Salient object detection or salient region detection models, diverging from fixation prediction models, have traditionally been dealing with locating and segmenting the most salient object or region in a scene. While the notion of most salient object is sensible when multiple objects exist in a scene, current datasets for evaluation of saliency detection approaches often have scenes with only one single object. We introduce three main contributions in this paper. First, we take an in-depth look at the problem of salient object detection by studying the relationship between where people look in scenes and what they choose as the most salient object when they are explicitly asked. Based on the agreement between fixations and saliency judgments, we then suggest that the most salient object is the one that attracts the highest fraction of fixations. Second, we provide two new less biased benchmark data sets containing scenes with multiple objects that challenge existing saliency models. Indeed, we observed a severe drop in performance of eight state-of-the-art models on our data sets (40 –70 ). Third, we propose a very simple yet powerful model based on superpixels to be used as a baseline for model evaluation and comparison. While on par with the best models on MSRA-5 K data set, our model wins over other models on our data highlighting a serious drawback of existing models, which is convoluting the processes of locating the most salient object and its segmentation. We also provide a review and statistical analysis of some labeled scene data sets that can be used for evaluating salient object detection models. We believe that our work can greatly help remedy the over-fitting of models to existing biased data sets and opens new venues for future research in this fast-evolving field.
Perhaps the most similar work to ours has been published by Li @cite_69 . In their work, they offer two contributions. , they collect an eye movement dataset using annotated images from the PASCAL dataset @cite_40 and call their dataset PASCAL-S. , they propose a model that outperforms other state-of-the-art salient object detection models on this dataset (as well as four other benchmark datasets). Their model decouples the salient object detection problem into two processes: 1) , followed by 2) using fixation prediction. Here, similar to Li , we also take advantage of eye movements to measure object saliency but instead of first fully segmenting the scene, we perform a shallow segmentation using superpixels. We then only focus on segmenting the object that is most likely to attract attention. In other words, the two steps are similar to Li but are performed in the reverse order. This can potentially lead to better efficiency as the first expensive segmentation part is now only an approximation.
@cite_40 @cite_69
2031489346 2086791339
Several salient object detection approaches have been published which have been assessed using different evaluation scores and datasets resulting in discrepancy in model comparison. This calls for a methodological framework to compare existing models and evaluate their pros and cons. We analyze benchmark datasets and scoring techniques and, for the first time, provide a quantitative comparison of 35 state-of-the-art saliency detection models. We find that some models perform consistently better than the others. Saliency models that intend to predict eye fixations perform lower on segmentation datasets compared to salient object detection algorithms. Further, we propose combined models which show that integration of the few best models outperforms all models over other datasets. By analyzing the consistency among the best models and among humans for each scene, we identify the scenes where models or humans fail to detect the most salient object. We highlight the current issues and propose future research directions. Human eye fixations often correlate with locations of salient objects in the scene. However, only a handful of approaches have attempted to simultaneously address the related aspects of eye fixations and object saliency. In this work, we propose a deep convolutional neural network (CNN) capable of predicting eye fixations and segmenting salient objects in a unified framework. We design the initial network layers, shared between both the tasks, such that they capture the object level semantics and the global contextual aspects of saliency, while the deeper layers of the network address task specific aspects. In addition, our network captures saliency at multiple scales via inceptionstyle convolution blocks. Our network shows a significant improvement over the current state-of-the-art for both eye fixation prediction and salient object segmentation across a number of challenging datasets. In this paper we provide an extensive evaluation of fixation prediction and salient object segmentation algorithms as well as statistics of major datasets. Our analysis identifies serious design flaws of existing salient object benchmarks, called the dataset design bias, by over emphasizing the stereotypical concepts of saliency. The dataset design bias does not only create the discomforting disconnection between fixations and salient object segmentation, but also misleads the algorithm designing. Based on our analysis, we propose a new high quality dataset that offers both fixation and salient object segmentation ground-truth. With fixations and salient object being presented simultaneously, we are able to bridge the gap between fixations and salient objects, and propose a novel method for salient object segmentation. Finally, we report significant benchmark progress on three existing datasets of segmenting salient objects In this paper we provide an extensive evaluation of fixation prediction and salient object segmentation algorithms as well as statistics of major datasets. Our analysis identifies serious design flaws of existing salient object benchmarks, called the dataset design bias, by over emphasising the stereotypical concepts of saliency. The dataset design bias does not only create the discomforting disconnection between fixations and salient object segmentation, but also misleads the algorithm designing. Based on our analysis, we propose a new high quality dataset that offers both fixation and salient object segmentation ground-truth. With fixations and salient object being presented simultaneously, we are able to bridge the gap between fixations and salient objects, and propose a novel method for salient object segmentation. Finally, we report significant benchmark progress on 3 existing datasets of segmenting salient objects. Despite significant recent progress, the best available visual saliency models still lag behind human performance in predicting eye fixations in free-viewing of natural scenes. Majority of models are based on low-level visual features and the importance of top-down factors has not yet been fully explored or modeled. Here, we combine low-level features such as orientation, color, intensity, saliency maps of previous best bottom-up models with top-down cognitive visual features (e.g., faces, humans, cars, etc.) and learn a direct mapping from those features to eye fixations using Regression, SVM, and AdaBoost classifiers. By extensive experimenting over three benchmark eye-tracking datasets using three popular evaluation scores, we show that our boosting model outperforms 27 state-of-the-art models and is so far the closest model to the accuracy of human model for fixation prediction. Furthermore, our model successfully detects the most salient object in a scene without sophisticated image processings such as region segmentation. Detecting and segmenting salient objects from natural scenes, often referred to as salient object detection, has attracted great interest in computer vision. While many models have been proposed and several applications have emerged, a deep understanding of achievements and issues remains lacking. We aim to provide a comprehensive review of recent progress in salient object detection and situate this field among other closely related areas such as generic scene segmentation, object proposal generation, and saliency for fixation prediction. Covering 228 publications, we survey i) roots, key concepts, and tasks, ii) core techniques and main modeling trends, and iii) datasets and evaluation metrics for salient object detection. We also discuss open problems such as evaluation metrics and dataset bias in model performance, and suggest future research directions. Recent advances of supervised salient object detection models demonstrate significant performance on benchmark datasets. Training such models, however, requires expensive pixel-wise annotations of salient objects. Moreover, many existing salient object detection models assume that at least a salient object exists in the input image. Such an impractical assumption leads to less appealing saliency maps on the background images, which contain no salient objects at all. To avoid expensive strong saliency annotations, in this paper, we study weakly supervised learning approaches for salient object detection. In specific, given a set of background images and or salient object images, where we only have annotations of salient object existence, we propose two approaches to train salient object detection models. In the first approach, we train a one-class SVM based on background superpixels. The further a superpixel is from the decision boundary of the one-class SVM, the more salient it is. The most interesting property of this approach is that we can effortlessly synthesize a set of background images to train the model. In the second approach, we present a solution toward jointly addressing salient object existence and detection tasks. We formulate salient object detection as an image labeling problem, where saliency labels of superpixels are modeled as hidden variables in the latent structural SVM framework. Experimental results on benchmark datasets validate the effectiveness of our proposed approaches. Image saliency detection has recently witnessed rapid progress due to deep convolutional neural networks. However, none of the existing methods is able to identify object instances in the detected salient regions. In this paper, we present a salient instance segmentation method that produces a saliency mask with distinct object instance labels for an input image. Our method consists of three steps, estimating saliency map, detecting salient object contours and identifying salient object instances. For the first two steps, we propose a multiscale saliency refinement network, which generates high-quality salient region masks and salient object contours. Once integrated with multiscale combinatorial grouping and a MAP-based subset optimization framework, our method can generate very promising salient object instance segmentation results. To promote further research and evaluation of salient instance segmentation, we also construct a new database of 1000 images and their pixelwise salient instance annotations. Experimental results demonstrate that our proposed method is capable of achieving state-of-the-art performance on all public benchmarks for salient region detection as well as on our new dataset for salient instance segmentation. Visual attention is a process that enables biological and machine vision systems to select the most relevant regions from a scene. Relevance is determined by two components: 1) top-down factors driven by task and 2) bottom-up factors that highlight image regions that are different from their surroundings. The latter are often referred to as “visual saliency.” Modeling bottom-up visual saliency has been the subject of numerous research efforts during the past 20 years, with many successful applications in computer vision and robotics. Available models have been tested with different datasets (e.g., synthetic psychological search arrays, natural images or videos) using different evaluation scores (e.g., search slopes, comparison to human eye tracking) and parameter settings. This has made direct comparison of models difficult. Here, we perform an exhaustive comparison of 35 state-of-the-art saliency models over 54 challenging synthetic patterns, three natural image datasets, and two video datasets, using three evaluation scores. We find that although model rankings vary, some models consistently perform better. Analysis of datasets reveals that existing datasets are highly center-biased, which influences some of the evaluation scores. Computational complexity analysis shows that some models are very fast, yet yield competitive eye movement prediction accuracy. Different models often have common easy difficult stimuli. Furthermore, several concerns in visual saliency modeling, eye movement datasets, and evaluation scores are discussed and insights for future work are provided. Our study allows one to assess the state-of-the-art, helps to organizing this rapidly growing field, and sets a unified comparison framework for gauging future efforts, similar to the PASCAL VOC challenge in the object recognition and detection domains. This paper proposes an effective salient object segmentation method via the graph-based integration of saliency and objectness. Based on the superpixel segmentation result of the input image, a graph is built to represent superpixels using regular vertex, background seed vertex with the addition of a terminal vertex. The edge weights on the graph are defined by integrating the difference of appearance, saliency, and objectness between superpixels. Then, the object probability of each superpixel is measured by finding the shortest path from the corresponding vertex to the terminal vertex on the graph, and the resultant object probability map can generally better highlight salient objects and suppress background regions compared to both saliency map and objectness map. Finally, the object probability map is used to initialize salient object and background, and effectively incorporated into the framework of graph cut to obtain the final salient object segmentation result. Extensive experimental results on three public benchmark datasets show that the proposed method consistently improves the salient object segmentation performance and outperforms the state-of-the-art salient object segmentation methods. Furthermore, experimental results also demonstrate that the proposed graph-based integration method is more effective than other fusion schemes and robust to saliency maps generated using various saliency models. To facilitate efficiency, most recent successful saliency detection methods are built on superpixel level. However, saliency detection with single-scale superpixel segmentation may fail in capturing the intrinsic salient objects in complex natural scenes with small-scale high-contrast backgrounds. To tackle this problem and realize more reliable saliency detection, we present a simple strategy using multiscale superpixels to jointly detect salient object via low-rank analysis. Specifically, we construct a multiscale superpixel pyramid and derive the corresponding saliency map using multiple saliency features and priors for each single scale at first. Then, we show that by joint low-rank analysis of multiscale saliency maps, we can obtain a more reliable adaptively fused saliency map that takes all scales saliency results into account. We further propose a GMM-based co-saliency prior to enable the above approach to detecting co-salient objects from multiple images. Extensive experiments on benchmark datasets validate the effectiveness and superiority of the proposed approach over state-of-the-art methods. Low-rank matrix recovery (LRMR) model, aiming at decomposing a matrix into a low-rank matrix and a sparse one, has shown the potential to address the problem of saliency detection, where the decomposed low-rank matrix naturally corresponds to the background, and the sparse one captures salient objects. This is under the assumption that the background is consistent and objects are obviously distinctive. Unfortunately, in real images, the background may be cluttered and may have low contrast with objects. Thus directly applying the LRMR model to the saliency detection has limited robustness. This paper proposes a novel approach that exploits bottom-up segmentation as a guidance cue of the matrix recovery. This method is fully unsupervised, yet obtains higher performance than the supervised LRMR model. A new challenging dataset PASCAL-1500 is also introduced to validate the saliency detection performance. Extensive evaluations on the widely used MSRA-1000 dataset and also on the new PASCAL-1500 dataset demonstrate that the proposed saliency model outperforms the state-of-the-art models. Recently, significant improvement has been made on semantic object segmentation due to the development of deep convolutional neural networks (DCNNs). Training such a DCNN usually relies on a large number of images with pixel-level segmentation masks, and annotating these images is very costly in terms of both finance and human effort. In this paper, we propose a simple to complex (STC) framework in which only image-level annotations are utilized to learn DCNNs for semantic segmentation. Specifically, we first train an initial segmentation network called Initial-DCNN with the saliency maps of simple images (i.e., those with a single category of major object(s) and clean background). These saliency maps can be automatically obtained by existing bottom-up salient object detection techniques, where no supervision information is needed. Then, a better network called Enhanced-DCNN is learned with supervision from the predicted segmentation masks of simple images based on the Initial-DCNN as well as the image-level annotations. Finally, more pixel-level segmentation masks of complex images (two or more categories of objects with cluttered background), which are inferred by using Enhanced-DCNN and image-level annotations, are utilized as the supervision information to learn the Powerful-DCNN for semantic segmentation. Our method utilizes 40K simple images from Flickr.com and 10K complex images from PASCAL VOC for step-wisely boosting the segmentation network. Extensive experimental results on PASCAL VOC 2012 segmentation benchmark well demonstrate the superiority of the proposed STC framework compared with other state-of-the-arts. We present a model for video segmentation, applicable to RGB (and if available RGB-D) information that constructs multiple plausible partitions corresponding to the static and the moving objects in the scene: i) we generate multiple figure-ground segmentations, in each frame, parametrically, based on boundary and optical flow cues, then track, link and refine the salient segment chains corresponding to the different objects, over time, using long-range temporal constraints, ii) a video partition is obtained by composing segment chains into consistent tilings, where the different individual object chains explain the video and do not overlap. Saliency metrics based on figural and motion cues, as well as measures learned from human eye movements are exploited, with substantial gain, at the level of segment generation and chain construction, in order to produce compact sets of hypotheses which correctly reflect the qualities of the different configurations. The model makes it possible to compute multiple hypotheses over both individual object segmentations tracked over time, and for complete video partitions. We report quantitative, state of the art results in the SegTrack single object benchmark, and promising qualitative and quantitative results in clips filming multiple static and moving objects collected from Hollywood movies and from the MIT dataset. Several visual attention models have been proposed for describing eye movements over simple stimuli and tasks such as free viewing or visual search. Yet, to date, there exists no computational framework that can reliably mimic human gaze behavior in more complex environments and tasks such as urban driving. In addition, benchmark datasets, scoring techniques, and top-down model architectures are not yet well understood. In this paper, we describe new task-dependent approaches for modeling top-down overt visual attention based on graphical models for probabilistic inference and reasoning. We describe a dynamic Bayesian network that infers probability distributions over attended objects and spatial locations directly from observed data. Probabilistic inference in our model is performed over object-related functions that are fed from manual annotations of objects in video scenes or by state-of-the-art object detection recognition algorithms. Evaluating over approximately 3 h (approximately 315 000 eye fixations and 12 000 saccades) of observers playing three video games (time-scheduling, driving, and flight combat), we show that our approach is significantly more predictive of eye fixations compared to: 1) simpler classifier-based models also developed here that map a signature of a scene (multimodal information from gist, bottom-up saliency, physical actions, and events) to eye positions; 2) 14 state-of-the-art bottom-up saliency models; and 3) brute-force algorithms such as mean eye position. Our results show that the proposed model is more effective in employing and reasoning over spatio-temporal visual data compared with the state-of-the-art. We propose a novel automatic salient object segmentation algorithm which integrates both bottom-up salient stimuli and object-level shape prior, i.e., a salient object has a well-defined closed boundary. Our approach is formalized as an iterative energy minimization framework, leading to binary segmentation of the salient object. Such energy minimization is initialized with a saliency map which is computed through context analysis based on multi-scale superpixels. Object-level shape prior is then extracted combining saliency with object boundary information. Both saliency map and shape prior update after each iteration. Experimental results on two public benchmark datasets show that our proposed approach outperforms state-of-the-art methods. Systems based on bag-of-words models from image features collected at maxima of sparse interest point operators have been used successfully for both computer visual object and action recognition tasks. While the sparse, interest-point based approach to recognition is not inconsistent with visual processing in biological systems that operate in ‘saccade and fixate’ regimes, the methodology and emphasis in the human and the computer vision communities remains sharply distinct. Here, we make three contributions aiming to bridge this gap. First, we complement existing state-of-the art large scale dynamic computer vision annotated datasets like Hollywood-2 [1] and UCF Sports [2] with human eye movements collected under the ecological constraints of visual action and scene context recognition tasks. To our knowledge these are the first large human eye tracking datasets to be collected and made publicly available for video, vision.imar.ro eyetracking (497,107 frames, each viewed by 19 subjects), unique in terms of their (a) large scale and computer vision relevance, (b) dynamic, video stimuli, (c) task control, as well as free-viewing . Second, we introduce novel dynamic consistency and alignment measures , which underline the remarkable stability of patterns of visual search among subjects. Third, we leverage the significant amount of collected data in order to pursue studies and build automatic, end-to-end trainable computer vision systems based on human eye movements. Our studies not only shed light on the differences between computer vision spatio-temporal interest point image sampling strategies and the human fixations, as well as their impact for visual recognition performance, but also demonstrate that human fixations can be accurately predicted, and when used in an end-to-end automatic system, leveraging some of the advanced computer vision practice, can lead to state of the art results. Training an object class detector typically requires a large set of images annotated with bounding-boxes, which is expensive and time consuming to create. We propose novel approach to annotate object locations which can substantially reduce annotation time. We first track the eye movements of annotators instructed to find the object and then propose a technique for deriving object bounding-boxes from these fixations. To validate our idea, we collected eye tracking data for the trainval part of 10 object classes of Pascal VOC 2012 (6,270 images, 5 observers). Our technique correctly produces bounding-boxes in 50 of the images, while reducing the total annotation time by factor 6.8× compared to drawing bounding-boxes. Any standard object class detector can be trained on the bounding-boxes predicted by our model. Our large scale eye tracking dataset is available at groups.inf.ed.ac.uk calvin eyetrackdataset . Recent development in fully convolutional neural network enables efficient end-to-end learning of semantic segmentation. Traditionally, the convolutional classifiers are taught to learn the representative semantic features of labeled semantic objects. In this work, we propose a reverse attention network (RAN) architecture that trains the network to capture the opposite concept (i.e., what are not associated with a target class) as well. The RAN is a three-branch network that performs the direct, reverse and reverse-attention learning processes simultaneously. Extensive experiments are conducted to show the effectiveness of the RAN in semantic segmentation. Being built upon the DeepLabv2-LargeFOV, the RAN achieves the state-of-the-art mIoU score (48.1 ) for the challenging PASCAL-Context dataset. Significant performance improvements are also observed for the PASCAL-VOC, Person-Part, NYUDv2 and ADE20K datasets. We are interested in inferring object segmentation by leveraging only object class information, and by considering only minimal priors on the object segmentation task. This problem could be viewed as a kind of weakly supervised segmentation task, and naturally fits the Multiple Instance Learning (MIL) framework: every training image is known to have (or not) at least one pixel corresponding to the image class label, and the segmentation task can be rewritten as inferring the pixels belonging to the class of the object (given one image, and its object class). We propose a Convolutional Neural Network-based model, which is constrained during training to put more weight on pixels which are important for classifying the image. We show that at test time, the model has learned to discriminate the right pixels well enough, such that it performs very well on an existing segmentation benchmark, by adding only few smoothing priors. Our system is trained using a subset of the Imagenet dataset and the segmentation experiments are performed on the challenging Pascal VOC dataset (with no fine-tuning of the model on Pascal VOC). Our model beats the state of the art results in weakly supervised object segmentation task by a large margin. We also compare the performance of our model with state of the art fully-supervised segmentation approaches.