My favorite mariner of all time. Class personified and the best pure hitter Seattle ever had. With the likes of Griff Jr around, that's saying something. 

The thing is, whether you like the DH or not, it's a postion that some players are asked to play. You can't penalize a player for playing the postion he has been asked to play. This is patently unfair. 

He is arguably the best DH to ever play. If not the best, certainly one of the two or three best.  Why does a shortstop ( Ozzie Smith as an example ) get in based almost exclusively for his defensive play, ( yes I know his offense improved over the years. ), but someone known for a great bat exclusively, is punished?

Edgar for the hall. It's the right thing to do.