We present and evaluate an approach for human-in-the-loop specification of shape reconstruction with annotations for basic robot-object interactions. Our method is based on the idea of model annotation: the addition of simple cues to an underlying object model to specify shape and delineate a simple task. The goal is to explore reducing the complexity of CAD-like interfaces so that novice users can quickly recover an object's shape and describe a manipulation task that is then carried out by a robot. The object modeling and interaction annotation capabilities are tested with a user study and compared against results obtained using existing approaches. The approach has been analyzed using a variety of shape comparison, grasping, and manipulation metrics, and tested with the PR2 robot platform, where it was shown to be successful.
Humans are excellent at quickly arriving at functional grasps, even for novel objects. We have the advantage of context and experience to help guide our choice. Whether for direct grasp suggestions, or for creating labeled model data, human annotations have been widely used. Human action may be observed and used under the LfD strategy and then processed to generate robot grasps @cite_130 . Alternatively, human input can serve to label grasping databases or to interactively choose grasps @cite_60 . In summary, a range of automatic and interactive methods exist that can use either raw perception and automation or existing models to obtain grasps. For a survey on data-driven grasp synthesis, see @cite_122 .
@cite_130 @cite_122 @cite_60
1489279189 2951159816 2106215490
We present a novel and simple experimental method called physical human interactive guidance to study human-planned grasping. Instead of studying how the human uses his her own biological hand or how a human teleoperates a robot hand in a grasping task, the method involves a human interacting physically with a robot arm and hand, carefully moving and guiding the robot into the grasping pose, while the robot's configuration is recorded. Analysis of the grasps from this simple method has produced two interesting results. First, the grasps produced by this method perform better than grasps generated through a state-of-the-art automated grasp planner. Second, this method when combined with a detailed statistical analysis using a variety of grasp measures (physics-based heuristics considered critical for a good grasp) offered insights into how the human grasping method is similar or different from automated grasping synthesis techniques. Specifically, data from the physical human interactive guidance method showed that the human-planned grasping method provides grasps that are similar to grasps from a state-of-the-art automated grasp planner, but differed in one key aspect. The robot wrists were aligned with the object's principal axes in the human-planned grasps (termed low skewness in this paper), while the automated grasps used arbitrary wrist orientation. Preliminary tests show that grasps with low skewness were significantly more robust than grasps with high skewness (77-93 ). We conclude with a detailed discussion of how the physical human interactive guidance method relates to existing methods to extract the human principles for physical interaction. In this paper, we address the problem of automatic grasp generation for robotic hands where experience and shape primitives are used in synergy so to provide a basis not only for grasp generation but also for a grasp evaluation process when the exact pose of the object is not available. One of the main challenges in automatic grasping is the choice of the object approach vector, which is dependent both on the object shape and pose as well as the grasp type. Using the proposed method, the approach vector is chosen not only based on the sensory input but also on experience that some approach vectors will provide useful tactile information that finally results in stable grasps. A methodology for developing and evaluating grasp controllers is presented where the focus lies on obtaining stable grasps under imperfect vision. The method is used in a teleoperation or a programming by demonstration setting where a human demonstrates to a robot how to grasp an object. The system first recognizes the object and grasp type which can then be used by the robot to perform the same action using a mapped version of the human grasping posture. In this paper we focus on the concept of low-dimensional posture subspaces for artificial hands. We begin by discussing the applicability of a hand configuration subspace to the problem of automated grasp synthesis; our results show that low-dimensional optimization can be instrumental in deriving effective pre-grasp shapes for a number of complex robotic hands. We then show that the computational advantages of using a reduced dimensionality framework enable it to serve as an interface between the human and automated components of an interactive grasping system. We present an on-line grasp planner that allows a human operator to perform dexterous grasping tasks using an artificial hand. In order to achieve the computational rates required for effective user interaction, grasp planning is performed in a hand posture subspace of highly reduced dimensionality. The system also uses real-time input provided by the operator, further simplifying the search for stable grasps to the point where solutions can be found at interactive rates. We demonstrate our approach on a number of different hand models and target objects, in both real and virtual environments. This paper presents a novel robot grasping planning approach that extracts grasp strategies (grasp type, and thumb placement and direction) from human demonstration and integrates them into the grasp planning procedure to generate a feasible grasp concerning the target object geometry and manipulation task. Our study results show that the grasp strategies of grasp type and thumb placement not only represent important human grasp intentions, but also provide meaningful constraints on hand posture and wrist position, which highly reduce both the feasible workspace of a robotic hand and the search space of the grasp planning. This approach has been thoroughly evaluated both in simulation and with a real robotic system for multiple daily living representative objects. We have also demonstrated the robustness of our approach in the experiment with different levels of perception uncertainties. We propose a new large-scale database containing grasps that are applied to a large set of objects from numerous categories. These grasps are generated in simulation and are annotated with different grasp stability metrics. We use a descriptive and efficient representation of the local object shape at which each grasp is applied. Given this data, we present a two-fold analysis: (i) We use crowdsourcing to analyze the correlation of the metrics with grasp success as predicted by humans. The results show that the metric based on physics simulation is a more consistent predictor for grasp success than the standard υ-metric. The results also support the hypothesis that human labels are not required for good ground truth grasp data. Instead the physics-metric can be used to generate datasets in simulation that may then be used to bootstrap learning in the real world. (ii) We apply a deep learning method and show that it can better leverage the large-scale database for prediction of grasp success compared to logistic regression. Furthermore, the results suggest that labels based on the physics-metric are less noisy than those from the υ-metric and therefore lead to a better classification performance. This paper is the first of a two-part series analyzing human grasping behavior during a wide range of unstructured tasks. The results help clarify overall characteristics of human hand to inform many domains, such as the design of robotic manipulators, targeting rehabilitation toward important hand functionality, and designing haptic devices for use by the hand. It investigates the properties of objects grasped by two housekeepers and two machinists during the course of almost 10,000 grasp instances and correlates the grasp types used to the properties of the object. We establish an object classification that assigns each object properties from a set of seven classes, including mass, shape and size of the grasp location, grasped dimension, rigidity, and roundness. The results showed that 55 percent of grasped objects had at least one dimension larger than 15 cm, suggesting that more than half of objects cannot physically be grasped using their largest axis. Ninety-two percent of objects had a mass of 500 g or less, implying that a high payload capacity may be unnecessary to accomplish a large subset of human grasping behavior. In terms of grasps, 96 percent of grasp locations were 7 cm or less in width, which can help to define requirements for hand rehabilitation and defines a reasonable grasp aperture size for a robotic hand. Subjects grasped the smallest overall major dimension of the object in 94 percent of the instances. This suggests that grasping the smallest axis of an object could be a reliable default behavior to implement in grasp planners. Humanoid robots must be capable of interacting with the world using their hands. A variety of humanlike robot hands have been constructed, but it remains difficult to control these hands in a dexterous way. One challenge is grasp synthesis, where we wish to place the hand and control its shape to successfully grasp a given object. In this paper, we present a datadriven approach to grasp synthesis that treats grasping as a shape matching problem. We begin with a database of grasp examples. Given a model of a new object to be grasped (the query), shape features of the object are compared to shape features of hand poses in these examples in order to identify candidate grasps. For effective retrieval, we develop a novel shape matching algorithm that can accommodate the sparse shape information associated with hand pose and that considers relative placements of contact points and normals, which are important for grasp function. We illustrate our approach with examples using a model of the human hand This paper proposes a new approach to using machine learning to detect grasp poses on novel objects presented in clutter. The input to our algorithm is a point cloud and the geometric parameters of the robot hand. The output is a set of hand poses that are expected to be good grasps. There are two main contributions. First, we identify a set of necessary conditions on the geometry of a grasp that can be used to generate a set of grasp hypotheses. This helps focus grasp detection away from regions where no grasp can exist. Second, we show how geometric grasp conditions can be used to generate labeled datasets for the purpose of training the machine learning algorithm. This enables us to generate large amounts of training data and it grounds our training labels in grasp mechanics. Overall, our method achieves an average grasp success rate of 88 when grasping novels objects presented in isolation and an average success rate of 73 when grasping novel objects presented in dense clutter. This system is available as a ROS package at http: wiki.ros.org agile_grasp. Grasp planning based on perceived sensor data of an object can be performed in different ways, depending on the chosen semantic interpretation of the sensed data. For example, if the object can be recognized and a complete 3D model is available, a different planning tool can be selected compared to the situation in which only the raw sensed data, such as a single point cloud, is available. Instead of choosing between these options, we present a framework that combines them, aiming to find consensus on how the object should be grasped by using the information from each object representation according to their confidence levels. We show that this method is robust to common errors in perception, such as incorrect object recognition, while also taking into account potential grasp execution errors due to imperfect robot calibration. We illustrate this method on the PR2 robot by grasping objects common in human environments. For applications such as Amazon warehouse order fulfillment, robots must grasp a desired object amid clutter: other objects that block direct access. This can be difficult to program explicitly due to uncertainty in friction and push mechanics and the variety of objects that can be encountered. Deep Learning networks combined with Online Learning from Demonstration (LfD) algorithms such as DAgger and SHIV have potential to learn robot control policies for such tasks where the input is a camera image and system dynamics and the cost function are unknown. To explore this idea, we introduce a version of the grasping in clutter problem where a yellow cylinder must be grasped by a planar robot arm amid extruded objects in a variety of shapes and positions. To reduce the burden on human experts to provide demonstrations, we propose using a hierarchy of three levels of supervisors: a fast motion planner that ignores obstacles, crowd-sourced human workers who provide appropriate robot control values remotely via online videos, and a local human expert. Physical experiments suggest that with 160 expert demonstrations, using the hierarchy of supervisors can increase the probability of a successful grasp (reliability) from 55 to 90 . For robots to attain more general-purpose utility, grasping is a necessary skill to master. Such general-purpose robots may use their perception abilities to visually identify grasps for a given object. A grasp describes how a robotic end-effector can be arranged to securely grab an object and successfully lift it without slippage. Traditionally, grasp detection requires expert human knowledge to analytically form the task-specific algorithm, but this is an arduous and time-consuming approach. During the last five years, deep learning methods have enabled significant advancements in robotic vision, natural language processing, and automated driving applications. The successful results of these methods have driven robotics researchers to explore the use of deep learning methods in task-generalised robotic applications. This paper reviews the current state-of-the-art in regards to the application of deep learning methods to generalised robotic grasping and discusses how each element of the deep learning approach has improved the overall performance of robotic grasp detection. Several of the most promising approaches are evaluated and the most suitable for real-time grasp detection is identified as the one-shot detection method. The availability of suitable volumes of appropriate training data is identified as a major obstacle for effective utilisation of the deep learning approaches, and the use of transfer learning techniques is proposed as a potential mechanism to address this. Finally, current trends in the field and future potential research directions are discussed. Current model free learning-based robot grasping approaches exploit human-labeled datasets for training the models. However, there are two problems with such a methodology: (a) since each object can be grasped in multiple ways, manually labeling grasp locations is not a trivial task; (b) human labeling is biased by semantics. While there have been attempts to train robots using trial-and-error experiments, the amount of data used in such experiments remains substantially low and hence makes the learner prone to over-fitting. In this paper, we take the leap of increasing the available training data to 40 times more than prior work, leading to a dataset size of 50K data points collected over 700 hours of robot grasping attempts. This allows us to train a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) for the task of predicting grasp locations without severe overfitting. In our formulation, we recast the regression problem to an 18-way binary classification over image patches. We also present a multi-stage learning approach where a CNN trained in one stage is used to collect hard negatives in subsequent stages. Our experiments clearly show the benefit of using large-scale datasets (and multi-stage training) for the task of grasping. We also compare to several baselines and show state-of-the-art performance on generalization to unseen objects for grasping. Current learning-based robot grasping approaches exploit human-labeled datasets for training the models. However, there are two problems with such a methodology: (a) since each object can be grasped in multiple ways, manually labeling grasp locations is not a trivial task; (b) human labeling is biased by semantics. While there have been attempts to train robots using trial-and-error experiments, the amount of data used in such experiments remains substantially low and hence makes the learner prone to over-fitting. In this paper, we take the leap of increasing the available training data to 40 times more than prior work, leading to a dataset size of 50K data points collected over 700 hours of robot grasping attempts. This allows us to train a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) for the task of predicting grasp locations without severe overfitting. In our formulation, we recast the regression problem to an 18-way binary classification over image patches. We also present a multi-stage learning approach where a CNN trained in one stage is used to collect hard negatives in subsequent stages. Our experiments clearly show the benefit of using large-scale datasets (and multi-stage training) for the task of grasping. We also compare to several baselines and show state-of-the-art performance on generalization to unseen objects for grasping. Studies of human manipulation strategies suggest that pre-grasp object manipulation, such as rotation or sliding of the object to be grasped, can improve task performance by increasing both the task success rate and the quality of load-supporting postures. In previous demonstrations, pre-grasp object rotation by a robot manipulator was limited to manually-programmed actions. We present a method for automating the planning of pre-grasp rotation for object transport tasks. Our technique optimizes the grasp acquisition point by selecting a target object pose that can be grasped by high-payload manipulator configurations. Careful selection of the transition states leads to successful transport plans for tasks that are otherwise infeasible. In addition, optimization of the grasp acquisition posture also indirectly improves the transport plan quality, as measured by the safety margin of the manipulator payload limits. This paper is the second in a two-part series analyzing human grasping behavior during a wide range of unstructured tasks. It investigates the tasks performed during the daily work of two housekeepers and two machinists and correlates grasp type and object properties with the attributes of the tasks being performed. The task or activity is classified according to the force required, the degrees of freedom, and the functional task type. We found that 46 percent of tasks are constrained, where the manipulated object is not allowed to move in a full six degrees of freedom. Analyzing the interrelationships between the grasp, object, and task data show that the best predictors of the grasp type are object size, task constraints, and object mass. Using these attributes, the grasp type can be predicted with 47 percent accuracy. Those parameters likely make useful heuristics for grasp planning systems. The results further suggest the common sub-categorization of grasps into power, intermediate, and precision categories may not be appropriate, indicating that grasps are generally more multi-functional than previously thought. We find large and heavy objects are grasped with a power grasp, but small and lightweight objects are not necessarily grasped with precision grasps—even with grasped object size less than 2 cm and mass less than 20 g, precision grasps are only used 61 percent of the time. These results have important implications for robotic hand design and grasp planners, since it appears while power grasps are frequently used for heavy objects, they can still be quite practical for small, lightweight objects. Animated human characters in everyday scenarios must interact with the environment using their hands. Captured human motion can provide a database of realistic examples. However, examples involving contact are difficult to edit and retarget; realism can suffer when a grasp does not appear secure or when an apparent impact does not disturb the hand or the object. Physically based simulations can preserve plausibility through simulating interaction forces. However, such physical models must be driven by a controller, and creating effective controllers for new motion tasks remains a challenge. In this paper, we present a controller for physically based grasping that draws from motion capture data. Our controller explicitly includes passive and active components to uphold compliant yet controllable motion, and it adds compensation for movement of the arm and for gravity to make the behavior of passive and active components less dependent on the dynamics of arm motion. Given a set of motion capture grasp examples, our system solves for all but a small set of parameters for this controller automatically. We demonstrate results for tasks including grasping and two-hand interaction and show that a controller derived from a single motion capture example can be used to form grasps of different object geometries. This paper presents a vision based method for grasp classification. It is developed as part of a Programming by Demonstration (PbD) system for which recognition of objects and pick-and-place actions represent basic building blocks for task learning. In contrary to earlier approaches, no articulated 3D reconstruction of the hand over time is taking place. The indata consists of a single image of the human hand. A 2D representation of the hand shape, based on gradient orientation histograms, is extracted from the image. The hand shape is then classified as one of six grasps by finding similar hand shapes in a large database of grasp images. The database search is performed using Locality Sensitive Hashing (LSH), an approximate k-nearest neighbor approach. The nearest neighbors also give an estimated hand orientation with respect to the camera. The six human grasps are mapped to three Barret hand grasps. Depending on the type of robot grasp, a precomputed grasp strategy is selected. The strategy is further parameterized by the orientation of the hand relative to the object. To evaluate the potential for the method to be part of a robust vision system, experiments were performed, comparing classification results to a baseline of human classification performance. The experiments showed the LSH recognition performance to be comparable to human performance. Automatic grasp planning for robotic hands is a difficult problem because of the huge number of possible hand configurations. However, humans simplify the problem by choosing an appropriate prehensile posture appropriate for the object and task to be performed. By modeling an object as a set of shape primitives, such as spheres, cylinders, cones and boxes, we can use a set of rules to generate a set of grasp starting positions and pregrasp shapes that can then be tested on the object model. Each grasp is tested and evaluated within our grasping simulator "GraspIt!", and the best grasps are presented to the user. The simulator can also plan grasps in a complex environment involving obstacles and the reachability constraints of a robot arm. In this paper, we analyze and compare existing human grasp taxonomies and synthesize them into a single new taxonomy (dubbed “The GRASP Taxonomy” after the GRASP project funded by the European Commission). We consider only static and stable grasps performed by one hand. The goal is to extract the largest set of different grasps that were referenced in the literature and arrange them in a systematic way. The taxonomy provides a common terminology to define human hand configurations and is important in many domains such as human–computer interaction and tangible user interfaces where an understanding of the human is basis for a proper interface. Overall, 33 different grasp types are found and arranged into the GRASP taxonomy. Within the taxonomy, grasps are arranged according to 1) opposition type, 2) the virtual finger assignments, 3) type in terms of power, precision, or intermediate grasp, and 4) the position of the thumb. The resulting taxonomy incorporates all grasps found in the reviewed taxonomies that complied with the grasp definition. We also show that due to the nature of the classification, the 33 grasp types might be reduced to a set of 17 more general grasps if only the hand configuration is considered without the object shape size. In a typical Human-Robot Interaction (HRI) scenario, the robot needs to perform various tasks for the human, hence should take into account human oriented constraints. In this context it is not sufficient that the robot selects grasp and placement of the object from the stability point of view only. Motivated from human behavioral psychology, in this paper we emphasize on the mutually depended nature of grasp and placement selections, which is further constrained by the task, the environment and the human's perspective. We will explore essential human oriented constraints on grasp and placement selections and present a framework to incorporate them in synthesizing key configurations of planning basic interactive manipulation tasks.