You missed the context of my argument.  The Conservative Party MPs that are crying today need to be reminded of their role in allowing Khadr to sue the government.  The Harper Government should have known better based upon the precedent of Arar.  Arar happened under Chretien, but Harper was in power when they had to flip the bill.  So lesson learned?  NO!  While Khadr was captured while Martin was in power, it was revealed 1 year later during Harper's regime that there were two survivors on the bunker in which Khadr was positioned.  Furthermore, the doctor who examined Khadr in the aftermath of the attack stated that Khadr was incapable of throwing the grenade given his extensive injuries sustained from the initial US assault on his position.  The fact that this information was even supressed should have been a call for the Canadian government to act, but it failed to do so for years.