POEM is a cost effective procedure: cost utility analysis of endoscopic and surgical treatment options in the management of achalasia
BackgroundAchalasia is a rare motility disorder of the esophagus. Treatment is palliative with the goal of symptom remission and slowing the progression of the disease. Treatment options include per oral endoscopic myotomy (POEM) laparoscopic Heller myotomy (LM) and endoscopic treatments such as pneumatic dilation (PD) and botulinum toxin type A injections (BI) We evaluate the economics and cost effectiveness of treating achalasia.MethodsWe performed cost analysis for POEM, LM, PD and BI at our institution from 2011 to 2015. Cost of LM was set to 1, and other procedures are presented as percentage change. Cost effectiveness was calculated based on cost, number of interventions required for optimal results for dilations and injections and efficacy reported in the current literature. Incremental cost effectiveness ratio was calculated by a cost utility analysis using quality adjusted life year gained, defined as a symptom free year in a patient with achalasia.ResultsAverage number of interventions required was 2.3 dilations or two injections for efficacies of 80 and 61 respectively. POEM cost 1.058 times the cost of LM, and PD and BI cost 0.559 and 0.448 times the cost of LM. Annual cost per cure over a period of 4 years for POEM, and LM were consistently equivalent, trending the same as PD although this has a lower initial cost. The cost per cure of BI remains stable over 3 years and then doubles.ConclusionThe cost effectiveness of POEM and LM is equivalent. Myotomy, either surgical or endoscopic, is more cost effective than BI due to high failure rates of the economical intervention. When treatment is being considered BI should be utilized in patients with less than 2 year life expectancy. Pneumatic dilations are cost effective and are an acceptable approach to treatment of achalasia, although myotomy has a lower relapse rate and is cost effective compared to PD after 2 years.
Surgical Endoscopy