I bought one of these mainly because it was the only holster offered that doesn't also need a case - I didn't want something too bulky. Sure it was $10 and fits what I wanted but what a piece of junk. I broke it within 4 months of use. I am very good to my phones and devices/cases and this thing simply wore out due to use. It's major failing point is the 2 plastic nubs that hold the "spring" in place for the clip to stay closed. The nubs break off leaving the holster worthless.In saying that, the case holster is built very cheaply (hence the price) but also the clip that holds the phone in is terrible as it doesn't close over the phone all the way so it is not as secure as it should be while in the holster.I would seriously recommend buying something else as a holster for your phone than this piece of junk. Gone through 2 of them now, should have just bought something else to begin with...