**Preference Data Components**: Our preference data selection involves choosing preferred and dis-preferred translations from a triplet consisting of outputs from GPT-4, ALMA, and the gold reference. In the right of Figure 4, we emphasize the significance of the data generated by both ALMA and GPT-4. The results indicate a notable decline in performance when ALMA data is excluded in the en\(\rightarrow\)xx direction. Conversely, omitting GPT-4 data leads to a significant performance decrease in the xx\(\rightarrow\)en direction. This demonstrates that data generated by both systems plays a helpful role in enhancing model performance.