PDF text classification to leverage information extraction from publication reports
OBJECTIVES Data extraction from original study reports is a time consuming, error prone process in systematic review development. Information extraction (IE) systems have the potential to assist humans in the extraction task, however majority of IE systems were not designed to work on Portable Document Format (PDF) document, an important and common extraction source for systematic review. In a PDF document, narrative content is often mixed with publication metadata or semi structured text, which add challenges to the underlining natural language processing algorithm. Our goal is to categorize PDF texts for strategic use by IE systems. METHODS We used an open source tool to extract raw texts from a PDF document and developed a text classification algorithm that follows a multi pass sieve framework to automatically classify PDF text snippets (for brevity, texts) into TITLE, ABSTRACT, BODYTEXT, SEMISTRUCTURE, and METADATA categories. To validate the algorithm, we developed a gold standard of PDF reports that were included in the development of previous systematic reviews by the Cochrane Collaboration. In a two step procedure, we evaluated (1) classification performance, and compared it with machine learning classifier, and (2) the effects of the algorithm on an IE system that extracts clinical outcome mentions. RESULTS The multi pass sieve algorithm achieved an accuracy of 92.6% which was 9.7% (p<0.001) higher than the best performing machine learning classifier that used a logistic regression algorithm. F measure improvements were observed in the classification of TITLE +15.6% ABSTRACT +54.2% BODYTEXT +3.7% SEMISTRUCTURE +34% and MEDADATA +14.2% In addition, use of the algorithm to filter semi structured texts and publication metadata improved performance of the outcome extraction system (F measure +4.1% p=0.002) It also reduced of number of sentences to be processed by 44.9% (p<0.001) which corresponds to a processing time reduction of 50% (p=0.005) CONCLUSIONS The rule based multi pass sieve framework can be used effectively in categorizing texts extracted from PDF documents. Text classification is an important prerequisite step to leverage information extraction from PDF documents.
J. Biomed. Informatics