When studying multi-body protein complexes, biochemists use computational tools that can suggest hundreds or thousands of their possible spatial configurations. However, it is not feasible to experimentally verify more than only a very small subset of them. In this paper, we propose a novel multiscale visual drilldown approach that was designed in tight collaboration with proteomic experts, enabling a systematic exploration of the configuration space. Our approach takes advantage of the hierarchical structure of the data -- from the whole ensemble of protein complex configurations to the individual configurations, their contact interfaces, and the interacting amino acids. Our new solution is based on interactively linked 2D and 3D views for individual hierarchy levels and at each level, we offer a set of selection and filtering operations enabling the user to narrow down the number of configurations that need to be manually scrutinized. Furthermore, we offer a dedicated filter interface, which provides the users with an overview of the applied filtering operations and enables them to examine their impact on the explored ensemble. This way, we maintain the history of the exploration process and thus enable the user to return to an earlier point of the exploration. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach on two case studies conducted by collaborating proteomic experts.
One of the first tools designed primarily for multi-body docking was CombDock @cite_10 . The algorithm works on a principle of hierarchical construction of the complex from smaller subunits and a greedy selection of the best-ranking subunits. The combinatorial step is followed by the reduction of solutions based on RMSD and a scoring function. Multi--LZerD @cite_24 uses a genetic algorithm to generate complexes from initial pairwise docks and applies an energy minimization structure refinement procedure for the ranking of the solutions. @cite_13 proposed an ant colony optimization approach to solve the combinatorial problem. DockStar @cite_33 formulates the task of detecting the spatial conformation of a protein complex as an Integer Linear Program. Unlike other methods, it also integrates experimental data from mass spectrometry into the scoring of the solutions. Another tool reusing pairwise docks in combination with experimental data is PRISM-EM @cite_14 . It uses density maps from cryo-electron microscopy for guiding the placement of subunits.
@cite_13 @cite_14 @cite_33 @cite_24 @cite_10
2005303043 2159653313 2101980405 2087151779
The majority of proteins function when associated in multimolecular assemblies. Yet, prediction of the structures of multimolecular complexes has largely not been addressed, probably due to the magnitude of the combinatorial complexity of the problem. Docking applications have traditionally been used to predict pairwise interactions between molecules. We have developed an algorithm that extends the application of docking to multimolecular assemblies. We apply it to predict quaternary structures of both oligomers and multi-protein complexes. The algorithm predicted well a near-native arrangement of the input subunits for all cases in our data set, where the number of the subunits of the different target complexes varied from three to ten. In order to simulate a more realistic scenario, unbound cases were tested. In these cases the input conformations of the subunits are either unbound conformations of the subunits or a model obtained by a homology modeling technique. The successful predictions of the unbound cases, where the input conformations of the subunits are different from their conformations within the target complex, suggest that the algorithm is robust. We expect that this type of algorithm should be particularly useful to predict the structures of large macromolecular assemblies, which are difficult to solve by experimental structure determination. Many biological processes are governed by large assemblies of protein molecules. However, it is often very difficult to determine the three-dimensional structures of these assemblies using experimental biophysical techniques. Hence there is a need to develop computational approaches to fill this gap. This article presents an ant colony optimization approach to predict the structure of large multi-component protein complexes. Starting from pair-wise docking predictions, a multi-graph consisting of vertices representing the component proteins and edges representing candidate interactions is constructed. This allows the assembly problem to be expressed in terms of searching for a minimum weight spanning tree. However, because the problem remains highly combinatorial, the search space cannot be enumerated exhaustively and therefore heuristic optimisation techniques must be used. The utility of the ant colony based approach is demonstrated by re-assembling known protein complexes from the Protein Data Bank. The algorithm is able to identify near-native solutions for five of the six cases tested. This demonstrates that the ant colony approach provides a useful way to deal with the highly combinatorial multi-component protein assembly problem. The tertiary structures of protein complexes provide a crucial insight about the molecular mechanisms that regulate their functions and assembly. However, solving protein complex structures by experimental methods is often more difficult than single protein structures. Here, we have developed a novel computational multiple protein docking algorithm, Multi-LZerD, that builds models of multimeric complexes by effectively reusing pairwise docking predictions of component proteins. A genetic algorithm is applied to explore the conformational space followed by a structure refinement procedure. Benchmark on eleven hetero-multimeric complexes resulted in near native conformations for all but one of them (a root mean square deviation smaller than 2.5A). We also show that our method copes with unbound docking cases well, outperforming the methodology that can be directly compared to our approach. Multi-LZerD was able to predict near native structures for multimeric complexes of various topologies. Here we present a novel technique for the alignment of flexible proteins. The method does not require an a priori knowledge of the flexible hinge regions. The FlexProt algorithm simultaneously detects the hinge regions and aligns the rigid subparts of the molecules. Our technique is not sensitive to insertions and deletions. Numerous methods have been developed to solve rigid structural comparisons. Unlike FlexProt, all previously developed methods designed to solve the protein flexible alignment require an a priori knowledge of the hinge regions. The FlexProt method is based on 3-D pattern-matching algorithms combined with graph theoretic techniques. The algorithm is highly efficient. For example, it performs a structural comparison of a pair of proteins with 300 amino acids in about 7 s on a 400-MHz desktop PC. We provide experimental results obtained with this algorithm. First, we flexibly align pairs of proteins taken from the database of motions. These are extended by taking additional proteins from the same SCOP family. Next, we present some of the results obtained from exhaustive all-against-all flexible structural comparisons of 1329 SCOP family representatives. Our results include relatively high-scoring flexible structural alignments between the C-terminal merozoite surface protein vs. tissue factor; class II aminoacyl-tRNA synthase, histocompatibility antigen vs. neonatal FC receptor; tyrosine-protein kinase C-SRC vs. haematopoetic cell kinase (HCK); tyrosine-protein kinase C-SRC vs. titine protein (autoinhibited serine kinase domain); and tissue factor vs. hormone-binding protein. These are illustrated and discussed, showing the capabilities of this structural alignment algorithm, which allows un-predefined hinge-based motions. Proteins 2002;48:242–256. © 2002 Wiley-Liss, Inc.