**Specialist Physician Ratings.** Specialist physicians evaluated both the conversational quality as well as the responses to the post-questionnaire for scenarios within their domain expertise (see Figure 5). Again, AMIE's responses were rated significantly better by specialists than those from PCPs on 28 of 32 evaluation axes; Specialists preferred AMIE's consultation, diagnoses, and management plan over those from PCPs. For this set of evaluations, differences in specialist ratings between AMIE and PCPs were statistically significant (\(p<0.05\)). No significant differences in ratings were detected for four of the axes in the Diagnosis & Management rubric, namely, "Escalation Recommendation Appropriate", "Treatment Inappropriate Avoided", "Followup Recommendation Appropriate" and "Confabulation Absent", despite no exclusions (N=149).