As it turned out in the conversation, you had misread the teaching regarding capital punishment, including that in St. John Paul II's "Evangelium Vitae".  But we expect no less from you.

But no matter, since you reject the Magisterium and have constructed your own "magisterium" based apparently on whim.

You have been corrected on Pius IX "calling freedom of religion 'an insanity'" and supposed conflict with the teaching of Vatican II enough times that unless you wish another drubbing, there is no reason to repeat the drill.

If "Rational people immediately see the contradiction.", what do YOU see?