Fast algorithms for optimal multi-robot path planning are sought after in real-world applications. Known methods, however, generally do not simultaneously guarantee good solution optimality and good (e.g., polynomial) running time. In this work, we develop a first low-polynomial running time algorithm, called SplitAngGroup (SaG), that solves the multi-robot path planning problem on grids and grid-like environments, and produces constant factor makespan optimal solutions on average over all problem instances. That is, SaG is an average case O(1)-approximation algorithm and computes solutions with sub-linear makespan. SaG is capable of handling cases when the density of robots is extremely high - in a graph-theoretic setting, the algorithm supports cases where all vertices of the underlying graph are occupied. SaG attains its desirable properties through a careful combination of a novel divide-and-conquer technique, which we denote as global decoupling, and network flow based methods for routing the robots. Solutions from SaG, in a weaker sense, are also a constant factor approximation on total distance optimality.
Similar to single robot problems involving potentially many degrees of freedom @cite_69 @cite_73 , multi-robot path planning is strongly NP-hard even for discs in simple polygons @cite_9 and PSPACE-hard for translating rectangles @cite_43 . The hardness of the problem extends to unlabeled case @cite_50 where it remains highly intractable @cite_46 @cite_64 . Nevertheless, under appropriate settings, the unlabeled case can be solved near optimally @cite_6 @cite_62 @cite_36 @cite_29 .
@cite_69 @cite_64 @cite_62 @cite_36 @cite_9 @cite_29 @cite_6 @cite_43 @cite_50 @cite_46 @cite_73
2170220350 1628219785 1485718613 2191404279
We present new techniques for establishing lower bounds in robot motion planning problems. Our scheme is based on path encoding and uses homotopy equivalence classes of paths to encode state. We first apply the method to the shortest path problem in 3 dimensions. The problem is to find the shortest path under an Lp metric (e.g. a euclidean metric) between two points amid polyhedral obstacles. Although this problem has been extensively studied, there were no previously known lower bounds. We show that there may be exponentially many shortest path classes in single-source multiple-destination problems, and that the single-source single-destination problem is NP-hard. We use a similar proof technique to show that two dimensional dynamic motion planning with bounded velocity is NP-hard. Finally we extend the technique to compliant motion planning with uncertainty in control. Specifically, we consider a point in 3 dimensions which is commanded to move in a straight line, but whose actual motion may differ from the commanded motion, possibly involving sliding against obstacles. Given that the point initially lies in some start region, the problem of finding a sequence of commanded velocities which is guaranteed to move the point to the goal is shown to be non-deterministic exponential time hard, making it the first provably intractable problem in robotics. We consider the following motion-planning problem: we are given @math unit discs in a simple polygon with @math vertices, each at their own start position, and we want to move the discs to a given set of @math target positions. Contrary to the standard (labeled) version of the problem, each disc is allowed to be moved to any target position, as long as in the end every target position is occupied. We show that this unlabeled version of the problem can be solved in @math time, assuming that the start and target positions are at least some minimal distance from each other. This is in sharp contrast to the standard (labeled) and more general multi-robot motion planning problem for discs moving in a simple polygon, which is known to be strongly NP-hard. In unlabeled multi-robot motion planning several interchangeable robots operate in a common workspace. The goal is to move the robots to a set of target positions such that each position will be occupied by some robot. In this paper, we study this problem for the specific case of unit-square robots moving amidst polygonal obstacles and show that it is PSPACE-hard. We also consider three additional variants of this problem and show that they are all PSPACE-hard as well. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first hardness proof for the unlabeled case. Furthermore, our proofs can be used to show that the labeled variant (where each robot is assigned with a specific target position), again, for unit-square robots, is PSPACE-hard as well, which sets another precedence, as previous hardness results require the robots to be of different shapes. In this paper, we study the structure and computational complexity of optimal multi-robot path planning problems on graphs. Our results encompass three formulations of the discrete multi-robot path planning problem, including a variant that allows synchronous rotations of robots along fully occupied, disjoint cycles on the graph. Allowing rotation of robots provides a more natural model for multi-robot path planning because robots can communicate. Our optimality objectives are to minimize the total arrival time, the makespan (last arrival time), and the total distance. On the structure side, we show that, in general, these objectives demonstrate a pairwise Pareto optimal structure and cannot be simultaneously optimized. On the computational complexity side, we extend previous work and show that, regardless of the underlying multi-robot path planning problem, these objectives are all intractable to compute. In particular, our NP-hardness proof for the time optimal versions, based on a minimal and direct reduction from the 3-satisfiability problem, shows that these problems remain NP-hard even when there are only two groups of robots (i.e. robots within each group are interchangeable).