Both Figures 3 (middle) and 12 illustrate the setting where each model consumes as much training data as its predecessor (\(T_{0}=T\)). We now relax the assumption that each successive model has strictly the same amount of training data as its predecessor. We assume that the generation 0 model is trained on \(T_{0}\) (here, \(T_{0}=100,000\)) amount of original data to generate AI data for generation 1. All future generations, starting from generation 2, are trained on data generated by the most powerful model from the previous generation (\(T=1,000,000\) data in this case). Figure 13 (for Hutter LLM) and 14 (for Hutter++ on paired bigram data) show the resulting scaling behavior. We take this setting even further by adding a top-p tail cutting mechanism and a temperature scaling mechanism for each synthetic data generation. Figure 6 cuts at \(p=0.95\) and Figure 16 at temperature \(0.9\).