I too enjoyed this holster and its ease of use for about four or five months; apart from seeming to get slightly looser, the phone never fell out of the holster. The phone was very easy to access and the only advantage of a rotating holster is that it is a bit more comfortable. Everything was going fine until I took my seatbelt off one day and the plastic clip attachment broke off. I use a leather rotating holster now, which is a little more comfortable when sitting but not nearly as accessible as the Samsung holster. On the whole, I recommend the plastic holster for its ease of use but it is sometimes uncomfortable when sitting and can break because of its rigidity.