Clustering is ubiquitous in data analysis, including analysis of time series. It is inherently subjective: different users may prefer different clusterings for a particular dataset. Semi-supervised clustering addresses this by allowing the user to provide examples of instances that should (not) be in the same cluster. This paper studies semi-supervised clustering in the context of time series. We show that COBRAS, a state-of-the-art active semi-supervised clustering method, can be adapted to this setting. We refer to this approach as COBRASTS. An extensive experimental evaluation supports the following claims: (1) COBRASTS far outperforms the current state of the art in semi-supervised clustering for time series, and thus presents a new baseline for the field; (2) COBRASTS can identify clusters with separated components; (3) COBRASTS can identify clusters that are characterized by small local patterns; (4) actively querying a small amount of semi-supervision can greatly improve clustering quality for time series; (5) the choice of the clustering algorithm matters (contrary to earlier claims in the literature).
Traditional methods assume that a set of pairwise queries is given prior to running the clustering algorithm, and in practice, pairs are often queried randomly. Active semi-supervised clustering methods try to query the most informative pairs first, instead of random ones @cite_8 . Typically, this results in better clusterings for an equal number of queries. COBRAS @cite_15 is a recently proposed active semi-supervised clustering method that was shown to be effective for clustering attribute-value data. In this paper, we show that it can be used to cluster time series with little modification. We describe COBRAS in more detail in the next section.
@cite_15 @cite_8
2794502420 1595562640 2153839362 2135914502
Constraint-based clustering algorithms exploit background knowledge to construct clusterings that are aligned with the interests of a particular user. This background knowledge is often obtained by allowing the clustering system to pose pairwise queries to the user: should these two elements be in the same cluster or not? Active clustering methods aim to minimize the number of queries needed to obtain a good clustering by querying the most informative pairs first. Ideally, a user should be able to answer a couple of these queries, inspect the resulting clustering, and repeat these two steps until a satisfactory result is obtained. We present COBRAS, an approach to active clustering with pairwise constraints that is suited for such an interactive clustering process. A core concept in COBRAS is that of a super-instance: a local region in the data in which all instances are assumed to belong to the same cluster. COBRAS constructs such super-instances in a top-down manner to produce high-quality results early on in the clustering process, and keeps refining these super-instances as more pairwise queries are given to get more detailed clusterings later on. We experimentally demonstrate that COBRAS produces good clusterings at fast run times, making it an excellent candidate for the iterative clustering scenario outlined above. Semi-supervised clustering seeks to augment traditional clustering methods by incorporating side information provided via human expertise in order to increase the semantic meaningfulness of the resulting clusters. However, most current methods are in the sense that the side information is provided beforehand and selected randomly. This may require a large number of constraints, some of which could be redundant, unnecessary, or even detrimental to the clustering results. Thus in order to scale such semi-supervised algorithms to larger problems it is desirable to pursue an clustering method---i.e. an algorithm that maximizes the effectiveness of the available human labor by only requesting human input where it will have the greatest impact. Here, we propose a novel online framework for active semi-supervised spectral clustering that selects pairwise constraints as clustering proceeds, based on the principle of uncertainty reduction. Using a first-order Taylor expansion, we decompose the expected uncertainty reduction problem into a gradient and a step-scale, computed via an application of matrix perturbation theory and cluster-assignment entropy, respectively. The resulting model is used to estimate the uncertainty reduction potential of each sample in the dataset. We then present the human user with pairwise queries with respect to only the best candidate sample. We evaluate our method using three different image datasets (faces, leaves and dogs), a set of common UCI machine learning datasets and a gene dataset. The results validate our decomposition formulation and show that our method is consistently superior to existing state-of-the-art techniques, as well as being robust to noise and to unknown numbers of clusters. Semi-supervised clustering uses a small amount of supervised data to aid unsupervised learning. One typical approach specifies a limited number of must-link and cannotlink constraints between pairs of examples. This paper presents a pairwise constrained clustering framework and a new method for actively selecting informative pairwise constraints to get improved clustering performance. The clustering and active learning methods are both easily scalable to large datasets, and can handle very high dimensional data. Experimental and theoretical results confirm that this active querying of pairwise constraints significantly improves the accuracy of clustering when given a relatively small amount of supervision. Semi-supervised clustering allows a user to specify available prior knowledge about the data to improve the clustering performance. A common way to express this information is in the form of pair-wise constraints. A number of studies have shown that, in general, these constraints improve the resulting data partition. However, the choice of constraints is critical since improperly chosen constraints might actually degrade the clustering performance. We focus on constraint (also known as query) selection for improving the performance of semi-supervised clustering algorithms. We present an active query selection mechanism, where the queries are selected using a min-max criterion. Experimental results on a variety of datasets, using MPCK-means as the underlying semi-clustering algorithm, demonstrate the superior performance of the proposed query selection procedure.