"Your charge against OS that it gives no actual reason why women cannot be ordained is totally false"

I notice you do not give any reasons from OS. Because, of course, as I correctly said, OS does not give any. But you are right about one thing: I did not read the document with an open mind. I knew that it would be just one more piece of sexist crap from the Vatican. The previous position paper on the ordination of women, Inter Insigniores, is an even worse piece of bovine feces than Humanae Vitae. Dubious history, worse logic -- II admits that the "women are inferior" argument is not acceptable, and then proceeds to sneak it in at least twice.