The album cover for "The Why's" features a group of musicians on stage, with the title "THE WHY'S" in large white letters. The cover also includes a list of songs in Spanish, including "Guitar: the reverb princess diamond arm 'RUIKO'" and "BASS: surfmuse scorpion head 'NAOIT'" with "DRUMS: starburst beat galaxy bakery 'YUTA'" in English. The cover is framed by a white border and includes a "FIVE NINE" logo at the top left corner.