Total public service, including health care, doctors, policeman, civil servants, teachers, etc.. is slightly less than $30 billion.  Even if you cut by say 10%, that is a $3 billion reduction, but you also lose the income tax revenue, so that $3 billion reduction is maybe $2 billion net to the Alberta govt.  OK, now where do you find the other $8 to $9 billion to balance the budget Prairie Girl?