LINX(r) magnetic esophageal sphincter augmentation versus Nissen fundoplication for gastroesophageal reflux disease: a systematic review and meta analysis
BackgroundThe LINX(r) magnetic sphincter augmentation system (MSA) is a surgical technique with short term evidence demonstrating efficacy in the treatment of medically refractory or chronic gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) Currently, the Nissen fundoplication is the gold standard surgical treatment for GERD. We are the first to systematically review the literature and perform a meta analysis comparing MSA to the Nissen fundoplication.MethodsA comprehensive search of electronic databases (e.g. MEDLINE, EMBASE, SCOPUS, Web of Science and the Cochrane Library) using search terms "Gastroesophageal reflux or heartburn" and "LINX or endoluminal or magnetic" and "fundoplication or Nissen" was completed. All randomized controlled trials, non randomized comparison study and case series with greater than 5 patients were included. Five hundred and forty seven titles were identified through primary search, and 197 titles or abstracts were screened after removing duplicates. Meta analysis was performed on postoperative quality of life outcomes, procedural efficacy and patient procedural satisfaction.ResultsThree primary studies identified a total of 688 patients, of whom 273 and 415 underwent Nissen fundoplication and MSA, respectively. MSA was statistically superior to LNF in preserving patient's ability to belch (95.2 vs 65.9% p 0.00001) and ability to emesis (93.5 vs 49.5% p 0.0001) There was no statistically significant difference between MSA and LNF in gas/bloating (26.7 vs 53.4% p 0.06) postoperative dysphagia (33.9 vs 47.1% p 0.43) and proton pump inhibitor (PPI) elimination (81.4 vs 81.5% p 0.68).ConclusionMagnetic sphincter augmentation appears to be an effective treatment for GERD with short term outcomes comparable to the more technically challenging and time consuming Nissen fundoplication. Long term comparative outcome data past 1 year are needed in order to further understand the efficacy of magnetic sphincter augmentation.
Surgical Endoscopy