I don't see the relevance. A racist policy (remember the Komagata Maru incident, or the Chinese ban) was wrong, and in retrospect the Jews were sent back to their deaths.

The situation here is different. Most Haitians would simply go back to poverty, and lose their cushy North American lifestyle. Those who managed to squirrel away money while in the U.S. could enter Haiti with assets to allow them NOT to enter at the bottom of the economic ladder.