If you are going to jump into a discussion in media res, please have the courtesy to read the prior exchange in order to ascertain what "the issue" under discussion is.

To hang your animadversion on my word "issue" and then fill the term with your own meaning is....what? silly? illogical? incoherent? anti-intellectual? 

Seriously, I'm sure ancient rhetoric has a Greek (or Latin) name for this particular brand of fallacious reasoning, but I just don't know what it is.