We revisit a particular visual grounding method: the "Image Retrieval Using Scene Graphs" (IRSG) system of (2015). Our experiments indicate that the system does not effectively use its learned object-relationship models. We also look closely at the IRSG dataset, as well as the widely used Visual Relationship Dataset (VRD) that is adapted from it. We find that these datasets exhibit biases that allow methods that ignore relationships to perform relatively well. We also describe several other problems with the IRSG dataset, and report on experiments using a subset of the dataset in which the biases and other problems are removed. Our studies contribute to a more general effort: that of better understanding what machine learning methods that combine language and vision actually learn and what popular datasets actually test.
Visual grounding is different from, though related to, tasks such as visual relationship detection @cite_9 , in which the task is not to ground a particular phrase in an image, but to detect all known relationships. The VRD dataset we described above is commonly used in visual relationship detection tasks, and to our knowledge there are no prior studies of bias and other problems in this dataset.
@cite_9
2770106191 2962811161 2554334383 2896603934
Reasoning about the relationships between object pairs in images is a crucial task for holistic scene understanding. Most of the existing works treat this task as a pure visual classification task: each type of relationship or phrase is classified as a relation category based on the extracted visual features. However, each kind of relationships has a wide variety of object combination and each pair of objects has diverse interactions. Obtaining sufficient training samples for all possible relationship categories is difficult and expensive. In this work, we propose a natural language guided framework to tackle this problem. We propose to use a generic bi-directional recurrent neural network to predict the semantic connection between the participating objects in the relationship from the aspect of natural language. The proposed simple method achieves the state-of-the-art on the Visual Relationship Detection (VRD) and Visual Genome datasets, especially when predicting unseen relationships (e.g. recall improved from 76.42 to 89.79 on VRD zero-shot testing set). This paper presents a framework for localization or grounding of phrases in images using a large collection of linguistic and visual cues. We model the appearance, size, and position of entity bounding boxes, adjectives that contain attribute information, and spatial relationships between pairs of entities connected by verbs or prepositions. Special attention is given to relationships between people and clothing or body part mentions, as they are useful for distinguishing individuals. We automatically learn weights for combining these cues and at test time, perform joint inference over all phrases in a caption. The resulting system produces state of the art performance on phrase localization on the Flickr30k Entities dataset [33] and visual relationship detection on the Stanford VRD dataset [27]. This paper presents a framework for localization or grounding of phrases in images using a large collection of linguistic and visual cues. We model the appearance, size, and position of entity bounding boxes, adjectives that contain attribute information, and spatial relationships between pairs of entities connected by verbs or prepositions. We pay special attention to relationships between people and clothing or body part mentions, as they are useful for distinguishing individuals. We automatically learn weights for combining these cues and at test time, perform joint inference over all phrases in a caption. The resulting system produces a 5 improvement in accuracy over the state of the art on phrase localization on the Flickr30k Entities dataset and a 4-10 improvement for visual relationship detection on the Stanford VRD dataset. Visual relationship detection, which aims to predict a triplet with the detected objects, has attracted increasing attention in the scene understanding study. During tackling this problem, dealing with varying scales of the subjects and objects is of great importance, which has been less studied. To overcome this challenge, we propose a novel Vision Spatial Attention Network (VSA-Net), which employs a two-dimensional normal distribution attention scheme to effectively model small objects. In addition, we design a Subject-Object-layer (SO-layer) to distinguish between the subject and object to attain more precise results. To the best of our knowledge, VSA-Net is the first end-to-end attention mechanism based visual relationship detection model. Extensive experiments on the benchmark datasets (VRD and VG) show that, by using pure vision information, our VSA-Net achieves state-of-the-art performance for predicate detection, phrase detection, and relationship detection.