I haven't tried any other hands-free set. I however have found this one to suit my purpose rather well. I've used it around the house (while walking around, doing dishes), or sitting at my desk. I've taken it outside while walking (not a very windy day) and numerous times driving.Only one person has complained that I was a little too quiet.Now, the only thing that I think I have had trouble with is that if I decide to remove the hands-free device when I answer a call with it, I usually have to hang up and start a new call. This however is probably my Motoral T720i.But great so far. I'm impressed. Good price.