Like most philosophers Mr. Kingwell seems to argue for both sides but I think in the end he believes government should direct or control our choices.

If I felt that government was omnipotent and always knew the correct solution perhaps I would agree with him.  Unfortunately I see too many decisions being made that lack evidence of any investigation of alternatives or even of consideration of pros and cons.

I have more faith that individuals'  happiness is enhanced more by even the illusion of choice than by assurance that the government is making the 'right' choice for them.