Bowel obstruction rates in antecolic/antegastric versus retrocolic/retrogastric Roux limb gastric bypass: a meta analysis.
BACKGROUND Previous literature is varied with regard to rates of bowel obstruction after laparoscopic Roux en Y gastric bypass (LRYGB) Internal herniation through mesenteric defects is a common cause of bowel obstructions. There are advantages and disadvantages to routing the Roux limb via a retrocolic/retrogastric (RC/RG) versus an antecolic/antegastric (AC/AG) position. OBJECTIVE To review the literature comparing obstruction rates in RYGB using the antecolic versus retrocolic approach. SETTING Community based integrated multispecialty health system with a teaching hospital serving 19 counties over a 3 state region. METHODS A literature search for articles published from 1994 2013 was completed. Articles were included if they reported an n>25, Roux limb route, obstruction rate by route, and follow up duration. Statistical analysis included kh(2) test by patient number. RESULTS The initial search identified 241 articles; 8 met inclusion criteria. There were 4805 patients in the AC/AG group, and 2238 in the RC/RG group. Follow up ranged from 0 to 68 months. A linear stapled technique was reported in 4231 (88% patients in the AC/AG group and 1541 (69% of RC/RG group. Handsewn closure of mesenteric defects was reported in 2152 (45% patients in the AC/AG group and 1012 (45% patients in the RC/RG group. Bowel obstructions occurred in 68 (1.4% patients in the AC/AG group and 117 (5.2% patients in the RC/RG group (P<.001) Internal hernias were reported in 65 (1.3% patients in the AC/AG group and 52 (2.3% patients in the RC/RG group (P<.001) Two mortalities were reported in the AC/AG group. CONCLUSIONS Increased rates of bowel obstruction and internal hernia were observed in the RC/RG group compared with the AC/AG group. A prospective, randomized trial would be necessary to definitively determine the impact of Roux limb position and routine closure of mesenteric defects on bowel obstruction rates after gastric bypass.
Surgery for obesity and related diseases official journal of the American Society for Bariatric Surgery