In the advent of the "synthetic data age", our work signals the end of current neural scaling laws and opens the door to a puzzling array of new phenomena in a world where the training corpora are enriched with AI generated data. We demonstrate that scaling laws cease to persist; test error tapers off due to altered, less heavy tailed, data distributions. As noted already in prior work, in a fully synthetic data world learning will stop and models will degenerate - their scaling will halt and revert completely. Yet, new opportunities arise from careful mixture and data curation, as we have shown, with interesting effects at the interplay of clean and synthesized data. We must recognize new learning plateaus and, for instance, adjust to changed learning curves from blending clean and synthetic data to unintended early stopping. A notable feature of our work is that our theory is _effective_ - we observe the predicted phenomena for relevant large models in two different settings.