**Are reference Gold or Gilded?** We conducted an in-depth analysis of the training data (FLORES-200 data) utilized by the ALMA model. We meticulously compared the quality of the reference translations with those generated by strong translation models. Our findings reveal that, in numerous instances, the quality of human-written parallel data is even inferior to that of system-generated translations. This observation underscores a critical insight: training models exclusively towards replicating reference translations may not be the most effective approach, and reliance on reference-based evaluation could be flawed.