The original PFD plan was shot down due to the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th amendment. It seems to me this income tax plan, to continue the PFD but take the money back from folks that work does not provide equal protection. Give money to every Alaskan and take it back from everyone with a job? Give away 1 billion dollars, 200 million goes to the Feds, take back another 400 million from everyone with a job? No! Do not put in an income tax when one hand gives it away and another, yet to be grown hand, takes it back.