Great holder for the price. High quality feel, looks great, wears nice, soft inside...very solid overall. If I was nit picking I would have the clip be a little better (very stiff to open and does not ratchet turn)...but that's more preference, and maybe the magnet could be a bit stronger but again it works fine as is.Overall I would highly recommend it. One other thing, is I have a Speck clear case on the MotoQ in addition to this pouch, and even with the clear case on, it fits nicely in the pouch.