Automatic note-level transcription is considered one of the most challenging tasks in music information retrieval. The specific case of flamenco singing transcription poses a particular challenge due to its complex melodic progressions, intonation inaccuracies, the use of a high degree of ornamentation, and the presence of guitar accompaniment. In this study, we explore the limitations of existing state of the art transcription systems for the case of flamenco singing and propose a specific solution for this genre: We first extract the predominant melody and apply a novel contour filtering process to eliminate segments of the pitch contour which originate from the guitar accompaniment. We formulate a set of onset detection functions based on volume and pitch characteristics to segment the resulting vocal pitch contour into discrete note events. A quantised pitch label is assigned to each note event by combining global pitch class probabilities with local pitch contour statistics. The proposed system outperforms state of the art singing transcription systems with respect to voicing accuracy, onset detection, and overall performance when evaluated on flamenco singing datasets.
Nevertheless, the authors report mistakenly transcribed guitar notes as a main source of error and the inaccurate vocal detection a the major limitation of the system performance. The reported note transcription accuracies reported in @cite_2 with a note f-measure of slightly below @math furthermore indicate the difficulty of transcribing flamenco singing. Significantly higher performance is achieved when evaluating the same transcription algorithm on a dataset containing pop- and jazz singing excerpts. We therefore identify a need for improving the state of the art on flamenco singing transcription and design an algorithm robust towards the particular characteristics of the genre which is furthermore suitable for the analysis of accompanied flamenco singing recordings.
@cite_2
1990908299
This article deals with automatic transcription of flamenco music recordings-more specifically, a cappella singing. We first study the specifics of flamenco singing and propose a transcription system based on fundamental frequency and energy estimation, which incorporates an iterative strategy for note segmentation and labeling. The proposed approach is evaluated on a music collection of 72 performances, including a variety of singers and recording conditions, and the presence or absence of percussion, background voices, and noise. We obtain satisfying results for the different approaches tested, and our system outperforms a state-of-the-art approach designed for other singing styles. In this study, we discuss the difficulties found in transcribing flamenco singing and in evaluating the obtained transcriptions, we analyze the influence of the different steps of the algorithm, and we state the main limitations of our approach and discuss challenges for future studies.