In Figure A11, we observe an interesting trend: for web-snapshot validation sets such as C4, the validation points closest to the training set are both (1) the easiest (lowest perplexity) points before data selection and (2) the points most affected by data selection. This seems to indicate that these validation points are "easy" due to their proximity to training points, and when these training points are removed from the training set due to data selection, the close-by validation points become difficult for the model. We do not see this trend on non-web snapshot validation sets such as DM Mathematics and Open Subtitles; in fact, we see an opposite trend where points furthest from the training set are generally most affected by data selection.