Impact of trainee involvement in esophagectomy on clinical outcomes: a narrative systematic review of the literature.
Changes in the structure of surgical training have affected trainees' operative experience. Performing an esophagectomy is being increasingly viewed as a complex technical skill attained after completion of the routine training pathway. This systematic review aimed to identify all studies analyzing the impact of trainee involvement in esophagectomy on clinical outcomes. A search of the major reference databases (Cochrane Library, MEDLINE, EMBASE) was performed with no time limits up to the date of the search (November 2017) Results were screened in line with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, and study quality assessed using the MINORS (Methodological Index for Non Randomized Studies) criteria. Four studies that included a total of 42 trainees and 16 consultants were identified, which assessed trainee involvement in open esophagogastric resectional surgery. A total of 1109 patients underwent upper gastrointestinal procedures, of whom 904 patients underwent an esophagectomy. Preoperative characteristics, histology, neoadjuvant treatment, and overall length of hospital stay were comparable between groups. One study found higher rates of anastomotic leaks in procedures primarily performed by trainees as compared to consultants (P 0.01) this did not affect overall morbidity or survival; however, overall anastomotic leak rates from the published data were 10.4% (trainee) versus 6.3% (trainer) (P 0.10) A meta analysis could not be performed due to the heterogeneity of data. The median MINORS score for the included studies was 13 (range 11 15) This study demonstrates that training can be achieved with excellent results in high volume centers. This has important implications on the consent process and training delivered, as patients wish to be aware of the risks involved with surgery and can be reassured that appropriately supervised trainee involvement will not adversely affect outcomes.
Diseases of the esophagus official journal of the International Society for Diseases of the Esophagus