By contrast, our fitted model implies an optimal ratio of around 20 tokens per parameter, which is consistent with both how the Chinchilla model was trained and the findings from Approaches 1 and 2 in Hoffmann et al. (see Figure 5). The inconsistency between the prescriptions based on the estimated scaling law (Approach 3) and the results from Approaches 1 and 2 in Hoffmann et al. raises further concerns about the accuracy of their parameter estimates. The alignment of our estimates with the token-to-parameter ratio used in practice and obtained from their other approaches strengthens the case for the validity of our fit.