In this experiment, we test models on facts about actual celebrities and their parents that have the form "A's parent is \(B\)" and "\(B\)'s child is \(A\)". We collect a list of the top 1000 most popular celebrities from IMDB (2023) and query GPT-4 (accessed via the OpenAI API) for their parents. The exact prompt is provided in Appendix C. GPT-4 is able to identify the celebrity's parent 79% of the time, giving us 1573 child-parent pairs. For each child-parent pair, we query GPT-4 to identify the child. Here, GPT-4 is successful only 33% of the time 11. Figure 1 illustrates this phenomenon. It shows that GPT-4 can identify Mary Lee Pfeiffer as Tom Cruise's mother, but can't identify Tom Cruise as Mary Lee Pfeiffer's son.