IL 18: throwing off the shackles to boost anti tumor immunity
In a new study in Nature, Zhou et al. identify IL 18BP as a novel soluble immune checkpoint, and describe engineering of a decoy resistant IL 18 to overcome this barrier and drive potent anti tumor immunity. Cytokines are soluble molecules important in cell signaling and communication, with the ability to orchestrate the immune response in autoimmunity, infection and cancer. The discovery of the potent tumoricidal activity of interferons paved the way for intense clinical investigation of several inflammatory cytokines in preclinical models, including IFN a and IL 2, with cytokine therapy historically being an important treatment modality for cancer. While the use of these cytokines was a significant milestone in cancer immunotherapy, as a monotherapy they have not fulfilled the promise of efficacy seen in preclinical models. In addition to a wide range of toxicities, the low response rate has largely relegated the use of these therapeutics in favor of immune checkpoint inhibitors, including anti CTLA 4 and anti PD 1, which have shown profound clinical benefits in a number of patients that were otherwise refractory to conventional anti tumor therapies. However, only ~13% of patients respond to these therapies, and despite a major effort to develop "second line" immunotherapies, there has yet to be significant additive clinical benefit beyond existing strategies. In this context, there is a renewed interest in potentiating the anti tumor effect of inflammatory cytokines in combination with existing immunomodulatory agents, including anti PD 1. To circumvent the earlier caveats with cytokine immunotherapy, such as pleiotrophism and low response rate, cytokines are now also being engineered to generate "superkines" sustaining their anti cancer efficacy or tailoring their receptor binding affinity. This is best exemplified by engineered IL 2 like molecules with augmented affinity for IL 2Rb and increased effector T cell function. In a new study published in Nature, the authors sought to explore novel cytokine circuits within the tumor microenvironment (TME) leveraging existing single cell tumor infiltrating lymphocyte (TIL) datasets. Using this approach, they found that transcripts of IL18R1 (encoding IL 18Ra) and IL18RAP (encoding IL18Rb) were enriched in activated and dysfunctional CD8 TILs. Despite the promising expression profile of the receptor, IL 18 had previously been explored in a phase II clinical trial which was prematurely terminated due to low clinical efficacy, failing to recapitulate the strong anti tumor immunity seen in preclinical models with recombinant IL 18. IL 18 is a member of the IL 1 family of cytokines, and analogous to IL 1b is a potent inflammatory cytokine. As such, both are tightly regulated and synthesized as precursors, which, in permissive conditions, are cleaved and released as mature IL 1b and IL 18. Upon secretion these cytokines are further regulated by decoy receptors IL 1Ra and IL 18BP, respectively. The affinity of IL 18BP for IL 18 is ~10,000 times greater than that of IL 18Ra, leading the authors to hypothesize that IL 18BP might be inhibiting the activity of IL 18 in the TME. The authors found that levels of IL 18BP were elevated in both human and murine tumors in an IFN g dependent manner. Interestingly, IL 27, a key cytokine driving expression of the co inhibitory module on CD8 TILs, is also a potent inducer of IL 18BP. Therefore, in addition to directly regulating the induction of surface inhibitory receptors on CD8 T cells, IL 27 contributes to CD8 T cell dysfunction in the TME through its action on myeloid cells, promoting a negative feedback loop through induction of a number of cell surface and soluble inhibitors, including IL 18BP. To overcome the inhibitory effect of IL 18BP, the authors performed a yeast display screening of IL 18 variants to identity mutants which could bind the IL 18Ra, but not IL 18BP. This "decoy resistant" IL 18 (DR 18) showed remarkable results as a monotherapy and synergistic effect with anti PD 1, expanding memory precursor CD8 T cells and mitigating T cell exhaustion with lower levels of TOX (Fig. 1) TOX is a key transcription factor critical for the transcriptional program of CD8 T cell exhaustion downstream of nuclear factor of activated T cell (NFAT) signaling. Interestingly, NFAT proteins have a dichotomous role regulating T cell activation while also participating in the transcriptional program of CD8 T cell exhaustion. The findings from this study suggest that NFAT activation concomitant with NF kB signaling through IL 18R is sufficient to deviate from an exhaustion trajectory, sustaining effector T cell responses for anti tumor immunity. While further studies are warranted to fully investigate this, it would provide compelling rationale to utilize the mutant IL18 (DR 18) in combination with anti PD 1, directing the expanded precursor population seen in PD 1 blockade, towards a potent effector lineage fate. Importantly, through its ability to license natural killer (NK) cells DR 18 could also act on MHC class I deficient tumors which are resistant to conventional immune checkpoint therapy (Fig. 1) Currently, a number of NK checkpoint molecules, including KIR and CD94, are being tested in clinical trials. It will be interesting to test the potential synergy of these therapies together with DR 18, which could have significant efficacy in "cold tumors" where there is a current unmet clinical need. While it appears that DR 18 is well tolerated and efficacious at low doses, immune related adverse events will need to be thoroughly addressed before clinical translation. Dysregulation of IL 18 is associated with autoimmune diseases including inflammatory bowel disease, granulomatosis, and SLE, where levels of free IL 18 (IL 18 not bound by IL 18BP) correlate with disease progression. Notably, loss of function mutations in IL18BP can lead to excessive NK cell activation resulting in severe hepatitis. Furthermore, similar to IL 1b, IL 18 induces IL 17
Cell Research