Content Analysis of Conceptual Change Research and Practice in Science Education: From Localization to Globalization
This chapter reviews the current research on conceptual change in science education. The review includes research located in the DoRise system (Database of Research in Science Education) in Taiwan and articles published in selected international science education journals (Journal of Research in Science Teaching, Science Education, International Journal of Science Education, Research in Science Education, and International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education) between 1982 and 2012. Three hundred and eighty three articles in the international journals (including 26 English papers from researchers in Taiwan) and eighty six articles from Taiwan were analyzed (60 and 26 articles from Taiwanese and international journals, respectively) There are five major findings. First, most of the research follows the empirical approach, regardless of it being an international or national article. Second, physics was the main discipline examined both in the international and national studies. Third, about two thirds of the studies from outside of Taiwan used epistemological perspective to frame and present their study. A similar percentage of articles investigated the instructional perspective whereas nearly two thirds of the Taiwanese articles investigated the instructional perspective and only 28 followed the epistemological perspective. Fourth, as for the research method, we found that qualitative data analysis was ranked first among all the methods we investigated whereas Taiwan appeared to integrate both quantitative and qualitative methods. Fifth, as expected, high percentages of published researchers were from English speaking countries (i.e. the USA, Australia, and the UK) Taiwan was ranked third out of 31 countries with respect to the number of publications in this study from 1982 to 2012 but was the first non English speaking country. Recommendations for researchers and educators are provided.