Not sure what you're talking about Jay. I was trying to respond to the OP who was complaining about "being lectured to by Liberal supporters." My point being that if one can respond rationally to the problems of literal interpretations of Islam, for example, then one shouldn't be accused of hate. However when that response is couched in uncivil, gross generalizations about all Muslims and ignores facts such as how Muslims are not only immigrants but have actually been in Canada since Confederation, then being accused of bigotry, prejudice, or hate may be appropriate. 

It's also possible that expressions of hate can appear to be made civilly but inspire of that they are not inherently reasonable or rational.