well, Jeff, you might be right. but you better be ready for a false arrest and violations of my rights law suit. because it will come and in short order. but, until you tell me I am officially under arrest and for what specific articulated crime, you will not get my compliance nor my cooperation unless you ASK me nicely and if I am in the mood. to expand on that, once I am under arrest you will only get compliance as far as who I am when questioned and what I am asked to do lawfully. and again, I will sue them as fast as I can walk across the street to the court house and file the papers. 

when the police act without probable cause that leads to an arrest, that charge usually never makes it to court. funny thing about the constitution and those rights under the law. of course we have also got to get past all the cops lies as well don't we before we usually find that justice. and you wonder why people dislike the police.