The problem is that logic, reasoning, Scripture, Tradition don't triangulate on the pope's conclusions.

One can't both be in a permanent union and not be in one at the same time.

It's called the law of non-contradiction. 

"Love" is not sweet feelings.  Love never leads one into an untruthful situation.

The problem is that so many Catholics have no idea what I am talking about.  They've become relativised.