The impact of evaporator fouling and filtration on the performance of packaged air conditioners
Abstract The goal of the study presented in this paper was to evaluate the impact of different filter types on the performance of three typical packaged air conditioners under both clean and fouled conditions. In a companion paper, combinations of six different levels of filtration and four different coils were tested under clean and fouled conditions. From the tests, it was found that fouling has a relatively small impact on air-side effective heat transfer coefficient, but can have a large impact on coil pressure drop. Data from the experimental study were used in developing simulation models for the three packaged air conditioners. Simulations show that the equipment cooling capacity is reduced with fouling primarily because of a decrease in air flow due to the increased pressure drop. In most cases, EER (energy efficiency ratio) was reduced with fouling primarily due to increased fan power. However, the changes in EER were relatively small, in the range of 1–10%. Equipment having low efficiency filters had higher EER after fouling than equipment with high efficiency filters, because high efficiency filters result in significantly higher pressure drops than low efficiency filters. The impact of the evaporator side fan efficiency was found to be significant. The energy penalty associated with high efficiency filters was reduced greatly when fan efficiency increased. Although high efficiency filters cause higher energy penalties they provide considerably better air quality. The quantity of dust passing through the coil with an MERV14 filter was approximately 30 times less than the dust passing the coil with an MERV4 filter. This difference was doubled when the MERV14 filter was compared to a case with no filter in place.