Hoffmann et al.'s paper has been highly influential in the language modeling community. Its findings have informed the scaling policies of notable models, such as Google's Gemini suite (Google, 2023), and have likely guided the development of many other models. Moreover, the specific parameter estimates of the scaling law presented in the paper are of significant scientific interest, such as for machine learning theory. Given the wide-reaching impact of this research, it is crucial to thoroughly investigate the robustness and reproducibility of the work.