The annotators used a customized interface,5 which provided them full access to the book text for reference. Each annotator was assigned to annotate all five LLM-generated summaries for their assigned book, which were presented in a randomized order. Annotators received $200 for this task, which took \(\sim\)11 hours to complete (STD=6.34). In total, Fables contains 3,158 annotated claims from 130 summaries across 26 books at a cost of $5.2K USD.