In August 2016 the church announced that an eldership team would be appointed, and Howard Satterthwaite would be appointed as Lead Elder.

The full list of previous pastors is:
1842–78 Revd Samuel Martin (helped by Henry Simon for the last two years of his pastorate)
1876–87 Revd Henry Simon
1887–94 no settled ministry
1894–95 Revd W. Evans Hurndall
1896–1902 Revd Richard Westrope
1902–04 no settled ministry
1904–17 Revd G. Campbell Morgan
1904–07 Revd Albert Swift (co-pastor with Campbell Morgan)
1918–22 Revd John Henry Jowett
1923–25 Revd John Hutton
1926–27 no settled ministry
1928–33 Revd Hubert Simpson
1933–43 Revd G. Campbell Morgan (associate minister for one year with Hubert Simpson)
1939–68 Revd D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones (associate minister with Campbell Morgan until August 1943)
1969–74 Revd J. Glyn Owen
1974–76 no settled ministry
1977–2002 Revd R. T. Kendall
2002–16 Revd Greg Haslam
In August 2016 the church announced that an eldership team would be appointed, and Howard Satterthwaite would be appointed as Lead Elder.
The full list of previous pastors is:
1842–78 Revd Samuel Martin (helped by Henry Simon for the last two years of his pastorate)
1876–87 Revd Henry Simon
1887–94 no settled ministry
1894–95 Revd W. Evans Hurndall
1896–1902 Revd Richard Westrope
1902–04 no settled ministry
1904–17 Revd G. Campbell Morgan
1904–07 Revd Albert Swift (co-pastor with Campbell Morgan)
1918–22 Revd John Henry Jowett
1923–25 Revd John Hutton
1926–27 no settled ministry
1928–33 Revd Hubert Simpson
1933–43 Revd G. Campbell Morgan (associate minister for one year with Hubert Simpson)
1939–68 Revd D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones (associate minister with Campbell Morgan until August 1943)
1969–74 Revd J. Glyn Owen
1974–76 no settled ministry
1977–2002 Revd R. T. Kendall
2002–16 Revd Greg Haslam
Westminster Chapel