We can assume that Muhammad could have dictated his will at a later time but what was there to prevent Umar and his supporters from claiming that it was dictated in a state of “delirium,” and was “nonsensical,” and was, therefore, not acceptable to the umma.
Tunaweza kudhani kwamba Muhammad angeweza kuamuru wosia wake katika wakati wa baadaye lakini ni nini kilikuwepo kumzuia Umar na wafuasi wake kudai kwamba iliamriwa katika hali ya "kupazaa," na ilikuwa "isiyo na maana," na kwa hiyo, haikuwa. yanayokubalika kwa umma.