Urban gray vs. urban green vs. soil protection Development of a systemic solution to soil sealing management on the example of Germany
Abstract Managing urban soil sealing is a difficult venture due to its spatial heterogeneity and embedding in a socio ecological system. A systemic solution is needed to tackle its spatial, ecological and social sub systems. This study develops a guideline for urban actors to find a systemic solution to soil sealing management based on two case studies in Germany: Munich and Leipzig. Legal planning, informal planning, economic fiscal, co operative and informational responses were evaluated by indicators to proof which strategy considers the spatial complexity of urban soil sealing (systemic spatial efficiency) and, while considering spatial complexity, to assess what the key management areas for action are to reduce the ecological impacts by urban soil sealing (ecological impact efficiency) and to support an efficient implementation by urban actors (social implementation efficiency) Results suggest framing the systemic solution to soil sealing management through a cross scale, legal planning development strategy embedded in higher European policies. Within the socio ecological system, the key management area for action should focus on the protection of green infrastructure being of high value for actors from the European to local scales. Further efforts are necessary to establish a systemic monitoring concept to optimize socio ecological benefits and avoid trade offs such as between urban infill development and urban green protection. This place based study can be regarded as a stepping stone on how to develop systemic strategies by considering different spatial sub targets and socio ecological systems.