In addition to automatic evaluation, we also evaluate Yi-6B fine-tuned on CQIA-subset by comparing it to state-of-the-art Chinese open-source chat models in similar parameter scale. As we focus on questions posed by real-world Chinese-speaking users. We sample 200 questions from OL-CC5 and Zhihu which are not present in the training set for human evaluation. We conduct pair-wise comparison, aiming to demonstrate how our model performs in comparison to others when facing real-world human prompt.