When I first got the carrying case, I was really impressed by the sleek design, cool color, and good fit. The phone will snugly fit in there, even with the earpiece attached. That's what I would rated five-stars. But, that soon changed after using it for a couple of weeks. The color is fading especially around the edges. It is not that easy to clean the accumulated dust off the blue fabric. Also, the belt clip is now somewhat loose, allowing the case to easily fall off as you are getting out of your car. I guess as far as belt clips go, the Motorola StarTac Holster's clip is the best I've used because it &quot;hooks&quot; around the belt, not just &quot;clips&quot; on it. That is why I conclude with a three-star rating.