Although artificial intelligence holds promise for addressing societ al challenges, issues of exactly which tasks to automate and the extent to do so remain understudied. We approach the problem of task delegability from a human-centered perspective by developing a framework on human perception of task delegation to artificial intelligence. We consider four high-level factors that can contribute to a delegation decision: motivation, difficulty, risk, and trust. To obtain an empirical understanding of human preferences in different tasks, we build a dataset of 100 tasks from academic papers, popular media portrayal of AI, and everyday life. For each task, we administer a survey to collect judgments of each factor and ask subjects to pick the extent to which they prefer AI involvement. We find little preference for full AI control and a strong preference for machine-in-the-loop designs, in which humans play the leading role. Our framework can effectively predict human preferences in degrees of AI assistance. Among the four factors, trust is the most predictive of human preferences of optimal human-machine delegation. This framework represents a first step towards characterizing human preferences of automation across tasks. We hope this work may encourage and aid in future efforts towards understanding such individual attitudes; our goal is to inform the public and the AI research community rather than dictating any direction in technology development.
Shared-control design paradigms. Many tasks are amen-able to a mix of human and machine control. Mixed-initiative systems and collaborative control have gained traction over function allocation @cite_26 @cite_38 , mainly through recognition that such systems can transform the task itself through conflicts and interdependence @cite_34 .
@cite_38 @cite_26 @cite_34
2592413607 2333632897 1541772155 1568126255
Shared control is a key technology for various robotic applications in which a robotic system and a human operator are meant to collaborate efficiently. In order to achieve efficient task execution in shared control, it is essential to predict the desired behavior for a given situation or context in order to simplify the control task for the human operator. This prediction is obtained by exploiting Learning from Demonstration (LfD), which is a popular approach for transferring human skills to robots. We encode the demonstrated behavior as trajectory distributions and generalize the learned distributions to new situations. The goal of this paper is to present a shared control framework that uses learned expert distributions to gain more autonomy. Our approach controls the balance between the controller's autonomy and the human preference based on the distributions of the demonstrated trajectories. Moreover, the learned distributions are autonomously refined from collaborative task executions, resulting in a master-slave system with increasing autonomy that requires less user input with an increasing number of task executions. We experimentally validated that our shared control approach enables efficient task executions. Moreover, the conducted experiments demonstrated that the developed system improves its performances through interactive task executions with our shared control. In this letter, we propose a framework for task allocation in human-robot collaborative assembly planning. Our framework distinguishes between two main layers of abstraction and allocation. In the higher layer, we use an abstract world model, incorporating a multiagent human-robot team approach in order to describe the collaborative assembly planning problem. From this, nominal co-ordinated skill sequences for every agent are produced. In order to be able to treat humans and robots as agents of the same form, we move relevant differences peculiarities into distinct cost functions. The layer beneath handles the concrete skill execution. On atomic level, skills are composed of complex hierarchical and concurrent hybrid state machines, which in turn co-ordinate the real-time behavior of the robot. Their careful design allows to cope with unpredictable events also on decisional level without having to explicitly plan for them, instead one may rely also on manually designed skills. Such events are likely to happen in dynamic and potentially partially known environments, which is especially true in case of human presence. In the next decades, practically viable robotic agent systems are going to be mixed-initiative in nature. Humans will request help from such systems and such systems will request help from humans in achieving the complex mission tasks required. Pragmatically, one requires a distributed task specification language to define tasks and a suitable data structure which satisfies the specification and can be used flexibly by collaborative multi-agent robotic systems. This paper defines such a task specification language and an abstract data structure called Task Specification Trees which has many of the requisite properties required for mixed-initiative problem solving and adjustable autonomy in a distributed context. A prototype system has been implemented for this delegation framework and has been used practically with collaborative unmanned aircraft systems. Tele-operated systems allow humans to extend their physical capabilities and enable them to intervene in hazardous operations or where their presence is not possible. However, the operation of such systems over long periods has proved to be difficult and stressful. Consequently, means to facilitate their use are the subject of much study and experimental work. In this paper, we propose a collaborative-shared control strategy that combines the operator abilities with robotic-based tasks to render these systems more flexible and robust. In our method, the collaborative control component is responsible for allowing operator intervention when the robot is facing complex situations, whilst the shared control component provides an automatic control mechanism to assist and to monitor-correct irrational operator actions. The paper demonstrates how collaborative and shared control strategies work together to facilitate the teleoperated control of a mobile platform in a cluttered environment. The experimental results include applications to surveillance and to search & rescue operations. In addition, a key component in the form of a hybrid obstacle avoidance module is introduced that allows the robot to be guided on a task basis by the operator at a distance.