I too like the choice of Tobin.  A mix of humility, with a sense of a servant church is a good place to begin.  As to the specifics of what he said about mercy, I continue to believe that while the theme of Mercy that Francis is pushing, would be a LOT more effective if he'd clean up the mess of the scandal.  Mercy and justice are intertwined.  The bishops continue to act as if they believe there is nothing requiring justice required relative to THEIR handling of the scandal.  I'd hope that sooner or later, these guys would understand that until they address that, the strength of their words will remained weakened.

As to his words about bishops needing to talk to one another, I think that they DO talk to and rely on each other so much is a bit part of the problem, especially at the usccb.  Perhaps it's time they talk more to the laity, and focus just a little less on each other?

I'm glad Tobin got the nod.