Non‐paradoxical multi‐location
lasting longer than 01 is an extrinsic difference, not an intrinsic one. There is a sense in which 01 and 02 have a different shape; this is because they differ with respect to their extrinsic shapes. But they have the same intrinsic shape; both 01 and 02 are intrinsically three-dimensional spheres. I would like to conclude with two brief observations about this response. First, perhaps we can take the defining thesis of endurantism to be the claim that enduring objects have their spatial shape intrinsically and their spatiotemporal shape extrinsically. Second, this response assumes that material objects have intrinsic shapes.5 This could be challenged. One could hold instead that the only shape had by a material object is the shape it has in virtue of occupying a region of space-time.6 But that is a story for another time.7