**Conversational Performance.** Patient actors and specialist raters both evaluated AMIE's performance to be higher than PCPs on metrics related to empathy and communication skills. These axes comprised a majority of the dimensions that were evaluated. This general finding is consistent with a prior study where LLM responses were found to be more empathetic than the responses from clinicians to health questions posted on Reddit [73]. However, the findings in that study may not be generalised directly to our setting due to the differences in study design. Specifically, prior work has not involved a direct, randomised comparison of physicians and AI systems in a prospective simulation of multi-turn dialogue with the same patient. In both settings, the lack of voice-based and non-verbal visual communication may be an unfair disadvantage to clinicians.