songs, for voice and piano (1893) I. The Robin Sings in the Apple Tree - II.
Midsummer Lullaby - III.
Folk Song - IV.
Confidence - V. The West Wind Croons in the Cedar Trees - VI.
In the Woods - VI
The following lists were compiled from information in collections of sheet music, Lawrence Gilman's Edward MacDowell: A Study (1908), Oscar Sonneck's Catalogue of First Editions of Edward MacDowell (1917), and John F. Porte's Edward MacDowell (1922).
Published compositions for piano, a complete listing
Op. 1 Amourette (1896) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op. 2 In Lilting Rhythm (1897) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op. 4 Forgotten Fairy Tales (1897) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op. 7 Six Fancies (1898) (as Edgar Thorn)
In 1895, an "Op. 8 Waltz" for piano by MacDowell was listed by Breitkopf & Härtel, but no price was shown, and the piece was not published.
Op. 10 First Modern Suite (1883)
Op. 13 Prelude and Fugue (1883)
Op. 14 Second Modern Suite (1883)
Op. 15 Piano Concerto No. 1 (1885)
Op. 16 Serenata (1883)
Op. 17 Two Fantastic Pieces (1884)
Op. 18 Two Compositions (1884)
Op. 19 Forest Idylls (1884)
Op. 20 Three Poems (1886) duets
Op. 21 Moon Pictures (1886) duets after Hans Christian Andersen's "Picture-book without Pictures"
Op. 23 Piano Concerto No. 2 (1890)
Op. 24 Four Compositions (1887)
Op. 28 Six Idylls after Goethe (1887)
Op. 31 Six Poems after Heine (1887,1901)
Op. 32 Four Little Poems (1888)
Op. 36 Etude de Concert (1889)
Op. 37 Les Orientales (1889)
Op. 38 Marionettes (1888,1901)
Op. 39 Twelve Studies (1890)
Op. 45 Sonata Tragica (1893)
Op. 46 Twelve Virtuoso Studies (1894)
Op. 49 Air and Rigaudon (1894)
Op. 50 Sonata Eroica (1895) "Flos regum Arthurus"
Op. 51 Woodland Sketches (1896) (for Robert La Fosse's ballet, see Woodland Sketches)
Op. 55 Sea Pieces (1898)
Op. 57 Third Sonata (1900)
Op. 59 Fourth Sonata (1901)
Op. 61 Fireside Tales (1902)
Op. 62 New England Idylls (1902)
MacDowell published two books of Technical Exercises for piano; piano duet transcriptions of Hamlet and Ophelia for orchestra (Op. 22); First Suite for orchestra (Op. 42); and a piano solo version of Op. 42, No. 4, The Shepherdess' Song, renamed The Song of the Shepherdess.
Published compositions for orchestra (complete)
Op. 15 Piano Concerto No. 1 (1885)
Op. 22 Hamlet and Ophelia (1885)
Op. 23 Piano Concerto No. 2 (1890)
Op. 25 Lancelot and Elaine (1888)
Op. 29 Lamia (1908)
Op. 30 Two Fragments after the Song of Roland (1891) I. The Saracens - II. The Lovely Alda
Op. 35 Romance for Violoncello and Orchestra (1888)
Op. 42 First Suite (1891–1893) I. In a Haunted Forest - II. Summer Idyl - III. In October - IV. The Shepherdess' Song - V. Forest Spirits
Op. 48 Second ("Indian") Suite (1897) I. Legend - II. Love Song - III. In War-time - IV. Dirge - V. Village Festival
Published songs
Op. 3 Love and Time and The Rose and the Gardener, for male chorus (1897) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op. 5 The Witch, for male chorus (1898) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op. 6 War Song, for male chorus (1898) (as Edgar Thorn)
Op. 9 Two Old Songs, for voice and piano (1894) I. Deserted - II. Slumber Song
Op. 11 and 12 An Album of Five Songs, for voice and piano (1883) I. My Love and I - II. You Love Me Not - III. In the Skies - IV. Night-Song - V. Bands of Roses
Op. 26 From an Old Garden, for voice and piano (1887) I. The Pansy - II. The Myrtle - III. The Clover - IV. The Yellow Daisy - V. The Blue Bell - VI. The Mignonette
Op. 27 Three Songs, for male chorus (1890) I. In the Starry Sky Above Us - II. Springtime - III. The Fisherboy
Op. 33 Three Songs, for voice and piano (1894) I. Prayer - II. Cradle Hymn - III. Idyl
Op. 34 Two Songs, for voice and piano (1889) I. Menie - II. My Jean
Op. 40 Six Love Songs, for voice and piano (1890) I. Sweet, Blue-eyed Maid - II. Sweetheart, Tell Me - III. Thy Beaming Eyes - IV. For Love's Sweet Sake - V. O Lovely Rose - VI. I Ask but This
Op. 41 Two Songs, for male chorus (1890) I. Cradle Song - II. Dance of the Gnomes
Op. 43 Two Northern Songs, for mixed chorus (1891) I. The Brook - II. Slumber Song
Op. 44 Barcarolle, for mixed chorus with four-hand piano accompaniment (1892)
Op. 47 Eight Songs, for voice and piano (1893) I. The Robin Sings in the Apple Tree - II. Midsummer Lullaby - III. Folk Song - IV. Confidence - V. The West Wind Croons in the Cedar Trees - VI. In the Woods - VI
Edward MacDowell