Manual annotations of temporal bounds for object interactions (i.e. start and end times) are typical training input to recognition, localization and detection algorithms. For three publicly available egocentric datasets, we uncover inconsistencies in ground truth temporal bounds within and across annotators and datasets. We systematically assess the robustness of state-of-the-art approaches to changes in labeled temporal bounds, for object interaction recognition. As boundaries are trespassed, a drop of up to 10 is observed for both Improved Dense Trajectories and Two-Stream Convolutional Neural Network. We demonstrate that such disagreement stems from a limited understanding of the distinct phases of an action, and propose annotating based on the Rubicon Boundaries, inspired by a similarly named cognitive model, for consistent temporal bounds of object interactions. Evaluated on a public dataset, we report a 4 increase in overall accuracy, and an increase in accuracy for 55 of classes when Rubicon Boundaries are used for temporal annotations.
Previously, three works noted the challenge and difficulty in defining temporal bounds for egocentric videos @cite_16 @cite_15 @cite_29 . @cite_16 , Spriggs discussed the level of granularity in action labels (e.g. break egg' vs beat egg in a bowl') for the CMU dataset @cite_40 . They also noted the presence of temporally overlapping object interactions (e.g. pour' while stirring'). @cite_38 , multiple annotators were asked to provide temporal bounds for the same object interaction. The authors showed variability in annotations, yet did not detail what instructions were given to annotators when labeling these temporal bounds. @cite_29 , the human ability to order pairwise egocentric segments was evaluated as the snippet length varied. The work showed that human perception improves as the size of the segment increases to 60 frames, then levels off.
@cite_38 @cite_29 @cite_40 @cite_15 @cite_16
854053868 2033639255 2217598536 2964222622
While egocentric video is becoming increasingly popular, browsing it is very difficult. In this paper we present a compact 3D Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) architecture for long-term activity recognition in egocentric videos. Recognizing long-term activities enables us to temporally segment (index) long and unstructured egocentric videos. Existing methods for this task are based on hand tuned features derived from visible objects, location of hands, as well as optical flow. Given a sparse optical flow volume as input, our CNN classifies the camera wearer's activity. We obtain classification accuracy of 89 , which outperforms the current state-of-the-art by 19 . Additional evaluation is performed on an extended egocentric video dataset, classifying twice the amount of categories than current state-of-the-art. Furthermore, our CNN is able to recognize whether a video is egocentric or not with 99.2 accuracy, up by 24 from current state-of-the-art. To better understand what the network actually learns, we propose a novel visualization of CNN kernels as flow fields. Identifying handled objects, i.e. objects being manipulated by a user, is essential for recognizing the person's activities. An egocentric camera as worn on the body enjoys many advantages such as having a natural first-person view and not needing to instrument the environment. It is also a challenging setting, where background clutter is known to be a major source of problems and is difficult to handle with the camera constantly and arbitrarily moving. In this work we develop a bottom-up motion-based approach to robustly segment out foreground objects in egocentric video and show that it greatly improves object recognition accuracy. Our key insight is that egocentric video of object manipulation is a special domain and many domain-specific cues can readily help. We compute dense optical flow and fit it into multiple affine layers. We then use a max-margin classifier to combine motion with empirical knowledge of object location and background movement as well as temporal cues of support region and color appearance. We evaluate our segmentation algorithm on the large Intel Egocentric Object Recognition dataset with 42 objects and 100K frames. We show that, when combined with temporal integration, figure-ground segmentation improves the accuracy of a SIFT-based recognition system from 33 to 60 , and that of a latent-HOG system from 64 to 86 . On a minute-to-minute basis people undergo numerous fluid interactions with objects that barely register on a conscious level. Recent neuroscientific research demonstrates that humans have a fixed size prior for salient objects. This suggests that a salient object in 3D undergoes a consistent transformation such that people's visual system perceives it with an approximately fixed size. This finding indicates that there exists a consistent egocentric object prior that can be characterized by shape, size, depth, and location in the first person view. In this paper, we develop an EgoObject Representation, which encodes these characteristics by incorporating shape, location, size and depth features from an egocentric RGBD image. We empirically show that this representation can accurately characterize the egocentric object prior by testing it on an egocentric RGBD dataset for three tasks: the 3D saliency detection, future saliency prediction, and interaction classification. This representation is evaluated on our new Egocentric RGBD Saliency dataset that includes various activities such as cooking, dining, and shopping. By using our EgoObject representation, we outperform previously proposed models for saliency detection (relative 30 improvement for 3D saliency detection task) on our dataset. Additionally, we demonstrate that this representation allows us to predict future salient objects based on the gaze cue and classify people's interactions with objects. We bring together ideas from recent work on feature design for egocentric action recognition under one framework by exploring the use of deep convolutional neural networks (CNN). Recent work has shown that features such as hand appearance, object attributes, local hand motion and camera ego-motion are important for characterizing first-person actions. To integrate these ideas under one framework, we propose a twin stream network architecture, where one stream analyzes appearance information and the other stream analyzes motion information. Our appearance stream encodes prior knowledge of the egocentric paradigm by explicitly training the network to segment hands and localize objects. By visualizing certain neuron activation of our network, we show that our proposed architecture naturally learns features that capture object attributes and hand-object configurations. Our extensive experiments on benchmark egocentric action datasets show that our deep architecture enables recognition rates that significantly outperform state-of-the-art techniques – an average 6:6 increase in accuracy over all datasets. Furthermore, by learning to recognize objects, actions and activities jointly, the performance of individual recognition tasks also increase by 30 (actions) and 14 (objects). We also include the results of extensive ablative analysis to highlight the importance of network design decisions.