Multicenter randomized clinical trial of supervised exercise therapy with or without feedback versus walking advice for intermittent claudication. The effect of supervised exercise therapy on physical activity and ambulatory activities in patients with intermittent claudication. A non-randomised controlled trial of the clinical and cost effectiveness of a Supervised Exercise Programme for claudication. Effects of home versus supervised exercise for patients with intermittent claudication. Supervised exercise therapy for intermittent claudication in a community-based setting is as effective as clinic-based. Supervised exercise therapy for intermittent claudication in daily practice. Efficacy of Quantified Home-Based Exercise and Supervised Exercise in Patients With Intermittent Claudication: A Randomized Controlled Trial Cost-effectiveness of exercise therapy in patients with intermittent claudication: supervised exercise therapy versus a 'go home and walk' advice. Does supervised exercise offer adjuvant benefit over exercise advice alone for the treatment of intermittent claudication? A randomised trial. Comparison of the effect of upper body-ergometry aerobic training vs treadmill training on central cardiorespiratory improvement and walking distance in patients with claudication. Value of a supervised exercise program for the therapy of arterial claudication. Improvement of the walking ability in intermittent claudication due to superficial femoral artery occlusion with supervised exercise and pneumatic foot and calf compression: a randomised controlled trial. SUPERvised exercise therapy or immediate PTA for intermittent claudication in patients with an iliac artery obstruction--a multicentre randomised controlled trial; SUPER study design and rationale. Optimizing supervised exercise therapy for patients with intermittent claudication. Impact of a supervised strength training or walking training over a subsequent unsupervised therapy period on walking capacity in patients with claudication. Efficacy of arm-ergometry versus treadmill exercise training to improve walking distance in patients with claudication Walking training for intermittent claudication in diabetes.
OBJECTIVE The initial treatment for intermittent claudication is supervised exercise therapy ( SET ) . Owing to limited capacity and patient transports costs of clinic-based SET , a concept of SET provided by local physiotherapists was developed . We hypothesized that provision of daily feedback with an accelerometer in addition to SET would further increase walking distance . METHODS This multicenter r and omized trial was set in vascular surgery outpatient clinics and included 304 patients with intermittent claudication . Patients were r and omized to exercise therapy in the form of " go home and walk " advice ( WA ) , SET , or SET with feedback . Local physiotherapists provided SET . The primary outcome measure was the change in absolute claudication distance . Secondary outcomes were the change in functional claudication distance and results on the Walking Impairment Question naire ( WIQ ) and Short-Form 36 ( SF-36 ) Health Survey after 12 months . RESULTS In 11 centers , 102 , 109 , and 93 patients were included , respectively , in the WA , SET , and SET with feedback groups , and data for 83 , 93 , and 76 , respectively , could be analyzed . The median ( interquartile range ) change in walking distance between 12 months and baseline in meters was 110 ( 0 - 300 ) in the WA group , 310 ( 145 - 995 ) in the SET group , and 360 ( 173 - 697 ) in the SET with feedback group ( P < .001 WA vs SET ) . WIQ scores and relevant domains of the SF-36 improved statistically significantly in the SET groups . CONCLUSIONS SET is more effective than WA in improving walking distance , WIQ scores , and quality of life for patients with intermittent claudication . Additional feedback with an accelerometer did not result in further improvement . SET programs should be made available for all patients with intermittent claudication OBJECTIVE / BACKGROUND Intermittent claudication ( IC ) is associated with a reduction in physical activity ( PA ) and a more rapid functional decline leading to a higher mortality rate compared with healthy individuals . Supervised exercise therapy ( SET ) is known to increase the walking capacity of patients with IC . However , it is unclear whether SET increases PA . The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of SET on PA levels and ambulatory activities in patients with IC . METHODS Patients newly diagnosed with IC were requested to wear an activity monitor 1 week prior to and 1 week immediately after 3 months of SET . The primary outcome was the percentage of patients meeting the minimum recommendations of PA ( American College of Sports Medicine [ACSM]/American Heart Association [ AHA ] recommendation for public health of ≥ 67 metabolic equivalents [METs]/min/day , in bouts of ≥ 10 min ) at baseline and after 3 months of SET . Additionally , daily PA level ( METs/min ) , duration of ambulatory activities , daily number of steps , pain free walking distance ( PFWD ) , maximal walking distance ( MWD ) , and Short Form Health Survey ( SF-36 ) health surveys were compared before and after SET . RESULTS Data from 41 participants were available for analysis . A higher number of participants met the ACSM minimum recommendation for PA at the 3 month follow up ( baseline : 43 % ; 3 months : 63 % ; p = .003 ) . Despite significant increases in PFWD ( baseline : 210 m ; 3 months : 390 m ; p = .001 ) , MWD ( baseline : 373 m ; 3 months : 555 m ; p = .002 ) and physical functioning score ( SF-36 )  following SET , no increase in the mean daily PA level was found ( 395 ± 220 vs. 411 ± 228 METs/min ; p = .43 ) . Furthermore , the total number of steps and time spent in ambulatory activities did not change following SET . CONCLUSION Three months of SET for IC leads to more patients meeting the ACSM/AHA public health minimum recommendations for PA . Assessment of PA could be incorporated as an outcome parameter in future research comparing different treatment modalities for peripheral arterial disease OBJECTIVES The main aims of treatment in patients with intermittent claudication ( IC ) are to improve the clinical indicators of lower limb ischaemia and patients ' quality of life ( QoL ) . The aims of this study were assess the clinical and cost effectiveness of a supervised exercise programme ( SEP ) in patients with IC . DESIGN Non-r and omised , controlled trial . SETTING University teaching hospital . PATIENTS AND METHODS Two groups of patients with IC were studied . Seventy patients were sequentially recruited before and after the establishment of a Supervised Exercise Programme at our unit . Thirty-seven patients ( median age 69 years , 26 men ) received  conservative medical therapy ( CMT ) and 33 patients ( median age 67 years , 22 men ) received CMT plus a 3 month SEP of graduated physical exercise for sixty minutes , three times each week . Patients were assessed prior to and at 6 months following treatment . At each assessment patient reported walking distances ( PRWD ) , treadmill claudication and maximal distances ( ICD and MWD ) , ankle brachial pressure indices ( ABPI ) pre & post exercise and patient reported QoL using the SF36 question naire were assessed . RESULTS Prior to intervention the two groups were well matched . Following treatment , CMT patients demonstrated no significant change in PRWD or ICD but did record a small but significant improvement in MWD .  CMT was also associated with a negative effect size in the SF36 index and in 7 of the 8 SF36 QoL domains , effect size > -0.5 for the domains of Physical Function and Emotional Role . SEP patients demonstrated significant improvement in PRWD , ICD and MWD . SEP was associated with a positive effect size in the SF36 index and in 2 SF36 QoL domains but a negative effect size in a further 2 domains . However , all QoL effect sizes following SEP were < + /-0.5 . Intergroup differences in effect sizes were > 0.5 for the SF36 domains of Physical Function , Physical Role , Emotion Role and SF36 index . SEP result ed in a 0.027 quality adjusted life year ( QALY ) gain over CMT in the first year post-treatment thus the cost/QALY gained of SEP is pound1780 at 1 year . CONCLUSIONS Compared to CMT , SEP increases walking distances , improves QoL and is a highly cost-effective treatment for IC PURPOSE This study was performed to test the efficacy of a supervised , hospital-based exercise program compared with a home-based exercise program involving minimal supervision , for both walking ability and quality of life measures in patients with exercise-limiting intermittent leg claudication . METHODS Twenty-one patients were assigned r and omly to 12 weeks of supervised exercise or to a home-based exercise group . After 12 weeks the participants in the supervised group transitioned to a home-based program . Both groups were then reevaluated at the end of 24 weeks . The initial claudication distance ( ICD ) and absolute claudication distance ( ACD ) on progressive treadmill exercise was measured at baseline , 12 weeks , and 24 weeks . Additionally , self-reported quality of life status was evaluated using the MOS SF-36 question naire . RESULTS Each group improved ( P < 0.01 ) ACD from baseline to 12 weeks , which was sustained at the 24-week follow-up . Both groups experienced similar long-term improvements ( P < 0.05 ) in ACD ( 521.5 + /- 253.4 meters to 741.9 + /- 365.6 meters for the supervised group , 532.2 + /- 263.5 meters to 715.0 + /- 394.4 meters in the home group , P not significant , between groups ) . The supervised group experienced a greater improvement ( P < 0.01 ) in the ICD after 12 weeks than the home group but not at 24 weeks . The on-site group also experienced significant improvements in ICD after 24 weeks ( P < 0.05 ) . Neither group manifested an improvement in self-reported physical function or mental health as assessed by the MOS SF-36 . CONCLUSION A structured exercise program was more effective in improving the ICD over a 24-week period than a less formal , home-based program . However , if patients are screened properly and receive adequate instruction , a home-based program can be a safe , low-cost alternative providing similar long-term ( 24 weeks ) exercise benefits in ACD OBJECTIVE This cohort study was conducted to determine the effect on walking distances of supervised exercise therapy provided in a community-based setting . METHODS The study included all consecutive patients presenting at the vascular outpatient clinic with intermittent claudication , diagnosed by a resting ankle brachial index<0.9 , who had no previous peripheral vascular intervention for peripheral arterial disease , no major amputation , and sufficient comm and of the Dutch language . The exclusion criterion was the inability to walk the baseline treadmill test for a minimum of 10 m. The intervention was a supervised exercise therapy in a community-based setting . A progressive treadmill test at baseline and at 1 , 3 , and 6 months of follow-up measured initial claudication distance and absolute claudication distance . Changes were calculated using the mean percentages of change . RESULTS From January through October 2005 , 93 consecutive patients with claudication were eligible . Overall , 37 patients discontinued the supervised exercise therapy program . Eleven stopped because of intercurrent diseases , whereas for 10 , supervised exercise therapy did not lead to adequate improvement and they underwent a vascular intervention . Three patients quit the program , stating that they were satisfied with the regained walking distance and did not require further supervised exercise therapy . Ten patients were not motivated sufficiently to continue the program , and in three patients , a lack of adequate insurance coverage was the reason for dropping out . Data for 56 patients were used and showed a mean percentage increase in initial claudication distance of 187 % after 3 months and 240 % after 6 months . The mean percentage of the absolute claudication distance increased 142 % after 3 months and 191 % after 6 months . CONCLUSION Supervised exercise therapy in a community-based setting is a promising approach to providing conservative treatment for patients with intermittent claudication OBJECTIVE This study describes the results and functioning of community-based supervised exercise therapy ( SET ) at one year of follow-up . METHODS We conducted a prospect i ve cohort study of community-based SET in regional physiotherapeutic practice s. Consecutive patients with intermittent claudication referred for community-based SET were included . Exclusion criteria for SET were pain at rest or tissue loss . All patients received a diagnostic workup consisting of an ankle-brachial index at rest and after exercise . Interventions were exercise therapy according to the guidelines of the Royal Dutch Society for Physiotherapy . The primary outcome measurement was the increase in absolute claudication distance ( ACD ) , assessed using a st and ardized treadmill protocol by a physiotherapist at baseline and at four , 12 , 26 , and 52 weeks of SET . RESULTS From January 2005 through September 2006 , 349 patients were referred by vascular surgeons for community-based SET . A total of 272 patients with intermittent claudication began the program . Of the 349 initially referred patients , 52 could not perform a st and ard treadmill test but did start community-based SET at a lower level , and 25 patients never started the program . At one year , 129 of the original 272 patients who began community-based SET  ( 47.4 % ) were available for analysis of walking distance . In the interim , 143 patients discontinued the program for the following reasons : satisfaction with the acquired walking distance ( n = 19 ) ; unsatisfying results ( n = 26 ) ; not motivated ( n = 22 ) ; (non)vascular intercurrent disease ( n = 48 ) ; and other reasons ( n = 28 ) . ACD increased significantly from a median of 400 m at baseline to 1100 m after 12 months of follow-up ( P < .001 ) , corresponding to a median increase of 107.8 % . CONCLUSION Community-based SET seems as effective as SET in a hospital-based approach in improving walking distance , however , it has a high dropout rate Background — This prospect i ve , r and omized , controlled clinical trial compared changes in exercise performance and daily ambulatory activity in peripheral artery disease patients with intermittent claudication after a home-based exercise program , a supervised exercise program , and usual-care control . Methods and Results — Of the 119 patients r and omized , 29 completed home-based exercise  , 33 completed  supervised exercise , and 30 completed usual-care control . Both exercise programs consisted of intermittent walking to nearly maximal claudication pain for 12 weeks . Patients wore a step activity monitor during each exercise session . Primary outcome measures included claudication onset time and peak walking time obtained from a treadmill exercise test ; secondary outcome measures included daily ambulatory cadences measured during a 7-day monitoring period . Adherence to home-based and supervised exercise was similar ( P=0.712 ) and exceeded 80 % . Both exercise programs increased claudication onset time ( P<0.001 ) and peak walking time ( P<0.01 ) , whereas only home-based exercise increased daily average cadence ( P<0.01 ) . No changes were seen in the control group ( P>0.05 ) . The changes in claudication onset time and peak walking time were similar between the 2 exercise groups ( P>0.05 ) , whereas the change in daily average cadence was greater with home-based exercise ( P<0.05 ) . Conclusions — A home-based exercise program , quantified with a step activity monitor , has high adherence and is efficacious in improving claudication measures similar to a st and ard supervised exercise program . Furthermore , home-based exercise appears more efficacious in increasing daily ambulatory activity in the community setting than supervised exercise . Clinical Trial Registration — URL : http://www . Clinical Trials . Gov . Unique identifier : NCT00618670 OBJECTIVES The Exercise Therapy in Peripheral Arterial Disease ( EXITPAD ) study has shown supervised exercise therapy ( SET ) to be more effective regarding walking distance and quality of life than a ' go home and walk ' advice ( WA ) for patients with intermittent claudication . The present study aims to assess the cost-effectiveness of SET versus WA . PATIENTS AND METHODS Data from the EXITPAD study , a 12-month r and omised controlled trial in 304 patients with claudication , was used to study the proportion of costs to walking distance and quality of life . Two different incremental cost-effectiveness ratios ( ICERs ) were calculated for SET versus WA : costs per extra metre on the treadmill test , and costs per quality -adjusted life year ( QALY ) . QALYs were based on utilities derived from the EuroQoL-5 dimensions ( EQ-5D ) . RESULTS Mean total costs were higher for SET than for WA ( 3407 versus 2304 Euros ) , mainly caused by the costs of exercise therapy . The median walking distance was 620 m for SET and 400 m for  WA . QALYs were 0.71 for SET and 0.67 for WA . All differences were statistically significant . The ICER for cost per extra metre on the 12-month treadmill test was € 4.08 . For cost per QALY , the ICER was € 28,693 . CONCLUSION At a willingness-to-pay threshold of € 40,000 per QALY , SET likely is a cost-effective therapeutic option for patients with claudication OBJECTIVE Exercise advice is the main treatment for symptom relief in the UK for patients with mild to moderate Intermittent Claudication ( IC ) . Would a weekly exercise and motivation class for 6 months offer adjuvant benefit over written and verbal exercise advice alone ? PATIENTS AND METHODS Fifty-nine patients attending a regional vascular centre for whom IC was the main factor affecting mobility were r and omised to either exercise advice alone ( n=30 ) or exercise advice with a once a week 45 min supervised exercise/motivation class ( n=29 ) . The mean age was 68 years . Baseline and 6-month assessment included a Quality of Life Question naire -- the Short-Form-36 , the Charing Cross Symptom Specific Claudication Question naire ( CCCQ ) and treadmill walking distance ( 3.5 km/h 12 % ) . RESULTS At 6-month follow-up the supervised exercise group had improved their treadmill walking by 129 % compared to 69 % in the advice alone group ( p=0.001 ) . This significant improvement was maintained at the subsequent 9 and 12-month follow-up assessment s. By the 9-month stage the advice only group CCCQ score had improved 16 % from baseline , while the supervised exercise group had a significantly better 43 % improvement in base line score ( p<0.05 ) . Self reported frequency of walks was higher in the exercise class group being significant for improvement in CCCQ score . CONCLUSION A weekly , supervised exercise and motivation class for a 6-month period provides a significant improvement in patients ' symptoms , quality of life , and distance walked compared with advice alone and this improvement continues after attendance at class has ceased BACKGROUND Supervised treadmill-walking exercise programs have been proven to be a highly effective in improving walking distance in peripheral arterial disease ( PAD ) patients with lifestyle-limiting claudication . Limited information is available on the contributions of central cardiorespiratory functions for improving these patients ' walking capacity with exercise training . METHODS This study r and omized 28 participants ( 21 men ; age , 65.6 years ; 92.7 % smoking history , 36.6 % with diabetes ) with lifestyle-limiting PAD-related claudication to 3 hours/week of supervised exercise training for 12 weeks  , using arm-ergometry ( n = 10 ) or treadmill-walking ( n = 10 ) vs a usual-care control group ( n = 8) . Cardiorespiratory function measurements were assessed before and after training at a submaximal workload and at the onset of claudication ( pain-free walking distance [ PFWD ] ) and at maximal walking distance [ ( MWD ] ) . Changes in these functions from baseline were analyzed among the groups with analysis of covariance . Associations between variables were determined by Pearson 's partial correlations . RESULTS The mean baseline demographic , medical , and exercise variables were similar among the groups . There were similar significant differences in the submaximal double product ( heart rate × systolic blood pressure ) and at MWD , ventilatory threshold , ventilatory oxygen uptake ( VO(2 ) ) at onset of claudication , and VO(2 ) peak in response to training in both exercise groups vs the control group . Statistically significant , moderate correlations ( r = 0.60 - 0.68 ) were found between changes in all cardiorespiratory variables and changes in PFWD or MWD . CONCLUSION Improvements in cardiorespiratory function after arm-ergometry or treadmill-training were significantly associated with improvements in both PFWD and MWD , providing supporting evidence of systemic contributions to exercise training-related improvements in walking capacity seen in patients with claudication PURPOSE This study was performed to test the effectiveness of a formal supervised exercise program against a home-based exercise program for both walking ability and quality of life endpoints . METHODS Patients with arterial claudication were r and omized to either a 12-week supervised exercise program ( SUPEX ) with weekly lectures relating to peripheral vascular disease or to a home exercise group ( HOMEX ) who attended an identical lecture program and received weekly exercise instruction . The study population included 29 men and 26 women , with a mean age of 69.1 + /- 8.1 years . Forty-seven patients completed the 12-week program , 46 were available for testing at completion , and 38 for 6-month testing . Claudication pain time ( CPT ) and maximum walking time ( MWT ) on a progressive treadmill exercise test were assessed at baseline , program completion , and 6 months . The Medical Outcomes Study Short Form-36 ( SF-36 ) was administered at these intervals to assess effects on quality of life . RESULTS Each group improved ( p < 0.001 ) in both CPT and MWT at the completion of the 12-week program , which was sustained at the 6-month follow-up . Increase in HOMEX CPT from baseline ( 3.6 + /- 2.73 minutes ) to 6-month follow-up ( 6.6 + /- 3.17 minutes ) was less than for the SUPEX group ( 3.8 + /- 2.74 to 11.2 + /- 4.02 minutes , respectively ) ; similar results were obtained for MWT . At both completion and 6 months , there was a significant intergroup difference for CPT and MWT ( p < 0.004 ) favoring SUPEX . For both groups , measures of health perception based on the SF-36 demonstrated improvement ( p < 0.002 ) in Physical Function Subscale , Bodily Pain Subscale , and Physical Composite Score . There were no between-group differences on the subsets of the SF-36 at the three assessment intervals . CONCLUSIONS Supervised exercise programs provide superior increased walking ability in the noninterventional therapy of arterial claudication , and both supervised and home based exercise therapy result in improved SF-36 functional measures . The lack of intergroup differences in these measures may be a result of the high degree of interaction with healthcare providers in the HOMEX group . Although a supervised program results in optimal walking benefits , a highly structured home-based program provides similar functional improvement and may be a satisfactory alternative for patients with lesser walking requirements OBJECTIVES To compare the effect of unsupervised exercise , supervised exercise and intermittent pneumatic foot and calf compression ( IPC ) on the claudication distance , lower limb arterial haemodynamics and quality of life of patients with intermittent claudication . METHODS Thirty-four eligible patients with stable intermittent claudication were r and omised to IPC ( n = 13 , 3h/d for 6 months ) , supervised exercise ( n = 12 , three hourly sessions/week for 6 months ) or unsupervised exercise ( n = 9 ) . In each patient , initial claudication distance ( ICD ) , absolute claudication distance ( ACD ) , resting ankle brachial pressure index ( ABPI ) , and resting hyperaemic calf arterial inflow were measured before , 6 weeks , 6 months and 1 year after r and omisation . Quality of life was assessed with the short form (SF)-36 , walking impairment ( WIQ ) and intermittent claudication question naires ( ICQ ) . RESULTS Compared with unsupervised exercise , both IPC and supervised exercise , increased ICD and ACD , up to 2.83 times . IPC  increased arterial inflow ( p < 0.05 at 6 weeks ) and ABPI .  Supervised exercise decreased arterial inflow and increased ABPI ( p < 0.05 at 6 months ) . Unsupervised exercise had no effect on arterial inflow or ABPI . IPC improved significantly the ICQ score and the speed score of the WIQ , while supervised exercise improved the WIQ claudication severity score . At 1 year clinical effectiveness of supervised exercise and IPC was largely preserved . CONCLUSIONS IPC , by augmenting leg perfusion , achieved improvement in walking distance comparable with supervised exercise . Long-term results in a larger number of patients will provide valuable information on the optimal treatment modality of intermittent claudication INTRODUCTION Treatment of intermittent claudication ( IC ) due to peripheral arterial disease ( PAD ) is aim ed at improving walking distance and includes secondary prevention of cardiovascular disease . Both supervised exercise therapy ( SET ) and percutaneous transluminal angioplasty ( PTA ) have proven to be effective in increasing maximum and pain-free walking distance in IC . However , the optimal treatment strategy in patients with IC due to iliac artery stenosis or occlusion remains unclear . OBJECTIVE To compare the ( cost- ) effectiveness of initial PTA versus initial SET in patients with disabling IC due to an iliac artery obstruction . DESIGN In a multicentre r and omised controlled trial 400 consecutive patients with IC will be r and omly assigned to PTA ( with additional stent placement on indication ) or SET . Primary outcomes are maximum walking distance and health-related quality of life measured using the disease-specific VascuQol instrument after 1 year . Secondary outcomes are pain-free walking distance , functional status , generic quality of life , complications related to each of the interventions , additional interventions , treatment failures and costs ( cost-effectiveness and cost-utility ) after 1 year . CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATION S Based on the results of this proposed large study well-founded adjustments of existing guidelines on the treatment of iliac artery occlusive disease can be implemented ( Clinical Trials.gov NCT01385774 ; Nederl and s Trial Register NTR2776 ) BACKGROUND The first-line intervention for intermittent claudication is usually supervised exercise therapy ( SET ) . The literature describes a range of exercise programs varying in setting , duration , and content . The purpose of the present study was to examine the exercise protocol s offered and to identify the impact of the intensity of the SET programs ( in terms of frequency , duration , and type of exercise ) on improvements in walking distance ( response ) in the first 3 months . The present study is part of the Exercise Therapy in Peripheral Arterial Disease ( EXITPAD ) study , a multicenter r and omized clinical trial comparing the effects of SET provided by regional physiotherapists , with or without daily feedback , on the level of activities with the effects of walking advice . METHODS The analysis included patients r and omized to receive SET with or without feedback . The physical therapists administering the SET were asked to fill out therapy evaluation sheets stating frequency , duration , and type of exercises . The relationship between training volume and the impact on walking distance was explored by dividing training volume data into tertiles and relating them to the median change in maximum walking distance at 3 and 12 months . RESULTS Data of 169 patients were included in the analysis . A SET program consisting of at least two training sessions per week each lasting over 30 minutes , during the first 3 months of a 1-year program tailored to individual patients ' needs led to better results in terms of walking distance after 3 and 12 months than the other variants . The results of our analysis dividing training volume into tertiles suggest that there is a relationship between training volume and improvement in walking distance and that at least 590 minutes of training should be offered in the first 3 months . No differences were found between program involving only walking and a combination of exercises , nor between individual and group training . CONCLUSION A SET programs consisting of at least two training sessions a week , each lasting over 30 minutes , should be offered during the first 3 months of the SET program to optimize improvement in terms of maximum walking distance Previous studies have demonstrated that supervised strength training ( ST ) or walking training ( WT ) improve walking capacity in patients with claudication . However , it remains unknown whether these improvements would be sustained over a subsequent unsupervised period . This article reports the findings of a study to analyze whether the improvements in walking capacity , achieved with a supervised ST or WT , would be sustained over a subsequent unsupervised therapy period in patients with claudication . Patients were initially r and omized to supervised exercise consisting of ST  ( n = 15 ) or  WT  ( n = 15 ) for 12 weeks . After this period , 12 patients in each group consented to be followed for an additional 12 weeks of unsupervised therapy .  Initial claudication distance ( ICD ) and total walking distance ( TWD ) were measured at baseline , after the supervised period ( Week 12 ) and after the unsupervised period ( Week 24 ) . In comparison with baseline values , both groups similarly increased ICD and TWD at Week 12 . From Week 12 to Week 24 , both groups similarly decreased ICD ( ST : -55 ± 110 m and WT : -82 ± 142 m , P = .04 ) and TWD ( ST : -68 ± 186 m and WT : -128 ± 112 m , P < .01 ) . However , in both groups , ICD ( ST : + 126 ± 149 m and WT : + 50 ± 167 m , P = .01 ) and TWD ( ST : + 104 ± 162 m and WT : + 45 ± 139 m , P = .01 ) at Week 24 remained greater than baseline values . The conclusion is that supervised ST or WT followed by an unsupervised therapy period similarly decreased walking capacity in patients with claudication . However , after the unsupervised period , walking capacity remained at a higher level than before the onset of the supervised exercise-training period Abstract The efficacy of treadmill walking training to improve pain-free ( PFWD ) and maximal ( MWD ) walking distance in patients with claudication is well documented . The effects of aerobic arm-ergometry to improve PFWD and MWD compared to treadmill walking or usual care are not known . Forty-one participants ( 29 male , 12 female , mean age 67.7 years , 92.7 % smoking history , 36.6 % with diabetes ) with lifestyle-limiting claudication were r and omized to 12 weeks of 3 hours/week of supervised exercise training using either arm-ergometry , treadmill walking , or a combination , versus control .  PFWD and MWD were assessed before and after training , and after 12 weeks of follow-up . The 12-week MWD increased significantly in the arm-ergometry ( + 53 % ) , treadmill ( + 69 % ) , and combination ( + 68 % ) groups ( p < 0.002 versus control ) . The 24-week MWD was maintained in the arm-ergometry ( p = 0.009 ) and treadmill ( p = 0.019 ) groups , whereas the combination group declined ( p = 0.751 ) versus control . The 12-week PFWD increased significantly in the arm-ergometry group ( + 82 % ; p = 0.025 versus control ) . Change in PFWD in treadmill ( + 54 % ; p = 0.196 versus control ) and combination ( + 60 % ; p = 0.107 versus control ) groups did not reach statistical significance . PFWD improvement was maintained in the arm-ergometry group after a 12-week follow-up ( + 123 % ; p = 0.011 versus control ) . In conclusion , these pilot data demonstrate for the first time that dynamic arm exercise training can improve walking capability in people with peripheral arterial disease (PAD)-induced claudication compared to participants receiving usual care and that improvement was not different from that seen with treadmill walking exercise training . Dynamic arm exercise may be a therapeutic exercise option for patients with PAD OBJECTIVE Walking training ( WT ) is an established treatment for patients with intermittent claudication ( IC ) . Abnormalities specific to diabetes , such as a relative preponderance of distal lesions and the contribution of microcirculatory disease , might well influence the results of WT . We compared changes in walking distance during WT in diabetic patients with those in nondiabetic control subjects . RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS In consecutive patients with limiting IC and proven peripheral vascular disease , 33 patients with diabetes were compared with 136 control subjects during a  half-year supervised WT program .  Walking parameters were determined every 2 months , while vascular parameters were obtained at the start and end of the program . RESULTS Of the 33 diabetic patients , 25 ( 76 % ) completed the program , as did 87 of the 136 ( 64 % ) control subjects . Thereafter , the symptom-free walking distance and the maximum walking distance ( MWD ) were significantly increased in diabetic patients from 142 + /- 30 to 339 + /- 57 m and from 266 + /- 39 to 603 + /- 52 m , respectively , and in control subjects from 126 + /- 8 to 400 + /- 39 m and from 292 + /- 18 to 628 + /- 36 m , respectively . The relative gain in MWD was 88 % greater in those with diabetes . The vascular parameters were comparable for both groups before and after WT . CONCLUSIONS WT is an effective treatment for IC , with a greater relative gain in diabetic patients
The HBET group did not show improvement in MWD/T compared with the WA group ( SMD 0.30 , 95 % CI -0.45 to 1.05 ; P = 0.43 ; moderate- quality evidence ) .Compared with HBET , SET was more beneficial for PFWD/T but had no effect on quality of life parameters nor on self-reported functional impairment .
Compared with WA , SET was more beneficial for PFWD/T and self-reported functional impairment , as well as for some quality of life parameters ( e.g. , physical functioning , pain , and physical component summary after 12 months ) , and HBET had no effect .
Data show no obvious effects on mortality rates .
Evidence of moderate and high quality shows that SET provides an important benefit for treadmill-measured walking distance ( MWD and PFWD ) compared with HBET and WA , respectively .
Although its clinical relevance has not been definitively demonstrated , this benefit translates to increased MWD of 120 and 210 meters after three months in SET groups .
These increased walking distances are likely to have a positive impact on the lives of patients with IC .
Data provide no clear evidence of a difference between HBET and WA .
Trials show no clear differences in quality of life parameters nor in self-reported functional impairment between SET and HBET .
BACKGROUND Although supervised exercise therapy ( SET ) provides significant symptomatic benefit for patients with intermittent claudication ( IC ) , it remains an underutilized tool .
Widespread implementation of SET is restricted by lack of facilities and funding .
Structured home-based exercise therapy ( HBET ) with an observation component ( e.g. , exercise logbooks , pedometers ) and just walking advice ( WA ) are alternatives to SET .
This is the second up date of a review first published in 2006 .
OBJECTIVES The primary objective was to provide an accurate overview of studies evaluating effects of SET programs , HBET programs , and WA on maximal treadmill walking distance or time ( MWD/T ) for patients with IC .
Secondary objectives were to evaluate effects of SET , HBET , and WA on pain-free treadmill walking distance or time ( PFWD/T ) , quality of life , and self-reported functional impairment .