More important than Robin Camp himself is what his history says about criteria for appointing judges.

1.  Prior to his appointment under Alison Redford in 2012 to the the Provincial Court of Alberta, Criminal Division, his Canadian legal experience was in commercial litigation. How much education - and of what nature - did he get before starting to hear criminal cases? 

2. His comments in the sexual assault case were in September 2014 and grabbed public attention when the Alberta Court of Appeal ruled on the case in October, 2015. The Alberta AG must have filed the appeal in late 2014 or very early 2015. 

The Harper government appointed him to the Federal Court in June 2015 - did they not investigate thoroughly enough, or did they know and not care?