This is about the stupidest law suit in a long time. The author has it correct that you really do not know why a person is elected. You can surmise, but you just don't know. All the GOP in the district could have voted for the Dems and all the Dems could have voted for the GOP, you have no idea.....IF you believe we truly have secret ballots.

But there is another point that should end this lawsuit immediately: there is no mention nor any place for political parties in our constitution and our system of government, period. So what is a partisan other than someone who strongly supports an irrelevant association when it comes to governing and the constitution. What next gerrymander to make sure the requisite number of blue eyed people are in each district? That there is the requisite number of Asians in each district? Gerrymander so that all libertarians are in a district so they get representation? All greens?