The Barn cover features a man and woman in an intimate embrace, with the man kissing the woman's cheek. The cover text reads "THE BARN" in large yellow letters, followed by "THE FARM Grew a Crop of Pretty Girls — AND ANY ONE OF THEM WAS HAYLIFT MATERIAL FOR BIG JODIE!" and "A Disturbing Revelation of Conditions Among Teenagers Driven to Passionate Excess by Boredom and Isolation" in smaller white text.