Upon Review of the Sell recommendations...  it seems TransAlta made me good money in 2016 but it also seems Choice Hotel didn't go bust? and paid a reasonable dividend?  or Hydro One listed at $18???    There must be something wrong with your data since Hydro One was $26 in August 2016...   or Prairie Sky has only moved up from Aug ($25->$30)???  maybe the IPO was at $20...   not sure if Accountability Research is still followed...  I tried a search Globe and Mail but got nothing relevent...  just a thought...  on accountability,  the value of RNW renewable subsidiary to TA is worth $15/share pays 6% and Market Cap? $3.4B yet TransAlta owns 60% or $2B in stock and receives $120M in dividends?  pays out only 3% div. and its M.C. is only $2B?  it's bizarre...  and then Alberta decided to shutdown Coal by 2030 and reimburse TA annually $37.4M for the assets phase-out.  I just figured with all those submersible pumps in Alberta pumping oil maybe they run on ??? TransAlta; can't say...