Automatic attribute discovery methods have gained in popularity to extract sets of visual attributes from images or videos for various tasks. Despite their good performance in some classification tasks, it is difficult to evaluate whether the attributes discovered by these methods are meaningful and which methods are the most appropriate to discover attributes for visual descriptions. In its simplest form, such an evaluation can be performed by manually verifying whether there is any consistent identifiable visual concept distinguishing between positive and negative exemplars labelled by an attribute. This manual checking is tedious, expensive and labour intensive. In addition, comparisons between different methods could also be problematic as it is not clear how one could quantitatively decide which attribute is more meaningful than the others. In this paper, we propose a novel attribute meaningfulness metric to address this challenging problem. With this metric, automatic quantitative evaluation can be performed on the attribute sets; thus, reducing the enormous effort to perform manual evaluation. The proposed metric is applied to some recent automatic attribute discovery and hashing methods on four attribute-labelled datasets. To further validate the efficacy of the proposed method, we conducted a user study. In addition, we also compared our metric with a semi-supervised attribute discover method using the mixture of probabilistic PCA. In our evaluation, we gleaned several insights that could be beneficial in developing new automatic attribute discovery methods.
In our previous work, the shared structure assumption is utilized @cite_35 . In particular, the work in @cite_35 proposed a selection approach of attribute discovery methods to assist attribute-based keywords generation for video description from surveillance systems. However, the work did not consider quantitative analysis of the meaningfulness of the discovered attributes ( how much meaningful content is contained in a set of automatically discovered attributes). In addition, the characteristics of the meaningfulness of attributes may vary to some extent.
@cite_35
2963381215 2152984213 1967988963 2022303741
Automatic video keyword generation is one of the key ingredients in reducing the burden of security officers in analyzing surveillance videos. Keywords or attributes are generally chosen manually based on expert knowledge of surveillance. Most existing works primarily aim at either supervised learning approaches relying on extensive manual labelling or hierarchical probabilistic models that assume the features are extracted using the bag-of-words approach; thus limiting the utilization of the other features. To address this, we turn our attention to automatic attribute discovery approaches. However, it is not clear which automatic discovery approach can discover the most meaningful attributes. Furthermore, little research has been done on how to compare and choose the best automatic attribute discovery methods. In this paper, we propose a novel approach, based on the shared structure exhibited amongst meaningful attributes, that enables us to compare between different automatic attribute discovery approaches. We then validate our approach by comparing various attribute discovery methods such as PiCoDeS on two attribute datasets. The evaluation shows that our approach is able to select the automatic discovery approach that discovers the most meaningful attributes. We then employ the best discovery approach to generate keywords for videos recorded from a surveillance system. This work shows it is possible to massively reduce the amount of manual work in generating video keywords without limiting ourselves to a particular video feature descriptor. We present a holistic data-driven technique that generates natural-language descriptions for videos. We combine the output of state-of-the-art object and activity detectors with "real-world" knowledge to select the most probable subject-verb-object triplet for describing a video. We show that this knowledge, automatically mined from web-scale text corpora, enhances the triplet selection algorithm by providing it contextual information and leads to a four-fold increase in activity identification. Unlike previous methods, our approach can annotate arbitrary videos without requiring the expensive collection and annotation of a similar training video corpus. We evaluate our technique against a baseline that does not use text-mined knowledge and show that humans prefer our descriptions 61 of the time. Visually identifying a target individual reliably in a crowded environment observed by a distributed camera network is critical to a variety of tasks in managing business information, border control, and crime prevention. Automatic re-identification of a human candidate from public space CCTV video is challenging due to spatiotemporal visual feature variations and strong visual similarity between different people, compounded by low-resolution and poor quality video data. In this work, we propose a novel method for re-identification that learns a selection and weighting of mid-level semantic attributes to describe people. Specifically, the model learns an attribute-centric, parts-based feature representation. This differs from and complements existing low-level features for re-identification that rely purely on bottom-up statistics for feature selection, which are limited in discriminating and identifying reliably visual appearances of target people appearing in different camera views under certain degrees of occlusion due to crowdedness. Our experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach compared to existing feature representations when applied to benchmarking datasets. This paper presents an efficient approach for copies detection in a large videos archive consisting of several hundred of hours. The video content indexing method consists of extracting the dynamic behavior on the local description of interest points and further on the estimation of their trajectories along the video sequence. Analyzing the low-level description obtained allows to highlight trends of behaviors and then to assign a label of behavior to each local descriptor. Such an indexing approach has several interesting properties: it provides a rich, compact and generic description, while labels of behavior provide a high-level description of the video content. Here, we focus on video Content Based Copy Detection (CBCD). Copy detection is problematic as similarity search problem but with prominent differences. To be efficient, it requires a dedicated on-line retrieval method based on a specific voting function. This voting function must be robust to signal transformations and discriminating versus high similarities which are not copies. The method we propose in this paper is a dedicated on-line retrieval method based on a combination of the different dynamic contexts computed during the off-line indexing. A spatio-temporal registration based on the relevant combination of detected labels is then applied. This approach is evaluated using a huge video database of 300 hours with different video tests. The method is compared to a state-of-the art technique in the same conditions. We illustrate that taking labels into account in the specific voting process reduces false alarms significantly and drastically improves the precision.