I think any judge would say:  "It appears to me he's answered that question, Mr. d1 - it's just not the answer you were looking for."  But hey, you're the one with the legal experience.

And when I object to a guy who refers to Southey's column as a "Holt Renfrew shopping scolding", and who sums up Hillary Clinton with a quote ending "if you don't show her enough appreciation, and after all she's done for us, she may cry" - you say that's "special care."  I do plead guilty to that, counsellor.