Tap the brakes there a tad.  Not everything is simple stats.  Talk to the guys who played with and against Manning, and they'll tell you even in his worst times he was intimidating and could pull a win from where it didn't seem it could happen.  

We'll see what Trevor has when it results in wins and post-season wins. I'm truly hoping he turns out very well and isn't just a passing-numbers-between-the-20's guy.