Given that our model operates in a many-to-many translation format and the additional data is specific to only de and zh directions, we anticipate changes in performance when translating into these languages, but not in others. To assess the impact of the human-labeled data, we conducted a comparison between models exclusively fine-tuned on triplet data and those fine-tuned on both triplet and human-labeled data. The training approach remained consistent, utilizing the ALMA-13B-LoRA model fine-tuned via CPO. It's important to note that tied data were excluded from this analysis due to their lack of clear preference.