Complex patterns of spatially extended generators of epileptic activity: Comparison of source localization methods cMEM and 4 ExSo MUSIC on high resolution EEG and MEG data
Electric Source Imaging (ESI) and Magnetic Source Imaging (MSI) of EEG and MEG signals are widely used to determine the origin of interictal epileptic discharges during the pre surgical evaluation of patients with epilepsy. Epileptic discharges are detectable on EEG/MEG scalp recordings only when associated with a spatially extended cortical generator of several square centimeters, therefore it is essential to assess the ability of source localization methods to recover such spatial extent. In this study we evaluated two source localization methods that have been developed for localizing spatially extended sources using EEG/MEG data: coherent Maximum Entropy on the Mean (cMEM) and 4th order Extended Source Multiple Signal Classification (4 ExSo MUSIC) In order to propose a fair comparison of the performances of the two methods in MEG versus EEG, this study considered realistic simulations of simultaneous EEG/MEG acquisitions taking into account an equivalent number of channels in EEG (257 electrodes) and MEG (275 sensors) involving a biophysical computational neural mass model of neuronal discharges and realistically shaped head models. cMEM and 4 ExSo MUSIC were evaluated for their sensitivity to localize complex patterns of epileptic discharges which includes (a) different locations and spatial extents of multiple synchronous sources, and (b) propagation patterns exhibited by epileptic discharges. Performance of the source localization methods was assessed using a detection accuracy index (Area Under receiver operating characteristic Curve, AUC) and a Spatial Dispersion (SD) metric. Finally, we also presented two examples illustrating the performance of cMEM and 4 ExSo MUSIC on clinical data recorded using high resolution EEG and MEG. When simulating single sources at different locations, both 4 ExSo MUSIC and cMEM exhibited excellent performance (median AUC significantly larger than 0.8 for EEG and MEG) whereas, only for EEG, 4 ExSo MUSIC showed significantly larger AUC values than cMEM. On the other hand, cMEM showed significantly lower SD values than 4 ExSo MUSIC for both EEG and MEG. When assessing the impact of the source spatial extent, both methods provided consistent and reliable detection accuracy for a wide range of source spatial extents (source sizes ranging from 3 to 20cm2 for MEG and 3 to 30cm2 for EEG) For both EEG and MEG, 4 ExSo MUSIC localized single source of large signal to noise ratio better than cMEM. In the presence of two synchronous sources, cMEM was able to distinguish well the two sources (their location and spatial extent) while 4 ExSo MUSIC only retrieved one of them. cMEM was able to detect the spatio temporal propagation patterns of two synchronous activities while 4 ExSo MUSIC favored the strongest source activity. Overall, in the context of localizing sources of epileptic discharges from EEG and MEG data, 4 ExSo MUSIC and cMEM were found accurately sensitive to the location and spatial extent of the sources, with some complementarities. Therefore, they are both eligible for application on clinical data.
NeuroImage