I am grateful to be able to have an antenna as mine broke off and I didn't want to buy a new phone. I bought one antenna and the plastic came off the metal part where it screws into the phone. I returned it for another one and within a week had the same result. I took some supper glue and glued it on carefully so as to not damage the antenna part. It has worked great so far. I just think that it would be nice if the factory would have glued it better.