All American Wrestling
AAW Tag Team Championship (4 times)
Alpha-1 Wrestling
A1 Tag Team Championship (1 time)
Absolute Intense Wrestling
AIW Tag Team Championship (1 time)
American Pro Wrestling Alliance
APWA World Tag Team Championship (1 time)
Combat Zone Wrestling
CZW World Tag Team Championship (1 time)
CZW Wired TV Championship (2 times) – Jake (1), Dave (1)
Best of the Best 16 – Dave
Destination One Wrestling
D1W Tag Team Championship (1 time) 
Harvest Cup (2014) – Dave
Impact Wrestling
Impact X Division Championship (1 time) – Jake
GFW/Impact World Tag Team Championship (1 time)
Heartland Wrestling Association
HWA Heavyweight Championship (2 times) – Jake
HWA Tag Team Championship (3 times)
HWA Television Championship (2 times) - Lotus (Dave) (1), Crazy J (Jake) (1)
HWA Heartland Cup (2011) – Jake
Infinity Pro Reign
Infinity Pro Duos Championship (1 time)
Insanity Pro Wrestling
IPW World Heavyweight Championship (1 time) – Jake
IPW Tag Team Championship (2 times)
IPW Junior Heavyweight Championship (5 times) – Dave (2), Jake (3)
IPW Super Junior Heavyweight Tournament – Dave (2004, 2006), Jake (2005)
IWA East Coast
IWA East Coast Tag Team Championship (1 time, current)
Independent Wrestling Association Mid-South
IWA Mid-South Heavyweight Championship (3 times, current) – Dave (1), Jake (2, current)
International Wrestling Cartel
IWC Tag Team Championship (1 time)
Juggalo Championship Wrestling
JCW Tag Team Championship (5 times)
Northwest Ohio Wrestling
NOW Heavyweight Championship (1 time) – Dave
Glass City Tournament (2016) – Dave
Pro Wrestling Illustrated
Ranked Jake No.
135 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2018
Ranked Dave No.
140 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2018
Rockstar Pro Wrestling
Cicero Cup (2014) – Jake
Rockstar Pro Championship (3 times) – Jake (2), Dave (1)
Rockstar Pro American Luchacore Championship (1 time) – Dave
Rockstar Pro Tag Team Championship (2 times) – Jake and Aaron Williams (1), Jake and Ron Mathis (1)
Rockstar Pro Trios Championship (1 time) - Dave with Sami Callihan and Jessicka Havok
Style Battle
Style Battle #1 – Dave
Xtreme Intense Championship Wrestling
XICW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – Dave with Aaron Williams, Dezmond Xavier, Kyle Maverick, Trey Miguel and Zachary Wentz
All American Wrestling
AAW Tag Team Championship (4 times)
Alpha-1 Wrestling
A1 Tag Team Championship (1 time)
Absolute Intense Wrestling
AIW Tag Team Championship (1 time)
American Pro Wrestling Alliance
APWA World Tag Team Championship (1 time)
Combat Zone Wrestling
CZW World Tag Team Championship (1 time)
CZW Wired TV Championship (2 times) – Jake (1), Dave (1)
Best of the Best 16 – Dave
Destination One Wrestling
D1W Tag Team Championship (1 time) 
Harvest Cup (2014) – Dave
Impact Wrestling
Impact X Division Championship (1 time) – Jake
GFW/Impact World Tag Team Championship (1 time)
Heartland Wrestling Association
HWA Heavyweight Championship (2 times) – Jake
HWA Tag Team Championship (3 times)
HWA Television Championship (2 times) - Lotus (Dave) (1), Crazy J (Jake) (1)
HWA Heartland Cup (2011) – Jake
Infinity Pro Reign
Infinity Pro Duos Championship (1 time)
Insanity Pro Wrestling
IPW World Heavyweight Championship (1 time) – Jake
IPW Tag Team Championship (2 times)
IPW Junior Heavyweight Championship (5 times) – Dave (2), Jake (3)
IPW Super Junior Heavyweight Tournament – Dave (2004, 2006), Jake (2005)
IWA East Coast
IWA East Coast Tag Team Championship (1 time, current)
Independent Wrestling Association Mid-South
IWA Mid-South Heavyweight Championship (3 times, current) – Dave (1), Jake (2, current)
International Wrestling Cartel
IWC Tag Team Championship (1 time)
Juggalo Championship Wrestling
JCW Tag Team Championship (5 times)
Northwest Ohio Wrestling
NOW Heavyweight Championship (1 time) – Dave
Glass City Tournament (2016) – Dave
Pro Wrestling Illustrated
Ranked Jake No. 135 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2018
Ranked Dave No. 140 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2018
Rockstar Pro Wrestling
Cicero Cup (2014) – Jake
Rockstar Pro Championship (3 times) – Jake (2), Dave (1)
Rockstar Pro American Luchacore Championship (1 time) – Dave
Rockstar Pro Tag Team Championship (2 times) – Jake and Aaron Williams (1), Jake and Ron Mathis (1)
Rockstar Pro Trios Championship (1 time) - Dave with Sami Callihan and Jessicka Havok
Style Battle
Style Battle #1 – Dave
Xtreme Intense Championship Wrestling
XICW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – Dave with Aaron Williams, Dezmond Xavier, Kyle Maverick, Trey Miguel and Zachary Wentz
The Crist Brothers