What exactly does MSW think is "wacky" about the Register?  

I followed the link to the best of Catholic blogging he cites here....I have no idea what MSW  finds so off putting.   I'm not exactly a big fan of the Register, but I can't deny that it's legitimate Catholicism.   Hardly the views of its extreme conservative wing (for that, visit Crisismag).   But even with its ever dour and deploring tone, Crisis too is Catholic.

Serious question:   Does MSW think Catholicism itself is wacky?     Or that only his conception of Catholicism is legit?