Hi Scott, about the only dividend stocks that have been super ok over the years are BMO,
RBC, and Scotia Bank. I never could buy  TD cheap enough so I never bought it.
I never touch CIBC for PAST behaviors but I must Say that Victor Dodig is quite a remarkable CEO,a new breed.
I have NEVER regretted owning BMO,RBC and Scotia for about 30 years, a tremendous ride and what a wonderful monopoly.