Recent advances in deep learning have pushed the performances of visual saliency models way further than it has ever been. Numerous models in the literature present new ways to design neural networks, to arrange gaze pattern data, or to extract as much high and low-level image features as possible in order to create the best saliency representation. However, one key part of a typical deep learning model is often neglected: the choice of the loss function. In this work, we explore some of the most popular loss functions that are used in deep saliency models. We demonstrate that on a fixed network architecture, modifying the loss function can significantly improve (or depreciate) the results, hence emphasizing the importance of the choice of the loss function when designing a model. We also introduce new loss functions that have never been used for saliency prediction to our knowledge. And finally, we show that a linear combination of several well-chosen loss functions leads to significant improvements in performances on different datasets as well as on a different network architecture, hence demonstrating the robustness of a combined metric.
There has been also a wave of models incorporating recurrent neural architectures. Han and Liu @cite_43 proposed a multi-scale architecture using convolutional long-short-term memory (ConvLSTM). It is followed by @cite_38 using a slight modified architecture using multiple layers in the encoder and a different loss function. Recurrent models of saliency prediction are more complex than feed-forward models and more difficult to train. Moreover, their performance is not yet significantly better than some recent feed-forward networks such as EML-NET @cite_17 .
@cite_43 @cite_17 @cite_38
2402146185 2890832667 2798322161 1934184906
Recurrent neural network architectures have been shown to efficiently model long term temporal dependencies between acoustic events. However the training time of recurrent networks is higher than feedforward networks due to the sequential nature of the learning algorithm. In this paper we propose a time delay neural network architecture which models long term temporal dependencies with training times comparable to standard feed-forward DNNs. The network uses sub-sampling to reduce computation during training. On the Switchboard task we show a relative improvement of 6 over the baseline DNN model. We present results on several LVCSR tasks with training data ranging from 3 to 1800 hours to show the effectiveness of the TDNN architecture in learning wider temporal dependencies in both small and large data scenarios. Recurrent neural networks (RNNs) such as long short-term memory and gated recurrent units are pivotal building blocks across a broad spectrum of sequence modeling problems. This paper proposes a recurrently controlled recurrent network (RCRN) for expressive and powerful sequence encoding. More concretely, the key idea behind our approach is to learn the recurrent gating functions using recurrent networks. Our architecture is split into two components - a controller cell and a listener cell whereby the recurrent controller actively influences the compositionality of the listener cell. We conduct extensive experiments on a myriad of tasks in the NLP domain such as sentiment analysis (SST, IMDb, Amazon reviews, etc.), question classification (TREC), entailment classification (SNLI, SciTail), answer selection (WikiQA, TrecQA) and reading comprehension (NarrativeQA). Across all 26 datasets, our results demonstrate that RCRN not only consistently outperforms BiLSTMs but also stacked BiLSTMs, suggesting that our controller architecture might be a suitable replacement for the widely adopted stacked architecture. Additionally, RCRN achieves state-of-the-art results on several well-established datasets. In this work, we apply state-of-the-art Convolutional Neural Network(CNN) architectures for saliency prediction. Our results show that better saliency features can be delivered by a deeper CNN model. However, it is very space-consuming to apply a complex model due to the large size of input images. The space complexity becomes even more problematic when we extract features from multiple convolutional layers or different models. In this paper, we propose a modular saliency system which aims at splitting the whole network into small modules. The main difference in our approach s that the encoder and decoder can be separately trained for the scalability. Furthermore, the encoder can contain more than one CNN model to extract features and the models can have different architectures or pre-trained on different datasets. This parallel design allows us to better utilize the computational space in order to apply more powerful encoder. More importantly, our network can be easily expanded almost without extra spaces, other pre-trained CNN models can be combined for a wider range of visual knowledge. We denote our expandable multi-layer network as EML-NET in this paper. Our method is evaluated on three public saliency benchmarks, SALICON, MIT300 and CAT2000. The proposed EML-NET achieves state-of-the-art results on the metric of Normalized Scanpath Saliency using a modified loss function. In recent years, the convolutional neural network (CNN) has achieved great success in many computer vision tasks. Partially inspired by neuroscience, CNN shares many properties with the visual system of the brain. A prominent difference is that CNN is typically a feed-forward architecture while in the visual system recurrent connections are abundant. Inspired by this fact, we propose a recurrent CNN (RCNN) for object recognition by incorporating recurrent connections into each convolutional layer. Though the input is static, the activities of RCNN units evolve over time so that the activity of each unit is modulated by the activities of its neighboring units. This property enhances the ability of the model to integrate the context information, which is important for object recognition. Like other recurrent neural networks, unfolding the RCNN through time can result in an arbitrarily deep network with a fixed number of parameters. Furthermore, the unfolded network has multiple paths, which can facilitate the learning process. The model is tested on four benchmark object recognition datasets: CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100, MNIST and SVHN. With fewer trainable parameters, RCNN outperforms the state-of-the-art models on all of these datasets. Increasing the number of parameters leads to even better performance. These results demonstrate the advantage of the recurrent structure over purely feed-forward structure for object recognition.