School gardening as a means to influence pupils nutritional attitudes and behavior A study at general and vocational high schools in Vienna
The impact of school gardening on nutritional attitudes and behavior regarding purchase and consumption of food is explored with pupils who participated in school gardens. The researchers of the recent study conceptualized a framework of potential factors influencing nutritional behavior based on empirical data with pupils from general and vocational high schools in Vienna. Three hundred and sixteen pupils, aged between 16 to 21, were interviewed in a cross sectional study. The pupils who participated in school gardening are significantly better informed about sustainability than the pupils who did not. There is a significant difference between pupils who took part in school gardening and those who did not, regarding their self assessment towards their connection to nature and sustainability. The total consumption of vegetables has increased within the families of participating pupils by 17% School gardening seems to promote pupils' reflection on their own diet as well as foster a favorable attitude towards a healthy and sustainable diet. We conclude that the implementation of school gardening has a significant positive impact on pupils' attitude and behavior towards sustainable diets. Keywords: School gardening, quantitative method, nutritional attitudes and behavior, general and vocational high school pupils, Vienna School gardening as a means to influence pupils' nutritional attitudes and behavior: Vienna Journal of Sustainability Education http:/www.susted.org/ Introduction According to a 2012 EU census, 21% of the Austrian population lived in urban and 32% in intermediate areas (BMLFUW, 2014) However it has to be considered that the rural area of Austria is diverse, and that there are many rural areas with strong relations to urban centers (Dax, Favry, Fidlschuster, Oedl Wieser, Pfefferkorn, 2008) In Austria, relocation of families from rural landscapes to large cities was observed, resulting in a 11% increase in urbanization between 2001 and 2011 (Statistics Austria, 2013) The average amount of farmland per farm increased in Austria from 9.6 ha in 1951 to 18.7 ha in 2013 (BMLFUW, 2015) In 1951, 1.624.034 people worked in the Austrian farming sector, whereas by 2013 this number was reduced to 414.410 (Statistics Austria, 2014) Austrian consumers purchase the vast majority of their food in supermarkets or discount stores. In 2009, only 12% of food was sold using various forms of direct agricultural marketing (AMA, 2009) These developments led to a situation where fewer people had direct experiences with food production and farming. Because of the long supply chains from farmer to consumer, pupils sometimes have no understanding of their food with regard to where and how it is grown and produced (Clugston Calder, 2007) Furthermore, in many cities, pupils have limited exposure to wild spaces or food production landscapes. Most of the time, they spend their days in school buildings and eat snacks or meals composed of highly processed foods. Adolescents who grow up in urban cities or landscapes have little relation to nature and agricultural production of food (KingeryPage, Hunt, Teener; Pierce, 2012) It is time to accommodate new strategies of human nutrition, based on food from low input, local, seasonal and agroecological production (Lairon, 2012) In international school education, there is a growing international attention on ecological and societal aspects of food systems. There is a clear concern that humans need to learn to develop healthy and sustainable methods of nutrition for the present as well as the future (BMBF, 2013; Larson, Story, Eisenberg, Neumark Sztainer, 2006) From that perspective, it is time to rethink school curricula to accommodate new strategies of human nutrition, based on food from low input, local, seasonal and agroecological production. One of these strategies is the implementation of school gardens. The objective of school gardening is to teach pupils about the origins and production of food, and for this, there is a need for environmental education (Mukoni, 2013) The process of teaching pupils where their food is grown and produced is characterized by environmental pedagogical strategies like experiential learning (Parmer, 2006) Holistically, experiential learning involves combining pupils' experience, awareness, cognition and behavior to engage them in ecological issues (Dunkley, 2016) Pupils therefore learn to change their own diet, which means that they can shape their own nutrition pattern in a more ecological and sustainable way. Rademacher, Leisch, Fiala, Freyer Vol. 20, April 2019 ISSN: 2151 7452 On the foundation of the work of Verstraeten et al. (2014) the researchers of the present study conceptualize a framework of potential factors influencing nutritional behavior in Viennese pupils (Figure 1) In the context of school gardening, schools can influence the pupils' nutritional attitudes and behavior, as well as sociocultural conditions such as families' values and rules. Individual factors such as subjective norms, attitudes or behavioral intentions are the driving forces to influence pupils' nutritional behavior (Hackman Knowlden, 2014) Further influencing factors on nutritional behavior include sociodemographic characteristics like pupils' age, habitat and level of education (De Bruijn et al. 2007; K. Harris Mullan, 2009; Vermeir Verbeke, 2008) Figure 1: Conceptual framework of potential factors influencing nutritional behavior in Viennese pupils modified according to Verstraeten et al. (2014) There are many publications in which the influence of school gardening on pupils' nutritional attitudes and behavior are analyzed. Quantitative methods with a preand post test design were used in the research on pupils' attitudes and behavior (Baldivia et al. 2014; Gatto, Ventura, Cook, Gyllenhammer, Davis, 2012; Jones et al. 2012; Pierce, 2012; Ratcliffe, Merrigan, Rogers, Goldberg, 2011; Stephens, 2014) The studies indicate that in schools with a gardening project, pupils eat more fruit and vegetables. Moreover, pupils have a better knowledge of growing fruit and vegetables as well as a better understanding of healthy ingredients. The pupils in these programs learn about the knowledge of using crop rotation for growing different vegetables can reduce the application of pesticides in plant production. School gardening as a means to influence pupils' nutritional attitudes and behavior: Vienna Journal of Sustainability Education http:/www.susted.org/ In 1993 Pehofer (2010) analyzed the status quo of ecological school programs in Austria using a questionnaire. From the 1586 initiatives only a few dealt with school gardening. For Vienna, there are no recent scientific studies on the analysis of the influence of school gardening on pupils' nutritional attitudes and behavior. Because only a few researchers described the age group of 16to 21 year old pupils in the context of school gardening (Jones et al. 2012; Parmer, 2006; Pierce, 2012) we argue that this group is of specific interest due to the fact they represent those who are on the brink of becoming a relevant consumer group. Therefore our objective was to understand the 16to 21 year old pupils' nutritional awareness toward sustainable aspects in nutrition, and the influence of participation in school gardening on pupils' sustainable nutritional attitudes and behaviour. Furthermore our intention was to construct a conceptual framework whilst explaining aspects of sustainable nutrition by analyzing pupils' attitudes and behavior. In relation to our objective, our research question was: "Does the pupils' participation in school gardening influence their nutritional attitudes and behavior?" Method This study is based on quantitative data collected in five schools in Vienna about the pupils' attitudes and behavior after participation in school gardening programs. The study follows a cross sectional and ex post facto design. The school gardening programs were introduced independently of the study. Measurements were taken via paper and pencil questionnaires. Questionnaire We collected data via a validated questionnaire. The questionnaire was conceptualized based on behavioral and environmental psychological models which applied to topics of sustainable diets (Ajzen Fishbein, 1980; Fila Smith, 2006; Hackman Knowlden, 2014; Lautenschlager Smith, 2007) The setup of statistical scale level has been selected for nominal and ordinal scales. Parameters of pupils' age and school type have been determined to confer a representativeness of the sample. The questionnaire consists of anonymous open and closed filtered questions. In total, the questionnaire consisted of 29 questions. The questionnaire is based on Likert Items. In the questionnaire, sustainability and environmental attitudes toward purchase and diet are examined only in closed questions. This is examined using question batteries in the form of Likert Items. To design the layout of the questionnaire, the free software tool LimeSurvey (Schmitz, 2012) was used. In a pre test questionnaire in June 2014, 18 pupils from one school were interviewed using a Computer Assisted Personal Questionnaire (Baker, 1992) which was improved using feedback from pupils and teachers on the sections concerning attitudes, intentions and behavioral questions. The questionnaire took place in Vienna, Austria from June 2014 to December 2014. Here the sustainable nutritional awareness of pupils aged 16 to 21 was explored. 35 pupils did not answer the complete questionnaire but rather gave only incomplete answers. Rademacher, Leisch, Fiala, Freyer Vol. 20, April 2019 ISSN: 2151 7452 Sample The sample selection followed the rules of quantitative sampling. Indicators for the selection of schools were similarities in school gardening practices, the distance of schools to each other and pupils' age. Pupils from five high schools in Vienna were selected to