The apartheid claim has been debunked. Palestinians are currently emigrating to Israel and express their preference for living in Israel and for good reason. They can enjoy the benefits of a liberal democracy and its freedoms. Where Arabs serve in the government and are freely elected.  Where Arabs from Israel, the West Bank and Gaza have access to Israeli hospitals. Where Arab doctors and nurses treat Jewish and Arab patients in Israeli hospitals.  Where Palestinians, including West Bank Palestinians claim that their rights have been abrogated in the course of an Israeli action, are entitled to file suit in Israel. Where the valedictorian of a graduating class at the Technion was a Muslim woman. Where an Arab commands an Israeli infantry brigade. Where an Arab sits as a judge on the Supreme Court of Israel. Where Arabs freely attend universities of their choosing. Apartheid in Israel? Hardly.