We present the first super-linear lower bounds for natural graph problems in the CONGEST model, answering a long-standing open question. Specifically, we show that any exact computation of a minimum vertex cover or a maximum independent set requires @math rounds in the worst case in the CONGEST model, as well as any algorithm for @math -coloring a graph, where @math is the chromatic number of the graph. We further show that such strong lower bounds are not limited to NP-hard problems, by showing two simple graph problems in P which require a quadratic and near-quadratic number of rounds. Finally, we address the problem of computing an exact solution to weighted all-pairs-shortest-paths (APSP), which arguably may be considered as a candidate for having a super-linear lower bound. We show a simple @math lower bound for this problem, which implies a separation between the weighted and unweighted cases, since the latter is known to have a complexity of @math . We also formally prove that the standard Alice-Bob framework is incapable of providing a super-linear lower bound for exact weighted APSP, whose complexity remains an intriguing open question.
Distance computation problems have also been considered in the CONGESTED-CLIQUE model @cite_58 @cite_54 @cite_4 , in which the underlying communication network forms a clique. In this model @cite_54 showed that unweighted APSP, and a @math -approximation for weighted APSP, can be computed in @math rounds.
@cite_54 @cite_58 @cite_4
2107805020 2950813619 1515635142 2951272922
We study the computation power of the congested clique, a model of distributed computation where n players communicate with each other over a complete network in order to compute some function of their inputs. The number of bits that can be sent on any edge in a round is bounded by a parameter b We consider two versions of the model: in the first, the players communicate by unicast, allowing them to send a different message on each of their links in one round; in the second, the players communicate by broadcast, sending one message to all their neighbors. It is known that the unicast version of the model is quite powerful; to date, no lower bounds for this model are known. In this paper we provide a partial explanation by showing that the unicast congested clique can simulate powerful classes of bounded-depth circuits, implying that even slightly super-constant lower bounds for the congested clique would give new lower bounds in circuit complexity. Moreover, under a widely-believed conjecture on matrix multiplication, the triangle detection problem, studied in [8], can be solved in O(ne) time for any e > 0. The broadcast version of the congested clique is the well-known multi-party shared-blackboard model of communication complexity (with number-in-hand input). This version is more amenable to lower bounds, and in this paper we show that the subgraph detection problem studied in [8] requires polynomially many rounds for several classes of subgraphs. We also give upper bounds for the subgraph detection problem, and relate the hardness of triangle detection in the broadcast congested clique to the communication complexity of set disjointness in the 3-party number-on-forehead model. In this work, we use algebraic methods for studying distance computation and subgraph detection tasks in the congested clique model. Specifically, we adapt parallel matrix multiplication implementations to the congested clique, obtaining an @math round matrix multiplication algorithm, where @math is the exponent of matrix multiplication. In conjunction with known techniques from centralised algorithmics, this gives significant improvements over previous best upper bounds in the congested clique model. The highlight results include: -- triangle and 4-cycle counting in @math rounds, improving upon the @math triangle detection algorithm of [DISC 2012], -- a @math -approximation of all-pairs shortest paths in @math rounds, improving upon the @math -round @math -approximation algorithm of Nanongkai [STOC 2014], and -- computing the girth in @math rounds, which is the first non-trivial solution in this model. In addition, we present a novel constant-round combinatorial algorithm for detecting 4-cycles. We study the broadcast version of the CONGEST CLIQUE model of distributed computing. In this model, in each round, any node in a network of size @math can send the same message (i.e. broadcast a message) of limited size to every other node in the network. Nanongkai presented in [STOC'14] a randomized @math -approximation algorithm to compute all pairs shortest paths (APSP) in time @math on weighted graphs, where we use the convention that @math is essentially @math polylog @math and @math is essentially @math polylog @math . We complement this result by proving that any randomized @math -approximation of APSP and @math -approximation of the diameter of a graph takes @math time in the worst case. This demonstrates that getting a negligible improvement in the approximation factor requires significantly more time. Furthermore this bound implies that already computing a @math -approximation of all pairs shortest paths is among the hardest graph-problems in the broadcast-version of the CONGEST CLIQUE model and contrasts a recent @math -approximation for APSP that runs in time @math in the unicast version of the CONGEST CLIQUE model. On the positive side we provide a deterministic version of Nanongkai's @math -approximation algorithm for APSP. To do so we present a fast deterministic construction of small hitting sets. We also show how to replace another randomized part within Nanongkai's algorithm with a deterministic source-detection algorithm designed for the CONGEST model presented by Lenzen and Peleg at PODC'13. The main results of this paper are (I) a simulation algorithm which, under quite general constraints, transforms algorithms running on the Congested Clique into algorithms running in the MapReduce model, and (II) a distributed @math -coloring algorithm running on the Congested Clique which has an expected running time of (i) @math rounds, if @math ; and (ii) @math rounds otherwise. Applying the simulation theorem to the Congested-Clique @math -coloring algorithm yields an @math -round @math -coloring algorithm in the MapReduce model. Our simulation algorithm illustrates a natural correspondence between per-node bandwidth in the Congested Clique model and memory per machine in the MapReduce model. In the Congested Clique (and more generally, any network in the @math model), the major impediment to constructing fast algorithms is the @math restriction on message sizes. Similarly, in the MapReduce model, the combined restrictions on memory per machine and total system memory have a dominant effect on algorithm design. In showing a fairly general simulation algorithm, we highlight the similarities and differences between these models.