I have a Motorola V551. Initially I bought the case made by Motorola. The phone frequently fell out of the case. A few times I didn't even notice that the phone had fallen out. I sometimes had to crawl under strangers' cars in parking lots to retrieve the phone. There was also a lesser problem with that case. Although the belt clip swiveled, allowing avoidance of the antenna stabbing me, the clip itself protruded and stabbed me. It was really quite uncomfortable to wear.This case holds the phone snuggly and securely. It is completely comfortable to wear. The only problem is sometimes it holds the phone too securely. I can have some difficulty removing the phone to answer a call. The 551 is a bluetooth phone. Once I have a bluetooth earbud I will be able to bypass this problem. Another very minor issue is that I have to remove the phone from the case to charge the battery.Overall this is a very good case and is vastly superior to the case produced by the manufacturer of the phone.