Nomad,

Apologies for veering off topic, but I agree with you.  As I've said elsewhere on this board, there is no such thing as "revenue-neutral" to the taxpayer.  Carbon pricing is a tax any way you look at it because it's money extracted by a government from the citizen.

Furthermore, hearing a transcript of Trudeau's introductory speech on the carbon tax bill he referred to carbon as a pollutant which is patently wrong.  It reinforces the notion that the Liberal government's action is not based on addressing AGW, rather more to further enslave Canadians through higher, pointless taxation.