Why
Was it just a lie in my mind
Or was I nothing but a good friend?
It's hard for me to believe
That was really all that you were feeling
’Cause what you said and what you did
Had two different meanings, oh
'Cause you'd lock your heart and mind
And kiss me all the time

And came today, and moved away
And I only saw you on the weekends
Nothing changed but the pain
I felt inside when I was leaving
Then you call me up, and let me know
You went and found a girlfriend, oh
I didn’t wanna make a scene
But I wanted to scream

Why would you wanna take my soul
And crumble it up, and just throw it out the window?
Tell me, why did you have to be so cold?
At least you could've looked me in the eye
When you said goodbye
It's funny how up 'til now
You and I did everything together
I was into you, you were into me
I thought it couldn't get any better-er
When we were making love
I was thinking of forever, oh
Then you pushed yourself away
And all that's left to say is

Why would you wanna take my soul
And crumble it up, and just throw it out the window, oh
Tell me, why did you have to be so cold?
At least you could've looked me in the eye
When you said goodbye

Let myself be vulnerable, oh
Only 'cause I loved you so, oh
I don’t think I’ll ever let this go
'Cause I still wanna know

Why, baby, baby, why
Would you take my soul, oh, oh, oh, oh
Ooh, ooh